DB Mind and its Potential 2010 – 2010 10 31 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 31

2 h 13 min · 21,564 words · 31 October 2010

DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 - 2010 10 31 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 31
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continuing a course on Mind and its Potential, the teacher reviews Buddhist psychology: the six factors that give rise to delusions (karmic imprints, objects, misleading companions, false teachings, habit, mistaken conceptualization) and how to work with each. The talk then explains karma as intention-driven action that produces results, and introduces the meditation on a perfect human rebirth, followed by a dedication and prayers.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2010-10-31

Duration: 2h 14m

UUID: d5d40693-5564-4667-b960-df944492e0c5

Words: 21,564

Alright, let’s go ahead and start our class with just a short meditation. So as usual find a good meditation posture. So again, whatever works for you. If you’re sitting in a chair, again they do say that it’s best move a little bit forward in the chair. If you’re leaning back in the chair then the back is probably not going to be straight.

So giving yourself a little bit more space to make the back straight. And then plant your feet firmly on the ground in front of you rather than tucking them underneath you. The hands can be in this traditional posture with the palms up, the thumbs together, the right on top of the left, just resting in your lap or wherever they’re comfortable in your lap. Bring the head to an upright posture and then you can tilt it forward just slightly. This will allow your gaze to go downward.

Ideally, we should keep the eyelids just slightly open. If this is too difficult to do though, you’re welcome to close the eyes, but otherwise bring them till there’s just a blur of light coming in. Just enough to keep the mind alert and awake. So let’s relax the body in this upright posture by doing this breathing meditation. So we’re going to breathe in very deeply and just feel every cell in your body expand, particularly those parts of your body where there’s tension.

And then when you exhale, just allow all of the tension, all the stress just to go out with the exhalation. So do a few deep breaths on your own in this way. So particularly with the abdomen, as you breathe in very deeply, try to keep the abdomen relaxed as you exhale so that it’s very open, spacious, very relaxed. So then when you’re ready, begin to pay attention to the sensation that you feel at the tip of the nose as you just continue to breathe regularly. So with each inhalation, with each exhalation, it’s a very subtle sensation that occurs just inside the nostrils.

And start tuning into that. Just notice that sensation and allow the mind to rest there. We want a very relaxed quality and yet the mind quite alert. Just simply holding on to that sensation at the tip of the nose in a very relaxed way. And the other instruction is necessary because we don’t have perfect concentration.

As much as we want to do this and have a desire to keep the mind on that point at the tip of the nose, our concentration will wane. And at the point when we recognize that we’ve gotten distracted, that we’ve wandered away, then the job is to just let go of that distraction. And then very gently bring the mind back to the breath. So even if we have to do this many times over the next few minutes, it’s perfectly fine. We’re training the mind to be more settled, to have less distraction, and it takes effort to do that.

But just do the best that you can. Again, keeping the mind on the breath, the tip of the nose, and then whenever it wanders, letting go of that distraction and bringing the mind gently back to the breath. So I’ll ring the chime. We’ll do a few minutes of this, and then we’ll set our motivation for our class today. You can let go of watching the breath.

And to set our motivation for today, I’m just going to briefly look at what we talked about last week. So last week we were focusing mostly on what we would call Buddhist psychology, understanding the various factors in the mind, various states of mind, particularly those that lead to our mind being deluded and disturbed. So we examined how we have this pattern of reacting to what is pleasant in our lives with the mind of attachment or desire that is exaggerating, overestimating the qualities that we see in that object, and then wishing to have it for our own, to pull it into our lives and to not be separated from it. And then that’s companion, the mind of aversion or anger that reacts to what is unpleasant in our lives, superimposing a level of unpleasantness, undesirability that is far beyond what is there, and then pushing that object out of our lives, wanting to be separated from it. And then we went on to see how both of those are rooted in a fundamental level of ignorance, where we are actually misconceiving how everything exists, how we exist, thinking that there’s some concrete independent existence, that these qualities that we see inherently exist in that object.

And then on that basis, we have these delusions. And on those the basis of those, we experience suffering in the mind. We experience discontent, dissatisfaction. So if we’ve come to some understanding of how this is how our minds are working according to the teachings of the Buddha, that this is what’s operative a good portion of the time, we can certainly generate some desire to be free of that, to have a mind that is more at peace, that isn’t disturbed by the afflictive emotions, that is wise and compassionate, patient, kind. But moreover, if we understand that this is our situation, that every single sentient being is in this situation, our heart should begin to open to wanting to help every one of them to also be free from these afflictive states, to also find the level of peace, inner peace, that will satisfy them truly.

So as much as possible, we want to be here today to continue this discussion, to continue to look at the afflictive states of mind and more particularly the karma, the actions that follow from these states of mind, so that in that way we can be at greater peace ourselves and produce the causes of our own well-being. But moreover, we can do this so that we can help others, benefit others, encouraging them to do the same and eventually being able to guide them to do the same through having tapped into the full potential of our minds, this state of complete enlightenment. So try to align your mind with that level of motivation because the level of motivation that we bring to these teachings has a direct correlation with the results that we receive. Okay, you can open your eyes fully. So good morning, and welcome to the fifth class.

We have one more class after this next Sunday. And then the following Sunday will be a practice morning. So we’ll get an opportunity to come together from nine to twelve thirty to do some meditation together, to have some discussion, to look at this class and get a chance to talk about how this has been for you and what have you. So I hope you can join us for that day as well, and there’ll be a vegetarian potluck lunch after that. So let’s take a brief look at everything we’ve talked about so far.

So this course is called Mind and Its Potential, and we began by defining what we mean by mind. So in Western science there’s a lot of disagreement about what is the mind and where does consciousness come from. We use these terms as equivalents, mind or consciousness. In Buddhism, the thinking is that mind has its own entity, if you will. It has its own nature.

And that nature is clarity or luminosity. And the implication of that is that mind is not material. And that mind has the ability then to kind of illuminate and reflect other objects. And that comes down to then what is the function of mind. So the nature of mind is clarity.

The function of mind is knowing, is awareness. So mind is kind of like space in that it’s clear, luminous. But space doesn’t have the function of knowing, whereas mind has this function. The implications of this, of course, are that if we identify it as its own that has some interrelationship with the physical body, then in that way we are also kind of separating it out as something that can have its own continuity apart from the body. So the implications of this, we’re actually going to be discussing this a little bit today when we look at this idea of karma and the role that it plays in shaping what we call our rebirths, our continued existences one after the other.

This is all contingent upon the idea of continuity of mind, that we can never find an initial moment when mind sprang up. It’s not like, again, you’ve got a piece of mind from some sort of universal consciousness that just kind of came into this body, and that’s when your consciousness started. We always have to posit that there’s something in that same continuity that gives rise to another moment of mind, and another moment of mind, and so on. We can never find a single moment of mind that arose from no causes. This whole idea of causality is a really fundamental concept in Buddhism, and this is another thing we’ll be examining today when we look at karma.

Because karma is kind of the overall picture of the law of cause and effect in regard to the experience of beings. But we could say at this level of just simple causation, just as in the way that all material things arise from various causes and conditions, one of them generally being a substantial cause, the cause for a flower being the seed from which that flower arose. But many other conditions contributing. In the same way, consciousness arises from its primary cause, which is another moment of consciousness. The human consciousness we have in this body arises on the basis, certainly, of having a brain and having the five sense organs and so on so that we can then experience the phenomena in this world.

But everything comes down to it, the very core of it, is this continuity of mind. So the implications of this are that we have had this mind since beginningless time. And this mind will go on without any end. And the Buddha then We kind of started to examine, how does the Buddha say that the mind works, and what is sort of the content of the mind? What we would call Buddhist epistemology and Buddhist psychology.

Because this is the whole key. If we kind of understand, well, this is what mind is, then we have to begin to understand, well, how is the mind working? And one of the primary things we focused on in that section was looking at the fact that we have two different ways of knowing. One is more direct, our perception. This is mostly our sense consciousnesses right now.

We have the ability for our mental consciousness, which is called the sixth consciousness. So we have five sense consciousnesses for the five senses of sight, sound, smell, taste, and touch. You know, the ability for us to know those phenomena more directly. But then we also have a mental consciousness that primarily works through the other avenue of knowing, which is conception. Conception means that we’re going to use our thought processes to kind of get at objects, but we’re always kind of somewhat removed from those objects.

We’re not knowing them directly. Kind of using an image that we have of those objects, And then we think about that image, and we overlay all kinds of stuff on that image through the force of our conceptual mind. And this drives us into the discussion of Buddhist psychology. As I said in the motivation today, what we are doing in most of our relationships with objects is we’re overlaying another level of existence that isn’t there at all. Initially, it’s kind of this fundamental ignorance that’s causing us to think that things exist in some sort of inherent or intrinsic way.

That an object such as a flower exists from its own side independent of my mind, independent of my involvement with that. And the Buddha says this is an illusion, that this independence exists. And that if we examine more closely, which is another part of this Discovering Buddhism course, we find that it doesn’t have that objective existence at all. And we can reason through that and undermine that ignorance. But on the basis of holding a flower or a piece of cake or whatever it is that we’re relating to in that inherently existent way, and then holding myself to have some sort of autonomous, independent existence, I then go about engaging in these delusions towards these objects.

The objects that I really want and crave, that are so delicious looking. I pull them into my life and exaggerate all their qualities and don’t want to be separated from them. I think that they’re better than they actually are. We’re not denying that there’s some good qualities there, but even those good qualities, if we pick it apart, we find that they don’t inherently exist. And again, it doesn’t take a lot.

I’ll go through one example. Last week we used music. Maybe we can use another example. Does anyone have one they’d like to put forward? Who’s willing to tell me their object of desire?

What is it that drives you crazy? Well, not necessarily crazy, but With? Paper. Wow. Interesting.

Okay. So I think it’s Well, it’s a good one. It’s a good one, Rita, because Rita has this When she sees paper in that, she has a real strong desire for it, and to own it, and to be touching it, and be involved with it. And so when she goes into Office Depot or something, she You know, this is like you know, her thing. So if we go into Office Depot, I mean, I’ll speak for myself, you know, I don’t necessarily Maybe it’s other objects in Office Depot that get me, but it’s not the paper.

You know? So where is the quality that Rita is seeing in that paper? Where is the lack of quality that I’m seeing in that paper that’s kind of causing me to have an indifference towards paper? Again, we find that there’s really nothing there when we start picking it apart. Our minds are involved in overlaying all of that, in seeing those qualities, in imputing those qualities, designating those qualities.

And then, of course, we go through this process when it’s attachment, when it’s this desirous quality, We elevate it to such extreme levels that we see something there that, again, is it really there? Buddha would say it’s actually really not there. This is a process we’re doing mentally, and we’re superimposing all of this on that. We make it so much more desirable than it is. And then there could be somebody who perhaps has aversion to paper.

Don’t know. Maybe somebody who’s gotten a lot of paper cuts or something. And all of a sudden, they get into a store and they want to avoid paper. They don’t want anything to do with paper. If anybody tries to give them a piece of paper, shun them or something.

