41 min · 3,949 words · 30 May 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains dependent arising: things exist but lack inherent existence because they depend on causes, parts and the labelling mind. Using a flower and the self as examples, it shows that no single part or collection is findably the flower or the person. It also says emptiness is itself dependently arising and outlines the stages of realising emptiness on the path. The session ends with a request to recite praises to Tara.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2000-05-30
Duration: 41 min
UUID: 3709940e-626d-423f-ad3d-0cea1f0147fc
Words: 3,949
Conditions. Things are existing, and but and there is but they are existing depending on causes and conditions. And it refutes the view of non existence by saying things are existing but they don’t have any true existence. They are existing but they are empty of being independently existing, inherently existing. Buddhist teaching is not denying that things do exist.
There is a person that does exist. But the only way that person, I, me, who is sitting here now can possibly exist and function is dependently, arising dependently on many factors, causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling consciousness. That’s the only way I can exist. I cannot exist as an independent phenomena. If I was an independent phenomena, I couldn’t do anything.
I would never change. Independent phenomena can’t change, they’re permanent. If I was a permanent phenomena, I would always be sitting here. Always would have been sitting here, always will be sitting here. Who wants to be that?
Especially listening to this. But you couldn’t even listen to this talk if you were a permanent phenomenon because this is a series of words. And you would never change to hear the different words. You couldn’t function, we couldn’t function as permanent phenomena. So all is empty of self nature and from this cause arises, and from this cause arises that effect.
These two certainties assist each other and abide in harmony. So things arise depending on causes that give a particular effect. That effect doesn’t have any true nature from its own side because it’s depending on causes. So it’s empty of true existence, but it is existing. Because it’s empty of true existence, it actually exists and functions, can produce effects.
What is more wonderful than this? What is more marvelous than this? If you are praised for this principle, that is real praise, nothing else. So before going on giving any more of this wonderful commentary on this text, I’d like to talk a little bit about to hopefully make this more clear, in talking about dependent arising, it has these three aspects. The most simple aspect is that things are dependent arising because of depending on causes and conditions.
So this is the view that all Buddhists accept, that things are dependent arising because of depending on causes and conditions. Many argue, even Buddhists argue, because things exist on causes and conditions, they really exist. Whereas Nāgārjuna and Lama Tsongkhapa argue because things depend on causes and conditions, they don’t truly exist. They are merely dependent arising. They are empty of inherent existence.
Whatever qualities, whatever existence they have, and whatever qualities that thing has is completely dependent on other things. So it has no quality, no existence from its own side. So things depending on causes and conditions are impermanent. Another term in Buddhism for impermanent phenomena is other powered phenomena. Other powered.
This piece of paper is impermanent, It depends on causes and conditions. It’s impermanent, and it’s also an other powered phenomenon. It is empowered by other things, not from its own side. It has nothing from its own side. Whatever it is, is empowered coming about because of depending on other things.
Right? So this means it doesn’t have any true existence. It is existing, but it doesn’t have any true existence. Another aspect of dependent arising more subtle than causes and conditions is that things depend on parts. Impermanent phenomena also depend on parts, but even by talking about depending on parts, this also covers permanent phenomena.
Permanent phenomena don’t depend on causes and conditions. Impermanent phenomena sorry. Impermanent phenomena depend on causes and conditions. Permanent phenomena do not depend on causes and conditions. But they are still dependent arisings because they depend on parts and they depend on the labeling consciousness.
An example of permanent phenomena depending on parts is space, So it depends on the spatial parts, the directional parts, north, south, east, and west, and so on, but also temporal parts. The space that is existing now is existing by depending on the previous moment of space. So it is also dependently arising. Emptiness itself is permanent. It doesn’t change moment by moment.
So it also has temporal parts. The space of the glass is existing because of previous moment of the emptiness of the glass. It’s not not just existing from its own side. Also impermanent phenomena also depend on parts as well. So I would like to do a demonstration.
Could you get one of these flowers? You have probably also seen this a million times before, but I would like to do it once again. Just one. That’s okay. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. That’s fine. Because this is a great meditation that you can we can do a million times. What is this?
This is a flower, right? We all agree this is a flower. So how does this flower appear to us? Well, hold it. That was a rhetorical question, that one.
The way this flower appears to us, it definitely exists, right? It definitely exists, but it appears that the Buddhist jargon for the way this flower appears to us is that it appears to be an inherently existing flower. It’s really there from its own side, findable, because this is also what inherent existence means. If it really exists, of course, you can find it. Right?
