Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012-04-06 – KR.mp3
UUID: f590db59-c840-450d-bfcb-d960d787755a
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Dependent Origination (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-04-06
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 26m
Words: 3,613
As Buddha Shakyamuni said, do not commit even the slightest of sins and practice virtue to perfection. This and none other is the Buddha’s dharma which tames the mind. This clearly indicates that the very essence of the Buddha’s Dharma is abstaining from non virtue and practicing virtue and is in accordance with the statement by Atisha in which Atisha said, the Buddha’s dharma is designed to lead one to happier rebirth. There is a slight difference of formulation between these two statements, which is due to the difference of the trainees for which they are intended. In the light of the stanza attributed to the Buddha, this is the Buddha’s dharma, this clearly expounds the Buddha’s teachings.
It also indicates that taming the mind in and of itself is not sufficient. It must be practiced within the context of trainees which are Buddhists for such practices to qualify as Buddhadharma? Discussing the generation of the motivation, Geshe-la will be making this series of preliminary statements. Generally speaking, when we ourselves who practice dharma say that we are Buddhists, this mere statement I am a Buddhist is basically meaningless. It only becomes meaningful when the difference between dharma and non dharma is understood and when the dharma is what we actually practice and train our minds in.
Now, in our case, we practice the dharma, we study the dharma, we volunteer to help dharma centers, and if one were to ask us, a non Buddhist were to ask us, what is this dharma you are talking about and we are at a loss to answer clearly, then this is very unfortunate. Now there’s a great risk that many of us will answer, dharma are the works composed by Buddha Shakyamuni. Then such a viewpoint is very problematical. So, this dharma, which we are trying to define is not the works of the Buddha. This dharma actually belongs to the category of means.
Means to do what? Means to subdue or to tame the mind. In keeping with the Buddha’s teachings, thoroughly subdue the mind. Therefore, if we say to someone who asks us what dharma is, thoroughly subduing the mind, this is correct and it may be of benefit to that person as well. So if we ask specifically what is Buddhadharma, this is actually not an easy question to answer to, and it is not the case that one is training to answer this question so as to address non Buddhist questions, so much as training to answer it for one’s own sake, rooted in one’s own study.
Thorough study is necessary to be able to answer such a question. Now in Tibet, dharma practice was exceptional. Perhaps all Tibetans practice dharma in one form or another. Their practice was profoundly rooted in faith, extraordinary faith. However, if one were to ask them what is dharma, most Tibetans would be unable to answer and would actually be very confused by the question.
This is a sign of lack of study. So generally speaking, faith is exceptionally important. However, faith alone is not sufficient. Faith must proceed in conjunction with study. They must actually be inseparable, helping each other.
So if we try to identify precisely the Buddha dharma of which we are talking, we can say that Buddha dharma is the totality of teachings and practices which is of benefit from the next life onwards. And specifically, this Buddha dharma must be understood through an understanding based on valid cognition of the so called Four Seals. When this occurs, then one can say that one has pure and authentic Buddhadharma. Even though one lacks realization through a valid cognizer of the pure four seals regarding the view, nonetheless, if one is able to generate some type of conviction within, within them, Then one’s practice will move towards being a practice for future lives and beyond and become an authentic Buddhist practice. Even if one is unable to understand fully and to ascertain through a valid cognition the four seals, Nonetheless, if one is able to understand the process of ingress into cyclic existence, which is actually rooted in the first and the second of the noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
And if one is able to understand the three characteristics of these, which are impermanence, suffering and selflessness, then one’s practice will proceed towards a Buddhist practice. Now here, when we are speaking of cyclic existence, we are not speaking of objects such as houses, tables, and chairs. We are actually speaking of the cycle of transmigrations of our aggregates, our contaminated aggregates. And, if we try to understand the first of the three features of our aggregates, is their impermanence, we can see taking our own body and reflecting on how it was fifteen or twenty years ago, that there has been obvious change in those fifteen or twenty years. We are totally different physically now from the way we were twenty years ago.
