1 h 32 min · 4,017 words · 1 July 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk argues that future lives should be held as a conviction grounded in reasoning and repeated study, not bare belief, since this reduces fear at death. It explains that only dharma practice helps at death, that fear comes from attachment to physical happiness and to the body, and that the mind should be turned inward. A question and answer session follows, touching on subtle consciousness after death.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: 0d7d9489-4ddf-47a0-a8c8-2a7c394f305a
Date: 2015-07-01
Words: 4,013
When we speak of Dharma, Dharma can be seen as the means to purify the mind or alternatively as a means of benefiting future lives. In this life, future lives become very important and a belief in future lives very relevant to oneself. When we speak of future lives, what we are speaking about is one’s own future lives. In other words, one’s own or the continuance of one’s own mental continuum. Regarding future lives, obviously, we say they exist.
And if we are asked, we say, yes. Yes. They do exist. But should we be asked what is their mode of existence, this calls for some reflection. Then when we speak of past and future lives, clearly past lives are behind us and are over.
Future lives are in front of us and are yet to come. When we compare relative importance of our present life and our future lives, if we analyze carefully, it is obvious that our present life at best will last one hundred years or so, and it is difficult to reach the age of 100. Future lives are immeasurable. Therefore, from the standpoint of duration and of importance, clearly future lives are more important than this life. As far as past and future lives are concerned, clearly future lives are in front of us.
But past lives which are in the past can actually be or their existence can be established rationally. It is clear that there are numerous children and people who have clear verified memories of previous lives. It therefore would seem that an understanding of future lives is extremely important. So how should future lives be understood in terms of the uninterrupted continuum of our mind, of our thoughts, of our consciousness? However, here when we speak of consciousness or mind, it is not the coarse consciousness or mind which is profoundly rooted in our body, which is has our form as foundation and includes the sense consciousnesses.
Such coarse consciousnesses will cease. What does continue is a subtle form of mind or consciousness. This is something we can understand through the metaphor of sleep. We know that when we fall into a deep sleep, all consciousness seems to be interrupted. There is no thought.
And this we know because a sign of someone not having fallen into a deep sleep is precisely the presence of conceptions, of fancies, of thoughts, and so forth. So when this is present, the person is not sleeping. Then we also know after waking up from our night that we can, it’s not the case for everyone, but most of us can remember dreams often very clearly. Now, these dreams are actually a manifestation of a subtle consciousness, a dream consciousness, to which, we have no access during the waking state, but which is nonetheless present. Then clearly, there is in the waking state, there are in the waking state subtle consciousnesses such as the dream consciousness to which we have no access and which we cannot control in the waking state.
Using this as a metaphor or a simile, we can see likewise that when consciousness, the coarse consciousnesses cease at death, there can remain subtle consciousnesses. Now this is not the dream consciousness we are referring to. There are numerous subtle consciousnesses. So clearly, to be able to control such a subtle consciousness which arises within the death process, it will be necessary for us to study numerous texts and again train our minds for this. It will not be possible just adventitiously.
This is something to which extensive reference is made in secret mantra. In addition, there are numerous cases of great beings who have accomplished the key points of the teachings who can remain after death present in their bodies in these subtle states of consciousness for one, two, or even three weeks. Then in our cases at present, our consciousness is heavily mixed with sensory consciousnesses. And I suspect that these are profoundly related to the brain and its neurological substratum. Whether there is anything else than this for those consciousnesses, I don’t know.
Then there is tremendous benefit, in this context in the study of the graduated stages of the path of the Lamrim. And this is a case because it leads one to an understanding and to a conviction in the existence of future lives, and this is of great benefit at the time of death since certainly for, almost all of us, the greatest fear in this life is death. It is critical that this conviction in the existence of future lives be based on reason and on logic and not on mere conviction. Otherwise, if we just say future lives exist, they exist, I’m quite sure of this, then all it takes is for someone who is rather forceful to come along and say, that’s absolute nonsense. There’s no such thing for for us to start wondering, are there future lives at all?
So such a conviction is not stable. We need a conviction based on reasoning. In most Buddhist countries in the world, people are intimately convinced of the existence of past and future lives. But this is an irrational ungrounded conviction. And when one asks simple people, in other words, people who haven’t studied, so what precisely were your past lives?
