Dependant Arising 2000 – 12 D A 2000 06 06

43 min · 4,516 words · 6 June 2000

Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 - 12 D A 2000 06 06
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains dependent arising at a subtle level: things, including the self, exist only in dependence on mind and on the label conceived for a basis. Using examples such as a plate, the letter Z and a rainbow, it argues that the basis and the label are not the same, and that the root of suffering is believing the labelled self exists from its own side, not the act of labelling itself. It draws on teachings attributed to Lama Zopa Rinpoche.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2000-06-06

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 237e6d69-f055-439e-926b-6ce3214c5a8b

Words: 4,516

That everything is dependent on the mind. So although this actually is the most subtle level of dependent arising, In some ways for us, having some awareness of this is something very helpful to use in our daily life to be aware of. And there are many levels of this teaching, but there’s the basic point, that just simply things depend on our mind. For things to exist, we there has to be our mind there for a start. This itself is showing that things out there are not separate from my consciousness.

They’re not independent. Alright. But, of course, this is not the real meaning of subtle dependent arising. But things can only exist depending not just on our mind, but the way our mind conceives things, which is meaning how we label something. Without the label, something cannot exist.

It certainly cannot exist in a particular way. I’m just going to try and rather than put this in my own word, I’ll do a bit of both, but I’m going to rely on some teachings directly from Lama Zopa Rinpoche. So he says, First the mind sees the aggregates, the five aggregates that make up our being, the form aggregate, the four mental aggregates. First the mind sees the aggregates and then the mind makes up the label ‘I’ relating to what the aggregates are doing. So if you see the ‘I’ as merely labelled, which we don’t, but if we did, if we were to see the I as merely labelled, it appears back to you like that.

It doesn’t appear to exist from its own side, so there is no way for attachment to arise. When we are experiencing ourselves as we actually are, as something merely labeled, a completely dependent phenomena, not existing from its own side, when we experience ourselves that way, then there’s no way for attachment, anger, and so forth to arise. But ignorance, our ignorance makes it appear the I as truly existing, and then we grasp at that appearance as true. Ignorance is like a film negative which project projects hallucination on the merely labeled I so that it looks like it can be found in the body. If in a dream you know it is a dream, you don’t become attached to the appearances in the dream.

But when we believe the appearances in the dream are real from their own side, then attachment arises. So then Rinpoche goes on to say that with whatever object that exists, such as this object, this is an object. For this to exist in a particular way, it depends on our mind giving it a label, plate. And only the mind can give that label. Nothing else can do it.

The object, the plate itself cannot give the label plate. Right? This is a plate. The the plate itself is not telling us it is a plate. It is our mind that is giving the label plate and therefore conceiving and experiencing this thing as a plate.

But actually, when we look at this plate, the way we experience it, it seems unquestionably to be a plate from its own side. We’re not conscious, not aware that it is our mind that is labeling this a plate, and because of that, we are then perceiving it as a plate. If we don’t give it the label plate, it cannot appear to our mind as a plate. It’s utterly impossible. For example, what is this thing?

Right, I have no idea either. I don’t know what you call it, what the correct label is. So because of that, especially anyway, I can’t do that. So it’s a clear appearing to us right now as some kind of plastic or metal black thing because we can’t put the right label on it. If it truly existed from its own side, it wouldn’t need the label.

We would just know what it was. Right? When we look at when we look at this and what we look at that, it’s the same thing. But this appears to us to be something very, very precise from its own side, but actually it’s only because we’ve given it a label. We have given it a label.

It hasn’t given itself a label that comes back to us like a mirror. We have given it a label. And because we can’t give that a label, it doesn’t appear as clearly to us as this. But as soon as we give this the correct label, from then on, this will appear so obviously whatever it is, just as this is so obviously. Of course, this is a plate.

What else you idiot do you think this is? It’s a plate. It’s obvious it’s a plate. Totally obvious it’s a plate. Idiot?

