45 min · 4,422 words · 23 May 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a teaching on dependent arising and emptiness. It explains that phenomena exist conventionally but not truly from their own side, and distinguishes permanent phenomena such as space and emptiness from impermanent ones. It argues that ignorance is dependent arising that can be eliminated through wisdom, and that the absence of partless particles and inherent qualities makes change possible.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2000-05-23
Duration: 45 min
UUID: b83083ad-7827-4c7d-bfe7-e4cf538eff6c
Words: 4,422
A literal, absolute first time, first cause, then there is not dependent arising, there is no emptiness, therefore there is no freedom from suffering. This is the whole point of dependent arising. There is no such thing as a first cause of anything. Everything is an effect which arises depending. It’s arising as an effect.
Whatever is existing is this dependent or it’s arising dependently. So there may have been a big bang that started off this universe, but that big bang itself is a dependent arising. It’s arising depend it could only the big bang could only arise depending on countless other factors, which means it’s not the first cause. It’s just a temporary first cause in countless other big bangs. I’m not saying that the big bang is the actual explanation, but anyway, even if they come to That’s the whole import of dependent arising.
If something is existing, it’s dependently existing. It could only dependently exist, which instantly says something existed before it because the dependence assumes something prior. For the effect to happen, there has to be the prior cause. Even with permanent things, which are not changing moment by moment, still there has to be a previous moment of that. Something that is permanently existing like space, present space, can only exist because there was space before that.
Well, not everything changes. There are some permanent things, but like for our experience everything is changing, yes, in our experience, depending on countless things. What’s permanent? Well, space is permanent, and there are a few things that are permanent, the other main thing this gets maybe complicated but the other main thing that is permanent is emptiness itself. Emptiness itself for example, this glass remember what the meaning of it permanent and impermanence is?
Remember, I did explain last week this is very important otherwise it gets confusing. Impermanent just means changing moment by moment, and permanent is not changing moment by moment. Permanent means static, and impermanent means non static. So this glass is impermanent. It is changing moment by moment and it’s also finite because it won’t last.
It’s impermanent and non lasting, finite, and this glass is empty of true existence. It doesn’t exist from its own side. But the emptiness of this glass is permanent, that the emptiness of the glass doesn’t change in any way moment by moment. While this glass is existing, the emptiness of the glass is permanent. But if I was to break this glass, the glass would no longer exist and there would no longer be the emptiness of the glass because the glass isn’t there to be empty.
There would be the pieces of the glass, so the pieces of the glass would also be empty. But you wouldn’t have a glass anymore, so you can’t have the emptiness of the glass anymore. But while the glass is existing, it’s a conventionally existing valid phenomena, therefore it is empty, and the emptiness of it is permanent. So for example, if you want to get technical, in the four bodies of the Buddha, there is the Rūpakāya, the form of the Buddha, that is impermanent. Then there is the Dharmakāya, which is permanent, but the Svabhavakaya, which I can’t pronounce properly, which is the emptiness nature of the dharmakaya, that is permanent.
That aspect of the Buddha mind is permanent, but it’s just referring to the emptiness of the omniscient mind of the Buddha. That is permanent. It doesn’t change in any way. Emptiness doesn’t change. Emptiness is emptiness moment by moment.
It’s not a little bit more empty one one moment and then less empty the next moment. Things are just simply empty of totally empty of true existence moment by moment. It doesn’t change at all. If I drink this, this glass becomes a little less empty, but that’s a different kind of emptiness. The emptiness of the glass is always completely, totally, one hundred percent empty.
Between what in a dream? The emptiness that we’re in. Well this is an analogy because when we understand dependent arising or actually experience it, experience the world like a dream or like an illusion. The world is not an illusion, it is like an illusion. So it’s like a dream because a dream appears to be very real, but in fact completely dependent on the dreaming mind and labeling it and so on.
It appears very real and solid, but isn’t. This whole existence is solid. Right? Yes. But it’s not just a dream.
