2 h 50 min · 21,187 words · 20 October 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher argues that meditation on death and impermanence is the most transformative practice, especially for Westerners, and explains subtle and coarse impermanence, the three roots, nine reasons and three convictions, and visualisations of one’s own death and decay. He then outlines the Kadampa ten jewels and closes with a question and answer session on sincerity, vows and practice.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 51m
UUID: a6e8cd84-0ca3-45e0-bcf9-03509108b9bb
Date: 2012-10-20
Words: 21,183
Well, a very good afternoon to everybody. Thank you for coming to another seminar by Ilya Juravic. And I’m sure that we’re in for another feast for the mind. And for those of you who haven’t met before, we are very fortunate to have Ilya who is a great supporter and benefactor of Tibetan Buddhist Institute, translator for our founder and mentor Kyabje Khensur Kangur Rinpoche, whose picture is up on the wall up there and currently in Sera Jey Monastery in India. Ilya will talk obviously more about the topic death, impermanence and the 10 innermost jewels of the Kadampa tradition.
We are very fortunate that Ilya is able to provide a bifocal view of Eastern and Western thought and to help us as Western students to bring to the fore our unexamined assumptions as we take an interest and pursue an interest in Buddhism. And Ilya has been a translator for many great teachers apart from Khensur Rinpoche, Geshe Rabten, and many others, and has translated for His Holiness the Dalai Lama. So and has been a former monk at Sera Jey Monastery. I won’t say anymore, but other than just to say thank you so much, Ilya, and I’ll be very happy to hand over to you. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Thank you very much. And I’m delighted to see so many known faces as well as a couple of new faces. It’s a great pleasure to have you all here for what is the last conference, the last seminar of this year before my trip to India. I look forward to continuing giving these seminars next year.
However, perhaps on a more infrequent basis because of other responsibilities which I have. But we will continue our shared exploration of the Buddhist teachings meeting perhaps once every two months. Our topic today is conceptually an easy topic. It is experientially an extraordinarily difficult topic in particular for a Western audience which spends much of its life in denial of the fact that it will inevitably die. The westerner who is accustomed to the fantasy of control, the illusion of control over every aspect of his life tends to die badly.
We have quite a few people here who work in palliative care. You can speak to them privately after I myself used to visit in hospitals in Switzerland. I was often surprised at how difficult the death of Westerners is as opposed to the very simple and easy deaths of people from more traditional cultures with perhaps simpler sets of belief. Now thinking about death is not a which we can dispense with. To dispense with thinking about death is akin to a student who has a final exam at the end of the year and who figures if he doesn’t think about it somehow it’s not going to happen and he doesn’t have to prepare.
It would be very nice if that was the way things were, unfortunately it isn’t. The tragedy about talking about death to a western audience especially from a Buddhist perspective western is that typically one talks about death to people who are already aware of their own mortality. There’s a preselection in the audience. Very few if any of you are under the ages of 40 or maybe even 50. Then by the time the person realizes that the axe has started falling it is late.
Sometimes it is too late. We get I’d say regularly I mean I wouldn’t say it’s a weekly occurrence but certainly almost a monthly occurrence terminal patients with cancer coming to the center who have just been told they have six months, one year left to live perhaps left, perhaps less. And then they come in a state of emergency of extreme distress trying to address in six months or less what was left unaddressed for one entire life. There simply isn’t time. It is simply not possible to find core answers which would enable every one of us to cross this very difficult passage in a couple of months.
Therefore it is for the going is good which means now for most of us that these reflections must be engaged in. Once your doctor says he wants to do a biopsy, once you have had your first stroke, once you have had the first heart transplant, it is late. I’m not saying it is too late but it is late. There are things which are no longer possible. The next life is already there.
As a great Kadampa Geshe has always said, all that separates us from the next life is this breath. When this breath stops, you are already moving to the next life. So as I said, it is the the tragedy of the West that when one tries to address the fundamental issue which is what happens after death, typically one’s audience is in a situation where what they can do about it is already limited. It is my personal opinion and I think it has been shared by all of the great philosophers Buddhist and non-Buddhist that the only meaningful life is lived in the light of death. If you do not assess your life in the light of death, your life is like that of a parakeet.
It is meaningless. It may be beautiful, it may be filled with satisfactions but it is transient, ephemeral and meaningless. This is why in the Buddhist tradition it is said that meditation on death is like the footprint of the elephant. There is no greater transformative meditation which is which exists. It is far more transformative for the ordinary person than meditation on emptiness.
For the very simple reason that emptiness is conceptually extremely difficult to understand and I can basically guarantee if you’re meditating on emptiness or if you think you’re meditating on emptiness that you’re meditating on something else than the correct view of emptiness. For someone who has not studied carefully, and these are years of study, meditation on emptiness is not an option. One ends up meditating on an absence which can lead to rebirth in for instance the formless realms or one ends up in some wrong practice of Mahāmudrā which actually dulls the mind and leads to rebirth as an animal. And we see this among westerners. Meditation on impermanence and death, however, is easy.
The concepts are easy, and it has to be the core of one’s practice. I cannot recommend another type of meditation day in, day out than this meditation. And for us I would say instead of meditating on advanced topics such as bodhicitta, renunciation, the correct view, meditation on death and impermanence every single day of our life will radically transform the way we live and the way we think. We will turn from fluttering socialites into people with weight, with gravitas. So it is for this reason that Je Tsongkhapa famously said in his three principles of the path, without pure definite emergence, there is no means to pacify the striving for the happy fruits of the ocean of existence.
In as much as the embodied are totally fettered by the desire for existence, initially you will search for definite emergence. Here definite emergence or renunciation is not understood by Je Tsongkhapa in the ordinary sense of the term as renunciation from cyclic existence. Je Tsongkhapa differentiates two types of renunciation. Renunciation of this life and renunciation of all lives. It is not possible to generate renunciation of all lives which is very difficult to generate if one doesn’t have certainty in the existence of past and future lives and cannot meditate correctly on the eighty-six sufferings and the three sufferings.
It is not possible to generate renunciation of all lives without renunciation of this life. And to generate renunciation on this life, there is no means more powerful than meditation on death and impermanence. And this is shared with all of the great spiritual traditions without one single exception. However, I think we can say that in no tradition has meditation on death and impermanence been developed so powerfully as in the Buddhist tradition. In today I would like to have a bit more of an experiential presentation than usually since the concepts as we said are not difficult, but it is this taste of one’s own end, one’s own transience which we have to acquire.
So we will try to intersperse this with two or three meditation sessions. I will show you pictures of the decay of the human body. Then, those of you who are uncomfortable with this are welcome to leave. Not everyone, is able to, look at this type of picture and we will be meditating on ourselves going through this process, which is one of the three modes of meditation on death in the Buddhist tradition. So I prefer to tell you in advance.
Now renunciation of this life as we said is shared with all of the great spiritual traditions and for instance, it is definitely shared with the Christian tradition. As you may know, the Latin translator of the bible, Saint Jerome, was always accompanied by a skull and he is represented in Renaissance paintings holding a skull which he used as a support for meditation. The Carthusian monks of whom this is one example, live in perpetual memento moris, contemplation of death. And as some of you may know, they take the vow of eternal silence and live as hermits. These are two practitioners of this level of the path.
This is the path of the being of small scope. Meditation on death and impairments is the central meditation of this path and it is shared with other traditions. As Je Tsongkhapa says, this life of leisure and endowment is rare and life does not last. By habituating the mind, turn away from the vanities of this life. In the Lamrim presentation and we have started talking about the Lamrim two sessions ago.
Meditation on death and impermanence is presented late. It is presented after a first presentation of Guru Yoga and after a presentation of what is known as a precious human rebirth, or a rebirth of leisure and endowment to prompt the practitioner onwards. To prompt the practitioner to take the essence of this precious human rebirth. And this is why here in this quote, Je Tsongkhapa mentions life does not last which refers to meditation on death and impermanence after meditation on leisure and endowment. So I have presented death and impermanence in the traditional sequence which I think is not beneficial for a western audience.
My personal feeling is that for a western audience, meditation on death and impermanence should be presented first. This choice of presentation in the Tibetan tradition simply was because Je Tsongkhapa was addressing a community of people for whom life after this life was taken for granted. It was taken for granted that all beings reincarnated. It was unnecessary to demonstrate this and therefore the goal of meditation on death in the Lamrim is to urge one to take the essence of this precious human rebirth. However, for westerners, meditation on death is what gets the person started on the path because most westerners live in complete denial of their own end.
For this reason, you are Buddhist or not, I think you owe it to yourself to reflect every single day on death. This will change the way you look at your life and it will give greater a greater edge to whatever spiritual questions you ask yourselves. Once you start meditating daily on death, it is no longer possible to evacuate the core questions. Who am I? Where do I come from?
Where do I go? These questions can only be evacuated and one can only live the typically hedonistic life which characterizes much of the West but Australia to an extreme degree if one never reflects at all on one’s own demise. Anything which can help you to do this is of great benefit. In my own case when I lived at the monastery, the, charnel grounds of the monastery where we burnt the bodies of the monk were some 400 yards from my, room. Then obviously in Australia, you probably do not have these experiences but the bodies of the monks would be carried wrapped up in sheets, to these charnel grounds to be burned and India being a very hot country, by the time the body was carried, there was this definite stench of human putrefaction which is unforgettable once you have smelled it.
It is a sweetish smell, which is really, both cloying and revolting. Then because there was little or no wood, wood is extremely expensive, the bodies would be burnt and what little wood there was, with large admixtures of gasoline. So we smelled literally barbecues. It smells exactly like barbecuing pork coming in and yet you know it is a human flesh. Then for myself when I was, at Sera Jey, whenever I had a moment every two or three days, I would go to the, charnel ground, the incineration ground and I would meditate there ten, fifteen minutes.
You could find the fragments of the bones of the monks and I took one of the fragments, It’s not it’s not big or it’s this big. I don’t know what bone it was it had cracked. They cracked the bones with mallets at the end, you know. And then I put it on my altar and it was one of my objects of refuge. It was much more beneficial for my mind than the statue of the Buddha and all the texts I had.
Because this one bone kept my own mortality in my own mind. I looked at it and I thought, he like you spoke, laughed and loved, there will you go. It is a tremendous anchor. Whatever tragedies we experience in our life, if we can anchor ourselves in our own forthcoming demise, then these tragedies become quite trite in ephemera. So we are speaking here of meditation on impermanence and death and therefore we do have to clarify what is understood by meditation in a Buddhist context.
There are so many misunderstandings about meditation and, I think many of you do not attend the teachings. I feel it is necessary to talk about this briefly. In a nutshell, meditation are a set or is a set of techniques to transform the mind. To transform the mind through habituation. The Tibetan term meditation, gompa, derives from the same root gom pa, which means to become accustomed to.
So the crux of a essence of the totality of the Buddhist practice is to accustom the mind to the way things are in reality as opposed to the way we fantasize things to be. And we ascertain the way things are in reality through observation and reason. For this reason, in many senses of the term it can be said, Buddhism is not a religion. It is much closer to the Greek ideal of a philosophy. Something which is lived and transforms a person but for instance all of this is unnecessary.
The temple, the statues, books, the rituals are totally unnecessary. They are prompts which are extraordinarily beneficial but they are prompts to lead to this stage of mental transformation. When the prompts substitute themselves to the mental transformation they are to lead to, this defeats their very purpose. Meditation involves three activities. Hearing, in other words studying, thinking which is reflecting on what one has studied or the teachings one has heard in meditating.
