DB Mind and its Potential 2010 – 2010 10 10 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 10

2 h 19 min · 21,359 words · 10 October 2010

DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 - 2010 10 10 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 10
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk opens with meditation posture and a breath-focus practice, then teaches that mind’s nature is clear and luminous and its function is knowing. It explains that unhealthy attitudes like hatred superimpose exaggerated faults on objects, while love and patience have valid foundations and can be cultivated, using the acorn and garden analogies. It also covers the beginningless continuity of consciousness and the relation between mind and body.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2010-10-10

Duration: 2h 20m

UUID: deaec651-5637-42d1-a1b3-db1d9080fae4

Words: 21,359

So those of you who are new to meditation, just a few key points on posture. The very next module that we go into will be on how to meditate. So you’ll get a lot more instruction then. And if you’re interested in learning more now, you can certainly come to the Buddhist Meditation one hundred one class that’s going on on Thursday. But basically, the most important point of our posture is having the back straight.

So if you’re sitting in a chair, often they say it’s better to move forward in the chair. Most chairs that we have, the back’s kind of at a slant, so you end up with this kind of disorientation of the back a bit. So if you’re sitting forward in the chair, then you can find this nice place where the back just rests in a comfortably upright posture. You don’t want to overly straighten the back, just find that place where you can rest where it feels like there’s no tension necessary to hold the back in that posture. If you have back problems and you need to lean back in the chair, that’s perfectly fine.

If you’re sitting on the floor, again just find a place where you can rest where the back is naturally upright. In terms of the legs on the floor, you just find a place where you can cross them comfortably. If you’re sitting in a chair, then ideally it’s good to plant the feet firmly on the ground in front of you or a pillow, whatever it is if you can’t reach the ground, but not to kind of tuck the legs underneath or cross them. We want the head in an upright posture and then tilted forward just slightly. This will allow your gaze to go downward, And ideally it’s good to bring the eyelids until there’s just a little bit of light coming in.

You know, with that little bit of light then it keeps the mind somewhat alert and awake. Yeah, there should be some seats back there. Good, no problem. So again, with the eyelids just slightly open, this is said to be ideal, but if you find it difficult to keep the eyelids open, if there’s a flutter in the eyelids or this is just simply too difficult, then you’re welcome to close the eyes. But just be mindful that we tend to get a little bit sleepier when the eyelids are closed.

So those are some of the main points of posture. Again, there’s many others that we’ll go through when we get to the meditation class. Just rest your hands naturally in your lap wherever they’re comfortable, and just bring a state of relaxation to the body. While we’re in this upright posture, we want everything to be free of tension. So you might begin at the top of the body and just feel this wave of relaxation going through the muscles in the face, releasing your neck and shoulders, releasing your chest, releasing the back, letting your tailbone kind of sink down into the chair or the cushion, and then releasing your abdomen as well.

And then releasing any tension in the arms or the legs. So we should now have this upright posture with a very relaxed and of quality to the body. We want the same with our mind. So what we’re going to do for the next few minutes is just to do a very simple breathing meditation that I introduced to you last week. So this is a meditation to help us to develop our mindfulness, our attention, focus.

You can bring your awareness to the tip of the nose and begin to pay attention to the sensation that you feel there as you inhale through the nostrils, as you exhale through the nostrils. It’s a very subtle sensation initially and it might be hard to find it, but it’s going to be slightly different on each of us. But somewhere just inside the nostrils you’ll feel this sensation of the air going in, the air going out. So once you begin to hone in on that, then the basic instruction is just to simply rest on that sensation. Moment after moment, paying attention to it, and not allowing the mind to get distracted.

But our minds will get distracted, and that’s the other instruction, is to have the awareness that notices when you’re caught up in something else, when your mind starts thinking about what you need to do later today, or perhaps thinking about things that happened last week, or perhaps we even get distracted by sounds or other sensations in the body. And when that happens, it’s important to just let go of that, to cease to give it any more energy or attention, and then gently, without any judgment, bring the mind back to the nose, to the sensation of the breath that you feel in the nostrils. So even if you have to do this many, many times over the next few minutes, it’s perfectly fine. We’re training the mind to have that awareness, to stay on that object. So I’ll ring the chime and we’ll do just a few minutes of this.

And then I’ll interrupt at some point to set our motivation for our time together today to kind of steer our minds in the most positive direction. So as you continue watching the breath, try to become aware of awareness itself, the subjective component, the mind that is observing the breath, that is the object. So try to feel the kind of spacious quality to this subjective mind. So in this course, we’re working with understanding the mind, understanding the potential that we have to change our minds. What the Buddha says is that we have been under the control of a lot of misunderstanding, misconceptions.

And consequently we’ve had a lot of disturbing attitudes in the mind, things that have kept us from finding true peace, true satisfaction. So in your heart now, just kind of generate a good motivation for being here. Thinking that you’re here to understand the nature of your own mind, to begin to become aware of the potential that you have, to develop all the positive qualities that are so essential to your own welfare and also of great benefit to others, and to also remove and diminish all of the negative tendencies that we have. Because these too affect others, not only harmful to ourselves, but also to those around us. So if possible, set this motivation to achieve your greatest potential, to fully awaken the mind, and in this way, to be able to benefit others truly, to have that peace and satisfaction that has eluded us for so long, and to help others to achieve it as well.

So again, those of you who are new to today’s class, to this series, maybe during the break, we’ll have a break in about an hour or so, if you’d come up and I’ll give you some information about the class and kind of introduce you to what we’re doing. But last week when we met, we started out with a little exercise where we looked at what happiness is to us and then, you know, how we go about finding happiness, you know, and whether or not we’ve actually found that happiness ourselves. This whole series of Discovering Buddhism, but in particular this very first module, is working with this whole idea of how do we really find happiness in our lives. The Buddha’s teachings tell us that we have to begin to reverse the process that we’ve had from the beginning, which is trying to get happiness through external causes, kind of looking at things outside of us to produce happiness in ourselves. You know, Lama Zopa, who’s a teacher in this tradition, calls this the if only mentality.

So we have this idea of, If only I had this, then I’d be happy. If only I had this person in my life, then I’d be happy. If only I had this job, then I’d be happy. And we live our lives kind of pursuing all of these things, changing everything in the external environment, thinking that it’s going to produce happiness in ourselves. And sometimes we might gain some temporal happiness from those changes.

But then we have another if only. Eventually that ceases to give us the satisfaction that we’re searching for, and we have to find something else. And so we live our lives this way, continually trying to fill the open spaces, the empty spaces, so that we manage to somehow convince ourselves that we’re happy. And Buddha says that this hasn’t worked and we should probably begin to look at other techniques. Those techniques are going inside, beginning to understand that happiness actually is derived from those feelings that we are able to produce in our own minds, That we can actually even have a life that from the outside might look miserable, but from the inside we can be quite content.

And His Holiness of Dalai Lama often speaks to this. Actually there’s a small passage here that I’d like to share with you in a book called Mind Science. And he says, We can see from our own experience that our state of mind plays a major role in our day to day experience and physical and mental well-being. If a person has a calm and stable mind, this influences his or her attitude and behavior in relation to others. In other words, if someone remains in a state of mind that is calm, tranquil, peaceful, external surroundings or conditions can cause them only limited disturbance.

