Dependant Arising 2000 – 09 D A 2000 05 30

44 min · 4,942 words · 30 May 2000

Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Dependant Arising 2000 - 09 D A 2000 05 30
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Commentary on Lama Tsongkhapa’s praise of the Buddha for teaching emptiness through dependent arising, which is presented as the easiest route to understanding emptiness. The talk explains innate ignorance as the root of suffering, the four-point analysis for finding the refuting object of the self, and the middle way between nihilism and inherent existence. It then reasons through why independent or inherently existent phenomena are impossible.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2000-05-30

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 8b96848e-8cdc-4676-97fa-e03b7247479a

Words: 4,942

A verse composed by Lama Tsongkhapa praising the Buddha for teaching emptiness and especially the ultimate nature of all phenomena, particularly praising the Buddha for teaching emptiness through dependent arising, showing how dependent arising is the easiest way to understand emptiness. And when we understand that emptiness, the actual nature of phenomena, develop the wisdom directly experiencing the true nature of phenomena. We’re able to free our mind of ignorance, the ignorance which is the very source of all suffering. So there are many kinds of ignorance from the Buddhist perspective. For example, there’s the ignorance of the law of cause and effect.

Other words, there’s the ignorance of the conventional nature of phenomena, such as the ignorance of the law of cause and effect. And then there’s the ignorance of the ultimate nature of phenomena. So, the ignorance of the law of cause and effect is not the root of saṃsāra, the root cause of suffering. As we discussed before, the fundamental issue of Buddhism is to get rid of suffering so that we can have because the Buddhist argument is and the Buddhist argument and the Buddha’s experience is when you totally eliminate suffering, then perfect happiness comes about. And the suffering has a cause, and this cause has to be found in order to be removed.

So if one doesn’t find the precise cause, then one cannot remove it. One will remove something but not but not completely. Or you may remove the wrong thing and not the right thing. You may remove something which is not the cause of suffering, try and destroy that. And even if you identify some kind of ignorance, if you don’t identify it completely precisely, one won’t be able to eradicate it completely and suffering will go on.

So, although not knowing the law of cause and effect, by not knowing that, believing in it, and living one’s life according to it, of course, by not knowing it, we experience a lot of suffering. But that itself is not the root cause of suffering. The root cause of suffering is this ignorance that does not know and distorts the nature of oneself nor phenomena. So within that ignorance, there is also what is called the intellectually acquired ignorance, and then there is the innate ignorance. So again, the intellectually acquired ignorance is not the root cause of of saṃsāra, the root cause of all suffering.

It is this innate ignorance, this inborn ignorance that exists at all times has always existed. Mind is beginningless, and during this beginningless time, there has been this ignorance existing. It’s always been there, operating. We’re we’re not even aware of it. We don’t consciously generate it.

It’s just there. It colors everything we experience all the time. So, for example, the consciousness of a fetus in the womb has this inborn ignorance. It’s there already. It came from the previous life, from the life before that, going back into beginningless time.

And the cause of that ignorance is simply a previous moment of that same ignorance. It wasn’t created by anybody or anything. It just is there. So this is the ignorance that we have to get rid of, recognizing what it does, what mistakes it makes, recognizing that, and then eliminating it. Very simply, if you take the example of seeing a tree stump in the countryside and thinking it’s a person in some very remote area, and then you’re staying somewhere in a very remote area.

You see a tree stump in the distance and you think it’s a person. And then you tell the person who lives in that area, I saw this person in the distance. And then and so you believe that you’ve seen a human being. You’re completely convinced of that. There isn’t hasn’t been a human being there.

There’s something else altogether, but one is believing there is a human being. So we’re holding that that belief. We don’t question it. We grasp at it as being real. But then the person who knows the area can explain to us that we couldn’t possibly have seen a human being, there’s no one in the area, and so on.

That what you saw where you went for a walk, there’s a tree stump in the distance, and that’s what you saw. Right? So if you trust the person, what they say, and listen to their logic because of this and that, and I’ve seen I know where the tree stump is, and if we go there, you can see it. It’s not a human being. Because of that logic, if you listen to it, that logic will destroy one’s belief and grasping that I saw a trick.

Simple. After you after you listen to the logic, you no longer hold that image in your mind of a person existing there. It’s completely gone. In the same way, ignorance is destroyed. It’s somewhat more difficult, much more difficult.