Now hearing includes attending teachings, obviously, reading, you can, engage in hearing at home, reading a text and receiving oral instructions privately from the teacher. Thinking is that mental process which really starts during hearing where you start reflecting on what you have heard and assessing its veracity. This assessment of the truth of what you have heard is critical. Our goal is to attain truth and to transform our minds in function of truth. If you don’t believe there is such a thing as truth in reality, you are wasting your time in the Buddhist tradition.
You are typical westerner who lives in constant ambivalence. The Buddhist tradition is profoundly within the belief belief that between experience and reason we can accede to the actual reality of things and once we have done this, we check whether our mind perceives things in accordance with this reality or not and generally speaking we realize it doesn’t. Then we see that this is the root of unhappiness. The world is like this and we perceive it like this. The world we cannot change.
Our minds we can change. We change our minds to be in accordance with the way things are and in so doing we find peace and happiness. Meditation in turn is divided into two, analytical meditation and fixative meditation. These are the two activities of the mind in the normal state, which is thinking about something and focusing on it. The difference is that here it is engaged in a controlled fashion.
The totality of the Buddhist path, everything, sūtra and tantra is summarized within these three activities. There’s nothing apart from this. Now through engaging in hearing, a certain wisdom, the wisdom arisen from hearing arises. This is understanding. Then through thinking, the wisdom arisen from thinking arises which is already much deeper.
If you have the wisdom arisen from thinking for impermanence for instance, you are very fortunate. You will not live the same way as before. And when this has arisen, you meditate and eventually the wisdom arisen from meditation arises. They are different in terms of their karmic weights. In other words, their impact on future lives.
The wisdom arisen from hearing is superficial. You will have a smattering of it in future lives but not a lot. The wisdom arisen from thinking the imprints are deeper. They will be carried with you to future lives. When you are reborn in a future life, hopefully as a human being, you will look at the world differently.
Certain thoughts will spring spontaneously in your mind. This is a result of the wisdom arisen from thinking. Finally, the deepest is the wisdom arisen from meditation. When that has been generated you are born looking at the world differently. Then the goal is that wisdom arisen from meditation.
These three wisdoms can be generated on any topic which is taught in the Buddhist tradition but you can see that as your goal is to transform your mind and to look at the world differently. You want to be very sure you are transforming your mind in the right direction. You must be sure that what you have determined to be reality is true. Otherwise, you may have experiences no one else has had before. And I don’t mean this in the good sense of the term.
So what is impermanence? When I was at Sera, I used to meditate on the wheat fields. Then we get a very sharp sense of inclement when it looks at wheat swaying in the wind because one sees it instant by instant it is changing. The sound is changing. The feeling of the wind is changing on the body.
Then when you reflect that your own body as well as your mind is changing to the same rhythm, you get an extraordinary sense of detachment from this world. There’s no point really in a lot of things we engage in. And before talking about impermanence from the standpoint of physics which I would like to address during this first hour, I would like to talk about impermanence from the standpoint of history because it is in this sense that we get a sense of what the ancients called vanitas vanitas, the vanity of vanities. It’s actually comes from the Ecclesiastes, a beautiful book in the in the bible. The futility of almost everything.
And if we look at impermanence in the history, we study it through the rise and the fall of the great civilizations. And it’s an extraordinary benefit if you want to meditate on impermanence to study history. The broad scope of history. To think that gigantic civilizations like the Roman Empire which controlled much of the known world rose and disappeared for such a degree that almost no traces were left. That other civilizations and this is the one I would like to talk briefly about today, the Angkor civilization were unknown until one hundred and fifty years ago.
It may sound difficult to believe that Angkor Wat was rediscovered one hundred and fifty years ago and this was not as you may think a temple complex in Cambodia of nominal relevance to world civilization. The Khmer kingdom which ruled in Cambodia from August to 1431 was the biggest urban civilization in history until the nineteenth century. Angkor itself had a population of almost 1,000,000 when London had a population of 45,000. While Angkor Wat was entirely erected on the control of hydraulics and of irrigation and had something akin to a modern system of water distribution and sewage. Our ancestors, your ancestors as Australians in this room lived in filth in on a small island off the European coast.
This is impermanence at the level of civilizations. This great civilization which was the leading civilization in Asia of its age, a megalopolis of 1,000,000, disappeared to such a degree that actually the temples itself were rediscovered one century and some ago and the extent of the civilization has been rediscovered by Australian scientists within the last decade, the last ten years. It was forgotten. Likewise, the largest empire in terms of extent history as has known was the Mongol Empire which stretched from Korea into Europe to the doors of Budapest and Vienna. Jan Sobieski as you know defeated the Ottomans.
This gigantic empire has disappeared without leaving a trace. All that is left is a small Central Asian state irrelevant to world politics. Some 800 ago this was the most feared power in history. We ourselves are in precisely the same situation. You are the descendants of colonizers in Australia, the products of an imperial and colonial civilization which rose from oblivion around 1600 and disappeared due to debt into World War II at the end of due to debt and war at the end of World War II.
The civilization which landed most of you on these shores has basically become broadly speaking irrelevant in a short three centuries. And your country then became a de facto dominion of the leading imperium, United States imperium, world imperium, which is at present on its decline. The span of the American imperium has been some sixty years. And just like The Buddhas imperium, it is being destroyed by debt and war. The forthcoming imperium will probably be the Chinese imperium to which you will have to learn to bow like the rest of us.
Now this is the cycle of impermanence and transition at the level of history of civilizations. Entire cultures and civilizations pass. They rise, they become dominant, they impose their language worldwide, they disappear and nobody even knows they existed. What happens at the level of civilizations happens at the level of individual and happens at the level of matter. So it is very helpful to get an overview of impermanence to look at these three levels of impermanence and we will directly pass to the more difficult level.
I try to cover these things during the first hour which is physical impermanence and specifically subtle impermanence. The Buddhist view of impermanence is extraordinarily modern. It is striking to think that up to maybe two centuries ago it was intellectually respectable certainly among educated spheres in the West to consider that phenomena were permanent. Change was an accident. Aristotle refers to change as the accident.
Matter did not change except by accident. And it’s actually with the advent of modern physics and to a lesser degree modern biology that it has become glaringly obvious that matter and life change instant by instant and that the ancient intuition of the Buddha himself twenty five centuries ago is fundamentally correct. I think there is no other example in history of a core intuition of that nature rooted exclusively in analysis which has withstood the test of 25 centuries to be proven true. And I remember the most extraordinary conversation I had with the dean of the the faculty of philosophy at the University of Adelaide over lunch. We were talking, he’s known Aristotelian and analytical philosopher and he lowered his voice at the end of lunch and he said to me, you know, I could be convinced that phenomena are impermanent.
Then I was so shocked that honestly I didn’t know what to say to him. I did not know what to say. Faced with the massive data which is coming in from the sciences, western philosophy at least parts of western philosophy still talk of the permanence of phenomena. This is an extraordinary level of cultural bias which is still prevalent in our societies. So if we try to understand subtle impermanence from the standpoint of physics, perhaps one of the seminal figures is the founder of quantum physics, Max Planck.
Who perhaps wasn’t aware of what he founded when he started his research in the way in which electrons responded to radiation, it was known as the black box phenomenon. Planck in addition to his famous constant, the Planck constant formulated theoretically at first and it is now recognized by physicists. The notion that there was a minimal length in space as well as a minimal duration of time which could not be transcended. The so called Planck lengths. It is extraordinarily small.
It is some 10 minus 20 times the size of a proton. So a proton as you know is the core particle, one of the two particles with the neutrons in the nucleus of the atom. But zero point and then you add 19 zeros and one one times that radius is the smallest possible length which is allowable by physics in the universe as we know it. Now where this is relevant for our topic is that Planck length leads directly to Planck time. The shortest possible instant of time which is not as the ancient Buddhist philosopher said one sixtieth or one three hundred and sixtieth of the time it takes to snap one’s fingers but at least theoretically zero point followed by 43 zeros and then a five seconds.
This has never been measured but the shortest instant of time ever measured is approximately ten minus nineteen seconds. This was just a couple two three years ago. So this is these are millions of millions of millions of of a second. It’s actually the interval between the time, two proton two electrons take to respond to stimulus of the atom by photons. It turns out they do not respond simultaneously which was thought of recently.
So what this shows is that matter is perhaps even more impermanent than Buddhist philosophy ever thought it was. While matter can change 20 at twenty attoseconds, a change if you wish. This is not the case for sense perception. Sense perception in other words are visual, ear, olfactory, gustatory and tactile sensations respond to change much slower. And this is what is commonly known as fusion threshold.
It’s a shortest sensory interval which can be measured. Now unfortunately it has only been measured for some of the senses. There’s a surprising dearth of interest in this topic. I I’m not quite sure why. Specifically it has been measured for the visual, the auditory and the tactile sense.
And what is striking is that the visual sense, the visual sense consciousness as we would say, can distinguish events separated by twenty to thirty milliseconds of time. So approximately zero point zero two to zero point zero three seconds. The auditory sense consciousness is by far the most acute. It can distinguish events separated by two to five milliseconds, zero point zero zero two seconds. We don’t have the data for the olfactory and the gustative sense consciousnesses but we do have it for the bodily sense consciousness and it’s extraordinarily short.
It is ten milliseconds. Stimulus separated by ten milliseconds can be differentiated by the bodily sense consciousness. Now while this is extraordinarily small, it is far larger than the rate of change of matter. And we have to face the fact that there is a huge discrepancy between the potential physical rate of change on the one hand and sensory perception of impermanence on the other hand. So the potential rate of physical change is one Planck time unit, ten minus 44 or five by ten minus forty four seconds.
The actual maximal rate of physical change is twenty attoseconds. Yet our eye, body and ear and the sensory and conceptual filters which are probably part of our brain as well as non material mind which we as Buddhist recognize process data in gigantic chunks. Every ten milliseconds for the body, every two to five milliseconds for the ear, every twenty to thirty milliseconds for the eye. What this means is that the change we perceive is incommensurably slower than the actual rate of change of the universe which surrounds us. At the level of our senses already, we are being deceived about the reality which surrounds us.
We see change occurring by the standards of the universe extraordinarily slowly. And this is something which cannot be addressed. Then when you throw in addition, a cultural bias towards permanence which is very much present in western societies, you can see how everything would slow down even more. So this brief excursus into physics and biology, I hope it wasn’t too complicated, leads us to a core topic, the Buddhist presentation of impermanence. Impermanence from a Buddhist standpoint can refer both to the smooth flow of phenomena and to the hasty and brutal cessation of phenomena.
Both are covered by impermanence but the one derives from the other. For this reason impermanence is subdivided into two subtle and coarse impermanence. Subtle impermanence is moment by moment change. We mentioned earlier that the Buddhist understanding of the moment is far closer than the contemporary understanding in physics. I personally believe the great Buddhist practitioners were able to access these changes every twenty to thirty milliseconds for the eye consciousness through Satipatthana meditation and perhaps even every couple milliseconds for the ear and bodily consciousness as well for Satipatthana meditation.
Because in the Mādhyamika school, the shortest instant of change is one three hundred and sixtieth of the time it takes to snap your fingers. And that is vaguely one, two, three milliseconds. You evaluate the time it take it takes to snap your fingers. You divide that by 360. You must be pretty close to between five and fifty milliseconds.