But it is extremely difficult for someone whose mental state is restless to be calm or joyful even when they are surrounded by the best facilities and the best of friends. This indicates that our mental attitude is a critical factor in determining our experience of joy and happiness and thus also our good health. So the idea here is that we in the end have most control over what our minds are doing as opposed to what’s going on in the outside environment. So the whole sort of purpose of this module in particular is to begin to develop that focus that understands that if we work with our minds and develop healthy mental qualities, we will then be able to be in any situation, no matter how good or bad it might appear, and have peace of mind. So what I’d like to start with for today’s lesson is to go back.

We did also last week look at the video for this series, and those of you who didn’t get a chance to see that, these Discovering Buddhism videos are all available on YouTube. I also do have the DVD that we watched, and if anyone wants to borrow that for the week, they’re welcome to do that. I think the VHS is in the library, but I’m not sure Catherine, our librarian, says it’s hidden somewhere in a closet right now in a box. So all those materials haven’t been completely unpacked yet. Basically in that video there were a whole lot of things touched on, and I’d like to start with the very basic thing that we all need to get some agreement on, which is what is the definition of mind?

If this course is about mind and its potential, we have a lot of different ideas about what this is. And we’re going to talk a little bit today also about what modern science, Western science, thinks about what mind is, because this is obviously a point of some divergence between Buddhism and Western science. But in Buddhism, a lot of things are defined in terms of two things that we would look at. You know, one is the nature, and the other is the function. So sometimes, for example, and to give an idea of this, in Buddhism they might define fire as that which is hot, that’s its nature, it has heat, and burning.

You know, it gives, that is its function is to burn things, to consume the fuel of fire. So, in the same way, we have a nature of mind, and we have a function of mind. So, what is the nature of mind? Clear or luminous. What do we mean by clear or luminous nature?

It has a couple of implications. One is that we’re talking about something that isn’t material. So today, a little bit later, we are going to talk about this sort of division between mind and body, or mind and matter, and the interrelationship of those. But when we isolate what mind is, we find that it is clear and luminous, meaning that it has sort of a reflective quality to it, that the mind is in a state where it will reflect the things that it becomes aware of. And that relates then to its function, which is to know.

Knowing or awareness. So, this might sound like a simplistic definition, but there’s actually a lot of profundity to this. When we talk about mind being that which is clear and knowing, we’re talking about the entire subjective experience that are that’s with us every moment of the day. We’ve had this mind functioning in this way, allowing us to know things. But oftentimes we get totally absorbed in the objective world.

This is where in the meditation today. I encourage you to kind of take a moment, if you can, to begin to become aware of awareness itself, as opposed to the objects that we’re constantly paying attention to. In this course, we’re going to begin to understand a little bit more about the implications of this, and I’ll touch on this a little bit today, but we’ll get into this even more in future classes, particularly when we begin to talk about the potential of the mind because of this definition. Already I want to touch on it a little bit in terms of what His Holiness the Dalai Lama says in regard to the qualities that we can develop on the basis of having a mind that has this nature. So His Holiness the Dalai Lama, in a wonderful book that was I think one of the first books of his teachings to be published this is an anniversary edition that was done called Kindness, Clarity, and Insight there’s a wonderful little piece in here about the luminous nature of the mind.

And what His Holiness says in here is that we have to begin to understand that if this is the nature of mind, then the things that are passing through the mind, all of our thoughts, all of the different ideas that we have, are simply constructs of the mind. And we can have more control over them because particularly the unhealthy attitudes that we have are not in the nature of the mind. We’ll be talking about this again in a few classes from now when we kind of pick apart the content of the mind on a more technical basis. But what His Holiness says is that basically if we identified one of those negative tendencies that we have, for example, hatred, what His Holiness says is that if hatred is generated in our minds, that’s because we are going about a process of working with what we’re experiencing in a particular way. It’s not in the nature of the mind to see things in this way.

We can actually change our thoughts. So what he says is that hatred is generated. Why? Because we superimpose upon things, upon phenomena an unattractiveness or a badness or something undesirable about it that exceeds what is actually there. This is kind of an interesting idea.

This is something that we probably haven’t thought about before. If this is new to you, this idea of working with the mind, we generally think that we’re quite accurate in what we’re seeing. That when we hate something or have a strong aversion to something, it’s because there is something inherent in that that is at the same level that we’re assessing it. In Buddhist thinking, we are actually exaggerating, superimposing an undesirable quality on that object that far exceeds what is there. Now we would all agree that there’s probably some undesirable quality there in terms of our own experience, but the extent to which it is there is the problem.

And when we have a mind that’s got this strong hatred, we’ve elevated it to an extraordinary level that goes so far beyond what is actually there. His Holiness says then, with this as a basis, we get angry at what prevents our desires. We get angry at what kind of challenges us and gives us some difficulty in our lives. Hence, the foundation of a mind of hatred is not valid. So again, this is something I’d encourage you to think about.

You may not be able to spend a lot of time in meditation on it, but to begin to pick apart when we do have these feelings arising in our day. Are we being completely accurate in how we’re assessing the situation? Let’s take the example of someone that you don’t like, someone you find very challenging in your life, maybe someone you work with or someone in your personal life. When we are having that strong reaction of dislike, we are totally neglecting any of the positive qualities of that person. Now, does everyone who that person relates to see them in that way?

When they go home, does everyone hate them, dislike them? When they go to the places that they With their friends, do their friends dislike them the entire time that they’re hanging out with them? Probably not likely, or else they wouldn’t be their friends. So what’s happening is we are seeing something that we’re reacting to, which is an unfavorable quality, that causes us to have this strong feeling of aversion in our minds, and then we exaggerate what is there and make them into a hateful person, make them into someone who is inherently that way. So His Holiness is saying that this is really inaccurate, because we aren’t looking at the whole picture.

We aren’t seeing that person for all the qualities that they might have. So when we go back to this definition of mind, this means that basically we ourselves, in our thought processes, in the space of this sort of clear, pure, free nature of the mind, creating more turmoil in our minds. We are creating our own problems. So as Holiness says, when over a long period of time an attitude that has a valid foundation sort of combats this one that has an invalid, a not valid foundation, the one with the valid foundation will win out. So, for example, if we were in those moments when we are confronted with someone who we dislike, if we were able to begin to be in a space of loving kindness towards them, if we began to give some space to that relationship and weren’t affected so deeply by the things that they might say to us or the way that they are, and we begin to see them through eyes of love, that that actually will be something that we can develop within our minds that will overcome those feelings of hatred.

Now is that mind of love a valid foundation? What do you think? His Holiness says it is. What is a mind of love? A mind of love in Buddhism is defined very specifically as one that wishes for the happiness of another, the causes of happiness for that person.

So if you have that mind that at that time, when we’re confronted with somebody who pushes our buttons and we make a decision, a conscious decision, not to go to a place of hatred, and we decide that we are going to embrace them in love and think, you know, I really want this person to be happy, Is there anything that’s invalid about that? What do you think? Can you find something wrong with that state of mind? Is that mind inaccurate? If we really analyze how that person is being, we often find that some of the things that they’re doing that actually might even annoy us are simply driven by their desire for happiness, right?

