44 min · 4,832 words · 23 May 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching is a commentary on Lama Tsongkhapa’s praise of dependent arising, explaining that all phenomena are empty of true or inherent existence and that this emptiness is what makes cause and effect possible. It contrasts the view that things truly exist with the Madhyamika Prasangika view, and stresses that emptiness is not nothingness. The speaker explains that ignorance and the grasping at a truly existing self are the root of suffering, and that understanding dependent arising is the way to free the mind from it.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2000-05-23
Duration: 44 min
UUID: 8fa9b37e-dc3d-4896-b0de-765e650265a4
Words: 4,832
Begin to develop qualities that benefit others, and not just superficially for some time, but perfectly, completely for all time. So that wish is the bodhicitta wish, understanding that the only way to do that is to become a Buddha, and the only way to become a Buddha is to destroy ignorance, and the only way to destroy ignorance is to develop the wisdom, understanding way things actually exist. This is the mind that is totally contrary, very opposite to the mind of ignorance that sees things in a false way and believes them to be true. For the sake of ourselves and all beings, we really want to overcome our ignorance, to be free of suffering, so that all others can be free of suffering, so that we can have perfect happiness, so all living beings can have perfect happiness. Especially, we can direct our wishes to have our mind blessed by all the Buddhas, to understand these teachings by making a strong request to Mañjuśrī, who is the very embodiment of all the wisdom of the Buddha’s perfect wisdom.
So this prayer is on page eight. Obeisance to my Guru and protector Mañjuśrī, who holds to his heart scriptural text. So if we’re trying to follow the Buddhist path, then the fundamental belief is the law of cause and effect, that we’re really trying to base our whole life on understanding that is the key to how things operate and it is the key by observing that in our daily life, the law of cause and effect. Working with it in the correct way, is the way to bring about more happiness, less suffering. So the more we have a belief in karma, in the law of cause and effect, and understand how it works, really see that the cause of negative karma, or how negative karma is created, is by following afflicted thoughts, the afflicted thoughts of desire, anger, and so on.
And really under having some understanding, some experience that desire attachment is an affliction. It is a poisonous, disturbing mind. It is a negative mind. It’s a negating mind. It negates our true nature, it negates our happiness, our chance for peace and so on.
It negates the fundamental qualities of our mind and it’s negating even the conventional reality. And the more we look into the nature of our afflictions and how they are suffering, we come to the understanding that ignorance is the cause of these afflicted thoughts. Our self-cherishing, we can say our self-cherishing is really the combination of how all our negative minds work together in combination to produce this self-cherishing thought. And that only exists, this self-cherishing thought, only exists because we have a completely wrong idea of who we are. We have no idea who we are, really are.
We have a completely distorted idea. And even our virtuous thoughts, our good thoughts, are afflicted in the sense that even whatever loving kindness, compassion, whatever we have as ordinary beings under the control of ignorance, that is still these these are still afflicted virtuous thoughts, and they themselves keep us in saṃsāra. By following the the negative afflicted thoughts, the negative afflicted thoughts throw us in the lower realms. The positive afflicted thoughts just keep us in saṃsāra, in the upper realms. But the upper realms of human beings and gods and so on, these are still unsatisfying states.
So it all comes from ignorance, this wrong view. So the more we really see that, that we just our our delusions and and our ignorance that is the basis of them just keep me trapped, limited, confined, frustrated. The more we if we’re intelligent, then we should generate this strong wish to be free of our ignorance. To be free of suffering, we need to be free of our ignorance. To see that this is absolutely the greatest enemy we have.
We have this terrible disease within us which is far worse than any physical disease that we could possibly have. It’s far worse than the combination of every possible bad disease that is possible to have. We have that disease called ignorance, and it’s not going to go away by itself. So we need to develop wisdom to destroy that ignorance, and the way the easiest way to develop that wisdom is to understand dependent arising. This is why we study this text as much these teachings of wisdom, of emptiness, and dependent arising as much as possible.
So even if we are not going to realise, develop a deep realisation of emptiness or dependent arising in this life, it’s so important to start accumulating the causes to understand emptiness. Even a little bit of understanding of it helps in the spiritual path and also in our daily life. A little bit of understanding, but especially not just the understanding, but an awareness of dependent arising in our daily life is so helpful. Again, just to remind you, when consider the highest view of emptiness is propounded by the middle way school, and especially within the middle way school there are two subdivisions. There’s what is called the Svatāntrika, sorry, yeah, the Svatāntrika Mādhyamika, and the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika or the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika.
