42 min · 4,356 words · 6 June 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk is a commentary on Praise to Dependent Arising by Je Tsongkhapa, explaining that things exist only dependently and not inherently. It covers the relationship between appearance and reality, the Madhyamaka Prasangika view, and how following delusions reinforces ignorance. The speaker says it is an introductory, informal set of ramblings on the topic.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2000-06-06
Duration: 42 min
UUID: fcc50443-4fa2-4978-ae6d-2e5f84512ada
Words: 4,356
And then finally there arises the wisdom, the highest level of wisdom, that comes from contemplating those teachings with single pointed concentration where we combine what is called penetrative insight that comes from a correct understanding of the teachings with calm abiding. When combine these two qualities together, we develop the wisdom that arises from concentration or meditation, and this is the highest form of wisdom. It all begins from listening to the teachings again and again. As I’ve said before, I’m not really qualified at all to give this commentary other than that I have, because I don’t understand what I’m talking about — I should explain, I have no idea what I’m saying, but at least I have had the good fortune to have received a commentary on these teachings, on this particular text, Praise to Dependent Arising by Je Tsongkhapa. I received that from Geshe Lhundup, who at that time was the abbot of Sera Je Monastery, and I’ve received teachings on dependent arising many times from the incredibly kind Lama Thubten Zopa Rinpoche, and also from his Holiness Dalai Lama and other people, many other great Lamas, so there’s something in the mind there that rattles around, so I try to say something.
So anyway, what I’m saying is this is just, all that nonsense was about, that at least this is an introductory teaching to this topic, so from that hopefully we make some good imprints, and then if one hears these teachings again and again from truly qualified teachers, greater wisdom arises from that, and so eventually we develop the highest liberating wisdom of all. So on page eight is the Praise to Mañjuśrī. So we got to about the twenty first verse, which is a conclusion to all the previous things, which is going back to a praise to the Buddha, what is more wonderful than this, what is more marvelous than this. If you are praised for this principle, this is real praise, nothing else. So then it goes on.
Before going on, these teachings about dependent arising, Lama Tsongkhapa said that this is the main way to, and the easiest way, to realise emptiness, the ultimate nature of all phenomena. It’s by realising, directly realising the ultimate nature of all phenomena, the ultimate nature of our self, and the ultimate nature of all phenomena, that we become free of suffering. We destroy ignorance, and in destroying ignorance, eradicating ignorance, then we are liberated from all suffering. By developing that wisdom even more, combined with the power of Bodhicitta, we are then able to eliminate the subtle obscurations to omniscience and achieve enlightenment. So developing wisdom, the highest form of wisdom, is incredibly important.
Basically, ignorance, the source of our suffering, it perceives reality, the reality of ourselves, in a false and distorted way, and creating the illusion of a truly existing person and that all phenomena are truly existent or inherently existent. If this appearance was true, it would mean that oneself and all phenomena existed as independently, as independent phenomena. But the teaching of dependent arising, which we can begin to see is actually the nature of things, shows that things exist dependently. They don’t exist as independent phenomena, Things exist as dependent phenomena. And in fact, the teaching of dependent arising shows, if we really understand it correctly, that things can only exist as a dependent phenomena.
There is no way anything can exist as an independent phenomenon. An independent phenomenon, as it says on the top of the third page of this praise, independent phenomena are like sky flowers. Sky flowers don’t exist. There aren’t flowers floating around in the sky. They just don’t exist.
They’re an impossibility. So independent phenomena, completely independent phenomena, totally independent phenomena are an impossibility. But if things did exist the way they appear to our mind, it would mean they were independent. They don’t actually appear as independent, but the way things appear to us would would mean logically that they were independent. That independent things cannot exist, therefore, the way things are appearing to us is completely false.
The appearance is there. The appearance is there, but it has no validity. Because for something to be for things to validly exist, the appearance and the way something appears and the way it actually exists have to be in concordance. They have to match. If something exists the way it appears to exist, then it is it’s it’s valid.
