Death and Rebirth – 2014-06-25 – KR

1 h 38 min · 3,956 words · 25 June 2014

Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth (Khensur Rinpoche)
Death and Rebirth - 2014-06-25 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains that Dharma practice is preparation for death, and that a healthy fear of death can motivate practice. It presents the Lamrim nine-point death meditation on the three roots, nine reasons and three resolves, and urges training the mind to complete the path of the small scope before death. A question and answer session follows on near-death experiences and whether practitioners can overcome fear of death.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 39m

UUID: f72c9235-a954-4db2-a8ad-16fc9b3e50f1

Date: 2014-06-25

Words: 3,952

All of us should put effort in Dharma practice and this effort entails study, study in turn which leads to practice. There are numerous forms of Dharma in keeping with one’s own mental outlook, one’s way of thinking, but whichever one engages in, one should behave in accordance, otherwise it is rather odd. There must be a difference posited between those who accept a Dharma and those who accept no Dharma. Clearly, when one accepts a Dharma, one studies it and one eventually puts it into practice. The difference between oneself and someone who has no Dharma whatsoever can only increase.

Should one be someone who verbally accepts Dharma but puts no effort in practice, there will be no real difference with someone who accepts no Dharma whatsoever. Then at the time of death, one will face considerable difficulties and even in the here and now, will face problems such as pride and so forth. Then should one’s study and practice of Dharma become the occasion for the increase in pride and arrogance, then Dharma will have become anti Dharma. And at this point it will be harmful. It is akin to the situation of water and fire.

Normally it is said that to extinguish fire, we pour water on it. Now if water cannot extinguish fire anymore, then what is left which can extinguish fire? If one engages in the study of Dharma and that study leads to practice, then the difference between one who accepts or endorses Dharma and one who does not will become ever greater and can only increase over time. And then, when hardship occurs in one’s life and one experiences suffering, one will consider that one’s own karma is at fault, and reflect on the fact that one is one’s own master and one is responsible for one’s destiny. Then in this world of ours, the greatest difficulty, the greatest form of suffering we can encounter is death.

And in this respect, there is a tremendous difference between a Dharma practitioner and one who does not practice Dharma. One who does not practice Dharma and whose mind is an extremely narrow, limited mind can only experience great suffering at this time. The first difference between those who accept Dharma and those who do not accept Dharma is that someone who accepts dharma by definition is focused on future lives and beyond. For such a person, this focus on future lives and beyond means that there will not be great fear and anguish at the time of death. On the other hand, someone who has never given a single thought to what happens after death and who does not accept the existence of past and future lives will feel ever greater fear and anguish as a time of death approaches or as he or she grows older.

To give an example, the difference between those who accept dharma and those who do not accept dharma is best understood in the following example. If somebody has to jump from the roof of a tall house, and that person is able to look at the ground and ascertain where he or she is going to fall, and establish that it’s basically a fairly level and soft area, then when they jump, there will be much less fear, and they will be prepared to land correctly. This is a case of someone who accepts dharma, and who understands that there are past and future lives, and understands how to prepare himself. Someone who does not accept dharma is someone who must jump from a high building, has no way of knowing what the ground looks like and where he or she is going to fall, then this can give rise only to great fear. So if you wish, this situation is a bit akin to the poor people on Malaysia Airlines flight three seventy, which crashed in the ocean and had no clue of what was happening to them, it is not the case that past and future lives exist for those who accept its existence, in other words, Dharma practitioners, and somehow don’t exist for those who don’t accept their existence, They exist for all.

This is an example of the greater and lesser fear one encounters. So for a dharma practitioner, this fear of death is a needle which prompts him or her to prepare for death. Dharma is nothing else but the preparation for death. Then this preparation means that at the time of death there will be little fear and anguish. Someone on the other hand who is not a dharma practitioner, who focuses exclusively on the happiness of this life, will experience great anguish, great fear at the time of death.

In this world of ours, we are all familiar with schools and the way one progresses from class to class to the higher grades. In our dharma training, this is how we should proceed. Then indeed, we should implant karmic imprints for the future. But what precisely imprints karmic imprints and what doesn’t is something we have to examine for ourselves. We need at least one stable one.