Sorry. It’s the correct way of saying The the the middle way the middle way consequentialist, which is that is the very highest view, the view of the Buddha, the view of Lama Tsongkhapa who wrote this text, the praise to dependent arising. In that view, it talks about that there are three aspects of dependent arising, that things everything everything arises depending on many factors. So the three main factors are things that are dependent arising either because of causes and conditions, or because of parts, or because of the labelling consciousness. Impermanent phenomena are dependent arisings because they depend on causes and conditions.
Permanent phenomena, such as space, are also dependent arisings because they depend on parts, and all phenomena, both impermanent phenomena and permanent phenomena, are dependent arisings because they depend on the labelling consciousness. And this point about the labeling consciousness is the most subtle aspect of dependent arising. So when we understand this more and more, we understand that things don’t truly exist from their own side. They the way they appear to us right now. When we understand dependent arising, we understand that things are empty of true existence.
They exist, but they don’t truly exist. They are empty of true existence, empty of inherent existence, empty of ultimate existence, empty of existence by way of their own character, empty of existing from their own side, empty of having any original existence. They are empty of having any natural existence. These are all synonyms which I got from the book. Alright.
And this so these are for us right now just words and maybe quite dry, intellectual words that don’t make much sense. But what these why we need to be interested in this really deeply, desperately interested because it’s a matter of life and death, it’s a matter of happiness or suffering, is because these words are trying to indicate experience. And the point is, a point, is that when we see things as being truly existing, as inherently existing, existing from their own side, existing with their own characteristics, being truly there, ultimately there, really there, when and this is what we’re doing right now. When we do that, this this experience is suffering and the cause of suffering. It’s not just, you know, some kind of neutral event.
Everything we experience, we experience as being truly existing, and that itself is suffering. And the cause of all other kinds it’s a very subtle kind of suffering or dissatisfaction or unsatisfactoriness, but it gives rise to all the grossest, most horrible kinds of suffering sooner or later. Because it also reinforces the sense of I and other, this dualistic thought, the separation that I am something separate from all other phenomena, which itself creates this subtle loneliness that we all have, this emptiness that not emptiness as Śūnyatā, but feeling empty inside. We grasp at being this person, this truly existing person, and we desperately live our life trying to build up the reality of this independent person. But it that hope and and we do that to be happy, but it itself is unhappiness.
It creates this huge division between self and others. And even yeah. So it’s a disaster. It’s a complete disaster. It’s completely wrong, and it leads to all suffering.
It perpetuates this wrong view of self and therefore perpetuates self-cherishing, this heavy burden of self-cherishing that we all have, that we carry around with us. So we need to intellectually understand what emptiness is because this will lead eventually, sooner or later, to the actual experience of emptiness. And also, again, the experience of emptiness is not well, the intellectual understanding of emptiness I don’t know how I can say that. Maybe not very satisfying, maybe. But the actual direct experience of emptiness is bliss.
This is the very opposite to experiencing things as truly existing. When we experience things as truly existing, there is always suffering, dissatisfaction. But when when there is the experience the experience of oneself and and phenomena, the way they actually are, that direct, spontaneous, vivid experience of how things really are, there is bliss, there is joy. It is the perfect experience. It’s not just some kind of intellectual exercise we’re trying to put our mind through.
It’s a whole way. They’re completely different ways of experiencing everything. One way leads to all suffering for our self and others. Another way leads to all happiness for our self and others. So also, just to make some basic points before going on, and I will try to go on, is that things way things are existing right now, they are existing as being empty right now.
In trying to realize emptiness, develop the wisdom realizing emptiness, this wisdom is not making things empty. It’s not making them something that they’re not. Things already are empty. Things everything we we experience right now is a dependent arising, is arising dependently. It doesn’t appear that way, but it is that way.
And we so we don’t have to make it a dependent arising. We don’t have to make things empty. They actually are that way. They always have been that way, and they always will be that way. What we’re trying to do is allow our mind to see that, to experience it, by getting rid of the confusion, the darkness in our mind so that we can see what has actually always been there, see in the sense of experience totally.
So maybe also just to mention, hopefully, because that might make more sense, some general mistaken ideas about emptiness. So when we talk about emptiness, which is referring to the true nature, the actual nature, or the ultimate nature of all phenomena. When we’re talking about this state, it refers to absolutely everything without exception. Every single thing that actually exists, exists as being empty. It has this quality.