This total change implies a progressive change over time. This is what is meant by the subtle impermanence of the physical aggregate. Now regarding the second characteristic of our aggregates that they are suffering in nature. The first characteristic, their impermanence referred to their transitoriness, the fact that they were changing instant by instant, but in addition to being transitory and impermanent, they actually arise from contaminated causes and condition, karma and klesha. Therefore, as a result, they are of the nature of suffering.
This is the second characteristic. The third characteristic here is that of selflessness or emptiness. What is meant here is the fact that persons are empty of being permanent, of being one and of being autonomous. Now in this context, this emptiness of being permanent one and autonomous was specifically directed against non Buddhist tenet holders. For this reason, it was formulated in these terms, since the non Buddhist tenet holders affirm the existence of a person which is permanent, one and which is independent.
From the Buddhist standpoint, there is no such person. Geshadar said, taking his own example, he himself, exists from a Buddhist standpoint purely as an imputation, a mental designation on the basis of his five aggregates. There is no Jampa Gilti apart from his five aggregates. And as the five aggregates change, change, Jampa Giltse himself as well changes. And there is a fourth characteristic, which is the specific characteristic of selflessness.
This refers actually to the fact that Japa Giltse, who has power over the aggregates, and the aggregates who are under the control of Japa Giltse, are in the relationship of designator and designated. And there is no Jampa Gilte existing inherently and independently of the aggregates on the basis of imputation of which he is designated. Such a practitioner who generates the motivation for striving for the benefit of future lives based on having actually identified the aggregates and their nature in such a fashion and having seen the impelling cause of future lives is worthy to be called a Buddhist. So this is not easy for any of us. However, through studying this over and again, thinking about it carefully, over time, you will start to have some doubts and queries and think, could this be actually the way things are?
And when this starts, you are on the right path. So we will now spend two minutes or so meditating on generating such a motivation. As Arya Nagarjuna said in his root verses on emptiness, that which is not interdependent does not exist. We will during the next three days cover the topic of dependent arising and interdependence and specifically the 12 limbs of dependent arising. This topic will be covered mainly relying on the root texts.
And each of the four schools of tenets, the Vaibhashika, Sotrandika, Chitamatra, and Madhyamika has their own presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent arising. During the next three days, we will rely on the presentation of one of the sub schools of the Madiameka, the Svatantrika Madiameka, which is the presentation adopted by the author of the Serage monastic textbooks, Jechuncuki Gilzi. And generally speaking, within the collection of monastic textbooks dedicated to the study of the perfections known as Parchin composed by Jesun Shugi Giltsey, the dominant viewpoint is that of this Svatantrika Madiamica school of thought. For instance, it is a viewpoint adopted for presenting the 12 links, for presenting the so called 20 Sangha and for presenting also the teachings on the concentrations of form in the formless realms. This is the dominant viewpoint.
And this viewpoint in the 12 links and in general in Parchin is rooted in Asanga’s Abidharma Samuchaya, which is the higher presentation of Abidharma from within the two presentations, the higher and the lower. There are also some passages from Vasubandu’s Lower Abidharma. Now the section of the 12 links has been translated for you by your translator in English. In keeping with the verse from Mula Madhyamaka Karika which was quoted previously, there is no phenomenon which is not a dependent arising. It can be seen that all phenomena arise independent on their parts and their components.
If we take the example of this building for instance, this building arises independent on its components, on its parts, such as the concrete which constitutes it, the wood, the foundations and so forth. There is no such thing as a building like this one which does not depend on its parts. Now based on experience, we can see this is the case for all phenomena, both composite phenomena and non composite phenomena. And this is the reason for which the definition of dependent arising, which is on page one of your definitions and divisions, is that which is established through relying on its parts. If we take the example of persons, human beings for instance, human beings are constituted on the basis of two main components, their bodies and their minds.
In other words, matter and consciousness. There is no such thing as a human being which is constituted of body or of matter alone. And it is the same thing for all phenomena. And there is a very beautiful presentation of this in the Samputa Sutra in which the Buddha compares the process of the 12 links of dependent or the 12 limbs of dependent arising to that of planting a seed in a fertile field where water manure and the requisite conditions present. Now the view of the penetrising in the Samputa Sutra is mainly that in terms of causality.