Now we might not agree with how they’re going about trying to become happy by putting us down or doing things that we dislike, but what is driving them? And this goes back to what we talked about last week in terms of us being driven by a fundamental need for happiness. And the Buddha says there’s nothing wrong with that. Mean, we can’t criticize that at any level because all beings are driven by that. Wanting happiness, not wanting to suffer.

What’s going on for most of us is that we are simply choosing the wrong states of mind to go about achieving that happiness. So if we have that genuine thought towards somebody who is belligerent towards us in this moment, and we’re making a conscious decision to wish for them to have happiness, to wish for them to have the causes of well-being, there’s nothing invalid about that mind. And if we really understand the true causes of happiness and we’re wishing for those for them, well then there’s It’s completely embracing the very nature of their minds, the nature of their being, how we actually go about achieving happiness. So what do you think of this concept before I go further in what His Holiness says? Says?

Challenging to do. Challenging to do, yeah, yeah. And why do you think it’s challenging? Because we’re ingrained with visual thought patterns. Okay, good.

When did we attract people with the same qualities that we have aversions to? This is something we’re going to talk about in one of the classes in this module as well, is kind of the force of karma, which is what’s behind that, is that oftentimes, because we have created the causes to have that aversion, this is exactly what we get in our lives. So but I think you’re hitting the nail on the head, Katherine, when you say, you know, the problem is, is that we become very habituated towards these states of mind. You know, the reality is most of us live our day to day lives feeling that we’re completely justified in having these responses things that go on in the world that we don’t like. Now, we have to be careful.

I mean, there are things in the world that we do need to correct, and that we do need to have a conscious, compassionate response to. And I’m not saying that we then, you know, just sit back and become a piece of wood and don’t do anything, you know, while the world around us suffers, but rather that we begin to isolate what portion of our minds is delusion. And delusion here is kind of an interesting concept, because what His Holiness is saying is when these attitudes are not valid, then they are deluded. They are looking at things through a very distorted perspective. They are seeing things in terms of a judgment that is being made from our minds that isn’t encompassing the whole picture, that isn’t looking at that being through eyes that will be much more beneficial to the entire situation.

Because what we often find is when we pursue those attitudes that we’re habituated towards, particularly anger, it only leads to more complication, more problems, more difficulty. And this is why so much of what we do in the world in terms of war and trying to, you know, compete with others and all this attitude of, you know, wanting things for ourselves often simply causes more strife, simply causes more difficulty in the world, because we’re not using a response that is actually in line with achieving the result that we want. So all that His Holiness and all that the Buddha is saying in this type of approach is to begin to use our intellect to sort of sort out, well, what’s going on? What is the content of our minds? And is it just?

Is it valid? Is it something that is truly rooted in our experience? Or is it something that needs to be reassessed? And is there a healthier attitude, a more beneficial attitude that will actually lead to the results that we want? So the one thing that His Holiness goes on then to talk about to a large extent is the idea that these sorts of healthy, positive attitudes, such as loving kindness, such as compassion, such as patience, wisdom, and so on.

All of these can be developed to an unbelievable degree, a limitless degree. What he says in Kindness, Clarity, and Insight, he says, Therefore if you familiarize steadily over a long period of time with positive attitudes, good attitudes that have a valid foundation, bad attitudes that do not will gradually diminish. Now, this is the thing, as Catherine said, we’re habituated. We have actually trained our minds to be angry, to be impatient, to be unkind. We need to do the exact opposite training.

And just as we have trained our minds to be that way, we can train our minds to be a different way. Why? Because our minds are in this nature. Our minds are sort of a bed of soil that’s just waiting to be planted with whatever we put in it. So I often use this analogy of a bed of soil.

There’s another analogy that Venerable Robina used in the video that I’ll touch on a little later. But I like this analogy because, you know, we often see what happens to an untended bed of soil, right? You have this wonderful bed of soil that maybe has been there and we’ve used it for gardens before. But if we leave it alone, what happens? It gets run over by weeds, right?

It’s unlikely that flowers are going to spring up in a place that we haven’t tended to, right? This just doesn’t happen. Our gardens need tending to. Because we have that habituation to having unhealthy states of mind, the weeds that these are grow up quite naturally in the bed of soil in our minds. So this is the reality of our current situation, but this doesn’t mean that the bed of soil inherently gives rise to weeds.

It’s simply the fact that we haven’t been able to be a good gardener. We haven’t really paid attention to this bed of soil that is our minds. So if we were to tend to our minds and begin to remove the weeds, at least, you know, stop them from overrunning the garden, and begin to be more aware of the flowers, the beautiful things that we want to grow in our garden, well then what will happen? We’ll all of a sudden experience a completely different garden, a different appearance to our minds. Yeah, Steve.

So are you saying that the mind is naturally inclined to wildness? Because we’ve habituated it to that. That’s why the analogy, again, doesn’t work perfectly in all regards. But right now, with our minds currently in the state that they’re in, it actually is quite accurate. What happens to most of us is do we find ourselves throughout the day maybe some of us do Maybe we’ve tended to our gardens in the past, and we do have these more positive attitudes springing up.

We live our lives thinking about compassion for others, acting kindly towards them. But the reality is, is that for most of us, this isn’t something that we’re used to. Yeah, I don’t know if the heat is working or not. It feels colder in here. Does it feel warmer?

Oh, okay. It feels cold up here. Uh-huh. It’s just recirculating. Okay.

Getting used to the new functioning in the center here, so. So what when we use this analogy, we can say that definitely where we’re at right now, the weeds will most naturally spring up. Why? Because that’s all that we’ve been growing in our minds. Occasionally, we tend to flower here and there.

But the reality is, is that most of our energy has been spent kind of putting these negative states of mind, just creating an environment in which they grow up quite naturally. But what I mean, if we go back to Steve’s question, I mean, if we really say, Well, what is a bed of soil ideally there for? A bed of soil ideally is there to produce something that is beautiful, that gives rise to something pleasant. You know, and so when we tend to the mind in that way, and when we actually pay attention to what we are cultivating, then we find that actually these flowers and all the positive qualities that we’re growing are quite resonant with the nature of the mind. As His Holiness says, they do have a valid foundation.

They kind of are resting in what the mind is ideally meant to do. This goes back to the other analogy that was used. I’m going to switch analogies for just a moment To what Venerable Robina said in her video, in her teaching last week when we looked at this. Does anyone recall the analogy that she used for the mine? The acorn.

Good, Leah. Yeah. So we could take an acorn comes off of a humongous oak tree, right? And we could do lots of things with that acorn. Maybe some people have art projects they could do, and maybe little kids might paint the acorn with a little face, or you might store them all in a bowl as like a showpiece on your coffee table.

But is that what an acorn is designed for? Is that the potential of an acorn? You know, the potential of an acorn is to be planted in the ground and to give rise to a mighty oak. So we have to begin to recognize that this is the potential of our minds. When we talk about that which is clear and knowing, it means that we have the potential to grow all of these qualities to a limitless degree, that we have the ability to actually transform our minds completely into what we call the state of a Buddha.

