Awakening Heart — 2012-04-01

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2012-04-01
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-04-01 – KR.mp3

UUID: 94e443d5-1210-4b63-a880-4fb600a1d9fb

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2012-04-01

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 35m

Words: 3,839

So both for teaching and for listening to the teachings, is critical to generate the requisite motivation. As Vasu Bandhu said, one’s practice should not be mixed with the eight worldly dharmas. In this context, it means that we should neither listen nor have the teachings explained mixed with the eight worldly dharmas. This is however a very difficult thing to achieve since we are ordinary, beings and our minds are suffused with the eight worldly dharmas. Therefore, we have to try to generate pure thought and with this pure thought to listen or to explain the teachings for two hours or an hour and a half, however long this lasts.

Then with this as a motivation having listened to the teachings at the end of this period, the merit which has been accrued must be dedicated through prayers of dedication which we recite. If we do this, then we would accumulate a huge amount of merit whether the dedication is for the sake of attaining full enlightenment, for the sake of all mother sentient beings, for the sake of attaining liberation, or any other suitable object of dedication. As the scion of the conqueror Shantideva said in his great bodhisattva Acharyavatara engaging in the practice of the bodhisattvas, whatever suffering there is in this world arises from self cherishing whereas whatever happiness there is in this world arises from cherishing others. It is clear from this quote that whatever suffering beings experience arises from self cherishing. All sentient beings are similar in that all sentient beings wish for happiness and all sentient beings wish to avoid suffering.

However, it is probable that without careful study, it is not possible to understand precisely and to identify precisely what suffering is. As Geshela explained previously on Wednesday, suffering has to be understood as subdivided into two categories. Suffering which arises independence on the bodily collection and suffering which arises independence on the mental collection. If one does not isolate in this way these two types of suffering and instead conflates and fuses them, then one’s understanding of suffering will be greatly affected. Regarding the sensation of bodily suffering, the sensation of bodily suffering, the first of the two subdivisions of suffering, arises mainly in dependence on the body.

Therefore it arises independence on the elements which are the foundation of the body. It is therefore not possible to dispel such bodily suffering such as for instance, headaches, the flu or a stomachache through studying for instance Buddhist scriptures. Likewise, through the mere study of dharma, it will not be possible to give rise to that sensation of happiness which arises from the collection of the body. So regarding the sensation of suffering which is rooted in the bodily collection in the body, this can be best eliminated through taking medication. Now passing to the second category of suffering, which is a sensation of suffering, which is rooted in the collection of the mind or in the mind.

It is the general purport of all of the religious traditions in the world to try to eliminate such suffering and to try to generate mental happiness. These sufferings, mental sufferings, are mainly of the nature of fancies or conceptuality, fear and so forth. Now within the religious traditions, extent at present on this planet, there are two broad categories of religious traditions, those which accept the existence of a creator or a demiurge and those which do not accept the existence of a creator. Those which do not accept the existence of a creator, generally speaking, accept the existence of past and future lives and therefore by extension the existence of karma and causality. These can in turn be subdivided into two broad categories.

Those which accept the existence of an I, a self, and those which do not accept the existence of a self, which is both an experiencer and an accumulator of karma and of its results. So for beginners such a presentation would be difficult to understand, but since most of you have studied, then such a presentation is very helpful and beneficial. Now within the category of beings which accept the existence of an imputed self but do not accept the existence of a creator, in turn, one can distinguish two Those for whom this imputed self is a permanent unitary and independent phenomenon and those for whom this imputed self is not a permanent unitary and independent phenomenon. Most probably Buddhists would fall in the second category. Now, however, irrespective of whether we are talking of the religious traditions which accept the existence of an imputed self or those which do not, in either case, it would seem that all religious traditions aim at eliminating the mental sensation of suffering and enhancing the mental sensation of happiness.

Within the initial teachings of the Buddha to the so called first circle of five disciples after the Buddha Buddha attained attained full enlightenment, the focus of the Buddha’s teachings was the four noble truths, of which the first is the noble truth of suffering. This is our focus at present and within the noble truth of suffering, there are three subdivisions of suffering, the so called suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. At present, our focus is the suffering of suffering and within the suffering of suffering, it is the suffering of suffering which is a mental sensation. All the great religious traditions identify the mental sensation of suffering within the first of the three subdivisions of suffering, the suffering of suffering, as that which they are trying to eliminate. And in as much as this mental sensation of suffering is intimately connected with fantasies, with fancies, with imagination, with hopes, in turn, the means to eliminate it must also be mental.