So this is, you know, again, is there something inherently wrong with paper? Is there something kind of there that’s negative from its own side? Now, I mean, we can admit that you can get a paper cut from paper, but does that make paper inherently wrong, inherently evil, inherently negative? So we’re doing this all the time. We’re superimposing these qualities, and we’re superimposing, even when it comes down to it, the very identity of those qualities or even of that object.

In the end, there’s nothing really that is inherently paper either. Real paper. Paper existing from its own side. Paper is just an idea, a name that we’re giving to that. So this fundamental level of ignorance where we think things hold their own identity, hold their own qualities, and we exaggerate the good qualities and exaggerate the negative qualities and have attachment and aversion.

This is our problem. The Buddha says that our psychological problem is that we are buying into reality at a level that is so far beyond what is there. Lama Zopa Rinpoche himself says what is there, how things actually exist, is very, very slight. It’s almost as if they don’t exist, he says. So this is what we’re going to be moving towards.

And all the Buddha’s teachings, in essence, are to help us to realize that. But slowly, slowly. We have to kind of work with where we’re at and begin to understand how we can work with our mind at perhaps a little bit grosser level rather than getting down to this very subtle level of understanding that we need to develop. We will develop this wisdom eventually by repeated exposure to it, meditation on it, and so on. But be patient and kind of hang in there with this.

This idea will flesh out over time. But this is really, when it comes down to Buddhist psychology, this is what it all boils down to. Every one of us, in a sense, has a mental illness. And that mental illness is that we are seeing things incorrectly. We are not ascertaining things as they exist.

And based on that, all of our delusions come into play. Well, the main subject we’re going to look at today is kind of then what comes from the delusions, which are our actions, karma. We’ll have a whole module where we’ll get into karma in much more detail. But there was one subject from last week that I do need to touch on before we get into that. And that’s kind of how these delusions arise.

The various factors that assist them. Because I think this is a really valuable lesson for very practical use. We can begin to say, Well, these are the things that kind of contribute to my having anger, to my having attachment. We can start to limit how those are arising on the basis of using that understanding of these factors in our own lives. So any questions on what we’ve talked about so far?

Okay. So those of you who weren’t here for some of these classes, I’m going to pass out these two handouts. This was Appendix I. I’m not going to talk about these a whole lot, but occasionally I might refer back to this one, Appendix II, which on the back has the afflictive states of mind, because we’re going to be talking again in this first part about the afflictions. So maybe, again, we’ll just start Appendix One going around for any of you who don’t have it.

Most of you should have this because you probably have been at the previous classes. But then maybe appendix two just following right after it if you can kind of keep it going in the same flow. And then anyone who doesn’t have those can go ahead and take a copy. If we run out by any chance, let me know and we’ll make some copies during the break. So, the first topic that we want to talk about today then is how the delusions arise.

I mentioned this is actually in the book that we’re going to be using. It’s called Wisdom Energy. It’s the book I think it’ll be republished by the time we need it. It’s out of publication right now, but there’s a new version, a new revised edition coming out from Wisdom Publications that we’ll be using for module three. So module two on meditation will follow, and then towards the beginning of next year we’ll go into module three.

But in the fourth chapter of this, we’re going to jump a little bit ahead and talk about what Lama Yeshe says in here about how the delusions arise. This actually goes back to the traditional Lamrim teachings of Lama Tsongkhapa. But he says that there are six factors that give rise to the delusions. They sort of stimulate the delusions in our minds. And we want to talk about each of these individually, and I’m going to put them out in the order that he presented them, but then later on we’ll talk about them in terms of where we might focus more directly in our own lives for the kind of practical application of this.

So these are, again, six factors that cause the delusions to arise. Number one is called karmic imprints. Can everybody see that? I don’t know. This blue isn’t the darkest.

Maybe I’ll change to the green. So the very first one. We haven’t really talked about karma yet. But karma is this principle, if you will, of kind of cause and effect. And in the end, karma really comes down to being the actions, particularly the actions of our mind, kind of the mental movement that we have.

And what the Buddha says is that every time that the mind moves, we create kind of an imprint, a karmic imprint in the mind. So, what this is saying is that for each and every one of us, we have sort of this kind of what you’d call a latent proclivity for the afflictions to arise, kind of the seed of the afflictions that is in our mental consciousness, sort of left there by having had these states of mind previously. So we can say that one of the things that is a factor in here is that we have never of uprooted these karmic imprints in our mind. In the end, this is one of the main things that we’re going to be targeting in terms of removing that fundamental ignorance that all this is supported on. But for now, we probably can’t do a whole lot about this first one.

The reality is probably every single being, everyone in the room certainly, has this proclivity to be able to have anger arise at a particular moment on the basis of particular stimuli that are happening in the situation that we’re in. We have the proclivity for attachment to arise, for jealousy to arise, for pride to arise, and so on. These karmic imprints, again, will kind of be there. They’ve been planted in our minds through the force of our own previous actions, our own previous states of mind, And the deeper level of uprooting them is not something that we can address in major way. So whenever these kind of arise, and they’re going to arise on the basis of certain objects, which is going to be the next thing that we look at, but on the basis of those, then the delusion comes.

Kind of like, Okay, I see something very pleasurable, and it’s something that I have a strong proclivity towards. Then that seed of desire that’s in my mind causes desire to arise again. This is just kind of understanding that we have planted these seeds in the past, and every time that we engage in that delusion, we create more seeds for it to arise again in the future. So as I said, there’s not a lot we can do about keeping these from being in our mind, the ones that exist already. We can stop planting so many through the force of not having the delusions as strongly.

Some of the other ones are going to be more relevant to the immediate situation that we’re in, and that starts with the second one. As I mentioned, it’s the actual objects themselves. So although the object doesn’t exist in this kind of independent, concrete way this is what we’re talking about in regard to this ignorance that’s operative and the wisdom that cuts through that we still can admit that there are objects. There’s no doubt that there are objects. We have objects all around us.

And particular objects cause specific delusions to arise. And it’s very different for each one. Again, going back to Rita’s example, the object there is the paper, and when that paper is in her presence, it provides the basis for the delusion of attachment to arise. For each of us in the room, we have our own other objects that we’ve developed that relationship with. It’s very, very specific, this either external or it could even be an internal thing.

It could be an idea or a thought. Right? I mean, it’s not always an external object that we might have an attachment towards. It could be some idea of that dream person that we want to find in our life or something. We have an ability to conjure up in our mind objects of desire or objects of hatred even.

But the object plays a key role. Without the object, there is no way that the delusion will arise. Lama Yeshe talks about how in the book Wisdom Energy about how this is exemplified when we’re shopping and we see something desirable on the shelf. How at some level the object almost seems, again, of the relationship we have with that object, it has this very desirable quality for us. Okay, I mean, go back to the paper.

For Rita, that’s kind of there. That is appearing. It’s this very desirable quality that causes her to have this strong desire to acquire that, to have that in her life. And for each of us, we can admit that there are objects that do that for us, that seem to have that kind of really tasty quality to them. And then we have the ones that are the undesirable objects, the stuff that we don’t want.

That when we have an interaction with that object, we instantly don’t want that object in our life. We want to remove it. So again, this arrival of the delusion is greatly contingent upon the object. So what do you think the implications on a practical level are for this understanding that the object is playing a key role in causing the delusion to arise? Anyone?

To understand Oh, sorry. Go ahead. To understand that the object really isn’t the cause for the delusion. You didn’t say that correctly. Well, in reality, yeah, I mean, we’re imputing all of that on it.

I think that’s another level of understanding. But even just at the level of kind of being in physical contact with an external object or mentally bringing to mind an internal object, if we know that this is playing a role Yeah, Steve. I was gonna say, since we’re surrounded by countless objects, we have a big job. Yeah, yeah. I think that this is a bit of the challenge, Israel.

All of which we will leave here when we die. Yeah, I think thinking about the fact that we’re going to have to separate from these objects helps. But can we also start to separate from them right now? You know? We don’t go in shoe stores.

Maybe Rita needs to avoid Office Depot and pay for stuff. Yeah, but this is the truth. Yeah, Claudia. It doesn’t mean that we can’t enjoy objects. It’s how we relate to them.

It’s not that all of a sudden we have to, like, we can’t enjoy something. It’s just about our own I think what we have to acknowledge, like Venerable Rubina says, we are junkies born in a world of junk. And at some point, the junkie needs to say, Okay, I can’t be around the junk because otherwise I know I’m going to use. I know I’m going to continue to perpetuate an unhealthy relationship with that object. Claudia is pointing out something good, which is that at a deeper level, the object isn’t the problem.

The object is a cause for the delusion to arise. But the object in and of itself and the pleasure we get from the object even isn’t a problem. What is the problem is the mind of delusion that arises in the presence of that object because we don’t understand the process and we haven’t put into place the controls to allow us to be able to be with the object in a healthy way. So initially, a very first line of defense for dealing with the delusions is to separate from the objects that cause you delusions. You know, if there’s a person in your life who is very difficult, as hard as it may be, particularly if it’s a relative, to be separated from them, you might have to make that decision.

You might have to say, Well, you know, I’m finding that the relationship that we have is not so beneficial for me right now because I get angry a lot, you know, or whatever the case might be. Well, then we might need some of that distance. It’s not to push that being out of, or that object out of your life completely, but to acknowledge that you need some space between you and the object to be able to develop a healthier relationship so that you can then be in the presence of the object. And if it’s a pleasurable object, experience its pleasure and not get so desirous. Yeah, Rowena.

Well, there’s middle stages which can be used. They’re not always easy to use. But coming from like I mean, have several places like bookstores I’m kind of like don’t go into too frequently myself. But you have to just watch, watch for a while how your emotions are working because there’s different levels. I mean, oh, I think I want this book.

Well, then maybe I’ll go to Borders or go online to Amazon, then I start looking at six books. You know? I mean you can watch how your attachment works. And then you can sort of apply the brakes and say, Okay, I’ve got one book not six. Or, This is more valuable to me over time and maybe this is worthwhile indulging in a little bit.

It doesn’t always work that way if you have aversion. Attachment I think is easier. The just simple attachments are easier. When you have aversion it’s a little harder because that sort of grabs you emotionally and can sort of come up from behind and sock you on, you know, when you think, Oh, I can speak to this person. All of a sudden, they say something that, you know, just pushes your buttons.

You’re, you know, you have to watch it. Okay. It comes through this emotional part of your being that is really not always a stable quantity, you Again, I think that this is the ground for us to each individually explore as to kind of what we need in our own lives. And there are some people who might give up drinking, but they were never at the level of addiction to alcohol that other people were, so that they can still be in the presence of alcohol, it’s not a problem for them. But, you know, we have to gauge our own sort of what level of addiction do we have to things.

And for those things that we might start with the thing that you feel is the one that drives you totally crazy. You know, the thing that pulls you in and it’s so convincing that this is the source of your pleasure. I’m not denying there’s some pleasure there. But in the end, we do find that the pleasure we experience is our own pleasure of that object. As we said, not everybody experiences that object the same.

So we have to begin to understand the internal mechanism that’s happening here. And this is the tie, actually, between the karmic imprint and the object, is that you have to have some sort of karmic predisposition for that particular object to have that experience with you. It looks very enticing. We even kind of grow to like certain things. Like maybe earlier in your life you didn’t like a particular food, and then all of a sudden you started to taste it and pull it into your life.