It’s not just an illusion. If it was just an illusion, we wouldn’t have to do anything or we could do anything we liked, but it is like an illusion and in this illusory like world cause and effect operate, so we have to be careful. Is there another world? No, no, no, no, that’s what I was trying to say at the very beginning. That everything is empty.
And so when one is enlightened, one is existing, but that enlightened state is also empty. It has no substance, but it’s real. It is valid. It is existing. The compassion of the Buddha, the wisdom of the Buddha is existing, but it is empty of any true existence from its own side.
So don’t take offense, but what you’re saying is and it’s good you said it, just because we always try we always you’re falling into this mistake of thinking, which we all do, if something doesn’t truly exist, it doesn’t it’s not really that real at all. But this is the whole thing that what emptiness and dependent arising is saying, things do validly exist as being empty of any solidity from their own side. They talk about when one achieves enlightenment, one becomes a Buddha, then one exists in a pure land, a Buddha’s pure land, and countless living beings can be reborn in those places. But these pure lands also don’t truly exist. Is there something after death?
Is that what you mean? Yes. There’s many things after death. Yes, you know, this death we can have a rebirth on this earth again, which is empty. We can be reborn as a human being again and that human being we will be will be an empty human being.
The Bardo state. No, There are things there, but they are all empty, just like there are things here, but it’s, you know, it’s empty. It’s there, but it’s empty. You know, they talk about in the Buddhist teachings like that there are other realms of existence, but all these realms, they’re existing, but they are empty of any true fixed existence from their own side. Just like this earth is existing but it’s completely free of existing from its own side with its own characteristics.
The city of Adelaide exists, is definitely existing, but it doesn’t exist from its own side. It’s a dependent arising. See, if Adelaide was a truly existing phenomena from its own side, it would have to mean that Adelaide always existed because it would never have depended on anything to cause it to come in existence. It would have always been here, but it wasn’t always here. Arose depending on causes and conditions and it changes moment by moment because it’s depending on causes and conditions.
But it does exist and exists because it depends on causes and conditions. And it exists because it depends on parts. It depends on many kinds of parts. And it exists depending on a particular labeling consciousness, perceiving it and knowing, oh, this is Adelaide. Try and go on.
Yeah. If you have some more questions. Not entirely. It doesn’t mean just that. You just can’t say like, I I can say there’s a pink elephant in this room.
I can say that, but that doesn’t mean that there’s a pink elephant in this room. Right. Yes, yes, right. So the way things exist this is the other aspect of dependent arising which we’ll talk about later on the coming weeks because it’s the most difficult part, is the point that for something to exist it depends on the labeling consciousness. But not just that, totally like the way you expressed it, it sounded like it depends on the mind.
But the way things appear to us definitely depends on the mind. So as a human being, we experience this world as existing and because it’s a dependent arising and depending on the mind, we experience this phenomena here unquestionably as a table. But an ant doesn’t see this as a table. There’s just kind of some for an ant that’s walking across here, it’s probably just walking across this vast red, enormous, endless red space or this flat red desert or I don’t know what, you know, I don’t know what an ant is experiencing. It’s experiencing this phenomena in a completely different way.
Maybe. Yeah. But even when we say that, we tend to have the the view that there’s something really here that we see as a table and an ant sees as something to walk on, that there’s something really here from its own side that we perceive this way and an ant perceives that way. It’s not like that either. There’s nothing really here from its own side.
There’s not a real a red table here from its own side that we’re able to see as a red table and that an ant sees as something else. There’s no red table here from its own side at all. But there is a red table here. This can drive us crazy, but it’s important. I am repeating what my teachers say.
I’m trying to say what my teachers say. And if we start to think about it and put the imprint in our mind, it’s helpful. And just basically, all this confusion I’m pouring onto you, I’m sorry, is at least what we can take out of this room with is to try to have this awareness and keep this awareness in our daily life as much as possible is the simple fact that things aren’t as fixed as we believe. They’re not so concrete as we believe. If we can just have that awareness, that space in our mind, then we can we can deal with things in fresh ways or start to.