We can see instances of this for instance, with those of us who have done an extensive amount of study, have obtained, numerous degrees and have high hopes for the future, for their professional future and yet this professional future is not fulfilled. In turn, through this nonfulfillment of a professional’s future arises a suffering rooted in expectation and hope. And in turn, what is the main antidote to these suffering which arise from expectations and from hopes? It is to reduce one’s wishes, one’s desires and to practice contentment. This is taught in Vinaya in which it is said that for the monk, the exterior monastic vestment should be that of a pauper.

Likewise, the dingua on which he sits should be that of a pauper or a beggar and likewise, the food he eats should be that of a beggar. The meaning of this passage in Vinaya is that everything he practices and engages in, the monk is striving for a reduction of desire and for contentment. How do we generate for ourselves this reduction of desire and discontentment? The foremost means is meditation on death and impermanence. Geshela believes that the more we meditate on death and impermanence, the more naturally both desires will decrease and contentment will increase and in turn the lesser the suffering.

The inner core therefore of all the great religious traditions in Geshela’s opinion is the reduction of desire and through this reduction of desire and the increase in contentment in turn progressively over time suffering will abate. Now for instance, in the case of Buddha Dharma, the foremost practitioners of this reduction of desire, which is the inner core of the Buddhist teachings, are those who have some level of ordination. Ordination is taken so that the time for study is freed up. And once the opportunity for study arises, it is then possible to blend these profound studies with one’s meditation and as a result of this to develop greatly in the spiritual path. For instance, if one looks at Geshela’s monastic attire, his vestments and his digwa, one might think that they look quite odd by our standards.

They are patched with numerous parts. The reason for this is because Buddha wished his disciples to practice contentment with regards to their garb, with regards to their vestments. So regarding the first subdivision of suffering, the suffering of suffering, animals in general have a clear understanding of the sensation of the bodily suffering of suffering. Therefore, we can say that this is something which is shared by all sentient beings who experience suffering. On the other hand, it is only sentient beings of a higher level who understand the mental sensation of suffering within the suffering of suffering.

And the elimination of this mental sensation of suffering is the goal of all of the world’s great religious traditions. So, there is nothing to be astonished at by the fact that animals such as herbivores in general and antelopes for instance, to, avoid the bodily sensation of suffering and when they experience this physical sensation of suffering such as hunger or thirst, do whatever is required to eliminate it through eating food or drinking. However, the uncommon feature of human beings, what differentiates us from animals is our awareness of the mental sensation of suffering. Now within the three general subdivisions of suffering, the suffering of suffering which we have covered, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, the third category of suffering and its understanding is critical for us and this can only be done for Buddhist practitioners who study. It is probable that none of the other religious traditions is able to identify all pervasive suffering and is able to see all pervasive suffering as suffering.

Now regarding this third category of suffering all pervasive suffering. To identify all pervasive suffering as suffering, it is critical to understand that the totality of our aggregates, in other words, the form aggregate, the feeling aggregate, the recognition aggregate, the volition aggregate, and the consciousness aggregate are of the nature of suffering. And the reason for which ordinary beings such as ourselves are afflicted by suffering is because we are under the influence of the afflictions, which can be broadly speaking subdivided into two, the afflictions of the past and present afflictions. The present affliction, which is foremost within our mind, is the innate apprehension of the inherent existence of a self, which in turn is the root of all of the other afflictions such as desire, anger, pride and so forth. Now what precisely is an affliction or a klesha?

An affliction is something whose function is to trouble the mind. My apologies, I made a mistake in the translation. The definition of a klesha is that which is mistaken or the function of a klesha is that which is mistaken with regard to what it apprehends. So if we take the case of anger for instance, why is anger an affliction or a klesha? Anger is an affliction because influenced by anger, we see others as evil and harmful even though as far as our actual sense perception of others are concerned, they are not evil or harmful.

So independence of on anger for instance, we perceive a being as much more hateful and angry from his or her own side than he or she is. And then even though anger itself does not dwell forever within our continuum, independence on this anger in turn, we use harmful or hateful words towards this person or this being, which once the anger has abated, we will be ashamed of. This is a function of anger. Now if we take the case of the affliction of anger, we have to ask ourselves whether the affliction of anger which has arisen is causeless or, if it is caused, does it arise from a discordant cause or finally from a concordant cause. Anger is not causeless nor does it arise from a discordant cause, a cause which is at odds with its effect.

