Dependant Arising 2000 – 05 D A 2000 05 16

48 min · 4,960 words · 16 May 2000

Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 - 05 D A 2000 05 16
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues an earlier session on the text praising dependent arising, composed by Je Tsongkhapa. It explains ignorance as self-grasping that mistakenly perceives things as independent and permanent, and why dependent arising, including the subtle Madhyamaka aspects of parts and mind-labelling, undermines this view. Examples include the cyclamen flowers and the impermanence of ordinary phenomena.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2000-05-16

Duration: 49 min

UUID: ea541037-d1bf-40b3-840b-9276bf890e17

Words: 4,960

If possible, we try to generate approximation of the bodhicitta motivation, the thought that arises from seeing that oneself and all living beings are trapped in a cycle of continuous dissatisfaction that produces all sorts of terrible sufferings. This suffering is something that can be removed, and we have the ability to remove it from ourselves, to eliminate the causes of it ourselves. In the process of doing that or in the process of doing it and after we’ve done it, we can be in the position to guide others to be free of suffering as well. So the more we feel our own suffering and the suffering of others, we can generate this very strong desire to be free of it, to free ourselves and all living beings from it. On the basis of that, we can come to an understanding that the only way that we can benefit others, to free every living being without exception from suffering, is to fully develop our Buddha nature, to become fully awakened, to become a complete, perfect Buddha, so we make the decision to do so.

So this mind, based on great compassion for others, the mind wishing to achieve enlightenment for the sake of others, this is the bodhicitta thought. It arises in dependence on refuge in the triple gem, in the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha. If we don’t believe in the Buddha, then how can we believe in Buddha nature and the thought to develop it? Also, if we don’t believe not only in our own Buddha nature but in the Buddha nature of every living being, then what is the point of becoming a Buddha in order to save all sentient beings? If they don’t have the Buddha nature, they can’t be saved.

So the complete development of Bodhicitta depends on having a very strong refuge in the Buddha and especially the teachings of the Buddha that logically show that mind exists and the mind has Buddha nature and this Buddha nature can be liberated. So this is the so we need to try and have this motivation based on some degree of refuge in the Buddha and the Buddha’s teachings and the great followers of the of the Buddha. So this is why we say these prayers at the beginning to help us generate these positive minds and to call on the blessings of the Buddhas so that we can understand the most profound teachings that show the true nature of our self and all phenomena. So this is why we start with this praise, which is on page eight, the praise to Mañjuśrī. Mañjuśrī, the Buddha or the bodhisattva of wisdom.

So before we start, if there are people who don’t have a copy of the text. How many people don’t have a copy of the text? Could those people just keep their hand up a little bit? Or anyway, just somehow pass them around. So I’m not sure, maybe there are some new people here tonight.

I just have to explain that this is the third of a series of six talks on this particular text. The topic is quite complicated. I’m only giving a basic explanation of this topic, so if you don’t have some background in Buddhism, this may not make much sense, even if you do, it may not make much sense. Because it really was, this series of talks was, everyone is welcome to attend, but it was really meant to be for people who have some background because then it’s because one really does need some background for it to make sense. Some of the teachings of the Buddha are very immediately, directly obvious and hopefully obvious and understandable and make lots of sense.

Some teachings are much more intellectual and require much more effort and study to really understand them. As I said, what I’m saying in this series of talks is just a very, very superficial discussion of this topic. This is the most profound topic in the Buddhadharma. It can take I shouldn’t say these things because it’s off putting, but it can take lifetimes to really understand and realize what topic is really about. It’s important to have that understanding though because when we listen to these kinds of teachings, we shouldn’t have this mind that demands that I understand this totally instantly right now.

We should just have listen with an open mind and approach it in a in a very open minded way, and just understand that it takes time to understand these things, approach it with some sort of humility that one hears these teachings the first time and maybe it doesn’t make much sense, but then if you hear it again and again and again slowly one understands more and more of what it really means and also the subtlety of it. Because we can hear it and think, oh, I understand this. This is very obvious, but we really don’t understand how profound it is. So we’re considering this text, is a praise written a a praise about to the Buddha, to Śākyamūni Buddha, for teaching dependent arising. This text was written, composed by the great master, the Tibetan master, Jetsün Tsongkhapa, who was the founder of the Gelugpa tradition.