That’s correct. But the way things appear to us right now is that they appear to be truly existing, that when one investigates, truly existing, inherently existing, that when we investigate, we find no such thing. There’s a disparity, thank you very much, a disparity between the appearance and the way something exists. So it’s something false. What I was trying to illustrate this with, but there’s no way to illustrate it.
But if you imagine a plastic flower, an artificial flower, very good artificial flowers look like real flowers. They can look more real than real flowers, so there is the appearance of a real flower to the eye consciousness, but when one checks, you discover it’s not a flower at all. There is a disparity between the appearance and the substance. That’s why it’s called an artificial flower. It’s not a real flower.
It just looks like a real flower, but it definitely looks like a real flower. There’s no doubt that it looks like a flower. Good artificial flowers look like real flowers. They don’t look like good artificial flowers, they look like real flowers. The appearance is very convincing, and if we don’t check, we believe it’s a flower.
But if one checks, one can discover that it’s not. So what is appearing to us now appears real. It is totally convincing, totally convincing. But we never check that. We never check that appearance correctly.
But when we begin to check, we discover that it’s an illusion. It’s something false. It doesn’t match up to the appearance. It’s not real. But, of course, it’s very easy easy to discover the falseness of an artificial flower, but to discover the falseness of the appearance of this world is very difficult.
This ordinary agitated mind that we have right now can’t discover that. It get a rough intellectual idea perhaps, but we can’t directly perceive the mistake with this ordinary mind. That’s why we have to, in the process studying the teachings on emptiness, we also need to purify our mind, to make our mind calmer and clearer, less agitated, less controlled by negative imprints and the delusions that cloud the mind. And as well, we have to build up our positive imprints that give us the ability to begin to really see more clearly. And we have to depend on a qualified teacher.
Anyway, part of this process is gaining this intellectual understanding, which is something that we have to try and apply, think about in our daily life as much as we can, to meditate on it, contemplate it, and to apply this in our daily life. My teacher Lama Zopa Rinpoche says that the best kind of retreat one can do is to retreat from ignorance. That’s what real retreat is about. Yeah. It’s not necessarily being in physical isolation, although ideally that’s the best way, but one can be physically isolated and meditating, but one’s mind is still totally stuck in saṃsāra, completely drowning in ignorance, in the darkness of ignorance.
But if we are retreating from ignorance in our daily life, this is real retreat, and the best way to do that is to be aware of dependent arising, to be mindful of this, to study the teachings, meditate on them, and then be mindful of that in our daily life as much as we can, to try and see that even if we don’t deeply understand it, but try to be aware that things are existing and trying to investigate that as well, that things are depending on causes and conditions, parts, and especially the bit we try and consider a bit tonight on the consciousness, on mind, and the label the labeling mind. Things are dependent on the labeling mind and the label. Things cannot exist any other way. If we can try to maintain some awareness of dependent and arising in our daily life, this is the greatest protection for our mind. Just this is ramblings on depend this talk this series of talks is called ramblings on Dependent Arising.
There’s no logic or anything. It’s just what pops up into my mind, because I said I’m not really qualified to talk about this. In the structure of the Lam Rim teachings, the teachings on dependent arising and emptiness are at the very end. All the teachings are structured to lead us to be able to purify our mind and accumulate the merit that will lead us to be able to understand even intellectually this idea of emptiness and dependent arising. Virtually at the beginning of the lum rim there is the teaching of the precious human rebirth.
What is the precious human rebirth? It is something that for something to be labeled a dependent precious human rebirth, it depends on having the eight freedoms and the ten endowments. Alright? If a human being has these eighteen qualities, these all of these eighteen things coming together, if you have this basis, on this basis, that is a valid basis for giving the label a precious human rebirth. Yeah.
This is already talking about dependent arising, sniggling. Yeah. There’s no such thing as a truly existing precious human rebirth. It’s only existing totally dependent on all of these eighteen factors coming together, depending on these eighteen eighteen things coming together at one time, arising together, dependently interdependently, dependently, interdependently arising together on that, and only because of that one can say there is the precious human rebirth. It is a dependent arising, and a most amazingly rare and precious dependent arising.
