Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 48-minute talk, a teacher offers a commentary on the Four Noble Truths and their relationship to the 37 facets of enlightenment, addressing a group of Buddhist students in an FPMT program. Rather than teach in isolation, the speaker connects the Four Noble Truths to personal experience and daily practice, emphasizing that intellectual understanding alone has no power. He walks through how renunciation develops first through acknowledging suffering in one’s own life, and warns against the constant social pressure that undermines such practice. The latter half shifts to a detailed Q&A on calm abiding meditation: its prerequisites (vows, minimal distractions), the risk of subtle sinking mistaken for progress, session length (5–10 minutes at peak focus), and how dominant afflictions (anger, desire, ignorance) surface and can derail concentration if unaddressed. He covers how to choose practice objects as antidotes, practical setup (straight-backed seat sufficient), and why group meditation is less effective than solitary practice. The final segment tackles deeper philosophical questions about the five powers and five forces at different stages of the path, and what genuinely constitutes abandonment of afflictions. Pitched at practitioners with some familiarity with Lamrim teachings and capable of sustained philosophical inquiry.
File metadata (for organising)
File: four-noble-truths-2016-03-27-kr
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2027-03-16
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,370
So I can see our numbers have shrunk dramatically. There’s a long line of students which has run away from TBI screaming, I don’t want to hear about the 37 facets of enlightenment anymore. So we will telephone to the police and ask them to bring them back. So do you have any questions? Is it on?
Now it is. Okay. I don’t think Rinpoche gave the teachings. I can’t find him in my catalogue of his teachings. And I guess Geshe Pema Tsering gave them as part of the FPMT programme teachings.
So I’m just wondering why they were chosen to teach at this time. Well, Geshe-la proposed a list of topics he was ready to teach, and this seemed like the one which tied in the best with what we had done last year. It is a development of the path of the being of the middling scope, so we covered the four noble truths in I think considerable depth last year. We didn’t do the 12 limbs in class that were, but they were, or that deeply, but there were several presentations on it. And then this is a natural development.
What you say is very right, I think that but you never taught it, it’s rarely taught. It’s an advanced topic of Prajñāpāramitā, typically taught in the context of the fourth chapter of Prajñāpāramitā. The commentary on the fourth chapter of which you will be studying at probably around year 10 maybe of your studies. So you’re very fortunate to get something like this, you know. Then if you study it in-depth, it’s I think you can see how rewarding it is.
Yes. Whether that whether we have classes to practice on this, you know, like day to day, you know, how we can, you know, like step guide through how we practice. You would practice at home. At home. You would practice at home.
You have to create a little space. Maybe it doesn’t have to be a separate room. It’s better if you have a little separate room. It can be very small. I had one in which I could turn and that was about it, you know.
And then the way you would meditate about it is you would start by meditating on the four noble truths. And then you would apply the four noble truths to yourself. And in this process that would lead you to a reflection on the four close placements of recollection. Then move upwards from that. Obviously, these practices we cannot do in a fully characterized form at present, right?
So strictly speaking, all 37 facets of full enlightenment can only be practiced when one has entered the path. Entered the path means one has either generated uncontrived renunciation, or uncontrived bodhicitta, or both. Then, obviously we haven’t. Right? But we can practice similes, we can practice approximations, you know.
And then as we practice the approximations, our practice will deepen a lot. Because if we reflect on the four noble truths just in a void, you see, typically when we meditate on the four noble truths, we meditate on them in the abstract. It’s when we apply them to ourselves it becomes powerful, right? Then, to generate renunciation is first and foremost to generate renunciation for oneself. Without renunciation for oneself, there is no renunciation for others which is bodhicitta.
And that, generating renunciation for oneself is very difficult. I mean, the key is seeing everything we see at present as qualities as faults. And everything we see at present as faults as qualities. That’s not easy because all of society is moving against you. So you have constant negative input.
Right? From family, from friends, I mean, many did not come to these teachings because it’s a long Easter weekend and their family or friends said, look, don’t be a fanatic, you know. Right? How many? You’re not going to spend Easter, you know, meditating in a monastery, come let’s go to the barbie.
Well, this is society. Society is you know, we speak of evil friends, but Pabongka Rinpoche puts it beautifully. He says, evil friends don’t wear hairy coats and don’t have horns. Evil friends are closest. You know.