Then you developed even more attachment to it, because the karmic imprints for you to continue to see that in that very desirable way is something that you’ve created. So again, it’s all the mechanism within our own minds as to how these objects appear and how we relate to them. But there’s always this kind of relationship between a particular object and the karmic imprints that we have. So we can get some flavor, some idea of what we have done with our minds based on the objects that we have in our lives. But all of them, in and of themselves, like Claudia was pointing out, the object, nor the pleasure or pain for that matter, that we experience from that object is the problem.

It’s our relationship to that. How we look at that. How we exaggerate that. How we then have delusion on the basis of that. Okay, so objects definitely play a role.

And like I said, that’s kind of our first line of defense. Maybe all of you are a lot stronger than me and need to, you know, you can be in the presence of the objects that bring you delusion and not have the delusion. But most of us find that we do have to be very careful about what objects we have in our lives And cut off those ones again that produce heightened sense of delusion. Begin where you are and begin to cut it back in terms of having those objects removed from your life for some period of time, as I said, until you can healthily relate to them. This isn’t like some sort of puritanical instruction.

This is do we really want to have minds? I think if we begin to analyze, we see that the mind of attachment in particular, which we think is so pleasing, Right? It feels really good to go into the bookstore and to have all those kind of delicious objects on the shelves that are kind of looking at you and saying, Buy me, buy me, read me. They seem like they’re out to really please us, out to really make us feel more fulfilled in our lives. But they actually disturb our minds.

Mean, think about your mind when you saw something in a store. I’m sure it’s happened to most of us. Where you kind of liked it. Maybe initially you looked at it and you said, Well, that’s kind of nice. Then you looked around the store and you went back to it and you looked at it again.

It looks even better then. And then you go home and all you can do is think about it and wonder if the next day when you get there maybe somebody else has bought it. I hope they haven’t. And you go in. You’re just waiting at the store when the door opens to go inside and buy that object.

Then you get it and you take it home and you put it on your shelf and it looks more beautiful, it seems. Eventually it loses its luster. This is my experience, at least. But the reality is we go through that process, and it’s really very disturbing to the mind. The mind’s not at peace through any of that.

And even when we get the object home, it’s often not at peace. If it’s something that’s really delicate, maybe we fear that the cat’s going to knock it over, and you know, there it goes. And all that beautiful object gone. So again, just be honest with your own mind. It’s basically all that this instruction is about.

So, let’s go on to the third one. The third one is also acknowledging that there are some external things that do influence the arrival of the delusions. This is the influence of misleading companions. We could just call this kind of bad friends, you know? Hanging out with the wrong crowd.

This is kind of a tough one, too. But there are people in our lives who perhaps do misguide us. Who, not from their side that they’re horrible people. They probably have great concern for our well-being even, but they steer us into engaging with objects and having more delusion just by their influence, just by being in our lives. Again, if we compare it to somebody who’s dealing with some form of substance abuse, well, obviously, all the people that they used to hang out with when they were engaging in that substance are those sorts of people for them when they’re trying to withdraw from that substance.

So whether it be an alcoholic or someone involved with other substances, basically they need to probably again separate themselves from the people who encourage that type of behavior. So again, it’s not at these extremes necessarily in our life. We might need to be a little more careful in regard to just the day to day people that we associate with and talk with and are with. And it’s not to, again, say that those people are some sort of Like we’re kind of better than them, and we know better, and we don’t want to be with them because they don’t know as much as we know. The idea here is that we don’t lose any of our compassion or feeling for people.

We just understand that if we’re going to work on our minds, maybe we need to be a little more careful about who we hang out with. You have a problem with that, No, no. I just think you have a hilarious example. When I was younger, I could learn languages pretty well. I was pretty stuffed on myself about it.

I was sharing a it was like a loft in New York. I could read and write French pretty well. And I had a lot of Latin in high school and somebody came along and one of the one of my loft mates was a a a poet and playwright. And this fellow came along that wanted to have him do something with Dante’s work. He wanted to teach him medieval Italian.

And of course I got real interested in wanting to learn medieval Italian. I thinking about I have no idea what they’re for. You know, but it was just one of these things because they were so geared up about medieval Italian. Oh, and read Dante in this whoops. I’m still laughing at that one because I still can’t figure it out.

Well, if we look back in our lives like this, we do see. There’s times when we just got sucked into doing something that Yeah, what was that all about? It was the influence of those people in our lives. Now, one thing to keep in mind is that, you know, as Lama Yeshe points out, it’s not that we’re saying that our friends are to blame for our delusions. Don’t get that state of mind either, where it’s like, You know, if you weren’t in my life, I’d be less angry.

You know? Well, the reality is that’s our anger. We have to own that. But we do have to understand that our friends, the people we hang out with, the people we’re choosing to have in our lives, you know, do play some role in that. Now, by all means, again, just as the same with the objects, these are not sort of inherently the problem.

The problem, of course, comes back to the delusion in our mind. And at some point in our practice, we may be strong enough in our own minds to hang out with people who might, again, be engaging in things that seem to be misleading, but we won’t be misled. Why? Because we have the integrity in our own minds that says, I’m simply not going to go there. I’m not going to be engaging in that activity.

Just as if somebody has been separated from their addiction for a long period of time, they may eventually get to a point where they’re comfortable being around it. Other people can be socially drinking, even though they were an alcoholic or consider themselves probably still an alcoholic, but have that ability to be very strong and determined in their own behavior around that, it doesn’t bother them. They don’t get coerced into doing it. They don’t get sucked back into creating that delusion again. So again, our own minds have that tendency of being influenced by the people we hang out with.

In the teachings on relating to a teacher or a guru, they say that sort of you want to find somebody to hang around with that produces good qualities, Just as if you take ordinary wood and put it with sandalwood, eventually that takes on the scent of sandalwood. And so it’s the same sort of thing. We take on the scent or the flavor of what we are hanging out with. If you want to have sort of a harsh and belligerent side to your personality, well then hang out with those types of people. But if you want to be soft and compassionate and caring, then you need to probably put people in your life that support that.

Yeah, Albert. There’s another manifestation of this. Uh-huh. For some time, I was drawing clients to me as an architect. Mhmm.

I was drawing clients who I finally figured out that I was judging for one reason. Mhmm. Mhmm. I finally drew in this client who was a big game hunter. Wow.

Uh-huh. And he asked me to design essentially a room for his house that was a museum for all these dead things. Mhmm. And I thought I had one of those moments of what can I learn from this person? Right.

What can I learn about myself from this person Mhmm? Who I would judge up one side and down the other? Mhmm. Mhmm. And I decided to take the take the project Right.

Project Right. Right. For the specific purpose of learning not only about this person, but Uh-huh. What he was reflecting to me Uh-huh. About my own thoughts and judgments.

Mhmm. And there were a lot of times where I squirmed in this process, But it was probably one of the most engaging learning processes that I ever had in the last few years. Well, think you’re pointing out something that can be true for those people who are ready to learn those sorts of lessons and be, again, confident enough in their own because there could be somebody, for example, maybe a person with different predispositions who would actually maybe be very enticed by this project and actually want to become a big game hunter themselves through the process of that. You used it as a technique to look at your own stuff and your own judgment to people and so on. And that’s a very admirable and worthwhile use of that interaction.

But also to see even though he’s doing things that I Yeah, yeah, yeah. And simultaneously, I was working with a client who I adored. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, absolutely. So, going back to this, I mean, I don’t think that we’re saying, again, don’t hang out with these people.

Don’t take money from them. Don’t have them as your clients, whatever the case might be. We’re saying, again, understand that they do have an influence. And if you feel confident enough in what you’re about, and as Albert’s pointing out, wanting to have some different experience with that, it can be very valuable. At some point in our teachings here, we will talk about mind training and transforming our mind to the point where we actually look at sort of people who we might see as misleading or, from our side, a bit malevolent or malicious, what have you, and actually see them as people that we need to embrace in our lives.

Why? Because they help us to work on our own qualities of compassion and patience and understanding and getting rid of some of the garbage that we overlay on them in terms of our judgment of them. So it’s just different levels of practice. The level of practice that we’re probably at right now, many of us in the room, is I simply need to acknowledge that some people in my lives may not be the best guides for me, may not be the best influence on me. Yeah, Elena.

I don’t know how to put that, but sometimes these influences, they are negative. They are working and they have own things too. Yeah. Yeah. Going through the same process that you are going.

Yeah. Yeah. Trying to get away. I just was quoting that because my object work with the mom, and ten minutes before the baby was born for the protocol, they changed it to a different midwife. Alright.

And then Wow. And the baby was gone, are around people who want the same thing all the time. That’s interesting. Yeah. That’s an interesting example, yeah.

Yeah, I think you’ve got With that awareness, though, you can work with it and understand it and then still have Yeah, find a way of changing that and being more joyful all the time. But yeah. Yeah. You want to be the one with the hands on first. Yeah.

So any other comments on this idea? Kind of again. Just to understand that this does play some role. For some of us, it may not be major. Mean, many of us might have kind of our own mindset.

We might hang out with this person or that person. And they say various things, but we don’t get kind of caught up. I think one of the ways that I see that it happens most frequently is just with kind of conversation. People that you talk to that you might spend you go out for coffee with them, or you talk to them on the phone, friends. And my own experience and it’s not necessarily to say that this is yours I’ve been involved with Buddhism for, what, about seventeen years now.

And basically, over that time, my friends have changed. You know, a lot of the people that were in my life seventeen years ago aren’t in my life right now. Now, that happens naturally with a lot of people anyway when they move around or what have you, which I have done as well. But I think it also got to the point where there was nothing more that we were kind of meeting on. The people that were in my life, it’s not that they were necessarily misleading, but the sorts of conversations we’d have, the time that we’d spend together felt, again, not maybe as conducive to where I was at as person.

And it’s not a judgment. And it’s really not me saying, Oh, I’m better than them now, and they’re less than me now, and they need to be out of my life because of that. It’s just what naturally happens. As we pursue any form of working on ourselves, which is what Buddhism is all about, we’re going to find out things about ourselves. And that’s going to have some bearing on who we have in our lives.

So it’s not that you get, again, very Yeah, think it’s probably enough on it. But the idea here is that you do this in a very gentle way. Don’t divorce people from your compassion and your love, your concern. But find a way, again, to not be so guided by their influence by what they do and say. Let’s go on to the fourth one, which actually is kind of a little bit related, but it has a slightly different flavor.

And this is also an external factor, which is following false teachings. False here is kind of a strong word. But we mean teachings or advice or philosophy that really doesn’t accord with how things exist and how, if we gain some confidence through this course, for example, of understanding Buddhist psychology, how the mind works, well, then any teachings that go of divert from that, that provide advice that is in contradiction to that, then these would be what we consider false teachings. So we’re not saying, we’re not kind of setting it up again as like, well, Buddhism teaches everything that’s correct, and all the other spiritual traditions and philosophies are all wrong. We’re just saying, listen to what you have heard in your life, prior teachings that you’ve had, prior influence that you’ve had from society at large as well, that have made you think in a particular way.

