Dependant Arising 2000 – 04 D A 2000 05 09

27 min · 3,128 words · 9 May 2000

Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 - 04 D A 2000 05 09
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the opening prostration to Mañjuśrī as a prostration to wisdom, and why a qualified guru is essential for realising emptiness. It presents emptiness as the true nature of dependent arising, contrasts correct understanding with academic misreadings of Nāgārjuna, and sets homework on why ignorance is the root of suffering.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2000-05-09

Duration: 28 min

UUID: 57f51879-c122-4ec8-8082-b1f44efe0640

Words: 3,128

Mañjuśrī here. The first one is because this text is about emptiness and so whenever a text is about the topic of emptiness or any Abhidharma topic of higher learning, not about the general sutras or about the Vinaya. If it’s not about the Vinaya, not about the general sūtra teachings on compassion and skillful means, if it’s about emptiness and related topics related to emptiness, then the prostration is always to Mañjuśrī. So this is the first reason why there is this beginning prostration. The other reason is that it is believed in the Gelugpa tradition that Lama Tsongkhapa, who himself was a great bodhisattva and it is believed, achieved As I said last week, there are various interpretations of his life and who he was, but at least one interpretation says that he had definitely achieved enlightenment in his human body.

He was an enlightened being. And it is believed that he, because of his spiritual accomplishments, he achieved at a very young age, he was able to directly perceive unmistakenly Mañjuśrī. He could actually talk to Mañjuśrī. Mañjuśrī spoke to him. At first, when he was young, he wasn’t able to directly talk to Mañjuśrī.

He used to have conversations with Mañjuśrī through another great Sakya lama. He would send a question to the Sakya lama and the Sakya lama, who was able to see Mañjuśrī, would ask the question and Mañjuśrī would give Lama Tsongkhapa the answer. But later on, Je Tsongkhapa was directly able to perceive Mañjuśrī and speak to him and hear his answers. So and Je Tsongkhapa took Mañjuśrī as his teacher. He had many human teachers, but his main teacher was Mañjuśrī.

Therefore, he says, I prostrate to the guru, Mañjuśrī, because Mañjuśrī was his guru, was his spiritual master, that he was able to perceive throughout his life. In the teachings on the stages the five stages of the five paths, sorry, the five paths, the five Mahāyāna paths, there is the path of accumulation, there is the path of accumulation, the path of preparation, then comes the path of insight. At the path of insight, one directly perceives emptiness. Not not directly meaning non conceptually. One directly with one’s mental consciousness perceives the true nature of oneself and phenomena in meditation, not out of meditation, but in deep meditative absorption one directly perceives emptiness.

At that time and even before that time, actually, somewhere on the path of preparation, you can actually see the Buddhas. You can you can go to Amitābha’s Pure Land and hear the Buddhas teach. You can go to Tuśita Pure Land and hear Maitreya speaking, teaching the Prajñāpāramitā. On the path of insight, when you directly perceive emptiness, you are able to manifest one hundred bodies from your ordinary body, which is no longer, by the way, an ordinary body. Your body, which looks like an ordinary body, can manifest one hundred emanations.

Each of these bodies can manifest a hundred other bodies, a total of ten thousand bodies, which you can send to the Pure Lands to listen to the Buddhas. This is well, well, long, long before one is a Buddha. So one shouldn’t doubt that Lama Tsongkhapa could speak to Mañjuśrī. By the way, this is not made up by Tibetan lamas. This is taught in the Madhyamakāvatāra, which is one of the most important texts on how to realize emptiness by Candrakīrti.

In that teaching, he explains this, how when you become a first level bodhisattva on the path of insight, you manifest a hundred bodies. If you want to, by way, not if you don’t want to, you don’t. If you want to These bodies are also they aren’t just to listen to the Buddha’s teachings. These are also to send out to benefit sentient beings. You send them out as looking like a lamppost, like a dog, like the milkman, like the next door neighbor, like a teacher, like something anything to help sentient beings, whatever takes your fancy.