Moron? Of course, it’s a plate. But it’s not obvious it’s a plate at all. There’s nothing obvious about this being a plate until one’s told what it is. Just like there’s really nothing obvious about what this is, actually, until one knows and gives it a label.

Someone gives it a label, and then it appears like that to us. Obviously, this is a thing. Yeah. What is this? What is it?

It’s a microphone unit. Yeah? An amplifying unit. It’s only existing on the label, but we don’t see that. We really don’t.

But we do see this is obviously a plate. From its own side, it’s a plate. But remember last week, where is the plate? The obvious plate. This is not the plate because this is only the front of the plate.

This is not the plate because that’s the back of the plate. This is not the plate because this is just the edge of the plate. And the blue part isn’t the plate because that’s just the blue part of the plate. And the white part isn’t the plate because that’s only the white part of the plate. And this thing, the foot of the plate isn’t the plate because it’s just part of the plate.

You can’t find this so obvious plate anywhere because such a thing doesn’t exist. It’s something what is here is simply arising like a rainbow depending on countless things. And especially, most subtly, it’s depending on the label that we give it. And we can’t just give it any label, course. If I tell you this is a what do you call it?

A frisbee. No. No. Maybe how about a TV antenna? You know, one of those I I can label it that, but it won’t appear to you that way because it’s not the valid basis.

It’s not the correct basis to be called a TV antenna. So things just aren’t a label. There has to be the base, the correct base. Let me just find this bit. Sorry.

If you think of the letters of the alphabet, when we see the alphabet, all the letters appear very obviously to be a, b, c. They’re there from their own side. For example, if you take the letter zed, that should have been written up, but if you take the letter zed, if you imagine that in your mind, you see the letter zed, yeah, existing from its own side. But actually, it’s impossible to see the letter zed. When you look at that do we have a piece of paper?

Big piece? Someone got a big piece of paper. Thick. Yeah. Right.

Thank you. Do you need the rest? Okay. So here, we see the letter zed. Right?

But, actually, again oh, hold on. That is zed. Right? That is zed. Is it?

No? Oh, either way. Okay. If it truly existed, I knew would have known which way to hold it up. Oh, well, yeah.

But even the right way up. But actually, if wherever wherever you look here, you can’t see the letter Z. All there is is actually three lines. There’s just three lines there. But as soon as we see those three lines arranged in a particular way, we immediately say this is it.

It’s really there. We see it. We see it completely, a particular letter of the alphabet. Does anyone deny that they can see the letter of the alphabet? I’m holding up a letter of the alphabet.

You can’t. You do see it. You don’t just see three lines. You can also, when you think about it, when you start to investigate, can see, oh, yes. There are actually three lines there.

But especially when you see it written in a book on a page, you see a truly existing zed from its own side, not just some, you know, some lines on the page. And when we look, no nowhere here is the letter zed. Nowhere. Nowhere. Nowhere.

Nowhere. Nowhere. Nowhere. Nowhere, nowhere, nowhere is there the letter zed. Is there?

No. There’s no nowhere there. Oh, anywhere along there is the letter zed. And yet somehow, there is the letter zed there. What is appearing, this letter zed that is appearing, not the lines on the paper for the time being.

The lines of the paper are there. We’ll just leave that for the time being. The lines of the paper are there. But the zed that we are seeing, experiencing, that is something that is merely arising depending on our mind. Nothing else.

It’s totally dependent on our mind seeing something and giving it a particular label. And then that zed appears in our mind, But you can’t find it anywhere here. It’s not there to find. All you can find there, if we remember about the parts of the flower, all that is there are three lines, and these three lines are not a zed. There’s no zed anywhere there.

This is just the base for the mind being able to conceive of the existence of something labeled zed. That’s what we call it in Australia. It’s a zed. It’s not a z, is it? No.

Still a zed. Good. We haven’t been totally overwhelmed by it’s a zed. One day we won’t see a zed. We will see a z.

