Emptiness

1 h 3 min · 2,887 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 64-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche addresses a fundamental question: how does the direct realization of emptiness at the path of seeing actually function as an antidote to self-grasping, given that grasping is only fully abandoned at the path of meditation? He unpacks this through Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika analysis, beginning with definite emergence—the mind’s striving for liberation—and the distinction between conceptual understanding and non-conceptual direct perception of emptiness. Using anger recognition as an epistemological example, he shows how valid inference operates. He then maps the four Buddhist path stages (accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation), explaining how the emptiness realization progressively antidotes increasingly subtle forms of self-grasping. Q&A follows. For practitioners with prior Lamrim training.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 20092016Salam – KR.mp3

UUID: c31f5a3c-9091-4c0f-a1db-605d7d473ab5

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Emptiness

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~2,877

So, as Jé Tsongkhapa says in the Three Principal Aspects of the Path, once it arises day and night continually, definite emergence has been well generated. Therefore, it is once definite emergence arises continually, even for instance in the dream state, that one can say that uncontrived definite emergence has been generated. And here, please be unmistaken in your understanding of definite emergence, it means exactly the same thing as the mind striving for liberation. And therefore, to repeat the mind striving for liberation and definite emergence are one and the same. Then you use repeatedly the concepts of the object of observation and the aspect, and these can be applied indeed to definite emergence.

That is a very, good way to look at things. So, what therefore is the object of observation of definite emergence of the mind striving for liberation? It is none other than liberation. Then whether the object of observation is a fully characterized liberation or not, is something which needs to be investigated. So, at this point, how precisely do we obtain liberation?

What obtains liberation is none other than that lineage within our mind stream which proceeds to liberation and what can be posited as this lineage is either the emptiness of the I or the emptiness of the mind. Liberation here refers to the state of an Arhat. Now, if I were to ask you, you are person who are striving for liberation, what is this liberation you are striving for? Then you can present it in one of two ways. You can present the cause of liberation, which would be the liberation in the mind stream of a Buddha, Śākyamūni.

The liberation which Buddha Śākyamūni himself attained. Alternatively, you can present a liberation which is related to ourselves or to yourself. And that is the liberation which we will eventually attain. in dependence on this type within our mind stream, the emptiness of the I or of the mind. Then this liberation will not arise through just relaxing and sitting back.

It calls for repeated habituation with emptiness and application of the antidotes. So, regarding definite emergence, we don’t have a contrived definite emergence within our minds, it would be difficult. But when we read text such as the Lamrim, regarding the qualities of liberation and the thoughts of cyclic existence, then a sensation of definite emergence arises. This is transitory definite emergence, occasional definite emergence. It is not uncontrived definite emergence.

And then at this point, the question which arises is what precisely is this definite emergence? Is it conceptual or non conceptual? It is definitely conceptual. If it were non conceptual, then as definite emergence is something in which the mind is transformed, is striving for liberation, there could be no analysis of its object. So regarding the distinction between conceptual and non conceptual mind, this is something which I have already explained here.

Conceptual minds are minds which perceive their object by means of what is known as a meaning generality, which is akin to a drawing or a representation of the object. They typically have one of two objects, either past or future objects. The difference of non conceptual minds, the best example within our mind stream would be sensory consciousnesses whose object is present. Now, regarding particular non conceptual minds such as the recollection of previous lives, these are paranormal powers which we do not have at present, which are direct perceivers and whose object is indeed a past object. So setting aside sensory consciousnesses, just as So, setting aside sensory consciousnesses, the mode of generation of liberation, the mind striving for liberation is quite similar to the mode of generation of desire, even though they are completely opposite.

And therefore, if it were possible for this mind striving for definite emergence to become non conceptual likewise, we would have to say that desire could be non conceptual. But desire, setting conceptual, setting sensory consciousness aside, is necessarily conceptual. So, therefore conceptual conceptual excuse me. Therefore, desire, which is a mental consciousness, is probably completely conceptual. Now, regarding anger, we know that anger is present within another person in function of their physical or verbal behavior.

Apart from this, there is really no way for us to know that anger is present within the mind stream of another person. Now, on what basis, therefore, does one know that anger arises within the mind stream of another person in terms of physical and verbal behavior. In terms of physical behavior, their appearance, their color, even the size of their face seems to change. In terms of verbal behavior, they speak in a disjointed fashion. What comes before is put after.

What should come after is put before. They say things which they really regret saying after saying them. Then in dependence on this observing another person, we can generate a valid cognizer which says there is anger within the mind of that person. So, what precisely observes, this change in the physical and verbal deportment of another party? Our sensory consciousnesses which see the change in the facial expression hears a change in the way the person is speaking.