We must therefore analyze for ourselves how to proceed. Another cannot analyze for us. It is something we must do for ourselves, and now is the time to do this. As Śāntideva said in Bodhicharyavatara, if at present when I have obtained a precious human rebirth, I put no effort and let it go to waste, What a tragedy this would be. What a tragedy indeed it would be if we did not put our precious human rebirth to good use.

And it is at present that we must put effort since we have such a precious human rebirth, not merely in implanted karmic imprints, but trying to realize what can be realized, so that eventually we can attain the state of full enlightenment, which is our goal. Now when we reflect on attaining the state of full enlightenment, the goal may seem very far away and this can induce a certain form of disheartenment or depression. So this is to be countered with the resolve to practice what can be practiced now. And therefore we must have the resolve in this life, while I have not died, while I am still alive, I will practice and attain what can be practiced and attained. Karmic imprints, whatever.

It is difficult to know what karmic imprints are stable and not, and it is only the stable ones which are relevant. Then in India, for instance, when one builds a house, first one casts the foundation out of cement, and then on this basis, one erects the house. Ideally, we will erect the house to full enlightenment within one lifetime. If this is not possible, then we will erect story by story from lifetime to lifetime until we complete our goal. How should we go about this?

How should we go about this? We need to actually make a pledge in this respect. Then one must continually work for as long as one is allowed to do this. Then as Potowa Rinchen Sel in parallel with the Lamrim teachings said in a metaphor, when a farmer sees a storm gathering in the distance, he will try to save all his cattle. If he is unable to save all his cattle and sheep, at least he will save one flock.

In our case likewise, ideally in this life, we will complete the practices of the beings of all three scopes, small, middling and great scope. But if we are unable to do that, at the very least in this life, we should complete the practice of the being of the small scope and there is work to do for this. How is that? Then if we pledge, if we commit to generate the path of the being of the small scope within our mind before we die in this life, this is quite something. And then on this basis in future lives, having implanted the karmic imprints and hopefully, predispositions for training in the path of the middling and the great scope will arise.

Then focusing exclusively on the practice of the being of the small scope, we would study and we would practice this. This would become our own system, and we would start erecting our own house from the 1st storey upwards. Then the practice of the being of the small scope is not a complex practice. We don’t have complex concepts such as the subtle selflessness of persons, non duality, things which are difficult to understand. There are a couple of simple meditations on death and impermanence.

Who doesn’t understand death and impermanence? Animals understand death. When an animal is walking down the path and it encounters a threat, it withdraws immediately. In other words, it understands death. And therefore, the oath we should take is, in this life, before I die, I will complete the path of the being of the small scope.

And therefore the motivation to be generated for these teachings is, while I am still alive before I die in this life, I will complete the path of the being of the small scope. Now we mention while I am still alive before I die simply because after death we have little or no control at all. So it is fully alive and we have control, we have autonomy that this must be done. And therefore, let us generate the motivation to train in the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope. Then if we decide to definitely generate within our mind stream the path of the being of the small scope in this life before we die, our practice in our studies will become easier.

Having decided to generate within our mind stream the path of the being of the small scope, we must find a means or a method to do so. We need a means or a method for this, and the method is thinking about death. The meditations which are related with death and thinking about death give rise to the fear of death, And when this great fear of death arises within our minds, then we try to find a means to be freed from it, to be liberated from it, and this leads to practice. It would be silly otherwise to generate such a fear with no means of being liberated from it. So you have to give rise to fear of death.

This is very important and it is at present that we can train in this, prepare for this. It is important to point out, I am not speaking of a fear of death, which is a fear of losing one’s friends, one’s relatives, one’s resources and one’s aging body. This is something everyone has without having studied, it’s not necessary to study for this. So what is explained in Lamrim as the fear of death is instead this fear which arises at the thought, what will happen to me if at the time of my death I realize I have not practiced a fully characterized path, for instance, of the being of the small scope? And as is said, from non virtue there is only suffering in the lower rebirth.

In this case, the road of the future is a dark and a bleak one. And therefore, thinking upon our impending death over and again, we put effort in training our mind in the practice of the being of the small scope. And as the time of our death approaches, our mental training increases as well. Ideally, we will have completed the path of the being of the small scope in this life. If that is not possible, we will at least have trained our mind repeatedly so that at the time of death, things go easier for us.