But while we while we we have this mind that sees things as truly existing from their own side, then we just follow this old habitual behavior again and again. So, basically, the the non-Buddhist schools argue if things didn’t truly exist or even some of the lower Buddhist schools argue if things didn’t truly exist, they couldn’t exist at all, and they couldn’t function. They couldn’t produce an effect. But the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika argue it’s just the very opposite. It’s because things don’t truly exist from their own side independently of of many factors.
It’s because of that that things can exist and can function and have effects. It exist no. We we can’t say you have to be careful. I’m not saying it doesn’t exist. It does exist.
This house does exist. Mhmm. It’s only a house because of the parts. Because of causes and conditions, its parts. Yeah.
Yes. They don’t truly exist from their own side. No. No. Is the concept.
See, we also have this idea that there are which is, you know, I think this is now refuted in science in the most I mean, actually, think it’s been refuted in science in the twenties maybe. But when I was at school, which was after the twenties, still the most profound scientific theories hadn’t got into the textbooks by that time, but I was taught that the smallest thing was an atom and there was an atom which was made up of protons and neutrons or something, and these were the tiniest things and they were really there, they were the smallest solidest particle that you could find. That’s has actually been refuted, but this was refuted by in the Buddhist teachings two and a half thousand years ago. Because we have this idea that things are made up of smallest particle. There is this somehow inherently findable smallest particle of real stuff.
You know, the the world is made up of real stuff, and it’s made up of these these tiny little bits of real stuff. And in Tibetan I’m sorry, not Tibetan. In Buddhist philosophy, this tiniest real stuff is called a partless particle. If this real stuff I hope I can come back and do this properly. If this real, smaller stuff existed, the tiniest particle of real stuff, it would have to be partless without any parts.
I don’t if I can explain this now. Oh yeah, sure. Because God. This thing has parts. It depends on parts, you know, side parts, top part, bottom part, inside part, outside part.
Therefore, it’s a dependent arising. But they argue that there must be a tiniest thing that is the smallest thing possible, an independent thing that everything depends on, the smallest independent object. Because we have to argue if this has got a part here and a part there, a part there, this thing exists depending on parts, Right? So this side part is a big part which we can make into smaller parts.
And the idea is the smallest, smallest thing, so the smallest thing would have to have no parts. Right? You couldn’t break it. Because if it’s got a part, you can break it down. So the finest real thing would have to have no parts whatsoever.
It could not have a top or a bottom, a side or an inside. This thing cannot exist. Because also if it had no parts, it could not have a top, a bottom, a left side, a right side. Therefore, if it had no parts, how could another partless particle join with it to make a bigger thing? Because there’s no parts to join together.
This, you can this part can touch that part because they got parts. But how can you make a big thing out of something that has no parts, and the smallest thing could have couldn’t have parts? There is no such thing as the tiniest phenomena. The final building block of the universe does not exist. No, it doesn’t mean that.
It doesn’t mean that, I don’t think. Well, everything is oneness in everything. Everything has the characteristic of being empty of true existence. Right. Right.
Yes. Yes. They also discovered that as soon as something it observes something, it’s different. The mere fact of observing changes, which implies that the thing is not existing from can’t exist from its own side. Is there another word for “from its own side”?
Inherently, truly existing. Naturally existing, Like, you know, the obvious thing is like what particularly things being beautiful or ugly or good or bad. We think those qualities exist from their own side. Some person is, from their own side, beautiful. Some person from their own side is ugly.
It’s really there inside them. It’s really there as an independent phenomena. Because when we say this, you know, you’re really ugly, you’re really beautiful, We’re saying this with a belief, with the experience that this is an independent quality. It’s not depending on anything. You are, you know, this you are really beautiful, really ugly.
If this was true, everyone would agree. This person is really beautiful. This person is really ugly. But it doesn’t work like that. You’ll get a lot of agreement that this person is beautiful, this person is ugly, but you won’t get total agreement.
