1 h 35 min · 3,662 words · 30 July 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching presents the reasons for conviction in future lives and the need to avoid lower rebirths through virtue and purification. It explains the sequence of meditations in the path of the being of small scope, showing why death and impermanence come before refuge, and how refuge arises from fear of lower realms. Questions follow on renunciation, stream enterers, and the difference between pure and mere refuge.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 35m
UUID: d690e0f7-1deb-42ea-b73a-42907c7c68fe
Date: 2014-07-30
Words: 3,658
As as Je Tsongkhapa said, since there is no certainty that after death, we shall not be reborn in the lower realms. And here, the lower realms obviously refer to our future lives. Undeniably, to understand this, one must have ideally a realization through a valid cognition of the existence of future lives, or at least a conviction or strong karmic imprints concerning the existence of future lives. I suspect you have these. I for myself cannot say I have realized this through valid cognition, but I definitely have strong karmic imprints towards this.
Do you have the understanding that future lives must definitely exist or not? It’s extremely important to have a focused conviction within one’s mind stream that future lives do exist. Just as when we engage in business activities, it is when we are profoundly convinced that future lives exist, that as a means to give rise to happiness in future lives, we will engage in the requisite activities in this life. Through reflecting on the fact that the continuum of consciousness will not be interrupted, one can understand that consciousness proceeds to future lives and there are only two possible destinations, the higher realms, which are the result of virtuous karma and the lower realms, which are the result of non virtuous karma. And as Je Tsongkhapa said, through reflecting on forthcoming death, prepare for the future.
Through understanding that our death is certain, we prepare at present for future lives. Even though at present, we may not have led a life in which we have committed heavy non virtuous deeds, nonetheless, it is definite relying on Buddhist scriptures that in previous lives, we did commit heavy non virtuous deeds. And these therefore, must as I have explained previously, be purified through the application of the antidotes, the four forces. And therefore, one should engage in the twin activities of confession and restraint, and also foster heedfulness which will prevent us from engaging in non virtuous deeds. It will occur that we engage in non virtuous deeds, but it is important to break the continuum of doing so.
And therefore, practicing heedfulness in avoiding engagement in non virtue, we will reach the end of our life. At the end of our life, clearly, if non virtue is present within our mind stream, we will be reborn in the lower realms. And I believe that once reborn in the lower realms, it is very difficult to be born out of them. At present, as human beings with a sharp intelligence and the capacity to do what we wish, we have the most excellent opportunity. Then in keeping with Buddhist scriptures, if at present we do not use the opportunity which is ours, then it will be very difficult in future lives not to be reborn in lower realms.
As Acharya Candrakīrti says, if at present, when we have the opportunity to do so, we do not seize the opportunities of this human rebirth, what shall we do when we have fallen into a blazing pit of fire? And indeed, if at present, we do not seize the opportunities, what will we do when we are reborn in the lower realms? So this is how one should think to enhance one’s Dharma practice. And therefore, I believe that if ideally one has been able to focus one’s mind completely on virtue, but if this is not possible, let us say 70% on virtue, then at the time of one’s passing, at the time of one’s death, one will not experience fear and will look forwards to a good rebirth. It is therefore extremely important to have strong conviction in the existence of future lives.
Materialists do not believe in the existence of future lives at all. And therefore, at the time of death, they will probably experience great fear, wondering what precisely will happen to me. The worst. The materialist, the ancient Cārvākas of India had a rationale for denying the existence of future lives. They used the following example.
They said, future life excuse me, the mind and the body are related in the same way as graffiti and the wall which supports it. When you destroy the wall, the graffiti or the drawings are destroyed as well. From the Buddhist standpoint, it is taught in Buddhist texts that there are various subtle levels of the body, and therefore, there are various subtle levels of the person as well. If at present, one does not practice regularly and consistently, then at the time of one’s death, when the dissolution begin and the mind becomes ever more subtle, it will be difficult to maintain any type of practice. And therefore reflecting at present on what shall happen to us at the time of our death and understanding that virtue is the supreme means to be reborn in the higher realms, and that non virtue can only lead to the lower realms, one should practice accordingly, and generate at present the motivation for these teachings.