Without training, it will not be possible. And this is why the injunction of Je Tsongkhapa is meditate on death and impermanence, since this meditation on death and impermanence gives rise to fear and this fear impels us to the practice of Dharma. Then I am not sure of what type of meditation you engage in, but when Je Tsongkhapa says in his injunction, meditate on death and impermanence, it’s a specific form of meditation he refers to. And this is explicit in the outline of the graduated stages of the path, where you have first a presentation of the disadvantages of not meditate meditating on death and impermanence, then a presentation of the advantages, and then in the third outline, a presentation of the method of recollecting death, which is twofold. This is very clear, and these presentations are methods.

The first of these is recollecting death and impermanence through meditating on the three roots, the nine reasons and the three resolves. The three roots are justified by the nine reasons and give rise to the three resolves of the three decisions. Then I will not re explain these in detail. They have been explained already. They are in Liberation of the Palm of Your Hand.

They are likewise presented in detail in Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the Path. Please read them. The first reason is that my own death is certain or definite. This predicate my own death is certain is justified by three reasons. These three reasons are first, that numerous causes contribute to my death and nothing can hinder it.

The second is that nothing is being added to my life, time is only being subtracted from it. The third is that even while alive, I am unable to find the leisure to practice Dharma. Reflecting over and again on these three reasons, we will generate a very strong sense of the predicate, the time of my death is certain. This is meditation. Meditation is not advanced in difficult topics like calm abiding, which are very far removed from our reality.

It is taking the time, one hour or whatever one has, and reflecting on topics such as this one, my death is certain. My death is certain because of these three reasons. And going incrementally through the three reasons and through the predicate over and again. Then whatever amount of time one might have, let us say one hour, such meditation does not refer to reading the text. One reads the text first and after having tried to memorize what one can, one closes the text, sets it aside, and one reflects on the topic over and again.

Then in the case of the certainty of our own death, this is a topic which we should reflect upon in this way. For thousands of years in human history, there has not been a single person who has not died. Every single human being who has lived in the past has died. The first root therefore should be meditated upon as follows. I will definitely die.

It is certain that I will die. It is certain that I will die because of the three reasons which were given. But these three reasons are merely the three reasons given in Buddhist scriptures. There are countless other reasons we should invoke to justify this position that it is certain that we will die. We can reflect, for instance, carefully on the first reason, that there is nothing which can prevent death from occurring.

This is self evident. The teacher of the past Buddha Śākyamūni himself died. Ārya Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, all the great teachers of ancient India died. Most of our teachers are dead already. We ourselves will die definitely.

The second reason for which our death, my own death is certain is because nothing is being added to my lifespan and time is being subtracted uninterruptedly from it. This is self evident. We can say actually that at the very instant we were born, the decision that we would die had already been taken. Then those of us who are elderly should reflect, in this life it is possible we will die, but in ten years it is guaranteed we will die. Then if it is possible that we will die in this year, what exactly will we do?

In a hundred years, nobody in this room will be left. It is certain we will die. So it is now we should reflect upon it. And therefore when meditating on this second reason, no time whatsoever is being added to my life, time is uninterruptedly being subtracted from my lifespan, the strong feeling of the certainty of my own death arises, and at this point, fear arises, then we can say that we have gained an experience of death and impermanence. And, the Kadampas of yore, and this was taken over by Je Tsongkhapa, said that this fear of death is actually the means to progress towards the future.

And then in dependence on the condition of this fear of death, we will actually focus upon practice. What practice? The practice of karma and causality in keeping with the injunction in Je Tsongkhapa’s Foundation of All Good Qualities, practice heedfulness. As Geshe Potowa says in the Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path, my core practice is death and impermanence, since death and impermanence is the fountainhead of all practices. If one’s recollection of death degenerates, so do all one’s practices.

And this is therefore how we should practice until we die. All of us in this room definitely have the time before we die to realize the practice of the being of the small scope. This is not difficult. It is not a complex demanding practice. It is of great benefit at the time of death since we will die at peace.

And therefore, let us try to memorize the three roots, the nine reasons and these three resolves in accordance with the great stages of the path and put them in practice. Then I have nothing extra to add, I will stop here. If you have questions, I am open to a couple of questions. Behind you Chris. Thank you Geshe-la.

