46 min · 2,511 words · 30 May 1991
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaches that retaliating against harm does not undo the suffering already received and instead creates new suffering, so tolerance and compassion toward those who harm us should be cultivated, drawing on Candrakirti’s verse and Shantideva. A question-and-answer section discusses whether one should deliberately stir up anger to identify it while grieving, and the teacher argues that identifying existing anger is enough. The talk closes by noting that examining a guru’s apparent faults can help build stable pure vision of the teacher.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1991-05-30
Duration: 47 min
UUID: 507f6334-dacf-4c91-9632-6c4ff878097c
Words: 2,507
So, it’s said that if someone out of anger were to hit us on the head with a stick and cause a wound, then what is the use of retaliating? Because does our retaliating transfer that wound on your head back to them? No, it stays on your head. So what use is it? What good is your retaliation?
Doesn’t remove your own wound. On the other hand, if an additional example, if someone were to kill a relative or a friend of yours, and in retaliation you kill that person. If killing that person had the ability and the power to bring back your friend to life, or your relative back to life, then it makes sense. There would be some use in it. But it can’t.
And what use is it? So, someone has hit us, the action is finished. And there is no use in retaliating. It makes no sense. Someone has already hit us, and we experience a suffering out of that.
And if we were to retaliate, it doesn’t take our suffering away. But in fact, it brings about a great fault, in that out of retaliating, bringing harm to others, in the future we are going to experience suffering from that act of retaliation. So, we’ve actually doubled our suffering. We had the initial suffering, which was finished. It was there.
But now we’ve created another suffering out of that suffering. So then it makes no sense to act in this way. It’s of no use. So rather than retaliate, we should try to practice tolerance. If we cultivate tolerance if we do not cultivate tolerance, then we’re involved in two types of faults.
If we cultivate tolerance, then there are going to be two benefits accruing. So, in what way are there these many benefits to be accrued out of the practice of tolerance? That the very fact that this person has hit you and brought you harm is bringing to fruition an unskillful action in which you have created in the past yourself. So the experience of that suffering is the exhaustion of that unskillful action created in the past, and that action is now finished. And if we don’t retaliate, on the contrary, we cultivate tolerance.
Not only are we not going to create any negativity for ourselves, which will bring us future suffering, the cultivation of tolerance in itself is beneficial in that it will bring us happiness in the future. Whatever arises in dependence upon causes and conditions, we need both of these. The wound on your head is the result of a cause, which is one’s own unskillful action which one has created in the past. The cause of that wound on your head is your own unskillful action. The condition for it is the stick that that person hits you with.
So one has created the cause for the wound oneself and it’s simply the stick which provides the condition for this wound to arise. So, there is no benefit in retaliating, but in fact it’s a fault because one does not want the suffering which will accrue from that. Quoting from the thirty-second verse: How could it be right for one wishing to assert that he is finishing the effects of non-virtuous actions done earlier to sow the seeds of others’ suffering through harming and hating others? You know, the fact is that we don’t want suffering. But we don’t like any type of pain.
We don’t want to be brought any types of troubles or difficulties. Whenever these arise, we want to be rid of them. We don’t like them. So, all of these unwanted experiences, whatever is undesirable, all our various troubles, all our various pains are the results of unskillful actions that we have created in the past. So, though we desire not to experience any problems, any difficulties, if in response to someone else’s harm, we ourselves become angry, various afflictive emotions arise, we harm this other individual, then we are planting the seeds for our own future suffering that we don’t desire.
Though we do not wish to suffer, the creation of the causes of suffering is incompatible with our wishes. That if we persist in creating causes of our suffering, then this is completely incompatible with what we actually wish, that is not to suffer. These two ways of thinking are incompatible or mutually exclusive. So, we don’t desire If we don’t desire suffering, then don’t harm others. Don’t retaliate and don’t become angry at others.
