1 h 29 min · 3,598 words · 6 May 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaches that abandoning the ten non-virtues can lead to full enlightenment, liberation or a higher rebirth, depending on whether the motivation is free from self-cherishing and self-grasping. Covers the middling-scope path from the Lamrim, the human sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death, then answers questions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 8d7a53f9-8575-4458-a71a-74da6627cdc1
Date: 2015-05-06
Words: 3,594
As is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s, the stages of the path, all of the sutras and the shastras were uttered for the sake of taming the mind. Whatever virtue one accrues, if the mind is unsubdued, liberation will not be attained. This is said in Lamrim Chenmo, but the source is elsewhere and was frequently quoted by the holy elder. So when it is said that all virtues of body and speech, should the mind be unsubdued, do not lead to the liberation.
What is to be understood in this case by all virtues of body and speech is, for instance, relinquishing the 10 non virtues and training in the 10 virtuous deeds which we studied already. When reference is made to the mind being unsubdued, this means that the mind is subject to the afflictions. The mind can be subjected to the afflictions under the influence of either self-cherishing or self grasping, the grasping at a self. Then if we reflect carefully, we can see that in dependence on one single category of deeds, the relinquishing of the 10 non virtues or the training in the 10 virtues, three totally different results can be obtained. And these three totally different results can be obtained independent exclusively on the motivation.
One can either obtain full enlightenment, or one can obtain liberation, or one can obtain a higher rebirth. Then for ourselves, we always think that full enlightenment, or for that matter, liberation, are very far removed and very distant. But if we reflect carefully, we can see that their root, which is the roots of virtue of an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, that is something which is quite close to us, which we may even have now. The cause for full enlightenment is bodhicitta. One of the causes for the attainment of liberation is the realization of emptiness.
But even if we are unable to generate these causes, nonetheless we are able to train in an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. One way of looking at it is if we take the ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues and engage in what is to be abandoned and what is to be trained in unmistakenly. And do this without contaminating this ethics with the slightest thought of self-cherishing. self-cherishing here means egoism, thinking of oneself. Then it is definite that this ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues will act as a cause for full enlightenment.
When we say not falling under the sway of self-cherishing, ideally, self-cherishing would be totally eradicated from our mind stream and we would never fall under its sway. But if that is not possible, at the very least, we should prevent ourselves contingently from falling under its sway by reflecting on its faults. When we see the faults of self-cherishing as faults and engage in an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtue, this ethics becomes a cause for full enlightenment. Now, how does an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues become a cause for liberation? Should such an ethics be unrelated in any way to self grasping, to grasping at itself, then it is definite that an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues will become a cause for liberation.
Abandoning self grasping is difficult, but we can counter it through seeing the thoughts of self grasping, seeing its thoughts as thoughts. Finally, how does an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues become a cause for a higher rebirth When such an ethics is totally unmixed with the preoccupations of this life, is in other words unrelated to the affairs of this life, it becomes a cause for a higher rebirth. As is said, there is no cause for a higher rebirth other than ethics and this is the ordinary sense of the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. Then what if this ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues was mixed with the preoccupations of this life. I am not sure one could speak in that case of an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues.
And instead of being a cause for a higher rebirth, it will become a cause for a lower rebirth. We can therefore see that the same root of virtue, the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues can in function of the motivation become a cause for full enlightenment, a cause for liberation, a cause for a higher rebirth or a cause for a lower rebirth. One might think it would be quite straightforward for such an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues to therefore become a cause for full enlightenment. This is not easy because such an ethics must be completely unrelated to self-cherishing. There are, as is explained in Lamrim, two reasons for which the stages of the path of the being of the small, of the middling and of the great scope must be trained in incrementally.
And the first reason is that it is obvious that for instance, the path of the being of the small scope leads into the path of the being of the middling scope which leads into the path of the being of the great scope. And one can only hope to attain full enlightenment through training in a fully characterized path of the being of the great scope. The second reason is to counter the pride of those who think it is unnecessary for me to practice the path of the being of the small and the middling scope. I am more than qualified to start immediately with the path of the being of the great scope. To generate a fully characterized path of the being of the great scope within one’s mental continuum, it is necessary to generate a fully characterized path of the being of the middling scope within one’s continuum.