But do those sensory consciousnesses realize that this is anger? No, they don’t. So in dependence on what do we understand that the other person is angry? in dependence on a conceptual mind stream, which drawing on the information from those sensory consciousnesses concludes this person is angry. So we can conclude they are angry, and therefore, this is a conceptual valid cognizer.

If you want to give an instance of a conceptual valid cognizer, this is it. So I have a question for you. As we said, that which perceives the changes in physical and verbal behavior of someone when they are angry are the sensory consciousnesses. Now, the mind which decides that the person is angry on that basis, is it conceptual or non conceptual? Is it a valid cognizer?

So it’s a conception which is a valid cognizer. Right? So, I’ve heard rumors some of you don’t accept the existence of inferentially valid cognizers. So, we are going to discuss conceptions which are valid cognizers. On what basis does this mind understand that the other party is angry?

What’s the mode of realization? So, it is on the basis of this behavior of the other party, their physical and verbal behavior that the conceptual mind which realizes that they are angry arises. Now you’ve accepted it’s a conceptual mind, you’ve accepted it’s a valid cognizer. It arises in dependence on reasons, the reasons of the physical and verbal behavior observed by the sensory consciousnesses. This is called an inferential valid cognizer.

How can you not accept the existence of inferential valid cognizers? Well, we you already agreed it was an inferential valid cognizer. So this fits exactly the definition of your inferential valid cognizer from Buddhist treatises. An incontrovertible conceptual knower which arises in dependence on a valid reason. Then on the basis of the observation of the behavior of this person, once you generate the realization that this person is angry, this is an inferential valid cognizer.

If you’re going to say that this is not an inferential valid cognizer, then there is no inferential valid cognizer. Then there are no valid cognizers period. So because we have direct experience of both anger and desire, we should reflect on how they arise. At present, we shall explain the distinction between a being who has not entered the path and a being who has entered the path and within beings who have entered the path. The distinction between the path of accumulation and the path of preparation, the path of preparation and the path of seeing, the path of seeing and the path of meditation.

Then we will explain the, last path, the path of no more learning, in Tibetan, next week after covering once again the motivations of hearers, solitary realizers and bodhisattvas, which lead to that state. What is the distinction between a being who has not entered the path and a being who has entered the path? A being who has generated uncontrived definite emergence has entered the path. A being who has not generated uncontrived definite emergence has not entered the path. What is the distinction between the path of accumulation and preparation?

We set as a foundation, a being must enter the path. Beings who have entered the path and who have generated an insight focused on emptiness are on the path of preparation. Those who have not generated an insight focused on emptiness, but have entered the path are on the path of accumulation. What is the distinction between a being on the path of preparation and on the path of seeing? Both have already generated an insight focused on emptiness.

The being who is on the path of seeing has in addition a direct valid cognition of emptiness. The being who is not on the path of seeing but on the path of preparation does not. What is at present the distinction between the path of seeing and the path of meditation? Both are rooted in a direct experience of emptiness. However, at the level of the path of seeing, the abandonments of the path of seeing are abandoned.

When one relaxes, you wish, or takes a break from the path of seeing, And then, with the motivation of abandoning the abandonments of the path of meditation, which are also known as the innate grasping at an I, or the innate ignorance, one returns to a direct experience of emptiness. At that point, one has entered the path of meditation. In brief, as soon as the direct realization of emptiness becomes the antidote to the abandonments of meditation, the state of meditation, one has entered the path of meditation. Alternatively, since the path of seeing is the path ranging from the first instant at which one has a direct realization of emptiness. When one interrupts that meditation and then resumes it with the intention of eliminating the abandonment of meditation.

At that point, one has entered the path of meditation. And this is the case since the path of meditation is defined as subsequent manifest realization. Then as far as the path of meditation is concerned, what mind is a path of meditation? It is a direct valid cognizer, therefore, it is an unmistaken mind within mistaken and unmistaken minds. So, now regarding the distinction between mistaken and unmistaken minds, the various schools of tenets have different positions.

So let us take Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika as the base. According to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, at present within our mind streams, there are only mistaken minds. All our minds are mistaken. There are therefore in our mind stream no unmistaken minds since according to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, an unmistaken mind is a mind which directly realizes emptiness. Therefore, the paths of seeing and meditation are both unmistaken minds.