If act in this way, then we are planting the seeds of undesired suffering in the future. So, if we do not desire suffering, then we must cease creating the causes of suffering. On the other hand, if desire happiness, then we must begin to cultivate the causes of happiness. And anything other than this is actually contradictory to that which we desire. So these are very good advices of Candrakīrti.
We should listen well to these advices. So, we’ll stop there for today. If you have some questions, we’ll answer questions. So, the best way is to understand that the harm that’s being brought to you is in response is the result of the harm that you brought to this person previously. That having harmed this person previously, now this result is coming back to you.
And understanding that this previous way of acting was mistaken because now you see the harm which is now you see the suffering which is a result of that previous harm. Now that previous mistaken action has come to fulfillment, that of the previous previously harming the action of having previously harmed this other person, now you have experienced the resultant suffering out of that, and now it’s finished. Now there’s no more needs to be done, and it’s beneficial what has occurred. Actually, you know, this person has benefited you. They brought to full circle this mistaken action that you created previously, and now the harm is finished.
And only through the benefit of this other person has this action been completely exhausted. And now this person is harming me and creating negativity for themselves. And here they are benefiting me, and we should develop a sense of compassion. And this person becoming angry at us and causing us harm, they are creating a great deal of negativities for themselves. And out of this, they will experience suffering in the future.
So seeing that they’re only creating the causes for their own future suffering, we should develop compassion for them. You know, this person has been extremely beneficial to me, that out of this harm that this person has brought me, that my previous unskillful action has been brought to completion, now it’s completely finished. But not only that, that this person has given me the opportunity to cultivate tolerance. And even more, they have given me the opportunity to cultivate compassion. And out of all of this, I’ve developed a great deal of positive potential, due to which I will experience great happiness in the future.
So, there are many different ways we can reason in working with this situation. Joy and what? Compassion. So, this is out of harm being brought to oneself. If we can develop it’s extremely beneficial if we can cultivate tolerance.
It’s extremely beneficial if we can cultivate compassion. Out of this we’ll develop a great deal of positive potential. This situation is extremely opportune to create a great deal of happiness for ourselves. Śāntideva tries to point out the great kindness of someone who brings us harm. In that the people towards whom we can practice generosity are a great number, are many in number.
But there are very few that we can practice tolerance with. And therefore, we can quickly bring to completion the perfection of generosity since there are so many objects we can practice it with. But it’s difficult to bring to completion the perfection of tolerance because those objects are extremely rare. And therefore, it is the person who harms us which is of the greater kindness because it helps us to bring us the occasion to bring to completion our perfection of tolerance. It is only people who harm us towards whom we can cultivate tolerance.
We can’t cultivate tolerance towards those who benefit us, for example, our parents. This question is about so in in in Western society, there’s a very widely accepted method for dealing with grief, which many people have found to be very beneficial. And part of that, and dealing with grief successfully, according to this method, is to go through a number of stages. And one of those stages is anger, and it involves acknowledging and accepting our anger. Acknowledging and accepting our anger before we can pass on to the next stage and finally to regaining a happy mind after experiencing, you know, grief, So, what is the cause of the grief?
So, no, so the question is, so we’re actually this method says that we should bring anger into our minds, allow anger to come into our minds, and experience it before we can let it go. If we don’t do that, then we may become stuck, and it may take us a very long time to experience a happy mind. So that seems to be a little bit contrary. It’s actually wishing to experience anger so that then you can move on. And what is the object?
What is there? Cause of the grief? For example, if we just use an example. Oh, you know, death of a father or mother or spouse. The What is the need to develop anger?
Who are you going to get angry at? Your parents for dying? Is that what you’re saying? Well, could be any one of a number of things. It could be, yeah, it could be getting angry with your parents for dying.
So, Rinpoche thinks that this is a big mistake, that getting angry at, for example, your parents, even if they’re dead, is extremely negative. For example, getting angry at your parents and at one’s spiritual teacher are some of the greatest types of negativities that you can create. And the arising of anger is an afflictive emotion and it is experienced as a disturbance to the mind. The mind becomes unpeaceful. How can anger bring happiness?
