Death and Rebirth – 2014-07-23 – KR

1 h 46 min · 4,287 words · 23 July 2014

Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth - 2014-07-23 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching covers how the karmic imprint dominant at death determines the next rebirth, and why generating virtuous mind in life prepares one for death. It explains purifying non-virtue through the four forces of confession and describes the sufferings of the lower realms (hell beings, pretas and animals). The talk closes with a question-and-answer session on the small, middling and great scopes, supplementary realisations, and refuge.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 47m

UUID: e6282d99-91be-4c79-aa1c-3759554ac5fe

Date: 2014-07-23

Words: 4,283

Mhmm. As Vasubandhu said in the or the, it is whichever karmic imprint which is dominant within one’s mind stream at the time of death, which impels the next existence. And therefore, at the time of death, whichever karmic imprint is present, virtuous or non virtuous, impels a future rebirth. If they are equal in strength, it is the karmic imprint with which one has the greatest habituation, which impels the next rebirth. If one has equal habituation, it is that which is the closest, and if they are equal in those terms, then it is that which is the earliest which impels the next rebirth.

Doubtless, the greatest hardship we will face in this life will be our own death. And it is clear that at the time of one’s own death, in keeping with the teachings, that nothing is of benefit at the time of one’s own death but Dharma, Dharma alone will be of benefit to us. Then it is indeed taught that one should generate virtuous states of mind at the time of one death one’s death. But this is very difficult. It is particularly very difficult if all our life we have only done what we felt like and have never really trained in generating virtuous mind streams.

Instead, while we are hale and hearty, we should generate virtuous states of mind, then it will be easier at the time of death. Then, clearly our minds are infused with the non virtuous karma which we have performed in previous lives. In addition, we know very well which type of non virtuous deed we have performed in this life. Now, it is said that sin or non virtue has only one quality, which is that it can be confessed. And indeed, this basis or foundation of ours is a basis or a foundation on which we can practice confession.

Clearly, we know exactly the non virtuous deeds which we have performed and therefore, we should engage in the purification of these non virtuous deeds through the four forces which are taught in the Lamrim, such as the force of the base, the force of repentance, and the force of the application of the antidote and so forth. When we apply these four forces, there is not a single non virtuous deed which cannot be purified in this context. In addition to the application of the four forces in the context of confession, one can also engage in other practices such as reciting the sūtra of the Confession of the Downfalls, which is a remarkable practice and so forth. However, it is clear that while it would be ideally the case that we would never mentally allow our mind to shift to non virtue as we are ordinary beings, this does happen. Our mind is suffused with anger and with desire.

Since even Bodhisattvas on the first ground succumb occasionally to desire what of us, so ideally, we should try to focus our minds continually on virtue at present where we have the capacity to do so. Then, things will go easier for us at the time of our own death. If we are able to die in a virtuous state of mind, then our future rebirth in a happy realm will have been decided, will have been settled. In addition, we will die in a happy state of mind. We must be very wary because clearly the two most important events of our lives, which are our birth and our death, are events over which we have no control whatsoever.

Therefore, it is important to take care of this body of ours, which is of the nature of the truth of suffering. Then we must indeed be very wary and careful while we are alive, since it is possible to die from numerous causes. One can die for instance from ingesting the wrong sort of food. If we reflect on the number of beings in this world of ours who die, we can see that not that many of them probably die in a virtuous state of mind. And therefore, in our daily dealings, since we encounter so many people, it is extremely important to be careful of the health of this body of ours.

For instance, if one reflects on the fate of Malaysia Airlines MH 17, which flew from Amsterdam or was flying from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur before it was shot down over the Ukraine, one can ask oneself, what would have occurred if I had been on that flight? And this is hardly impossible. There were many Australians on this flight. Then this is something we should think about for a long time, wonder where we ourselves would have ended had we been on flight MH 17 and allow a great feeling of fear and anxiety to arise in our mind. If we do this, our mind will eventually become much vaster.

As for the people who were on the flight and their destiny and future lives, we have no way of knowing what it was. If we take the case of love, compassion and bodhicitta, whether they are in actuality of benefit to others or not is a very difficult issue to decide. We train them because they are of great benefit for our own mind, and therefore, we should give advice to ourselves, to our own mind. And therefore, if we train our mind in this fashion, our death will be easy and there will definitely be a path to liberation for us. I have mentioned previously that it is under the power of grasping at our own permanence, the belief that we will be around for 100 or more that we do not engage forcefully in practice.

And therefore, we shall at present generate the motivation to abstain completely from non virtuous deeds, and to apply the four forces in the process of confession to those non virtuous deeds in which we have engaged, and to focus our mind ideally, completely, 100% on virtue, and if this is not possible, to focus it as much as we can 60 or 70% on virtue. Let us therefore generate this motivation for a couple of minutes. Then if our focus is exclusively onto this life until the time of death, whether this qualifies as virtuous Dharma practice or not, obviously it does not. Then from which point onwards does the uncommon virtuous practices characteristic of Buddha Dharma begin? They actually begin from the practice of the being of the small scope upwards.