And question those and examine whether you’re following some other way of being that might be in contradiction to what you’re learning here. Now, it’s not to say, again, that what you’re learning here is absolute. This is a relative way of working with your life, and something that we can understand through experience. And if you’re finding that what you’re hearing here gives you more spaciousness in your own life, gives you more compassion, more open heartedness in how you’re dealing with things, well, you should be finding that that’s a positive result in your life, and you’re feeling better about who you are and who you are in the world. And these teachings will appear contrary to that.

But I use the example sometimes of, like, I didn’t quite grow up in the ’60s. I was in my younger years in the ’60s. But there was an awful lot of of a tone that was set in a lot of the country around the ethics of the ’60s. Use the phrase, know, if it feels good, do it. A lot of people were living their lives by this mentality, right?

I mean, without a doubt. People were engaging in whatever it was with the understanding of, you know, if it feels good, well, then just do it. You know, just go for it. Well, is this a philosophy that we want to live our lives by? Sounds pretty contradictory to what the Buddha’s saying.

You know? Because our feelings of pleasure, feeling good, isn’t the measure of whether something actually should be engaged in or not. Temporary, sensual pleasures, what have you, are all very fleeting in nature and don’t really lead to any real firm satisfaction in our minds if we examine them. Well, then if we follow those kinds of teachings, are we really going to make any progress? Are we really going to provide ourselves with an opportunity to grow and develop?

So again, there’s lots of different examples of what we might find as false teachings, but it can be the influences of other information that we receive from spiritual traditions that may have a particular tone to them that could be contradictory to this. But again, I’m not saying one’s right, one’s wrong. It’s just from your own experience. If you’re finding that what we’re learning here contributes to your well-being, and that you’re gaining some conviction in the validity of these teachings, well then the falsity of other teachings will become more apparent, because they don’t lead to those states of mind. Again, from my experience.

The way that Lama Yeshe kind of encapsulates this is he says, Misconceptions and misinformation cause more delusion if the mind lacks discriminating wisdom knowledge, which is the other side of this. It’s not to say that there’s, again, this sort of influence from these that is just from its own side going to take us into incorrect behavior or more delusion. We can discriminate. We can think about what we’re hearing. Think about what the people around you are saying.

Think about the general philosophy that you’ve lived your life by. Think about all the teachings that you’ve had. And discriminate what is correct and what isn’t. I think if we use our discriminating wisdom, we find that in most spiritual traditions and philosophies, there certainly are some things that resonate, that are true. But there may be some things that, again, go against the grain of what we’re trying to do.

So just use your own discrimination to discern what is false, what is true. And that is based, again, on your own experience. Did anyone have any experience with this or an example that they wanted to share? Yeah, Albert? For me, the point or the lying is that any teaching or following that professes that I’m separate from Uh-huh.

Uh-huh. The planet Uh-huh. Or my creator Uh-huh. Is the indicator Uh-huh. That this is not where I wanna be.

Right. Right. Because I want to experience that pain. Mhmm. It’s not that I would make them bad.

Right. It’s just a path that I don’t want to follow. Right, right. That’s a good one. Yeah, definitely.

I think, you know, when we look back at the Judeo Christian tradition and how a lot of the world has lived, there’s this idea of kind of an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. This is a general tenet of a lot of society, right? And this is how wars are created. Again, this goes, in my heart, goes against the grain of what Buddha’s teaching, you know, and what Christ taught even for that matter. I mean, Christ said, somebody slaps one cheek, you turn the other cheek to him.

He didn’t say, You slap them back. You know? So again, I think that if we look, we find some truth that resonates with how we’re trying to live our lives, with what brings us meaning, with what helps us to be better people in the world. So instead of an eye for an eye, it might be, you know, take an eye and I’ll give you the second eye for free. The idea here is, again, we have to begin to question the way that we are buying into various philosophies.

Philosophies. And then they’re incorporated into our behavior, into the delusions that we might have. The hatred we might generate for parts of the world or for people in the world on the basis of these types of tenets, philosophies. Yeah, John. There was one that I heard in the ’90s a lot that always struck me as wrong, but it was widespread.

It’s every person has their price. Yeah. Yeah. That’s just not true. That was a very commonly, widely held All politicians are corrupt.

I mean, this is the modern day one, you know. I mean, I think it Surprise. Yeah, it does kind of influence us. I think with these sorts of ideas that, again, get bounced around in the world at large that we kind of buy into, and at some level, they reinforce some level of delusion. Some level of how we’re not looking at things with an understanding that the Buddha’s really telling us that things are changeable.

That the mind has got the potential for so much more. So yeah, I think this is something it’s a very interesting area to just kind of begin to pay attention to the way that you’re buying into false teachings. It’s a good one. All right. Judith.

Yeah. In working in programs that help people who are living in poverty, one of the things that we have learned is that many people see people living in poverty as having a character flaw. Right. Right. That’s so erroneous.

Mhmm. And that they have nothing to do with that. Right. Those who are looking from the outside. Right.

And it really impacts service and the notion of community how we see other people. Absolutely. Discard that moment. Yeah. We do this with poverty.

We do it with gender, with race, with so many things in society that I think can know, that evolution of if you have lots of things, that must mean you’re a good person. Yeah, yeah. It’s really unfortunate. I think it’s good to be more critical in your own mind as to what you hear and how you think about it, and develop your own discriminating wisdom that is capable to see the truth rather than buy into all these sort of generalities and conceptions that society holds. Let’s go on to number five.

Number five’s a big one. This is the one that I think we have to also acknowledge as something we can do about right now. The force of it is a pretty obvious habit. So while the first one kind of referred to the fact that we’ve laid these karmic imprints in our mind through this type of behavior in the past, the delusions in the past, this is talking about kind of what we’re doing in the present in terms of the influence of the past, but also how we strengthen it through our continual delusion. We are more inclined to have the delusions that we are more habituated towards.

I hear it all the time, people who say, Well, you know, I’m just an angry person. That’s just the way I am. Well, why are they an angry person? We wouldn’t even agree that they’re an angry person. But why are they an angry person?

Because they are very habituated to anger. They have created I like to use this idea of kind of a groove. They’ve created a groove in the mind that then they fall into all the time because the groove is so deep and so pervasive in their mind that even the smallest thing triggers that response of anger because they’re greatly habituated towards it. So habit plays a strong, strong role in terms of the arrival of the delusions in our mind, because those things that we’re habituated towards will Those tendencies that we’re habituated towards will arise much more frequently. So the good thing about understanding this role of habit is that while here we’re talking about it in regard to how the delusions arise, habit also is completely a factor in how we have more wholesome states of mind arising.

So right now we’ve got these grooves for anger and attachment and whatever that it kind of falls into so much easier. But we can, through not using those states of mind, not cultivating those states of mind, they will eventually kind of fill themselves in. And the deeper grooves that we have may be a sense of non attachment, non hatred, loving kindness, compassion. All of those also are habitual states of mind that will strengthen over time. This is the nature of our minds.

Again, that our minds are shaped by the thoughts that we have. If we continue to perpetuate the delusions, then we are under their influence to a large degree, and they will always be kind of hanging out there, waiting to happen. However, if we become more habituated to the positive states of mind, then those are the states of mind that will arise more frequently. Again, don’t have to look so far to see examples of this in our world, but to understand that we can be just like them. His Holiness the Dalai Lama talks about how when he meets anybody, regardless of who that person is, how he just has this feeling that this is just simply a person I haven’t met yet, but he feels this extreme openness to them.

Sees him as somebody who’s kind of like an object of love that just simply hasn’t entered into his life yet. I was really taken aback a bit when I was living in San Francisco. One of the first In the first few years that I was studying Buddhism, somebody showed me a picture of His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, with Senator Jesse Helms, with a smile on their faces, looking at each other like best buddies. And it was a real contradiction for me. Because, again, I was seeing through the eyes of my own way of kind of perceiving Jesse Helms and then perceiving the Dalai Lama.

But the Dalai Lama has a mind that’s not habituated to those sorts of delusions. And he was able to be with Jesse Helms in a very open and spacious and compassionate way. They also happened to share, both of them, a distaste for occupied Tibet and wanting that situation to end with communist China and what have you at the time. So there was some common ground that they were finding. But regardless of that, I have no doubt that His Holiness is greatly habituated to having loving kindness and compassion for whoever he meets.

That he’s not going to make those sorts of value judgments. Like, I can’t be in a picture with Jesse Helms. Forget it. This guy’s a bigot. This guy’s whatever.

Own projection. Sorry about that. Go ahead. Projection number two here was His Holiness is quoted as saying he thought George Bush was a nice man. And I know that of us might have a different opinion.

Different opinion. A few people, maybe. You know, and so you have to really sort of, okay. What’s the context in which His Holiness is actually looking at someone? I obviously am not there yet.

So we have our own habits that, again, influence the arrival of these delusions, because then they’re more inclined to arise, but we can habituate the mind otherwise. I think that’s one of the things, again, in looking at this that’s important to emphasize is that habit works both ways. Oh, sorry. Any comments or questions on that? Lama Yeshe says, Habit builds up certain associations so strongly that whenever a similar situation arises, your mind automatically runs toward delusion.

So again, I think habit is something that we can definitely acknowledge as playing some sort of a role in all of this. And in terms of our very practical advice, we have to start breaking the habit. So when you have that tendency of the mind of anger arising in a particular situation, I think one of the from my experience, one of the easiest places to start to work on this is driving. That when you’re out there driving, and you’re dealing with other drivers who are kind of out there driving, too, and doing their thing, that you need to watch the mind and see what sort of things habitually arise on the basis of somebody cutting in front of you, somebody not giving you the right of way, you know, what have you. All these various things that we encounter in driving.

Driving, I think, is a wonderful place to start, because then it’s a relatively safe space in terms of, you know, there is some distance between you and the other people. It’s not like you’re there and maybe you start getting into road warrior stuff doing all this. But usually there’s some distance. And so you can just sit in your car with all this metal around you and work on your own mind and hopefully have some changes. But you’ll see that things change over time.

And initially, just an awareness that that habitual response of getting angry is there. It might come after you’ve already honked your horn and done all sorts of stuff, yelled at them. And then eventually it’ll come when you’re halfway through that, and eventually it’ll come when you’re just starting to do that, and eventually it’ll come before you do that. You kind of go, Oh, there’s that. There’s that anger arising.

I don’t need to follow that. And that’s how we change our habit. But it comes slowly. The last one, the sixth factor. We’ve already spoken about this to a large degree, but I think it’s important to put it up here.

Is mistaken conceptualization. We haven’t put these words to it, but this is what we’ve been talking about in the past when we said, well, the mind is going through this whole thought process that is overlaying other levels of attractiveness on the basis of something that’s pleasing, or unattractiveness on the basis of something that is unpleasant. This mistaken conceptualization is something that is, again, pretty pervasive, and it’s definitely a part of the delusion arising. Because it’s not that, again, if we analyze our experience, we encounter something that’s pleasant. There’s simply a good feeling that arises.

And we talked about this last week. Feeling in and of itself isn’t the problem. It’s our reaction to that feeling. And we overlay all kinds of stuff on it and think it’s the most beautiful, wonderful feeling. We do this particularly, as I said last week, with relationships with people in our lives, where all of a sudden you’re overlaying all this about the attractive qualities of that person.