If there’s a pink elephant really in this room, you can find it. If you can’t find it at all, it means there’s no pink elephant. There’s no pink elephant existing here. If you lose some small change out of your pocket in this room, and if you look long enough, you’ll find it because it it it conventionally exists. So if something is existing in a certain way, you should be able to find it.
Alright. So this flower appears to exist to us, a flower, a flower. We are seeing a flower. Right? So if we look, we should be able to find a flower.
Right? Because when we’re talking about a flower, it is a truly existing flower. A flower. All we’re seeing is our flower. So some of you know all of this, so please don’t be tricky Buddhists and be honest Buddhists, and what we intellectually know and what we emotionally experience are different things, unfortunately.
So we may know that this is a dependently arising flower and blah blah blah, but we are perceiving. And I don’t mean just seeing, right? Seeing means experiencing knowing. We are knowing a flower. So if this flower really exists, we can find it if we look, if we investigate.
So where is the flower? So we start, you know, is this is this here the flower? This bit here, if I take this off, is this the flower? Anyone will say this is a flower? What is it?
Well well, okay. It’s part of the flower or even part of the stem. Alright. But it’s not the flower. Right?
This is not a parlor trick. It looks like a parlor trick, this is very serious. Yeah. It’s very serious. No.
I mean, this is how you do it in meditation, right, mentally. So you can go along, and none of this here is a flower, is it? It is the stem which is a part of a flower, but it is not a flower. And this is not a flower, The flower. It isn’t this is not the flower.
It is a leaf, which is part of the flower. This is also a leaf. It is not the flower. It is only a part. Right?
Another part. Rotten thing? Can’t find a flower. Just another part. This also not the flower.
It’s just a part of the flower. Can’t seem to find a flower yet. Now, this is looking like a flower. This is really looking like a flower. I would say this is a flower, but, you know Oops.
It’s not a flower. This is not the flower. It’s just part of the flower. It’s a petal. A petal is not a flower.
Right? Another petal, another part, you know, endlessly. You check everywhere you go, you can’t find the flower. All you can find is a part. Everywhere.
This is not the flower. This is also not the flower. It’s only a part. This this thing is also just a part. These little crummy things inside, also not the flower, just a part.
Alright. So you go like that, mentally investigate, and no matter what you look at, with this real flower, you can’t find it. All you can find of the flower is a part. So where is the flower? Where is the flower?
So one answer is you can say, well, it’s all the parts of the flower is the flower, but these are all the parts of the flower. If you took this to your girlfriend, they would not be impressed. This is not a flower. This is just a pile of petals and stuff. It’s just a mess.
Then you say, no, it’s not just the parts of the flower. It’s if you put all the parts of the flower together in the right order, you’ve got a flower. Right? Right? Wrong.
Wrong. What you have, what you really have, actually have, when you put all the parts together and join them together, you have the basis for a flower. You have the basis for a flower. All the parts of the flower correctly put together is the basis of the flower. That’s all.
And on top of that, for a flower to exist, the mind then has to label this flower. Mind does not label that flower a flower, and all the things and the point is the point is the subtle point is for the the label flower to exist in your mind, the belief flower, there has to be something you perceive first. And then comes the idea flower. So the flower can’t come before the idea flower. Right?
You can’t have flower before the idea of flower. What comes before the idea, the appearance of flower is the basis, which is not the flower. The basis is not the flower. The basis is the basis of the flower, but is not the flower. What we experience as a flower is a dependent arising, depending on causes and conditions, parts, and a labeling mind.
We don’t believe that though because we think there’s a real flower here. Because our ignorance keeps saying, but look, of course, there’s a flower here. But then if you look, where is this real flower? Where is there a flower that is independent of parts? Or you can sit wherever you look, wherever you look, you can’t see you look, you can’t see a flower.
You can just see the parts. I went part, part, part. What is appearing right now to our mind as a truly existing phenomena is in reality, in reality, arising depending on many things. And it can only exist that way. You can’t have the experience of a flower without the label flower, without the basis flower, and the basis can’t exist without causes and conditions.
I mean, we don’t you know, none of us will realize this now. And this is not like, it’s really not a game. It’s not being silly. This is the point. Yeah.
Yeah. You would see something. You’d see a thing. Yeah. You’d see an object.
You’d see a yellow green object. Because if a flower of any kind truly existed, you would know it was a flower. A dog also, if the flower truly existed from its own side, a dog would know this was a flower. Or a dog would know this was a watch. If the watches truly existed from their own side, the dog would know this is a watch, what a watch is.