They say, ah, you know, I mean, don’t push too hard, it’s good you’re religious, but you know, don’t overdo it, have fun, enjoy. Then have fun, enjoy, have fun, enjoy, and eventually it’s finished, right? So the key in all of these practices is however obviously we haven’t understood everything with a topic like this, it’s not possible. But whatever we have understood to apply to ourselves, And that means we have to move beyond the books, so we rely on the texts. But we have to link it with personal experience.
If we don’t, it never bites. It’s got to bite. And personal experience, each one has a different personal experience. My personal experience, your personal experience is completely different, you know. What works for one person does not work for another person, because they’re different.
What might, even in terms of culture, what will work for our Asian students very well will not work for our Western students. And within Western students you have people who come from typically Northern European cultures, people who come from Mediterranean cultures like myself. Then we’re different again, you know. So you have to see what clicks for yourself, you know. Then if you have lived a bit, then it becomes easier, right?
The noble truth of suffering is something which resonates with people who have lived. If you’re very young or inexperienced, it doesn’t click. I’ll never forget a conversation I had with my father, who never was a Buddhist, nor was he actually a religious man, was sort of he was a scientist and nebulously a deist, you know, God was a great scientist, you know, who could create the universe. And he was very keen to understand why he became a Buddhist. Then I told him about the noble truth of suffering and he looked at me, he was in his seventies, he said, but Elia, that is obvious.
You see, normally this is something you have to hammer home with westerners, right? He said, it’s obvious. Why why was that considered a great revelation? Then I have found when I talk of the noble truth of suffering with Russians, it goes down very well. Because lives are hard, you know.
I remember a conversation with old grandmothers on the border of Estonia and Russia, you know, and they were talking of their experiences in World War two. They saw that life is suffering, that maybe not in the technical detail we talk about, you know. So we have to link with our practice, you know. And then, obviously, we can have group meditations here, but I mean I have never been in favor. I mean, the monasteries we don’t meditate in groups, I never meditated in a group.
I used to direct group meditations, but there’s something which is problematic with the group meditation, which is that everyone is being directed the same way, and we’re not the same, you know. So whoever is directing the meditation has his own slant or her own slant, and everyone is not going in the same direction, right? So it’s more difficult to meditate by oneself, it’s more beneficial. It doesn’t have to be anything fancy. One of the best is to sit in the formal position, but if that’s not possible, in a chair is okay, as long as the back the seat at the back has to be straight.
That’s the one thing. And then meditation is just one of two activities, it’s analyzing a concentration. So we meditate every day without knowing it. Unsurprisingly, people who have scientific background, people who have done university studies, typically will do very well at analytical meditation. You do mathematics, you’re doing analytical meditation.
Very structured. You can pass from math to Lamrim just like that. Then concentration meditation in the West, we are not really trained in that. Right? It’s our weakness.
I would suspect that manual laborers in the West would have a bit of an edge for concentration meditation. If you if you use an axe, let’s say I split wood like Daniela, you know, I split 10 tons of wood in one year, then it’s a very nice exercise because if you don’t concentrate, you take your knee out. There’s no no margin for error. Do you have other questions? Whichever.
So following on from what you said about manual labourers having an edge for the concentration. If one was to do a concentration retreat, what kind of activities should one do in the break? For instance, I don’t have a problem with analytical meditation and I’m quite happy to keep thinking about the topics in the break time. And the other thing I like to do in break times is a little bit of artwork, something repetitive and sort of a bit mindless. Would that kind of thing harm or help a concentration meditation?
It depends what you mean by concentration meditation. If your goal is calm abiding, typically when we speak of doing a retreat on fixative or concentration meditation, really the goal is calm abiding. Then really, everything apart from calm abiding is harmful. Everything. Then if you are doing a retreat on Lamrim, during the break you should engage in activities which are related, so that might mean reading the text and manual activities typically you could do things like tsa tsas.
A friend of mine casts little statues, you accumulate merit doing that, but retreats on analytical meditation are more flexible. Calm abiding, it’s actually very mechanical. If you get the preconditions first, the most important of which is basically no noise, and then little or no activities, those are the two keys, no noise, no activities, no company. You get those conditions, you decide you will stay in retreat until you achieve calm abiding, which most people cannot take as a decision. It’s open ended.