As Buddha says in the Samputa Sutra monks, he who sees dependent arising sees dharma. This very profound verse indicates that he who realizes dependent arising or interdependence realizes dharma and what is meant by dharma here is actually selflessness. Generally speaking, when we speak of taking refuge in the triple gem, in other words, the Buddha, the dharma and the Sangha, the actual refuge is the dharma. The Buddha himself is an ancillary refuge in a sense. He is the teacher of the dharma.
And when we speak of taking refuge in the dharma, the actual refuge within the dharma is the mind which realizes directly selflessness. And who realizes directly, sees nakedly, selflessness? It is none other than the Buddha who sees simultaneously both conventional and ultimate truths. Such a presentation of dependent arising is a presentation of the thoroughly purified dependent arising in keeping with the Sutra on Pratitya Samutpada in which it is said, from this arises that, from the existence of this occurs the existence of that. This is a difficult quote.
And the statement in that sutra from the existence of this that arises is probably specifically intended to counter the view of the ancient Indian materialists, the Lokayatas or the Charvakas, who asserted the existence of causeless results. This passage from Sutra clearly affirms that whatever effect exists is necessarily the effect of a preceding cause. And the further statement in the Sutra, for the sake of giving birth to this that arises, is specifically intended to counter the viewpoint that any category of cause can give rise to any category of effect. It is not the case that any category of cause can give rise to any category of effect. Instead, a cause must necessarily be of concordant type with the effect to which it gives rise.
This therefore directly counters the view of the existence of a creator deity. And therefore, the passage from the Sutra on Dependent Arising, which starts for the sake of giving rise to this that arose, clearly indicates that the cause which gives rise to a given effect must be of concordant type with the effect it gives rise to, therefore, must have the capacity to give rise to that effect. And therefore, those who assert the existence of God of a creator, whether he be called Ishvara or by any other name, assert the existence of a permanent being who gives rise to an impermanent universe. They therefore assert the existence of a first cause, which gives rise to an effect which is of a different type than it. The only way for this to happen would be if this first cause, God, himself had within him the type of the effect, in other words, changed in the process of creation which they cannot assert.
And therefore, this passage from the Sutra on Dependent Arising which says, for the sake of giving rise to that arose, specifically targets those ancient Indian schools of thought such as the Vaisheshika and the Mimamsaka who assert the existence of God and of a creator. So as Buddhists adopting the viewpoint that effects are necessarily of concordant type with the causes which generate them, We then analyze the origin of our own bodies and we can see under careful analysis that we run into some difficulties which must be investigated. We look at our own bodies, they arise, our physical bodies arise from the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother which give rise to the embryo. Now, if we trace the substantial cause of that embryo further back in time, through lineages of spermatozoa and ovum, back and back in time, we will eventually reach a point which is known as the dawn of this world. It is the point where this universe of ours arises for the first time.
Before this is a period known as the empty eons, where there is no physical matter. And the difficulty which arises is at this point what the substantial cause of the spermatozoa and the ovum or the material support might be. So in our case, most of us probably can trace our ancestry three mothers back, should I said mothers. So our mother, our grandmother, and perhaps our great grandmother, and after that we really don’t know very well where we come from. But in keeping with Buddhist philosophy, the causal chain is one of concordance in type with the effect concordant in type with the cause which gives rise to it.
And this counters two viewpoints in ancient India. The one is the Lokayata viewpoint, the materialist viewpoint, which asserts that there is no such thing as causality. Phenomena occur adventitiously. The other viewpoint is the Sankhya viewpoint, which asserts that causes and effects are of the same nature. Now for those schools of thought in ancient India which asserted the existence of God, of a creator and also asserted the existence of karma and causality, we can say certainly in terms of the result of their practice that their practice was beneficial since it involved a training in ethics and therefore necessarily involved for such practitioners the attainment of higher rebirth.
Whether such practice in and of itself is able to lead to a steady decrease in desire is open to question. Generally speaking, the tenants of those schools who assert the existence of God assert the existence of a being whose nature is to be permanent. Such a being is a person who is permanent one and autonomous. For them to practice ethics fully, they must meditate on death and impermanence. Therefore, they must meditate on the death and the impermanence of their own person.
