Death and Rebirth – 2014-11-05 – KR

1 h 36 min · 3,792 words · 5 November 2014

Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth - 2014-11-05 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Teaching on Nagarjuna’s Ratnavali verses on how non-virtue leads to suffering and lower rebirth, while ethical restraint leads to higher rebirth. The speaker advises facing death with confidence through ethics and health, then explains the ten non-virtues in detail, including the four components of each and the points on lying, gossip and wrong views. Listeners’ questions are taken up near the end.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 36m

UUID: 3122f26a-7ff8-474e-a660-04f39cfd27f2

Date: 2014-11-05

Words: 3,788

As Ārya Nāgārjuna says in his Ratnāvali, his Precious Garland, from non virtue or suffering, and later on, all lower rebirth. The meaning of these two verses is that when one engages in a non virtue, let us say, for instance, a heavy non virtue such as killing a human being or, for that matter, stealing a great amount of wealth, who in the very short term, there may occasionally be pleasure. As a result of this, one eliminates one’s enemies or one gains money. In this very life, one will face suffering, and in future lives, one will definitely be reborn in a lower rebirth. This is the meaning of this stanza.

And the stanza continues with the following two verses from virtue or happiness, and later on in the future, higher rebirth. The meaning of the last two verses is as follows. Generally speaking, if one engages in the practice of an ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues and which is focused on this abandonment out of a fear of lower rebirths in future lives, then indeed in future lives, one will experience higher rebirths, and in this very life, one will experience happiness. If, on the other hand, one engages in such an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues, through thinking the 10 non-virtues are really something one ought not to engage in in the here and now, then such a motivation is not focused on future lives and will not lead to fruition of the virtuous deed in future lives. Then if we take the cases of living beings from animals upwards, it is not exclusively a human experience, all experiences suffering of the four different categories of suffering, the sufferings of birth, age, sickness and death.

Death and the fear of death is not only a suffering which human beings experience, it is also a suffering which animals experience. However, if one merely remains paralyzed by the fear of death and does nothing to address the difficulties one is facing, this is really not beneficial. To give an example, it’s akin to having to sit a written examination. A written examination is something which is quite difficult for oneself. Then we know we have to sit the examination, therefore before sitting it and before receiving our grade, we must prepare for the exam.

Then when the time comes to sit the examination, we can sit it in confidence, and we will pass the examination. And what enables us to face death with fortitude is precisely the firm conviction, which focuses exclusively on future lives. Therefore, a firm conviction, a stable conviction in the existence of future lives is of extreme benefit. Let me give you an example. Let us imagine that we are standing on top of a cliff, and we have to jump for whatever reason.

However, we can see down at the bottom, some distance away, that there is a fairly soft landing, there is some grass. The landing is not just composed of rocks. And we think to ourselves, well I have no choice, must jump, but the odds are that I just break my legs when I land, probably I will survive the jump. Then we experience limited fear because we have a sense of what will happen. If on the other hand, we stand on the edge of a cliff and when we look down, all we can see is empty space, there is no landing, then we experience tremendous fear because we have no way of knowing what will happen to us.

This example indicates the difference between those who understand the existence of past and future lives and those who do not. Those who do will not experience great fear at the time of death, those who do not will definitely experience great terror. As the Kadampas of yore said, worry not about your place, worry about your rebirth. The meaning of this stanza is that our status in society is transient, whereas our future rebirth, say in the lower realms alone. And therefore, in keeping with the proverb of the Kadampas of yore, fear not your lot in this life, fear your future rebirth, it was quite extraordinary to see how beautifully our teacher, the holy abbot, Khensur Rinpoche, passed on.

There was not one iota of fear or worry, since he knew exactly what the future held. And as a result, his passing was extraordinarily smooth. This demonstrates the benefit of the dharma for us. It is not the case that one’s great courage halts the fear of death. Instead, it is the benefits of dharma which prevent the fear for fear of death.

Then there are many reasons to fear death. For one who believes in future lives and their existence, one of the main reasons to fear death is the realization that one has accumulated no causes for a good rebirth, but that one has a large number of causes for a rebirth in the lower realms. For most of us, the fear of death, however, arises from extraordinary attachment to the affairs of this life and fear of suffering in this life. Then there is no means for attaining a higher rebirth superior to ethics. And therefore, if one has engaged in an ethics, which is the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, it is 100% certain that one will have a higher rebirth in a future life.

