Dependant Arising 2000 – 13 D A 2000 06 06

23 min · 2,687 words · 6 June 2000

Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 - 13 D A 2000 06 06
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains dependent arising and emptiness: things lack true existence, and realising this brings bliss, while grasping at a truly existing self causes suffering and anger. Using insults as an example, it argues that a self that is merely dependently arising has nothing to protect. It then praises the Buddha’s teaching on dependent arising, links wisdom to cause and effect and bodhicitta, and closes with a Tara recitation.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2000-06-06

Duration: 23 min

UUID: 36f418f8-a6e4-42e9-8c92-a193b770ab3c

Words: 2,687

Upset. It’s just like when you watch a movie, you’d roughly speaking, when you know it’s a movie, you know, it doesn’t bother you. Actually, actually watching movies is an interesting example because at one level while we’re watching them we know it’s a movie, but our mind gets completely caught in that and it becomes real even though we can say, oh he’s acting very well and I know how this effect was done and blah blah. But then, you know, it’s really scary or something or other, or like these giant, what do call them, IMAX things where they zoom over mountains, know, and your stomach falls, you know. The illusion is very powerful because we have this grasping at true existence.

People think, oh, I love such and such an actor or actress, they’re so wonderful, and we’ve never ever seen them. We’ve never ever seen them. All we’ve ever seen are colored dots on a piece of paper or on a television set. We haven’t come remotely close to seeing one square inch of some famous actress or actor. Yes, right.

But we’re convinced when we’re seeing that image in a magazine that that’s the person. So even when we know we’re seeing an illusion, that shows how much our ignorance, deep our ignorance is. So we don’t respond as much. The more we distance ourselves from you really know it’s just an image, we’re not affected. Beings who are actually experiencing dependent arising that things are empty, it’s just I don’t know, I don’t don’t have the experience, but it’s just like bubbles, you know, nothing you just there’s nothing to get attached to or afraid of because also out there nothing is real and the I is nothing solid to be protected.

But basically, as I said before, I think last week, the difference between experiencing things as truly existing and existing the experience of experiencing their emptiness is that one is suffering and one is bliss. I mean, the point is when you realise emptiness, it’s not just like you sit there and, Oh, emptiness, now I see the truth. It’s blissful. It is utterly, utterly blissful. Your mind goes, well, no.

It’s blissful, and not like the bliss that we know. It’s an inconceivable kind of pure ecstasy, not ecstasy either, as in pills. Yeah? We just can’t conceive what it’s like. But when we experience things as truly existing, it’s still it’s dukkha, even the happiness that we have is that happiness appears to be truly existing.

The object is truly existing, and that itself is still dukkha, is still unsatisfying. Even the bliss of the God realms is the compounded pervasive suffering. I mean, it’s just beyond our ability to conceive what it’s like. It’s much better than what we’ve got. That’s the point.

It’s in every way. And also in that state, there’s no way that we can give rise to any kind of mind that can harm others or harm ourselves in the future in any way. Just roughly, a simple example of when we get angry, when someone insults us, we feel there’s a truly existing I that has been insulted and we feel that the mind is by holding the concept of a truly existing I and that image of the I is shattered by these words, we get upset. And to protect the image of I, the appearance of I, we react with anger, which causes and that anger is our mind, is a painful mind. So in order to try to make I happy, we’ve been we’ve been made unhappy to reestablish our our happiness, we get angry, which actually makes our mind unhappy.

And because our mind is unhappy, the I that is actually existing, the merely labeled, dependently arising I, has to be unhappy because the I that does exist is what is merely existing depending on the body and mind. So if the mind is unhappy, I am unhappy, I can’t be anything else. So if we even had some kind of intellectual understanding of that when we were insulted, then there’s no point getting unhappy because you know, angry because that anger is disturbing the mind, and therefore I can only be disturbed. If one really was experiencing what one actually is, something that is merely arising moment by moment depending on the momentary situation of the body and mind, then when somebody insults us, there’s nothing to protect. If someone says, you’re ugly, well, I, the I, is not ugly because the I is not the body.

So the person who says you’re ugly, you just know this is nonsense, you know? It’s like saying you’re a giraffe. I mean, this is a big mistake, you know? Why get upset if someone calls you a giraffe? You one is obviously not a giraffe.

