Entering the Middle Way – 37 Entering 1991 08 22

44 min · 2,258 words · 22 August 1991

Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way (Khensur Rinpoche)
Entering the Middle Way - 37 Entering 1991 08 22
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that form and emptiness are one entity, as the Heart Sutra says, and that the ultimate truth is the emptiness of phenomena while conventional truth is their false appearance. Using the example of a flower, it argues that things exist only by being imputed by name and not from their own side, and that emptiness must be understood before conventional falsity can be. It ends by describing analytic and stabilizing meditation as the means to develop wisdom.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1991-08-22

Duration: 45 min

UUID: b83650e6-faf2-4475-b362-1a9d3ed30396

Words: 2,254

So as it says in the Heart of Wisdom Sūtra, says that form is emptiness, emptiness is form. This sets out emptiness and form are the same entity. For example, our mind and the emptiness of our mind are one entity. The emptiness of our mind and our mind are one entity. If they were different entities, many would accrue.

The emptiness in terms of the mind is an ultimate truth. That is to say it is the final mode of abidance of the mind. Therefore it is truth. Whereas the mind itself is not the final mode of abidance of the mind and therefore it is a falsity. So in in terms of the world, when an individual speaks, when whatever an individual speaks is an accurate reflection of what they’re thinking, then we say that this person is straightforward, that they’re truth, that they’re honest, that they’re truthful.

On the other hand, someone who thinks one way and speaks another is referred to as we would say a hypocrite, but this doesn’t get at the meaning of the word that we want. We would say he’s a pretense, he’s a pretender. And then when what he says, he thinks it is but he says it isn’t, then there’s a falsity and such as the word we want is falsity but it doesn’t he’s a false person, dishonest person. So likewise, in the term conventional truth, that is to say it is a false truth. The word means false, so conceal it and means truth.

It is a false truth. Whereas the word means the ultimate truth. If a false person, we can’t trust him because it’s not an accurate reflection of the way what he’s actually thinking. There’s a falsity. So we call it a person a liar.

So with respect, it’s necessary that we again and again read the various texts presented in the middle way, that we listen to these teachings and we reflect upon them and try to understand this mode of abidance is reality from many points of view. We aren’t going to understand it immediately. Returning to the analogy of the TV, because the image appears to be a person to the eye consciousness but it does not exist the way it appears then this object is referred to as a falsity. We can understand that it’s a falsity. But to understand that the flower is a falsity is a little more difficult.

In order to understand the falsity of the flower, it’s necessary that we understand the presentation of emptiness. Until we realize emptiness in terms of the flower, we won’t be able to understand that the flower is a falsity. So as I mentioned previously there is a difficulty, degree of difficulty, difference in difficulty, a difference in difficulty, a difference in the degree of difficulty in understanding the two truths. Until we understand the emptiness which is the ultimate truth of the flower we will not be able to understand its conventional nature. That is to say it is the flower of falsity.

Why is that? When the object flower was first designated by giving the name flower to it, an object was named flower, then that object appeared to be a flower not by means of being named but from its own side it appears to be a flower. This is the way it appears. That the flower does not exist the way it appears is its emptiness. And in order to understand that this appearance is false, it must necessarily understand that it doesn’t exist the way it appears.

Therefore, we have to know it’s understanding in terms of its emptiness before we can understand in terms of its falsity or its conventional nature. We said that flower does not exist not being imputed by means of a name. How can we establish this? We know that the flower grows it depends upon causes and conditions. If the flower existed from its own side without being imputed by means of names, then it would not rely upon causes and conditions to grow.

But we know it relies upon causes and conditions to grow therefore it cannot exist on its own side. It must be imputed by names which is difficult. All conventional existences are just like this flower. That is true of all phenomena. So, it’s necessary that we meditate upon what is being explained in terms of meditation.

Meditation is just not sitting there with a straight body. Meditation is something which occurs within one’s mind. And with respect to meditation, there are two types. There are analytic meditations and stabilizing meditations. In terms of analytic meditations, proceed with making use of various reasons, analyzing objects, trying to determine what is its reality, what is its mode of existence.

Then when we come to some conclusion, we then stabilize upon that conclusion. So if we proceed in this session by analytically investigating in our meditation again and again various objects as to the nature of the way in which they exist, their reality, then we are going to develop a wisdom with respect to their reality. And when this becomes developed to the point where we will come to understand the final mode of reality of the object and develop wisdom with respect to that. As our wisdom develops, develops it is able to eliminate all our various faults proportionately. And that wisdom which is able to eliminate all our faults is the final wisdom.

Or the transcendental wisdom. And this transcendental wisdom is the ultimate result. So what do we mean by name? A name is a sound. Every phenomenon whatsoever is given a name.

You know for example, we give the name flower or table. All the various objects are given a name by a first individual who designates that object. Now in terms of the way of designation, there are three ways in which the name can be designated. One, the first is the name is designated because it has a relationship with the object. The second because it has a similarity with another object.

And the third is simply haphazardly giving your name. So this third type of means of designating a name which I call haphazardly is simply the giving of a name out of a desire for there is no reason, there is no particular relationship or similarity with other objects but simply the desire to give a name such as giving the name flower, giving the name table. Immediately upon Jampa being born from his mother, Jampa didn’t exist. So when Jampa was a little boy, his name was Sanford. But even Sanford immediately upon birth was not Sanford.