But basically, what we have to do is that we have to find this ignorance creates the illusion of a truly existing, inherently existing person, a self of persons. There is a person, there is a me, there is I. There is an I who goes to town, who goes to work, who goes to sleep, who drinks tea and coffee or whatever. But on top of that, we create this self of that person, some truly findable being there, something independent that we grasp onto as being really existing. We grasp at that, but right now, we don’t perceive that even though we’re grasping onto it.

It’s a very strange thing. So what we have to do is discover that false appearance that we’re grasping onto. We have to develop a pure, calm mind. We have to purify our mind, accumulate merit, develop concentration in order to find this wrong this self that we believe exists. And this is called finding the refuting object.

This is the most difficult thing in the entire Buddhadharma, probably. Intellectually understanding emptiness is not so difficult. Finding the refuting object correctly is the difficult bit. And then what one does is one is finding, here’s the refuting object in the mind, the truly existing person. You know, there’s the mind believing.

There’s the appearance of a truly existing person, me. Yeah? And the mind is seeing that clearly, the truly existing person that really seems to be there. But then you use your understanding of the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika logic to just pound that view, saying that although it looks like it’s really there from its own side, it’s utterly impossible. It cannot exist.

By doing that again and again with a very clear, undistracted mind, eventually, the mind holding that appearance as true, which is the ignorance, just can’t do it anymore because this other mind is just destroying everything that is making that appear so substantial. So right now, we’re not trying to find the refuting object. We’re just trying to understand something about emptiness and dependent arising. Because when we find the the refuting object someday, one day, we will discover that in words, one can describe it is that this refuting object appears to be an independent phenomenon, existing from its own side. But then dependent on the teachings, say, and we can logically understand, intellectually understand that nothing can exist as an independent phenomenon.

It’s a it’s a total impossibility. Things can only exist as a dependent arising, arising depending on many, many factors. So we we bombard that understanding, that correct understanding against this mind saying, no. No. I truly exist.

I’m independent. I’m really here from my own side. Don’t depend on anything. But if we bombard with the right logic, clear logic again and again and again and again, then don’t don’t don’t don’t, nothing. Nothing.

No ignorance. And therefore, no basis for and all the negative karma we’ve created in the past cannot ripen. There’s no basis for it to ripen and produce suffering. Basically, quite simple, what we have to do. But it’s important to understand that realising emptiness, really, realising it, is not just an intellectual exercise.

One part of it is, in a sense, an intellectual exercise of using one’s intelligence to understand the logic of of the of the teachings of of the middle way. But we have to find the refuting object. And in order to find the refuting object precisely, we have to purify the mind. This this mind we have now, no matter how intelligent it is and sophisticated, whatever it is, this mind, as it is now, is not subtle enough to find. It’s a very subtle, refuting object.

We need to purify the mind, accumulate merit, develop more concentration. So all these things have to come together. And, of course, in the process of doing all these things, we have to depend on the guru, the perfect guru. Maybe I should just mention, probably you all know this anyway, but it just reminds me, is how to find a refuting object. At least we can try and start doing this now.

Doing some meditation on this in our daily life from time to time. And in the teachings, it explains that basically what one tries to do is to remember at a time what is called one way of meditating on emptiness, as you probably know, is called a four point analysis. It’s one of the three worthwhile ways to try and meditate on emptiness, the emptiness of the person. And the first point is finding a refuting object, trying to find a refuting object. And the basic method of doing that is trying to remember a time.

I’m trying to, it should be pretty easy remembering a time when, for example, one got very angry because in those moments or when one was extremely afraid, because when one is very angry or very frightened, then the sense of I appears very strongly. The I and grasping at it appears very strongly. For example, a time when one was insulted or felt accused of something that one felt unjustly accused of. And in those times, the sense of I, you know, I didn’t do this. How could you say this to me?

You know, the sense when there’s fear, the sense of I is very strong. Appears more vividly. It’s always there, but at some times, it appears, arises more vividly. Or, for example, also, it may work for it depends on our personality of a time when we were extremely happy. Also, for example, when someone praises us, says, How beautiful or handsome or how this or that you are, then again, the sense of I arises very strongly.

So one tries to remember just one of those instances in one meditation, try to think of one incident, you know, one powerful emotional incident, and try to catch what the sense of I and the tree stumpy thing is, the skill is to, at the one time, to remember the instant so the sense of I arises, but also you shouldn’t get caught into remembering that instant. You know. You have to remember the incident without getting just, oh, yes, and that happened, and I hate that person. Remember the incident so you but then bring the mind to the sense of I, what what did I appear like, feel like at that time. And then with one part of the mind, you try to look at that I.