Normally it takes six months, I have known cases three months, but six months it can take two years. Just take that decision, I’m not budging, you know. And then, you need vows. You need lay vows, if you’re monastic, one has one’s monastic vows. The function of the ethic of the vows is to train the mind in a restraint from coarse sense objects, so it is impossible to control agitation in calm abiding, when one wants to create calm abiding, if the mind is constantly distracted towards coarse sense objects.
So actually having vows a fair bit before engaging in a calm abiding retreat is the best way to do it. And then calm abiding retreats are very different from other retreats, it’s not four sessions a day of let’s say two hours, two hours and a half each. You’re looking at 18 sessions a day, that’s sort of the ideal. Sessions, if you actually intend to achieve as opposed to just doing it to see what it’s like and trying it out, The session should last five to ten minutes. Then you stop the session at the moment when you lose concentration.
So the key to achieving calm abiding is not to drag on a session with mediocre concentration because you become accustomed to mediocre concentration. And before that, you must have received very clear teachings on calm abiding. So here they have been given several times and one should study the chapter on calm abiding of Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo, precisely because it’s really the only text in the Tibetan tradition, until then, since then there have been others, which very very clearly illustrates the major pitfall, which is subtle sinking. So I have known many people who have trained in calm abiding in some of the other traditions and you know immediately whether they have succumbed to subtle sinking, typically at the level of the fifth mental abiding, because it’s actually very enjoyable. The object of meditation is clear, let’s say if you practice with an image of the Buddha, it’s clear, it’s stable, with agitation the object seems, especially such subtle agitation the object seems to waver a bit.
It’s stable, it’s clear, and you’re comfortable. And there’s a real feeling you’re at the ninth level of calm abiding. And you will be experiencing the pliancies any moment. So pliancies are the criterion which define having attained calm abiding. Once you have experienced physical and mental pliancies, you have attained calm abiding until then you’re on the ninth level of abiding.
But when there is subtle sinking, the object is clear, the object is stable, there’s no coarse agitation, there’s no coarse sinking. It’s very pleasant. And the ancient Yogis of Tibet mistook this for calm abiding and called this meditation with no effort. If you continue focusing, the problems will not arise at first, don’t If you continue focusing on the object at that level, typically the fifth mental abiding, the subtler sinking, without correcting the subtler sinking, it is like, if any of you for instance has sharpened a very fine knife, you would understand what I say. It is like taking a very fine knife and rubbing it on something with very high grit in the wrong way.
You will dull it very slowly. The mind becomes dull, but it’s a very subtle dullness. You will not lose the object of meditation, clarity will progressively decrease, and the sign that this is happening is a loss of memory. So, calm abiding is the development of memory, what we call recollection. Someone who says he or she is training in calm abiding and whose memory is deteriorating is someone who is mistaking subtle sinking for concentration.
And then the end result, and Sakya Pandita was very harsh in his judgment, he said, these mistaken practitioners of Mahāmudrā who end up training all their life to be reborn as animals, Because what you’re doing, you’re taking a very good human mind and you’re just dulling it, you know. So if you want to do a concentration retreat, you need those instructions and ideally one would be directed by someone who has experience, but it’s difficult. Do you have other questions? Yes, Anilah, please. Exercise you have to do, because otherwise if the body is not strong, one is in trouble.
Typically prostrations. Prostrations is a marvelous marvelous practice, you you accumulate merit, it’s just there’s only benefit, you know. Do have other questions? Yes, Anil? I’ve read, in a number of texts that it’s, it’s best to stop the meditation at the peak of, when it’s going really, really well rather than, as you were saying, when it starts to decline.
Yes, I mean typically when you practice at home, that’s how you would do it. But when you enter a retreat, then you have a number of sessions you must do every day. And if you do a deity retreat, then you must complete the sādhana. Whether it goes well or not, there’s no margin. But with calm abiding it’s different.
Calm abiding your focus is on very very short sessions, really the shorter the better. I mean five, people say ten minutes, but five minutes. And your goal is for stellar concentration, perfect concentration. Then calm abiding retreats are boring. It’s very boring.