There are four schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Historically, the first of these schools was the Nyingmapa school that arose mainly through the inspiration of Padmasambhava. Then came the Sakya school, then the various Kagyu schools of Tibetan Buddhism, and then in the middle of the fourteenth century came the Gelugpa school, the last of four major schools, which is a synthesis of the three previous schools, but also has some very unique points of its own because of the unique presentation of emptiness of Lama Tsongkhapa. His view on emptiness has some very unique points, also his unique understanding of the way to practice Tantra and so on. So although the Gelugpa school combines many aspects of the three previous traditions, it has its own unique qualities and flavor.

One quality of, and it is a quality not a deficit of the Gelugpa tradition is that it emphasizes the importance of intellectual study of the teachings. Not only to do that, but the argument is from Lama Tsongkhapa is that unless one has firstly a correct intellectual understanding of the teachings, there’s not much point meditating on them, because if meditate on them with a wrong understanding, all you’re doing is reinforcing wrong views. We already have wrong views. We don’t need more wrong views. We need to have correct views and meditate on correct views.

Therefore, it’s necessary to put effort into understanding the teachings, but not just to leave it at that, because the great Gelugpa masters didn’t just leave their practice as simply an intellectual investigation, but they combined it with very deep and sincere meditation practice and purification of the mind based on a very strong moral discipline. I don’t know why all that came out. Anyway, it did. So, as I said before, Je Tsongkhapa is believed to be in the Gelugpa tradition as an enlightened being, and he composed this praise the morning of the day, the morning after. He realized emptiness in the very early morning, and he he wrote this praise straight after that when he first directly perceived emptiness.

And he prays and so this these verses are a praise of the Buddha demonstrating that the fact that the Buddha taught dependent arising shows that he is a perfect teacher, the most valid teacher, the one that we can really trust because this teaching is so so profound, so amazing. And the Buddha taught it so simply and directly. He made what is the most difficult thing to understand accessible to us, ordinary, deluded people. And it shows it it indicates the incredible wisdom of the Buddha and the incredible skillful means of the Buddha to be able to not just have wisdom, but be able to bring that wisdom to others, make it accessible to all beings. So, as I was saying last week, if I can remember what I said last week has everyone got a copy now of the text?

Yeah. Good. I usually don’t try to use notes if I can help it. When I use them I can never find them. Last week I was talking a little bit about trying to indicate that according to the Four Noble Truths, we are experiencing continuous dissatisfaction of various kinds.

We’re all seeking happiness, but we experience it. Instead, we’re experiencing dissatisfaction. This is the very nature of limited existence, that we’re all dissatisfied, and this dissatisfaction has a cause. And the Buddha’s insight is that our dissatisfaction has actually one root cause. There are many secondary causes for our different kinds of physical and mental sufferings and problems, but all these secondary causes come down themselves.

They themselves arise because of one principal cause. This cause is called in Buddhism ignorance, which is a mind that does not perceive the true nature of oneself and phenomena. It’s a mind that actively distorts the way things actually exist. We create it it just makes it create a distorted perception of how things how oneself and phenomena exist, and more than that, it grasps that that distorted view, that distorted appearance is reality. It’s unquestionably true.

This is why, as I was saying last week, another term for ignorance is self grasping. There’s this grasp, there’s this wrong appearance, false appearance created by ignorance itself, not consciously. It’s not a mind that says, Now I will make a false view, false appearance. This just simply happens. It arises.

But then the same mind, the same ignorance grasps that this false appearance is actually correct without any doubt. So this is called self grasping. And there are two major kinds of self grasping, which is the self grasping at the person, and there is the self grasping of phenomena. And as I tried to say last week, this term self has the connotation of something fixed and findable and factual and absolutely unquestionably true, some essential quality that one can find. This essential me, the essential we believe that with the self grasping of a person, we believe that there is a person that we can definitely find who is really there that is not the body, not the mind, not a combination of the body and mind, but something that is really there independently existing from its own side with its own unique independent qualities.

This essential me, we grasp at that belief and appearance which is completely false. And similarly, with all external phenomena, we believe that external phenomena have their they exist from their own side, with their own characteristics, under their own power, with their own qualities. When we look at something beautiful, we believe that beauty resides in the object. We don’t question that at all. Of course, intellectually listening now, we can question it.

We can sit down in meditation and question it. But in our lived moments, in our emotional life, when we come in contact with something beautiful or something ugly, we don’t experience this beauty or ugliness as something, Well, anyway, put it this way. We experience it as something. This beauty is really there in this person, in this object. There is no question that the beauty is there.