What was that I that was so so happy, so afraid, so so angry? Was it my body? Was it my mind? Was it part of my mind? Was it both my body and mind together as some interesting kind of soup?

Was it something else? Did it feel, look like something else? This is not easy to do, but we can train to try to do this. Even in our daily life, we can try and catch the sense of I. Even when you’re eating, sometimes you can try and catch the sense of who is eating this?

Who is doing that? Whatever action you can do, you can try and suddenly stop and ask yourself, who is this I that is doing this? But, of course, the this way is when one is doing it in informal meditation with a very quiet mind, undistracted mind trying to do that. I’ll just briefly mention the other points of the analysis. I won’t go into them now, but the next point in the analysis is ascertaining the pervasion.

So we have to understand that if this I that we believe in truly exists the way we believe it to be, the way it appears and feels to us, it either has to be completely oneness with the five aggregates, that is the body and mind, it either has to be the body, the five aggregates, or some aspect of the five aggregates, or it has to be something completely separate from the five aggregates. There’s no other choice. We have to come to an understanding that there’s no other possibility. If I, the person that we believe in, really exists, it has to be inherently connected, totally related to the five aggregates in some way or completely separate, having absolutely nothing to do with the five aggregates. This is called the law of the excluded middle.

It’s either this or that. There can’t be any alternative. We have to come to some understanding of that, that I I have to be this body and mind, or I’m something completely different from the body and mind. And there’s no other possibility. Right.

So then that then the the next point is then to check whether I am I am the body or the mind. Am I the body? Am I the mind? Am I both? Am I all of my body, part of my body?

Am I all of my mind, part of my mind? Am I both my body and mind? One checks in relation to that instant one is remembering. And then one also can check the other one. If I’m not the body and mind, then what is the I?

If I’m not the physic this body, take away the body. I’m not that. I’m not the mind. What am I? And where am I?

So it’s quite good to do this meditation even now. It’s quite helpful to train to do this kind of meditation. But especially the more we actually understand the logic of the Mādhyamika meditation, the more we train in that, this meditation becomes more and more effective. And of course, in that meditation, the key point is this one of trying to check out whether I’m the body, mind, or that. Because it’s fairly easy to see, actually, isn’t it?

If we take away the body, I’m not my body, and I’m not my mind, then what am I? I am sitting here. Right? Right? Everyone right now is thinking, I am sitting here.

We’re all sitting. So we’re all thinking, I am sitting here. But if you take away the body, it’s sitting here. And since the mind is associated with the body, so you take away the mind as well. Because the mind doesn’t sit right.

Minds don’t sit. Can you see a mind sitting somewhere? Any free cushions with a mind sitting on you? So if you take away the body and the mind, it’s not sitting here. What’s sitting here?

The only reason we say I am sitting here is because the five aggregates are here sitting. Or at least one of them is sitting. The first aggregates are sitting here. That’s something to think about, to worry about. So in finding the refuting object, the problem is that in one case, we can refute too much.

We go to one extreme saying, Oh, there’s nothing at all. There’s not even a conventional I. You can totally refute that. So that goes to the extreme of nihilism. And on the other hand, we don’t refute enough.

And that’s falling into the extreme of true existence. There’s something really here. Well, maybe I’m not actually like I think I am, but I still, even so, I’m really here. So we have to find the Mādhyamika, the middle way between those two extremes of refuting too much and not refuting enough. Because if we refute too much, then we refute the person that actually does do good things, creates good karma, we refute the person that creates negative karma.

If we refute too much, we refute the whole basis of observing the law of cause and effect in daily life. We refute that if I don’t exist, then other people don’t exist, really, then I can do anything. So we refute everything, we can refute too much. So that’s very dangerous. But also there is a danger of not refuting enough, because if we don’t refute enough, we haven’t found the actual refuting object, the actual root cause of suffering.

So by doing this kind of meditation, starting trying to do this now, we can start to peel off the layers of ignorance about ourselves that we have. Because, for example, at some points, we do believe I am the body. When we look in the mirror and think, I am so ugly, or I am so beautiful, I am so incredibly attractive, or whatever, when we look at that and do that, or someone says those things to us and we feel, oh, yes, that’s me for sure. At those points, we are definitely identifying with the body. But at other points, we identify ourselves as being the mind.

