Emptiness – 2014-10-08 – KR

1 h 41 min · 3,701 words · 8 October 2014

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness - 2014-10-08 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A lamrim teaching on the three scopes of practice: the small scope, which abandons non-virtue and takes up virtue with karma and causality as its foundation; the middling scope, built on the four noble truths; and the great scope, centred on bodhicitta. It explains coarse and subtle impermanence and how they relate to death and to karma. The recording closes with a question and answer session on the order of practice.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 41m

UUID: c11ed082-f3bc-407e-b822-15bfc3312072

Date: 2014-10-08

Words: 3,697

As is said in the sūtra, the sūtra of the Embryo of Buddhahood, the foundation of mind is of the nature of clarity and luminosity. Indeed, even though all sentient beings are afflicted by the afflictions, nonetheless, these afflictions do not penetrate into the innermost nature of the mind. And therefore, the goal is to free the mind from the obstructions which impede it. Now whereas our body, our physical body is free, our mind is not free because it has fallen under the sway of the afflictions. Afflictions.

What precisely is this liberation of the mind, which at present has fallen under the sway of the afflictions? It is actually what is referred to as the state of liberation. And what binds the mind and prevents it from attaining this liberation is the apprehension of the self. In other words, ignorance. The antidote to this ignorance is its direct opposite, which is the wisdom realizing selflessness.

And as much as the wisdom realizing selflessness and the ignorance which apprehends a self of the phenomena have the same object of observation and are direct the opposite, the wisdom realizing selflessness can act as an antidote to ignorance. The greater the wisdom realizing selflessness, the lesser the ignorance which apprehends a self of the person and of phenomena in as much as they are direct antidotes to each other and have the same object. When the wisdom realizing selflessness is led to its completion, one attains a state of unalloyed happiness in which one is completely free of the afflictions, and this state is liberation. Therefore, this mind which engages initially in hearing, in other words, study, then in reflection, in other words, analysis, and eventually in meditation, could be called the lineage of Buddhahood. Then this is something which calls for study.

Study both of the object of observation and of one’s goal, which is liberation. And one progresses incrementally over time through the paths of the being of the small, of the middling, and of the great scope. And therefore, out of our present foundation of benightedness with liberation as our object of observation, we progress along the path of the being of the small scope initially. And the main focus of the being of the small scope is to abandon non virtue and to train in virtue. It is therefore important to understand clearly, both the object of abandonment and the object attained in the practice of the being of the small scope.

The object of abandonment for the practitioners, the being of the of the small scope is non virtue, and the object attained is virtue and by extension, a higher rebirth. In other words, rebirth as a human being or a deity. And therefore, taking the path of the being of the small scope as a foundation, a foundation in which one’s object of abandonment is non virtue and one’s object of attainment is a higher rebirth, one progresses to the practice of the being of the middling scope. The core practice of the being of the middling scope is, on the one hand, engaging in those of the four noble truths which must be engaged in, and on the other hand, turning away from those of the four noble truths which must be turned away from. Once one has been able to engage in an unmistaken fashion in what is to be engaged regarding the four noble truths and to turn away from what is to be turned away from the four noble truths, one can then enter into the practice of the being of the great scope.

And the focus of the practice of the being of the great scope, as is said in the Lama Chöpa, is as follows. self-cherishing is the gate of all downfalls, whereas cherishing others or altruism is the foundation of all qualities. Practicing in this way, eventually, one will attain one’s goal, the object of attainment here, which is full enlightenment. So this is how one should proceed in an unmistaken fashion from the path of the being of the small to the middling to the great scope, identifying the respective object of abandonment of each of the scopes and the respective attainment of each of the scopes. Then, in general, the four noble truths are the foundation of all of the Buddha’s teachings.

However, in the context of the presentation of the beings of the three scopes, they are the main practice of the being of the middling scope. So the way one should proceed is initially, one should listen to, in other words, one should study practices of the beings of the small, of the middling, and of the great scope. This is what we are doing at present. And then after studying these, when the time has come to practice, one should practice incrementally trying to gain realization in each of these. Just as when you irrigate a field, you lay down an irrigation pipe.