Lama Zopa was I wish I’d brought with me the transcript of what he taught in North Carolina. He was very, very cute when he was talking about it. It was very endearing. But you know, we do this I’ll read a little bit from this. He says, The mind works in such a way Oh, you have a boyfriend, for example, with whom you are obsessed.

You find his every movement and gesture interesting, the way he walks, what he says. By the way, you can fill in girlfriend if you need to. What he does. It all seems good to you. Even when he does something incredibly bad for you, becomes a source of pleasure.

You’re concentrating so much on his attractive qualities that his negative aspects are totally obscured. The mind works in such a way, however, that if one day he says something particularly unpleasant to you, your attitude begins to change. You think he’s not nice at all. Your mind concentrates on this thought: not nice, not nice, not nice. Soon everything about him appears repulsive.

There’s nothing about him anymore that is pleasing to you. You can see this happen, can’t you? It’s incredible how the deluded mind works. First something appears completely positive, and then it changes to its opposite. So again, we’ve got these minds like yo yos, like was on the sheet that I gave you with the outline, that’s going up and getting all excited about what we see and thinking it’s so wonderful.

Then it changes over time, and all of a sudden they’re the most horrible person in our life, and we can’t wait to be rid of them. This is our mistaken conceptualizations, because we are overlaying all kinds of stuff on this. And so we have to have a much more balanced mind, a mind that kind of embraces all of it, that understands that you kind of get warts and all. You get the whole package with the people that we experience, with the situations that we’re in, with the objects that we experience. Not let the mind get so excited when it’s really positive, so downfalling when it’s negative.

So these mistaken conceptualizations are again some area where I think we can target. So if we talked about kind of right now, what can you do? You can’t probably do a whole lot about the karmic imprints that you have. You have to acknowledge that until we do the deeper work that kind of removes the whole foundation that all that’s based on, and we’ll talk about that over time, but again, that’s something we probably won’t be able to be completely rid of. But we can, through stopping the delusions, diminish the amount of imprints that we do have in the mind.

The objects, we can certainly separate from those things that we feel we need some distance initially in order to relate to them more on a more healthy basis. Misleading companions can be very critical about who you hang out with. Or if you hang out with them, you still need to hang out with them. Be critical about how much you buy into the things that they’re espousing, because that can have some influence. Just be critical.

Again, use your discerning knowledge. Also with false teachings, looking at what’s influenced you. And certainly, habit. Break the habit of doing these things. Again, this isn’t meant to be some sort of advice of you have to do this or else, or you should do this.

It’s saying if you want the results that I think you want in your life, which is more peace, more contentment, not a mind that’s so disturbed, well then breaking that habit is important. If you want to continue to have those delusions in your mind, then that’s, again, a choice that we need to make. But the ideal thing would be to move away from the habit of the delusions and move towards the habit of more constructive, more positive states of mind. And then finally, the mistaken conceptualization. I think we can do a lot about this.

See how that arises. Be more critical when you’re around particularly desirous objects. I think when it comes to the negative objects, we know that it doesn’t necessarily feel good to be angry or to be in a place of hatred. And we might be able to lessen some of that more naturally simply because it’s a very unpleasant thing. But attachment seems to be all about pleasant, as I said.

It makes you feel good. But it really isn’t. It’s counterproductive. It’s producing more disturbance in the mind than what it is pleasure. So be really critical with what’s going on in your mind when you’re interacting with what is pleasant and what is unpleasant in particular.

We also have that towards what is neutral. As we saw in the meditation from last week on equanimity, even with strangers, we have kind of just a feeling of indifference. Well, at some level, that’s a mistaken conceptualization, too, Isn’t it? To have a mind of indifference, why are we unconcerned about that person or being? Indifference isn’t the same thing as just observing.

Yeah, exactly. I mean, I think that we have to be, again, using our wisdom throughout all this and trying to be really critical as to how we are thinking about things, regardless of what type of object that is in our lives. So any last comments or questions before we leave this topic and have our break? If I was an advertising executive, I would use these six factors in selling things to people. Would you?

It would It would be understanding that not everyone has the karmic imprint to be attracted to your product. Right. And let’s take cigarettes, because I think that’s a very strong example. Uh-huh. So the objects, the cigarettes, the next step is influencing misleading companions.

There you can have the barber or man or, you know, someone that is attractive to people. So you’re saying they’re using them to cause more delusion to arise? Psychologically, it’s a key to help people get advertising sucks us into. Yeah, yeah, I think there’s something to be said for that. Yeah, that definitely, you know, these factors are used by companies, by the world at large, to entice us into various things.

Once you establish a habit, a mistake in conceptualization would be that what you’re doing is actually good when it’s not. It gives you pleasure when it really isn’t. Or sometimes also with mistaken conceptualization, it’s like you already have something, but I have something better. There’s something missing in what you have. And that’s the other element that we’re always playing with with these conceptualizations, is wanting more, wanting better.

Wanting something this has happened to a large degree with technology. Mean, my gosh, how much technology has advanced in this last few decades? And every year, within the course of a year, you’ve got I was really a bit taken aback when I saw the lines that were forming for this iPad product. People They said they actually had a news report how they were asking people online if they had any idea what this thing did, and they said no, but they wanted one. It’s just like, I want one.

You know, I’m in line with my five hundred dollars or whatever, but I have no idea what I’m buying. They’ve done that with pet rocks, and it was a little comfy thing. I don’t know if they had Yeah, well, I suppose with pet rocks, but I think that we have to acknowledge that this is playing a role in the arrival of that kind of unsatisfied mind that’s craving new and craving better, craving more. So see it at whatever level it’s manifesting in your life and begin to yeah, deflate some of that. Because the more that we buy into it, it’s not again, it’s not like it’s an inherent problem.

It’s a relative problem. It’s a problem for us. Why? Because this is not a source of peace and satisfaction in our lives. It’s a source of disturbance and continual dissatisfaction.

We’re continually driven in this way. So just be very critical in your own mind using these six factors. It’s also the basis for divisive behavior. I mean, I’m going through my own mental processes, and it makes you judge people the wrong way. It makes you judge everything you do.

It’s sort of really skewed. I agree. All right, let’s take a short break. When we come back, we’re gonna talk a little bit about karma in the mind and the role that the mind plays in that. So one thing Elena was talking to me during the break, and actually I should have mentioned it as well in regard to number four, is this idea when we say following false teachings, a lot of it is even what we get from our parents and the sort of upbringing that we have.

And we were talking about this idea of kind of even how their view of what might be a successful life influences us so greatly. It looks like this. You know, a home in that particular range with this type of job, with that type of status, with this type of partner, with those many children or whatever. I mean, there’s all this stuff that gets layered on us that influences kind of how we see ourselves and how we see the world. And so understand that, again, false teachings come from all sorts of directions.

They come oftentimes primarily from our homes, from how we’re brought up and the sorts of values that we’re taught by our parents. So it’s an important thing to acknowledge. And again, I’m not saying that they were all wrong. I’m saying we have to just be critical in looking at them, discriminating. Well, is this the correct way to be?

Yeah. There. I was thinking about that earlier, and I find it very difficult when I go to India, for example, I’m speaking with someone in English, and we seem to be saying the same words, understanding each other, but yet they come from a completely different set of values, which I’m not aware of, unlike I am to them. And it ends up that there can be surprises involved. And they can say, how did that happen?

I thought we understood each Yeah. Yeah, so I think we have to have a critical ear, a critical eye. One of the things that I’ve encouraged from the beginning of this module, too, those of you who are new to discovering Buddhism, is that you have to bring that same critical eye to these teachings as well. I can tell you these teachings are true from my own experience, but it means something else when you find that they’re true for yourselves. In that way, the teachings will be so much more impactful rather than just being something that you kind of know about and you can recite the words, but you don’t really have the taste or the experience of it.

Any other last comments or questions then before we move on to karma? Okay. So, this word karma gets used a lot even in Western language, there’s perhaps some misunderstandings about it. We’ll look at that in a lot more detail in module six when we talk about karma. But technically it means action.

And so what we’re talking about when we talk about it and referring to this idea of cause and effect, we’re mostly talking about the causes. So we use the term karma as referring to those actions of either our mind or by way of our body and speech that’s influenced by our mind. Those actions that then create a seed, if you will, that gives rise to a result. It’s the cause that produces a result. So karma is kind of a tough concept to get because there’s nothing we can really kind of point at and say, There it is.

That’s karma. That thing is karma. Just in the same way that we refer to the mind. Kind of hard because we know our minds from our own experience, but there’s nothing you can kind of point to and say that that is the mind. But understanding karma and embracing karma is a pretty central concept of most of the Asian schools of thought, and particularly in Buddhism.

His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, in the article that’s actually part of the Discovering Buddhism required reading materials for this module, the article that’s called What is Mind. He says there are two reasons why it is important to understand the nature of mind. One is because there is an intimate connection between mind and karma. The other is that our state of mind plays a crucial role in our experience of happiness and suffering. And these are actually very much correlated.

Mind and karma are kind of working together to produce our experiences. So there’s a wonderful quote. I’d mentioned that I was going do a quote from the Dhammapada. The Dhammapada is sort of a collection of the sayings of the Buddha. It’s a very central text that’s used in a lot of Buddhist traditions.

And there is a Tibetan Dhammapada that contains a number of very brief writings in verse. There’s this one that’s got two verses to it. The very first one is, Mind is the forerunner of all states. Mind is chief. Mind made are they.

If one speaks or acts with an impure mind, suffering follows, like the wheel that follows the cart pulling ox. Second one is, Mind is the forerunner of all states. Mind is chief, mind made are they. If one speaks or acts with a pure mind, happiness follows, like one’s shadow that never leaves. So Lama Zopa quoted this in North Carolina this year as well.

But the idea here is you have two different things going on. Just this general idea that mind is the forerunner. Mind is what precedes everything. And based on having a pure mind, happiness will follow, just like your shadow follows you. The shadow never leaves in that way that the happiness will continue to follow you from the actions, the states of mind that were pure, that were more virtuous, more wholesome.

The other one, the first one, working with an impure mind. Just as the wheel follows the cart pulling ox, if If the ox is at the front pulling the cart, well, wheels just naturally follow. In the same way, suffering naturally follows from those actions that we engage in with an impure mind. So this is one of the fundamental principles of karma, is that karma is quite precise. That if we have impure states of mind, suffering follows.

If we have pure states of mind, happiness follows. And they never get mixed up. If you have sort of these impure states of mind, you don’t get happiness as a final result from them. Now it might seem like at the moment we’re getting happiness because an impure mind, for example, this is referring to the minds that are quite afflictive that lead to non virtue, like attachment or anger. You know, at the moment when attachment is there, might seem like it’s leading to our happiness.

But the reality is those states of mind are actually impure. They’re actually unwholesome, and they lead to suffering results. Again, if you’re very critical, you can see, as I was saying earlier, that the mind is actually quite disturbed at that moment. And that in and of itself is some form of suffering. But it also means that eventually, for example, if we have a mind that’s really quite miserly and very wanting to be attached and hold onto our own possessions, and when people come and ask us for money for something, we’re like, No, I can’t give you any.