Then in this life, we must work to eat, to have clothing, and when we go to work every day, we should always think that I am doing this obviously because I have to do this, but I am also doing this as much as I can for the sake of others to help others. And then I have had direct experience of this myself. If one protects one’s health, if one takes care of one’s health, then one’s death will be a very smooth death. It will be akin to falling asleep. And, therefore, this is how to proceed if one wishes for a peaceful death.

Then one of the main sources of suffering at the time of one’s passing is attachment to one’s children and one’s relatives. And in a country like Australia, in which children leave home when they are 18, they have their own car, they just go off and do whatever they do, and the parents stay at home, the parents’ mind is at ease with respect to their children. It’s a very different situation from countries in which children stay with their parents for a very long time. There are however exceptions. I believe Chris has two children still living with him.

I’m sorry. But Yes. I was very sorry. And this is a very good aspect of the culture in this country. Then if, from one’s own side, one is able to protect an ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, and in addition to lead a healthy wholesome life, things will turn out very well for oneself.

Then in our own cases, all of us, probably without exception, wish for physical and material happiness. And we see this physical and material happiness as arising from the outside, from the exterior world. This is the core source of our problems. Clearly, this is not unimportant. We do need favorable material conditions.

But to view exterior things as our helpers is somewhat odd. After all, it is matter. It is not matter which should control us, it is we who should control matter. Therefore, it is important not to fall under the control of exterior things, but instead to control them. And therefore, instead of placing all of our trust in exterior material entities, viewing them as the main means of causing our happiness, whereas they can only cause physical happiness, which by its nature is transient and unsatisfactory, Instead, we should search for the true source of happiness and have faith in our own minds.

It is within our own minds that the true source of happiness is to be found. Then, if true happiness is to be found within our minds, we need a guide to this mental happiness. And this guide is the graduated stages of the path, the Lamrim. With this as a motivation, we should study the Lamrim and not merely study or literally hear it. Instead, we should place the teachings as much as we can within our own minds.

Otherwise, it is quite lamentable that our happiness should depend exclusively on the food we gorge ourselves with. Do you understand? And therefore, in the context of the practice of the being of the small scope, we should train in this way, and we should preserve our physical well-being, extending our life for as long as it has been given karmically to us to live. Then, if we behave in this way, at the end of that life we will fade quietly and almost invisibly, just as when someone falls asleep. I asked you a couple times ago, at what time precisely you had fallen asleep?

And nobody in the temple was able to answer my question, simply because nobody is aware of falling asleep. And therefore, in my personal opinion, the way one should train is while preserving one’s health to meditate on death and impermanence and on karma and causality. This is how a being of the small scope trains. Now, those, do you understand? Really?

Good. This is not difficult. And since our present state is contingent on our body, literally our form aggregate, then it is important to preserve our health. And understanding that happiness, true happiness comes from within the innermost depths of one’s mind and that the Lamrim is a guide to this happiness, we should then integrate the Lamrim within our mind stream. This is how a human life will be profoundly happy and meaningful.

Let us generate the motivation. I have seen that it is important to give a detailed commentary on the 10 non virtues, and therefore we shall enter into this. If you do not understand or do not know the nature of the 10 non virtues, listen carefully and ask questions afterwards. If one doesn’t understand what precisely is the object of abandonment, which is abandoned by an ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues, how can one hope to engage in such an ethics and protect it? Therefore, one must understand the 10 non virtues, and then one will easily understand what is to be engaged in and what to be foresworn.

Listen carefully therefore. So be careful. Listen to me. The 10 non virtues are subdivided into three categories. The three non virtues of the body, the three physical non virtues, the four verbal non virtues, and the three mental non virtues.

It’s a very easy way to study them, to subdivide them into three physical non virtues, four verbal non virtues, and three mental non virtues. Let us therefore analyze these 10 non-virtues one by one carefully, starting with the three physical non virtues. The first physical non virtue is a non virtue of killing, literally in Tibetan, to cut the life force. For the deed of killing to become a karmic path of killing, four components must be present. There must be a base, which is a living being different from oneself.