So let me speak to what His Holiness says about this whole idea of kind of why this is capable of the mind to be able to be developed in this way. He says if you’re training physically in broad jumping, for example, the basis of the process is the gross physical body, right? And even though we do find that in athletics they are continually pushing the range of how far the body can jump and run and all of these things, so there’s constantly little nudges made in terms of where that limit is. But there is a limit to how much we can jump. There is a limit to how fast you can run.

Why? Because the basis is the physical body. However, since the mind is an entity of mere luminosity and knowing, when the basis of training is the mind, it is possible through gradual familiarization to develop salutary attitudes limitlessly. Do our minds have a limit? Right now, we might think they do, feel kind of contained in some sort of narrow range.

But what all of the Buddhist teachings are about is helping us to develop limitlessly the potential that we have in our minds. Just as that acorn can become a mighty oak, so our minds can become completely unbounded, can have an unbelievable quality of spaciousness and connectedness to all beings combined with vast wisdom, compassion, all these qualities that we’re trying to develop, we can have these limitlessly. So this is what this whole course is really about, and it comes down to what is, again, a very simple definition, but this is the basis for all of the Buddha’s teachings. You know, in the Dhammapada, which are the sayings of the Buddha, one of the very first teachings that are in there and that Lama Zopa Rinpoche and the retreat that I just got back from that happened in North Carolina, he taught on this one evening. There’s a very basic premise that says everything comes from the mind.

And we’re going to talk about the ramifications of that throughout this class, but we already see that with this understanding, we begin to gain some appreciation for what that statement says. That, in fact, what we are able to enjoy in our lives, how we are able to live our lives, what sort of peace and contentment we have, as well as the flip side, what sort of disturbing states of mind we have, what friction we have with other people, what discontent we have with the things around us. All come from the mind. And in the end, the mind plays a very key role in even producing these situations, as we were starting to talk about with Katherine in terms of, you know, the role of karma in that. Yeah, Rita.

Well, I’m trying to wrap my head around the focus. Okay. So if someone mistreats you view that as that person has a desire for happiness just like I do then? And not label it as mistreatment? So again, I think we have to be kind of wise in how we approach it, too, and understand that there’s nothing wrong with sort of labeling it as, This is a person mistreating me through verbal or physical actions.

But we have a choice as to how we’re going to react to that. Now, again, I want to separate this from these bigger issues, like if we see that there’s injustice in the world, or we see an example where, for example, someone’s being physically abused in a relationship and what have you. Those, I think, require a stronger force of attention with compassion for the perpetrator and the victim in those scenarios. But if we’re just talking about someone who, again, pushes our buttons, we work with them and they say things to us and they treat us in a way. Now, it doesn’t mean, again, that we don’t find a constructive way of working with that, but we can choose in that moment to see them in a different light.

We can choose in that moment to even develop qualities from that experience that we might otherwise be blind to. For example, if we lash out with verbal abuse towards that person who’s verbally abusing us, then we’re making a decision at that point to follow that angry mind. And as I said, oftentimes that leads to simply more of the same and perhaps even escalates the situation to a point where verbal becomes physical and who knows what else follows. If at that moment we decide that we’re going to actually use this opportunity of somebody saying negative things to us as an opportunity to develop patience, well then what a rich field that is to be able to do that. I mean, again, I’m not talking about becoming a doormat, though.

You actually become much stronger through being the patient one in the situation. Another thing that we’re going to be touching on throughout this course is how actually following these negative states of mind is very weak, is actually giving in to unhealthy things that only produce more pain and difficulty for ourselves and others. What does that sound like to hear that? I’m sorry? Challenging.

Challenging. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Let me see if was one other comment, I think. Was it Felicia or Mark?

Mark. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We don’t have to be overrun with weeds. This is a good way to put it. And the choices that we make will hopefully influence others around us at some point, too, eventually.

And this is kind of, again, getting to the potential of the mind, is if we become a person who lives their lives in this compassionate, loving, kind, wise space, then we may begin to have an effect on others around us, and we may be able to teach them how to tend to their gardens better. Possibly. Maybe there’s a few people that we might influence in that way. And again, these are concepts we’ll be touching on in this course as well. It’s kind of how we begin to use this not just to tend to ourselves, but to help others.

Yeah, Judith, you were going to say? In all of the it just came to me that in so many of the teachings on the mind, I never hear about safety. And to me, safety’s an issue that I think I’ve had to address as a Westerner to be able to move from an angry, judgmental, categorizing holistic mind. And so I’d love to hear your thoughts on that. Because I think that we’re taught what safety is, and it’s this is a different paradigm of course.

Right, right. Yeah, I mean, think just to give some brief thoughts on it, because this is something, again, I think we can bring up in later parts of this course as well when we do speak about karma. For one thing, I mean, safety is a pretty elusive concept when it comes down to it, because how are we actually safe in a particular situation or in our lives? And, again, I think the Buddha is telling us that safety is something that resides within us. For example, if we look at somebody who has a lot of material possessions, they may actually although you might think that by having all these things in their lives, they might feel more safety, more security, more sense of, I’m a bit immune from the suffering of the world because I have all these things, Oftentimes, they’re driven to have even more insecurity because they fear losing all of these things.

So security or safety kind of gets to be a very elusive concept in terms of where do we really find it. And I would suggest that, again, the Buddha is telling us that we’re only going to feel as safe in any particular situation as we feel within our own minds, within our own perspective as to how we are in that situation. This is why I think, again, we could be developing these qualities to a point where no matter what situation we’re in, we’re going to feel quite safe and secure. What were your thoughts on this issue of safety? I just feel like that, at least how I was taught and all my friends were taught when we were young in this particular life, is that you’re armor yourself with toughness, with you equip yourself with whatever you need to do to be safe rather than to extend life to other people.

Loving the family, but that’s it. And I do think that Western some of us have to address that issue of how do I define safety in order to embrace the teachings. Right, right. Because you’re right. I think Yeah.

No, I think it is a challenge. But my own experience is that when I live my day in a space of kind of openness and feeling comfortable with the world around me and the people that I encounter, that I often That’s often what I receive then, too. And this goes back to, again, where I wanted to bring this up in the context of karma. When we get to that class where we do speak about the role of mind in creating karma and karma in our experience, that in effect, what we do is I’m not saying that, you know, you wake up in the day and you decide, Okay, I’m gonna be loving and kind and compassionate to everyone I meet today, and that you’re necessarily gonna get a positive response from everybody you interact with. I’m not saying that that’s the proof of whether this works or not, because the reality is is we The whole point of all this discussion is to say, in the end, we only have control over what we have from this side, which is our own minds.

I don’t have control over what Rita’s going to say to me. I don’t have control over what John’s gonna say to me. I don’t have control over these things. But I do have control over how I am going to choose to be in the world and to react to whatever others do. Yeah, John.

One of the things that I try to practice when I run into someone who’s annoying to me, I accept them for what they are. And try to think positively about the situation. But if the annoyance continues, I excuse myself and walk away. Yeah, yeah. I said, you know, this is there’s nothing wrong with that response, certainly.