There is no question that this thing is really ugly. We believe, we make the mistake. If if people were asked how their mind works, we would probably say, Well my mind works like a mirror. Whatever is there, I just see it objectively. Here’s the room, I’m just observing it very objectively, cream walls, decorations, carpet, fancy lines, frilly lines, and stuff.

Just like a mirror. I’m not making it up. It’s really there just as I see it. Just that my mind is a mirror. This is completely wrong.

Completely wrong. Our mind has the potential to be a mirror, the Buddha nature or the pure mind, the unconfused mind is a mirror mind, but that mirror mind isn’t functioning at the moment. We have one of these carnival mirrors that’s all curvy and distorts everything. And you may say, of course, but everyone agrees that this is like this and this is like that. Sure, we all agree because we all have the same delusion.

This is anyway, there’s much more to what this delusion is. But also, for example, you may think, I’m not ignorant. I’m a very well educated, intelligent person. I have much experience. Please don’t go around telling me I’m ignorant.

But in this sense, we are even the most brilliant people are ignorant. We have this basic confusion in our mind that doesn’t allow us to see things as they are. Just to try to simply demonstrate that is that, for example, an example of our self grasping of or a type of ignorance that comes from this fundamental ignorance is that when we look at things or experience things, we experience them as being permanent, especially in, again, in our lived experience, in our emotional the emotional moment of contacting, experiencing things. They appear to our mind unquestionably to be permanent. This is permanently beautiful, I will love this person forever, this person is personally permanently ugly and bad, I always hate them.

It appears like that to our mind. This table appears to be permanently like this. This building, these walls, they’re permanently like this, but they’re not. Nothing we, as ordinary people, experience is permanent. Nothing.

Only one thing, space. Space is permanent. Everything else we experience, every single thing that we experience is impermanent. It is changing all the time, either very grossly, but also subtly, And we don’t see that. We don’t experience that.

We are and we even deny it. Even when the evidence is before our eyes, we deny it. This is an example of ignorance. Not the the root ignorance, but it is a manifestation of this very root ignorance that doesn’t allow us to see the nature of phenomena. The conventional you may have heard there are two kinds of truths.

There is the conventional truth and the ultimate truth. One aspect of the conventional truth is that everything that we experience is impermanent. That true, that everything we experience is impermanent. We do not experience this. Even this conventional truth we don’t experience, relate to correctly.

Another example, more subtle perhaps in some ways, is what we think of as happiness. Certain things we call happiness. We are convinced that this is happiness. But from a higher view, the Buddha said, this is just suffering. It’s very hard for us to accept that.

Even just having a body, a human body, even a very beautiful human body, a beautiful, healthy human body, which we would think of as happiness, the Buddha said, this is suffering. It is not satisfying ultimately. Our mind does not perceive that. Very difficult for the mind to perceive that, experience that, believe it, even believe it, let alone actually experience it. This is all a reflection of our ignorance that does not allow us to see what is real, even conventionally real, let alone the ultimate reality.

If we can’t see the conventional reality, we will never see the ultimate reality. So what this I think I have to get on to the point. So what this ignorance does in relation to oneself and others is it basically creates the illusion that we are independent. This is not strictly true, but the way we ourselves appear to our mind, the way things appear to our mind, if this appearance was true, it would mean that things are independently existing. That is, not depending on causes and conditions or anything else.

Things, if they really existed the way we believe them to be, they would be independent. From a Buddhist point of view, if things are independent, they cannot exist. An independent phenomena is a logical absurdity. An independent phenomena, a true and a truly independent phenomena does not depend on anything at all if it’s independent. Buddha argued that something like that cannot exist.

Also, if something was truly independent, didn’t depend on causes and conditions or other factors, it would mean that it would be permanent, it would never ever change. Because if it changed, it would no longer be an independent phenomenon. Because for it to change something would have to cause it to change, and if something caused it to change it would depend on that cause to change, it wouldn’t be independent. So if something is really independent, it would have to be permanent. But one can discover that all the things that we experience are, even though right now we believe them to be, permanent, we can discover that they are actually impermanent, which means they depend on causes and conditions, which means that they’re not independent phenomena even though we believe them to be.

If things were independently existing they couldn’t interact. Independent phenomena cannot react with each other. There could be no connection of any kind between two independent phenomena. Utterly impossible. As I mentioned before, when we have the experience, I don’t know if you check this one, of having a shower, and you think I am having a shower, there’s a feeling, a belief, some kind of experience that there is there is an I, a person that is having a shower.