Anyway, that’s another story. Yeah. And the point is another point. The point is I have to check my point. So don’t wanna botch this up.

But the label and the basis are different things. They are different things. And the the basis has to come before the label. In order to label something as something, first, there has to be the base. And then you call it Z.

So there has to be a particular base in order to call it Z. The base has to come first, there has to be a base which has to be separate from the label, and the base has to be there before the label comes. If that wasn’t so, then you wouldn’t need the base to call something zed. Here is zed. Right?

Don’t need a base. Zed is here. But even conventionally, there’s no zed there. But at least conventionally, there is a zed there because the base is there. Again, this is not a parlor game of being clever.

It is trying to capture what our mind is actually doing all the time, which is the source of suffering. Right? No. No. You can’t have the same base and validly, you can’t have the same base and different labels.

No. Both those things don’t work. Oh, okay. But yeah. But there has to be yeah.

And there has to be a valid base that has having the characteristics. Right. No. It’s a different base. Yeah.

The three lines are in a different arrangement. Yeah. It’s a different thing. Then it would be a completely different thing. Yeah.

Yeah. But that’s that’s proving the same point. Proving the same point. Showing the same point. So before anyone tells us that this is a zed, there is no zed there.

There’s just three lines. When we were learning at school, the lady, miss so and so, the lady that went away as a kid, miss so and I can’t remember her name, put these three lines up on the board, and who knows what she was doing, just giving us hard time. You know? It was just three lines on the board. There’s nothing.

But now every time we see an arrangement like that, there appears something, a zed. Yeah. But what we are seeing is something only completely depending on our mind arising it’s arising in our mind, not there. The zed appears to be there, but it’s not there at all. You can’t find it anywhere there.

It’s something arising in our mind, depending on our mind conceiving of something. But it looks the appearance appears to be that there is a Z here in front of me. Right there, on the page. There appears to be a Z on the page. A real Z on the page there.

Yes. Yes. Sure. Not not saying this is yeah. But that that’s not the point.

The point is we believe there is a real zed. We see a zed there from its own side. But when you investigate, it’s not there. It’s not there. It’s just not there.

And even when you start, then you you can go down to the base. You say, this is a line, but where is the true line on the page? Is is this the line here? That’s not a line. It’s just a point.

You can’t even find a a truly existing line on the page. And, of course, let’s not go into talking about the page itself and the person holding it up. It’s all arising in our mind depending on how we can see things and label things. And this particularly also applies to I’ve been talking a little bit about the refuting object, finding the refuting object, particularly this truly existing person that we believe to exist. So there are various and I was talking last week about doing the four point analysis, where you try to think of a situation which was either very frightening or where one was very angry or very proud or very happy when the sense of ‘I’ is very strong and one tries to look at that what was that ‘I’, this ‘me’ at that time?

How did it appear? And then we can check is it the body or part of the body? Is it my mind? Part of the mind? Which part of the mind?

Some combination of both or neither? And in this way, by doing that, we can begin to peel away some of the layers of confusion we have about ourselves. But if we do this long enough with a clear enough mind, we start, we still, you know, we say, oh, well, I’m not my head. I’m not my I’ve I’ve come to the conclusion I’m not my head. I’m not my ears.

I’m not my nose. I’m not my toes. You know, all these things. Are not my mind, are not my emotions. I thought I was my emotions, but I’m not my my feelings.

I’m not this. I’m not that. But still, there’s this you know, we start to refute these things, but still we continue to grasp that there’s this real me there, and we try to find, get down to the actual refuting object, the very subtle source of all suffering. And what is this actual refuting object, the subtle refuting object that is the source of ignorance? According to the Mādhyamika, this subtle refuting object is the I that we believe to exist totally from its own side that does not depend on any label.