It’s mine. Well, they say that this mind of attachment is an impure mind that leads to the future suffering of not having resources. If we have that greedy, grasping mind that doesn’t want to give away what we have, doesn’t want to share what we have, well then we will be denied resources in the future. Again, it’s not some divine retribution for our actions. It’s simply the way it works.

The sort of energy that you create comes back around to create those types of results in your life. And they’re completely concordant. Unhealthy states of mind bring about negative results. Healthy states of mind bring about positive results. And the Buddha didn’t invent this.

The Buddha simply observed it. So this is the understanding that we need to have of karma. Not that it’s some divine rule that the Buddha created, or that it’s some form of retribution or punishment, but rather that we look at it as it’s simply the way that things work. We’re quite convinced of cause and effect in the real world. Right?

I mean, we know that you have to do certain things to create certain results in your life. You don’t have if any of you grow vegetables in the summer, you don’t get a vegetable garden by just sitting back and going, you know, I hope there’s a vegetable garden in my backyard tomorrow. You know, it doesn’t come from a wish. It comes from its proper causes and conditions. You have to go out and you have to till the soil and put nutrients into it, plant the seeds in it, water it, make sure it gets lots of sunlight, that it’s kept away from those forces that will harm it, insects and what have you that will destroy the plants.

We have to do all that or we don’t get the crop. So we’re quite convinced of cause and effect in our daily life when it comes to the external world. The Buddha is simply saying, from his observation, karma is the way that things work in the internal world, in terms of our mind generating certain states, and then us having the experiences that are concordant with that. One of the problems, of course, with these teachings on karma, or getting some conviction in them, is that it’s very, very rarely instant. Fact, instant karma isn’t really a tenet of Tibetan Buddhism, at least.

The idea is that everything that we’re experiencing is probably coming from actions we did a long time ago. Actions in our mind, states of mind that maybe produced physical acts or verbal acts, but those left imprints in our mind that give rise to the experiences that we have. So one of the problems I always have when I’m introducing karma in this first module is that this isn’t really something that we can generate the same conviction in as some of the other things that I presented. I mean, we can get an experience of this, but it’s very hard for us to experience the role of karma in our lives. However, sometimes we can pick up on some things.

Pema Chodron uses this phrase that karma is life giving you the lessons you need to learn. So we can begin to pay attention. Well, what is manifesting in my life? If what you have in your life, for example, are people who don’t trust you, well then maybe you have to go back and look at how have I betrayed the trust of others? And maybe that’s something you could actually identify from this life, that you created the causes within this lifetime, even by your habitual way of betraying the trust of others, that then people aren’t trusting you.

Or people don’t believe what you say. Well, perhaps you need to watch your language in terms of whether you’re telling the truth all the time, whether you’re being dishonest with others, that will bring about the result of other people lying to you, or people thinking that what you’re saying is a lie. Again, we have these kinds of karmas that we can begin to discern through our own experiences. But mind is playing the fundamental role in driving this whole mechanism, and it all comes down to the role that our mind is taking and then the results that we’re experiencing. Now when it comes down to being more precise about karma, I said it was action.

But what we’re talking about when we go back to those mental factors, remember the sheet that I passed out? Some of you got it earlier. Appendix two has, on the front side, the five omnipresent mental factors, ever present mental factors. It’s a second group. One of those was intention.

Intention is this sort of, again, force of the mind that moves the mind in a particular direction. And what it all boils down to is if we had to pick apart karma and say, Well, where is it coming from? It is your intention. What’s scary is that we have intention every single moment because it’s ever present. But a lot of our intention is kind of neutral.

And then it gets flavored by the other influencing factors in our mind, the virtuous mental factors or the afflicted states of mind. So when we Actually, me give you a definition of intention from Geshela Tashi Sering. I like the way that he describes it. This is from his book on Buddhist psychology. He says, Intention is the factor that actualizes what feeling has initiated.

So again, feeling is also omnipresent. If the feeling generated upon contact with an object is attraction, intention moves the mind forward toward the object. For example, I smell a ripe mango in a shop I am passing and the feeling of attraction arises. Intention is the shift in the mental process that will drive you to buy it or to acquire it. Again, because our intention intention in and of itself isn’t attachment, but intention kind of moves the mind in particular directions.

So based on that movement of the mind, which is a reaction often to the feeling that we have, pleasant feeling, unpleasant feeling, all the other stuff kind of then follows. So we talked here about kind of how mind is the fore forerunner. It really comes down to kind of our intention is the forerunner. The way that the mind gets directed. Now, right now, we just kind of have minds that are on automatic pilot.

Our intentions just go wherever the wind blows, and we don’t have much control over it. What we need to be more aware of in this whole teaching on mind and karma is to drive us to once again go back to having more control over our thoughts, over what we’re doing with our mind, And to be aware of the process that when those feelings arise and the intention starts to draw you towards those objects that are pleasant, or push away those that are unpleasant, that this is the forerunner for all the states of mind that you’re going to generate: The attachment, the desire, the aversion, the ignorance, what have you, all of this kind of coming into play. We need to get more control over this process, more awareness of this process. Because from that, karma is generated. Just the mind moving in that way produces some level of karma.

But then often we even go about engaging in other behavior on the basis of that. Some of it being quite unskillful. Yeah, Harper? I think there’s a four step process there when feeling arises and your intention starts to move your mind, and then something and then comments from Well, then, to some degree, some of the other mental factors follow. Because of all the force of some of these other influences, our habit and so on.

So, okay, we have a pleasant feeling. We’ll use his example, Geshela Tashi Sering’s example, of a ripe mango that we smell, you know, as we’re in the grocery store or whatever. And so the feeling arises. It’s quite pleasant if you like mango. Some people may not like the smell of mango, but put in whatever works for you.

So we have this smell that’s arising that’s quite pleasant. And then our intention kind of draws the mind towards that. And then the afflictions follow. Because our intention is drawing us towards that, then the attachment arises. The attachment that goes, Oh, that is so pleasant and so wonderful.

I can’t wait to buy one of those mangoes and take it home and just experience the full pleasure of the taste of that mango based on the smell. And I’m not saying that the pleasure of the taste or the smell is a problem. I’m saying the way of relating to it. And intention is what’s driving us there in the first place. It could be aversion that’s supposed to be attachments.

Yeah, because if you don’t like the smell of mango, then it could be the aversion one that’s arising. But most of us, again, are quite blind to this whole process and how intention is kind of driving the whole show in terms of the way that our minds move towards these objects and begin to relate to them on the basis of that. So I don’t if it’s quite a fourfold process, but it’s definitely I mean, the action would probably come afterwards. So there’s feeling, intention, oftentimes affliction, and then the action. A physical or verbal action could follow.

But mental action, in and of itself, is enough. That’s really what we mean by karma. Like, say you don’t have the money to buy a mango, but you’ve got a nice big pocket in your jacket that the mango will fit in. You know? Then you might, like, kind of look around and you grab the mango.

Most of us don’t do that. I hope most of us don’t do that. But some people will. Some people will put the mango in their pocket and go home. Just experiencing the desire is not enough to create the harm you have to take into the action.

No, no, no. My point is that once you have that kind of intention that is moving in that direction, then you already are creating some form of karma there. So this is what’s a little I think it’s a little scary. But it also again means that if we have more control over the process, we actually have the mechanism for producing all the good results that we want in our lives. Because the wholesome intention we bring to things actually allows good karma to be created, positive karma.

Yeah, I know we’re getting back into this dualistic thing of positive and negative and what have you. But this is again, conventionally how things work. The Buddha is simply saying, you know, we call this result suffering, and this result of suffering that we label as such arises from these types of actions, these types of unwholesome actions. And it can be actions of mind, body, or speech. On the other hand, the Buddha’s observing and saying, this result that we call pleasant, that we call happiness, this arises from its respective causes, just like tomatoes from tomato seeds and apples from apple seeds.

Just a simple observation. But the action, when we say action, we mean any movement of the mind in a particular direction. And that happens initially with intention. But what happens is that intention often gets flavored through the force of delusion because all these other factors contribute to the arrival of those delusions at that time. The real mechanism that’s happening is just our mind kind of going there.

They say it’s sort of like the way that iron filings are drawn to a magnet. They just kind of intention works quite spontaneously. I often talk about I used to say when we talked about karma that learning about karma is to learn to get in the driver’s seat to take charge of where your mind is going. But then I kind of came to the realization that it’s about learning that you already are in the driver’s seat. Because the reality is you’ve just been a really bad driver.

You’ve been just driving towards these objects with all these deluded states of mind, and you’re off the road most of the time. You’re not even really going where you want to go. If we really want to go towards lasting peace and happiness, we need more control over the mind. We need to be a better driver. And it’s not just about not getting tickets, it’s about not driving badly.

Yeah. Running over other people in the process of getting what we want, or avoiding what we don’t want. It’s a lot of things to be said for that analogy. But the idea here is that if we don’t gain some control over this intention and all these factors influencing the delusion that’s in our mind with that intention becomes the mechanism for us to experience suffering in our lives. Now, again, when we get to a deeper level of analyzing, well, what do we mean even by the happiness that we experience in our lives?

Lives? At some level that, too, in our conditioned way of existing, isn’t really satisfactory. But yet there’s nothing that kind of is problematic about preferring that. You can look at it and go, well, okay, there’s this happiness result, and there’s this suffering result. Well, which one do you want?

In conditioned existence, you’re going to experience probably one or the other, or some neutral result. There’s nothing wrong with at some level saying, I would prefer to have more happiness results in my life. Simply because it is a little bit easier if I have resources, if I have a good life where I’ve got the ability to use my mind well and to study and to do things, if we couch everything in the context of an understanding that there are some choices we can make, even at this initial point, as to what is a preferable way to live our lives. Now, it doesn’t mean that then anytime something upsets the apple cart, we have to experience a little bit of suffering, that we get totally bent out of shape because we become so attached to everything being good. But we just understand that the mechanism is there and that we are going to continue to experience, no doubt, both results: suffering and happiness.

But why not, at least for the time being, put more focus on abandoning what gives us the more overt forms of suffering and adopting those things that bring about more temporal happiness, with the understanding that those generally are what will allow you to use this life for more ultimate happiness. So this comes to the subject of kind of the mechanism that’s at work that produces even the states of existence that we have, this mechanism of karma that produces, for example, this human rebirth. And this is the meditation that I’m going to pass out in a moment. But the idea here is that the Buddha’s teachings on karma show that karma has a bearing on our experiences, as I said, kind of what you meet day in and day out, whether it brings you pleasure or pain. The Buddha also says that it has an influence to a large degree on what actual rebirths you take.

So if mind has this continuity, and if we can never find a beginning moment to our mind, and it continues on, well then when this life ends, because this life will end, this is one of the modules coming up, death and rebirth. When this life ends, we will go on. Our consciousness will continue. And the mechanism for shaping what our future existence is, is karma. The seeds that we plant, particularly those more powerful seeds, will ripen at the end of this life and propel us into another existence.