No. That’s being ridiculous. Whatever you know will suit the mind of the person you’re trying to whose karma is ripe to hear something, to be nudged along the path somehow. So that’s why this teaching on emptiness, on dependent arising is prostration to Guru Mañjuśrī, because it is a prostration to wisdom, because this is the most wonderful thing. The wisdom teachings of the Buddha are the heart of the Buddha’s teachings.

It is the key. It is the key to the Hīnayāna path to one’s own individual liberation. In order to achieve nirvana for one’s own individual liberation, one has to achieve wisdom, this perfect wisdom. If one wants to become a Buddha, one has to develop this wisdom. If one wants to benefit others, one has to teach this wisdom.

If one wants to perfectly benefit others, one needs to teach others this wisdom, guide them to this wisdom. In the in the vajrayana path, which is the fast path to enlightenment But why is it the fast path? Because it’s a way to directly experience the most subtle level of mind which is called the primordial mind of clear light, because this most subtle level of mind is able to directly realize emptiness very easily and quickly. All of the Buddha’s teachings are about realizing wisdom, and the only difference is why one is realizing wisdom. Is it just for me or for all sentient beings?

Is it going to be for all sentient beings slowly or for all sentient beings quickly? It’s a prostration to the Guru, Manjughosha or Mañjuśrī, because it’s so incredibly important to rely on a truly qualified spiritual master on the spiritual path. One needs to follow, have a spiritual master, especially, like, maybe at the very, very beginning, like, for us to have a spiritual you know, to have a strong connection with a spiritual master is not so important. Maybe this is heretical to say this, but I’ll say it anyway. Sorry.

All the but but certainly, one has to, at some point in one’s spiritual life for this or one’s spiritual life to really be completely successful and especially to gain the the deep realizations on the path one needs a spiritual master, especially to realize emptiness. One needs this. Because it’s such a subtle thing, it’s so easy to make many mistakes, many, many, many mistakes. And as I said, to realize emptiness, to have this direct experience, this direct vivid experience of it, unmistaken experience of it, as I said, one needs also to develop Samādhi, single pointed concentration, and on top of that, this next level beyond Samādhi, which is called Samatha or calm abiding, you need a qualified teacher to achieve that. But also, what is the best way to purify the mind is by relying on the guru.

The best way to rely on to purify the mind is to develop guru devotion, complete trust in one’s teacher, in a qualified teacher. What is the easiest way to accumulate so we need to purify the mind, right? The best way is in reliance on a teacher, a qualified teacher. We also need to accumulate merit to realize emptiness. What is the easiest way to accumulate merit in relation to the spiritual master?

We need to understand the teachings on emptiness. How does one understand the emptiness the the teachings on emptiness? One can’t understand them by oneself. It’s not possible, more or less, unless one is an exceptional being who has already studied these teachings correctly in previous lives and therefore has very strong imprints. We shouldn’t fool ourselves that we’re in this category.

Some people would like to. We need a qualified teacher to guide us on the path, to explain these teachings again and again. I mean, there there are people now and in the like in the early days when Buddhism came to the west who who who just assumed that if you read the sutras, you could understand them and experience their truth. This is not possible. It is so easy to misunderstand the sutras.

It’s only through contact with the living tradition, the living tradition, that one can enter that tradition. Just reading them doesn’t you can make even the most simple teachings people are able to make the most horrific misunderstandings of what it means. So, in a topic like this, it’s crucial to hear teachings from a valid lineage. Like in universities now, I say there are some people who seem to have some correct understanding, but also, right now, in universities throughout the world, there are academics taught teaching about Nāgārjuna’s view of emptiness and writing books about it, and they’re all completely wrong. They are, like, a million miles off the point.