This is all you do, you know. And you cannot change object of meditation. So there are many many fine fine points of the practice of calm abiding. You know, if anyone of you wants to do a retreat, should receive teachings. There is one case where you can change object of meditation and that is if you have badly chosen your object of meditation.
Then, what happens in calm abiding is basically when you train in calm abiding, the mind is being turned inwards from the sense faculties. Then we don’t do this, right? So we have no experience. As the mind is turned inwards, typically your sense faculties will start to dim. You will not hear, you will not see, you will not feel.
First it’s progressive, then your sense faculties just shut down completely. You know. And as the mind is turned inwards, typically your dominant affliction becomes very powerful, and that we are different. For some it’s anger, for some it’s desire, for some it’s ignorance, it depends on the person, we have to know ourselves in these matters. Then this dominant affliction, which was hidden always under sensory stimuli, becomes very powerful and it interferes with calm abiding.
So let’s say if you are the angry type, you know, then once you start to get good concentration, let’s say on the image of Buddha Śākyamūni, then a lot of irritation appears in the mind for no reason. It’s irritation with the representation and irritation with Buddha Śākyamūni and irritation with the teaching and that is a clear sign, anger is a dominant affliction and there you may have to change objects of meditation and meditate on an object which acts as an antidote to that anger, because otherwise you would never progress. And that will make you move backwards in your practice unavoidably, right? But otherwise you would not achieve your goal. Then if it were desire, then you would focus on the skeleton and whatnot.
Right? The skeleton, you know, the dirtiness, the filth of the human body. No. You know you won’t feel ecstatic, you will feel a lot of agitation and the mind will start wandering away towards objects of desire. But that’s these are really fine points for people who really, you know, do the retreats on calm abiding, you know.
Didn’t you have other questions? Fear. Which fear? Anxiety. I think it depends on the person.
I’ll take your question immediately after I didn’t realize. I think probably meditation on death. On death. I mean, we are anxious and afraid because the things of this life have become too important. For this, nowadays, people have a lot of fear and anxiety about money.
Right? Do they have enough? Will they get enough? Will they ever be able to retire? Will they lose their job?
Oh, you are very kind, thank you very much. Then, it can be health in another age group. But once one meditates on impermanence and death, then when things will, as I quoted yesterday or before yesterday, all is transitory, right? Everything passes, everything changes, you know. There is nothing to cling to it, this is the nature as Buddha Śākyamūni said, the end of all accumulation is loss.
So the end of any well filled bank account is an empty bank account, right? And the end of being elevated is a fall. The end of a high status in society is being on the street. I saw many in Switzerland, know. I knew many many Swiss bankers, know, I I still run into them, you know.
It’s okay. But very striking, he was very high up in the bank, know. And he lost his job after 2008, obviously, you know. Like, what they all did create his own little internet company at home. Sometimes they create it at their parents, right.
And it’s got fancy internet site, but it’s actually a one man company. Right? And this man, he was quite proud when I met him. Handsome, well built Swiss man in his fifties, bond trader at the top, you know. He saw me came running towards me, hell.
And he is, he is, he is. Oh, would you be interested in doing something? I said, no, thank you. So it’s like that nowadays. Right?
He was on top and he ended up at the bottom. They could be on top again, right? So when you look at it like that, then there’s no fear, right? It’s a very powerful an antidote to anxiety. The end of being high is a fall.
The end of meeting is separation. Every meeting, every friendship, having parents, having boyfriends, girlfriends, lovers, children, whatever, this all ends in separation. I’m 54, I’m starting to see it, almost 54, you know, many people I know have either died or moved away and the contact is gone, you know. And the end of life is death. If you meditate like this, then there’s great peace, there’s no fear, there’s no anxiety.
Right? That’s the benefit of Dharma. Because much of the problem I think we have as westerners, and many Asians I think have sort of integrated the western outlook, is this idea that somehow we are responsible for everything. We are omnipotent. Obviously, we aren’t.
I think if you look back on our life, you can see that basically that life is largely conditioned by conditions. Right? Then once you realize that you are powerless for other things, the fear goes. It’s not in our control, you know. One does one’s best, that’s not to say one doesn’t do one’s best, but then after that.