So let’s go back to what happened prior to this life. For every one of us in the room, the Buddha would say that we had an incredibly positive action that we did in a prior life. You can pat yourself on the back. You did something really phenomenal that caused whatever you were However you were living in your past life. Maybe you were another human.

Maybe you were an animal. Maybe you were in some other realm of existence. But you were able, through the force of that action, to create the causes so that at the end of that life, that ripened and that brought you into this human life. Just getting a human rebirth, they say, is pretty phenomenal. Now, look at the numbers of humans on this planet, we might think, well, it doesn’t seem like they’re that rare.

There’s six and a half billion of them now. But compare them to the number of animals which are also said to be sentient beings. And my gosh, here in Santa Fe in the summer, how many ants and other creatures occupy the same space that maybe one or two humans live in? And that’s only that one little plot of land. And they say, in the oceans, the amount of sentient beings in the depths of the oceans is phenomenal, and no human beings live there.

So we are by far outnumbered by animals on this planet. And the karma to be reborn as an animal is an unwholesome karma. Why? Because animals do have many, many more obscurations than we have, And most of them are subject to a lot different experiences in their life. Most of them live with great fear of danger, with an inability to find the resources that they need to even survive often.

And human beings at least have an intellect that they can make some decisions about, how they go about sustaining their life and what have you. So we can look at it and qualitatively say, I’m not putting animals down again. I’m just saying animals don’t have all the potential that a human being has. I didn’t bring that with me that Rowena gave me Friday night. Shoot, I forgot it.

There was a nice little bit in Time magazine, make something for kids, time for kids. There was a centerpiece that had to do with the minds of animals and how I can remember one of them, these Bonobos in Congo or somewhere or something. There’s a research center. They used language quite well. They put together two different words to refer to a third object.

So they put together for the object kale, because when they chew kale, it takes a lot longer. They put together slow and lettuce. So this is slow lettuce for kale. It’s quite ingenious. I’m not denying animals have some form of intellect, some of them at least, but it’s very limited.

Can I teach an animal all these things about the state of their mind? Get the cards. Bonobos might do it. Maybe at some point. So again, going back to at the end of your previous life, whatever it was, akarma, a really wholesome action, because a human rebirth is a very positive result, ripen for every one of you, and you took rebirth in a human womb.

So again, this is the mechanism that the Buddha would say that at a big level, our karma is determining what types of experiences we have for quite a duration of time. The individual experiences within that are also flavored by our karma. Whether we’re born in a particular part of the world, whether we’re born with resources around us, whether we’re born with good, healthy faculties, all these kinds of things are products of our karma. Well, there’s a meditation. The meditation I’m going to pass out kind of looks at this idea of a perfect human rebirth, or getting a rebirth that has not just the quality of being human, but has many other factors involved in it, which we may or may not have all of.

I’m not saying that everyone in the room can definitely say, Well, yeah, I’ve got that one, that one, that one. This topic is introduced in the first module. I don’t know why I’m not as keen on it in the first module. We will reintroduce it in the third module, and we’ll go into more detail there. But just know for now that the Buddha says that there are many different realms of existence.

We could kind of funnel them all into six different states. Three of them are unfavorable, and three are favorable. The humans and animals are kind of right in the middle. humans being kind of said to be favorable, but in terms of the amount of pleasure that we experience, not as favorable as some of these god realms, where they’re very heaven like, where beings are experiencing constant pleasures. But animals, again, there’s a fair amount of suffering, but not as much suffering as other beings that are in these sort of hellish existences, existences where they’re incapable of really having much relief from pain and suffering.

So I’m going to focus on those two in the middle. And you will get teachings and understanding of these various other realms when we get to module three. But when it comes down to this meditation on a perfect human rebirth, one of the very first things that we need to acknowledge is how incredibly fortunate we are that somewhere along the line, we created the causes to get a human rebirth and not be an animal or not be in any of these other states that are unfortunate or not as useful as this human life. But then we can even look at our own individual situation. And this is where, again, there’s a more detailed teaching on this that I’ll go into later in module three.

But we can look at things like, well, we have been born with complete faculties. I mean, how amazing. How many human beings are born without sight, without hearing, or perhaps even with mental impairment that doesn’t allow them to reason through things as much as we can. So we can really embrace this idea that we’ve created also the causes to have kind of very good faculties, mental and sense faculties. I’m not saying that if you didn’t have vision and didn’t have hearing that you couldn’t learn the Dharma or couldn’t practice spirituality in your life.

But you’re going to have a lot more challenges. We can be grateful for what we have. This whole meditation is about really acknowledging from our side what we’ve created in terms of this very powerful karma. Other things we could focus on if we feel that we’ve already gained some benefit from the Buddha’s teachings, we can focus on the fact of the karma we’ve created to come into contact with this. Or even to be born in a land where you have religious freedom to be able to be exposed to these teachings.

And my gosh, there’s some parts of the world where Buddhism is completely disallowed. There are no Buddhist teachings existing in many countries in this world. And you could have been born in one of them. The United States is quite unique in its religious freedom to some degree. So again, we can embrace a lot of these concepts and ideas.

We don’t have to understand every single little bit of freedom or endowment that we might have in this life. Let me pass out the meditation, because that’s Again, the meditation itself does not give all of these, delineate all of these. You will find them in some of the readings for the course that are part of the required reading. But this meditation on a perfect human rebirth can be done in a couple of ways. And what I would encourage you to do then is, as you’re getting this, first part basically gives that idea of focusing on these Eight Freedoms and Ten Endowments or Ten Opportunities, whatever they’re called on there.

Let me get my copy. Here it is. The Eight Freedoms and Ten Endowments. You don’t have to know all these or go back to the readings that delineate all these. I would focus on a few things again.

One, how incredibly fortunate that you’re born as a human and not as some other being. Even just compare yourself to your pet or the birds out in the yard or whatever. The ants crawling around that are still trying to prepare for winter. We compare yourself in that regard and generate some joy at what opportunity you have in this life and acknowledge that you created the causes for this. I know this is a little revolutionary, a lot of people, again, in Buddhism, this idea of a creator god isn’t embraced in terms of not saying, Well, we can disprove such a thing.

It’s simply the Buddhist point of view is that it’s not necessary. Why? Because we create everything from our own karma. I mean, the physical body that we have, the actual body, was created from two cells of your parents, sperm cell, one egg cell, that united and created this physical body that you have. But your karma to have this body, for your consciousness to be with this body, that’s all yours.

No being decided that you were going to take that rebirth. Yeah, Albert? Take on it, but the the idea that there is an intention before life. And I would subscribe to to that by saying, I know that I had an intention to Uh-huh. Experience compassion.

Uh-huh. So I chose imperfection in the human existence. Mhmm. Mhmm. What that’s done is taken me deeply into a heart experience.

Yeah. So the transformation that I needed to go through to see this defect as a positive thing that I chose Mhmm. Was an interesting path. Mhmm. But it ties all of the pieces together.

Yeah. Yeah. And so I guess what I’ve come out of this is Right. For me is the hopes of telling that story Right. That people will look at those with infirmities or especially birth conditions Right.

As perhaps a karmic device Yeah. For that person and or the family Right. That’s involved, for that life to have some other significance maybe that might not be apparent, but that evolves. I think that that’s totally in line with the idea of karma. When I said that phrase from Pema Chodron earlier, that sort of karma is life giving you the lessons you need to learn, it’s life giving whoever the lessons you need to learn because your family had lessons they needed to learn as well.

I think the difference, once again, though, is that we see that the lessons aren’t always learned. In your case, you were able to really work with what you created, you say through choice. They would say, Yeah, because of the karma that you created, this is what you had to work with. It’s just simply acknowledging that that’s the cause behind that. Now what you learn from that result that you now have to experience, that’s the richness of it.

But many people don’t learn that. I’d say there are many people probably born with birth defects that end up being angry about it, or end up feeling very less of themselves or what have you, and don’t learn that lesson. But they simply are they got the same material to work with, but they didn’t learn the lesson. They didn’t do the work that was necessary on the basis of treating that as something that they could learn from. Yeah, yeah.

Well, and we see this with so many things in the world, you know, where, yeah, That’s a very rich lesson that I would hope beings are learning all the time. Because some people look at karma and I think have problems with it. I look at it as this is the most skillful way that we can actually learn and grow in our lives is by paying attention to what is around us in our own condition and the condition of others who are in our lives. It makes everything very rich because the responsibility, once again, still does come back then down to ourselves. I mean, one of the other reasons why, again, in the Buddhist tradition there isn’t this idea of a creator god is because if there’s some puppet master up there who’s taking charge of everything and causing this person to experience famine in Ethiopia and that person to experience being born on Park Avenue in New York City.

That seems so unfair to me. I’m sorry. It just goes against the grain of some sense of fairness. Now, if you say, Well, there’s some sense of self responsibility that the person who is born, unfortunately, yes, can have incredible compassion for that person born in famine starved Ethiopia, and then you have a person who is born through their own good actions in a family that has all these resources, you simply acknowledge this is the mechanism that brought them to that point. But we’ve all been at both of these points.

We’ve all been all over the place, and we’re all dealing with the same situation. Kind of understand the fundamental birth defect that we’re all dealing with, which is that we’re all born with ignorance. But all these things are manifestations of that same principle. Yeah, Rowena. This is sort of a little aside, there was a, if you go to the FPMT website, they keep putting up other sayings over and over again every time you open it up.

And there was one there yesterday that said, I think it was from Lama Yeshe said, the person who is starving in a in a famine stricken land and the person that’s having great bouts of indecision in the supermarket because they can’t choose what they wanna eat or really suffering from the same problem. It’s kind of a harsh way to look at it, but the fundamental problem is just, you know, not not not knowing what you want, not having it, not having things available that you want, or having so much you have no clue what you want. I mean, it’s still the same grasping mind that you’re dealing I think with an awareness of karma, we get that kind of universality and identification with the soup that we’re all in. We’re all dealing with the situation. The term for it in Tibetan Buddhism and all Buddhism is saṃsāra.

saṃsāra kind of refers to the cycle of existence, that we are kind of trapped in a state of, if we examine very deeply, pervasive dissatisfaction. Because even those things that we get that are nice in our lives, they’re very fleeting, very temporary, very transitory. And so if we are really critical of our lives, we find that there is this overriding feeling of dissatisfaction that we simply cannot get over. Well, the Buddha says you can get over it. You can experience a much more lasting form of satisfaction.

And that’s really, again, what this whole path is driving towards. It’s not to say, again, that these more temporal results need to be abandoned. There’s no point in kind of getting any sort of temporal happiness because it’s all transitory and it doesn’t last. Well, point is, though, that we do see that it has an effect on our minds when we are able to use something like this human rebirth in a very beneficial state. Being able to help others.

Being able to develop our own qualities. So not to throw those temporal results out the window, but to acknowledge them for what they are, which is, in the end, they are kind of unsatisfactory. I’m going to lose this human rebirth. Every one of us is going to lose this. We’re all going to die.

Hate to tell you. Okay. Where do we find this faith freedoms in You can find them in most Lamrim texts, stages of the path texts. Like Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand will have them. They’ll have them.