I think it’s a good way to treat it, is to initially try to work with it and say, Can I be with this in a very spacious way and not be judgmental, not go to the same place that they’re going to, and confront them in that way? And then when we find that it becomes too much, then we distance ourselves. I was mentioning being a piece of wood. I mean, is some of the advice given by Master Śāntideva, a great Buddhist master, Indian Buddhist master of the eighth century, in his seminal work, The Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, he says, just be a piece of wood. I mean, just be kind of removed from it.

And of course, there can be distancing as well. We can simply remove ourselves from the situation. We don’t have to react to everything that we see. I think some people feel like if they don’t confront it, then they haven’t lived up to their part of the deal, and part of the deal is to simply control your own mind, control your mind in whatever way is beneficial. And initially, sometimes the best response that we can have is to create that distance.

Why? Because that’s our first line of defense. If we can’t be there in that spacious, kind, compassionate way for that long, then we know what’s going to happen. We’re going to go to the mind that is not so healthy, not so beneficial. So excuse yourself.

Remove from the situation. Yeah, Claudio. I was going make a comment about that, about being skillful and being aware of what we can and can’t do. I know. There is tremendous strength and power and compassion, but having wisdom to know what level of compassion can one generate, and is this the right situation to I think that’s an important skill that I’m hoping people will begin to be engaging in through this course as well.

Just kind of have that introspection that is aware of where we can and can’t make constructive decisions. Again, doing these these other responses are completely valid. You know, just remove yourself from the situation. Disconnect if it’s at a point where you feel that you’re going to go to an unhealthy place. But this is important, is to really be kind to ourselves throughout this process.

The Buddha’s not saying that we have a switch in our minds that we can just flip, and all of a sudden we go from being nasty, irritable, angry people to wonderful, kind, compassionate, loving people. It’s just not going to happen that way. Why? Because we have spent, as we’re going to see today in the later teaching when we look at the continuity of mind, we have spent an unbelievable amount of time cultivating these unhealthy attitudes. We have been a horrible gardener, to put it mildly.

We just have not taken responsibility for what we’ve been doing. This is one of the tricks of it, that we have felt totally justified in it. In part because this is how the world around us is. That’s why so many of these amazing teachers, like His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, are so compelling to us. But we have this tendency, as was brought up in the video last week, we have this tendency to think that we can’t possibly be like this.

We can’t be like His Holiness the Dalai Lama. We can’t be like Mother Teresa. We can’t be like all these selfless individuals who work so hard for the welfare of others and are so at peace with themselves. This is why we can, because in the end, the nature of our mind, every single being’s mind, is exactly the same. Now, our individual capacity to work with our minds is what needs to be developed.

And we might find that right now we don’t have many skills as a good gardener, but we have skills that we can learn. And that’s what all of Discovering Buddhism is about, is learning those teachings, those skills, those abilities that will help you to be able to work with your mind better. Other questions or comments? Yeah, Mark. Yeah.

Well, think this goes back to what His Holiness is saying in terms of these sort of destructive emotions or delusions are all invalid. In terms of when we pick them apart, we actually find that they’re not based in reality. But if we look at the positive qualities, they are concordant and complementary to the nature of the mind. Why? Because they are valid.

So in the end, we would say that when we talk about kind of what is our fundamental nature in terms of, yes, the mind is clear and knowing, so it doesn’t kind of inherently have any of these qualities. But what resonates with the nature of the mind most are the positive qualities. Why? Because they are valid. Because when I have love for a being, a genuine thought for their happiness and well-being, that’s completely concordant with reality.

Now, of course, again, as I said earlier, the means for them obtaining it like, can have a wish for Osama bin Laden to be happy, but it doesn’t mean I want Osama bin Laden to derive happiness from the misfortune of others. They’re very different things. My wish for him to be truly at peace and happy is very different from the means that he might choose right now to become happy. So this is where we have to acknowledge that this level of working with things is totally valid. There’s nothing that goes against the grain in terms of what that genuine wish for that being is about.

Because in the end, I know that what is driving Osama bin Laden is the same thing that’s driving me: a quest for happiness, a wish to not suffer. Misguided in his approach as he is, he still is the same as me in that regard. So this is where if we do talk about kind of, well, what is the, in the end, the fundamental thing that’s going on at that basis, it is to complement everything that is valid and true, to actually be in accord with reality as opposed to in discord with it. Does it make sense then? Yeah, okay.

Good. Other questions or comments? Yes? Right. It’s a good question, Shari.

I think that, again, when we deal with the subject of the continuity of mind in the second part of the class, we will touch on this. But the basic Buddhist premise is that, as you said, mind is beginningless, meaning that what we have now as our mind didn’t start at conception or birth, even, some people, or sometime in the womb. It’s not like all of a sudden we got this kind of thing that’s called consciousness, and then that was this clean slate that we could make decisions about, or even that the people around us made decisions about, and influenced us and created that from the ground up. That in reality, what we have inherited is everything that we’ve done prior to this through the mind that has that continuity. Maybe I could go ahead and move into that discussion right now and go ahead and introduce that topic, because, again, we have quite a bit to cover in the second half of class anyway.

But in the Buddhist thinking, if we talk about the world of phenomena, and we particularly talk about what we call phenomena that are caused or conditioned. So there are physical things, of course, like this Gerbera flower came from its respective causes and conditions, right? It didn’t just magically appear here. There was someone who planted a seed that gave rise to the stem and eventually the flower bloomed. And we have this here now it’s a product of all of its various causes and conditions.

The Buddha says that there are three categories of phenomena that arise in this way from their causes and conditions, and one is form or matter. So in the Descartesian model, there’s basically a duality of kind of mind and matter, and mind is also a phenomenon that Buddhism embraces. So we can talk about matter, form, all the physical stuff that we experience, and we can talk about mind. But it’s not a Cartesian kind of approach to it in some regard, because in the end we find that there’s interrelationship between these two things. And there’s even a third category of phenomena in Buddhism, which we would call kind of abstract concepts or another term for them is non associated compounded phenomena or conditioned phenomena.

What this means is if we talk about something like time, for example, is time material? Is it matter? Is time mind? Consciousness? That which is clear and knowing?

No, but time exists, right? Because we can talk about past, present, and future. And time is constantly changing. So time is a conditioned phenomenon, but it’s neither of those two categories. So if we start talking about these three different categories, what we do see in essence, though, is that all of these arise from their own respective causes and conditions.

Whether we talk about matter, whether we talk about mind, consciousness By the way, I’m going to use these terms interchangeably. Mind and consciousness, or awareness. These are all three referring to kind of the same thing. Although you do find in Tibetan Buddhism that they have different terms for these. That’s just to, again, look at things from a slightly different angle, but we’re going to use them interchangeably.

So we have matter, physical things, we have mind, and we have these non associated compounded phenomena. All of these we find in the Buddhist teachings arising from what we call their respective causes and conditions. So if I plant a seed for a Gerbera, and I take the seeds out of this and I plant them in the ground and I tend to them in the way that is appropriate for producing that flower, and a rose comes up, we’d be shocked, right? Okay. Why?