Ultimate nature is emptiness, that it is empty of being truly existing, existing from its own side with its own characteristics. Everything is empty. Everything is a dependent arising. But it’s not just some things are empty and some things are truly existing because that’s the view some the view of some of the lower schools, that some things are empty, but some things truly exist. The Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view says that absolutely everything is empty of true existence.
One’s body, one’s mind, one one this the person, all phenomena. The Buddha is also empty. The Buddha exists, but the Buddha doesn’t truly exist from his own side. Buddha is definitely existing, but is empty. And emptiness itself, which is existing, is empty.
Emptiness doesn’t truly exist from its own side with its own characteristics. Absolutely everything is empty but existing. And also so it also doesn’t mean that at one point things truly exist and then become empty, or at one point they’re empty and then they become truly existing. Not like that. Everything has always been empty.
Everything has always existed as a dependent arising and doesn’t become anything else. And of course, one of the major things to understand, at least if we don’t understand it, to bear this point in mind, is that emptiness doesn’t mean nothingness, nonexistence, which is what even even academic philosophers in universities still say that this is what Nāgārjuna Nāgārjuna means by emptiness, that he means nothing exists at all. This is complete misunderstanding. It doesn’t mean nothingness. Because some people still, even in some Buddhist schools, argue that the whole purpose of meditation is to lead to the experience where you experience nothingness, a total mere blankness, a total space out where no thoughts, nothing arises in the mind.
There is nothing in the mind. You empty the mind of absolutely everything, and that the mind becomes empty, and that’s the realization of emptiness. This is not correct at all. Not correct at all. It’s actually a completely it’s not even a little bit correct.
It’s totally wrong. It’s a completely wrong view of what emptiness means. When you experience emptiness, you don’t fall into some kind of big black hole where there’s nothing and disappear. Also, don’t know if we would ever make this mistake, but, emptiness also doesn’t mean, emptiness in terms of one object being empty of another one, such as I don’t know. Anyway, the example given here is a vase being empty of being a column.
So the point is emptiness is talking about things that actually exist. Last week, I think we mentioned about the horns of a rabbit as an example of something that doesn’t exist at all. So you can’t talk about the emptiness of the horns of a rabbit because the horns of a rabbit don’t exist. But this glass of water exists, so you can talk about the emptiness of the glass of water. The emptiness of the glass of water only exists because there is a glass of water.
If there was no glass of water, the emptiness of the glass of water couldn’t exist. So also when we talk about a cup with no water in it, the cup is empty. We’re not talking that is not the meaning of emptiness either, having nothing in it. Like, everything is empty is like everything is hollow. It doesn’t mean that.
It means the emptiness is referring to the things that exist are existing, but they are empty or free or they lack this solid, fixed existence from their own side under their own power as independent phenomena. Nothing exists like that. Everything exists dependently on many factors. And also the Buddhist argument, the Mādhyamika praji prajnigika argument is that things can only exist that way. If there wasn’t emptiness, nothing could exist.
Or maybe I shouldn’t say that quite like that because that kind of sounds like there’s there’s emptiness floating around, and in that emptiness, things can appear. It’s not like that. Anyway, we’ll try and understand it as we go along. We got to about actually, in the I hope you’ve got a copy of the text by now, everyone, or the book. So in the root text, it’s not numbered, but it would be quite useful to number the verses so I can then refer to them so everyone knows, so we don’t get lost.
And I haven’t done that. With this one. But I think we got to about the the eighth verse, which is which starts with, oh, wondrous teacher, oh, wondrous refuge, supreme speaker, great protector. I pay homage to the great teacher who so clearly explained explained dependent arising. So that I mean, I I won’t go into much about this one because this is more or less the conclusion of all the previous verses so far.
Because the whole point of this praise is to praise the Buddha, especially for teaching dependent arising. There are many ways that one can praise the Buddha as being free of all faults, possessing all qualities, praising the Buddha for having the thirty two major signs, the eighty minor signs, praising the Buddha for having great compassion, and so on, having the perfect, skillful means to teach others. But here, Lama Tsongkhapa felt that the greatest praise of the Buddha is to praise the Buddha for being the one who taught dependent arising, that the one who realized emptiness, this most subtle nature of all phenomena, and explained it so clearly. This is the proof that Śākyamūni Buddha is a true teacher, the perfect teacher, the perfect refuge, the perfect guide, the perfect protector. Because the understanding of dependent arising, the understanding of emptiness is the greatest protection for our mind.