Depending on many causes and conditions, many things, more than eighteen things, you get one of these, whatever it’s called. But this ain’t so valuable. But getting these eighteen things together, arising together at the same time, all interconnected, of which we can label the precious human rebirth, this is an amazing miracle. It’s not a miracle. It’s actually just a dependent arising.
But it’s a very, very rare dependent arising. Then of course later on in the lower scope there are the teachings on the cause and effect. Cause and effect is the law of cause and effect. karma is an aspect of dependent arising. It’s a crucial aspect of dependent arising.
It’s one of the most basic parts. The first fundamental understanding of dependent arising is that functioning things, impermanent things, depend on causes and conditions. Effects or everything we experience depends on causes and conditions. And as I think I mentioned here before, Nāgārjuna said that until we’ve experienced the highest right view of emptiness, until we reach that point, as ordinary people, what we have to hold onto as our right view is the law of cause and effect. That is believing in and understanding and practicing and being mindful of the law of cause and effect in our daily life.
This is being wise, and it leads to wisdom. If if we reject the law of cause and effect in our daily life, We are just perpetuating ignorance. We create negative karma by following the delusions, believing in the delusions, identifying them as me. The delusions are a manifestation of ignorance. Every time we follow a delusion, we just apart from anything else, we just reinforce our ignorance.
We reinforce the belief of this truly existing person. And while we do that, there’s no way we can realize emptiness. And at the same time, we agitate our mind. Following the delusions, creating negative karma just keeps the mind completely obscured. An obscured mind will never understand or realise emptiness.
An obscured and agitated mind will never develop single pointed concentration, and single pointed concentration is essential to being able to directly experience emptiness. So it’s very wise observing, developing faith in the law of cause and effect and observing it in our daily life. Then of course later on in the middle scope teachings there’s the subject of the twelve dependent links, showing how by following ignorance, on the basis of ignorance we follow delusions, create negative karmas and so on, and how this inevitably throws us into another life of suffering in saṃsāra again and again. So showing how every life itself is a dependent arising, Whether it’s a suffering life in saṃsāra or a happy life in saṃsāra, it arises depending on all these links, these twelve links that flow from ignorance inevitably. This is another aspect of dependent arising.
So to be aware of these things in our daily life is very helpful. And again, like we did last week, the analysis of things being dependent on their parts This is very helpful, because we have to do this kind of analysis again and again and again, because the habit of thinking of things as being truly existing, of conceiving things as truly existing, believing in the appearance of things is so strong. Just hearing teachings on emptiness once, twice, ten times, meditating on emptiness ten times, twenty times is not going to make us wise. It’s it’s just the beginning. But it’s the nature of the mind because the mind is also a dependent arising.
If you change the conditions, what is what is affecting the mind, the mind will change. So if one meditates on something again and again and again and again and again and again, if you establish those conditions again and again and again, the mind has to change. A particular mind will arise dependent on those conditions. Can’t nothing else can happen. There’s no choice because the mind isn’t a truly existing phenomena.
If you bombard it with wisdom, it will become wise. If you bombard it with ignorance, it becomes more ignorant. There’s no choice because the mind doesn’t truly exist. It’s not independent. It’s not immune.
If something is independent, it’s totally immune to anything else. Alright? Fortunately, the mind is not immune. It’s not independent. It’s up to us.
It’s our choice how much we bombard our mind with the right information and awareness. So we’ll try and go on to the the verses. Those held in slavery by delusions helplessly resent you, you is referring to Śākyamūni Buddha, so free and clear. Small wonder they find intolerable the sound of non inherent existence. So this is particularly referring to sorry, this always sounds a little bit sectarian, but Lama Tsongkhapa is referring to the non Buddhists who are held in slavery by delusions and therefore resent the Buddha who is completely free of all delusion, and for them, the teaching on that things don’t inherently exist, they exist but they don’t inherently exist, this is completely unacceptable.
Because the more we follow delusions, of course, the more things appear truly existing to us. When we follow desire and attachment, what we’re doing, we’re ourselves to believe that this thing is first, there’s something appearing attractive, beautiful, and then we allow our desire for it to increase, and therefore our attachment to it increase. And so we’re allowing the ignorance that says this is really beautiful from its own side to operate more and more. That’s why we desire things, because they’re beautiful from their own side. Yeah.