But specifically the uncommon virtuous practices of Buddhadharma begin with the practices of the middle, being of the middling scope. Since it is the being of the middling scope who turns away from the sufferings associated with the contaminated aggregates, which are of the nature of the noble truth of suffering. However, the foundation of these practices is to be found in the practice of the being of the small scope. Then, as was mentioned, the mental capacities of the hara beings and of hungry ghosts or pretas are akin to those of human beings. Clearly, hell beings experience the intolerable sufferings of the hells as a karmic result of maturation of previously accumulated non virtue.

And theoretically, they would have the perfect conditions for meditating and reflecting on Dharma in the light of their suffering. Yet, this does not seem to happen. Then in the case of the Hungry Ghost of the Preta’s, this is most definitely the case. In Tibet we had clear instances of this with spirits of the King and the Tse class. These are spirits which sometimes can descend or manifest into human beings.

They seem to have the capacities of human beings and perhaps some of the ordinary mundane protectors belong also to the category of pretas. Of this, I am not sure. Because hungry ghosts or pretas are continually thirsty and starving, their heads are disproportionately large, their throats thin and their bellies distended. They are extraordinarily thin and their skin is dry as parchment. It is said actually that when they walk, their limbs through friction with each other produce sparks as firing sticks.

Pretas experience these sufferings of hunger, of thirst, of cold, and of heat, and of fear, and of anguish. In addition, they are said to suffer from three possible categories of obstructions. The first are outer obstructions. These are obstructions which prevent the pretas from enjoying food and drink. When they see food and drink in the distance and they approach, it disappears or it is surrounded by gods and they cannot ingest or absorb it.

Then before all of this, one should analyze the causes for a rebirth as a The causes for being reborn as a preta are generally speaking extreme greed, a disproportionate attachment to one’s own possessions without the ability to relinquish them, and a craving for the possessions of others. When these two causes are present, if we have not applied the four forces as antidotes to purify them, we will be reborn as something akin to a preta. Then we should ask ourselves, are these causes present within my mind stream or not? Have they been purified or not? Then, as mentioned previously, there are three types of obstructions which pretas experience.

The outer obstructions have been covered. The inner obstructions refer to physiological obstructions, for instance, when the pretas do actually find food and they try to ingest it, their throat is too narrow or their mouth is too dry for them to swallow the food. The third category of obstruction, pretas experience includes karmic obstructions which prevent the preta from using or absorbing the food it ingests. When it ingests the food, because it does not have the karma to benefit from this food, it is unable to absorb it or because its stomach is so large, the food does not even come close to fitting it. Then if you have a very big stomach, there’s perhaps a risk of being reborn as a preta.

Then we do not know how factual this account is, but it is recounted by Pänchen Sangye Gyatso during one of his trips. He encountered literally an army of Preta’s, a mother Preta with some 500 offspring. And she addressed, addressed Pänchen Sangye Yeshe and told him, it has been twelve years that my husband has gone forth to try to find a morsel of food and during that period, 500 children have been born to me. We have nothing to eat. If you see him, please beg him to return swiftly.

Then Pänchen Sangye Yeshe said to the Preta mother, there are many Preta’s in this world of ours. How will I recognize your husband? And she said, my husband is blind of the right eye and he totters when he walks. Then in the case of pretas, apart from the differences of appearance, they are quite akin to human beings. And Pänchen Sangye Yeshe traveling on eventually encountered the husband of this preta who confirmed to him that he had been gone for twelve human years and that in these twelve years, he had been able to find only one fistful of bread.

My apologies, it is not even a fistful of bread. It is a glob of spittle, which was spat by a virtuous bhikṣu who dedicated the spittle to the pretas. And this is why the preta husband was able to get it in his hand. It is therefore very beneficial to dedicate one’s food and not just to consume it and allow it to go to waste. Then there are numerous accounts in the LAMRIM regarding such entities, and what counts is whether or not these accounts benefit our mind.

Then it is said that a Bhikśu who passed on was reborn as a preta. And therefore, once reborn as a preta, until the maturing karma which has led to this rebirth is exhausted, it seems difficult for any type of practice to occur. Although there are accounts of pretas having attained the grounds in the paths. We now will pass to the third category of lower rebirth, the animal rebirth. All hell beings and pretas were similar in mental capacities to human beings, although experiencing far greater suffering.