Because what is the substantial cause Somebody used this term frequently in this discussion. Substantial cause for a gerbera is the seed of a gerbera, right? What is the substantial cause for the wood that was made into this dowel that’s on the end of this chime ringer? It would be the wood from a tree that had its own substantial causes in terms of the tree rising from the seed or acorn or what have you that gave rise to that tree. We see that in the physical world, all these phenomena have conditions that help them to come into existence, but they have what’s called a substantial cause.

Something that we can pick apart and say, Well, really what it comes down to is you get a Gerbera because there’s a Gerbera seed. You get a wooden dowel because there is the wood of the tree and so on. Main cause that kind of is the thread going through all of it. I’m not saying phenomena don’t kind of combine and arise and change. That’s the whole thing is that they do that.

But we can always still kind of point to something and say, In essence, this is coming about because there’s something that is very similar to it. In general, we can say this. I know it gets a little complicated if you start picking things apart. Like if you one of the big examples is like water. Water is two molecules of hydrogen, right, and one molecule of oxygen.

So does water have a substantial cause in those two gases? Again, a Buddhist perspective would be that there is inherently or not inherently, but kind of innately within there all of the elements, And the elements just simply haven’t come to the forefront. And when you combine those two and those one, the liquidity of the water arises from that. So you do see that even in those situations, you still have something you can point to that you can kind of say, Well, this is why it’s arising into this phenomenon. Is everybody with me on this so far in terms of kind of this idea of a substantial cause?

So we looked at mostly matter, that first category. Well, what is the cause, the substantial cause, of mind? What the Buddha says is that we can only identify one other thing that can be the substantial cause of mind, and that is another moment of mind. So if we talk about this moment right here, we can see that that moment was preceded by another mental moment, by another mental moment, another mental moment, another mental moment. We can look at our lives, and actually the meditation that I’m going to encourage you to work with over the next week is on this continuity of consciousness.

Kind of going back and looking at particular moments. We can think about the moment when you got up today. Like the first conscious moment of hearing your alarm or waking up and starting to deal with things. You can think about the moment before you went to bed last night. Well, were there mental moments between those?

Maybe at a very subtle level. I mean, we might have been dreaming, and that’s again a subtler level of consciousness. But the Buddha would say there’s no way that you could have this moment in the morning and the moment in the evening unless there was a continuity of moments that continually are giving rise to mental moments until you have a waking moment. But that there is this constant stream of consciousness. Go back further.

Go back a year ago. What were you doing a year ago? Not necessarily October tenth, two thousand and nine, but this time of year. We can recall, we can digress back and go further and further. Some of us can’t go back that far.

We might find that at ages three or four, we start losing some sort of memory of our existence and our mind. People go back all the way to birth and have some recollection of birth. Pretty rare, but some people do. But whatever your first moment is of this life, was that your first moment of consciousness, the one that you remember? No.

No? How do you know? Okay. Good. Yeah, basically, think we come to rely on memory an awful lot to validate our experiences, but I don’t think memory is the sole validator.

And actually, if we go back and we ask our parents, Well, what was I like when I came out of the womb? They could probably tell you, There must be some consciousness going on there because we were screaming and wanting this and wanting that. We did a lot of things that showed that there’s a conscious being there. Yes, and if you’re a twin, they’re often quite different. Yeah, yeah.

So again, you have this kind of individual stream that is yours that goes back at least to birth, right? We can say that at birth it became more evident to others. But what about in the womb? Again, a lot of debate on this in Western science. We’ll talk about that a little bit later in terms of mind body connection.

But we can basically say that if there was consciousness coming out of the womb, there must be consciousness in the womb, because the substantial cause for consciousness has to be there. Let’s go all the way back to conception. Again, don’t think anyone remembers conception. Your parents were engaged in an act that allowed your body to begin to form. The one cell, a sperm cell of your father with an egg cell of your mother, came together.

This fertilized egg grew into your body. But where was your consciousness at that time? Now what Buddha would say is that basically your consciousness linked up with that fertilized egg at the moment of conception. That there was a force of attraction, primarily through karma, that caused you to link up with that particular body, with those particular parents, and develop into this particular being that you are now. But that consciousness has its own continuity.

It did not come from the sperm. It did not come from the egg. It didn’t come from your mother. It didn’t come from your father. It has its own entity.

So what would be some of the consequences if you got it from your mother or your father? Say your consciousness came from your mother. Somehow her consciousness, a bit of it broke off and kind of combined with the egg and ended up being a part of you. We’d kind of have the same consciousness or awareness of your mother then, wouldn’t you? You’d be just like your mother.

Oh, my goodness. No reflection on mothers in the room, please. Anyway. What if it came from your father? Same consequence, right?

What if you got a little bit from each of them? You know, your mother gave a little bit half of your consciousness, and your father gave half of your We can think about a lot of different scenarios, but the Buddha says none of these really pan out. In the end, what you are bringing forward into this life is your own continuity of consciousness that came from another life. Now this, again, is something that I’m not expecting everyone in the room to completely accept and say, Well, yeah, I can get behind this. I can totally accept that there’s beginningless lifetimes.

But the Buddha says that we can never find a beginning to this. Why? Because if you find a beginning moment to consciousness, then you have to posit that that consciousness did not have a substantial cause similar to it in the prior moment. Yeah, John. Just oh, my.

So this would tend to imply that stem cells have consciousness. Not necessarily. Not necessarily. Because, again, the biological side of it versus the fact that you’re if you have a growing fetus, you don’t necessarily always have the conditions for consciousness to be there. It has to do with whether what is there is a living being or not.

And again, when we would say, for most of us, again, all of us ended up coming out of the womb and being living beings. So we can posit that consciousness was there. When we start talking about things that are done outside of the womb, again, I don’t think that it necessarily implies that consciousness is always going to be there. Interesting discussion. Yeah.

I mean, His Holiness, I think, has talked about this, and I’ve heard other Tibetan Buddhist teachers talk about it. And I don’t think that they hold that everything that is done kind of in vitro is necessarily consciousness. And they might even propose that if you had something that was done in vitro, and then the egg, the fertilized egg, put into a womb, that it could even occur at that time. The consciousness being attracted to that, and the force of the warmth of the womb and what have you. Again, it gets to be quite complicated in terms of we’re talking about an entity, again, that has no physical substance to it.

And so to track, like, where our consciousness is going or has been, right now it’s quite bound up with this body because of the strong interlacing of it with this body. The mind and matter have sort of come together in that regard. But when they come together and how they come together in some of these situations, I don’t think it’s quite as clear. Yeah, Mark. I don’t I’m not sure if I’m getting how you’re making that jump.

But if we talk about this flower again, there was a specific seed that gave rise to this flower, right? Does that mean that it’s one with all the other flowers that are similar to it? A Moment of mind. And you’re saying that the human consciousness came into Right. You know, was attracted or manifested from a moment.

Mhmm. Become a baby or a Right. Right. Previous moments of mind created that egg and that sperm before consciousness came into it. Likewise.

So in other words sorry. I guess I should just think about it more. Yeah. I think I have a question. Yeah.