How does that happen? If someone experiences if someone feels the anger and they can’t but they can’t actually acknowledge it, then it’s possible for someone to be it’s it’s being observed that someone can actually be angry all the way up until they die and die angry because they haven’t been able to accept that they’re angry and and let it go and move on to something else. To accept it, it means they have to sort of feel it and bring anger into their mind. So that if if they if they accept it and bring anger into their mind, recognize it, and somehow manage to apply an antidote, then they can die happy and not angry. Therefore, it’s beneficial.
That’s that’s that’s So, it’s definitely necessary that we identify anger in order to cease it. But I don’t think it’s necessary that we create it in order to identify it. We have to identify the anger that’s already there, not try to create anger in order to identify it. The bodhisattva is continually trying to cease his anger. He is always working to cease his anger.
I can see no benefit in creating anger, though it’s definitely necessary that we identify anger when it is there. So sometimes one emotion can mask another. For example, though you may be attached to someone, they may do something wrong that you don’t like, and you become angry at them. And you cannot be attached and angry at the same time. Though you’re presently angry at them, it covers over or masks your attachment toward them.
So, you know, if someone’s even though we don’t like it, someone’s life is exhausted, there’s nothing they can do. They die. So the I mean, the the only the only way it could be of any use to get angry would be if it masks another emotion. You know, when we can cause one emotion to arise in order to mask another one. But he doesn’t think that would be beneficial.
Doesn’t see how becoming angry could be beneficial in getting rid of this unhappy mind, this grief. So, if you were drinking hot tea and your mouth was burning, if you drank cold water, it would eliminate that. Can I just ask one question? Is Rinpoche thinking it’s a meditation? So I guess this just says that maybe people are angry and they don’t identify it.
And then to actually apply an antidote to the anger, they have to identify it properly, which means they have to allow themselves to feel well, maybe they have to feel the anger, and they’re afraid of feeling it so they don’t they keep pushing it down. So it’s possible that in order to identify, there may be some benefit to increase the emotion. Just like in order to wash your clothes, try to work up a good lather, suds, but eventually you’re going to wash them away. You want to get rid of them eventually. So maybe in order to identify the emotion, maybe it might be useful to increase it.
But that’s the only way he can think of the benefit. So in the teachings on the graduated path, when one says that one is to view one’s spiritual master as the Buddha, and this is a process of cultivating this pure vision. And in the stages of developing this awareness that one spiritual teacher, one’s lama is a Buddha, it becomes necessary to see his or her faults. One actually tries to see what faults do they have. And as they appear, one looks at those apparent faults, and identifying them, one sees in fact these are not faults and begins to apply reasoning why, in fact, these aren’t faults.
So, there is a period when one actually looks for faults in order that one can refute that these are actually faults, in order to gain a pure vision of one’s teacher as a Buddha. So this is the way we can achieve a very stable and perfected pure vision by having reasoned through these various apparent faults that you begin to see. So, if one were simply to sit there in meditation thinking that my spiritual teacher has no fault, my spiritual teacher has no no fault, my spiritual teacher is a Buddha, and cultivate devotion in this way, then one day you will see that your teacher has a fault. And then all of that effort in cultivating was of no use. It was of no benefit.
But on the other hand, if in the process of cultivating this pure vision of one’s teacher, you actually
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is it beneficial to bring up anger in order to recognise it and apply an antidote, so that someone doesn't die angry?
It is necessary to identify anger in order to cease it, but it is not necessary to create anger in order to identify it. What needs identifying is the anger that is already there. The bodhisattva is continually working to cease anger, and there is no benefit in creating it. Sometimes one emotion masks another. For example, anger at someone you are attached to can cover over the attachment, since you cannot be attached and angry at the same time. Creating one emotion to mask another might have some use, but it would not help here. Becoming angry would not be beneficial for getting rid of an unhappy mind or grief.