The dog doesn’t know that this is a watch. And the point is, again, to remind you that this is not just an intellectual exercise. The problem of seeing a truly existing flower rather than a dependent arising flower Just seeing a truly existing flower as such doesn’t seem to be a big problem at all. But the problem is every time we see true existence, this is the basis for all suffering to arise, for attachment to arise, anger, and so on, all the negativities. Of course, in the case of a particular flower, we’re probably not going to get very attached, right, Or get very angry.
But in the case of certain things, we get very attached, very angry, and so on, very proud, jealous, and so on. And the reason why we’re very attached to certain things is because there is attachment in general, even to little things, because we can see things in the wrong way. We don’t see some things in a correct way and others in a distorted way. We see everything this way. And like the point is even with some simple thing like that, when our mind is very deluded, there’s, for example, a lot of attachment in our mind, a lot of bitterness in our mind.
You know, someone comes along and touches your one flower and you freak out. Yeah. Even yeah. It really looks like there’s a flower there, doesn’t it, from its own side? There’s no doubt.
There’s no doubt. It seems. But we if you look every time you investigate, you can’t find it. But the mind, ignorance always goes back to grasp, to this old habit that it’s really there. It must be there.
It’s really there. And you can do this also with the person, me. This person is also depending on parts, in a sense. There’s a rising dependent of if you take the body away. Am I by my body is this me?
Is this me? This bit? This bit? Which bit is me? Or even, you know, I have a body.
So what is my body? Is this my body? This is not my body. It’s just my finger. This is just my ear.
It’s not it’s just part of my body. And of course, you know, with this part, this is a flat this is a petal. But where’s the petal? You know? Is this this the petal?
No. This is only one side of the petal because the petal has got two sides. So this is not the old petal. This is just one side of the petal. And this is not the petal because that’s the other side of the petal.
And this is not the pedal because it’s just the top part of the pedal, and this is not the pedal because it’s the bottom part of the pedal. See, everything you investigate, it has no true existence from its own side. It’s all it’s existing, but it’s existing it’s it’s just there and that’s all. It’s something very subtle. It seems so unbelievably real, you know, that when one really starts to investigate, it becomes very much like an illusion.
It is not an illusion, but when one really investigates, it becomes to be more and more like an illusion. Something very, very subtle, just insubstantial, not so incredibly heavy and fixed and solid as we think. The subtle mind, this is also completely empty. Everything is like this. You know, the divine form has a top and bottom.
Well, mind doesn’t have any form anyway. Mind doesn’t have a top or bottom or this or that. Something completely formless, And it also does it does exist, but it doesn’t truly exist from its own side. It’s nine o’clock, four past nine. Do you have some other questions?
Emptiness doesn’t have a cause. Emptiness is a dependent arising, but emptiness is permanent, so it doesn’t have a cause. It’s it’s it’s it’s uncreated. Emptiness is an uncreated situation phenomena. But it’s a dependent arising because it depends on parts and the labeling consciousness.
Emptiness cannot exist without mind knowing it. So it’s also empty. Emptiness is empty. Also no. No.
It doesn’t matter. I’m not sure you can say the basis is there and the flowers in your mind. The inherent one, but also the non inherently existing one is also something. Yes, yes, yes. For the Buddhadharma?
There’s many bases. It depends which Buddhadharma, which Dharma you’re talking about. In the case of this amazing Dharma rising in your mind depending on me speaking, the basis is the is the sounds. Basis is the sounds. Yes.
You could say that one basis is the sounds being made. No, I think you can do the same analysis that there’s all the parts and all those parts together are the basis for a merely labeled talk. Same with, like, a year. A year exists, but it doesn’t truly exist. Today isn’t a year.
It’s just part of a year. It’s never ever existed a truly existing year from its own side. It’s something depending on many days in sequence. Yes. Yeah.
The person that does exist is what is merely labeled by the mind on the basis of the body and mind. No. No. No. No.
The person that validly exists, not the inherently existent one which doesn’t exist. The the person that we have that we like the a Buddha also says I, you know, I exist. That I that does exist as a dependent arising is something that is merely labelled by the mind on the basis of the five aggregates. Is the subject, but the consciousness is not me. It’s an object of consciousness, sure.
It’s something conceived by consciousness but dependent on something else, which is the five aggregates. You have to have the five aggregates. Depending on the five aggregates, the mind conceives of a person’s in dependence on a label. Right. Right.