And you won’t get anyone to agree that this person is as really beautiful as you think they are. Not a truly good thing or truly here we go again. But again, still things have in emptiness when we’re talking about emptiness, we’re not negating that things do relatively exist and have qualities. Just as the whole universe does exist but it doesn’t truly exist, then further down, you can say relatively things are good, things are bad, things are beautiful, ugly, are meaningful, meaningless, but all in the context that they are these things are not truly existing, things aren’t truly good, truly bad, truly harmful, truly helpful from their own side, but they still have that characteristic. This is why it’s important to understand this meaning of emptiness because, like Lama Tsongkhapa said, that the more you the more you really understand emptiness, the more you understand that the law of cause and effect is infallible, that it actually works, that there are things that are conventionally harmful and dangerous, and they produce suffering results.
Not from their own side, but depending on all many factors. Relatively, certain things are, you know, are good and produce happiness. Certain things relatively are conventionally negative and produce suffering, but not truly from their own side. No. No.
No. Because things have a conventional existence depending on various factors. So because depending on various factors, you will get a particular result. So various factors will produce suffering and various dependent arisings will produce happiness. If happiness truly existed, we could never experience it.
If suffering truly existed, we could never get rid of it. Think about that. That’s the point. If perfect happiness, or any kind of happiness, truly existed, existed from its own side, we could never experience it. Because either we’ve got it now or we could never have it because it doesn’t depend on causes.
So, there’s nothing we could do to have experience happiness if it truly existed. If the happiness of getting drunk truly existed, no matter how much beer you drank, you wouldn’t get drunk. Forget that one. Maybe no. That that’s right.
Because getting drunk wouldn’t and the happiness of getting drunk wouldn’t depend on causes, the cause of drinking, beer. And if suffering, our suffering that we have now, truly existed from its own side, we could never get rid of it. It would never change. It wouldn’t it doesn’t depend on causes. But it does depend on causes, and therefore, can change it.
Of course, main thing to always remember Oh, god. Done it again. I’m sorry. This is called ramblings on emptiness, this course. Ramblings on emptiness.
No? Oh, I think I lost my point then. More Lamrim. What was that about to say? Sorry.
I’m distracted. Oh, yes. So and, like, although it’s really difficult to deeply understand the meaning of the final part of emptiness about how everything depends on the labeling mind, even just some rough idea of this is so helpful in our life, to have this awareness of dependent arising. Because in terms of having problems or difficulties in our life, those difficulties depend on causes and conditions. So sometimes we can change those, we can be aware of the causes and conditions of why we’re suffering.
And some of them are amenable to a change or some change. So then, if we change those causes and conditions, the situation has to change because it’s a dependent arising. But then, to be honest, some situations there’s very little we can do about the causes and conditions of the problem, the external causes and conditions. But there is one thing that we can always do with problems because all problems depend on our mind, the way we perceive it. We can’t change the thing itself, but we can change our perception of it.
That we can do. It may be difficult at first, but definitely we can change our mind because even the fixed ideas we have now that this is horrible, I cannot stand this, it’s unbearable, That that idea doesn’t truly exist. That idea that I can’t do this is a dependent arising, fortunately, and so it can change if we work on it. And by working on that, of getting rid of that idea, I can’t do things, I’m not capable of doing this, I can’t cope with this, We can change that thought, and when we change that thought, we change our perception of the problem. For example, we can change the perception of this problem being an enormous problem to being quite a big problem, which is better.
It’s better. It’s much better. And if we’ve done that, we can change the perception of it being quite a big problem to being a big one. And then we can change it to being not so big. And so on.
This is the whole point. If things truly existed, our mind truly existed, we couldn’t change our mind. And if he also oh, in conclusion, ignorance itself is very powerful that it doesn’t truly exist. If it truly existed, we couldn’t get rid of it. But it exists, but it doesn’t truly exist.
Well, in itself is a dependent arising. Ignorance is perpetuated because we follow it. We were because we don’t look into the nature of things. We just blindly accept what is happening to us as being the total truth, the total unquestioning reality. This this itself perpetuates our ignorance.