For instance, a sheep. Then there must be an intention which is afflicted, an affliction in other words, the wish to end the life of a living being. There must, in the third place, be a deed. This deed of killing can be performed with a weapon, with poison, with drugs, or whatever. And finally, there must be a culmination or a conclusion.

The living being concerned must die. Let us take the second physical nonvirtuous deed, the deed of stealing or theft. Again, the four components must be present for it to become a karmic path. The first is the base. These are possessions or wealth which is not one’s own.

For instance, a watch. The second is the intention. This is an affliction which leads one to wish to steal, to appropriate what is not one’s own. The third are the means, whatever means one uses to appropriate what is not one’s own. And as a fourth, the conclusion is the thought, this is mine.

At this point, the deed of stealing is a karmic path. Then the third physical non virtue is sexual misconduct. This once again has four components for it to become a karmic path, the base, the thought, the deed and the conclusion. Regarding the deed of sexual misconduct, as far as laymen and laywomen are concerned, there are four possible deeds of sexual misconduct. The first involves a wrong path for sexual intercourse.

This is all non vaginal intercourse. The second involves a wrong time for sexual intercourse. This would be for instance when one of the two partners has taken vows of purity for a period of twenty four hours, for instance, or when the mother is pregnant. The third would be a wrong place for sexual intercourse. This is in any room in which a representation of the Buddha’s body, speech or mind is present.

The fourth is a wrong relation with whom to have sexual relations, and this would be, for instance, a relative such as one’s own mother or a sibling. Now if one is ordained, any type of sexual misconduct, any type of sexual relations is sexual misconduct. Then if on such a basis motivated by an affliction, one engages in the deed, which is the third component, the conclusion is the experience of orgasm. At this point, a karmic path of sexual misconduct is complete. This is the presentation of these three physical non-virtues.

At present, the four nonvirtuous verbal deeds are lying, divisive speech, harsh words and chatter or gossip. The first non virtuous verbal deed is lying. This has four components: the base, the intention, the performance and the conclusion. The base of lying is someone who either understands or does not understand what is being uttered. The deed is to utter or to indicate motivated by an affliction.

The performance of the deed is the actual utterance or indication of something which is false, and the conclusion of the deed is when the other party has understood what is said. For instance, in my own case, if you were to ask me a question about Lamrim and I have not understood your question but answered nonetheless, this would be a deed of lying. The following verbal nonvirtuous deed is divisive speech. Divisive speech has four components: the base, the intention, the deed, and the conclusion. The base is people who live in harmony with each other or people who are in a disharmonious relationship.

The intention is any affliction. The deed is to cause disharmony between those who live harmoniously with each other, such as, let us say, Chris and Aaron, or to increase the disharmony between people who are already at odds with each other. And the conclusion of the deed is when the other party or both parties have understood the meaning, and as a result of this understanding, their estrangement is increased. The third verbal nonvirtuous deed, is harsh or injurious words. This has four components.

The base is another party towards whom one experiences anger. The motivation is any of the afflictions, and the deed is to utter verbal statements or to intimate something which is insulting or offensive to the other party, such as saying, you dog and so forth. The conclusion is when the other party has understood the meaning which was said. Then the fourth verbal non virtue is chatter or gossip. This is one to which we are highly vulnerable.

It refers to any meaningless talk which is unrelated to the situation in which one is in, whether it is understood or not by the other party is irrelevant. Three mental non virtues, the last three non virtues, the first is covetousness to which we are greatly exposed. This arises, for instance, when we see a car, let us say, which we find very beautiful, and the desire to possess this car arises within our mind. At this point, covetousness is present. Regarding the second mental non virtue, the ninth of the 10 non-virtues, ill will, this arises when reflecting about someone whom we dislike.

We think, I wish he died. I wish he became poor. I wish something unfortunate happened to him. The tenth non virtue is wrong views. Wrong views refer to wrong views concerning the Triple Gem, karma and causality, or past and future lives.

And they arise if one understands what these are, what the Triple Gem, karma and causality, past and future lives are, but nonetheless says they do not exist. Otherwise, if one merely asserts their non existence, it is deprecation, not wrong views. Okay. Finish it. Then this went very well.