It arises from a concordant cause. The concordant cause anger arises from is the wrong state of mind, the mistaken mind, which apprehends innately the self as inherently existent. Therefore, this third subdivision of suffering from within the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change in all pervasive suffering, is actually none other than the five contaminated aggregates. The contaminated form, feeling, discrimination, volition and consciousness aggregates. The all pervasive suffering is in other words, none other than cyclic existence.

It is not possible to understand the all pervasive suffering for non Buddhist schools of tenets. The reason is that to understand correctly this third subdivision of suffering or pervasive suffering, it is necessary to understand its cause. Its cause is the mistaken or wrong mind which perceives the self innately as inherently existent. To understand this correctly, it is necessary to understand its antidote, which is the view of the lack of inherent self existence of the self. Such a view is absent into non Buddhist traditions.

Therefore, the precise understanding of all pervasive suffering hinges on an understanding of selflessness. For this reason, it will be difficult to explain it in detail here. However, this is the uncommon feature of the Buddhist teachings. This is a difference of the Buddhist teachings with the non Buddhist teachings. Therefore, it is important for us to reflect on this and if reflecting on it, we generate doubts, hesitations, questions, then this is extremely beneficial because in general it is said that when one studies, doubts and hesitations should arise.

The more doubts and hesitations arise, in turn, the more intense our study will become. Otherwise, if there are no doubts and hesitations which arise when we study, then we remain placid and without reaction. Once one has started to try to differentiate between Buddhist and non Buddhist views of the self and the major doubts start arising powerfully within one’s mind, then there is no hardship whatsoever in studying three, four, five hours at a time. And therefore the correct identification of the nature of all pervasive suffering meets up with the Buddhist view, the uncommon Buddhist view. Therefore it is through studying this over and again that our understanding will increase.

So at present, returning to our text, Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, we have completed the presentation in the seven point mind training which is the root text underlying this text by Geshe Chekhawa of the verse first train in the preliminaries on page three and have at present entered in the presentation of the great vehicle which starts on pages 42 onwards of Nam Kappel’s presentation. Now in this context, when one speaks of training the mind in the great vehicle, one is referring to training in the mind in that love which finds others agreeable, finds all sentient beings agreeable with as a goal, the goal of attaining the state of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. However, that initial training of the mind in a love which finds other sentient beings agreeable must initially be rooted in an understanding of the benefits of training in such a state of mind and the faults of not training in such a state of mind. And as a preliminary for this, it is necessary to understand the advantages of eliminating self cherishing and the faults of self cherishing which are difficult to understand. So to train, therefore, in bodhicitta, it is necessary as a preliminary to be able to train in seeing all sentient beings in the aspect of being pleasing.

For this, it is necessary to understand the qualities of the realizations and of the abandonments related with bodhicitta. As Arya Chandrakirti says in the Madhyamaka Vattara, love and compassion which are a preliminary to bodhicitta arise independence on mother sentient beings. Likewise, bodhicitta which itself is the cause of unalloyed and full enlightenment arises also independence on mother sentient beings. Even the state of full enlightenment in as much as it rests on sentient beings is something which arises independence on sentient beings. So to give an example for this, we can see clearly that if we plant a sound seed in a fertile field and, gather all the requisite conditions for the seed to sprout, sunlight, water and manure, then it is basically 100% certain that crops will arise.

Likewise, if we gather all of the requisite conditions to generate such a state of mind, then it is basically 100% certain that bodhicitta will arise. As Arya as the scion of the conquerors, Shantideva says in the bodhisattvacharyavatara, why do I despise sentient beings and revere the Buddhas? They are equal in their kindness. Indeed, why do we see the Buddhas as superior to sentient beings in terms of their kindness to us? They are equal in terms of their kindness.

Therefore, as is said in the Lama Chöpa, when I am beset by suffering as by rain, through seeing these as the exhaustion of formerly accrued karma, bless me to practice in this way. The meaning of this stanza is that when we are faced with great suffering, through seeing this as a means of exhausting past non virtuous karma, we should in turn practice forbearance. And there are two quotes from Shantideva, one in the chapter on forbearance and another quote as well to this effect. So the practice of forbearance is a practice of forbearance within the context of the six perfections. The perfection of generosity, of ethics, of forbearance, of enthusiasm, of concentration and of wisdom.