So then we’ll go on into the ninth verse. So this begins the first eight verses were a kind of an introduction to the whole idea that Lama Tsongkhapa was elaborating. So now verse nine begins the elaborate presentation of the teaching. So as I said, again, just to make this point, that I can only give a very simple introduction to this whole text. Every verse can the the lamas can give much more profound explanations for every word and then the meaning of the combinations of words, so I’m just introducing the text and some basic ideas.
Please don’t think at the end of this course you’ve now got the perfect I’m sure you’ve already realised that, that you’ve got the perfect you have not received the perfect teaching on this topic. So it on to say, O benefactor, to heal all beings you proclaim dependent arising, the peerless reason for ascertaining emptiness, the heart of the teaching. So of course, Śākyamūni Buddha is the benefactor, the one who benefits us most perfectly through his teachings and great compassion. And the way to heal our minds from this terrible suffering, the disease of suffering in our minds, and to heal all beings is to understand dependent arising. That’s why Buddha taught that.
And dependent arising is the peerless reason for ascertaining emptiness. The peerless one is the highest way, the best way to understand and and also in the sense of the easiest way to understand emptiness. So it’s the very heart of the teaching. So how could those who see the way of profound Dependent arising as contradictory or unproven ever understand your system. So the whole point is that ever since the Buddha and the main person who explained the Buddha’s teachings on emptiness, Nāgārjuna, tried to explain these teachings to sentient beings.
There have been philosophers who have argued that there are so many faults in this teaching, that they find all sorts of contradictions between dependent arising and emptiness and so on, and they feel it doesn’t it’s not proven. And this is and and the Lama Tsongkhapa is saying this is basically because they don’t really understand what is being said. But if one understands, listens to correct explanations, then one can see that the teachings on dependent arising are perfect and profound and that the two things of dependent arising and emptiness fit perfectly together. They explain each other perfectly and refute all other ideas. So when one perceives empty as the meaning of dependent arising, empty of inherent existence does not contradict the function of agent and action.
Lama Tsongkhapa is trying to say that what the Buddha taught, what Nāgārjuna taught, what all the great masters have taught, is that when the Buddha taught emptiness, that something is empty, what he was saying is that things are dependent arisings. They arise dependent on many factors. And because something arises depending on many factors, then it means that it is empty. It doesn’t have its own characteristics. It’s not existing from its own side.
It cannot exist that way. So if one understands that correctly, by saying something is empty of inherent existence, this does not contradict the fact that things, that the functioning of cause and effect, agent and action is referring to cause and effect. So what it’s actually saying is that the teaching of dependent arising is one aspect of dependent arising is that there is cause and effect. Things depend for their existence on agents. They have some cause.
They have some agent that brings things into existence that leads to results. And because of that, things are dependent. The effect is dependent on the cause. Because things are empty, that is, they are dependent arising, there actually can be causes and effects. But what people tend to believe is the opposite.
In the next verse it goes on to say, whereas if one perceives the opposite to this, because they argue that if things are empty, then if they’re empty of true existence, then nothing nothing can work. There can’t be any action in voidness. There can’t be any activity in emptiness. And if something if there is something that is acting, working, functioning, then it can’t be empty of true existence. It must really exist.
The Buddha argues, Nāgārjuna argues, Lama Tsongkhapa argues, it’s only because things are empty of true existence that there can be cause and effect, that things can operate because of emptiness. So for example, if something is, as many people argue, and how we perceive things, if things were truly existing from their own side, having their own characteristics, they would be independent phenomena. Not dependent phenomena, but independent phenomena. If they were independent phenomena, they couldn’t depend on causes. They would not depend on any cause.
Right? An independent phenomena cannot depend on anything. Otherwise, it wouldn’t be independent. So anything that is if if something independent existed, it would have it would have to be it could not rely on any causes. If it didn’t rely on causes, it couldn’t change.
It couldn’t act. It couldn’t be an agent. Because for something to produce a result, it has to act. It has to change. There has to be a cause for that change.
So an independent phenomena can’t act according to Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika. If something was independent, it would not depend on causes, and therefore it would never change. It would be permanent, and it could never produce a result. Because for something to produce a result, it has to change, and there has to be a cause for the change. For something to be in one state at one moment and then produce an effect in the next moment, bring about a result, Something has to have changed.
Something has to have caused that change. It has to have depended on some cause. But an independent phenomena can never depend on anything. There be any cause for the independent phenomena to change. Therefore, it could never produce anything.