So we have at present reached the topic of refuge within the presentation of the path of the being of the small scope. There are perhaps seven There are perhaps seven topics of meditation within the path of the being of the small scope. So these topics would be relying on the spiritual teacher, the precious human rebirth and its rarity, death and impermanence, the sufferings of the lower realms, refuge, and karma and causality. Then depending on whether you fuse the precious human human rebirth and its rarity or not, you’ll have a different number, seven or eight subdivisions. We have finished presenting all these topics apart from taking refuge in karma and causality.
And when you meditate or cover them yourselves, you should proceed incrementally, sequentially. And we have at present reached in the outline the topic, training the mind in the holy refuge, the gateway to the teachings. When we train in these topics, we must train our mind incrementally, topic by topic, sequentially. And specifically in the case of refuge, the topic of refuge comes after the topic of the suffering of the lower realms. So what is the reason?
What is the purpose for this? So for instance, if one wishes to give rise, which is our case to authentic experiences of the stages of the path and the being of the small scope, then one must for instance meditate first on death and impermanence, then on the suffering of the lower realms, and then on refuge. Refuge, the meditations on refuge do not come before the meditations on death and impermanence, they come after. There is a reason for this. Likewise, the meditations on refuge arise immediately after reflections on the suffering of the lower realms.
There is also a reason for this. Now for instance, if we take the verse from the three principles of the path, turn away from the vanities of this life, clearly, this is a result of meditation on death and impermanence. To which degree does this prepare taking refuge? Do you understand my point? The teachings on refuge come after the teachings on death and impermanence.
For which reason are the teachings on death and impermanence necessary as a preliminary to the teachings on refuge? A person who has actually a full realization of death and impermanence is someone who has turned away from the vanities of this life. One can posit such a person as not having refuge as being prior to someone who has refuge. Then if refuge is generated after reflecting on death and impermanence, I’d like to ask you what the purpose is? The Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha give us a way to higher rebirth because with realization of death and impermanence we are looking at rebirth, a higher rebirth and that is the way by taking refuge.
By meditating on death and impermanence we’re looking at not just one of the four seals of Buddhism that being that all compounded phenomena is impermanent so we are turning away from the vanities of this life because that is what causes suffering so we are going to the triple gem for that realization that he would teach us the path or we will listen to the path to enlightenment. In an existence that ends in death, and everything we strive for in a worldly sense comes can come to nothing ultimately. And refuge is the only solid foundation for anything. There is no foundation anywhere. This life is above and impermanence is omnipresent.
And so going for refuge is going to something that is more stable than those things. By meditating on death, I will understand the urgency of practicing in this lifetime. By meditating on impermanence, I will understand that I’m not a permanent being and therefore I can actually become a Buddha. So therefore I need to meditate on those before I take refuge. Before I follow someone out of prison, I must first realize that I am in prison.
And another. As Natalie said, meditating on death makes me realize how short and impermanence, how short this life is, therefore I must practice Dharma now and the realization of the lower realms, the fear of the consequences of my next rebirth makes me want to, the fear of that drives me to find a reliable refuge. So the way to look at it is as follows. First, one must generate a realization of death and impermanence. Then, one must generate a realization of the suffering of the lower realms.
Then, one must generate a realization of refuge. So the realization of death and impermanence precedes the realization of refuge, doesn’t it? Then we have to ask ourselves, is the realization of death and impermanence present within our mind streams or not? Is the realization of refuge present within our mind streams or not? And is it possible to have refuge without having realized death and impermanence?
Then this is something all of us have to think about, and see for ourselves. Is it true that to generate refuge within our mind stream, one must have initially realized death and impermanence or not? There’s a question I ask you. So the way to look at it is to start by looking at the seven or so cycles of meditation, topics of meditation within the practice of the being of the small scope. Go through them mentally and ask yourself, how does refuge arise in this context?
Most of us in this room, perhaps everybody has refuge vows, which means most in this room have taken refuge. Then, if we have taken refuge and it is true that one must have realized death and impermanence before taking refuge, most of us should have realized death and impermanence. Is that the case or not? That’s how one has to think about it. It’s quite beneficial to think like this.
For instance, Aaron, how many topics of meditation are there in the practice of the being of the small scope? Right? That’s exactly it. And this is how one has to go about it, cover these topics, and then in dependence on this one will understand. It’s no problem.