To generate a fully characterized path of the being of the middling scope, it is necessary to generate a fully characterized path of the being of the small scope. Now why is such a fully characterized path of the being of the small scope necessary to enter in the path of the being of the middling scope? Because the essence of the path of the being of the middling scope is seeing the faults of self grasping. The relationship between the path of the middling and the path of the being of the small scope becomes evident when we reflect that the foremost object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope is self grasping. To be able to abandon self grasping, one must see the faults of self grasping.
These faults become evident when we realize that self grasping is the cause of the afflictions and the afflictions themselves are the cause of the 10 non-virtues, which are the main object of abandonment of the being of the small scope. So we can see that the two scopes are intimately related. A doubt might arise when one starts practicing the path of the being of the middling scope. After all, my focus is on the faults of self grasping. And all the training of the path of the being of the small scope has actually gone to waste and is no longer used.
This is not the case in the slightest. Since to focus on the thoughts of self grasping means to have focused on the thoughts of the afflictions which arise from it. And to focus on the faults of the afflictions means to have focused on the faults of the 10 non virtuous deeds. Therefore, everything is intimately connected. Do you understand?
Really? That’s good, thank you. And therefore, through understanding that the 10 non virtues are faults and for that matter are grievous faults. We understand their defects and realize that the ethics of an abandonment of the 10 non virtues can lead in function of the motivation to three fundamentally different goals. It can lead to full enlightenment, it can lead to liberation, or it can lead to a higher rebirth.
At present, since the topic of this teaching is the path of the being of the middling scope, the question which arises is how can our verbal and physical deeds become causes for liberation. This is not easy to understand. But if our verbal and physical virtues, the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues in other words, are completely uncontaminated by grasping at a self, then they will definitely become a cause for liberation. Now, the intent of the Lamrim is none other than to indicate that physical and verbal virtues become causes for liberation when they are not mixed in the slightest with self grasping. How is it possible to generate an abandonment of self grasping?
It is possible through understanding the faults of self grasping. How is it possible to understand the faults of self grasping? It is possible to understand the faults through the afflictions which arise from it. What is the definition of an affliction? Asaṇga in his Abhidharmasamuccaya says afflictions are mental factors whose function is to give rise to unsuitable states of mind.
And we can see for ourselves that this is a case for anger and for envy. So how do we see the thoughts of grasping at a self? Through seeing the thoughts of the afflictions which arise from it, such as anger and envy, through seeing their faults as faults. Having studied the Lamrim, it should be evident to us that when afflictions which are extremely faulty arise in as much as these afflictions are effects, they arise from a cause and in as much as they are faulty, their cause also must be faulty. So if anger and envy are profoundly defective faulty states of mind, then the grasping at a self which they arise from must also be a faulty defective state of mind.
And indeed grasping at a self is a mistaken state of mind. It is a state of mind whose mode of apprehension is mistaken. It is extremely important to be able to prevent self grasping from arising within our mind stream even for one hour. And this is possible through seeing its faults as faults and through understanding how to eradicate it. Within our mind stream, there is anger, there is hatred, there is jealousy and envy arisen from self grasping.
It is nonsense to say that these afflictions are not present within our mind stream. Then instead of saying they are not present, we should struggle against them and fight to prevent against falling under their sway. How is this done? This is done through studying the Lamrim and meditating. It is important for us, for instance, not to fall under the sway of anger.
Because if we fall under the sway of anger, we would engage in inappropriate physical and verbal deeds. So as not to fall under the sway of anger, we must apply the antidotes to anger. And this covers this initial presentation. So for today, let us generate the motivation that the 10 virtuous deeds which we engage in will not themselves fall under the sway of self grasping and in that way will become the causes for liberation. Let us generate this motivation through meditation.