Keep in mind that this was formulated twenty five centuries ago without laboratories. That is quite extraordinary. Then subtle impermanence is the instant by instant change. Physiological subtle impermanence is change that occurs within those brackets of let’s say five to twenty milliseconds. Physical subtle impermanence is a change which occurs at the maximum every pliancyk instant.
In other words, nothing ever stays the same. This subtle impermanence is the cause of coarse impermanence. It is precisely because everything which surrounds us changes instant by instant that things eventually cease. And coarse impermanence refers to the death both of beings and of objects. This little table in front of me which is of plastic for instance is changing instant by instant.
If you took an electron microscope and you examined the molecules of plastic polymer and perhaps even tried to go into the carbon atoms, depends how far you can go with electron microscopes nowadays, but you can go almost to the atomic level. You would see constant change. This constant change, which is manifesting at a gross level by infinitesimal particles of plastic falling from this table to the floor, will eventually lead this table to collapse. If we leave this table in this room for centuries untouched at a certain point, this table will collapse under its own weight. The plastic will split, the metal legs will topple without anyone touching it.
This is a coarse impermanence of the table. At that point, we will have the impression that something shocking happened. Nothing shocking happened. This was a process in becoming for centuries. We are in exactly the same situation as human beings.
We are dead in becoming. It is, from the moment of our birth, we experience a process of aging and dying of which our death is merely the exterior manifestation. It’s the exterior manifestation of the change which has been going on for fifty, sixty, seventy, eighty years. And therefore subtle and coarse impermanence are intimately connected. While every phenomenon which is characterized by subtle impermanence changes momentarily not every such phenomenon eventually ceases.
The mind for instance changes instant by instant yet has no beginning and no end from a Buddhist standpoint. On the other hand, everything which dies, everything which ceases necessarily was changing instant by instant. Before that, that instant by instant change is what leads to the death of phenomena. Now what are phenomena from a Buddhist standpoint? Broadly speaking, we have two categories of phenomena.
Impermanent phenomena, we said some impermanent phenomena are characterized by coarse impermanence. In other words, they actually will be destroyed like vases, tables, human beings. And phenomena which are only characterized by subtle impermanence such as minds which are beginningless or perhaps let us say from the standpoint of physics energy. We can say that energy, if we view it in the broadest sense as energy and matter is beginningless. Permanent phenomena, phenomena which do not change instant by instant, they tend to be abstract phenomena such as space which exist mainly through conceptualization.
They don’t really interest us here. We will focus on the first category impermanent phenomena. And impermanent phenomena in turn are subdivided into three categories. Matter, consciousness and what is neither matter nor consciousness which are known as non-associated compositional phenomena. Matter, we as westerners understand perhaps better than any other civilization in history.
The focus of all of western science is the understanding of matter. There is particular, perhaps no particular need to study the Buddhist presentation of matter since after all, the western presentation is far superior. However, there’s a second category of phenomena which we deny the existence of and that is consciousness. Consciousness is considered by the Buddhists and the Hindus as non material. It’s a phenomena which can be associated with matter with the body or not.
Contemporary western science overwhelmingly considers consciousness to be a name given to the activity of the brain. In other words, to put it bluntly, to be non existent. To put it politely, to be an epiphenomenon of the brain. In other words, when the brain ceases to function, eventually the physical support for the activity of consciousness ceases and that activity of the brain ceases. These two viewpoints are radically incompatible.
So it is up to each one of us to to see where he stands in this matter. Clearly, if consciousness is non material, then something happens to consciousness after our death. It goes somewhere. And very possibly it has come from somewhere before this life. Then it becomes critical to know where it goes and perhaps a bit less critical but interesting to know where it came from.
If on the other hand consciousness is an epiphenomenon of the brain, which is I would say globally the dominant view in western culture, certainly the dominant view, many among biologists, physicists are much more open to the idea of a non material consciousness. Then if one really subscribes to that, I would say there’s no particular reason to go to any religious center or to engage in any type of religious activity. Perhaps one should just lead life, as best one can. As a famous British short story novelist Somerset Maugham said, my philosophy of life is to do what I wish with due regards for the policemen around the corner. Now this is perhaps the dominant viewpoint of most westerners nowadays.
You abide by the laws which are so loose that basically everyone can pretty much agree they make sense. And for the rest, you use or you waste the time you have on this earth as best you can because before there is nothing and after there is nothing. We are, as Pascal said, a flash of lightning between two expanses of meaninglessness. Then these two positions, the position for which mind is non material and cognitive and the position for which mind is a byproduct of the brain are totally incompatible. If you are a Buddhist, you are committed to the viewpoint that mind is non material and cognitive.
If you do not believe that mind is non material and cognitive, then you are not a Buddhist nor for that matter a Hindu. Perhaps not even a Jew or Christian or a Muslim. The place of mind in these traditions is taken by the soul. But whether we mean something different that is to be analyzed. On the other hand, if you believe sincerely that mind is material, is another name given to the brain’s activities, then I encourage you to draw the full consequences of your position.
Which I think are best drawn by the French philosopher Albert Camus in his book, The Myth of Sisyphus. In other words, if truly mind is just another name given to the brain’s activity, then our lives are meaningless. We are accidents, biological accidents. Consciousness is the supreme biological accident. Biologically one of the most expensive phenomena in creation since to keep a human brain functioning consumes a gigantic amount of energy of the organism.
And our self awareness is a tragic byproduct of the development of our brain. And the conclusion Camus drew was that the only free act, he could really envision was suicide. The fact he never suicided I think says something about the resilience of the human spirit to that type of viewpoint. But if you’re going to go that route, if you’re going to go the route of people who believe that mind is another name given to the brain’s activity, then be honest. Go to the full, draw the full conclusions of that position and look at yourself in the mirror and ask yourself if this is something you can live with.
And if a society which espouses such views is not a society which is condemning itself to its own destruction, which seems to be happening under our eyes for western societies. So matter as we said is one of the three subdivisions of impermanent phenomena. These are traces of particles in the bubble chamber. The subtle most particles of physics are detected in chambers typically with superheated hydrogen, liquid hydrogen, which they leave traces. The only evidence of their existence are the traces we can see.
And what is striking is that the definition of matter given by the Buddhist philosophers and this goes really back to Dharmakīrti has been from the beginning that which is constituted of particles. So Buddhism from its very inception is we would say atomistic But there is absolutely nothing in the term particle which implies we are talking of atoms. And that’s why you can speak of much more fundamental particles such as for instance, quarks in the standard theory of subatomic particles. And this understanding of matter is fundamentally compatible with that of modern physics. There’s nothing here which is at odds with modern physics.
Modern physics would probably go one step further and say that we’re looking at a matter energy continuum that is not addressed in Buddhist philosophy. It is regarding the mind that there is a huge discrepancy between the Buddhist presentation and the contemporary scientific presentation. Since the mind and I used here the example of a lens because it’s a very good metaphor for the mind is that which is clear, in a Buddhist from a Buddhist standpoint means non material. The mind’s materiality is immediately denied and cognitive which knows. The mind, in other words, from the Buddhist standpoint is a phenomenon which is non material and whose sole function is to know.
Then we can give two broad examples of minds. Non conceptual minds such as the eye consciousness perceiving a color and conceptual minds which can be memories. The memory of my trip to Egypt, the memory of your confirmation, your high school graduation. These are all non mental phenomena which in the case of memories may be rooted in a physical substrate in the brain. Finally the third category of phenomena we said are non associated compositional phenomena.
These are persons. People such as human beings, this is the Tibetan class, TBI, the beginning of the year. Animals, birds, cows, cats, these are conglomerates of mind and matter together. They also are impermanent and it is a little bit the category in which you put everything impermanent which is neither a mind nor matter. These are composite phenomena which are neither mind nor matter.
So moving back you can see that these three categories of phenomena from a Buddhist standpoint matter, consciousness and non associated composition of phenomena are impermanent, change instant by instant. They are literally said to be destroyed instant by instant. They die instant by instant. Instant. And there is a bevy of other synonyms for impermanent phenomena and perhaps one of the most beautiful ways of meditating on impermanence for someone who has some training in Buddhist philosophy is to meditate on the synonyms of impermanence.
These are composite phenomena. Composite phenomena are phenomena which have parts. And composite phenomena are defined as a disintegrating phenomena. Everything which has parts disintegrates. Our bodies are constituted of cells.
These are parts of the body they disintegrate. Disintegrate. Relationships are constituted of parts. These are two human beings. They disintegrate.
Families are constituted of parts. These are three or four human beings. They disintegrate. My speech to you is constituted of moments of sound. It has parts.
It too will disintegrate and there will only be the memory of the speech. Impermanent phenomena able to act precisely because they change the accord effective things, they are able to act on each other. What does not change cannot act. This is the fundamental Buddhist critique of the existence of God. God is said to be permanent and yet an actor, this is impossible.
If he is an actor, if he is a creator of the universe, then he must change. Impermanent phenomena are products and more importantly they are both causes and effects. Everything which is a cause, those which gives rise to something else, must change to give rise to that phenomenon. Everything which is an effect which has risen from something else must change in the process of arising. Then from the Buddhist standpoint, every impermanent phenomenon is both a cause and an effect at the same time but of different things.
I myself am the effect of my parents. If my parents had not met, I would not be born. I am the cause for instance, of this presentation. If I did not exist, this presentation would not exist. Then my parents are previous to me.
They no longer exist as they used to be when they give rise to me. I myself am prior to this presentation. The present presentation you are looking at right now is not the presentation I created. It is numerous instance of time after this presentation. Every single impermanent phenomenon has a cause and an effect.
Is both a cause and an effect. And a marvelous way to meditate on impermanence is to meditate on one’s own life. Just sit in meditation and start recollecting your life event by event going back from the present moment backwards. And as you go back, notice how every single event in your life is part of a causal chain leading to the present moment. So I myself am 50.
Myself at age 50, I remember myself six months ago when I was 49. Myself at 49 was the cause of myself at 50. My thoughts at 49 are the cause causes of my thoughts now. The cells of my body at 49 are the causes of the cells of my body now. Then if I take the dominant features of my life and I move backwards to try to trace the root causes of every single event in my life, you will find that you cannot stop.
The further back you go, the more causes there are. And you will see that you yourself who are a non associated compositional phenomenon, a person constituted of mind and matter can be traced back from a Buddhist standpoint to the first instance of conception. At the first instance of conception, perhaps shortly after, when the egg is created, consciousness is associated with that egg and this is the beginning of every single one of us, of Jill, of Chris, of Natalie. This beginning carries its death in it. This beginning, this egg with its associated consciousness changes instant by instant.
It is literally destroyed instant by instant. It grows so the better to die. Therefore, there is no particular reason to be sad at death. Death is written within creation. It is a given.
So we have spoken so far of subtle impermanence because it is through understanding subtle impermanence that one can understand coarse impermanence. And the coarse impermanence of this glass is precisely the moment when the glass breaks. You can see the substantial continuum of the glass in the past. Here you still have a glass. From a Buddhist standpoint, when would we say that the glass ceases to exist?
It ceases to exist when it can no longer perform the function of a glass to hold a liquid. So if at this point even though it’s cracked, you could still it could still hold three fourths of a container of wine or water. It would still be a glass. Definitely here it cannot do so. At this point, the continuum of the glass is separate.