But it’s very difficult to find this independent being that is having a shower. If you take away the body that is under the water, what is having a shower? It’s impossible to have a shower without putting your body under the water, as far as I know. The only showers I’ve ever had. So this shows that actually who we are, whatever it is, is actually something dependent on this body.

But the person that we grasp at as being the essential me doesn’t feel like it’s dependent on the body. We grasp that there’s something that is really me, that is not the body and not the mind, not a combination. So this is why, Lama Tsongkhapa said and experienced, that the easiest way to realise the true nature of phenomena, to break that ignorance that believes that things truly exist from their own side, is to understand dependent arising, to allow the mind to become familiar and actually experience more and more that things arise depending on many factors, that they actually, if we investigate, are not independent in any way. There is nothing that is an independent phenomena. Everything, absolutely everything is a dependent phenomena.

It arises, meaning it comes into existence and remains in existence totally, totally depending on many factors. And this is something our mind, if we train our mind and purify our mind, begin to perceive. First intellectually, then more deeply, in a deep meditational state, but again as a conceptual experience, but finally we can directly non conceptually experience the ultimate nature of phenomena, the empty nature of phenomena, that things are actually merely arising moment by moment depending on many factors. There are various dependent arising is talked about in all the different systems of Buddhism, but although they may use this term, there are four main philosophical schools, they each have their own understanding of dependent arising. And even in non-Buddhist schools there is some understanding, in a simple way, of dependent arising.

But the dependent arising we’re talking about, the true dependent arising, is something very subtle. The dependent arising we need to understand to develop the wisdom that destroys ignorance. So the most obvious understanding of dependent arising is that we can see that certain things or most things, at least intellectually we can understand that things depend on causes and conditions, including this body. This body depends on causes and conditions, therefore it’s a dependent arising. But most philosophical schools leave the understanding of dependent arising just at that, that dependent arising means things depend on causes and conditions.

But that’s only one aspect of dependent arising, because of things I don’t know how to put this exactly accurately, but just try to bear with me in my very bad way of expressing things, but one can say that there are things that don’t exist at all, that are mere fantasies of the mind, of a deluded, confused mind. The traditional examples that are given in Indian philosophy, particularly in the Buddhist tradition, are for example the horns of a rabbit. Rabbits do not have horns, but you can have a concept of the horns of a rabbit, but they don’t actually exist. You can talk about them but they have no reality whatsoever. Another classic example is the child of a barren woman, child of a barren woman by a woman who is not able to give children, can’t have a child, so the child of a barren woman doesn’t exist.

Similar, a western example, I hate to disillusion you with this, is Father Christmas. Father Christmas is an idea that doesn’t actually exist. So there are things that don’t exist at all in reality, and then there are things that validly do exist, and one can break up the things that validly exist into things which are impermanent and those which are permanent. As I said, impermanent things constitutes the vast, like ninety nine point nine nine percent of all phenomena that validly exist. There’s only a few things that are permanent phenomena.

One of them as I said is space. Space in the sense of the mere lack of obstruction. The mere lack of obstruction. This is a permanent phenomena. It’s uncreated and indestructible.

It never changes. What else? Emptiness itself is permanent. The actual nature of phenomena, the final nature, the ultimate nature of all phenomena is something which is permanent, it never changes. There are some other examples, but these are the two main ones of permanent phenomena.

And maybe just to make this clear, it’s a bit unfortunate because maybe these two terms, permanent and impermanent, are not very good terms but they’ve become, in English Buddhism, the translations of the Sanskrit and Tibetan words, so they need to be explained. So in Buddhism when we use the words permanent and impermanent they have specific meanings. Impermanent means something that changes moment by moment. So for example, the primordial mind that we all have, that has always existed and always will exist, that is infinite, its existence is infinite but it’s impermanent because it changes moment by moment but it always exists. So something can exist forever and be impermanent.

A glass is an example of something which is a finite phenomena but also impermanent. It’s changing moment by moment. So impermanent means it doesn’t mean something that doesn’t last forever, it means changing moment by moment. And a permanent phenomena doesn’t mean something that lasts forever, it means something that while it’s existing does not change moment by moment. Unchanging.

Is that clear, sort of? Alright, so of things that do exist, there are things which are permanent, some but most are impermanent. So if one understands that dependent arising just means things depend on causes and conditions, this only means that therefore only impermanent phenomena are dependent arisings, and that permanent phenomena aren’t dependent arisings, if the definition of dependent arising just means depending on causes and conditions. It’s a limited, very limited definition. So this is why in the Mādhyamika system view of dependent arising is much more than that, because the subtle dependent arising of the Mādhyamika school says there are three aspects of dependent arising.