In the case of the animals, the suffering experience is far lesser than that of hell beings or pretas, but the mental capacities are far lower than those of human beings. Animals are said to be extremely dull. It is said that a non virtue of great power will cause rebirth as a hell being, of middling power will cause rebirth as a preta, and of small power will cause rebirth as an animal. Irrespective of this, when we reflect on these topics, we should think, if I have accumulated the karma to be reborn, let us say, as a Preta, I myself will experience all this and contemplate it. As to the suffering of the animals, perhaps it is unnecessary for me to explain them here since they are self evident.

We can see them directly with our own eyes. Unlike the sufferings of the pretas or the hell beings, we can see that animals devour each other, that they are enslaved and put to labor, that herbivores for instance devoured by carnivores. Then if I understood the account correctly, there was a Lama of Dakpo who had two sponsors, one of which offered to him butter and the other offered meat, and because of the inversion of the offerings, they were reborn as cows in the Dakpo area, and it was said that they gave or they produced a lot of butter. And these rebirths of the sponsors were the result of the karmic debts which had been accrued with respect to Dakpo Lama. And therefore, this is why Je Tsongkhapa’s Foundation of All Qualities, the Yonten Shigyuma says one should develop heedfulness and one should train in virtue ideally, if one can continually, and if one is unable to do so, one should train as much as one can 60 or 70% of the time.

Then I have nothing left to add. If you have questions, I will take them now. If you question and because more time tonight, We have the opportunity tonight. Very good opportunity time. One question.

When you do the meditation, the way you do the meditation on the small scope for dead and impermanent, you move to the medium and great scope, do you have to also do the foundation of the small scope and then move progress to the next step and next step? I I could barely hear you. When you do the meditations They’re really close. Sorry. Can you hear me now?

Better. Okay. When you meditate on the small scope, on death in impermanence, and that person doing the medium scope and progress the great scope, do you have to in the morning to go back from the basic step the foundation of the small scope and then progress to the medium and great scope? So if you meditate in the morning on the path of the being of the small scope, and then you meditate on the path of the middling and of the great scope, do you have to go back to the path of the being of the small scope? What I mean is when when that person is in a great scope, do you have to go back you know from the beginning doing the small scope, meditated on that and then progressed to medium and great It is indispensable to have practiced the path of the beings of the small and the great scope as a foundation for the path of the being of the great scope.

And this is made evident by the denominations which are used. We speak of the path shared with the being of the small scope, the path shared or common with that of the being of the middling scope, but we do not use the terms shared or common for the great scope. So what is shared here, the path of the being of the small scope is shared with that of the great scope, the path of the being of the middling scope is shared with that of the great scope. For instance, let us say that our goal is the attainment of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. This is a great vehicle goal, but to attain this we will need in future lives to attain over and again a physical basis, a human physical basis which enables us to do that, otherwise it would be very difficult.

Now training for that basis is a practice which is shared with the being of the small scope, and to obtain such a basis we must engage in the training in ethics, in forbearance, in generosity, and so forth. Now in this context, the training in the ethics, which is the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, becomes a practice of the great vehicle. Thank you very much. I would like to ask a question about supplementary realisations and we were discussing it in our study group. I’m wondering if a supplementary realisation for a person who has fully characterised realization of death and impermanence and then meditates on the suffering of the lower realms would be the examples given in Lamrim Chenmo I think it’s at the bottom of page 116 in the Tibetan text and it says furthermore the good qualities of suffering are that you dispel arrogance develop compassion, avoid sin and delight in virtue.

I’m wondering if they might be supplementary realizations. When was supplementary realizations spoken about? Supplementary realizations of what are the path of the being of the small scope? Of death and impermanence? No, I thought it was.

The question was what are the supplementary that a person would gain from meditating on the suffering of the lower realms when that person has a fully characterised realisation of death and impermanence? What were the realizations you found? Dispel arrogance, develop compassion, avoid sin. Sorry, please. Dispel arrogance, develop compassion.

Carefully avoid sin, and delight in virtue, and they are described as the good qualities of suffering. Would you repeat them again? Dispel Pride. I’ll repeat the whole thing. I’ll give you the book.

Can I give you the book? Please, Ms. Goodread. I see. Now we know what it is, it’s from the Lamrim Chenmo.

Okay. Thank you very much. Yes indeed, so clearly if you have meditated on death and impermanence, and you meditate after this additionally on the suffering of the lower realms, you will definitely generate these four qualities. As Geshe-la mentioned, there are two types of beings. There are beings which must follow all three paths in incrementally, but there are beings who from their very birth in this life have no particular attachment to this life, and actually are beings who are predisposed towards entry directly into the path of the being of the middling scope.

Then the question which arises is, what benefit is there for these beings in meditation on death and impermanence? The benefit they derive for meditation on death and impermanence is because through understanding that death is certain and its time is uncertain, they are greatly motivated to attain the grounds and paths now while they have the possibility to do so. They derive however no particular benefit from meditating on the sufferings of the lower realms. This is a good question you ask. It’s a question which is born of reflection.