Therefore, as a preliminary to the practice of forbearance, often called patience, one must practice first generosity and ethics. Then when one engages in the practice of forbearance, one must identify the target or the focus of this forbearance. And having identified the focus of this forbearance, it is then possible to practice it correctly. And the quote in Shantideva’s Bodhisattva, Chariavatara, was, in the same same way as nothing can be created with a cause, happiness needs a cause, and my foe is the cause of forbearance. Here, forbearance is not causeless nor does it arise from a discordant cause.

It must arise from a concordant cause and the cause of forbearance, our focus is the enemy. So Nam Kapil in Mind Training like Rays of the Sun gives an example for the practice of forbearance saying forbearance protects us in the same way as courage does. Through forbearance we can overcome all foes. As the scion of the conquerors, Shantideva says in Bodhisattva Charyavatara, there is no need to say much on this topic. Look at the results of the childlike who practice self cherishing and compare them with the results of the Buddhas who have practiced cherishing others.

This quote is self evident when we look at the results of the behavior of ordinary beings such as ourselves who engage in self cherishing and compare it with the results of the behavior of the Buddhas who have engaged in cherishing others, the discrepancy is obvious. And therefore Nam Kappel, in mind training like the rays of the sun says, understanding this one counters self cherishing and one gives rise to cherishing others, The practice which conjoins the elimination of self cherishing and training in cherishing others is the interchange of self and others. So it is difficult for us at present to understand clearly both what self cherishing and cherishing others is. If one were to hold the view that self cherishing is none other but the apprehension of an inherently existing self. Then there would be some very unwanted consequences such as for instance that, Shravakas, in other words, hearers and Pratyaka Buddhas would have eliminated self cherishing whether whereas they have not.

They still suffer from self cherishing even though they have abandoned the mind which apprehends a person as it inherently existed as well as its seeds. So it is not possible to identify self cherishing and the mind which apprehends the self as inherently existent. Likewise, it is not possible to identify cherishing others and the mind which perceives persons as selfless. Otherwise, there will be again numerous unwanted consequences. Therefore, we should all reflect carefully on this for next time.

So this topic of self cherishing, cherishing others and the interchange of self and others is one which Geshela finds difficult for himself. He suspects, therefore, we will probably find it difficult too. However, we will reflect on it together and study the texts together. And as the doubts and questions arise, we will try to clear them. So we have probably hereby completed the presentation of the second outline which is striving for the state of full and unalloyed enlightenment upon seeing all sentient beings in the aspect of being pleasing.

At present, if you have questions, Geshela will answer them. So the question is, Geshela thought that if one studies but without cherishing others, there’s a great risk that this study will go into becoming the afflictions. Could Geshela elaborate on this? Well, Geshela says that generally speaking, merely studying without cherishing others is not sufficient for those studies to move into the direction of the afflictions. There are several possibilities.

If one studies thinking of success in this life alone, then one studies will go in the direction of the afflictions. However, if one studies wishing to attain a higher status in future life such as a human being or a god, then one studies will not go in the direction of the afflictions and if one studies wishing for liberation from the cycle of lives, then one studies will also not go in the direction of the afflictions. So regarding the studies of Buddhist texts, it is inappropriate to study focused on this life alone, then one studies have a high risk of moving in the direction of the afflictions. Instead, one should focus at least on the benefit of future lives. Are there other questions?

Yes. So your question is why in a nutshell? Mental sufferings is your question. So it’s not the case that animals don’t have mental suffering, but they have far weaker mental sufferings than we do. It is clear that they experience a suffering of fear but they don’t experience a suffering of unsatisfied hopes and fantasies.

Yes. Oh, yeah. I’m sorry. It’s a bit strange when I talk with the mice. Yes, definitely.

That is the suffering of fear. It is clear with herbivores such as antelopes, and various other herbivores that they are accustomed to live in groups. And when they are isolated, the herbivore, the antelope, for instance, immediately feels the fear of isolation. Yes, please. So generally speaking, it is important to train one’s mind in reduced desires and in contentment.

Then when fantasies and expectations arise through reflecting on contentment and on reducing one’s desires, in turn this will counter these. It is for one’s own sake one does this. It is not for others. We we are not able to practice like that for others. There’s another question I think.

Yes, Sam. That’s why forbearance is difficult. Yeah?

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top