You have a substantial substantial continuum reaching this point at which point the glass dies. This is exactly the same thing with a human being. When a human being ceases to be able to perform the functions of a human being, he or she dies. And if you ask me what the functions of a human being are, each society has its own answer. In our society, it tends to be easier to breathe or to think.
These tend to be the criteria in which you are adopted. Or having one’s heart beat for human beings. The Buddhist criteria is overwhelmingly that there is thinking activity connected with the body. And from the Buddhist standpoint, death occurs much later than the death process as we understand it in Western medicine. Depending on whether you define death in western medicine as the moment the heart ceases to beat or brain death, when you have no trace of brain activity with an EEG, you are looking at a couple minutes after the heart has ceased to be at most.
From a Buddhist standpoint, that person is still alive because the consciousness is still in the body. There is still a connection between the consciousness in the body which can last for a normal person up to three days. For highly trained practitioners, it can last into one month. But there’s there are no physiological signs and yet there are signs to those who are trained to see them and the consciousness is present. Then we will stop, here for our tea break.
So the first part was a little bit difficult, my apologies. I hope it was understandable nonetheless. In the second part, will talk of the main type of course in permanence which is death. And we will try to do a little bit of meditation together. Thank you very much.
So we pointed out how subtle impermanence gives rise to coarse impermanence, the end of the continuum of phenomenon. And the aspect of coarse impermanence which is of interest to us is obviously death, which is as we said something every single one of us will have to experience. Something which is neither surprising nor shocking. It is something we are experiencing instant by instant. In this context, I would first like to help us to settle ideas to talk briefly about death in Australia.
How Australians die, as a prelude to, a presentation of the Buddhist techniques of meditation on death. The reason for this is simply that these meditations are at their most effective if one connects them to one’s own experience. We are not meditating in the abstract for instance on a Lamrim outline. We have to meditate on something which will happen to us. If you’re in a society in which for instance nobody basically dies of typhus fever and, the texts refer to typhus fever, it will not have any impact on your mind.
In Australia, people die of strokes, of heart attacks and of cancer. And to a lesser degree of Alzheimer’s. Therefore, it is these types of death which actually will be meaningful and which have the potential to change our minds. So to start with, you all know that life expectancy in all Western countries, in Australia among others, has risen sharply since the end of the nineteenth century. Broadly speaking, we’ve passed from a situation where life expectancy was between 45 and 50, depending on whether you were male and a female, to one where life expectancy now is eighty to eighty five.
This has had a huge impact on the outlook regarding death and impermanence and often prevents Western Buddhist students from connecting with the topic of their own demise. What is however misunderstood is that this dramatic increase in the life expectancy is due to a very narrow set of causes which could very, very easily disappear. As was said in a report of the Australian Bureau of Statistics which I cannot recommend to highlight you as a source of information, most of the decline in the death rate was due to a dramatic decline in infectious diseases. More than any other treatment of non infectious chronic degenerative diseases. Now as you know, we as societies have entered an age in which more and more of us are living longer and longer and expect to have the same high standard, of livelihood when we retire as at present when we are working.
One of the things which is evident based on the present situation is that irrespective of the change in mortality, whether life expectancy continues to increase or not, it is I think a given in all Western societies that old age is going to become more and more difficult simply due to economic constraints. It will become impossible for our societies to afford ever an ever greater number of aging baby boomers who are basically taking more out of the system than they put in. Therefore old age will cease to be the blessed old age of retirement and fun basically and will return to what it used to be which is a period of ever greater deprivation and hardship. This almost inevitably will will foster social tensions between those who can afford ever more expensive medical care as they grow older and those who will be told that this or that newfangled treatment is simply not available for someone in your economic category. This is happening right now in Europe.
It is happening in The United States. It will happen in this country within two, three years as your budget basically veers south. So irrespective of the change in mortality, old age itself will become a period of hardship. Now if we look at the leading causes of death in Australia we find that they are largely heart disease, stroke, dementia has progressed dramatically and then the cancers with diabetes tossed in. Overwhelmingly these would be called degenerative diseases perhaps with the exception of ischemic heart attacks.
And as most of you know the leading cancer for males is prostate cancer and the leading cancer for females is breast cancer. All colorectal cancer has progressed dramatically in the last thirty years. Now when you engage in meditation on death, you want to meditate on your own death and you want to connect it with the most probable causes of your own demise. So it is clear that if you lead a sedate life to meditate on death by accident is meaningless. But if you are on the wrong side of 50, meditating on death by cancer will be quite effective.
If you have Alzheimer’s in the family, meditating on death by Alzheimer’s will be very effective. If on the other hand your father or mother died of a stroke or a heart attack, meditating on your own death by a stroke or a heart attack is the way to do it. The goal is to impact one’s own mind. There can be no universal statement in this matter. And this is just some additional data regarding death rates for selected cancers.
So based on the data so far one might think we are in an environment in which life expectancy may continue to rise and eventually may reach some sort of a ceiling as it becomes unaffordable socially to extend it anymore. Not so much unaffordable medically or scientifically but simply unaffordable financially. It is far from clear that such an optimistic scenario is the one we are talking about, largely because the great increase in life expectancy in the last century is connected with the near elimination of infectious diseases. We no longer face cholera, typhus, scarlet fever, measles, tuberculosis which were standard diseases in the mid nineteenth century in England or in Australia for that matter. However, it is very possible that we at present have entered a new world in which infectious diseases are once again on the rise.
And this became particularly evident with AIDS which appeared when I was a young man in 1981. I remember the huge impact it had on people. This was an infectious disease which was incurable and in addition was sexually transmissible. This activated some of the most powerful buttons if you want within people. You had the punishment of sin by death as it were.
For someone who’s a Judeo Christian I’m bringing, this must have been very very powerful. We have had some thirty million deaths from AIDS at present. As you know, AIDS is controllable in Western countries. It is not controllable in several countries where the treatment by the tri therapies is simply unaffordable. Then we have a series of viral diseases which are hovering on the periphery of western societies.
You may have heard of Ebola Zaire. It is one of the viral diseases with the highest death rate worldwide, above ninety percent of people infected and die. There is at present an epidemic in Uganda which, is being controlled to try to prevent the passage of the epidemic or the transmission of the epidemic to the capital Kampala. Ebola Zaire which is one of numerous set of Ebola’s, Ebola Sudan, Ebola Marburg. Thank heavens, is only contagious through bodily fluids.
It at present is not contagious through aerosol. It is a disease which is completely incurable. We have a dramatic return of tuberculosis. I personally was involved in the struggle against tuberculosis at Sera Je monastery. The Tibetans are highly prone to tuberculosis with multiple drug resistant tuberculosis.
There are some four hundred thousand cases known. Extremely drug resistant tuberculosis and finally totally drug resistant tuberculosis which does not even respond to vancomycin. Now tuberculosis was the biggest killer in, Western Europe in the nineteenth century. We live in a post tuberculosis world. My father has restrained as a physician in the pre pre tuberculosis world in which when someone like Chris starts coughing and drinks a cup of tea, everyone would move away from him.
Just to give you an idea, of how close this may be to home, I read this morning in The Australian that you have in a case of XDR TB in Queensland, an indigenous man who has come in contact with more than 200 persons and who is being traced now by the queen of Queensland Tuberculosis Authority. XDR TB is completely incurable. There’s only two treatments. The old treatments from the nineteenth century. It’s a partial section of the lung or a high altitude residency in the sanatorium.
Then you may have heard of, NDM-1, New Delhi Metallo-beta-lactamase which is a mutation of bacteria which appeared in India last year which turns ordinary bacteria such as Escherichia coli into bacteria which are resistant to all the known antibiotics. This, mutation can be transmitted from bacteria to bacteria as bacteria, as you know, exchange genetic material. And finally, have a bevy of as yet unknown viral diseases. I just read a couple days ago, that there has been an outbreak of a coronavirus in Saudi Arabia akin to SARS. It’s a new virus.
It is untreatable, with a sixty percent mortality. Then in this type of environment, we are indeed facing a pandemic risk. Our societies are wide open to something of this nature because of modern means of transportation and because we are coming in contact with environments we have had no contact with previously. You may have heard of the special issue of Nature magazine, one of the two most widely respected general scientific magazines with science dedicated to, H5N1 as recently as 06/20/2012 in which the research of a Dutch researcher Ron Fouchier on the number of mutations necessary for H5N1 to be transmissible as aerosol, in other words through coughing between human beings was investigated. Fouchier found that five mutations were required, only five.
And another team, Kawaoka, found that in the wild h five n one, specifically in Egypt and Vietnam, already has most of these mutations. Now H5N1 has a mortality of sixty percent approximately. Once it is or if it is transmissible by aerosol, we are looking at a situation where we have a disease to which we have no immunity. This can switch dramatically the mortality curve. It may sound a bit fantastic to say this.
I would strongly suggest if you’re interested in this topic that you study the impact of the black plague on Western Europe between 1348 and 1352 in which an estimated seventy five percent of the European population in certain areas was destroyed. The black plague had an impact on European culture for more than one century in art, in religious history, and so forth. We have forgotten the impact the Spanish flu had at the end of World War two largely because it was kept under wraps. But there were some twenty million deaths worldwide. An article in Foreign Affairs which as you may know is the leading US diplomatic quarterly.
It’s basically the closest thing we have to a quarterly for the State Department. What was it three years ago estimated, in the worst case scenario if H5N1 became pandemic, deaths between four hundred and eight hundred million. So this is a complete switch. If we have a return of infectious diseases which we seem to be having since AIDS, then the optimistic paradigm of ever increasing or ever decreasing mortality may very well be something of the past. And we as a civilization will come face to face once again with death and impermanence in our daily lives.
Then from a Buddhist standpoint, there are strong advantages in recollecting death and strong disadvantages in not recollecting death. This very nice picture is the morphing showing the aging of one person. You know, it’s very helpful to meditate on something like this for yourselves. The six advantages, the main advantages of meditating on death are that it is the most beneficial meditation. It is more beneficial than any other Buddhist meditation we can engage in.
It’s much more beneficial than meditating on emptiness, on bodhicitta, on renunciation, on karma and causality, especially for westerners. It is the most powerful meditation because it impacts directly our identification with our body. It is important at the beginning, the middle, and the end of one’s practice. In other words, it’s important during the totality of the path leading up to the attainment of full enlightenment. For that matter, key aspects of the generation in the completion stage are meditations on death.
And finally, it will enable one to die happily and gladly. Not only will our minds have become accustomed to death, but we will have lived our lives meaningfully. As a result of this at the time of death, there will be no regret. Those of you who work with dying people know that it is seldom physical suffering which is a source of difficult deaths. It is regret.
If only I hadn’t done this, if only I had done that. Such regret does not arise if one has on a daily basis become familiar with death. And there are six disadvantages to not meditating on death and impermanence. The first is simply not remembering Dharma and Dharma here, I think we should understand in the broadest sense of the term a spiritual tradition. Someone who does not meditate on death, which means 99% of our western populations, lives this life basically in the here and now, much like an animal.
In the satisfaction of the senses without any particular interest in asking the core questions. The basic problem as we said is just like a student at an exam, the core questions will be asked from you. There is no doubt about this. The question is can you give an answer or not? But if a student doesn’t prepare an exam and arrives at the whiteboard and says, sir, please be kind, what do you think, let’s say, at the University of Adelaide or AMU, the examiner will say?
It is not my task to be kind. I’m not your friend. I’m here to assess knowledge. But death treats us in this way. At the time of death we are assessed, are weighed, our life is weighed, our experiences are weighed.