Generally, there are two types of questions, trite questions and questions which are born from reflection. This is not a trite question. I heard that when can Geshe-la explain why some people need to take refuge again when once the guru is passed away? Are you speaking of refuge or the refuge vows? I’m not sure because I heard somebody, you know, they they go they have one guru, and then the guru pass away, and then they find another guru that they are very close to and then they just take refuge.

Some of it is Vietnamese or Tibetan or Western or? Asian. Asian. That is really not the Tibetan tradition. In the Tibetan tradition, you take refuge and refuge vows from your teacher, and then when your teacher is no longer, that makes no no difference to the refuge vows, There’s no necessity to take them again from anybody.

They don’t disappear because the teacher no longer is of this world. Then, if unfortunately, you were to be or we were to be reborn in the lower realms, then once when we are once again reborn as humans, we must take refuge vows again, since the human base has disappeared. Jade. We are now in the human rebirth. It seems to me that in all the other realms we still seem to be human but experiencing great suffering.

We have a human body in the hell realm? Now if you are reborn, let’s say, in the hot you don’t have a human body, you have the body of a hell being, and that body is a product of the karma of a hell being. Maybe you’re speaking of the revival here. Everyone has arms and legs, animals too. So it is said in Buddhist scriptures that hell beings and pretas akin to human beings in intelligence, and they even have some type of paranormal perception.

They know the karma which led to their being reborn as a hell being or a preta. Going back to last week’s teaching, Geshe-la asked us a question which we all got wrong and I would like to propose my thoughts on that. Geshe said someone who has gained a fully characterized sorry the question is for someone who is a fully characterized experience of death and impermanence what is the purpose of meditating on the suffering of the lower realms? And saying that this leads to a supplementary realization. So is the supplementary realization of meditating on the suffering of the lower rebirths having renounced the vanities of this life having through meditating on death and impermanence is a supplementary realization to renounce the suffering of the lower realms and then further then to renounce the vanities of future lives as part of developing a fully characterized renunciation of saṃsāra?

Yes. That’s that’s the purpose. Is the only way of leaving the lower realms only when your karma has been exhausted because it doesn’t seem there’s any other way to be able to leave or go up in the realms? It is probably possible there is a passage in the Buddhist scriptures in which I think in the Jātaka, the Buddha was reborn in a higher realm without completing his stay in one of the lower realms. Geshe-la, very beginning of today’s teaching about impelling karma that if it’ll be that which is closest between virtue and non virtue but if they’re equal in terms of the closest then it is that which is earliest which impels us.

Given our rebirth go back through beginningless time is the earliest karmic imprint that would be that impelling karmic imprint is that the earliest karmic imprint of our current rebirth Like of the first, so which would be like a first action of body, speech and mind after our birth? Yours is a very sharp question indeed. There are two possible answers. The first is that it just refers to which has been accumulated before the time of death. The second is that it refers to karma accumulated in the time before this life, means the previous life.

Nothing? My question is regarding the passage of time in different realms and just to help explanation Elliot have you read The Lion, Witch and the Wardrobe? Sorry. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe. No it’s a children’s book.

Okay I’ll explain it in a different way. In The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe there’s a human realm and then there’s this other place called Narnia and when one year passes in the human realm lots and lots of years pass in narnia. That’s the gist of it. So it seems to me from reading the Lamrim and Buddhist sutras that when it said and I’ll use the example in the Lamrim that fifty of our human years constitute one day for the gods in the realm of the four Maharajas if a person died say on day one and was born for one day in the realm of the four Maharajas that only one day one human day would have passed although they would have experienced the equivalent of fifty of our human years. This is what makes sense to me.

I’m wondering how Geshe-la sees it. So when you are reborn in the realm of the four kings, in the the God realm of the four kings, after one day of life, fifty four human years on earth would have passed. Got a trite one now. Geshe-la said about prettas descending and manifesting as human beings although he said that he wasn’t quite sure about that. So does this mean that you know prettas actually walk amongst us in the human realm?

No. When a for instance, king spirit possesses a human being, that possessed human being is not a preta. And Thursday, next week is a trip to Virgon on the thirty-first. So there’s a 05:30 those who are going to take the refuge, please make sure come before 05:30. And 05:30, we’ll start the refuge now.

And then

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Once a person is practicing in the great scope, do they still need to go back to the practices of the small and middling scopes?

Yes. Practicing the paths of the small and middling scopes is indispensable as a foundation for the path of the great scope. This is shown by the terms used: the small scope path is called shared with the middling scope, and the small and middling scope paths are called shared with the great scope, but no such term is used for the great scope itself. For example, if the goal is full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, we need to obtain a human physical basis again and again in future lives. Training for that basis is shared with the small scope, through ethics, forbearance, generosity and so forth.

Scroll to Top