37 min · 3,671 words · 6 May 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that ignorance, a subtle misperception of a truly existing self and of all phenomena, is the root of suffering and of the cycle of disturbing thoughts. Using the rope-and-snake analogy, it teaches that the self we grasp at is a mental projection rather than something findable. It presents dependent arising, praised by Tsongkhapa, as the easiest way to understand emptiness and to eliminate ignorance.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2000-05-06
Duration: 37 min
UUID: 48cc333c-4089-4d07-969f-edabb05d7879
Words: 3,671
So this is very roughly what ignorance is doing. Right? And this is the root of all suffering. I’m only just talking about it in a very, very general way. But, for example, in the case of a disease, we get a disease.
We don’t want this disease. We want to stop it totally. We don’t want to just reduce the disease. If it’s possible, we want to eliminate the disease, right? So, in order to do that, the root cause of the disease has to be identified and then, if it’s identified, you do the appropriate procedures, maybe an operation, a particular kind of medicine, a particular kind of diet or something.
If the real root cause of the disease isn’t identified, you get a kind of a close approximation and you work on that, then you won’t get rid of the disease. You might modify it or you might stop it for a while, but it will come back. Like, for example, cancer. You have cancer, the doctor locates the cancer, cuts it out, but he didn’t locate the main part. Maybe he only got a secondary part.
And the real partI don’t know if this is how cancer works but I think you get a general ideaif the real cause isn’t identified and eliminated, the disease goes on, the suffering goes on. So, this ignorance that the Buddha talked about is something very, very subtle. So, our job is to discover how our own ignorance works and how it very subtly distorts things. We have to find this very root ignorance and then uproot it, eliminate it. If we don’t, suffering goes on.
So even within the Buddhist teachings, there are many different views about what this root ignorance is. Everyone all Buddhists agree that ignorance is the root of suffering. All Buddhists agree that ignorance distorts the way things appear and grasps that that is true. But then there’s different interpretations of what and how ignorance distorts, how much it distorts. So this is the tricky point.
So this is why there are these four major schools of philosophical schools, each saying this is what the Buddha means by ignorance, Then another school says, No. So you have these four schools, the Vaibhāṣika school, the Sautrāntika school, the mind only school, and the Mādhyamika school. So, in order to develop the wisdom that counteracts this ignorance and destroys this ignorance, we have to do a number of things, principal things. Within those main things, there’s lots of other things to do. Firstly, we have to or one thing we have to do is to understand the teachings that the Buddha gave, about what ignorance is.
The the to the and how ignorance creates this false appearance of the self, the person, and all phenomena. And to understand the teachings that explain how oneself and all phenomena actually do exist. That’s one thing we have to do to gain that intellectual understanding. But that in itself won’t destroy ignorance. Just studying the teachings on emptiness and actually understanding them, this doesn’t destroy the ignorance that is causing us suffering.
Because there are two kinds of ignorance. Right? It’s basically the same thing, but two different objects. There is the ignorance that has a wrong view of self, of person, and there’s the wrong view of all phenomena. The the the wrong view is the same, the object is difference is different.
There’s the wrong view of the person, the wrong view of phenomena. And in trying to destroy ignorance, in the teachings it explains that we need to try it’s easiest to to work with the wrong view of self If we develop an understanding of the wrong view of self and eliminate that, then the wrong view of phenomena is very easy to understand. Within this wrong view of self, our ignorance is creating the appearance of a truly existing person. Right? A truly existing person.
Someone something that is definitely findable and unchangeable that we believe is really there. We have a body, we have a mind, and then there’s me. Right? What is this me? We’re convinced it’s there, it’s real, it’s very solid, but we don’t really know what it is.
And in in our ignorance, we grasp at a completely mistaken idea of it. So in order to destroy that wrong view, we have to we have to find this mistaken conception. We have to be able to identify who we think we are. We have to find this false appearance. Because this false appearance that we have of ourselves is called the refuting object, the object to be refuted by logic, the object to be destroyed.
And this is the tricky part, the most tricky part, is to be able to find the refuting object. And in order to find Anyway, thank you. We have Just go back. We have a body. We have a mind.