It could not be an agent that produces an effect. Try and put this another way. The classic example is if you have a seed, that will produce a sprout. This is the classic boring example that’s always given in the teachings illustrate practically everything. If you want a sprout, you have to have a cause.
So people who don’t understand dependence arising, they say, Of course, cause and effect exist, because cause and effect exist, things have a cause and produce effect, that means things truly exist. They argue that because a seed produces the effect of a sprout, they do agree that that happens, that to have a sprout you have to have the seed, you have to have the agent, the cause. But they argue, since seed produces the sprout, then that seed must be really there. It must truly exist from its own side. Otherwise, how could it produce an effect?
If it didn’t truly exist from its own side with its own characteristics, as a sprout as a seed, as a bean seed, as an orange seed, as a tomato seed, with its own characteristics, how could it produce the result? That’s their argument. It has to truly exist from its own side. The people who don’t understand emptiness correctly and dependent arising correctly are saying this. And that’s what we tend to think.
You know, we put a tomato seed in the ground and it produces a bush, a tomato bush. Why? Because that thing really exists from its own side. How else could it produce the plant or the flower? You put a a a I don’t know, some kind of flower seed in the ground, it produces a particular kind of flower.
Why? Because that seed really has all those qualities from its own side. Otherwise, how could it produce it? But the Mādhyamika Prasangikas say that’s wrong. Of course, the cause has the effect, But they argue, I say, oh, I hope we don’t lose this.
In my so I’m I’m just apologizing, but in my mind, I I I do have some understanding, but when I try and say it out loud, sometimes it just I can’t put it properly. But or to take put it take another example where it’s easier to explain it, you have a mother and her child. Right? This is the agent and the result. The mother is the agent and the child is the result.
So, the people who don’t understand dependent arising properly and emptiness properly, they would say the child exists because the mother truly exists. Without a truly existing mother, how can you have a child? Right? No real mother, no child. No really existing mother, no child.
But the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika argue is that, sure, you have to have a mother to have a child. You have to have the cause to have the effect. But how is why is someone called a mother? Why is any particular woman called a mother? And she can only have that title, bear that label because she has a child.
No child. She’s not a mother. So without the effect, the the cause oh, sorry. Forgive me. Everyone can see that a cause produces an effect, but the Mādhyamika argue that also for an effect to oh, sorry.
The cause produces an effect, but the cause itself depends on the effect. If you don’t have the effect, you can’t call this thing the cause. The mother only comes into existence when there is the child. There’s no truly existing mother there to produce the child. They’re dependent arising.
They’re dependent on each other. They’re not independent phenomena. Whereas, when we don’t understand emptiness, we think the cause of something, whatever happens, and we can think about this in our daily life. When bad things happen to us, when we get a bad effect, we think the effect truly exists oh, sorry, the cause truly exists from its own side as an independent, separate phenomenon. But the cause itself depends on the effect.
Without the effect, the cause isn’t there. I didn’t explain that very well, sorry, but please try and think about it. Maybe you understood it spontaneously. Is that making sense a little bit? Yeah?
Right. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. As well.
Yes. Also. Yes. Yeah. Yeah.
Well, that’s considered a more simple point that, you know, we we ourselves can understand that easily, that for an effect to happen it needs a cause, and that cause itself needs many, many causes going back and back in time and space. But also there’s this immediate thing to understand that although that cause depends on many other causes, it also depends on the effect. It’s completely dependent on the effect. The effect is dependent on the cause. Well, this is yeah.
To try and answer that question is things do exist. Again, have to repeat myself. Things exist, but they don’t truly exist and therefore it’s very difficult to find them as a fixed thing. For example, we can talk about beauty. We all agree that beauty exists.
There are beautiful things. There are beautiful people, beautiful things. We all agree that there is beauty in the world. Right? It really it it does exist.
But then, where is that beauty? What is how do you find that beauty? Where is the borderline between something being ugly and beautiful or quite nice but really beautiful? You can’t find that even though we all agree that things are beautiful. You can never define that you make an actual border between anything Because things don’t truly exist to make these total separate divisions, this is ugly, this is beautiful, and there’s this huge gap between.
Things that completely dependent arisings. They’re existing, but depending on many things. Well, a first cause dependent arising is saying there is never a first cause. There cannot be a first cause of anything. Right.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- upper realms
- The three higher realms in samsara of human, asura and sura. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.