You can give them all. It’s not really the case, right? Normally, it’s not included in the path of being of the small scope. Sorry, we were focusing on something else. I thought you said at the beginning there was seven reliance on the guru, precious human rebirth, death and impermanence, suffering, refuge, karma and causality.
If you include the rarity of the precious human rebirth as a different one then there’s seven and then you said there could be seven or eight so perhaps death and impermanence are separated. If you separate death and impermanence there would be eight. The reliance on the Guru, precious human rebirth, the rarity of the precious human rebirth, death, impermanence, suffering of lower realms, refuge, karma and causality. The most important thing is to follow the sequence of the topics of meditation of the being of the small scope. If one doesn’t do this, one will get confused.
Since the difference between being a Buddhist and a non-Buddhist, literally an insider and an outsider is refuge, Refuge is said in the outline of the Lamrim to be the gateway to the teachings. So, the question we have to ask ourselves is, is there refuge in my mind stream or not? These doubts are very helpful, especially if one looks at things sequentially. And one doubt would be the following one. Let us take a practitioner, a being who gets turned away from the vanities of this life, and who therefore has realized death and impermanence.
Such a being would be a being on the path of the being of the small scope, but if refuge has not been generated in his mind stream yet, how could such a being be a Buddhist? On the other hand, he is a being of the small scope. Don’t worry about it, however. It is said in the text that to give rise to pure refuge, the preliminary realization of the suffering of the lower realms is indispensable. Then we can say that pure refuge is not present in our mind stream, since pure refuge is the result of the cause fear of the suffering of the lower realms.
It would however be narrow minded and a little bit strange to say that refuge is totally absent within our mind stream. We have an unstable refuge in our mind stream, which has not arisen out of its natural cause. And therefore, it is said in Buddhist scriptures that refuge arises from the fear of the suffering of the lower realms. And in dependence on this, one asks the question, who can protect me from the sufferings of the lower realms? It is a realization that the Triple Gem can protect us from these sufferings, which is the cause of refuge.
Then what is refuge? Refuge is pure refuge. And what is this pure refuge? It is the realization through a valid cognizer that the triple gem can protect us. Then I have nothing extra to add.
If you have questions, I’ll take a couple questions. In my case and I guess in a number of other cases of Western students, the reason I wanted to become a Buddhist, why I became interested in Buddhism was because I was really becoming aware of the suffering in this lifetime and a lot of that was not necessarily physical suffering but mental suffering and there had to be something better than what was being on offer in the West. So that was what led me to become interested in Buddhism and I guess wanting to take refuge in the first place. And then as I started to learn more about Buddhism and started studying the Lamrim to start off with, then I started learning about the lower realms which were a bit horrific at first. There’s no special question, is there?
I guess what I was sort of alluding to in that preamble was that for me the suffering of this life was enough to want me to take refuge before I’d even understood much about the suffering of lower realms. So I said again there’s still not a question. Okay so, could Geshe-la comment on that? The hardship of this life or the sufferings of this life, it’s going around and experiencing difficulties. Those are solved within this life.
I just had a question that I’ve reached a bit of an impasse with my studies because I don’t really understand the nature of renunciation and Geshe-la has said things like disgusting cyclic existence and the vanities of this life. What are we supposed to be renouncing, whole of life? Like Geshe-la said, the abandonment of life, what does that exactly mean? So when one says to turn away from the vanities of this life, the vanities of this life are things like clothing, food, and one’s reputation. And what is meant by turning away from the vanities of this life is to be contented, to be satisfied with what one has.
So when we speak of the vanities of this life, we’re speaking of exterior things. This can be people, this can be things produced by people. So we’re not saying you should throw away everything you need for living. That would be silly, wouldn’t it? Throw away your food, your money, and all that.
What is being said is that you should eliminate attachment, desire, craving for those things, and should foster satisfaction. I don’t want you to throw everything away, he sort of says. We have problems. If taking refuge vows is insufficient to having refuge, could Geshe-la explain why taking them is When one has taken refuge vows, it is not that one doesn’t have refuge, one has refuge, but one does not have the pure refuge explained in the lamrim which arises from its pure cause. So I would say that within our minds, there is a mere refuge without analyzing too much.