This man is a little deluded, you know. Right? And then also if the person says you’re stupid, well if you are stupid, he’s just told you what’s true. And if you’re not stupid, himher saying you’re stupid doesn’t change the nature of your mind. So why get upset?

If we were really experiencing ourselves even even approximately as what we are as I am what is merely arising depending on my body and mind, then the key thing is always to protect the mind. If the mind is protected, I’m okay. If my mind is in a state of virtue, peaceful, calm, then I have to be okay. I will be peaceful and calm. If my mind is not peaceful and calm, there’s no way I can be happy because I am something totally dependent on what is happening to my mind.

But we don’t experience ourselves as something totally dependent on our mind. We experience ourselves as something independent. My mind. I’ve got a mind, but it’s not me. And therefore, my mind can be unhappy, but I’ll be okay.

It’s impossible because there isn’t such an I. There’s no such I. We have to stop, folks. There’s many more verses. I was hoping to read them, but or maybe is it okay we just read them?

We’re just gonna read them just to conclude? Which which this comes down to basically praise again, praising the Buddha for teaching dependent arising. Your speech is seen as peerless because it presents the path of dependent arising, and this gives rise to certainty that your other teachings are valid too. This is a very important point because His Holiness many, many, many times makes the point, the argument that if you get some understanding, if you put some effort first into trying to understand dependent arising and emptiness, you gain some faith in the logic and truth of these teachings, then this is the best basis for developing a strong faith in all the other teachings. Because they’re all interconnected and actually if you read Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, the first verse of the chapter about wisdom says everything that the Buddha taught before is for the purpose of wisdom.

All the other teachings on the six perfections, all the other teachings are merely skillful means to lead us to realize wisdom. So especially if we understand dependent arising, emptiness and dependent arising, this is the key to understanding and developing faith in the law of cause and effect, which is the fundamental practice in our daily life. This is something we cannot ignore, the law of cause and effect. Is observing in our daily life the law of cause and effect is being wise and it leads to wisdom. There is no way to develop the highest wisdom by ignoring the law of cause and effect.

So you saw reality and taught it well. Those who train in your footsteps will transcend all troubles, for they shall destroy the root of evil. But those who turn away from your teaching, though they wearily struggle long and hard, invite problems one after the other by their firm views of the self. So the more we grasp at this view of self and reject the Buddha’s teachings, we will only suffer, because this grasping at ourself is the root of all suffering, all confusion. Marvellous, when the wise comprehend the difference between these two trainings, how can they fail to respect you from their innermost hearts?

Not to mention the entire wealth of your teachings, just generally understanding one small part of them is to bring supreme bliss. Alas, my own mind was ruled by confusion when long ago I sought refuge, blind to your teachings vast qualities, not to mention their fine details. Yet the stream of my life has not yet sunk into the mouth of the Lord of death, and I have a little belief in you, even this I think fortunate. Of teachers, the teacher of dependent arising, of wisdom, the wisdom of dependent arising. Like kings over all conquerors in the world, these prove your wisdom supreme.

All that you have taught is related to dependent arising, and since this leads to nirvana, no need deed of yours does not bring peace. For example, how do we develop Bodhicitta? Bodhicitta is a dependent arising. It arises depending on many, many factors. Meditating on many, many things on, for example, the six causes and one effect technique of Atisha.

If one establishes the six causes in one’s mind, thinking of all sentient beings as mother, thinking of the kindness of the mother, generating the thought repaying the kindness of the mother, which gives rise to love, which gives rise to compassion, which gives rise to the altruistic wish. Depending on these things, Bodhicitta arises. It’s a dependent arising. Everything is connected to being in it arising. And love itself, loving kindness, is a dependent arising.

And the strength of it is a dependent arising. Depending on meditating on it in the correct way, again and again, loving kindness grows and strengthens and becomes more and more expansive. Fortunately, the love we have is not truly existing. If our love was truly existing, we are doomed. If you got as much love as you have now, we would never be able to make it grow because it doesn’t truly exist.

It’s a dependent arising. It can grow. Wonderful is your teaching since whoever listens will attain peace. Who could not be devoted to preserving such teachings? As it overcomes all opponents, is free from internal contradiction and fulfills both goals of beings, my delight ever grows for this doctrine.