As said, is vital to become master of one’s mind. And in this context, even if one is striving for liberation, which is a state of durable and lasting happiness. Nonetheless, it is important while striving for liberation to master one’s mind. All of us want to be happy. This is clearly explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra.
It is the means of establishment of happiness we do not begin to understand. It is not mere physical material happiness, but a happiness from within the innermost depths of one’s mind which one should be aiming for. And for this one must counter, one must target the afflictions. Now moving onwards within the outline of the path of being of the middling scope in Kyabje Pabongkha’s, Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand. The outline is subdivided into two.
The means of generating a mind wishing for liberation from cyclic existence and ascertaining the means to attain liberation from cyclic existence. The latter is subdivided into two, a presentation of the Four Noble Truths and a presentation of the 12 links of dependent origination. The presentation of the four noble truths is subdivided into four, beginning with the presentation of the noble truth of suffering. This in turn is subdivided into two, the presentation of the general sufferings of cyclic existence and of the specific sufferings of cyclic existence. Now within the presentation of the specific sufferings of cyclic existence, meditation on the sufferings of the lower realms, being sufferings has been completed within the context of the path of the being of the small scope.
At present, during the path of the being of the middling scope, one meditates on the sufferings of these three higher realms, the realm of human beings, of demigods and of gods. So within the presentation of the specific sufferings of cyclic existence, the suffering specific to human beings, which we ourselves know well, the following. The suffering of birth, of aging, of disease, of death, the suffering of being separated from the pleasant and of encountering the unpleasant. And the suffering of striving for items one seeks for and being unable to get them. So regarding the first suffering, the suffering of birth, this is a suffering which we have forgotten, but which was well nigh and horrible.
When we were in our mother’s womb, if she drank hot or cold liquids, we were either scalded or freezing. When she walked and moved around, we felt as if a powerful wind tossed us left and right. And when she lay down to sleep, we felt as if a huge mountain was crushing us. I suspect the mothers among you understand this. Us, we don’t understand this.
When a child is born, the child cries. The child cries because in the birth process the child’s delicate skin is or feels as if it were being flayed. Likewise, when the mother talks to her child, her sweet words sound like a roaring torrent. And when she carries her child gently, he feels as if he’s being tossed around. Probably we ourselves have no understanding of these sensations.
In the suffering of old age, we have direct experience of. As one grows older, one’s hair turns white and one dyes it. Then if one is unlucky, one goes bald. One’s eyebrows wrinkle and one is bent over. In my case, my hair never turned white.
There was little to start with, and it seems to have been white from the mother’s womb onwards. Just joking. Then from age 39 or 40, we have first hand experience of the suffering of old age. A clear sign that someone has direct personal experience of the suffering of old age occurs when you ask them, after all how old are you? And they act really coy and they say, oh, not more than 35.
Then, when they are 40, they say they are 35. When they’re 50, they say they are 45. The older they get, the younger they become. This is a clear sign of the fear of their impending death. They are afraid of death.
There’s nothing which can be done about this. This is the nature of cyclic existence. All living beings experience the suffering of old age. Then I will not enter into detail about the suffering of sickness and disease. You understand it from your own experience.
And as for the suffering of death, this is something we should reflect on a little bit by ourselves. So Geshe Potowa, a Kadampa Geshe said, it is indeed the nature of cyclic existence to be like this. But we should try to find what the causes of these unwanted sufferings are. Then it is very helpful for us to think that this is the nature of cyclic existence. This tends to put our mind at ease.
Otherwise, we think that we ourselves and ourselves all alone are experiencing these sufferings and no one else ever does, the mind becomes very upset and very tight. So it’s important to put our mind at ease in this way. Then we shall stop here for tonight. At present, I will take your questions. Please make them simple and easy to understand.
It is said that the cause for a human rebirth is stainless ethics conjoined with stainless uncontaminated prayers. It is these stainless uncontaminated prayers in my opinion, which are the way in which dharma benefits at the time of death. Bema? Thank you. I may have heard this wrong.