Right? And there’s me. Am I my body? We could be, but, actually, we don’t believe this. Am I my mind?
No. I’m not my mind. There is an ignorance that is grasping that I am something that is not the body, not the mind, and not a mixture of the body of mind, but something else, something that is existing independently of these things, a truly existing, independently existing phenomena, me. For example, you can check this out tomorrow morning. I don’t know if you do it tomorrow in the morning, maybe you do it in the evening.
You can check it out tonight, tomorrow morning, wherever you do it, when you have a shower. Next shower, you have. You think, I am having a shower. Right? I am having a shower.
But what is being washed as you think, I am having a shower? It’s your body. It’s just the body is under the water. There is a body under the water in the shower, singing away, scrubbing away, But there is a strong sense that I am washing myself. I am this is also I am washing myself.
Very tricky feat, that one. But I am being washed. I am having a shower. You can’t wash your mind and take out your mind and wash them, so you’re not washing your mind. So what is this I that’s having a shower, that we really feel is having a shower?
Because it feels definitely that I am having a shower. So what is this I that is separate from the body that is getting washed? So, you see, we are grasping at something and making up some very powerful appearance that we believe in. So there is a person that does exist. We shouldn’t worry about that, that there is a person that does exist.
Things do exist, but the trouble is our ignorance, as Lama Tsongkhapa says, decorates what is there. It adds something to what is existing. Ignorance adds something on top of what is already there and believes that thing that has been decorated on top of what is there is the real thing, and we grasp at that as being true. And then we suffer. Because what it comes down to is this ignorance.
It doesn’t believe that I am a dependent phenomena. It doesn’t believe that things are totally in dependence upon other things. But, logically, if what we believe was true, the person that we believe in, if that being did exist and if things actually did exist the way we grasp at them, it would mean logically that they were independent, completely independent phenomena. The way things appear to us really means is implying that they’re independent, completely independent. And we tend to act in our life like that, that things are separate from us, unconnected to us.
And even me, the person that we grasp at, the real me that we grasp at, somehow feels something not the body and not the mind. Whenever we talk about me, it has to be in relation to the body or the mind, such as when you put the body in the shower, I am having a shower. Can you have your body outside the shower and have a shower? No. You would never stand outside the shower stall, turn on the shower, and then say, I’m having a shower.
So, somehow, the body and who we are is somehow connected, but we don’t see that. We have this belief that somehow there is a real me that’s something separate. Even though my body is always going along with me, it’s not me. My mind always comes along with me, but it’s not me. So there is this kind of sense of grasping at something independent.
And that that independent person doesn’t exist. It’s just a manufactured by the mind. It’s a hallucination, a wonderfully powerful hallucination, which we believe to be something real, and therefore, we act on again and again. As you’ve heard, I’ll just repeat it again. Just we be repeated several times in this series of talks, but there’s the famous analogy of the snake in the rope.
Right? You know about the snake in the rope. You have a piece of rope in the darkness, coiled multi colored coiled rope. You open the door. It’s dark night.
You walk out. Quickly, your mind is distracted by other things, you look at the colored piece of rope and you think it’s a snake, and you believe it’s a snake. And because of believing it, you react with fear, yell, run off, and so on. Sweat pouring down from the body, panting, my heart beating like crazy, believing, you know, I’ve almost been eaten and bitten and eaten and crushed by this gigantic, terrible snake. And that image appears vividly in the mind.
We’ve all had experiences like this. You know, seeing a stump, a dead tree stump, thinking it’s a person if you’re walking in the country. Seeing a person thinking it’s a dead tree stump. Or, you know, walking in the city street, someone up ahead of you, you think it’s an old friend and you get up close and it’s a complete stranger. Or even just looking at some object and you think, Oh, this is my book and it’s not your book at all.
You take the wrong coat, wrong suitcase, something like that at the airport. The interesting thing about that is that, going back to the rope and the snake, there is this vivid appearance in the mind of a snake. It’s very vividly appearing in the mind, and we believe it completely. We don’t question that we’ve seen a snake, but amazingly, there isn’t a snake there at all. Not at all.