We change. And we can start to see that. And as we really start to see that, like, really feel it, notice it, how deeply we do that, then we can start to shake this, you know, we can start to be really aware of it that we’re grasping at many things. But even though we grasp at these many things, as I tried to say before, deep down there’s something even more subtle that we grasp. I thought I was the body, but I’m not.

But I’m really here. I’m really here, and we grasp to that. We still grasp, I’m really here, solid, somehow I’m really real. And that thing we’re grasping onto feels to be something independent, not a dependent arising. So in verse thirteen, says, understanding dependent arising as you taught is well praised.

Things are not totally nonexistent nor are they inherently existent. So totally nonexistent is the extreme of one extreme that we could go to, And the other extreme is that things are inherently existing. So of these two extremes, the one of believing things don’t exist at all is not the root of saṃsāra. That’s more an intellectually acquired view that we can fall into, and there are some philosophical schools that have arisen in India and also in the West that argue that nothing exists, that there’s kind of nothing? If nothing exists, who is arguing that there’s nothing existing?

Something that doesn’t exist is arguing that things don’t exist. So in sense, this view intellectually is not such a problem. The main problem is the one of believing inherent existence, which is what we have all the time, this belief in inherent existence. So then in the next verse it goes on to say, The independent, that is independently existing things, the independent is like a sky flower, therefore nothing is not dependent. Existence by its own nature precludes establishment by causes and conditions.

So to say the independence is like a sky flower, the sky flower doesn’t exist. There are not flowers floating in the sky. There’s no such thing as a sky flower. So to say something is independent is saying it’s a sky flower because an independent phenomena simply cannot exist, something truly independent. You know, we talk about countries becoming independent.

Australia is an independent country, or we want it to be a republic so it can be a truly independent republic. But, of course, I mean, conventionally, you have independent countries, but no country is independent at all. We depend on trade, people coming here, food and trading and so on. There’s no country in the world, even those like Burma, that try to cut themselves off, that are totally independent. And anyway, Burma, even if it even if it economically and politically cuts itself off, still it’s part of Southeast Asia and there are rivers flowing into it from other countries and so on.

And the weather comes from elsewhere. It’s not an independent country, right? The wind, the sun, you know, it’s dependent on those things. So if you really think about it, I mean, what we think about it as independent is a very, very relative term. So if you try to conceive of an actually totally independent phenomena that does not depend on anything whatsoever, is impossible to exist.

This is Buddhist argument logic. It would also be permanent, it couldn’t function. It could an independent phenomena could have no relationship of any kind with anything else. Because as soon as you have some relationship, some contact, there is change, there is interaction. But if something interacts, it’s no longer independent.

An independent phenomena could have no contact, even the tiniest, tiniest, momentary contact with anything. Nothing could happen to an independent phenomena. Absolutely nothing. It would be totally, permanently the same all the time with no connection with anything, not even a tiny mote of dust. Because even if one mote of dust landed on this independent phenomenon, it would then become a dusty one.

It would have changed. Right? An independent phenomenon cannot exist. But that’s how also, again, I try when we see this ignorance that we have, the way we perceive it, you know, the words that are used, ourselves, phenomena appear to be truly existing, inherently existing, existing from their own side. So if this was true, it would mean we are independent, phenomena are independent.

Because when we actually the way ignorance works, ignorance doesn’t actually create the appearance of independence. Like, when we look at each other, we do have some understanding, experience, that there’s some dependency there, that there’s not total independence at one level. But at the same time, our ignorance is perceiving things as truly existing. So, if things were truly existing, they would have to be independent. If they truly existed with their own characteristics, they would have to be independent.

We’re not actually seeing things this is anyway, we’re not actually seeing things as independent, but the way we see things would mean they are independent. So this is why the logic of dependent arising is helpful. Because the logic of dependent arising destroys the idea that anything could be independent. And by doing that, it then shows that the way we see things cannot possibly be true. So independence is like a sky flower, therefore there is not one thing that is not dependent, everything is dependent.

Existence by its own nature or with its own nature precludes establishment by causes and conditions. The way we perceive things as existing by their own nature, having their own qualities, if that was true, then nothing could arise in dependence on causes and conditions. When we see something as beautiful, it appears to have that beauty exists from its own side. That beauty it is the own nature of that phenomena to be beautiful. Right?