I may not have heard it correctly. If if I heard that if the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues is mixed with concern for this life, Once the ethics of the abandonment of the non virtues is focused on this life, it ceases to be virtue. And at that point, it becomes a cause for a lower rebirth. So restraining from killing Should there be such a thing as abandoning killing only for the sake of this life, it would not be virtue. Depends on the motivation.
We need the motivation. And, Nada? Yeah. That’s a very good question. Basically, the absence of self-cherishing does not imply necessarily the presence of bodhicitta.
But in the context of the topic being discussed, if one generates a mind which is bereft of self-cherishing during one hour and engages in an ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues for the sake of others, Although this is not bodhicitta, it definitely is altruism and it acts as a cause for full enlightenment. If it was a case that virtuous deeds would become a cause for full enlightenment only if actual bodhicitta was generated, almost nobody would ever attain full enlightenment. Likewise, if it was a case that for a virtuous seed to become a cause for liberation, the elimination of self grasping was necessary, then likewise almost nobody would ever attain liberation. What is necessary for it to become a cause for full enlightenment is that wish in the absence of self-cherishing. Natalie.
No, they are quite different. The thought of relinquishing over and again one’s body is the thought of abandoning one’s body over and again at the time of death and so forth. The thought of being conceived over and again is the thought of being conceived under the influence of karma and affliction over and again. Another? In the Lamrim, it is said that self-cherishing is evidenced by the incapacity to give up one’s body, in other words, one’s life.
Grasping of the self or self grasping on the other hand is a consciousness. Arhats have eliminated self grasping. They have not eliminated self-cherishing. There are numerous types of self-cherishing. There is, for instance, the self-cherishing which is grasping at prominence under the sway of self grasping.
There is a self-cherishing which is There is the second, which is self-cherishing under the sway of self grasping. And there is also established basis under the sway of self-cherishing. What is the last part of your question? No, definitely that third instance of a being who, for the sake of future lives, abandons non virtue and trains in virtue is a motivation under the sway of self-cherishing. Definitely.
Alperma? Second. Yes. I have a doubt, and it’s about what I asked before. Of the 10 non virtuous.
If ethical behavior is not virtuous unless one abandons attachment to this life, then it would seem to follow that no one who does not believe in rebirth can engage in virtue. No, definitely. The abandonment of the 10 non-virtues in the mental continuum of a being who has not relinquished attachment to the vanities of this life is virtue. The abandonment of the 10 non-virtues in the mental continuum of a being who has not abandoned attachment to the vanities of this life is virtue. It is virtue.
Is virtue. Yeah. Yes. 100%. If it were the case that virtue could only be accumulated if one had relinquished attachment to the vanities of this life, almost nobody could accumulate virtue.
This is a good question. It is a question which is indicative that you are reflecting on the meaning of what is said. There is a big difference between someone who thinks only of this life and does not think at all of future lives in the slightest, and someone who even though he or she has not been able to relinquish attachment to the vanity of these this life, nonetheless does think of future lives. In the case of the first, the abandonment of the 10 non virtue should it be possible would only lead to a lower rebirth. In the case of the second, it would lead to a higher rebirth.
What we can say is within the mental continuum of a being who has not relinquished the attachment to the vanities of this life, all virtue can be present. It will not be powerful virtue and it will not be pure virtue. Another? It’s an appropriate question, but there’s no necessary entailment. To attain direct realization of emptiness, one must have the realization of a path of preparation.
Thank you. Good question. [Recording ends].
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If ethical behavior is not virtuous unless one abandons attachment to this life, does that mean people who don't believe in rebirth cannot practise virtue?
No. Abandoning the ten non-virtues is virtue even in the mental continuum of someone who has not relinquished attachment to the vanities of this life. If virtue could only be accumulated after relinquishing that attachment, almost nobody could accumulate virtue. There is, however, a big difference between someone who thinks only of this life and not at all of future lives, and someone who has not relinquished attachment to this life but does think of future lives. For the first, abandoning the ten non-virtues would only lead to a lower rebirth; for the second, it would lead to a higher rebirth.