I should be able to use that same logic for myself, shouldn’t I? Yes. To some extent. Yes. Yes.
Well, for example, to go back to the simple example we talked about is we are all sitting here. We all have the thought subtly going on now, I am sitting here. Right? So when we think that, we believe that there is a real me here that is not the body, mind, combination, or anything depending on anything. There’s a real me here.
That me does not exist at all, or it exists only as an idea, a concept, a false concept. Yeah. Just like, you know, people when they drink see pink elephants. Pink elephants do not exist. They only exist as a mistaken consciousness created by an invalid mind.
But there is a person sitting here right now. The person that is sitting here right now is what is merely conceived of, like in terms of me, being here sitting, the me, the person that is sitting here is what is merely conceived by my mind, in dependence on my body sitting here. While my body is sitting here and because my consciousness is fortunately connected with this body right now, so there are the five aggregates here. And because of that and the body is particularly sitting, while the body is sitting, it is valid to say I am sitting. But there’s no separate I sitting here.
All that is sitting is what is merely conceived by the mind, totally in dependence upon the five aggregates. When the body stops sitting, there will not be an I sitting here. It’s impossible. As soon as the body starts doing something else, then the I becomes something else depending on the five aggregates. And it’s not like, you know, if I’m wearing my watch, you know, wherever my watch goes, you know, wherever my body goes, my watch goes.
And that’s like something separate that’s being dragged along. It’s not like that either. It’s just because there is this arising of the five aggregates, then the mind can conceive I on the basis of that. But it’s not something separate, has some separate existence. It is it is only existing and totally it is merely labeled.
It is merely existing. It is only existing merely by the mind conceiving of it being there because the aggregates are there. Mhmm. So does that mean that the I that doesn’t exist, the mistaken I, the nature of that is the same as our concept of the flower in that for the I that truly exists, we can’t find it when we look at the flower. Yes.
Yes. Yeah. Yeah. We think there’s a real flower there. There is a flower there, but there is a truly existing one.
There is a person there, but not a truly existing person. It’s it’s if we can just maybe oh, no. Okay. Yeah. Sure.
Go on. No. No. Okay. I’m just gonna ask about emptiness.
Mhmm. Once you’ve experienced emptiness, is that it? Well, this is this is a yes and no. The but see, there are many levels of experiencing emptiness. That’s the point.
So if we’re following the Mahāyāna path, there is a point where we enter the actual Mahāyāna path. We’re not on the path now. We may be trying to Mahāyāna teachings, but we’re not actually on the Mahāyāna path. When you study the Lamrim, there’s the three principal qualities of generating renunciation, Bodhicitta, and some understanding of emptiness. So when one does all those things, then you enter the path, on the path of accumulation.
At that point, you have developed śamatha, single pointed concentration or calm abiding, and in that state of meditative absorption on calm abiding, you you have a correct intellectual understanding of emptiness, and you you have a a correct conceptual idea, image of emptiness when enter Mahāyāna path. And by accumulating more merit and meditating on it more and more, you pass through the into the path of preparation, and then at one point you enter the path of insight, which is when you see, you experience sorry, we say ‘see’, it’s not seeing with your eye you experience emptiness directly for the first time non conceptually. Going back, firstly, one can generate a conceptual like a non meditative like, for example, like now, if we study, put a lot of effort into studying emptiness, we can get to a point where we will have a correct intellectual understanding of it. This is not the realization of emptiness. But then if we practice meditation and develop Samatha, and then in that state of śamatha, we meditate on emptiness, we will get this meditative conceptual experience of emptiness.
That will not stop, destroy ignorance. Right? But then by progressing, progressing, we get to the path of insight where we have a direct perception. There’s no concept. It’s non conceptual.
It’s a direct experience of emptiness called the space like emptiness. But that also, that doesn’t destroy ignorance. That’s when you start to destroy it. And so from there, you go through the levels of the bodhisattva levels where you destroy it. And that when you get to the eighth level from bodhisattva, then you have totally eliminated ignorance.
And then And then on the eighth, ninth, and tenth levels, you destroy the the obstacles to omniscience and become a Buddha. So there are many kind of levels of emptiness. So even the first direct experience of emptiness doesn’t destroy ignorance, that’s when you definitely start to undermine it. According to the sūtra part. This is the sūtra way.
Okay. I think we’ll stop for tonight. We should do the praises to Tārā.
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.