I mean, when we if we talk about kind of what became this human existence that you have, we can say that there’s a physical component to it that are the two cells from your mother and father that reproduced in your mother’s womb through the kindness of her eating food and sustaining that growth throughout the nine months of gestation. And then we can talk about the mental component of your existence, which your mother and father had nothing to do with, in a sense. That was your own consciousness that had a continuity prior to this life that through the force of, again, karma, after having left that previous life and wandered in, again, what we call sort of intermediate period, where you don’t immediately go from one existence to the next one. You have to find it. You have to you know, force of your karma draws you to various places, it says.

And then eventually you do locate something that resonates with you. And that consciousness links up with that existence. These are all, again, philosophical things that, as I said, not everybody might be ready to accept. You can put them on a little shelf and just take them down and entertain them later. But if I mean, we’re going to talk about the implications of if the materialist approach is correct, and basically you are nothing but something created through the force of matter, and that mind doesn’t have its own entity, well, then there’s implications to that.

But the idea here in Buddhism is that you have a substantial cause to consciousness that needs to be maintained, and it’s a substantial cause to your consciousness. It’s not a universal consciousness that a piece of it goes floating off and becomes you, and a piece of it goes floating off and becomes somebody else. It’s your individual stream of consciousness that was associated with a whole another body in another lifetime, and another lifetime before that, and another lifetime before that, and so on. And we can never find a beginning. Pretty mind blowing.

Yes? Take that Buddhism has with the soul. Mhmm. The soul has a place within the mind. Yeah.

It’s a good question, Theia. Not sure how that moves in, but I feel like a lot of what we’re talking about consciousness can be linked Right. It’s a good question, Theo. In the word soul, there’s nothing in the Buddhist vocabulary that kind of points to that entity existing. But if we talked about what we mean by this level of consciousness that is going from life to life that has this continuity, it has many of the same characteristics that people would ascribe to a soul, in that all of the experiences of those previous lives are embedded within that awareness.

All of the force of what’s driving it from life to life is embedded within that. So consciousness kind of is the seed of all of it. But when we talk about a soul, particularly, I mean, the way that it’s defined in the Judeo Christian tradition, is even when you look at In the Buddhist time, there was this concept of ātman in the Hindu faith that basically spoke to something that had some sort of nature that is completely independent of this mind and body, that may share some experiences with that but has its own kind of continuity if we wanted to use the same sort of analogy or description? Well, I think in the Buddha’s experience, he can’t assess that there’s anything that really speaks to the existence of such an ātman or a soul. And that, in effect, what we have in terms of our physical experience and our mental experience is enough to substantiate what’s going on, and that there’s no need to posit something independent of that.

And if we go looking for something even on a conventional basis that can be that, we don’t find anything. And you might say, Well, physically I don’t find anything for mind either. But we can find mind through our own awareness of awareness, right? We can speak to the fact that we have consciousness. We have awareness.

Now, the implications of that, again, prior to this life or beyond this life, we might have to have some faith in whether these teachings are true or not in that regard. But if you kind of leap over to a soul, what the Buddha says is this is not He would basically say it’s a fictitious phenomenon. You cannot find anything that is the soul. Now, I’m not saying throw all your beliefs in a soul out the window. Again, this is something that you might have to work with over time.

But in effect, what we mean by consciousness embodies a lot of what we mean by soul. You know, there is a piece of you, in a sense, a part of you, a very subtle undercurrent to your awareness that goes on from this life. It just didn’t start with this life, and it doesn’t end up in some sort of eternal state of bliss or damnation or whatever that some traditions would teach in regard to the future of your soul. So if it’s comfortable for now to think of this awareness, consciousness, as a soul, I don’t think there’s a whole lot of problem to it, except if you start ascribing qualities to it or experiences to it that are from other traditions that speak to kind of things that the Buddha didn’t really find to be correct from his state of wisdom. Now again, I’m speaking only from my own perspective of having faith in this, and this way of delineating how we can assess that certain things are explainable in regard to this idea of substantial causes.

This is one way to kind of rationalize the existence of past and future lives, is to say that our consciousness has this continuity by the fact that there is a substantial cause of consciousness running through the entire thread. Now, while you brought this up, I might go ahead and introduce two other ways that the Buddha said that we can actually gain some conviction in this continuity of consciousness and the existence of past and future lives for what they’re worth. One is we can actually develop a direct knowledge of the continuity of our own minds through understanding our past lives. Now, how does that happen? According to techniques that have been taught for ages in both the Hindu and Buddhist tradition, you can develop very deep states of meditative concentration in which you can access, through clairvoyance, recollection of your past lives.

Everything that has happened to you has been imprinted on your mind. Every bad TV show you’ve watched, every, you know, wonderful experience you’ve had, everything is imprinted on your mind. Okay? You carry it all with you. Nothing is lost.

And you can recollect through the power of developing your mind in that way, through very deep meditative concentration, a clairvoyance that will allow you to have that conviction. And beings have done this. I mean, there are, again, throughout history in both of these traditions, least, these techniques for developing meditative concentration have been practiced. So we have the ability to test that theory ourselves as to whether there is a continuity of consciousness. The third way that we might gain some conviction, though it’s still not direct, not as direct as gaining that through our own clairvoyance, is through understanding it through the experiences of others.

And many young children, in particular, are born into this world with strong recollections of their past lives. Some of it wasn’t lost through going through the birth process, as it can be for many people. And we hear these stories, and there are many of them documented. I even had ABC News on one morning or something, and they were interviewing this family that had this young boy who identified himself as having been a World War II fighter pilot. And he knew the numbers on his plane and all this stuff.

And they were able to find who he actually was identifying himself as based on all this information that this young, young person had. And we can’t explain a lot of these things, but the Buddha says we don’t have to because it’s all within the Buddhist view of consciousness having no beginning, that we’ve had these lifetimes many, many, many, many lifetimes. We can’t even imagine because it’s beginningless. And our consciousness is endless too, but it’s not going to continue to go from life to life unless that’s the choice that we make, is just to keep going from life to life. The Buddha actually says that we can break free of this whole cycle of rebirth.

And these are some of the deeper teachings we’ll get into over time in discovering Buddhism. Thoughts or comments on that? Interesting. Okay. So again, this whole idea of like a soul, I won’t use this term, and probably you won’t find many Buddhists that use this term.

But in the Western world, and we have a strong identification of this, and actually the Buddha thinks that this is a fictitious thing that we’re just taught to believe in. And there’s no real valid basis for it. And again, I can only give you that as the Buddha’s word, but I think we have to go into this ourselves and kind of make our own decisions about. And if we’re quite comfortable with consciousness having some of the same qualities that we like to attribute to a soul, then we still have that. You still can acknowledge that there is that kind of continuous part of us that does go on from life to life.

Yeah, Claudio? I think so. I think so. But, you know, I grew up Roman Catholic, and I had a hard I have a real hard time even defining what a soul was because I don’t think I ever got a clear definition from the people teaching me. But I did have this idea of it being, again, limited to this life experience, that it wasn’t something that was in nonhuman beings.