I wanted to ask a question along the lines of Wynn what West called near death experiences. Near death experiences from what I’ve read from books both in Tārā Institute library and through my own research occur when physiologically death is imminent or when the person psychologically feels that death is imminent. They characterised by a feeling of being out of the body, by a feeling I’ll talk about the good ones first by a feeling of peace and joy and often meeting with either deceased relatives or other people that might take them to another realm. I was wondering if there’s anything any occurrences like this in Tibetan culture. We have to distinguish between ordinary medical death and death from the standpoint of Buddhist scriptures, which occurs when the subtle most level of mind has been reached.

When the subtle most level of mind has been reached, it is difficult to envision any type of return into one’s body, since at that point one would immediately enter the intermediate state as a bardo being. Geshe-la, is coarse impermanence an accelerated subtle impermanence? Coarse impermanence can be understood in terms of subtle impermanence, but it is not subtle impermanence. I’m just trying to understand either way we’re going to be in fear when we die whether we practice Dharma or not because we’re practicing. Please do increase because my hearing is not what it used to be.

Because when we practice, we still are going to be fearful of the fact that we might be going into a lower rebirth or just that intermediate stage. So we’re still going to be in fear when we die either way. Is that correct? Someone who practices Dharma through recollecting death and the fear which arises from that has access to the means to eliminate that fear. Someone who does not recollect death will not have access to those means to eliminate fear.

As well as meditating on the nine point death meditation of the Lam Rim I also find it helpful to meditate on the actual death simulation process of actually visualizing myself sick and then dying. Would Geshe-la, is that a valid practice to do that as well? There’s no difference. Meditating on the appearance of death is meditating on one’s own death, visualizing oneself as dying, the emotions one experiences, and so forth. I’d like to ask another question about we call near death experiences.

From the literature I think it’s difficult to say that it’s actually a death experience because about fifty percent of cases are where the person is not actually close to death they just think they are. And as far as I understand the Buddhist death process for ordinary beings happens in almost a single moment or an extraordinarily short period of time. My question at this stage is though the research shows that in general most major cultures of the world have had these phenomena reported for hundreds and hundreds of years and I’d find it strange if Tibetan culture didn’t have any of these experiences reported. So are there any experiences of these kind reported in Tibetan culture? The problem is that you do not agree on the definition of death.

You are talking of medical death or medical stress experiences. From a Buddhist standpoint, this is not death. Death is when the mind enters a state of clear light. And Geshe-la said that he has never encountered the case of someone whose mind has reached the fundamental state of clear light and who has returned. I know one case of a westerner who has become an exceptional dharma practitioner, one of the most exceptional I know, who had a car accident at 21 in Hamburg and was pronounced dead on arrival at the hospital, was resurrected and had clear memories of being told during the death experiences by what she described as very beautiful women that the time had not come for her to die and she had to return.

This person became a Buddhist immediately on encounter with the Buddhist teachings in the person of Geshe-la in Dharamsala, and because she had such powerful experiences, her practice was extraordinary. I was I told Geshe-la she must have offered in excess of 1,000,000 prostrations in Bodh Gaya. Now this is not someone who experienced the subtlemost mind of death, but medically it is a near death experience. Chris? With the nine point death meditation, the first root death is certain.

One of the reasons being one cannot add time to life, one gets closer to death with each moment. However long life practices work to extend one’s life. My understanding is that for example if someone dies in a car accident at say 40 they may still have the karma to live another twenty years but that could Geshe-la please explain how long life practices work? I will think about your question and I will answer it next time. Practices such as offering long life pujas, performing tenshug, receiving long life initiations seem at first hand to be at odds with the idea of not being able to extend one’s lifespan.

However, I believe that there is a means of explaining them, which eliminates the contradiction. I will cover that next time. All right. Stop. Thank you.

His Holiness’s birthday celebration, we’re having lunch here provided by TBI on Sunday July 6 from 11:30 till approximately 02:30. So just to get an idea of numbers, if you’d like to send us an email or let us know if you’re coming that will help with catering. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
nine-point death meditation
The nine-point death meditation is an important meditation on the impermanence of this life. LYWA
prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top