Any realization of the death and impermanence of their own person affects in turn their vision of the eternity of God. And should their vision of the eternity of God be affected and God turn into an impermanent phenomenon, this would be at odds with their tenets. So this creates considerable difficulties for their practice. So this is the viewpoint of those who assert the existence of God. Then generally speaking, from a Buddhist standpoint, it is said that the origin of our contaminated aggregates, our five aggregates, is none other than karma and causality.
In other words, the karmic chain. In terms of practical results, such a viewpoint is not that dissimilar from that of those who assert the existence of a god who creates beings. And therefore, it is independence on ignorance that the remaining of the 12 links arise. In other words, compositional factors, consciousness, name and form, the six spheres, contact, feeling, craving, appropriation, existence, birth, and aging and death. So this is the cycle of the 12 thoroughly afflicted limbs and the 12 thoroughly purified limbs arise as follows.
Through putting an end to the first limb of ignorance, in turn, one puts an end to its effect, which is the second limb of compositional factors. This in turn puts an end to the third limb of consciousness and so forth through all of the 12 limbs. The definition of thoroughly afflicted dependent arisings are dependent arisings which arise from their own cause and conditions and which are of the nature of the poisons I. E. Cyclic existence.
The reason for the first part of the definition, dependent arisings which arise from their own causes and conditions is to exclude their arising from adventitious unrelated causes and conditions. The second part of the definition actually defines their nature. So when we speak of psychic existence, what is meant? Psychic existence does not refer to the world in general of houses, tables, chairs and so forth. Psychic existence refers to those beings who transmigrate within cyclic existence.
The migrators, in other words, who transmigrate under the power of karma and affliction. As was said in one of the Lamrim texts, Geshela has been expounding, our bodies are none other than guest houses for the guest of the mind. The mind passes from body to body, from life to life. And this is what is meant by cyclic existence. So what therefore is cyclic existence?
Cyclic existence is none other than these aggregates of ours. These aggregates which are of the nature of suffering, these aggregates of maturation which are the result of contaminated karma and affliction. And in addition, cyclic existence, in other words, our own five contaminated aggregates arises as is mentioned in the definition of the thoroughly afflicted dependent arising, Independence on its own causes and conditions. There are actually three conditions which give rise to phenomena such as dependent arising. The first is the immutable condition, the second is the impermanent condition and the third is the condition of potentiation.
The immutable condition indicates that dependent arising do not arise in dependence on a creator or a god such as Ishvara and so forth. The impermanent condition indicate that not only do dependent arising such as are contaminated aggregates not arise independence on God, but in addition they arise independence on impermanent causes of the same type such as impermanent persons in the past. The potentiating condition indicates that in addition to this, they arise independence on causes which are of a concordant type with themselves. We will stop here for today, for this morning, should I say, and this afternoon. Michel I will start explaining the first of the 12 links that make the limb of ignorance.
We have time for one question. Yes, Richard. So, actually in the Buddhist scriptures, it is said that during that, empty, those empty eons, it is not the case that there is no matter whatsoever. There is something which is known as the atoms of space, which is mentioned in the Kalachakra Tantra as well as in some of the Abhidharma treatises. Now these are not atoms which are actually made of space, which is a non obstructive subtle substance.
This is an extremely subtle form of matter and it is on this basis that later on matter arises. So in the case of consciousness, since consciousness is non obstructive, tracing backwards the substantial continuum is quite straightforward. In the case of the body, and specifically the spermatozoa and the ovum, Since they are material tracing back the continuum during these periods becomes, awkward. However, it is certainly, absurd to assert that there would be a point where they were causeless. Yes.
It’s not clear. These atoms of space congregate to form coarser levels of matter such as the so called partless particles, which is just talked about in the text. It may be under the power of the energy of the fundamental elements, Geshela says. The energy of the elements. Geshela does not know exactly.
A simile might be given to the breath breathing in and out of a person. We inhale and exhale. And then Geshela said, you can ask your translator questions during the break. Please, I have my commitments to finish. So first allow me to Mhmm.
Do you have
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.