This is really disgusting and ugly and repulsive and evil and bad from its own side. Anger believes that totally. It’s all out there person, in that thing, in that situation. It’s got nothing to do with me whatsoever. So for those held in slavery by delusions to say things don’t truly exist is just totally unacceptable.
So Lama Tsongkhapa is saying that that’s quite understandable that people who are held, you know, held in slavery by their delusions find the teachings of of non inherent existence unbelievable, unacceptable. But then he goes on to say, but to accept dependent arising the precious treasure of your speech, then resent the roar of emptiness, this I do find surprising. So what Lama Tsongkhapa is referring to here are the Buddhists, because all Buddhists, all the Buddhist schools of Buddhist tenets, accept that there is dependent arising. But they don’t all accept what Lama Tsongkhapa calls here the roar of emptiness, and here what Lama Tsongkhapa is referring to by emptiness is the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view of emptiness. So all other schools, the Vaibhāṣikas, the Sautrantikas, the mind only school, and the Mādhyamika Svatantrikas, all of these schools reject the prasangika view that things are totally empty, completely empty.
There’s nothing existing in any way from its own side. So Lama Tsongkhapa is saying for Buddhists to accept the Buddhist teaching of dependent arising, but then to reject that things are empty, this is completely illogical. He can’t understand how this could be possible. But the point is that, again, just to repeat the point, this is just not my style of repeating the point here, but when I receive these teachings, the lamas basically give these same points again and again and again. But in the lower schools, when they talk about dependent arising, basically it’s just referring to dependent arising meaning things depend on causes and conditions.
In the lower schools, that’s their understanding of dependent arising. But the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view is much more profound because it talks about not only things being dependent arising because of depending on causes and conditions, but that things also are dependent arising because of depending on parts. But even more than that, and the most subtle aspect of dependent arising is everything is a dependent arising because of depending on the mind, on the labeling consciousness and the label itself. Lama Tsongkhapa is saying, how can anyone lead them on the path? For example, the first of the four schools of Buddhist tenets are called the Vaibhishikas.
So they talk about finding the emptiness or the selflessness of the person, but they argue, they believe that external phenomena are truly existing, inherently existing, that the external world is exactly like it appears. The person is selfless, but our external phenomena, tables, the whole world truly exists. So they don’t really understand dependent arising at all. Also, the Sultantrikas, the second of the schools, also has basically the same view. And then the mind only school, they talk about there are three kinds of phenomena.
There are what are called other powered phenomena, so this refers to impermanent things. Then there’s ultimate phenomena, this is referring to emptiness. So they say that, and there’s another kind of phenomena called imaginary phenomena. So they say that other powered phenomena, are impermanent, and therefore depending on causes and conditions, and also emptiness, they truly exist. They exist by way of their own character, but imaginary phenomena don’t exist by their own character.
And then in the Mādhyamika school, the Middle Way school, there are two divisions, the Svatantrikas and the Prasangikas. The Svatantrikas, they say that phenomena do not truly exist, but they do exist by way of their own character. They don’t truly exist as independent phenomena, but they do have some characteristic that is uniquely arising within them. They exist by way of their own character. Something there is independent.
But the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika, which is our school, is what we’re trying to become because this is the view of Lama Tsongkhapa. And Lama Tsongkhapa proves logically in his very famous text called the Drangwa Lekshey Nyingpo, he proves that the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika view is the actual final view of the Buddha, because at different times the Buddha taught many different things about the nature of reality. Lama Tsongkhapa, because of his inconceivable wisdom, was able to show through the power of logic that although different sutras say different things at different times, if you really check, one can discover that what the Buddha’s highest view, his own view, his own experience is is captured by the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika viewpoint, and which is that not only do things not truly exist, they don’t exist by way of their own character at all. Nothing exists by way of its own character at all. Everything is existing only merely as a dependent arising.