And also it helps a lot to practice altruism. So that there’s a lot of research in biology biology on this, psychology especially. Because when you practice altruism and you see people who are a lot worse off than you, it really contextualizes things. Like, a lot of our worries are very unsubstantial because we’re doing very well. Like, in Australia, you’re doing beautifully.
You know, I’m just delighted to have been able to set settle here. My brother my sister’s husband, my brother-in-law is Belgian, you know. I mean, you heard what’s happening in Belgium. Right? Then we know we don’t have these problems here, you know.
I mean everyone I know over there has lost their job. Brother-in-law lost three jobs one after the other. Top top top, you know. It was like this, like this, like this. He ended up with a company ran for ran for my mother’s apartment.
Right? He had to rebuild in his fifties from scratch, you know. So compared to that, we can’t say it’s that bad here, can we? Honestly. Then do you have other questions?
And if you don’t, I have questions for you. Please. What’s the difference make to the one’s life? Does it make from reflection and meditation? Could you what is life?
What kind of difference make to people when people only do reflection, like applying antidotes right away in daily life versus doing it in meditation? Daily life is very difficult. So when you’re dealing with afflictions, let’s say desire or anger, you have to act before they arise. Once they arise, it’s much more difficult to control. Then what you do is, first, there’s there’s strategies here because the time is limited for all of us.
One identifies one’s biggest problem. What is the biggest problem? Is it desire? Is it ignorance? Is it hatred?
Then one focuses mainly on the biggest problem. We are all different in this matter. Then that does not mean you’re not going to focus eventually on the other afflictions, but they are subsidiary. Let us say desire is the biggest problem. Then before desire arises, one does a lot of meditation on death, meditation on the nature of the body as a skeleton, on the filthy nature of the body, then you can do it in the Mahāyāna or the Theravāda traditions, you know, that’s up to you, you know.
The result is exactly the same. Then this these meditations kick in when you are exposed to an object of desire. Now desire is not just physical or sexual, right? You can desire things like cars, you can desire high status in society, these are all forms of desire. So we have to identify these objects of desire we crave for and then meditate on why they are unsatisfactory.
Let’s say we desire high status in society. Then we think, well, the highest status in society comes to an end. The wealthiest man eventually suffers from cancer, from Alzheimer’s, you know. The most influential man is ever eventually voted out of office, eventually becomes at best a part of history, at worst an object of contempt or ridicule, look at what happened to Helmut Kohl in Germany, those of you who follow history, you know, Then high status high status is not worth pursuing. Then relationships is another classic way we basically crave for the projections we impute on the body of another person, because that’s what it amounts to.
You have no access to the mind, right? So we have our own fantasies, own projections, and love amounts, as we, what we call love, amounts to finding someone who accepts to carry our projections and whose projections we accept to carry. That’s what it amounts to. Then this continues for a period of time until the contrast or the discrepancy between what we project on the other and who they are becomes too great. You are my sweet adored Lulu and the sweet adored Lulu is sharpening an axe in the night.
Then at that point it collapses, right? Or their projections on us collapse. And at this point, we have those damning sentences all of us have heard or have said, you have changed. Right? So the person never changed.
We projected something on them and obviously they kept changing and they are impermanent phenomena and eventually the discrepancy became too great. So this is profoundly narcissistic, right? And it’s very easy when you look at it like that, it’s very easy to prevent it from happening, isn’t it? This is inside my own mind. And you do find when you do a lot of purification that these projections really really decrease.
Until you do a lot of purification, one is a bit like an automated one is controlled by what amounts to karmic imprints. We each have our own. Right? So this is basically the way to proceed. It’s meditation.
Yes. It’s meditation. Meditation is that. I mean, obviously, we here are Buddhist center, we focus on Buddhist texts, but I encourage you greatly to read on the outside. I mean, is now studied extensively, cognitive psychology and whatnot.
There’s material we can use, we can adopt, you know. If we live in a bubble, you know, like in my case I would happily live in a bubble in the fourteenth century, Then how do we communicate with anyone in the 20 century? Right? Now, but it’s true if you read Je Tsongkhapa, it’s it’s very, very inspiring. You know, then when you try quoting Je Tsongkhapa at the center, it goes down like a ton of lead.
Right? It does, doesn’t it? You know, but when you say magic words, modern scientific research has established that. Right? At that moment, everyone’s ears perk up.