Thank you Geshe-la. I just have a question because this word comes up in the refuge part. What is a stream enterer? And does the Tibetan meaning of stream enterer, is that the same as the Theravada meaning? It’s a bit difficult.
A stream enterer is a Śrāvaka. Yes. So the topic of stream enterers is presented within what is known as the 20 sanghas, which is one of the more difficult treatises studied at Sera Je Monastery. One speaks also of once returners, of never returners, of Arhats, and makes a distinction between these various practitioners. You have a good mind, Lily, and it is very good you ask these questions, but I would suggest that you focus single pointedly on the Lam Rim.
Otherwise, if you try to mix too many things together, it will create confusion. Then if one wants to study well, one focuses on the essence. Then if one wanders left and right, one becomes confused, doesn’t one? Is it talked about in relation to that point of your It’s it’s not the main topic. So stream enterers are Shravakas, they are actually Shravakas.
Excuse me. It seems to me that reflecting on the suffering of lower realms and fear is inferior to compassion as a motivation and so I would like to understand why fear is a means for taking refuge and encouraged as a means for taking refuge as opposed to love and compassion. There are three refuges, there is a refuge of the practitioner of the small path, the middling path and the great path. The refuge you are referring to is that of the being of the great vehicle. Mark, also.
I personally took refuge perhaps initially out of self compassion more than anything. I wasn’t too aware of the lower realms at the time. I do recall Geshe-la saying that those with a greater propensity for compassion don’t necessarily need to reflect so much on the suffering of the lower realms. And so myself as someone who must have some sort of karmic imprint for compassion. I’ve been compassionate since I was young.
I’ve saved animals out of compassion not thinking I was going to go to the lower realms or go to the higher realms or avoid the lower realms. So is it necessary for someone who has that type of karmic propensity to reflect repeatedly on those sorts of sufferings or should I focus specifically on increasing my own compassion and empathy? The presentation in the Lam Rim is an incremental presentation, which is designed for beginners such as ourselves. Then it is clearly possible to take refuge out of an incapacity to support the suffering of sentient beings. If that is your motivation, why not?
In relation to realizing refuge, what is its pure cause? Taking pure refuge has two causes, the first is the fear of the lower rebirth in general and saṃsāra, The second is the faith born out of conviction that the triple gem has the capacity to protect us from this. For someone such as me who takes refuge out of compassion and not fear, does that mean my refuge isn’t pure? It sounds similar to a pure refuge. Chris?
I’ll ask a question. In terms of lo rig, would doubt tending towards the Triple Gem be the basis, the lowest level that one could define as having an unstable refuge? If one takes the refuge vows based on a hope and a wish without necessarily an understanding but an inclination would that qualify as the basis for the minimum for an unstable refuge? Yes, a factual doubt, a doubt tending towards the fact that the Triple Gem has the capacity to protect us from suffering would not be a pure refuge, but it would be a mere refuge, an uncharacterized refuge. Just a couple of things.
As Geshe-la said, Chökhor Chenmo, the celebration of the first turning of the wheel. As Geshe-la said, the guru devotion is the beginning of the path. And so this is a great opportunity to come to do a Guru Puja. Secondly, there will not be a teaching next Tuesday or Wednesday because of preparation by Ilya for the symposium. And this is a wonderful opportunity to develop strong conviction in past and future lives.
Ilya will be looking at the data relating that to the Dharma science to help us to gain a firm grip on past and future lives which will help us in our practice. So there’s still places for the symposium the following weekend. Apart from chai, I’ve forgotten something else. Aaron? Biscuits and chai, cake.
Aaron, anything else? Sorry. The program will be up tomorrow. Probably tomorrow, all things being well. And then followed by the magazine very shortly after that.
Key terms in this teaching
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What are we supposed to renounce, and what does it mean to turn away from the vanities of this life?
The vanities of this life are things like clothing, food and one's reputation. These are exterior things, which can be people or things made by people. Turning away from them means being contented and satisfied with what one has. It does not mean throwing away everything one needs for living, such as food and money, which would be silly. What is to be eliminated is attachment, desire and craving for those things, and satisfaction is to be fostered in their place.