For the sake of the doctrine you gave again and again over countless eons, sometimes your body, sometimes your life, your dear family and treasuries of wealth. When I contemplate, that’s why we offer the mandala at the beginning of teachings. The Buddhas offered their life in order to develop wisdom, so we don’t have to do that. The Buddhas in their skillful means taught us to offer things visualizing offering, to give everything, Because actually at some point, we do need to be willing to give everything to become wise because it’s the most precious thing. We do have to give up something to become wise.

We have to give up our grasping. Heavens, no. Just the grasping at it. Okay. When I contemplate the excellences of your Dharma, you appear to my mind as a fish is drawn by the hook.

How sad my fate to have not heard it from you. That is from the Buddha directly. The intensity of this sadness does not let my mind go free, just as a mother’s mind never separates from the thought of her beloved lost child. But when I imagine your teaching blazing with splendor of holy marks and signs, haloed by rays of light, oh teacher, your beautiful Brahma voice, eloquent in such glory. When in my mind this image of Śākyamūni arises, immediately my sorrows are healed as moonbeams soothe a fever.

That’s why it’s so good when we hear the teachings from our Gurus to visualize them, to think of them, that we’re directly hearing it from the Buddha. That’s what Guru devotion is all about, seeing the Guru as Buddha unquestionably. So when we hear the teachings, we’re hearing them from the Buddha. So we don’t have to worry that we never heard them directly from Śākyamūni Buddha, because when we hear them from our Guru, we are hearing them from Śākyamūni Buddha. Although this good system is so marvellous, the unskilled become totally confused, ideas all tangled in every way, just like the Balbhaja grass.

And we all know what Balbhaja grass is like, right? Very tangly, imagine. Having understood this problem, I then schooled myself in the text of skilled sages and with energy listened here and there, ever seeking the meaning of your intention. I studied many treatises of Buddhist and non-Buddhist schools, yet my mind was tormented sorely time and again in a web of doubt. So I went to the night lily garden of the treatises of Nāgārjuna, prophesized to clearly explain the principle of your final vehicle, free from extremes of existence and nonexistence.

Illuminating garlands of white light, true eloquence of the glorious moon Candrakīrti, whose bright orb of immaculate wisdom moves freely across the sky of scripture, dispelling the darkness of extremist hearts and out shining constellations of wrong speech, I discovered this by the kindness of my guru and my mind found relief at last. Of all his deeds, Buddha’s speech is supreme and for this very reason true sages should commemorate the perfect one for this teaching on dependent arising. Inspired by the teacher, I renounced the world and studied well the conqueror’s teaching. I have been diligent in yoga practice. Such is this picturesque reverence for the great seer.

By the kindness of my Guru I was fortunate to meet the liberating teaching of the Peerless Guide, therefore I dedicate this virtue as a cause for all beings to be received by spiritual friends. Until Samsāra ends, may the beneficent one’s teachings be undisturbed by the winds of wrong views. May all beings in the world forever understand the essence of the teachings and have faith in the teacher. May they uphold Śākyamūni’s excellent way which reveals the principle of dependent arising. Through all their lives let them never waver even at the cost of their bodies or their lives.

Day and night may they always be thinking how to best propagate this glorious success achieved by the supreme liberator in lives of assiduous effort beyond measure. When beings strive with pure intention to preserve this doctrine, may Brahma, Indra, and the world’s protectors and the guardians such as Mahankala be constant aids, never letting them down. So basically, Je Tsongkhapa’s Lam Rim is telling us how he practiced, and this is how we should practice completely entrusting ourselves to the Buddha’s teachings and to a qualified guru, and then really dedicating ourselves, really recognizing that we have this precious human rebirth and really put as much effort as we can into studying these teachings because we’re so incredibly fortunate to have met them, even to have some faith in them. In the teachings it says it requires enormous merit even to hear the word Buddha, to hear the word emptiness, to hear the word dependent arising, even to have some vague idea what it means requires enormous merit. So we’ve somehow generated that in the past.

Now we need to build on it and use it, not just for our own sake, but for the sake of all sentient beings. Okay. Thank you very much. So it’s extremely late, but if people would like to stay and follow Kensur Rinpoche’s request to recite the Tārā praises three times, which we do for the benefit of Buddha House to become a wonderful place, a more wonderful place and have a physically better place in order to benefit all beings in this state and beyond. So this is on page it is the end of the book, thirty four.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top