If we have taken death on the path within life, death will not be difficult. If we have not, death can be very difficult. Very difficult. Then if we do not recollect death, we may remember Dharma. I think it’s a case for many students at the Buddhist centers but will not practice it.
It’s a nice meeting place. Nice to meet congenial people, have a cup of tea, talk a bit, talk before the teachings, talk after the teachings, those in daydream during the teachings. Then we may remember the Dharma. We may think, yes, I should practice. I will practice, tomorrow I will practice, well maybe next year once I have a break, once I retire, once I retire and have paid my mortgage, once I retire and have paid my mortgage and my wife allows me to practice.
But at this point we are deferring practice indefinitely or we may practice Dharma but not practice it purely and this is extraordinarily common among both westerners and Asians. This means that we practice trying to gain advantages in this life. Some view the Dharma as a cash cow. They are present in all the religions. They exploit the sincerest quest of others for answers to fleece them.
Then the karmic results are extraordinary. Some view religion as a means to gay prestige. This is present both in Asia and the West. One becomes a big sponsor, one gets special seeking, special privileges. This is a way of transforming Dharma into poison.
Then not practicing seriously is very common. Practicing a bit, letting it go, practicing something else, practicing something one makes up oneself. The question is, does this benefit at the time of death or not? The moment you ask that question, you can narrow down the scope of meaningful practices to a handful. Acting vulgarly, we all know we can see this around us and dying with regrets as we said is extraordinarily common.
So these are the six advantages and the six disadvantages of respectively meditating and not meditating on death. Now how does one meditate on death? In the Buddhist tradition, we have broadly speaking two different types of meditations on death. We have analytical meditations on death and visualizations of ourselves experiencing the death process. A combination of both is probably the best way to train the mind.
So the analytical meditations on death are known in the Lamrim as the three roots, the nine reasons, and the three convictions. This is the Lamrim meditation on death. Visualization of the death process occurs in three different ways. According to the Lamrim, it’s visualizing your own death in detail. Defining a cause of your own death, be it cancer as we said.
It might be Alzheimer’s. It might be a stroke, whatever. And then visualizing the actual process. The second form of meditation is visualizing visualization of oneself as a skeleton in accordance with Abhidharma. And the third is visualizing the foulness of corpses in accordance with the Visuddhimagga.
Then I will present these different forms of meditation and we will try to practice together a couple minutes each one. And if you go back home to your families, downcast and shaking, I will feel I have fulfilled my purpose. The three roots, the nine reasons, and the three convictions which is Je Tsongkhapa’s meditation on death and impermanence is rooted in analytical meditation in three routes. And here you should really add my before each of these statements. My death is certain.
The time of my death is uncertain. And at the time of my death only Dharma is of use. There is a clear progression here in intensity. The certainty of death is a topic which generally is easy for most people except Westerners. But most people in less developed cultures find itself evident that they will die.
I have met quite a few Westerners who have told me that they believe that somehow their lives and the progress science will time in such a way that as they grow older their lives will be indefinitely prolonged which seems extraordinarily optimistic to me. The root, the uncertainty of the time of death is the most difficult one to meditate on. Because it really impacts our conviction in our own permanence directly. The fact that we can die at any moment. There is absolutely no guarantee that we will wake up the next day.
And then the third cause that at the time of death only dharma is of use will transform indeed all lives. Each of these three groups is subdivided into nine reasons which are drawn in the picture to justify them. Death is certain because it inevitably comes and nothing can prevent it. Indeed when our time has come, you see even in hospitals, at a certain point the doctors simply throw their hands up. There’s nothing left to do.
It is over. Nothing is added to our lifespan. It is only being subtracted from. The Buddhist viewpoint is that our lifespan, maximum lifespan is predetermined at birth. This is broadly speaking compatible with the viewpoint in contemporary genetics.
The one can definitely subtract from that through lifestyle. But it is very difficult to go beyond a maximum. Therefore, once that maximum is set, we are in the situation of someone who has been given 20 meters of rope and is told to walk along those 20 meters of rope. As he starts walking, it is a given that walking at a certain pace he will reach the end of the rope. It is not a matter of choice.
The rope is only 20 meters long. Now whether for you it is 20 meters long, 15 meters long or 22 meters long, that is open to question. But it is finite in length and you are walking along it. You will reach the end. Finally, we will definitely die before we start practicing Dharma.
It’s an extraordinarily blunt statement. I think it is true for basically everybody. A couple exceptions in Dharma centers perhaps. In our society, nobody practices anything. People start thinking about some type of spiritual practice on their deathbed.
At which point it is really too late. So when one says we will definitely die before practicing anything, it means the way we are thinking at present, is a given we will die before practicing anything. We must change the way we think. Here at the center for instance, one doesn’t come to the teachings because of vacations, the other because of family, the third because of health. There is always an excuse.
An excuse for something which is fundamental. This mind training is fundamental. Not for the center but for yourselves. It makes no difference to the center, frankly. For yourselves it makes a big difference, a very big difference.
Secondly, the time of death is uncertain. The first point is when I think which is broadly speaking irrelevant. It is rooted in the Buddhist cosmology, the Abhidharma according to which beings in certain continents had fixed lifespans and beings in the Southern Continent did not. That cosmology is superseded. You can just skip this point.
The second point is very striking and cogent. Many factors contribute towards death and few towards life. If you reflect on the number of factors necessary to stay alive on the one hand and the number of factors which can cause your death on the other hand, it is very very disturbing. All it takes for you to die right now in this room is for one small vessel in your brain to rupture. There may be right now in every single one of us a blood clot circling in our body at the speed of our pulse sixty, seventy times a minute.
Where it stops would determine whether we live or not. This is all it takes. In a certain age group, all it takes is poor oxygenation of the heart for a heart attack to occur. When you are driving on the way back home, all it takes is a couple of instances of inattention to be already in the next life. However, to maintain life, you must eat a balanced diet with neither too many vitamins nor too few because it turns out that let’s say excess vitamin A is just as harmful as too little vitamin A with enough minerals but not too few, enough protein but not too little, and we go down the list.
If you are too cold, will be sick, but if you put the heater on the maximum, you will be sick as well. If you are thirsty and you don’t drink water, you will die from hypothermia. But if you drink too much water, you may die actually from excess water which actually seems to cause problems in the brain. It’s just recently been been released. So water which is a cause normally for life can become a cause for death.
Finally, the body is ephemeral. This topic is best analyzed in the light of subtle impermanence. Reflecting on the transitory nature of both the physical body and the mind. And on this basis, one meditates on the third reason. At the time of death only Dharma is of use.
Then we live our lives as if a lot of other things were much more useful. All I think the world at present, not just the West, is obsessed with money. Then it is a guarantee that money is broadly speaking irrelevant once you have entered the death process. You cannot take a penny of it with you. Not only that, the time spent accumulating it is time which has been spent non doing other things which would be useful.
It is I think a truism that great wealth is generally accumulated by at best tangent means often dishonest means. Those dishonest means which are used to accumulate great wealth, they will have results in future lives. I remember a case, a very striking case. A friend of mine is an orthodox monk in Geneva and he was called to the bedside of a very very wealthy Greek, what do say in the ship? Not ship builder.
He owned a ship, a fleet of ships with terminal cancer. And obviously, you know, this was Switzerland, one of the best hospitals, in the country. He was a billionaire. Then he just, you know, was given the very best treatment which is possible. And finally, nothing could be done and this friend of mine was with him and the the cancerologist came in and said, we have exhausted the resources of of contemporary medicine.
We would suggest that you make your peace and put your affairs in order. And, this Greek shipbuilder looked at him and he said, I’ll give you 1,000,000 if you save my life. 1,000,000 Swiss francs. And the face of the doctor fell and this big pause and he said, there’s really nothing we can do. We’ve exhausted the possibilities.
My friend, he told me he was very shocked. The weak people looked at him and said, 5,000,000. You see the tragedy? All his life, he had gotten everything he wanted to money. And at the end, this is how he functioned and money would not get So those those of you who think first of your mortgage, of your salaries, of your professional life, reflect on the fact that these are at best transient, temporary, broadly speaking meaningless.
They will not help you at the end. It is mind training which will help at the end. But the time you take for mind training to gain money for your mortgage, to gain money for that artificial need, to gain money for that trip to Bali, that time you cannot retrieve it. You cannot retrieve it. Then friends and relatives are of no use at the time of death.
If you have, ever been present at someone’s dying, you would know that the family is assembled generally in tears. There will be husbands, wives, partners, children, friends. The tears do not make one eye open of difference. If anything they trouble the dying person. Then if we think of the amount of sacrifices we make all for human relations.
I’m often amazed at the sacrifices people make to have a boyfriend or a girlfriend. It’s a it’s astonishing. In a society in which we have fifty percent divorce rate, in which relationships basically don’t last more than a couple months or years, people sacrifice the Lam-rim for these meaningless trite encounters of the sexual organs because this is what it amounts to. They sacrifice their future lives for that. It is absurd.
It is absurd. None of these friends of this life will accompany you. Your husband, your wife, your children, they will not accompany you. They will remember you for a couple of years and they will forget you. You yourselves in future lives will not remember even their names.
It will be as if neither you nor them had ever existed. And yet this is the main focus of people’s lives especially in a country like this one where living standard is good. And finally, our body is a no use. This body of my best friend, I will have to leave behind in at most twenty, twenty five years. Nobody will ask my opinion.
One day I will wake up and I will be floating up here, I’ll be looking down. There’ll be a 100 kilos of meat on the bed, you know, with the blood pooling downwards in the body and I will look at it and not accept what has happened until I realize the time has come to move on. And yet what we do not do for our bodies, we give it eight hours sleep at night, we feed it three meals a day, we go to the gym, the slightest pain that we tear off to the doctor, nothing is too good. But does our body pay us back in kind? Look at your lives, what you have done for your bodies.
Drinking drugs to calm the anxiety. Where do you think that will lead the mind? Then infidelity, adultery to satisfy a momentary bodily pleasure. And then that accompanies us in future lives. So this body which is our servant as Shantileva says must be paid its wages and then put to work.
When I used to have cleaning ladies, I had to pay them $20 an hour. And once I paid the $20 I expected them to give $20 worth of work. Your body you pay a salary to. Three meals, eight hours sleep, clothing, you have to work to keep the body happy. Your body must pay you a salary.
The salary is that it enables you to practice something for beyond this life. If the whole goal of living is living, then we are not different from animals. Then there’s no difference. And therefore once these three roots are generated in your mind on their basis you generate three convictions. Death is certain, I must practice.
The time of death is uncertain, I must practice now. At the time of death only Dharma is of use, I must practice purely. That mixing my practice with worldly affairs. In this matter, I’ll cover briefly pure and impure Dharma before we do a brief meditation on the three roots. Pure and impure Dharma are like a river which is contaminated by pollutants in a clear stream.
When we speak of pure and impure Dharma we are speaking of Dharma which is not contaminated by the eight worldly dharmas and dharma which is contaminated by the eight worldly dharmas. If you are thinking of this or this then yours is impure dharma. Whether you are prostrating or making offerings, it is not dharma. It is poison masquerading as the medicine. What are these eight worldly dharmas?