A million miles off the point. Because all they do is they they they study it academically from other Western academics because they look at the words and they say, oh, this means this. They have no idea what it actually means in the tradition. And they come to the conclusion, which so many people, you know, non-Buddhist critics of of Nāgārjuna have said that Nāgārjuna, when he says that things don’t truly exist, he means they don’t exist at all. That Buddhism that Nāgārjuna is a nihilist or a nihilist.

I don’t know what the exact pronunciation, nihilist. This is completely wrong. But there are still academics and books written right now that are propagating this ridiculous view, having no understanding of what Nāgārjuna was about. But what Nāgārjuna was about, what he meant, that living tradition exists today. It was carried on by Candrakīrti, the other great Indian masters, to Atisha, this great, great Indian master who came to Tibet and who spread it among the Tibetan lamas.

And this living tradition is carried on now. And we have the good fortune to make connection with that. And, hopefully, what I’m saying is at least a little bit based on what they said. I hope I don’t make too many mistakes in what I’m saying. I’m sorry, we’re almost at the end.

I haven’t got anywhere. So, anyway, I bow down to him whose insight and speech make him unexcelled as sage and teacher. So, just very briefly, in this verse the term insight refers to the Buddha’s knowledge, insight into the nature of phenomena. And because of that insight into the nature of phenomena, all knowledge arises. So this is direct insight, direct experience.

And so the term speech refers to the quality of the Buddha being a peerless teacher. So, the Buddha is unexcelled as a sage and teacher. Why is he unexcelled? Because he possesses the perfect qualities. Has freed himself of all faults and gained all qualities completely.

So he has perfect loving kindness and compassion, and this is his motivation for teaching dependent arising and emptiness to everyone without exception. So, he has the perfect motivation, the perfect compassion, and this is mixed with the perfect wisdom, the perfect knowledge. What he is teaching is perfect because he has freed himself of all faults, all obscurations. There is nothing infecting his mind at all, nothing obscuring his mind. So he is seeing reality as it is, experiencing reality as it is, and therefore is able to teach that perfectly.

There’s no obscuration whatsoever. So he is the perfect teacher. In the past, in India, there were were beings who who were also like the word emptiness is a translation of the Sanskrit word Śūnyatā. So Śūnyatā is just simply a Sanskrit word. It’s not it’s not a Buddhist word as such.

It’s a Sanskrit word. So many people, many Buddhist philosophers and yogis and teachers talked about Śūnyatā, but the Śūnyatā and they also talked about dependent arising to some extent. But what they meant and what the Buddha meant was something completely different. So, Buddha is the perfect teacher because he taught the most profound meaning of dependent arising. He understood the full meaning, the total meaning of what dependent arising is, and therefore, he he experienced emptiness, the most profound level, the truest level, the completest level of emptiness.

Many people some Buddhists make the mistake when they read other texts from non Buddhists that just because they were use the word selflessness or emptiness, they say, oh, this is Buddhism. It doesn’t mean it’s Buddhism or it’s talking about the Buddhist view at all just because it says selflessness or empty. These are just words. And even in Buddhism, there are all Buddhists talk about selflessness, but they mean different things, completely different things. As I said last week, there are four major schools of Buddhist philosophy, And they’re all different and contradictory.

But this is actually one of the great qualities of of the Buddhadharma and one of the great qualities of of the Buddha, why he is the perfect teacher. Because not only did he is he free of all thoughts and possesses all qualities and therefore can teach everyone, he teaches according to the what is suitable for the mind of a person at that time. So the Buddha didn’t teach the highest view, the most profound view of emptiness and dependent arising to everyone. He only taught that to a few people because only a few people had the purity of mind, the good karma, to be able to understand it and do anything worthwhile with it. So for other people whose mind was less purified, he taught something slightly different.

And to others, he taught something slightly different, and to others, something even different. We’re all the time bearing in mind what was suitable for that person and what would eventually lead them to enlightenment, to liberation and enlightenment. Because the Buddha’s teachings are said to be unbetrayable. The Buddha is a perfect guide, the perfect teacher, a valid teacher because his the teachings are unbetrayable. If we if we understand them and follow them, they are unbetrayable.