The grossest aspect is that things are dependent arisings and therefore don’t inherently exist from their own side because they depend on causes and conditions, or impermanent phenomena depend on causes and conditions. But for example permanent phenomena, these are also dependent arisings. Why? Because even though they don’t depend on causes and conditions, they do depend on parts. What kind of parts?

For example, space depends on directional parts, north, south, east, west and the other part in intermediate directions, top and bottom, and also it depends on temporal parts, previous moment of time, previous moment of space, present moment of space, future moment of space. If there wasn’t a past moment of space, there can’t be a present moment of space. If there isn’t a present moment of space, there can’t be a future moment of space. So it’s not independently existing, it’s a dependent phenomenon. We will try to go into this in more detail as the course goes on, because this is just a brief introduction to what dependent arising is referring to.

And then the final aspect of dependent arising, which is the most subtle, the most difficult part to understand in its complexity, is that both impermanent phenomena and permanent phenomena are dependent arisings because they depend on the mind, on the on the mind and and depending on the on labeling. Without being labeled, things don’t exist. So these are the three aspects of dependent arising that we’ll try to think about a bit as this text goes along. So everything depends on mind. Nothing exists without the mind, and not only just the mere existence of the mind, but the fact that the mind also labels things.

If the mind doesn’t label something in a particular way, it cannot exist in a particular way. For example, I don’t know if this is a good example, it’s not a good example. Okay. These are flowers, right? Everyone agree these are flowers?

Yes? Don’t be come on. Yes, right. They are flowers. Okay, so what kind of flowers are they?

Oh, okay. Now, you have to be honest, right? Because anyway Buddhists have to be honest anyway, but who knows what these are called? How many people recognize what these are called? Okay, so most of us, I don’t know what they are.

Yeah? So now, yeah, but the point is, right, if these so we now know that these are cyclamens, it seems there’s a number of people in this room who agree that these are cyclamens, we probably have to agree that these flowers are cyclamens. If these flowers so now every time we see a flower like this we will see cyclamens, but when we see them, if we remember, and when we see them they will appear to us to be truly existing cyclamen flowers. It’s like when we’re experiencing them, just to put it very roughly, it’s like they are telling us I’m a cyclamen flower. We just see them and instantly we know this is a cyclamen.

But the point is why we know that they are cyclamens is because someone told us. This flower does not exist from its own side as a cyclamen. It depends on our mind labelling it that way. But it doesn’t appear that way to us, even now you are forced, all of us are forced to see cyclamen flowers. We can’t call them poppies, we can call them poppies but we just simply can’t believe it because we’ve been told the truth, that these are cyclamens.

But even though we know that we’ve been told that, now they appear from their own side as cyclamen flowers. We really feel, experience them as really cyclamens. But it’s our mind that is saying that, doing that, is creating that. If these cyclamen flowers truly existed from their own side the way we think they do, we would know instantly what they were. You know, I can bring in another bunch of flowers that no one in this room has heard the name of, ever seen before, but if they truly existed the way we think everything truly exists, we wouldn’t know what they were, because they don’t depend on anything for their existence, they’re merely existing from their own side with their own qualities.

That’s how we experience the world, whether we believe it or not. When we look at these flowers we may think these are very beautiful flowers or we may think of these are really ugly flowers, and it’s the same thing. This quality of beauty and ugliness we believe is there just like the name cyclamen is there. It’s obvious this is a cyclamen flower, it’s obvious this is a beautiful flower, because it’s there, it’s there, it’s all over the thing that this is a beautiful cyclamen flower, but it’s not at all. It appears to be truly existing from its own side.

And when we talk about truth, something is a fact, right? When we use this term, it has the implication that that is true and factual is something completely objective. Right? It’s undeniably true that something is like this. A crime is committed and you look for the facts of the case, the indisputable objective truth of what happened, believing it’s possible to find it, but there’s nothing objective.

We think there is total objectivity. We think that there is this total findable truth. When I went to school and university I was very interested in history and I thought I was studying the truth. But of course it’s just one culture’s version of things. One culture’s biased version of things, which is presented as the truth.

There is no such thing like that in the ordinary world. This utterly objective findable phenomena. But that’s what we think we’re seeing. The un indisputable objective truth. This is a truly existing phenomenon.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
Kagyü
The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top