Right? Well, those are our biases, you know. Tibetans, when you see everyone’s ears perk up, you know. So I have questions for you then. Sorry.
Please. Please. Quickly a little line of detail about the four correct abandonments in the subdivisions. There’s actually only one of those is an abandonment and the rest is like a generation of so what yeah. How how are those generations abandonments?
So you abandon the not you abandon not generating. Right? Yes. Yes. We we yes.
Yes. Yes. And just with the continuing the seven subdivisions with the repetition of the subdivisions like enthusiasm and and, you know, that’s repeated from the third legs of magical four legs of magical emanation through to the seven branches of enlightenment. With generally, with those qualities that are repeated, is is that because it’s like an intensification of that Yes. Through each stage?
Yes. Yes. And that’s why I have questions for you. That’s why I have questions for you. So remember we said that the seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment, the three first ones are trained in from the path of accumulation to full enlightenment, right?
Then on the path of preparation, we train in two of the seven subdivisions, right? We train in the five faculties and we train in the five powers. So, could someone give me the five powers? If possible from memory, if possible from memory because you can all read I see. Yeah.
Attention, no. Not really. Faith and enthusiasm, yes. Recollection. Recollection, yes.
Yes. Wisdom. Wisdom. So these are at the path of preparation. Right?
Then I have two questions for you. The first question is why does faith appear for the first time as a quality on the path of preparation and not on the path of accumulation? I mean we say that faith is the foundation of good, all good qualities, right? So why is faith appearing as one of the five powers and one of the five forces on what is a very advanced stage? And when does that deep analysis occur?
The stage of the path of accumulation, I think. When? The first one, close placement of recollection. No, move on. Then the second one No.
For sure not. Yes. Third one. When one. Sorry?
Within the four legs of magical emanation. What is one of the four legs? Yes. So when we speak of faith at the level of the five powers and the five forces, is that faith as you and I understand it? No.
It’s a faith which is based on analysis. Analysis. Then if it’s a faith based on analysis, it is what we call in logic a No, valid cognizers are not faith. Conviction, precisely. This is how you have to analyze these topics.
When you debate about this, everyone disagrees with everyone else by the way. A good question. Does anyone have an answer? The question is the you have the five powers from the path, the path of warmth and peak, and the five forces on the path of forbearance and supreme phenomena. What is the difference?
We have faith in both. Enumeration is exactly the same. Faith, enthusiasm, recollection, concentration, wisdom. So what’s the difference between the five powers and the five forces? Wish I mentioned that this morning actually.
At the stage of the forces, you can abandon what is discordant with Did I say abandon? I’m sure I didn’t. I’m just reading what Geshe-la said. Well, would never have translated abandon. Okay.
You can turn away. What is the difference between turning away and abandoning? At the level of the five, your answer is correct so far. At the level of the five forces, thanks to the five forces you can turn away from what is discordant, which is the afflictions. Whereas at the level of the five powers it’s not completely possible to do so.
But if you had at the level of the five forces the capacity to abandon an affliction, as opposed to turning away from it, what is the very important difference? What does abandonment in Buddhist philosophy mean? It no longer arises. Yes. Who said that?
Andy, right? Yes. So what is the difference between never rising again and just turning away from? Turning away when you want to it from that moment. No, no.
No, no. Look, imagine you go, Doctor, Ronald, Moira, the shopkeeper is obnoxious and you’re ready to blow up, but you restrain your anger. What is that? Yes.
It’s turning What that means is you have controlled anger, you have prevented it from arising, but in the future you will still get angry. Abandonment means never ever again will we get angry. Abandonment is not contrived, because you must put effort to generate it. Yes, but once the abandonment is generated, you never put any effort ever again. We don’t use the terms contrived, but what an abandonment means is that the door is not just closed, but a wall has been erected there.
Now, the big question, that’s why it is so important, Sakya Pandita says, the central question in Buddhism is whether abandonments are possible or not. There’s a lot of Buddhism which is rationally constructed, like if you believe in past and future lives, you can basically construct an awful lot of Buddhism. There’s evidence for past and future lives. Perhaps not as strong as we’d like, but there is. But the big question is, do abandonments exist or not?
