Emptiness

1 h 7 min · 3,152 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 68-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche traces the leap from conceptual to direct realization of emptiness. Practitioners on the path of preparation understand emptiness conceptually by analyzing whether the eye or self are truly established from their own side, using reason and instruction. He illustrates with a striking analogy: just as you cannot see your face without a mirror, conceptual realization is a mediated cognition similar to—but not—emptiness itself. At the path of seeing, realization becomes direct and non-conceptual. He emphasizes focusing on self and eye to counter the ignorance that grasps at inherent existence. The session includes student questions on concrete instances of emptiness and closes with guided discussion on the conceptual-to-non-conceptual transition. Pitched at serious practitioners with prior Buddhist training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 16082016Salam 2 – KR.mp3

UUID: e6971e76-1d5e-45f9-a557-8e2c0e2040d8

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,144

When was explaining, Maitreya, he mentioned the context of explaining the mode of engaging in meditative equipoise and emptiness that at the level of the seventh ground, one just had to think slightly. I must engage in meditative equipoise and emptiness and it would occur. And at the level, levels below the seventh ground, in other words, from the sixth ground downwards to the first ground, obviously, then one would not have that degree of habituation with meditative equipoise on emptiness. Once one has attained the path of an ārya being, in other words, from the first ground upwards, one realizes emptiness by means of a direct valid cognizer. This does not however mean that conceptuality is not present during meditation on emptiness since one can pass from a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer to conceptual cognition and back.

But this conception is a memory, a recollection. So at the level of the path of preparation, although one does realize emptiness, when one realizes emptiness by means of a valid cognizer, it is a realization which is mixed with a meaning generality. In other words, it is a conceptual realization of emptiness. And this obviously ceases at the level of the path of seeing when one realizes emptiness directly by means of a valid cognizer. So, obviously, with all this talk, one must gain an understanding of emptiness.

Then, in our cases, gaining a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer would be difficult. But this does not preclude gaining an understanding of emptiness. A sense that emptiness exists in the same way as we would say bodhicitta or great compassion exist. Then bodhicitta and great compassion are also difficult to generate in our mind stream, but we have a definite sense of their existence. So we should also gain the sense of the existence of emptiness.

Obviously, it would help if we had more time, but I’m told we don’t have time. Then people who have time say they don’t have time, people who don’t have time say they have time, I’m not quite sure. Having or not having time depends on how one looks at things. So both yourselves and myself should reflect on emptiness, and if we do so, then our understanding will improve. So at the level of the paths of accumulation and preparation, specifically at the level of the path of preparation, one experiences a realization of emptiness.

This is a realization of emptiness which is conceptual in as much as it arises in dependence on analysis, and specifically on the instructions of our spiritual teacher. Since otherwise, it is difficult for us to gain an understanding of emptiness. Such an understanding of emptiness is not naked. It is mediated by a meaning generality. At the level of the paths of seeing and meditation, however, one gains a direct experience of emptiness, which is said to be naked since one sees emptiness as we would see an object with the eye consciousness, and it is said to be naked or non conceptual because one realizes it in this way for no other reason.

As Āryadeva points out in his Chatuhshataka, the Four Hundred, everything the Buddha Śākyamūni taught, he taught for the sake of the realization of emptiness. And all of the teachings of, Ārya Nāgārjuna and his spiritual son, Āryadeva, as well as Asaṇga and his disciples, was for the sake of the realization of emptiness. Now when emptiness is presented, it should not be presented in dependence on exterior objects such as this building or the stand in front of Geshe-la. Instead, one should present it in terms of the eye. One should present an ascertainment of the emptiness of the I, the mode, in other words, of positing the I.

I think if the one understands how to posit the I correctly, an understanding of the emptiness of that eye arises naturally. So the key here is to understand the nature of the eye. The eye exists, yet when we seek for the eye, it is unfindable. And therefore analyzing in this way, we can understand how to counter the ignorance which grasps at an I, which is established from its own side. As Je Tsongkhapa says in the Tenrel Töpa in his praise of dependent origination, However, much it is ascertained by consciousness, it butts onto the view of permanence.

And the meaning of these two verses is that the position of all of the lowest school of schools of tenets, from the Sāṃkhya downwards, is that the I is findable within its basis of designation. It is findable within the aggregate. And this findability intimates a view which is an extreme of permanence. A second passage in Je Tsongkhapa’s praise of dependent origination indicates that the lower schools of tenets are incapable of gaining a realization of emptiness and however much emptiness is analyzed, they are never able to sever the net of doubt. So we should reflect on the fact that initially we should focus on the nature of the I or the self.

And if we do so, it is quite pleasant to do and I doubt any one of us will stand up and leave. On the other hand, if we actually try to analyze the nature of the little stand in front of me to see whether it is established from its own side or not, this is actually very difficult to do. Then obviously, if one were to rely on the study of Buddhist philosophy, then one would deal with consequences such as the subject of vase that follows that it is not established from its own side and so forth. But this would take a very long time. As I mentioned last time, when we investigate whether the I is established from its own side or not, whether it is truly established or not, we rather rapidly have to face the issue of consciousness, which is of one nature but different isolates from the eye.