That is the subtle refuting object. That there is an I, a person existing here within us that doesn’t even need to be conceived of because it’s really there. It’s not something depending on the label. It’s existing like the zed from its own side. A completely unlabeled me doesn’t depend on a label.

A inherently existing phenomena. Such a phenomena does not exist at all. It can’t exist, because if we meditate on the Zed my wonderful teaching on the letter Zed, Lama Zopa Rinpoche taught this for several hours, for several days at Kopan in nineteen ninety six. It was one of the best teachings I’ve ever heard. I have not been able to capture it.

But you look, you look and look, and we always see this Z that when you investigate it, where is it? It’s not on the page at all. But you look and you say, of course it’s on the page, it’s right there. But it’s not there at all. It’s something merely conceived by the mind depending on on a base.

And the base itself is something dependent on other things, and these are dependent on some and each of those is also merely labeled. Things are existing, but it’s so subtle. It’s just in a momentary arising, like like like a rainbow. One of the classic examples is like a rainbow, which we had in the sky today, you noticed. Huge rainbow in the sky.

Looks like something is really there in the sky. But if you were to fly up in the sky, it’s not there at all. It’s only there depending on many factors. There’s no colors there hanging in the sky at all. There is a purple there, but you can’t find it at all.

There’s no purple actually hovering in the sky there at all. But there is a purple there, but it’s not really there. It’s there, but it’s not really there. This table is here, but it’s not really here the way we believe. And when we experience things like that way, it is liberating.

There’s no basis for anger, attachment, or anything when we’re experiencing things as they are, merely momentarily arising, depending on countless things, and especially our own mind and our own way of conceiving them, labeling them. I think that’s about all I can say on this, otherwise I get totally lost. I think I’ve probably lost everyone anyway. But again, I mean, I think I have said something correct here. I can’t and even if we don’t understand it’s it’s a starting point to contemplate and at least to try to generate some honest doubt about the way we see things.

This is so important to try to have that, That the way things appear to us, there’s no doubt, oh, this is Another way of talking about the refuting object, which is what His Holiness’s Rato Khen Rinpoche used to say, which my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, often quotes, is that when we look at something, such as a table or another person, we see the basis and the label as the same thing. We’re not able to distinguish the basis from the label. So that is the refuting object. Not being able to sing the table and not being able to distinguish the table which is just merely the basis and the merely labeled table becoming oneness. That is the refuting object.

Being able not the mind that cannot distinguish those two things, the basis and the label, which is what we’re doing all the time. We say, this is the table, but it’s not a table. It’s the basis for perceiving a table. The table is something conceived in our mind depending on the label table. And I think if you’re looking from your side, I’m not sure, but you’re seeing a Tibetan table.

Yeah. Tibetan style table. Tibetan style teaching table. Something like that. If you’ve been around Tibetan Buddhism long enough, you see a truly existing Tibetan Buddhist teaching table.

Someone else walking in the room wouldn’t have a clue what it is. I mean, when you’ve what what is that? Right? What is that? If you’ve been around it long enough, you know what it is.

If we haven’t, for most people in the West, this is not obvious it’s not obvious what this is. In China or Japan, it’s very obvious what it is. No doubt what it is. But it doesn’t if it existed from its own side, we would know. If the if the characters of the Chinese alphabet existed from their own side, we could read them.

To Chinese people, they appear like that from their own side, just like our alphabet. It’s obvious that’s a zed, unquestionably. But if it really was a Z from its own side, we could also read the Chinese alphabet, we could read Tibetan, everything, because it would be existing from its own side. It wouldn’t depend on our mind conceiving it, understanding it, and being able to label it. If languages existed from their own side, you know, someone spoke Chinese we would understand it immediately, Chinese people would understand us immediately, We’d all understand everyone, each other perfectly.

Yeah. Mhmm. Well, things that point is good in one sense because some things appear, like you say, to be very natural, but the point is everything is merely labelled. There’s not some things that are depending on being merely labelled and others not. Everything is like that.