So at present, in brief, what is the distinction between the path of seeing and of meditation? A precise answer would be, these are ārya paths, and in addition, distinction hinges on whether the antidote to the innate grasping at a self is generated or not. So this is a distinction or these are the distinctions between, beings who have not entered the path and those who have entered the path between the path of accumulation and the path of preparation, the path of preparation and the path of seeing, the path of seeing and the path of meditation. So according to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, as was mentioned, all the consciousnesses within our mind stream are necessarily mistaken consciousnesses. Here, we must be mindful of the distinction between a mistaken consciousness and a wrong view.

Mistaken consciousnesses are not necessarily wrong views. Why? According to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, are all our consciousnesses mistaken consciousnesses? Because according to Prāsaṇgika, phenomena appearing to be established from their own side, appear to all the consciousnesses of an ordinary being, and phenomena are not established from their own side since establishment from its own side does not exist. It’s a very elegant viewpoint.

Then according to Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards, the other schools of tenets consider that within our mind stream, are both unmistaken and mistaken consciousnesses. Then according to Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards phenomena are established from their own side. They are findable under ultimate analysis by a mind of analytical investigation. So at present, within the context of generating the motivation, let us reflect on the difference between beings who have not entered the path and those who have entered the path and the distinctions between the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, and meditation, as well as a distinction between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses in the context of mental and sense consciousnesses. Page one.

One, two, three, four, and also page five. Number six, number of offerings, first one and three. Then we have to reflect on the distinction between conceptual and non conceptual minds. Both exist within our mind stream. So it is something which is quite easy to think about.

We do not have to rely on texts for this. Now, the way to understand the existence of conceptual minds is to try to understand what the minds which have arisen from sense consciousnesses are. Minds which have arisen from sensory consciousnesses are conceptual minds. And what precisely the mode of engagement of its object of conceptual and non conceptual minds are. Now strictly speaking, one ought to present those conceptual and non conceptual minds in terms of common and uncommon controlling conditions, but that takes us too far afield.

So at present, I’ll take only a couple questions, very short questions, just on what we covered tonight. Sorry. I just wanted to get a little bit of clarification on what happens between the path of seeing and the path of meditation. You mentioned or implied that there seemed to be a desire for, I don’t have the exact words in front of me, just can’t find the page, but I’ll hear an innate grasping of the self is present between path of seeing the path of meditation and I was wondering how the person has come out of an experience of emptiness and now they’re they’re grasping at themselves and then that’s propelling them into meditation. Is that correct?

So we do enter the path of meditation. The path of meditation is a path in which one sees emptiness nakedly, directly. The difference between the path of seeing and of meditation is that at the level of the path of seeing, it is not possible to apply to apply antidotes against the innate grasping at the self. At the level of the path of meditation, is possible to do so. Another.

Here. Why is that? The reason for which there is a distinction between the path of seeing and the path of meditation is because on the path of seeing, one is unable to abandon innate grasping at a self, and on the path of meditation, one is able to do so. So so the reason for which there is a distinction between the path of seeing and the path of meditation is because, on the one hand, the object of abandonment at the level of the path of seeing is more coarse than the object of abandonment at the level of the path of meditation. And the antidote at the level of the path of seeing is more coarse than the antidote at the level of the path of meditation.

As the object of abandonment becomes ever more subtle, the path of meditation, the antidote itself becomes ever more subtle. Then whether there is a difference in the emptiness, that is another question which is one of my private doubts. And we are just studying these topics. At a certain point, we have to meditate on them. If one doesn’t meditate on them, we will not understand.

So there are substantial differences in the subtlety of emptiness or selflessness is perhaps a better way of putting it. Since emptiness is only accepted by Mādhyamika and Cittamātra, selflessness accepted by all the Buddhist schools. There are numerous degrees in subtlety. Whether there are also differences in the subtlety of the emptiness as understood in Prāsaṇgika, I cannot say. So when you enter any presentation of the path of meditation, there is a progression from the smaller levels of the path of meditation to the greater, which corresponds to a progression from the greater innate apprehensions of a self to the lesser innate apprehensions of a self.

Mhmm. And just one question in discussion. Yeah. The antidote that is applied at the path of meditation, does that automatically arise? What do you mean spontaneously?

Yes. It does arise spontaneously because the experience of the path of meditation is an experience arisen from meditation. These are spontaneous experiences. Now for a discussion, the topics will be the distinctions between not having entered the path and having entered the path, as well as the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation. That’s one topic.

And the other topic is the distinction between conceptuality and non conceptual minds in terms of their mode of engagement of the object. By pairs? Okay. Could you start, please?

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
valid inference jepag tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive outer cognition directly generated in dependence on its support, a correct reason. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top