And an understanding that the I is not established from its own side leads to an understanding that consciousness is not established from its own side. Now when we refer to the fact that phenomena are not established from their own side, What this means is that they are mere conceptual imputations out there. And the example I gave last time was the example of a $100 bill. A $100 bill does not gain its value from out there. It gains its value through a process of conceptual imputation.

As was mentioned last time, the reason we focus on the fact that the eye is not established from its own side is because ignorance apprehends the eye as being established from its own side. And this apprehension of the eye as being established from its own side, means that the eye is seen by ignorance as being within the aggregates. Now, in as much as being established from its own side and not being established from its own side are directly contradictory, when we focus on the one, we reduce the power of the other. At the level of the path of preparation, to rely on the instructions of the spiritual teacher, text and reasoning, we are able to focus continually on emptiness. But this focus on emptiness is conceptual.

Emptiness is realized by means of conceptuality. There is realization of emptiness at the level of the path of accumulation as well, But it is not continuous in as much as at the level of the path of accumulation, one proceeds in dependence on minds arisen from thinking. One is unable to generate yet minds arisen from meditation for which calm abiding at the very least is necessary. So setting aside the path of accumulation during which there may or may not be realization of emptiness, let us analyze the differences in the experience of the realization of emptiness on the paths of seeing and of meditation. On the path of accumulation, one definitely must rely on a reason for a realization of emptiness and the mind realizing emptiness is unstable.

It is not continuous. On the path excuse me, on the path of seeing, with the mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, one has a stable realization and such a mind may or may not depend on a reason. So in brief, what you should understand is that at the level of the path of preparation, one has realization of emptiness, but it is conceptual. At the level of, the path of seeing and above, one has realization, but it is of emptiness, but it is non conceptual. And when we speak of the conceptual realization of emptiness at the level of the path of preparation, an example will make it easier to understand.

It is akin to looking at one’s own face in a mirror. Now if you want to look at our own face, we can’t look at our own face without a mirror, can we? We can’t sort of come out of our body and stare at ourselves. So we need a mirror to look at our own face, and with a mirror, we can see the features of our face and so forth. It is the same thing with the conceptual realization of emptiness.

With the conceptual realization of emptiness, we realize something which is similar to emptiness. It is not emptiness, but it performs the function of emptiness. And therefore, we can speak here of a realization of emptiness. Another example would be when we remember our previous plans, the plans of last week, last month or even last year. Then these are former plans, they’re in the past, they are not in the present.

But when we remember them something which is similar to them appears to the mind. What appears to the mind is not the plans because they are already gone. They are of the past, but something similar appears. So in dependence on these examples, you will be able to understand the mode of realization of emptiness at the level of the path of preparation. And then naturally, through the wisdom arisen or through a mind arisen from hearing, one must try to understand emptiness as well.

So obviously here we are referring to the emptiness in keeping with Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. It would be superb if we could realize it also in terms Svatāntrika Madhyamaka, Cittamātra and so forth, but it would probably be overwhelming. Even though you might feel like saying I like this Svatāntrika Madhyamaka view or I like the Cittamātra view, frankly, it is the Prāsaṇgika view which counts. Therefore, at the level of the path of preparation, when one has gained a conceptual realization of emptiness, there is a distinction between disciples of sharp and of dull acumen. And this is a delicate point.

Disciples of sharp acumen can probably counter the ignorance which grasps at the true existence of the self. That does not mean that they are able to abandon it and the afflictions, but they can counter it. Disciples of dull acumen are not able to do this. Why is this the case? Why is it the case that, it is possible to counter but not to abandon, the, ignorance grasping at a self, and by extension, the afflictions and the three poisons at the level of the path of preparation.

Obviously here, one is not countering the afflictions and the three poisons individually, since this would be overwhelming. But one is countering their root, their origin, which is ignorance grasping at a self. And this is possible because the mode of apprehension of the self by the ignorance grasping at a self, and the mode of apprehension of the self by the wisdom realizing emptiness are directly contradictory. So could you give me an instance of emptiness? What you’re saying is a pot not being established from its own side.

Where? Why is a part not established from its own side? So if something is merely imputed by mind, it is not established on its own side. What about others? Other examples?

Chris can hear, for example, about emptiness. Quick, quick, quick. Absence of, inherently existing self. Why is the I not established from its own side? Because it is merely imputed upon a basis of designation.

Which is the aggregates. So when one asks for an instance of emptiness, it is best to give the I not being established from its own side. Since a vase not being established from its own side is broadly speaking irrelevant to us. So, at the level of the path of preparation, when one meditates on the I not being established from its own side, One does this by means of conceptuality, by means of a meaning generality. And this continues and as one proceeds in this way, obviously one does not gain a naked perception, a non conceptual perception of the I not being established from its own side.