Yeah. For this first course, I just don’t like to go through too many lists. You’ve already had a lot of lists. And these also, again, make a little more sense in the context of module three when I go into kind of an overview of the path to enlightenment, the lamrim. But if you want to go and look for them, that’s fine.

But what I would encourage you to do is, for step one, just think about the good fortune that you have. Compare yourself to other states of existence, like animals, but also compare yourself to other human beings. You know, think of the good fortune that you have. I mean, we have amazing good fortune in this country. Even like the worst people in this country are living better than the best people in some countries.

And seriously, we really don’t I watch these things on TV about the kids that live in Brazil and on the Amazon River, and they try to hang on to these ships. They’re never going to come into contact with either that education, much less the karma. Yeah. They’re just so far out. I I was watching talk about even this country.

I watched a film last night, this Winter’s Bone I don’t know if anybody’s seen this about, like, rural Missouri down near the Ozarks. I mean, these people are like I wasn’t projecting. Qualities that they were demonstrating were just really very narrow minded and very hateful and fearful. It was really sad to watch. This is even in this country.

We have a lot of pockets of this country where you could have been born into. If the karma had been there, you could have gotten a human rebirth but been born in a part of the country where you wouldn’t have had access to much education, to many resources, to an environment that supports your personal growth and development. I I don’t know. It’s a little I think we don’t have to go very far to think about it. We don’t have to think about, oh, these beings that are in some realm that I don’t even know about, you know, that’s some god realm or what have you.

We just can simply rest in our own comparison of other humans and the beings that we do know of, the animals in this world. When it comes to step two, if you want to do this, I’m going to skip step three. You don’t need to meditate on step three unless you want to and you’re sort of aware of that. I may touch on it briefly in regard to that step 3A, but step two is where we kind of acknowledge that this life has great value. This is one of the main points of this meditation is that we really kind of get this idea that, Wow, I need to use every moment of this life well.

Well, you see that through three steps. First, seeing the temporal value, which means that if you do things well in this life, according to this law of karma, you will create some very strong causes that at the end of this life will help you to have another rebirth like this or be even better than this. A human existence where you come into contact at a much younger age with the Dharma than many of us have. And many of us in the room didn’t find the Dharma until much later in our adult years. How wonderful.

Feel like you had Buddhist parents that taught you the Dharma, that you get this continuity of these teachings, what have you. Step two, B, the ultimate value. Meaning that with this life, according to these teachings, you can actually even attain enlightenment or liberation. You can actually achieve incredible results, freeing you from this cycle of existence and putting you in a state where you can help others to do that. But that all comes down to step 2C there, where you see the moment by moment value, this momentary value, that actually the preciousness of every single moment that we have.

The whole purpose of this meditation is to make you feel great joy and the sense of opportunity that comes with acknowledging what you have so that we don’t waste our lives. As we’re going to see when we get to the death and rebirth module, one of the main things we need to take away from that is the uncertainty of the time of our death. We all like to think we’re going to live to a nice, ripe, old age. And many of us will. But there’s no guarantee.

Any one of us could die today. This is the reality, is that we don’t know. So we need to use this life well. We need to be inspired to use this life well. And if we think that it’s got great value, that we have just arrived at the most amazing opportunity, well then that will lead us to taking advantage of this life in a way that all these other results will come.

We will get a good rebirth. We will attain enlightenment eventually. We will reach our full potential. So this last one, the only thing I’ll touch on in regard to step three is this first part, where we look at kind of the Buddha says that there are basically some primary causes that lead you to getting this rebirth. And the main one being the practice of morality.

As I said, morality here, again, isn’t the Buddha coming down from on high and saying, Do this, don’t do that. The Buddha’s simply saying, There are certain wholesome actions that we did with our body, speech, mind that led to this result. That’s what we mean by morality. You practiced well in the past. You did good things in the past.

You helped others, were kind, were compassionate. You avoided killing. You avoided some of these non virtuous actions. How wonderful. And this is one of the main causes for getting a human rebirth in the future.

So the other things that are on there are also important in terms of our generosity. As I said, the more generous we are with our resources, the more resources we have. Nice to have resources. No denying that it’s a lot easier when we don’t have to worry about where we’re going get our next meal at every moment of the day. We can be more focused on developing our minds in such situations.

And also pure prayers. From our side, prayer here, we haven’t talked a lot about prayer. We will talk about it in module two, but prayer is simply you’re making strong intention. Going back to this mental factor, driving your mind towards, This is what I want. I want to get good results in my life.

Again, not because I see them as a final solution, but that I see them as a means to get to those final solutions. The solution of liberation and enlightenment. These other ones, again, 3B and 3C that are on the other side, these are the more traditional ones. And we’ll reintroduce this meditation in module three with some of those other teachings. But the real driving force behind this meditation is to just bring some awareness that if you can accept this as just a theory, you know, that I’m here in this human life because of karma, because I created the causes to do this, to have this, well then, you know, generate incredible sense of good fortune at what you have done and what you have with you right now, and to use this life well to accomplish something meaningful.

And the most meaning that we can get is to, in Buddha’s eyes, is to move away from those tendencies that have led us to more suffering and move towards what will lead us to more lasting peace and happiness. It’s all very practical, and it should have an influence on your day to day life. You should find that you have more peace of mind, that you feel better about yourself and the world that you live in and the way that you are in that world. Right. Any questions on that?

I know I introduced that in a rather rapid way, but Okay. So if you can work with that meditation over the next week, that would be terrific. Tom, who some of you recall from some of the earlier classes, is going to be here next Sunday, I believe, to lead the meditation. I’ve been leading them so far in this module, but he’s going to be taking over that. And then Vasanta, who you probably haven’t met, but Vasanta was leading meditation.

She goes to the Southwest Acupuncture College and has been very busy. And so I’ve been filling in for her. But she’ll be here eventually to lead some meditations before class. But if you can come next Sunday at nine I think the people that have been coming have been finding it helpful, I hope, to get together and meditate together, and we’ll do this meditation on a perfect human rebirth. Next week is change our clocks.

Oh, yeah, yeah, that’s a good thing to yeah, turn your clock back, fall back. Otherwise what will happen, you’ll show up here and you’ll be an hour early. We won’t be here probably. Someone may be here. I better remind Tom so Tom doesn’t show up an hour early.

He’s traveling this week. All right. Let’s just do a short meditation to kind of seal all this and to dedicate for the people that are on this list. I meant to mention this list earlier. If this list came by you and you weren’t sure about what to do with it, or even if you’ve thought of some other names since this list went around, you’ll have an opportunity to add those names.

But first let’s just start with kind of sealing this positive energy that we’ve created. They call this sort of dedicating, and we’ll talk about this more in the next module. But the idea is that we’ve created a lot of positive seeds in our own mind. We’ve had some wholesome thoughts. We’ve been trying to steer our minds in the direction of the Buddhist teachings so that we can achieve the results of our own potential being fully actualized so that we can then benefit others to the extent that we really desire, so that we can be a source, again, of love and light and compassion and wisdom in their lives as well.

So now we kind of seal this energy. We think that most definitely it will cause that result to arise in our lives and in the lives of others. And then while we’re thinking of others, we can steer some of this energy that we’ve created in their direction. First of all, thinking about those beings who are experiencing obstacles in their life. So whether they’re experiencing obstacles mentally, physically, what have you, through the force of what we’ve done here today, may this become the cause for the removal of these obstacles for these beings, driven by our own compassionate connection with each of these beings.

So we’ll recite the list of names, and again, you can add any names at the end of people or organizations that you’ve thought of who require this assistance with removing obstacles. Obstacles, Cynthia, Bruce, Catherine, Sam, Harper, John, Linda, Kenny, David, Felicia, Amy, Mary, Bernice, Anne, Marge, Charlene, Phil, David R, Doctor. S, Janice, Connie, Steven, Deb V, Linda, Jack, David S, Claudio, Felix, Vivian, Catherine, karma, John, McGraths, Laura, Veronica, Stephanie, Jovi, Chris, Melanie, Christopher, Alexia, Matthew, Elena, Steven, Rāja, Eric, Susana, Martin, Vaco, Libby, Rowena, Ivy, Rohanah, Soren. And the next group that we want to share this energy with are those who have illness. And so, again, think very strongly that by sending this energy out to them, this removes all their illness, and they’re placed in a state of good health.

Patrick, Harper, Cricket, Bernice, Anne, Marge, Israel, Tito, Brendan, Lenore, Toomer, Sammy, Norell, Darren, Judith Baldwin, Asun, Mike, Amy, Mackenzie, Jenny, Sarah, Moriah, Rocky, I’m not sure, Sheila or something. Sheila. Reg, and Kevin. Scott, Sunny, Leanne, June, Billy, Virginia, Mary, Margaret. Then the last group that we want to share this energy with are those beings who are dying or who have died recently.

So here, along the lines of what we’ve talked about today, we want this energy to create the most conducive conditions for them in the future. May they, too, find a perfect human rebirth. May they have all the opportunity to work with their minds, to develop their qualities, and remove all their negative tendencies. Carol Shannon, Two Crows, Indonesians, victims of war and natural disasters. And then finally, we can kind of close this session today by making strong prayers for all the people in the world that are practicing these teachings in particular, but also any spiritual path where they are trying to be of benefit to others.

You can think particularly about the great teachers in this tradition, His Holiness, Dalai Lama, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, the head of our organization, and make strong prayers that these beings may continue to experience good health, have long lives, continue to be a guiding influence in this world, to lead this world to a state of true peace and satisfaction for every single sentient being. Okay, thank you all very much. Appreciate everyone being here. So again, next class is the final sort of formal class. But then we’ll have an opportunity on the following Sunday to review all of this and do some meditation together.

And that will start at nine on the fourteenth. The other thing to keep in mind is that on the twenty eighth, this is also on your calendar, is a special session that we’re doing. It’s Thanksgiving weekend, so some people may be out of town and what have you. But if you are in town and want to come for, I’ll be here to host a sort of video presentation and discussion. These Mind Life Institute conferences that His Holiness, Dalai Lama, has participated in.

I’ve got a DVD set of one of them called Investigating the Mind, all about Buddhism and the behavioral sciences and kind of how the mind works. And I haven’t watched all of it, but I’ve watched parts of it, I have some idea of what I’m going to be sharing. But I think it’ll be really interesting to hear these sorts of different points of view and partake of those teachings and discussions. So if you can join us for that, that’ll be from ten to twelve thirty on November twenty eight. And that will be preceded by a meditation as well.

I’ll probably be here to lead that. Thank you. Have a good week.

Key terms in this teaching

eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
perfect human rebirth
The rare human state, qualified by eight freedoms and ten richnesses, which provide the ideal conditions for practicing Dharma and attaining enlightenment. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is merely feeling a desire harmless, so that karma is only created once you act on it?

No. Once an intention is moving in a particular direction, some form of karma is already being created. Action means any movement of the mind in a direction, and it begins with intention, which is often flavored by delusion. Intention works spontaneously, like iron filings drawn to a magnet. We are already in the driver's seat but have been driving badly, under deluded states of mind. The upside is that with more control over intention, we have the mechanism for producing the good results we want, since wholesome intention creates positive karma. Suffering and happiness arise from their respective causes, like tomatoes from tomato seeds.

Scroll to Top