And yet we see one. We definitely see one because that’s also true. We do see a snake that is not there at all. Not even one scale of a snake is there, not even one bit of that forked tongue is there, but we see it vividly in the mind, not there at all. Even more amazing than that, more amazing than that I’m smiling, it’s actually kind of sad.
This is the source of suffering. But what is there, the rope, the rope is there. It is there on the ground. It’s there, but we do not see it at all. Not at all.
It is there, but we don’t see it. What is not there at all, we see and relate to. And point is, this doesn’t just happen seeing a tree trunk as a person. This is what we are doing right now, right now. What we are experiencing right now is not there at all, at all.
And what is here, we are not experiencing. Think about it because it’s time to finish. Sorry, I didn’t get There is something here, it is here, but what is actually the way what is actually here we are not experiencing at all. There is a table here. I am here.
I am here. But the person what you are seeing is not here at all. This table is here, but the table you’re experiencing is not here at all. It’s other than as something created by your mind. In the desert, there are mirages that create the illusion of water.
The mirage is definitely there. It’s definitely there. The appearance of water is definitely there. There’s no doubt about that. The appearance is definitely there, but you can’t drink the water because the water isn’t there at all.
We are all here. This room is here. It’s all here, but it’s not here the way we think. What we’re experiencing is a distortion of what is here. That distortion is something very subtle, but it’s the source of suffering.
And until we change, we will continue to suffer. But we can change. The mind changes. The mind has this amazing ability to unlock this mistake that we’re making, to unravel it and totally destroy it. Just briefly to try and explain this point, why this very subtle thing is the source of all suffering.
Again, you’ve probably all heard this, but I shouldn’t leave you totally, for those who are not familiar, very briefly, is that this very subtle distortion that we have of ourselves creates the illusion, the sense of an independent me. There is me and everything else, quite separate from me, unconnected to me, unrelated to me. Because of that, just naturally there is this little me in the entire universe. There is self and other, this huge dichotomy, this huge duality existing all the time. Therefore, anything that makes this and because this sense of I, this I which we’re grasping at, actually doesn’t have any substance, it has to be something continuously built up because there’s nothing actually there.
The illusion of the snake, the illusion of me has to be built up. So when anything in the external world makes this illusion of I feel stronger, more substantial, more real. I feel happy. I feel good. I feel validated, empowered, and therefore this thing out there that is doing that, it must be good.
It must be beautiful. It must be wonderful. How could anything that is that is, you know, making me good be bad? It’s got to be good from its side. Not not because of anything I’m saying.
It itself must have this essential, truly good true goodness in it, this incredible beauty or goodness. Therefore, we seek it, we chase after it, we desire it, and we get dependent on it, we get attached to it. This disturbing thought of desire attachment arises. Anything that threatens this sense of I makes me feel less real, less substantial, less authentic, and so on. It must be bad.
It must be terrible. It must be ugly from its own side. It really is like that. Therefore, aversion and hate and anger generates another afflicted thought, another disturbing thought arises. Without this wrong view of self, it is utterly impossible to have disturbing thoughts.
If we understand that disturbing thoughts then create all these karmic potentials that then ripen as suffering, we can see how even though this distortion made by our mind is something very subtle, it explodes, it just mushrooms to produce all other disturbing thoughts that continually obscure the fundamental clarity of our mind. The fundamental ability to know things as they are is continuously obscured by following ignorance. We follow ignorance, we see wrong views and we grasp we have false appearances, we grasp unquestionably that they are true and then because of that all the disturbing thoughts arise. And the disturbing thoughts arise from ignorance and they reinforce the ignorance. The reinforced ignorance gives rise to more disturbing thoughts that reinforce the ignorance.
This is saṃsāra. This is the wheel of suffering. This is the wheel of endless confusion. But this can be broken because ignorance doesn’t truly exist. It does it has no reality from its own side because nothing really exists.
This is the whole secret of the Praise to Dependent arising. If none of this talk made any sense, this is all the more reason to come back next week and find out what was he talking about. But just in summary, why Je Tsongkhapa praised Buddha for teaching dependent arising, because it’s one of the great qualities of Je Tsongkhapa’s teachings. Je Tsongkhapa said that to develop this wisdom that realizes the true nature or what is called the empty nature or the Śūnyatā nature of all phenomena is very difficult, is very profound, and so on. But the easiest way to understand it is to understand dependent arising.