They were given for the first time by Nāgārjuna, his letter to a friend. Gain and loss, happiness and unhappiness, fame and ignominy, praise and blame. And if you think about it, how many people come to dharma centers to be happy? And when do we say happy, we mean happy here and now. They have mental problems, have psychological problems, they have health problems, they come to the Dharma center, they’re interested in Buddhism to try to find relief from this.
Is this pure Dharma? No. This Dharma for this life? How many people come to the Dharma center because they’re lonely? Is this pure Dharma?
No. Is Dharma for this life? How many engage in dharma activities, mainly in Asian countries, but in the West too, to build up a reputation, to be known as an important sponsor, a wealthy benefactor, someone who meets business partners at the center, Used to be the cases for churches in the West. This is not your dharma. It’s not dharma at all.
These are worldly affairs. And therefore these eight worldly dharmas are summarized in five. Food and clothing which we have for free in the West, relationships, reputation, and money. If you take yourselves and look at your motivation coming to teachings, ask yourself seriously, Am I here to meet people? Am I here because I want people to think well of myself?
Am I here for money in one way or the other? Like a translator who translates for money is not involved in Dharma activities. A teacher who teaches for money is not a Dharma teacher. Someone who teaches because it feels good to teach is not a Dharma teacher. It’s difficult to practice pure Dharma.
It’s very difficult. But that pure Dharma is what we take with us. The rest is just for this life. And this is why one of the great Kadampa Geshe’s says, in all the Dharma we engaged in, having striven for the self aggrandizement of this life, that in turn became the origin of the increasing one’s pride. Envy, hatred and desire which in turn became a cause of cyclic existence.
When one thinks I practiced Dharma since it led to the lower realms, there is no difference with going to the lower realms out of sin. So if you’re not going to practice pure Dharma, don’t bother. Just run around town, go to the pubs, have fun. May very well end up someplace you don’t want to go but at least you’ll have had fun in this life. It defeats the purpose, for instance, to offer 100,000 prostrations within the nether reaches of one’s mind the motivation to have people think well of oneself.
Because one does not gain merit. It’s actually a tremendous amount of work. And frankly, you want people to think well about yourself, I can propose less challenging means to do it. Dharma begins with the future life. This is how we have to try to transform our minds.
Then we’re running a little bit short of time so I will perhaps skip the meditation on these three groups and present the visualization of one’s death process and we will try to meditate on that together. It is, these two meditations function very well together. Clearly the second one is much more powerful. This is a human skull after a couple years in the grave. You can see what is left of the human face.
Very little if anything. By the time the insects have finished eating away at the flesh, the plants have finished growing through the bones, tree roots can grow through bones, The remains of a human being are paltry indeed. How does one visualize one’s own death process? For this, one must be quite familiar with the process of death and the process of purification. Then there’s a tradition in Buddhist monasteries, especially in Thailand.
The His Holiness has really commended it very highly to have in the temple pictures of the process of putrefaction of the human body. It is the most powerful means to counter attachment. If you suffer from excessive attachment or lust, meditate meditating on the purification of the human body and one’s own death is an extraordinary powerful means to eliminate this within seconds. This timeline of purification is broadly speaking as follows. Over a period of four weeks which eventually much after four weeks leads us to a skeleton, within the two or three first days depending on the temperatures in the country, that discoloration appears on the skin and the abdomen starts to swell through a process known as autolysis in which basically the bacteria start proliferating, generating gases.
We basically start digesting ourselves. That’s what it amounts to. This discoloration then spreads and the discolored veins become visible. It’s quite striking on our dead body when you see that. And the abdomen, which is where most of the gases are generated, swells noticeably and starts blistering.
As the abdomen continues to bloat, internal gas pressure reaches a maximum and at this point the corpse can actually burst. After this, the tissues especially the inner organs become de facto liquefied. The nails fall off and you are coming close to the final stage in which the corpse resembles mud, liquid mud which is poured on the skeleton. It actually flows downwards from the skeleton and it has led some some writers in French to refer to the muds of the body. Our ancestors saw human decay firsthand and they had a very clear sense of what happened.
So when we meditate on our own death, we start by meditating on falling sick with whatever disease is, the one we risk to fall sick from. Let us say cancer. But if it’s Alzheimer or the stroke, strokes which run-in your family, you change that in function of your family back. You visualize yourself as being told by the doctor that additional biopsies are necessary. And you visualize the doctor as calling you in his office and explaining to you that there are perhaps some issues which have to be addressed.
You visualize yourself undergoing a first course of chemotherapy with no results. And finally, you visualize yourself on your deathbed in the hospital, surrounded by relatives, bereaved, yourself desperate to survive but unable to do so. You visualize yourself as trying to breathe but incapable to draw that last breath. And then you visualize your heart stopping to beat, your breath stopping to flow and your body growing cold. Those of you who have handled dead bodies know that it is extraordinarily shocking to see how cold a dead body is.
It seems colder than an ice cube. Your body is both cold and moist, slightly moist. And then you visualize the death process, in keeping with the description which will follow. Immediately after death, this is within the hours following death, you have a pooling of the blood in the lower parts of the body. As the body cools off you can see the lower parts of the body become dark red.
This is followed by the first level of putrefaction in which you have autolysis which has started. You can see the bloated abdomen, the skin peeling off progressively from the body and it is at this point that flies in the West, it is less of an issue because the body will be in a morgue, but in several countries definitely, flies will enter through all the bodily orifices. They will enter through your nose, your ears, they will focus on the eyes, and they will lay eggs. These eggs are the maggots which will actually feed on the dying body. In the second stage of putrefaction, the bloating is accelerated.
You see the body covered with maggots. You only see the exterior putrefaction. The totality of the inside of the body is filled at this point with fly larvae as well as the larvae of other insects especially if the body is on the ground. The insects will penetrate through the rectum inside the body as well as through the mouth. The fleshes at this point start to liquefy and turn progressively into this oozy mud we talked about.
This is around the third week of putrefaction. You can see at present the face is almost impossible to recognize. Alternatively, if the climate is particularly dry there may be causing mummification of the body. In either case, its resemblance to a human body is almost non existent. At this point, the maggots have broadly speaking destroyed all of the internal organs inside the bodily cavity.
The body is filled with larvae and reaches rapidly the third stage of putrefaction which is partial skeletonization. And you can see here that the head for instance is skeletonized, the skull, some dried skin remains on the thorax. Finally, after months or years depending very much on the level of insect infestation and on the climate there is complete skeletonization. And all that is left is what we know as a skeleton. The calcium substrate of the body.
Then those of you who would like to do so I would propose meditate on this. Those of you who find this too disturbing, you are welcome to just remain seated. I will do my best to guide you through this process of meditation. You don’t have to sit cross legged. Meditation is something of the mind, not of the legs.
If you choose to sit cross legged, you should adopt either the half vajra or the full vajra posture, straight spine, even shoulders, straight neck, the eyes focused on the tip of the nose partially open, the mouth open, the tip of the tongue behind the palate. Your left hand rests first and your right hand rests on your left hand with both thumbs touching. At present choose the disease you will be dying from. The one which has the biggest impact on your mind. And imagine if this cancer, the doctor has just told you that the tests for a woman with your breast tissue for a man with prostate readings are problematic.
Imagine them doing additional tests and telling you that you have an inoperable tumor. Imagine clearly the fear and the shock when you were told this and the shock of your family. Imagine after undergoing six to eight months of chemotherapy, losing all your hair, suffering of constant nausea and finally reaching the point where you would prefer to die than to live. Imagine yourself on your deathbed in the hospital with drips coming in your arm having lost one third of your weight, surrounded by family members telling you all is well or you know it is not. Imagine yourself unable to breathe desperately trying to breathe but unable to do so.
Your heart stops. You feel yourself sinking into yourself and a tremendous feeling of cold and fear appears. Imagine that your body is quickly counted to the hospital’s morgue. You are still in it. The orifices are plugged with cotton to prevent the bodily fluids from escaping.
Look at your body and observe the process of decay. The blood pools downwards. The top of your body is preternaturally pale. Imagine now your body put in a coffin continuing its process of decay during a service in your memory. Imagine your body in the coffin placed in the grave underground and covered with soil.
Now imagine within the coffin the decay continuing. Insects are able to enter the coffin and into your nose in the bodily orifices. They reproduce in the body. Devouring the body from the inside. See your organs as liquefying or the pressure of the gases increases.
Visualize your body as mud on a skeleton. With an inconceivable stench. Fast forward a couple years down. All that is left is dry bone. Visualize the bone clearly and ask yourself who was this person?
Why did they live? Now we will rise quietly out of meditation. You can loosen your focus. Loosen your arms. Take a couple of deep breaths.
It’s a simple, powerful meditation. This is the way things are. It’s not yet Buddhism. That’s why you should be interested seriously in Buddhism. So this is the way of meditating on visualizing one’s own decay in keeping with Lamrim.
Then there is a second visualization of the death process in keeping with Abhidharma, which we would not do together. I will describe, however. It’s even more powerful, but I think you do want to progress incrementally. Otherwise, you may be a bit shocked. In this visualization, one visualizes oneself of the skeleton.
One starts by seating oneself in meditation posture. And then one visualizes that a small flap of skin, the size of a coin, is removed from one’s forehead. And one sees the bone on one’s skull. Then one imagines that progressively all the skin disappears and one’s skull appears on top of the fleshed body. And then moving downwards, the thorax of bone appears, the legs still have flesh on them.
And finally, oneself seated in the meditation position exactly as one is now sees oneself as a skeleton which is meditating. And one focuses on this clearly, visualizing oneself as a skeleton. And then imagine that the bone nature spreads from oneself to the floor. The floor becomes bone. The walls of the temple become bone.
The ground around us becomes bone. All the trees become bone. Or the living beings around us turn into skeletons. The birds into bird skeletons, the dog into dog skeletons, the human being into human skeletons. Until the entire world is of the nature of bone and ash.
Visualize clearly this white, dry, dusty world of the nature of bone and ash and concentrate upon it. Think to yourself, the nature of the world is death. Then progressively from the outer periphery, the bone re transforms into flesh. Trees re transform into trees. They progressively draw inwards and one’s own body re transforms into flesh from the feet upwards slowly up to the summit of one’s skull.
And then once everything is as before, think to yourself, it looks real but in nature it is a skeleton. Then if you train in this visualization powerfully, you can reach a point of a great Theravada Achat who saw one day when he was going to the market a young woman coming towards him and she flashed a smile at him. And whatever sense he had of her beauty disappeared instantaneously when she flashed a smile at him because he saw her teeth. The bone nature of her teeth immediately suffused her entire body. Those are the benefits of this meditation.
Then to help you in your visualization, there are some very beautiful churches, one in Czechoslovakia and one in Portugal entirely made of skeletons and bones. This is a Czech church. The Kutna Hora church, the chandeliers are made of skeletons and tibias. This is how you should visualize things if you do this visualization. Everything becomes of bone, of skeleton.
And this is the wall of the Capel Of The Bones in Evora in Portugal. You can see that these practices were present in Christianity but not in such a refined form. The entire wall of the chapel is made of skulls and tibias. Last visualization is a visualization of the foulness of corpses in conjunction with that of one’s death. And this is a picture of an autopsy.
This is exactly how you and I look when we are cut open. As a friend of mine who’s a very good monk once said he never could understand desire because beneath two millimeters of skin was absolute horror. And that’s exactly it. There’s two millimeters of skin and beneath that is something out of the horror. Blood, muscle, bone, nerve, fluids.