One gets the strangest of answers. And when one asks them what precisely are the future lives you’re talking about? One gets very odd responses as well. So our goal should be to generate a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, which is based on repeated study and reflection. This stable conviction in the existence of future lives, will be of tremendous benefit at the time of death since with such a stable conviction, there will be very little, if any, fear.
The example I gave previously applies. If you think of someone standing on a building and having to jump down to the ground, if after checking the distance, the person thinks they can probably make it without being killed upon landing, there will not be as much fear as otherwise. On the other hand, the majority of those who do not accept the existence of past and future lives, will experience great fear at the time of death. Since they do not have the slightest idea of what is going to happen, and they think that their consciousness is like a string which is going to be severed, and there will be nothing whatsoever after. So they are akin to someone who is standing on top of a very high cliff and who must jump.
But when he looks down, he doesn’t see anything, and he doesn’t know how far he will fall and what chances there are of surviving. Then there will be great fear. Then it is said, it is actually the third root of meditation on death and impermanence, that at the time of death, only Dharma will be of benefit. Why is this the case? Precisely for this reason.
Why is there such fear in the mind of ordinary beings at the time of death? It is due to the extraordinary level of attachment to this life with which they have tremendous habituation and to the fear of losing it. So, therefore, dharma is that which is of benefit at the time of death and nothing else. And it is said that at the time of death, the being of supreme capacity is delighted. The being of middling capacity experiences no fear, and the being of the lowest capacity has no anxiety.
Now the absence of fear in the being of the middling capacity probably refers to someone who has relinquished this life. Then when it is said that at the time of death nothing is of benefit apart from dharma, the dharma which is referred to here does not refer to reciting your prayers. I am not terribly sure that if you were to recite your commitments out loud during the death process, this would be of any particular benefit. Dharma instead is that process of transformation of the mind. Why, therefore, is there such profound fear at the time of death?
This is due to our deep attachment to this life. What precisely does deep attachment to this life come from? As I mentioned previously, all the deeds we engage in, we engage in in the pursuit of happiness. But there are two types of happiness. There is physical and mental happiness.
And in our cases, we consider that the only happiness which exists is physical happiness and that is the only one we strive for. So when we speak of physical happiness, we are referring to the sensation of happiness induced by the five doors. In other words, happiness which is related to the sensory consciousnesses, not just the happiness of our physical shape. Do you understand the, sensory consciousnesses of the five doors? In other words, the visual consciousness, the auditory, olfactory, gustatory, and tactile consciousnesses.
Is this something you have to gain experience of? It is for the happiness of these five senses that we engage in all the activities called search for physical happiness. Then what is the source of the sensory happinesses of the five doors? It is simply the five exterior sense objects on which it depends. In other words, forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and physical sensations.
Our situation is therefore one in which we believe only in the existence of physical happiness and therefore we focus exclusively on the happinesses of the five sense doors, the five sensory consciousnesses. We view the source of their happiness as none other than the five exterior objects which are conditions for this happiness. In other words, forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. Within these five sensory happinesses, the foremost are the two last. In other words, gustatory happiness and tactile happiness.
Gustatory happiness is obvious in our craving for food and drink. Tactile happiness, if you reflect a bit by yourself, you will see that this is self evident. Then focused exclusively on physical happiness, the question we have to ask ourselves is whether we can be happy just in dependence on physical happiness. And if we take the case of someone, who has all the excellent contributory conditions to physical happiness, great wealth, health, and so forth, we do find nonetheless that such people are not blissfully happy. And the reason for this is simply the lack of mental or interior happiness.
When we speak of mental happiness, what we are referring to is mental peace and happiness, and this is something we don’t think about at all. Then after reflecting in the light of the Lamrim, on whether or not physical happiness alone can establish durable happiness for ourselves, it will become evident to us that physical happiness cannot do this. What can do it? Mental happiness can. In this case, we will wonder how precisely to establish mental happiness.
In turn, when we are able to create mental happiness within our own mind, by our own mind, then in turn, the happiness, the physical happiness induced by the five senses dwindle, and as it dwindles, the attachment to the exterior objects which are the condition for this happiness dwindles as well. As this dwindles in turn, attachment and craving to the exterior world dwindles. So this is reality. This is the actual way things are. Happiness cannot be established alone on the basis of exterior physical reality.