That his parents, they said well what should we call the baby? And someone said let’s call it Sanford. So it depends upon being given the name, being designated or imputed as Sanford. Sanford came into existence. Without having been given that name, Sanford didn’t exist.

Sanford came into existence upon being designated by this particular name. Then other individuals, they came and they looked at the baby and they said, What’s its name? They thought, It’s named Sanford. So this baby began to become popularly known as Sanford. When this child walked into the room they said, Here comes Sanford.

And when Sanford was eating they said, Sanford is eating. When this child was walking they said Sanford was walking. And Sanford himself began to think of himself as Sanford. I am Sanford. Then Sanford went to India and at that time he had long hair and smoked and at that particular time there was no Jampa.

So subsequent to having gone to India then Geshe Ngawang Dhargyey acted as his abbot and cut his hair and gave him vows and gave him the name Jampa Gyatso. This was his name of renunciation and after that people began to call that same individual Jampa Gyatso. Jampa Gyatso came into existence upon being given that name. When this person went, they would say, Oh there goes Jampa Gyatso. When this person arrived, they would say, Oh here comes Jampa Gyatso and this person began to think of himself as Jampa Gyatso and all of the various activities which were done by this person were activities done by Jampa Gyatso.

So, Jampa Gyatso was merely imputed by name and was not established from his own side. If Jampa Gyatso were established from his own side without being imputed by name, then even before he became a monk, when he was Sanford, then when this person came, they would say, Oh here comes Jampa Gyatso. Or when Sanford went, they would say there goes Jampa Gyatso because Jampa Gyatso existed from his own side and was Jampa Gyatso even before he became a monk. Jampa Gyatso exists in dependence upon his name. He does not exist without being given that name.

When did he come into existence? When he was given that name. Previous to that he did not exist. Therefore, Jampa Gyatso exists merely in dependence upon his name or being imputed by name. So this holds equally true for all of us that we are dependent upon our name.

But additionally, this applies to all phenomena whatsoever. For example, the flower. Before the name flower was imputed to a particular flower didn’t exist. For example, there would be appearing to us when we look at this object in front of us. There is a red object, there is a white object, and we don’t know what those objects are.

We just say a red object and a white object then we say well what should we call it? Let’s call it a flower and it depends upon being called, given, imputed that meaning flower and flower came into existence. So in Australia, we take the example of that. They print up little pieces of paper and they put numbers on them and they put someone’s portrait on it and they say let’s call it a hundred dollar note. You know and then in dependence upon being called a hundred dollar note, when I give you a hundred dollar note, you think ah I’ve received a hundred dollars and when you give it to me, I think ah I’ve received a hundred dollars.

But before we gave it that name, a hundred dollar note, we just received a printed piece of paper with a picture and a number. So likewise all phenomena are really imputed by name. What did they what did they just decimate before they made it? They decimate the idea of the hundred dollar note? Did the hundred dollar note exist before it was printed?

Prior to printing the note, the hundred dollar note didn’t exist. It was a thought in someone’s mind. This thought, you know, the thought of printing the hundred dollar note, but the hundred dollar note didn’t exist. At the time he says that? Yes.

At the time he says that. So at the time of making this prophecy, Jampa Gyatso doesn’t exist. They just say that Jampa Gyatso will exist in the future. So at the time he makes his prophecy that Jampa Gyatso will be born in a hundred years, Jampa Gyatso’s name does not exist.

The name? The name. He said it doesn’t exist. It doesn’t exist. So what is being referred to, we say it’s not actually Jampa Gyatso’s name.

It is that which possesses the holder of the name. A similarity to the name, a similarity to the name. It’s not the name, it’s a similarity to the name. So does the concept of space travel exist before? So if a person is Bob Hawk, is he necessarily the Prime Minister of Australia?

So Ārya Asaṇga is referred to as the charioteer of the mind only school. So whoever is Ārya Asaṇga is the pioneer or the charioteer of the mind only school. But before Ārya Asaṇga met with Maitreya and received his teachings, before that time, giving that name Ārya Asaṇga to that person is simply a nickname. He has the nickname Ārya Asaṇga because at that time he’s not the charioteer. He is not the pioneer of the mind only school.

Only after meeting with Maitreya, that is when he really became Ārya Asaṇga. If a person is Bob Hawke, then he’s necessarily the prime minister of Australia. When he was little, they gave him a nickname Bob Hawke. Word emptiness is an expression, and emptiness is the object of that expression. In the Consequentialist Middle Way school all phenomena what ever is really imputed by name.

There’s nothing which is not imputed by name. If emptiness were not really imputed, it would exist from its own side and it would truly exist. Sanford doesn’t exist. And Bailey hasn’t been designated as of yet.

The basis of imputation also needs the basis of imputation. For example, our five aggregates — forms, feelings, perception, mental construction and consciousness — act as the basis of imputation of the person. Those in turn, for example the form aggregate, the four elements act as the basis of imputation for the form aggregate. So those in turn, each of the aggregates in turn have the basis of imputation. Whether the base of the imputation and the object which is imputed are coming to existence simultaneously or not and they don’t.

Come into existence simultaneously: the basis of imputation and then the object which is imputed upon it.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top