So these visualizations you may find hard. These are really visualizations for monks. But the visualization of the foulness of corpses, if you want to engage seriously in it, you actually have to have a corpse. So in the ancient days, it was quite straightforward. You just go in the jungle and you could basically run on one.
But you would visualize the various aspects of the corpse. The bloated, the livid, festering in other words infested with insects. Cut up typically in Tibet when they were cut up to be offered to the animals. Gnawed by the animals, scattered, hacked and scattered, bleeding, worm infested, and finally in skeleton state. In these visualizations, there is nothing more powerful for your mind.
Don’t waste your time in some sort of so called meditation and emptiness. This is what is helpful for the mind. The rest, but this the mind is transformed. Once one does or engages in these meditations on death correctly. So the three roots, the nine reasons, the three conclusions, the Lamrim analytical tradition on the one hand.
Visualizing one’s own death in keeping with Lamrim, the bone meditation in keeping with Abhidharma, and visualizing the foulness of the corpses in keeping with the Visuddhimagga, the Theravada tradition. Then one can engage in the practice of the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition which are the innermost practice of the being of small scope. This is one of the very great practitioners in my opinion of this tradition. The, until recently, Abbot of Serage monastery, a great disciple of Khensur Kangur Rinpoche, Gen Lobsang Palden, whom we hope will be coming to TBI at some point in the future. The 10 Kadampa jewels include the four focuses, three diamonds, and banishment, finding, and attainment.
The four focuses start with having completed meditation on death. Once you have meditated on death and you are disgusted with this life, You understand that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and at the time of death, the only thing of benefit is Dharma. And you draw the three conclusions that you must practice, you must practice now, and you must practice purely. Then you engage in the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition and you focus the first jewel is to focus your mind on the Dharma at the exclusion of everything else. The second is to focus Dharma on beggarhood, to practice even if you have to become a pauper, a beggar.
The third is to focus beggarhood on death That is to practice as a beggar even if you starve. The fourth is to focus death on death alone. To think even if I die without a single mourner it doesn’t matter. And then in dependence on this, you train the three diamonds, no foundation, having no family or friends, non embarrassment, having no shame, befriending the diamond of wisdom, focusing exclusively on wisdom. And you will gain banishment finding in attainment.
You’ll be banished from the ranks of mankind. You’ll be an object of ridicule and disgust. You will find the rank of a dog. You’ll gain the company of dogs on the street, and you will attain the rank of a god. You will become an enlightened being.
This is how the great Kadampa Geshe is practiced. This is a practice which turns its back totally on this life. One can only practice in this way if one has meditated on death and impermanence. Then this life is not worth bothering with. It is certain we will die.
We don’t know when. The only thing which helps is practice. Everything else is a waste of time. And then to enter in detail in these practices, one becomes like my great teacher Geshe Rabten Rinpoche, one of the greatest meditators of his age, a hermit. This is a picture of Geshe Rabten Rinpoche in the hills above Dharmasala.
He attained Shine. He gained realization of emptiness. He progressed some say to full enlightenment in this life. He saw as the Dalai Lama had a stupa built in the site where he passed on. Then such a being has focused his mind on the dharma to the exclusion of everything else.
And this means in terms focusing the dharma on beggarhood. This is accepting to let everything go. Your mortgage, your health insurance, your money in the bank, your car, your toys because this is the only thing which matters. As Pabongka Rinpoche says, even if I begger myself for engaging in hardship for the Dharma, I will do so. I will be able to practice Dharma while surviving as a beggar in ranks on the worst of fools.
In a country like this one where even if you were destitute on the street, the government would feed you, how is it that more dharma practitioners aren’t doing just this? This simply because there’s no realization of death and impermanence. I’m sorry to have disturbed you. Then one focuses beggarhood on death. Even at the expense of my own dying, I will practice.
Put it beautifully, actually, all the wealthy and the beggars are similar in dying. It is true. Whether you are rich or poor, you will die. Why bother be rich? It makes no difference.
Not only that, as we said, being rich often means that one will accumulate tremendous new negative karma for money. One lets it go. Finally, one focuses the forced focus on death in solitude. Death alone. We are alone at birth.
None of us is conceived in company. We are conceived alone in the womb. We are born alone in suffering. We die alone. The beginning and the end of the life.
Every little child, we are alone on the path. If that is the case, why bother with friends? Why bother with family? Why bother with children? It’s an interlude and instant of pleasure.
After that we will have to abandon them. We will never see them again. They will never see us again. Since until I have grown old and there isn’t the slightest certainty of leading a long life, it is fitting after having practiced to die alone like a dog. It’s the best death for a Dharma practitioner.
The best death for a Dharma practitioner is alone without anyone knowing that he has died. Because in that case one can control the mind within the death process. Then the fifth Kadampa jewel is no family. The biggest obstacle to one’s practice is family. Which is why in the Buddhist tradition we have monastic ordination.
A monk is able to dedicate or a nun is able to dedicate all his or her time to practice. Once you have children, husbands, wives, parents, every single one of them with your best interests at heart does everything to prevent you from practicing. The diamond of non embarrassment, lack of shame. You were wealthy, you were well known, you were reputed, you gave it all up, you lived like a beggar on the streets and you become an object of ridicule. But that ridicule is meaningless.
It’s just a ridicule of this life. And befriending the true diamond, the diamond of wisdom which is training our minds, This diamond we will take with us. This is why it’s the only thing which counts. And finally the three, banishment, gaining and attainment. We are banished from the ranks of mankind.
We become like a buffoon or a beggar. We find the rank of a dog. We become akin to a dog on the streets. And through the intensity of our practice we attain the rank of a god. We go as far as it is possible to progress in this life from the past.
And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says In his song of realization, this base of leisure, in other words this precious human rebirth, is superior to your wish fulfilling gem. We can achieve any state we wish with it. Such will be obtained but this one time, this is the only time we may hope to have a human rebirth, a precious human rebirth with connection to the teachings. Wherein perishable it is akin to a flash of lightning in the sky. Having contemplated dust upon realizing that all mundane matters akin to winnowed chaff.
By day and by night must one unremittedly extract its essence. I, the yogi, have practiced thus and thus as well should those wishing for liberation. These are the conclusions one could draw from a meditation on this and training in the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition. Then I have completed what I wish to present to you today. I hope there was some benefit and it’s not too disturbing and I am wide open to your questions.
You can. Definitely. I didn’t do it because I didn’t explain it. When you train in the dissolution of the elements, you’re training at a very different level. You’re really training to recognize the inner signs of death as a preparation for generation completion stage practice.
But definitely, definitely, those signs will occur. Whether they occur, that clearly is another question. That depends a lot on the mode of death. If the death is natural and the person was relatively healthy, then they are quite clear. If the death is violent, accidental, then sometimes they’re not clear at all or don’t happen.
Does that answer your question, Christa? No. Not at all. Not at all. But I mean the main focus here is twin.
The first focus is the sense of horror at one’s own death. Then if the meditation dissolution of the elements helps that so much the better but the main focus is that. And then a sense of urgency which breaks through the complacency has to be created. That is the goal of these meditations. The goal for those who engage in these meditations is to gain an experience similar to someone who came close to dying in this life.
We do have them in Dharma centers and they are the ones you never have encouraged to practice. Those who have had these near miss experiences, car accident, disease, boat accident, whatever, they are the ones they have actually seen what life is all about. Then all you have to do is from time to time encourage them to go a bit more in this direction, more in that direction, but motivation is there. But generally for westerners who have no experience of this this type, who’ve never been in war zones, who have never seen death firsthand, there is tremendous complacency. And the complacency lasts during the years when they actually could do something.
Then by the complacency disappears when it’s generally late, if not too late. That’s the problem. Do you have other questions? Not really because basically when we’re speaking of coarse impermanence, we’re speaking of something big at a certain point unable to perform the function it used to perform. At that point, you can really say it has ceased to exist in its previous form.
Like my projector for instance. If there is a point where suddenly this projector just stops working completely and cannot be repaired, it is a broken projector. Its continuum as a functioning projector is interrupted and it is irretrievable in that sense. If at a certain point this table collapses and thus it’s unable to perform the function of a table to hold things, then we say its continuum is severed. It is dead literally.
That’s what we are saying. That’s not an illusion that is real. In this room, every one of us, like like, the average age is what? 45, 50 maybe. You have six thousand days in front of you.
Those of you who are 60 or 70, you may have three hundred, four hundred days. You know? At the end of those three hundred or four hundred days, we hope for your sake you have an idea of what’s happening Because whether you do or not, you would have to move on. Does that start to answer your question? Flower I’m a little bit hard but to answer your question I think perhaps pollination.
Perhaps. But if we take an easier example, the glass is quite easy. The function of a glass is to hold liquid. So the moment the glass is damaged to the point where it cannot hold liquid anymore, it’s no longer a glass. Then you see very clearly on the stroboscopic image of the disintegration of a glass.
There’s this turning point before that. At one point it’s a full glass. Then it’s splintered but you suspect that it could probably hold a small amount of glass. It’s still a glass. Damaged but still a glass.
Then at the moment when its damage is so great, it’s collapsing, it cannot perform that function. Then the continuum is severed. So you have a continuum of subtle impermanence at the point where the previous capacity to perform a function ceases we speak of severance of the continuum. Does that help? Do you have other questions?
Well, clearly it is the big taboo now in modern western culture because it smacks straight in the face of the materialist consensus, doesn’t it? But in third world countries, the issue never arises. In villages in Africa or in Asia, if you eat meat, you have to kill the chicken. Meat is not bought in the supermarket. If you drink milk from a cow, the cow has to calf every year and the calf has to be killed or grown as a steer.
Then the child sees death on a daily basis, the death of animals, and then in most third world countries, the hospital is a luxury. People die at home. So a young child will see death by the age of 10 for sure, the death of a relative, not just ordinary death. Then for better or for worse, that the worst that is the way it is. I think it makes for more mature human beings.
I think the Western culture model keeps people in a state of adolescence indefinitely. That’s a good point. A very good point. Yes. I think it’s very important to talk to children about death.
It’s actually important that children see death. I think almost without exception, the people who come to Buddhist centers or Westerners come either because they have themselves had a near near call or because they were exposed to death in childhood and the question has remained with them all their life. Because death is the ultimate taboo. It is completely evacuated in our societies. When someone starts to be sick enough to be facing death, they’re actually moved in separate areas either of the hospital or even of society in general.
Nobody sees people die anymore. A friend of mine who actually works in geriatry told me that once his patients come in, the family visits for the first couple of weeks and then that’s it. The person typically dies alone. And I think much of that is rooted in a fear of the dying process. I think it would be very good for your children to be exposed in a skillful way perhaps with the death of animals, first of pets and then to be told, to be told.
I mean, you know, what would you say if someone who raises children believing in Santa Claus? You’d say that that’s a little bit unrealistic. Then how can one raise children to believe that they will live forever and their parents will live forever? Part of growing up means accepting that it ends. Then life becomes meaningful.
We turn it to be something meaningful. The best initial training you can do if you were to meditate on death and impermanence, but I don’t know how this one will receive be received, so I’ll just throw it past you, is to stop dying your hair, to stop putting makeup, and to forget any aesthetic operations. Then you will see your face as it is. In my case, if I still don’t shave for two days, there are white patches. That hits home more than hours of meditation.
Accept the ugliness of age. If you do that, I think you can meditate a lot less on death and impermanence. Right? It’s more effective. More effective.