Why? Simply because there are two types of happiness, mental and physical happiness, and mental happiness has been left aside in this analysis. And therefore, when the focus on the physical sense organs inducing pleasure dwindles, in turn, the focus on the exterior objects which are the condition for this pleasure dwindles. When the mind which follow or which go after these physical exterior conditions for pleasure dwindle, in turn, the mind turns inwards. And at this point, one has less attachment to the exterior world and greater contentment.
This is what is of benefit at the time of death, when we have little attachment to the exterior world, when we have contentment. So at this point, when the mind is no longer focused on exterior sense objects, but has been withdrawn inwards, the coarse afflictions which are linked with the exterior objects dwindle since the mind has been withdrawn inwards, and they cannot harm one at the time of death. Such a person is someone who has probably realized the path of the being of the middling scope. So clearly, there are two categories of entities to which we are attached. The things we own, our stuff, if you wish, and our bodies.
I say our bodies, but actually we have five aggregates. But if we analyze carefully which is the stronger of these two, when clearly it is our bodies or our aggregates to which we are more attached than to the things we own. Since the things we own are there to satisfy the demands of our aggregates. So as we train in this this path, the attachment to the things we own dwindle, the mind turns inwards, and in turn, we are less attached to our bodies. Such a being has completed the realizations of the path of the being of the small scope and is entering the path of the being of the middling scope.
So let’s take the example of attachment to exterior objects such as your houses or your cars. Your cars, for instance, I will assume that we only consider people who own cars and not those who don’t own cars. Now if you own a car and you analyze whether you are more attached to your car or to yourself, your aggregates, then obviously you’re more attached to yourself than to your car. Your car is there to serve you, not the other way around. So clearly, once the attachment to exterior objects dwindle, then the mind is turned inwards.
Now clearly at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, although there are numerous afflictions which are objects of abandonment, the main object of abandonment is attachment to exterior physical objects. Once that has been relinquished, then one is ready to enter the path of the being of the middling scope whose main object of abandonment is the afflictions. Then this is quite straightforward. Then for people like Lily and Ali who don’t have cars, focus on your attachment to your mobile phones. Aaron, who doesn’t have a car.
So focus on your phone. Your phone, you know? So at present, as the mind is withdrawn inwards from exterior sensory objects, one realizes that there is tremendous grasping for the contaminated aggregates, and the contaminated aggregates are fivefold, Form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness. And one asks oneself, where does this tremendous attachment to the contaminated aggregates come from? As one analyzes, one realizes that one is attached to those such as family, friends, spouses, which benefit one’s contaminated aggregates, and that in turn one experiences hostility and anger towards those who are at odds with them or harm one’s contaminated aggregates.
So in this context, when we refer to the contaminated aggregates, the contaminated aggregates are five in number. It is not just the body. In other words, it is the form aggregate, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness. And these are subsumed within the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering. One must reflect on the nature of these contaminated aggregates, and in this way, the process of generation of the afflictions.
In the context of the path of the being of the small scope, our goal is to relinquish or to abandon the vanities of this life. And the one must reflect over again on the ways of countering attachment to exterior physical entities, which is the main object of abandonment of the being of the small scope. Once this has been accomplished, in turn, one must reflect in-depth on the process of generation of the afflictions, which is the main training of the being of the small scope and generate as much as one can a wish to abandon these afflictions through applying the corresponding antidotes. When we speak of meditating or generating the motivation, it just refers to thinking as much as one can about this. Let us meditate on generating the motivation.
The foremost object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope is the afflictions or cyclic existence. There is no particular difference between the afflictions and cyclic existence. So you can clearly see that if the foremost of objective abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope is the ten non-virtuous deeds as well as the vanities of this life. This is an indispensable preliminary to training in the path of the being of the middling scope. Since if for instance, one were not to have abandoned the 10 non virtues, it is far from clear whether it would be possible to train in the long run and the path of the being of the middling scope.
One approach is to study first all of these cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope and endeavor to realize them, then study all of the cycles of meditation of the being of the middling scope and endeavor to realize them. And then study all of those of the being of the great scope and endeavor to realize them. And at the same time, the specific objects of abandonment of the being of the small scope and endeavor to abandon them, those of the middling scope and those of the great scope. So to enter correctly in the path of the being of the middling scope, it is best to initially reflect on what is required at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, what are the objects of meditation, how to realize. So we shall stop here for tonight.