If we understand that things arise dependently, we understand that things can’t be independent. And it’s ignorance that creates the view that things seem to be independent. I am independent. Everything and all the qualities of things are independently, separately like that, existing from their own side. This is just an illusion.
It is possible to understand more and more that things exist merely in dependence upon many, many factors. The more we understand that, the more we destroy ignorance. Because ignorance survives in ignorance. It has no power from its own side. It itself is a dependent arising, fortunately.
If it wasn’t a dependent arising, we couldn’t get rid of it. But since it’s not an independent phenomena, it can be eliminated. In the next five talks, we’ll try to go into all of this with some greater clarity and, what, expanding on these things and to go through the verses themselves. I hope some of this made some sense, or if it didn’t make much sense, at least it raised some interest to investigate this most amazing teaching, this most amazing teaching that exists in the universe on the nature of phenomena. The next talk is Monday, so we don’t have much time.
But it’s really good to Tuesday. Tuesday, sorry. Tuesday nights at seven thirty. To start now to try to be more aware how one perceives oneself and phenomena. To try and catch this mind that sees things as existing completely independently from their own side, having their own qualities.
You know, you walk down the street in a shop and you see something beautiful and the mind instantly thinks, this is really beautiful and therefore I want it because it’s so beautiful. But to try to catch them and try to understand that that beauty doesn’t exist from its own side. It appears to. The food seems to taste unbelievably delicious from its own side. The weather seems to be extremely cold from its own side.
That’s how things appear. But could they exist in another way? Maybe things exist in another way. If this thing that I see is so unbelievably beautiful was really like that, if the beauty resided totally in the object, unquestionably in the object, wouldn’t it mean that everybody found that thing beautiful? Because they have eyes, they can see, the thing is really beautiful, unquestionably beautiful.
If this is true, everyone would agree. We would all eat the same things all the time. We would all wear the same clothes because we would all agree that this is the most beautiful thing. This is the most delicious thing. If it was really like that, unquestionably like that, So I’ll stop here.
Do you have some questions? Yeah. We try and meditate on this topic. What are some good things to especially try and develop or or perhaps Well, maybe I I can’t go into this now. Maybe just in in the in the coming weeks, we can do that and sort of do some different things step by step.
Yeah. Yeah. But but, basically, I mean, what what this whole teaching is leading to is to understand that everything is really coming from our mind. This is what dependent arising, the most subtle aspect. You see, I didn’t want is to understand that things are it’s not just out there, but things, what we’re experiencing, are dependent on our mind.
So just to try to be aware of that more and more, that even though it doesn’t appear that way, it doesn’t feel like that, that when something I experience or see something as beautiful or something ugly, to to try to create some space to be aware that some at least some aspect of that beauty or ugliness is my mind saying that. It’s my decision. It’s my concept. This sense of a fixed I is created by ignorance, yes. There is a person that is actually existing, has yeah.
But this person that actually has something, just like the rope, has some existence, But so there there is a person, me, that is existing, of course. But the ignorance creates the illusion, the distortion that this person is some kind of something separate from the body and mind. Yes, that’s part of it. To try and catch it in words is very difficult because we haven’t experienced this yet, directly seen it, even though we grasp at it. It’s something very subtle.
Anyway, we’re just starting, so this was just Like I said, we have slowly, slowly, just make maybe make some sense. Okay. So if you Well, we don’t have this book, unfortunately. It’s all explained. Some of it is explained in here, anyway.
The root text and the commentary is in here. I’ve been requested, I think. Khen Rinpoche wanted all the regular students at the end of each teaching to recite the twenty one praises to Tārā. I think this was to help to make requests to Tārā for the benefit of Buddha House. I think this is the main purpose, isn’t it?
For some specific thing, or just the general well-being and success of Buddha House so that it can benefit many sentient beings, countless sentient beings. It’s on page thirty four.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- real I
- The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.