But if that is true, that thing could not exist depending on causes and conditions. But, for example, when you turn out the light and it’s all black, you can’t see the thing. You can’t see the beauty of the object. So the beauty depends on causes and conditions. And if it’s in a bad light, it’s not as beautiful.

I mean, just some simple points to show that things everything that we’re experiencing is arising depending on causes and conditions. Even though it appears in one way, if we investigate. And if this thing was really beautiful from its own side, of course, it would have a fixed beauty. The beauty would be fixed in one particular way. But even though, you know, if you change the lighting, the thing may still remain beautiful, but it’s beautiful in different ways.

And you could say, well, I like it with this kind of lighting, I don’t like it quite so much with that lighting. Because when you have that lighting like that, this bit sparkles and that bit doesn’t, and this color comes out and and so on. But if the thing was really beautiful from its own side, it would be fixed and permanent and wouldn’t depend on different things, like the angle you looked at it, the lighting, this and that. And, of course, if this thing was beautiful from its own side, However however long you looked at it, it would always be beautiful. You sit in front of it for a hundred years, and you would always think it’s totally beautiful.

But we have noticed that our mind changes. Where is the hairdo of twenty three years ago? The fashions, you know. I once had a hair, went down here, and I knew I was never ever going to cut my hair. Never ever.

So the mind changes. So what you know, a beauty depends on our mind also, seeing it that way. Seeing that this is this is perfect, exactly what I want, that our mind changes. If we listen to our favorite piece of music constantly for seventy two hours, it would drive us insane, probably. It would no longer appear so attractive, so pleasant.

But if it truly existed from its own side, it would always be like that. We have an expression that absence makes the heart grow fonder. Depending on causes and conditions, things appear in certain ways. Thus it is taught that because nothing exists other than the dependently arisen, there is no existing thing which is not empty of inherent existence. So because something depends on something, such as it can depend on causes and conditions, or it can depend on parts, or it can depend on the mind itself, or it does depend on the mind in itself, because of that, all existing things are empty of inherent existence.

They’re existing, but they’re empty of inherent existence, of existing from their own side, having their own inherent qualities, their own independent qualities. So since inherent nature has no end, you said nirvana would be impossible, so you as the Buddha. Since so if there was inherent existence, there isn’t, but if there was, if there was inherent existence, then nothing would come to an end because inherent existence means permanent. So if if our suffering truly existed the way it appears to us from our side, it would never come to an end. And therefore, nirvana, the extinction of suffering, would be impossible.

If phenomena had any inherent existence, I think this next word is a spelling error or something, a printing error. I think it should be our, not for. O u r, our elaborations could not be stopped. Here, you know, elaborations is referring to our all our afflicted thoughts, afflicted minds, all our concepts, and so on. If phenomena had any inherent nature, our elaborations could not be stopped.

Therefore, who can challenge him who in assemblies of the wise has clearly proclaimed with lion’s roar freedom from inherent existence. Everything is free of inherent existence. And because of that, everything is possible. Liberation is impossible is possible. Enlightenment is possible because nothing inherently exists.

It it it the only way things exist is dependently, either depending on causes and conditions, depending on parts, and especially everything depending on the mind and the labeling of the mind. So it goes on to say, since the lack of inherent nature and the ability to function do not contradict, never mind the dependent arising and emptiness coexist. So what this is referring to is that the people who the non Buddhists who argue against the Buddhist view of dependent arising are saying that If things didn’t inherently exist, nothing would exist at all, and therefore nothing would function, nothing could happen. But the Buddhist argument is the very opposite. If things inherently existed from their own side, nothing could things would be independent and they couldn’t exist at all, they couldn’t function, they couldn’t inter react, nothing could happen.

Things wouldn’t change. It’s because things are dependently arising and therefore not inherently existing that things can actually exist and function and interrelate. So don’t worry, never mind, that dependent and arising and emptiness coexist. They don’t contradict. They actually function together.

They coexist. Because things arise dependently, they are empty of any true existence. And because things are empty of true existence, all things are able to arise depending on various factors. By the reason of dependent oh, sorry. So by the reason of dependent arising, there are no grounds for extreme views.

For this fine teaching, oh protector, your speech is unexcelled. Nāgārjuna and all the great Buddhist scholars have argued that understanding dependent arising actually refutes all the wrong views, the extremes of things truly existing and the extreme that things don’t exist at all. And the way this is done is that the view of dependent arising refutes extreme of

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top