Everything even and and the characteristics of things, especially this is getting to the most subtle point, the characteristics of things are what is merely labeled. The characteristics of everything are what is merely labeled, merely conceived of by the mind. There’s nothing there from its own side by itself. This view is very difficult to arrive at, to understand and experience, because we always want to think, well, yes, but there’s something there. There’s got to be something out there.
Really there by itself, hovering there somehow. But every time we really check logically, carefully, we can’t find it. Now we talk about beauty. Beauty does exist, but you can’t find it from its own side. It’s only something that is conventionally existing, depending on many factors.
It has no ultimate existence from its own side. It’s what something just merely labeled by the mind. So then Lama Tsongkhapa goes on to say that if through the very term of highest dependent arising, which is the door that leads to non inherent existence, They, which means people who don’t understand the Buddhist teachings, they grasp inherent existence. By what means can these people be led into the good path that pleases you, that incomparable entrance well traveled by supreme aryas? So what Lama Tsongkhapa is saying here is that if when even Buddhists, so called Buddhists, study dependent arising, and this is the method to liberation, to developing wisdom, to destroying ignorance.
If when they hear the teachings on dependent arising that leads to the understanding that things don’t inherently exist, through hearing these teachings, they come to the conclusion that things actually inherently exist. You know, they they get the wrong idea, the wrong conclusion. Then if this is the case, how are they ever going to get liberated? There’s no hope. Here is the remedy.
Someone there is a disease, and here is the medicine. But for these people, they turn the medicine into poison. The very thing that is going to cure the disease becomes another poison to make the disease worse. So it’s incredibly important that in studying the teachings of Dependent Arising we hear the correct teachings and really come to the right understanding. Because as I was saying in the very first talk, Lama Tsongkhapa — because we think we understand something about dependent arising, things are dependent arising because things don’t truly exist because they exist on causes and conditions, because they depend on causes and conditions.
And we think, oh yes, I understand that. If things depend on causes and conditions, then they don’t truly exist from their own side. But actually, philosophers argue that because things depend on causes and conditions, they’re real. They’ve come into existence, and now they’re real. They’re totally solid, fixed things.
Because there are real causes, real conditions, they come together, and they produce a real, truly existing phenomenon. But they don’t. They produce a non inherently existing phenomenon. This table, we know depends on causes and conditions. We know it just didn’t appear out of nothing, but it looks unbelievably real from its own side.
If someone says there’s a pink elephant in this room, we say, that’s impossible because there isn’t the causes and conditions for a pink elephant to exist. It’s just not possible. But we know the you know, there are valid causes and conditions for tables to exist, and here it is. It’s totally real. But it’s not, the Buddha say.
Then Lama Tsongkhapa goes on to say, inherent existence, unmade and non dependent. So these are synonyms. Right? People who argue that things inherently exist, it’s also saying things are unmade, uncreated. If something inherently exists, it must be uncreated.
It could never be if something really exists from its own side, inherently, truly existing, it could never have been created. Because if it’s created, it’s a dependent phenomenon. It is not truly existing from its own side, and therefore its inherent existence, unmade, and also non dependent are all synonyms. Whereas dependently related, made, or created, and dependent, these are all synonyms and the very opposite synonyms to the first set. So how can these two states be combined on one base without contradiction?
So in other words, if this appears to us to be inherently existed, it would have to be unmade, uncreated, but we know it was created. So these two things are totally contradictory. There’s a contradiction between the appearance and its actual way of existing. In the moment we experience things emotionally, this thing appears inherently existing, but when we investigate, we know it’s created. But these two things contradict.
Therefore, whatever arises dependently, though always always free of inherent existence, appears to exist from its own side. So you said this is like an illusion. So although the this thing, this what we call a table here, is depending on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind, it doesn’t appear that way to us. It appears to be truly existing. It appears in another way.
And that’s why the Buddha said this whole world is like an illusion. It is not an illusion, but it is like an illusion. So this is a very subtle distinction because if we say everything is an illusion, we’re falling into this extreme of nihilism, that nothing exists. Then if we say, think this this table really exists the way it appears, we’re falling into the extreme of realism, of true existence. So the way this thing exists is like an illusion.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
- The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
- obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
- One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.