Otherwise, if you were to water the field in any which way, the water would go to waste. Likewise, initially, one must study the path one must follow, and then one is able to follow this path. The example which is given in the text is one is receiving teachings just as if one were to go to a show. Then at this point, when one engages in the practice later on, the practice does not go well. So within the context of our topic of study, the path of the being of the small scope, the focus is upon abandoning non virtue and practicing virtue.

What precisely is meant by this? What is meant by this is that one should be ready, one should have the conviction that one will not engage in the practice of non virtue even at the cost of one’s own life, and that one will bind one’s mind to the practice of virtue. At this point, one is able to train. Then this training does not occur only in meditation, but occurs in daily life as well. As is said in Lama Tsongkhapa’s Foundation of All Good Qualities, bless me to have the heedfulness to practice virtue and abandon non virtue.

As is said in both Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path, and liberation in the palm of your hand, the gateway, in other words, the foundation of practice is karma and causality. It is with karma and causality that practice begins. And therefore, with, as our object of observation, liberation, and as foundation, the practice of the being of the small scope that is at present generating motivation to listen to these teachings reflecting on the fact that karma and causality is the foundation of the practice of the being of the small scope. So if one studies the continually, this is how one should proceed. Then we have received Lamrim teachings many times, so one should proceed in this way from the beginning, the purpose of the being of the small scope.

Therefore, initially, when one studies the lamrim, when one listens to the lamrim, one must listen or study the totality of the lamrim from the practice of the being of the small scope all the way up to the state of union or Yuganaddha, but then after this, one engages initially in one’s practice in an overview meditation, which understands how each topic of Lamrim is linked to the next before focusing on one topic, which is one’s main practice. Then the relationship which exists between the practice of the being of the small scope and the four noble truths, in my opinion, is as follows. The first of the four noble truths is the noble truth of suffering. And the noble truth of suffering has three characteristics, impermanence, emptiness and selflessness. It is the first characteristic of the first noble truth impermanence which is taught within the context of the practice of the being of the small scope.

Within the four characteristics of the first noble truth, which are taught within the Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path, the first characteristic impermanence is subdivided into two, coarse and subtle impermanence. It is specifically coarse impermanence in my opinion, which is taught in the context of the practice of the being of the small scope. The distinction between coarse and subtle impermanence must be understood. Coarse impermanence actually refers to death and impermanence. Then irrespective of whether one has been affected or not by tenets, whether one has been trained or not in tenets, all of us are subject to coarse impermanence, death impermanence.

What is coarse impermanence? Coarse impermanence refers to the cessation of the continuum born from concordant causes through the interference of discordant conditions. To give an example, let us take the white silk silk scarf, on this table, the kata on this table. This white silk silk scarf abides continually, changing instant by instant even though we cannot perceive this, until through the power of a discordant condition such as being cast into the fire, it is incinerated and disappears, ceases, and is destroyed. This is what is to unders be understood by coarse impermanence.

Then how do we apply this to death and impermanence? Well, death is an instance of coarse impermanence in which, in our own case, the potency which has been impelled through previous karma and which gave rise to this existence has reached its point of exhaustion and through the interference of discordant conditions, which are diseases which may be greater or smaller, we cease to exist. Then the intervention of diseases is guaranteed. It does, however, happen that due to discordant conditions such as a car accident, crime, violence, and so forth, the potency which gave rise to the present existence and which has arisen from previously impelled karma ceases brutally before it has reached its point of extinction. It is, however, certain in either case that we will die as a result of the intervention or interference of discordant conditions.

Then coarse impermanence is counted as death or death and impermanence within the presentation of the path of the being of the small scope. And our own death at the time of the interference of discordant conditions will give rise to the suffering of the lower realms. When we search for a means to be protected from the suffering of the lower realms, we turn for refuge. However, this refuge should not be a a reasonless refuge. It is a refuge which must be based not only on faith, but also on reason.

Then if one reflects incrementally in sequence in this way, this is extraordinarily beneficial if one has the time to do so and can meditate. Then the presentation of karma and causality was in the context of the path of the being of the small scope, training and virtue and abandoning non virtue is a coarse presentation of causality. That was in the context of the path of the being of the middling scope is a subtle presentation of karma and causality. When this presentation within the context of the practice of the being of the small scope, which relies on a presentation of coarse impermanence as a subtopic of the four noble truths leading to subtle impermanence and eventually to the path of the being of the middling scope, is, in my personal opinion, a presentation for beings of somewhat dull acumen. Then you are naturally practitioners of sharp acumen, and therefore, one should immediately start with a focus on subtle impermanence.