Very powerful. Because the core meditation on selflessness in Buddhism is meditation of the selflessness of persons that’s shared by all the Buddhist traditions, Hīnayāna and The selflessness of persons is persons being empty of being permanent, one, and independent. Now when you meditate on death, you’re destroying the belief in the permanence of the person. When you meditate on the body and the mind being composed of parts, destroying the belief that they are unitary. So these meditations on impermanence and death, they go quite a way towards being a meditation in the selflessness in of persons.
It’s very powerful. Very good idea. If if Tenzin now accepts, it might be very appropriate for the temple. You know? It has them framed.
We make do with the situation as it is, don’t we? Clearly. But having said that, dharma is about the mind. Then it’s very very easy to get lost in externals. The externals in and of themselves may very well not help you.
Now it is perhaps the weakness, one of the weaknesses of the Tibetan tradition that we have such a rich collection of externals to help people to the inner core. It’s very easy to get lost in the externals. For instance, one thing I find very striking, I’ve mentioned it before is the issue of prostrations. A prostration means that you respect the person to whom you are prostrating so much that you put yourself on the ground in the dust of their feet. This is what it means.
Just as shaking the hand in the West came from the old habit of showing that the right hand was free. There was no weapon in it. You shook hands and the man shook the hand of the other man and said, I do not bear a weapon. I am your friend. Prostration is complete self abasement.
If that is the case, how do we have students who prostrate with their teacher at the beginning of a teaching and then who disappear and whom we never see again. What happened? They manifested total devotion to their teacher and then that self same person within a week or two weeks is gone and we never see them again. Then that prostration is hypocritical. It’s meaningless.
It is something which is pretty culturally determined. People do it because it’s done in the center. Then my suggestion has been not to do it. If you cannot do a sincere prostration, don’t do In this world, in this life, we do not like people who are not honest and sincere. We know it.
In daily life, somebody who says things he doesn’t mean to us is not someone we want to be a friend. Then for our practice, it is better to be honest and direct. If truly we can make a sincere prostration, we make a prostration and that is very beneficial for the mind. But just to make a prostration because 30 people are making prostrations, that is impure down. That’s of no benefit.
That’s worldly because the motivation is to fit in. That’s such a motivation. It may look good in the center, but the person derives no benefit and ultimately, the teachings derive no benefit because there is an illusion of discipleship, which is actually absent. And this has been seen at TBI directly. We had the direct and Rinpoche had the direct experience of students who said he they were his students for years.
They came to teachings. They prostrated. From Rinpoche’s standpoint, they had entered into a student disciple relation with him at their request, not at his request. And yet, when Rinpoche asked his students for the help a teacher was entitled to ask from his students, I think, basically, with one or two exceptions, every single one of Rinpoche’s Australian students walked away, and they are still in that room. Every single one walked away.
And Rinpoche publicly said during one of the meetings of TBI, and I was a translator, that this had caused many tears but of this he would not talk. So this is a result of hypocrisy. Then I think the best way to counter this is to encourage people to be sincere. In other words, everyone is entitled to the differences of opinion but if people make a prostration, it must be a heartfelt prostration. They can change down the line their opinion.
That’s obviously legitimate. But clearly when ninety ninety five percent of the students change their opinion, then it means they never had this opinion in the first place. Now this is a problem of westerners in general. Historyist has pointed this out many times and Alan Wallace has pointed this out in a very strong article, the fickleness of Western students. But in Australia, is extreme because I think Australians I don’t know if inferiority complex that Australians like others to have a good impression of them.
And they will say what it takes without really meaning it. Then with the Tibetans, this causes very big problems because with the Tibetans, a given word is very strong. The given word to a teacher is very strong. So the best way to counter this this is to encourage from the beginning everyone to be honest and sincere. One can be a Dharma practitioner without making prostrations.
One doesn’t want. One doesn’t want. One doesn’t need to get involved in Tibetan. But it’s much more helpful if there’s one or two points which will really take some border, takes them on sincerely. One point is enough.
I really believe in impermanence. I changed my life through this belief. And then if someone asks you are you a Buddhist or not? And you examine, do I believe in reincarnation or not? Not really.
And you say no, I’m not a Buddhist. It’s okay. Or you believe in reincarnation but you don’t believe in karma then you say no, no I’m not a Buddhist. It’s okay. What is not okay is to fudge.
It’s not okay for the person and it’s not okay for the spread of the Buddhist tradition. That’s not okay. And we have a lot of that. I I have students who have had monastic ordination, bodhisattva vows, tantric vows, Australians will walk away from everything within years of receiving order. Then what message are they sending to to the Buddhist tradition that perhaps we have to be much more careful?
You see what I’m trying to say? I think it is very important. In one’s marriage, instance, people understand. If you are married, it’s important to be honest. You’re not unfaithful.
You’re not married with something on the side and when you have a wife or a husband, you say the truth. Right? You don’t go around gilding the lily. We all understand that and with in your business partnerships, if you go around building the lily, the law will come after you. Right?
So how come when it comes to spirituality, which is much more important, everyone goes around building the lily? I remember during the Yamāntaka initiation, it was very striking for me. Rinpoche had been requested to give Yamāntaka teachings in Sterling and then it was very clear that a lot of people were coming who didn’t really relate to Rinpoche as a teacher. And to clarify things, we proposed that people sign a statement that they recognize Khensur Kangur Rinpoche as a teacher and they accepted the commitments of Guru yoga. And we had something akin to a rebellion of the older students.
Two Lojong students just directly refused. One still comes to the center. I thought it was very beneficial because what it showed was that their word meant nothing. What was written meant something for them. Then when it became real, suddenly they weren’t ready to go this route.
But in that case they shouldn’t have been there in the first place. So I think if we from our side can take the teaching seriously, then the teachings from their side can really benefit us. But if we don’t take the teaching seriously and it’s all a bit dodgy like this, then what we would get would be dodgy too. So it’s a very long answer to your question but I hope it it freshes things out a bit. It’s not an instant.
It’s perfect. Okay. That’s perfectly okay. You come, you attend as many teachings as you want. You don’t become a Buddhist for ten years.
That’s fine. But when you come and you take refuge within two months and you take Bodhisattva vows two months later, then you take tantric vows, then a year later you convert to the evangelical tradition or Islam, we know a case, then what does this say? It’s not good for the person and it’s certainly not good for the teachings. So I think in a nutshell, we have to encourage people to slow down and to be serious. Think seriously.
Am I a Buddhist or not? Then don’t take vows casually. You would never sign a contract the way you take your vows. I was in business. I had my own pharmaceutical company.
I can tell you, when people signed a contract, they get teams of lawyers. You know? I’ve seen people take Bodhisattva vows, which are vows of a multiple lives just at least, you know? Then they break them just as quickly. Then this harms a person.
I know one one case, I’m a trusted student, but she said such people we do not need at the center. We worked on but she said we do not need. Told him not to come. So take your practice seriously, take your vows seriously, don’t rush, think carefully but when you give your word, because that’s what a vow is, when you give your word, have to keep it. When you take refuge, you’ve taken refuge.
Does that make sense? And there’s no need to worry about hurting our feelings. Know? Rinpoche can take a lot and I think Geshe-la is very, very solid, you know. But honesty is appreciated, very appreciated.
Honest. Are you a Buddhist? No. I’m I’m coming to the teachings out of interest. I’m not a Buddhist.
I don’t plan to Buddhist. Fine. Are you a Buddhist? Yes. But you have to be able to answer yes or no yourself.
That clarity is really helpful. His basically his holiness is basically looking over many lives. So I don’t have that capacity, you know. Then I can only only repeat what my teachers have told me and I can only encourage you to be just clear, sincere, and honest. Then there’s no, for oneself there is no embarrassment or shame and for the teachings there’s only benefit.
There’s only benefit. His holiness in private is not the way His holiness is in public. His Holiness has a very powerful presence and he has very little time for shilly-shallying. So that cannot be practiced in the family. I mean, clearly, having chosen family life, there are things which are not possible.
The 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition are for yogis or monks who sacrifice everything to the teachings, then we’re not in that category. It can be an ideal we can have. Is it no way I mean, no way suggesting that you go and you sell everything in anyway, you wouldn’t if I suggested it. Right? But honestly right?
But the the ten years of a Kadampa tradition, therefore, somebody who has been meditating on death and impermanence until everything else is just ash. Then such a person typically would become ordained or would be a wandering yogi. So for someone like that, family, money, health, reputation is just meaningless. And you cannot consider it the truth. Right?
What Candrakīrti said is that lay people like us should practice the three first perfections. Are those we can practice? Right? Generosity, ethics to a degree. For this, for lay people ethics is difficult.
But generosity, we can practice. Everyone in this room has a decent salary. You can practice generosity. If you believe in karma, there’s benefit. If you don’t have a decent salary, then you can try to teach.
You can try to translate. You can try to volunteer your time. This has karmic results for you, for the future that we can practice as lay people. Forbearance as a lay person, patience we can practice. There’s always problems.
Not snapping at another person, being philosophical, taking what comes, you know, is a very powerful in ethics, normally, once you try to hold the lay vows, then the lay vows can be held by a lay person. They don’t mean that you are celibate. You you renounce killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, in other words, adultery, lying, and drinking, and intoxicants, in other words, alcohol and drugs. This is not impossible to keep. So those practices are lay person can practice.
Then on top of that, we’re fortunate to have a center, one can come to teachings. Someone who has refuge and who does not come to teachings is someone who is in contradiction with himself or herself. Refuge is taken in the teachings. If you take refuge and you don’t go to the teachings, then you basically never took refuge because you’re not going to what is the refuge. And whether you study at home or go to the teaching, that’s up to you.
But attending the teachings and then after that, Rinpoche explained generating a motivation in the morning before going to work, a good motivation as good as one can, and at night checking what happened. Then for lay persons, that’s all that is possible. Then if one wants to practice more than that, then one must walk away from one’s family, become ordained, and then one can speak of such practice and I have known people who have done it. It’s an option for every Buddhist. But to think that one can can have a monastic level of practices labors, and that’s difficult.
And it’s not the case that because one is ordained when practices at Ten Kadampa Jewels, are many monks who whose lives are more open to question. Right? And the motivation is always a big question. Does that answer your question, Chris? So it’s a very long I’m giving you very long answers today.
Yes. It’s a good way to look at things. It’s true that etymologically, vows really mean to bind. Don’t bind. Tibet means to bind because right now we want to do what is not good for us.
We have had a lot of experience with that. We’ve not had a lot of experience doing things which are good for us. So we’re little bit like a sick person in a hospital, you know. Sometimes you have to strap them on the bed. Well, obviously, it looks awful but really the person benefits.
Right? If they don’t bounce up and down and tear the catheter out and whatnot. Then vows are hard but what we take we have to keep. That’s a good way to look at them. Then if you have no more questions, thank you very much.
I hope I didn’t shock you too much with the presentation and, the only thing that I would encourage you to do is to think on a regular basis about death and to try to practice sincerity. Sincerity in your relation to your teachers and to your practice. If one cannot accept something, it is perfectly alright to say one cannot accept it. What causes problems is insincerity. Be sincere, be honest, be clear.
Each one of us has his own road. People don’t have the same capacities. The goal is for us to benefit ourselves. And thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- completion stage dzog rim (Tib)
- The second of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which control is gained over the vajra body. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- tantric vows sang ngag kyi dom pa (Tib)
- Vows taken by tantric practitioners. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.