They cannot harm us. So even when the Buddha taught those things which were not the actual perfect truth, the highest ultimate truth. These teachings are also said to be unbetrayable because by practicing these, they won’t cause harm. They will bring great benefit and eventually they will lead to the next highest view. At achieving that next highest view, one can then get to the next highest view and eventually one will achieve the highest view.

And the Buddha taught that with this complete understanding, with this purpose in mind. So the very diversity of the Buddha’s teachings is a proof of the incredible wisdom and skill of the Buddha mind, the omniscient mind of the Buddha, that he is the perfect teacher. I think I have to stop here. We didn’t get very far. We’ll try again next week.

We will move along. Is there any questions so far? Yes? We’re about emptiness. Is emptiness the here and now?

No. No. the here and now is empty. It’s our actual nature is empty, but the here and now we’re experiencing right now seems to be truly existing. Everything is empty right now.

Always has been, always will be. It’s not like when we realize emptiness, we make something empty. It already is empty. It already is a dependent arising. What we have to do is understand and experience firstly understand it and then experience it moment by moment, directly.

So, when we’re doing that, definitely we’re really living in the here and now. Until that, we’re just living in a concept, in our own concept of the here and now, our own idea of the here and now. So are you saying that the here and now that we understand is what the dependent arising means? Yes, everything is a dependent arising. Everything is a dependent arising.

This is the point. Everything that we’re experiencing now, its actual nature, the way it exists, it exists as arising. It arises, It comes into existence, remains in existence depending on many factors. That’s its nature. It always has been, always will be, but we don’t see that.

It’s there. It’s there all the time, but we do not experience things like that. When we when we start to understand that and we begin to actually experience ourselves and everything as just merely arising moment by moment, depending on many things which themselves are arising moment by moment depending on many things which themselves are merely arising moment by moment depending on many things. When we experience life like that, we will realize that everything is actually empty. It is existing, but it is empty.

It is free of any graspable, fixed, rigid self-existence from its own side. Everything is in that state, always has been, but we we have never experienced anything like it. And that’s why we suffer. So for those people, please, it’s really important to to to in your homework, you have homework, you should please read the text. Start reading it and thinking about it.

If you’ve already studied something about emptiness, really think about it some more. And, for those who have got the book, start reading this first section on this to think about it. So on top of that, one thing I would really like to ask you to think about for the next week is do you understand why ignorance is the root of suffering? Do you have some understanding why that is? In fact, it would be very good if you could write something down, your understanding of why ignorance is the root of suffering.

What is your understanding? Do you see the connection? I haven’t gone into that tonight but this is a fundamental point. So, do you really see the connection between how all different kinds of suffering are due to ignorance? Because this is crucial.

We really need to understand this. So please think about that one. Can you make the connection between having a wrong view of self, wrong view of phenomena, why that causes suffering? All suffering. I mean, generally, ignorance is the basis of delusions and delusions are suffering and cause suffering.

So, basically, what I’m asking is, do do do we understand how this wrong view of self gives rise to the afflicted thoughts of anger, afflicted desire, worry, doubt, fear, jealousy, pride. Do I understand? Do I have some understanding of that? Because that’s the key. Right?

Okay. So now, any more questions? Please, if you have some questions of people. Kyabje Rinpoche has requested us at for each session of these talks to do the praise to Tārā, the twenty one praises to Tārā, which is on page thirty four.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is emptiness the same as the here and now?

No. The here and now is empty, but it is not itself emptiness. Its actual nature is empty, yet the here and now we experience seems to be truly existing. Everything is empty right now, and always has been and always will be. Realizing emptiness does not make something empty, because it already is empty and already a dependent arising. What we have to do is first understand this, then experience it directly, moment by moment. When we do that, we are really living in the here and now. Until then, we are only living in a concept of the here and now, our own idea of it.

Scroll to Top