Then a practitioner of sharp acumen who focuses on subtle impermanence probably starts immediately at the level of the being of the middling scope. Then it is important to understand that coarse and subtle impermanence are fundamentally different in one respect. Whereas in the case of a coarse impermanence, the continuum of an entity or an object is interrupted through the interference of a discordant condition, this is not the case in the case of subtle impermanence. In the case of subtle impermanence, phenomena disintegrate instant by instant, and this disintegration is due to the previous instant of the phenomenon. It is due to each instant of the phenomenon being the substantial cause of the subsequent instant.

It is not due to the intervention of an exterior discordant condition. There’s food for thought here since we can see that karma must be the result of a concordant cause, and this concordant cause is ignorance which gives rise to karma. Likewise, in the case of the four noble truths, the two first features of the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering are impermanence and emptiness. And impermanence itself, specifically subtle impermanence, must be understood as the result of a concordant cause. The concordant cause is the previous instant of the given impermanent phenomenon.

Then this presentation, in terms of subtle impermanence, is for practitioners of subtle acumen and as a result is somewhat difficult to understand. As we ourselves have far greater direct experience of death and impermanence, the presentation in terms of course coarse impermanence of the practice of the beings of the three scopes is mainstream. In the case of subtle impermanence, the cause of the disintegration instant by instant of a subtle impermanent of a phenomenon is its mere creation. The cause of its nature as a phenomenon which disintegrates instant by instant is its mere creation. Through understanding this as the foundation of all impermanent phenomena, we can see how subtle impermanence would eventually transform into coarse impermanence.

As for instance, 60 fractions of the time it takes to snap one’s fingers turn into one second, sixty seconds turn into one minute, sixty minutes turn into one hour, twenty four hours turn into one day, seven days into one week, fifty two weeks into one year, and so forth. So this is how the coarse is built from the subtle upwards. Refuge abuts upon karma and causality, and specifically, the refuge advice about or the refuge precepts about karma and causality. The refuge precepts are subdivided into two, proscriptive and prescriptive precepts. The foremost prescriptive precept regarding Dharma is to relinquish violence towards other sentient beings.

And this is why within the outline of this text, it is said the root of all excellent happiness is giving rise to the convinced faith in karma and causality. Right? And, therefore, the foremost prescription of refuge is to foreswear non virtue and to engage in virtue. For instance, when one refers to for swearing or abandoning non virtue, a classic example would be lying, which is so prevalent among us. Let us imagine, for instance, since we have studied the dharma for a very long time, that someone comes to us with a question about the dharma and we do not know the answer.

Instead of answering honestly, I don’t know, which is the correct and true answer, should we make up an answer to impress the other party, this is a lie. This is food for thought. So what is lying other than the attempt to deceive another party? When, therefore, one completely foreswares any attempt to deceive others, any attempt to engage in non virtue, then one will have abandoned non virtue. So one should be very careful.

It is a bit less of a case in Tibet where we tend to pay the agreed upon price. But in India, for instance, one initiates a lot over prices, and it is very possible to deceive someone in the bargaining process. So the best is to pay 100% of the asking price. And, therefore, this is how one should endeavor to practice As is said in the Foundation of All Good Qualities, bless me to have heedfulness in the accumulation of the collection of virtues. And this emphasizes the importance of heedfulness in one’s practice.

So this is how one should practice, and this is the most pleasant way to do things. Then in this particular coarse presentation of karma and causality is called the authentic view of a worldly being. It is called the authentic view of a worldly being because it is a practice of a beginner’s coarse. Stop. Then we shall stop here.

And if you have a couple questions, please ask your questions. Not that many questions. Yes, please. Ah, the gentleman, excuse me, has a microphone. Usually I mentioned to study by following the lamrim as it is set out.

Then And when my practice is to consider an overview bearing in mind we need an understanding of how it all fits together. Then he said then one can then focus on one’s main practice. How does one identify one’s main practice? Generally speaking, our main focus is the generation of bodhicitta in as much as we are practitioners of the great scope. To give rise to bodhicitta, we need great compassion.