I endeavored to explain the 10 non virtues in a simple and accessible form, and I hope you have understood. This is a straightforward practice we can all engage in, it is not difficult to understand. And setting aside past and future lives, you can imagine how this country and all the countries in the world would be happier if everyone followed this ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues, and if it spread throughout the world. And therefore the way to proceed is at the end of one’s day, before going to sleep, one should look back at one’s day and ask oneself, have I engaged in any of the 10 non virtuous deeds? And if we have, then we should apply the antidote of the four forces, because it is said that the non virtuous deeds have one great quality.

They can be confessed and restrained from. Do you understand? Or do you understand anyone, please? No? Do you understand?

Do you understand? Do you understand? I think Geshe-la is hoping for a response. 100%. So, Geshe-la said, and therefore, at the end of the day, the way to proceed is to see whether or not one has engaged in any of the 10 non virtues, and if one has, then one should engage in the practice of the four forces which are antidotes.

Because it is said that non virtue has one great quality, it can be confessed and it can be restrained from. And this is a good question. However, when someone asks a question from me, if I am aware that I don’t understand the question, and nonetheless answer that question, it is very difficult for that answer not to be motivated by the delusions. I have already decided to lie at that point. So the concept doesn’t exist in Tibet, and I have to give an example.

And the example I gave was in English we have this notion of white lie, where we say something which is meaningless to somebody. It has supposed to have no weight. For instance, imagine if a lady who is very fat asks us, am I overweight? And we say, no, no, you’re very thin. Then it’s a white lie.

Then Geshe-la said, obviously, we and she both know she is fat. So it is a lie. And therefore, one should abstain from meaningless talk. As Atisha said, when alone, check your mind. When in community, check your speech.

Avoiding other gossip in terms of everyday conversations? Idle chatter or gossip is said to be meaningless talk in the Buddhist scriptures. If the motivation is to become close to another person, it’s not meaningless. So idle talk or chatter is talk which is unrelated to the circumstances, to the occasion. Then the 10 non virtues are the coarsest non virtues which concern us.

There are numerous other non virtues, for instance, the six root afflictions, 20 branch afflictions are all non virtues, and in the case of distraction, it is a fault for those who engage in the practice of calm abiding, and for those who wish to be reborn in the form and the formless realms. Now since this doesn’t concern us, it is far too advanced for us, it is not mentioned. I’ve been reading a couple of the Lamrim texts to compare it with Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand including Steps on the Path to Enlightenment in which it says that idle talk can also relate to reading certain books that increase feelings of desire and anger etc. Extrapolating that to the lives that we have today could this also then apply to watching TV, certainly the internet, or that kind of activity? Steps on the Path to Enlightenment by whom?

This example is given in the Lamrim Chenmo. It is mentioned that reading this sort of unfortunate book and talking about it after is idle talk. For a verbal deed to become a karmic path of lying, all four conditions must be present: the base, the motivation, the deed, and the completion of the deed. Then if we take the example of someone who comes to us with a criminal intent and asks, where is this or where is that person? We know his intent is evil and we utter an untruth, then our motivation is good.

Therefore, though this has some affinities with lying, it is not lying. No. It’s it’s idle talk. It’s chatter, which is the the non virtuous deed we engage you most easily in and which we must be the most wary of. This is said in liberation in the palm of your hand.

The No, all four of these components must be present for mental non virtuous deeds. To take the example of ill will, which you mentioned, one needs a base, which is another person, and then on this base, one needs an evil motivation, which is a thought, may something unfortunate happen to them, and one needs a conclusion to this thought, which is something like a mental resolve. I really wish something unfortunate happened to this person. And we’re aware of future lives and specialists saying it would be like going to sleep. How important is it in this process It is of great benefit to have a good helper with oneself at the time of one’s own death, somebody who knows one’s practice and can help or engage in that practice as one dies.

Yeah yeah, alright, I think. That’s enough? Yeah yeah. Yes. So Geshe-la was just announcing, which is the puja special puja on the thirteenth.

Thirteenth, not not tomorrow.

Key terms in this teaching

lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top