At the level of the path of seeing, which is an ārya path for the first time, one realizes that the I is not established from its own side, nakedly without relying on a meaning generality. Now at the level of the path of seeing for the first time, one realizes emptiness nakedly by means of a yogic direct valid cognizer. In other words, a direct valid cognizer. This is not the case at the level of the path of preparation where emptiness is realized conceptually. So at the level of the path of seeing, which is an ārya path, therefore, for the first time emptiness is realized directly by means of a yogic direct valid cognizer.

Emptiness is a permanent phenomenon. It is a non implicative negation. When we speak of permanent phenomena, this is permanent from within the division of phenomena into permanent and impermanent phenomena. So an example will make this clear. Let us take the instance of intermediate space or uncompounded space in technical Buddhist terminology.

The space between objects. Then do we realize this intermediate or uncompounded space directly or not? After all, other living beings such as cows and so forth do experience it as well. Do you understand what uncompounded space is? The empty component.

The empty part. So in Buddhist texts, uncompounded space, refers to the absence of obstructive contact. The fact that I can move my hand like this. And that is a non implicative negation. Then I’d like to ask you, is that realized directly or by means of a of a meaning generality?

So in the same way as we can realize directly uncompounded space, the intermediate component between us and objects. Likewise, one can realize directly when one enters an ārya path, the emptiness, the lack of existence from their own side of phenomena such as the I and so forth. Whereas at the level of the path of preparation, this is not possible. One must rely over and again on reasons drawn from the instructions of one’s teachers, from scripture and so forth. So once one has attained the path of seeing, one has attained an ārya path, and there are at the level of the path of seeing, the abandonments of the path of seeing, and later on at the level of the path of meditation, the abandonments of the path of meditation.

Now these abandonments of the path of seeing and of meditation can be said to be abandonments of grasping at the true existence of the I, but they can also be said to be abandonments of the afflictions. Both are appropriate. There is a doubt regarding whether when one has attained the path of seeing, one immediately abandons all the abandonments of the path of seeing. This is a delicate point. So at present, let us reflect during a couple minutes on the reasons for which the path of preparation is conceptual and the reasons for which the path of seeing is non conceptual.

We open the paper, page one. I will take only one question. Yes or no?

Question? No question? Yeah. I have a question which isn’t properly formulated in my mind, so I’m going to ask, another one. If the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view is the only one that counts, then why realize other views?

Principally, the other systems of tenets are in preparation leading up to the Prāsaṇgika view Because for those of lesser capacity, if they were to study Prāsaṇgika directly immediately, there is a risk they would fall into either of the two extremes of eternalism or nihilism, mainly the extreme of nihilism. Then should however, students wish to study directly Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, there is no reason why not. The reason for which in the great monasteries, one studies the views of all four schools of tenets is because the path in the great seats is that of the Mahāyāna, and one wishes to understand all the paths leading up to the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika and train in them. Then should one wish to enter directly the path of a Hearer or a Pratyekabuddha and focus on that practice that is perfectly acceptable. Mādhyamika is divided into two schools, Prāsaṇgika and Svatāntrika.

Now all Prāsaṇgika views are Mādhyamika views, but all Mādhyamika views are not Prāsaṇgika views since Svatāntrika Mādhyamika exists as well. Quickly. What would be some of the consequences of the self being permanent? Could you repeat? What would be some of the consequences of the self being permanent?

Self is not permanent. When you say the self, you mean the I? It’s very straightforward. If the self was permanent, then we could not go any place, we could not study, we could not better ourselves. The I is unchangeable.

It’s permanent. Then, I mean, when you eat, you get full. When you don’t eat, your stomach is empty. Clear evidence that the self is impermanent. Sometimes it gets angry as well.

Who gets angry but the I? The I. So actually, there were two viewpoints on the self. The non-Buddhist the philosophers of ancient India considered that the I was permanent, one and independent. Therefore, they thought that the self only changed occasionally.

Most of the times it did not change. This is not the Buddhist perspective, for which the self changes from instant to instant. So if you ask, what would be the consequences if the self were permanent? Look at those who assert the permanence of the self. So today for discussion, I would like you to discuss the reason and the mode in which the path of preparation involves a conceptual consciousness.

And the reason and the mode in which the path of seeing is a non conceptual consciousness and the transition from the one to the other. Mhmm. Okay. Could you discuss, please? Two, two or three?

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

If the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view is the only one that counts, why study and realize the other tenet systems?

The other tenet systems are mainly a preparation leading up to the Prāsaṇgika view. For those of lesser capacity, studying Prāsaṇgika directly right away risks falling into one of two extremes, eternalism or nihilism, mainly nihilism. Students who wish to study Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka directly may do so, and there is no reason why not. The great monasteries study the views of all four tenet schools because their path is the Mahāyāna, and they want to understand and train in all the paths leading up to the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view. Someone who wishes to enter directly the path of a Hearer or a Pratyekabuddha and focus on that practice may also do so.

Scroll to Top