So for us at our level, some things easier to give examples to show, and others it’s more difficult. So it’s not much point trying to meditate on them like baby crying, because it’s very widespread and goes back from life to life. Mhmm. But still there is concept there. There is still concept there.

There is still the concept in the child’s mind of pain. And that’s because of that something happens, something appears in a particular way to them. I mean this point of labelling has many many levels. Of course when we see this thing we do give it a label, but because we give it a vague label it appears in a vague way to us. As soon as we give it a precise label we experience it and understand it in a very precise way.

For example, roughly, sometimes when we’re trying to explain something to another person, or describe something to another person, or some particular person no, can’t think of it, how does it go? But anyway you can’t remember the exact name of something and you’re trying to describe it to another person. So you’re describing this thing to the person and they’re saying, Is it this? Is it that? Is it that?

Because you don’t give it the right label, it can’t appear in their mind. You have to no matter how much you describe it and then suddenly you give it the label and they say, Oh, yes, now I know what you’re talking about. So there’s many levels of this. So if you try and think up all these things with the more subtle ones, it becomes very difficult to understand. For us, with our gross mind, we have to start with gross examples, but then we can begin to understand, dependent arising, that everything is like that.

Absolutely everything. It has to be. Yeah. Because also even with the pain that the baby and the candle flame and so on, if the if if this pain of the flame truly existed from its own side, the heat of the flame truly existed from its own side, the child would know without touching it. Yeah.

But what my teacher is trying to point out, if you take a very simple example of the Z, we see something which is not there at all, which is coming from our mind, and we’re not aware of that. Something is completely coming from our mind and we place it on something. We decorate something, and then we believe it’s there from its side, and all suffering comes from that, all confusion. Because it’s beginningless. The imprint of ignorance is beginningless.

So when we just hear it, the power of that is so weak. The Lama Yeshe used to talk about we have this little wisdom flame and then there’s this huge darkness, And our wisdom flame is also being blown around by the winds of delusions. So it’s very difficult for this little wisdom flame to instantly dispel all that darkness. It takes a lot of time and it’s not as I was trying to say, it’s not just an intellectual process. It’s something that we that we have to purify our mind in order to really understand it.

Yeah. And accumulate merit also. And then we just have to habituate our mind with it again and again to try and break this old habit of of grasping onto the appearance. So just another point that Lama Zopa Rinpoche makes is that the mind making up the label I, you know me, this is not the root of saṃsāra. This is not the problem.

Just saying I is not. Some Buddhists go around trying to avoid saying the word I, you know, going shopping, buying something, drinking, but somehow this is practicing selflessness. Anyway, they do. It’s not the problem of saying I. You know, Buddha says I.

His Holiness says I. That’s not the problem. This is not the root of saṃsāra. And the mind which makes the label having seen the base, having the the aggregates also, this is is not ignorance. You know, you see the base, the five aggregates, and then the mind says I.

So this is not correct, but this is not ignorance. But the very next thought by which we believe that the I somehow exists from its own side and then grasping that this is true, this is ignorance. It’s not giving labels to things that it’s the problem. We give the label but then we believe that the label is existing from its own side. There are the aggregates and there is the appearance of the I and then we grasp and we label that I, but then we grasp that that is being totally true and real from its own side.

This is the root of suffering. It’s not so much the problem that things are appearing to be truly existing right now, it’s believing that. That is the problem. This is what Rinpoche said. The mind making up the label I is not the root of saṃsāra, and the mind which makes the label having seen the base, the aggregates is not ignorance.

But the very next thought by which we believe that the I somehow exists from its own side, and then grasping that that is true, that is ignorance. That is the root of saṃsāra. What situation? Well, I can only make a rough guess. Or or, you know, to see a nice nice car or or whatever.

I mean, they would still see a car. Yes. You still see a car. It’s not like when you see emptiness that you know, it’s when you see the emptiness of the table,

Key terms in this teaching

Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top