That’s a big question. Like, if you apply an antidote to desire, let’s say desire arises in my mind, I apply the antidote meditating on the, you know, evanescent nature of the object, then the desire for the car will dwindle, that desire will reappear. Is it possible to create a state where desire never appears again? That’s The Buddhist assertion is it is. But that’s a central question.
That’s why distinguishing verbally between abandonment, on the one hand or abandoning, and turning away or relinquishing on the other hand is very important. At the level of the path of preparation, we are not able to abandon. No. Preparation, the second. Yes.
Well, so at the end of five, we enter the path of seeing. And this is why I have a second question for you. What is the criterion or one of the criterions for entering the path of preparation? You have to have Single pointed. Calm abiding, yes.
You have to have calm abiding, right? So if you have calm abiding, what does that mean? Yes, but if you, let’s say you have calm abiding on emptiness, emptiness is your object. Do you need recollection or vigilance once you have calm abiding? No.
Actually, if you apply recollection of vigilance, what is that? It is, yes, it’s inappropriate intemperate application of the antidotes. Correct, right? If that is the case, why is recollection listed in both the five powers and the five forces, where you already are on the path of preparation? You can see why concentration would be listed, that’s okay.
Concentration would be calm abiding, wisdom is fine, faith we talked about, enthusiasm is okay, but what about the third one, why recollection? You have calm abiding, you don’t need recollection. If you need recollection, you don’t have calm abiding. You’d still have to recall the object emptiness in its many different applications as you make your mind more subtle. Maybe?
Maybe? I’m not answering the question. Don’t ask Ishila by the way. That’s for you to to basically worry. That’s how you address these these topics, right?
Because it’s it’s a major question. Once you have attained calm abiding, have perfected the power of recollection, you don’t need to train recollection. You put the mind the nature of calm abiding is when you focus on an object, there is no effort required. You put the mind on the object and the mind just stays on the object. You don’t have to check if there is agitation or sinking.
Right? With calm abiding, if you do not decide beforehand when the meditation stops, it never stops. Yes, definitely, yes. Using that term of calm abiding for the outcome you want. You can.
I mean, find your answers. I have no answer to give you. No, but the path of preparation you have calm abiding and you’re training in insight. Insight in other words, insight is analysis on the object of meditation within calm abiding. The mind of calm abiding is focused on the object.
It’s said to be like basically the relation between a stream and a fish, right? The stream is calm abiding, the fish which bounces or swims in the stream is insight analysis. So there’s a small stream of insight going on within the core of calm abiding. The mind is just focused on the object, in this case emptiness, and within that powerful focus, there’s an inner core which is analyzing the object, you know. So calm abiding itself is attained when you have the two pliancies, right?
Physical and mental pliancies as a result of concentration. Then insight is attained when you generate pliancies in dependence on analysis. That’s something else altogether, you know. And you have to recollect that balance so that one doesn’t overtake. Because if you just Well, for us, yes.
But once you have calm abiding No. But that’s what Tsongkhapa says at the end. Mhmm. If you still see the subject and object is different and you have not yet But you have no direct perception. That’s right, you have not yet attained the goal.
So the emptiness, the object and emptiness would be not the final emptiness at the path of preparation because there’s still more to realise. Object is the same. The level of the path of preparation, the object is realised conceptually through an inferential valid cognizer and that inferential valid cognizer is a mind of calm abiding, of insight, excuse me, occurring within the stream of calm abiding. The transition from the path of preparation to the, we’ll talk about that Tuesday, The transition from the path of preparation to the path of seeing occurs when through repeated familiarization that valid cognizer, which is conceptual, which understands its object emptiness through a generic image, a meaning generality, eventually sees it without a meaning generality, nakedly. And that’s I think a very good statement to stop our question and answers upon, thank you very much, you know.
And please, you think of these 37 facets of enlightenment, try to analyze them like this, this is what’s really really helpful. Why? Right? Why is for instance a recollection within the five powers and the five forces, why is faith present at the level of the path of preparation and what faith is it, right? It’s rather odd, you know.
What is a livelihood referred to within the eight, eightfold path of an ārya? Does an ārya need livelihood? If so, what is it? Etcetera etcetera etcetera. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- pandita khäpa (Tib)
- Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.