As soon as we like it says in the teachings, as soon as one doubts, begins to doubt, have a genuine doubt as to what one is experiencing, this begins to destroy saṃsāra. So everything we do, like just simple breathing meditation to have a little bit calmer, clearer mind that can create this just this tiny little bit more or a little bit of space to look at things freshly is is undermining ignorance or can undermine ignorance. Because ignorance itself thrives in ignorance. Darkness thrives in darkness. As soon as we start to show shine just the tiniest little bit of light, we have changed the dependent arising.
The mere fact that we’ve met these teachings has changed our situation incredibly. We have already under undermined. We get we have already started to undermine ignorance just by knowing it’s there and that it doesn’t have to be there and we can get rid of it. So every every time we try to honestly be aware that things are dependent arising and to question our perception, and even just to intellectually tell us ourselves, I I this thing is really beautiful. I would like it.
I want to buy it. But just to tell ourselves, well, this is just coming from my mind. Yeah. I can still buy it and enjoy it, but still it’s a hallucination, you know, that is so wonderful and beautiful. Right now I think it’s going to make me happy, but it’s not.
It’s itself is a dependent thing. It’s going to change. My mind’s going to change. Things are going to change. One can be, you know, at least even intellectually aware of that helps.
Right. Right. Because if well, Buddha you mean our Buddhahood? Why wasn’t our Buddhahood well, if our Buddhahood was there oh, no. This is can we do this next week?
If Buddhahood was there and then it went away, there’s no point having Buddhahood. And that isn’t Buddhahood. Something that goes away, some kind of perfect state that goes away that doesn’t last isn’t isn’t the perfect state? And all I can say to answer that at the moment is that that when we develop you completely develop the mind of wisdom that understands the actual nature of phenomena, it destroys ignorance, and it destroys it completely in such a way that this ignorance, although it’s beginningless, it can never come back. It can never arise again because the ignorant the ignorance is a dependent arising.
But once wisdom is established in the mind, that that wisdom is the that wisdom does not allow by its very nature for those things to arise that give rise to ignorance. It’s the very opposite. Is a mind that is clearly, perfectly seeing things as they are. Once that mind is perfectly, continuously established in the mind, Right? You can’t get ignorant again.
Ignorance can’t come back because it doesn’t truly exist. It can’t come back from somewhere, and it can’t originate from within wisdom, If you see what I mean. If if one is seeing things really, not not not just temporarily, superficially, but totally experiencing things absolutely as they are, unmistakenly, how can you have how can a mistake arise out of that? How can a mistaken perception experience arise out of perfect perception? So we’ve never been in that state of perfect perception, but we can be.
That is the the nature of our mind, the potential of our mind. You know, another way of looking at it, you know, is we have ignorance now. Why do we have ignorance now? Because we have ignorance yesterday. It it depended on previous ignorance.
This life’s ignorance depended on last life’s ignorance going back and back and back. The ignorance that existed within our mental continuum forty five trillion billion gillion trillion billion eons ago depended on a previous moment of ignorance back, back, back endlessly. But that doesn’t but that doesn’t mean it’s truly existing. That’s just showing that even though this ignorance is beginningless, it’s dependent arising. It doesn’t truly exist, and therefore, it can be eliminated.
Even though it’s beginningless, it can be it can be eliminated. Like, for example, right I I can’t think of this. Maybe Timbuktu. Probably none none of us here have been to Timbuktu, but it does exist. So it’s not existing on our mind right now.
It’s existing depending on the minds of others. And it will become a reality for us when our mind experiences it in some way or another. Timbuktu exists for us now in some way. It exists as some vague idea depending on our mind having a vague idea of it. If we actually went there, our consciousness could directly experience Timbuktu, and then it would vividly exist for us.
Well, again I’ll try to make that clear. There are two kinds of phenomena: impermanent and permanent. Impermanent phenomena depend on causes and conditions, parts and all three levels of dependent arising. But permanent phenomena do not depend on causes and conditions, but they do depend on parts and the mind, the labeling mind. Alright?
We better stop here for tonight. We’re supposed to Kensur Rinpoche has has requested us to recite the twenty one praises.
Key terms in this teaching
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
- A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.