If you have questions, Geshe-la will take your questions. These should be questions which are short and easy to understand. What makes the person the best in generating the conviction that Geshe-la was talking about earlier as opposed to other systems of logic, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist? Which conviction? The conviction in past and future lives.
Yes, when we refer to past and future lives, we are referring to coarse interdependence. Now an understanding of coarse interdependence does not hinge on an understanding of subtle interdependence. When we’re talking about the five senses and the five doors, when we buy something or we eat something, which we all will continue to do, is it a matter of not having attachment or not believing that it makes you happy? We still all do this. We feel something, and we see something we like.
We feel something. We we have smells that we like or don’t like. Can Geshe-la please explain how to, abandon this? So I’ve answered this many times before. We must rely on exterior objects because we must rely on this body we are born in.
There’s nothing we can do about that. But we should not place 100% of our confidence in outer objects capacity to generate our happiness. This is what is meant by turning one’s back on the vanities of this life. What is meant by this is that one trains in contentment towards visual objects, auditory objects, olfactory objects, gustatory and tactile objects. Yeah.
Andy? Could Geshe-la explain just from, he was talking about, at the time of death, those of great capacity are delighted. Those of middling capacity have no fear, and those of lower capacity have no anxiety. Could Geshe-la explain the difference between the middling and the lower capacities, no fear and no anxiety? So it’s my fault, mistranslated.
So the being of supreme capacity is delighted. The being of middling capacity has no fear, and that of lowest capacity has no regret. So it sounds the same thing in certain dialects. So the being of middling capacity has no fear because this is actually a being who has relinquished the vanities of this life. And therefore, such a being does not fear having to abandon exterior physical objects, his aggregates, and so forth.
The being of the lowest capacity has no regret because such a being, does not regret nonvirtuous deeds which he or she committed. I was thinking that surely, mental objects can be, just as much and a problem as, physical objects. Sorry for this long question. I’ll try and get to the point. Is that if you if you’re attached to views or if you for instance, philosophers friends who are philosophers and they take great pleasure in ideas and these are mental objects.
And so I’ve seen these things as as much an obstacle and a cause for afflictions as external objects. Is that the case? Can we’re asked to seek the mental happiness, but these are objects of mental happiness that also cause afflictions. Definitely there is attachment to the view. However, in the context of the practice of the being of the middling scope, the foremost object of abandonment is the attachment and the craving for one’s form aggregate and for the remaining four aggregates.
I was just wondering why, the subtle mind would wanna stay with the the body after death for so many days. So the issue of how long the subtle mind stays in the body is one which arises in the context of tantra. There is no mention of this in sūtra. This depends very much on the person. For some, it stays for one day, for some for two days, for some for a bit more for three days.
And it departs at the end of that period normally in conjunction with exterior signs, such as the flow of blood from the nose or of the drops from the orifices. And? And question, another question. Have you Yeah. I think.
Geshe-la, do you have a comment about the Western mind in the sense that it will accept, subtle dream consciousnesses and the Christians, for instance, will accept a future life in heaven. Why do they find it such a leap of faith to accept future lives in the Buddhist context? Is it because they don’t want to take responsibility for their karma? It depends very much It depends on one’s way of thinking. It also depends on the depth of one’s analysis.
The Buddhist texts have analyzed the issue of past lives in tremendous depth to reach a conclusion that they are measureless. I just wanna ask. When you talk about the subtle consciousness and when we die, our gross mind dissolves into subtle consciousness. And I just wondering what factors sort of drives our, subtle conscious consciousness. And how do we, when when we are alive, how do we get access to that subtle conscious consciousness?
So that that will be so I just wanna ask, how do we put information into subtle con the subtle consciousness to benefits our death at the time of of our death. So this is something you should receive teachings upon. Basically, one must gain familiarity with the dissolution of the 25 coarse states of mind and then be able to take the three bodies on the path. Then through taking the three bodies on the path in conjunction with a sadhana, it is possible to gain control of the subtle mind in the death process. Have questions?
Just just one. Just one question. It’s a follow on from Chen’s question. For those of us who not going to be adept in practicing tantra, what do we do at the time of death to influence the subtle mind? So the most important thing for us is to have stable faith in the spiritual teacher at the time of death.
In dependence on that, all this will happen.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.