To give rise to great compassion, we need all of the preceding levels. However, to identify one’s own level, whether we are ourselves beings of the small, middling, or great scope, we have to check specifically as far as whether we are a being of the small scope or not, whether we have turned away from all the realities of this life or not. If even in our dreams, we have no attachment whatsoever to food, to clothing, and to reputation, then we have the realization of the being of the small scope, otherwise not. Mhmm. Oh, sorry.

I was just wondering if you could repeat the characteristics of suffering, and So the six perfections do not have any specific relationship to the practice of the being of the small scope. They are specific to the practice of the being of the great scope. So the three first characteristics of the first noble truth of suffering are impermanence, suffering, and selflessness. Impermanence here refers within coarse and subtle impermanence to subtle impermanence. In other words, to the fact that phenomena change instant by instant, and the fact that phenomena disintegrate instant by instant is a direct result of them merely being produced.

The fact that phenomena disintegrate instant by instant, in other words, their subtle impermanence leads to an understanding of their coarse impermanence, which leads to an understanding of karma. Karma itself is rooted in ignorance. The counter to ignorance which gives rise to suffering, the second characteristic of the first noble truth. The counter to this ignorance is selflessness. Hello.

Geshe-la said that in terms of the potency of the karma which gave rise to the present existence that sometimes through an accident or some violent means that that potency ceases before it has reached its extinction but that seems to imply to me that a violent end such as a car accident is not a result of karma. So could Geshe-la clarify that, I believe that in the case of a premature death, such as this one due to a car accident, this is due to another non virtuous karma maturing. For instance, the non virtuous karma of having repeatedly killed others in previous lives. So this would be akin to a subsequently concordant experience. Yeah.

The, going back to Pamela’s question about the six perfections, I understood that in particular the first three generosity, patience and enthusiastic effort were ideally suited to the early beginning practitioner to help develop virtues and abandon non virtues. Krakesh, shall I speak about that? So it is true that the practices of generosity, of ethics and of patience, of forbearance, are practices for beginners like ourselves, but these are not the perfections. These become the perfections only if they are upheld by bodhicitta. So if your practice of these three is upheld by bodhicitta, then these are the perfections.

Geshe-la mentioned that in Lamrim Chenmo and in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand that the gateway or foundation for practice is karma and causality and it’s with karma or causality that the practice begins. The use of the gateway, I’ve heard that is understood that death and impermanence was the gateway to the Dharma. Is that have I got that wrong? 110%. That’s great.

You know? It’s an excellent question. Basically, the foundation, of practice is doubtlessly, meditation on death and impermanence. However, there is probably nothing in meditation on death and impermanence which one should adopt, and there is also nothing which one should relinquish. One merely meditates on death and impermanence as a prelude to the actual practice, which is a practice of karma and causality, which involves training and relinquishment.

So until these reflections on death and impermanence lead to a practice of virtue and a relinquishment of non virtue, leading to an understanding of the sufferings of the lower realms and taking refuge, within the dream state. Until that point, probably, one has not gained any realization. Geshe said Geshe-la said? You see, every time you say Yes. I understand.

And there’s only Geshe-la who teaches. Geshe-la said that you are naturally practitioners of sharp acumen, which from my own side, I dispute that statement, but and that as such, one should start with a focus on subtle impermanence and then we start immediately at the level of being of the middling scope. But if we’ve not had in any way any realizations of death and impermanence leading to renunciation, how can we move on to the practice? Or how can we start at the practice of being of the middling scope? So I should emphasize that this is my private opinion.

It is unclear in the text. What I would say is that it depends on what is most beneficial for oneself. If it is most beneficial for oneself to meditate from the beginning on death and impermanence, to start training as a being of the smaller scope, then train as a being of the middling scope, then we should proceed in this way. Alternatively, if it’s more beneficial for oneself from the beginning to meditate on subtle impermanence and start training as a being of the middling scope, then one should train in this way? Today, he has stopped.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

How does one identify one's main practice in the Lamrim?

Generally, the main focus is the generation of bodhicitta, insofar as we are practitioners of the great scope. Bodhicitta requires great compassion, and great compassion requires all of the preceding levels of the path. To identify one's own level, whether small, middling or great scope, one has to check specifically whether one is a being of the small scope, that is, whether one has turned away from all the realities of this life. The test is this: if even in our dreams we have no attachment whatsoever to food, to clothing, and to reputation, then we have the realization of the being of the small scope. Otherwise, we do not.

Scroll to Top