My dog didn’t have a soul. That’s not the Catholic view. That soul is sort of, in my view, sort of a piece of God or something that kind of is with you, that goes through all these experiences, but is definitely affected by what we do with this life. And if we make bad decisions in this life, this soul gets eternal damnation. And if we make good decisions, this soul gets to hang out with God up in heaven.

There’s this idea of the soul having that eternal dimension to it beyond this life. And again, the Buddha would basically say, what we have in consciousness, yes, is influenced by all of our actions and goes on to potentially states of suffering or states of happiness, but those are all temporary. And so as you’re pointing out, it’s impermanent, changing. The mind will go to these various other experiences. My mind could end up in the body of an animal and have the mind of an animal.

Because the Buddha says that when we talk about this level of consciousness, we’re talking about all sentient beings, all beings who are capable of experiencing things through their feelings, through having a reaction to the world around them. So sentient beings includes animals in this world, all levels of what we call animal life, as well as human beings. And we’ll talk about this more in the future. There are other states of existence that the Buddha says we don’t know in this life, that through his wisdom he can say these states exist. Now again, that may be an issue of faith in the Buddha as to whether we believe in those or not.

But we don’t go on to a state of eternal damnation or a state of eternal happiness. When you achieve full enlightenment, then you are, in effect, achieving a state of well-being that’s so far beyond what we can even imagine. And the mind will abide in that state, but it will continue to change in terms of how that mind is working with others and being in the world. So enlightenment is not a kind of final, unchanging product in that regard. Unchanging thing.

Seems like it’s time for a break. Let’s take a break. So when we come back, we’ll go into this a little bit more detail, and we’ll also look at this idea of kind of mind body connection. Again, those of you who are new, who weren’t at the last class, maybe you could come up and I’ll make sure you get the information that you need. Oh, also, those of you who ordered the CD ROM, I have these up here for you.

Yeah. Twenty two. Twenty two? Hi. Hi.

My hand’s cold. Frank. Greg? Frank. Oh, Frank.

Yes. I’m Doug. It’s good to meet you, Let me give you the information from last week. Sure. Thank you.

Oh, great. Did you have you been to the center before, Frank? I is this the same one that was over Over over on Water Street? Alameda? Yeah.

Yeah. I was there once. Okay. Do you let me get you a welcome packet too, though, just to make sure. Because I don’t know if do you have the book?

I didn’t get anything. Didn’t get anything? Okay. Good. Let me give all of this to you.

This is kinda an overview of the course. Okay. We’ll be meeting over the course of the next several Sundays and kind of the topics that I’m gonna be discussing at various points in here. And then we’re gonna have kind of a practice morning to get together, do meditation and discussion together. This is the material for it, and again, there’s a free book that I’ll give you, and that really should be enough.

But if you’re interested in pursuing this further, there’s these little CD-ROMs that have a whole bunch of readings because we just started this Discovering Buddhism course, and you can follow along with that. This is a little reading from last week that I gave out as well as a meditation. And then hi. Hi. I’m I’m listening because I’m Okay.

Good. Good. So let me give those to Frank. What’s your name? Susan.

Susan? I’m Don. Nice to meet you. Good to meet you. Yeah.

Let me give you this, I wanna get both of you and Emery as well some information on discovering Buddhism. So again, this is an overview of the course with some about the reading materials and meditation assignments, as well as a little bit of reading in last week’s meditation. And let me run out to the kitchen after I give these to Emery, and I’ll get you all a copy of the information on Is this your first time at the center too, Susan? Yes, it is. So what I’m giving you all, this is kind of an overview of Discovering Buddhism.

It’s thirteen different teaching modules, and then there’s a fourteenth module that people can do that has practices in it. But for now, kind of take a look through this and it gives you kind of an overview of that. In this packet is kind of an introduction to our center and what we have. This is the free book that we’re using for this module. Oh, you got one of those?

Okay. So do we have this whole packet? I got that one. Okay. Good.

Let me go ahead and give that to you And give you this. Okay. Thank you, brother. Yes. That’s it.

Thank you. Alright, Frank. Any questions? I’m not so far. Okay.

Did you need this book at all? Do you have a miss which book is it? Becoming Your Own Therapist. And with with the yes. Absolutely.

You can make it payable to just put t n l. Okay. And probably twenty two, I think, is what we’ve been collecting because it’s, I don’t know, eight or nine dollars, something like that for shipping. So and there were five ordered, so let’s see. Mark you there that you’ve gotten out.

Joan? Alright. I’ll see you in a moment. Alright. Great.

Thank you. There you go. Okay. Yeah. Let me know if there’s any problems.

I didn’t get a chance to check all of these. But if you put it in your computer, it should come up with something that tells you to go to the menu, and then you get menu, and it’s got all the readings you can access from there. So okay. Good. Where did Shari go?

She’s gonna talk to me. I need to tell Rabini’s story about the consciousness all waiting. Beings, whatever species I’ll I’ll share that when we get to the karma module. We can talk a little bit more about kind of Okay. Yeah.

But hi, Nan. Uh-huh. I had a friend that had a brain tumor once. Uh-huh. Uh-huh.

Painful for several years. Wow. When he when I was notified of his death Mhmm. I went, alright, Charles. Congratulations.

I wanna know what the other side’s like. Mhmm. So if there’s a way for you to let me know, just let me know. Alright. And a few days passed, and I was lying in the hot sun.

We had floor to ceiling glass, and went into this kind of twilight state. Mhmm. All of a sudden, was absolute awareness, three hundred and sixty degrees, and the knowing was instantaneous. I knew. I just knew things, but I had no identity.

I wasn’t a woman or a mom or anything. It was, like, three hundred and sixty degree. Right. That’s right. Wow.

And then and I’m so scared I jumped out of it, you know? But years later, then I read a book about the river of consciousness. And so I’m wondering if this is the knowing that you’re talking about. Yeah, I mean, obviously we kind of always have some level of knowing. What we are going to talk at some point probably I don’t know if it’s the next class or the class after about kind of how we have different levels of our consciousness or awareness, and the things that are quite gross, of course, all the way down to those that are very subtle.

And so any of these sorts of experiences that we have could be, again, in some way of tapping into subtler levels of Right. Right. Right. Okay. Yeah.

No. Definitely. I mean, we I go back there a lot. It’s been years since I had it, but it was kind of, wow. There’s something there.

One thing in in these teachings and one of the modules that we’re gonna work with eventually in the death and rebirth is where we talk about kind of how important it is to work with our minds. Get to death when there is sort of an unfolding of all those grosser levels of mind fall away and we get to even subtler states that we’re able to maintain some awareness of that process. Because we’ve gone through it zillions of times before whenever we’ve died, but we’ve gone through it without any awareness. So, I think bringing any level of awareness to all the variety of our experiences is so important. So there are many more places to go, is what you’re saying.

Yeah. To have a little more control and awareness of what’s happening in that way, be able to kind of control things a little more. What the Buddha is saying is that we’ve been in control, but the problem is we’ve been in control with an out of control mind. And we need to develop more control over our minds so that we actually dictate where we’re going throughout our daily life as well as where we go from this life. Sue, are you going to talk more about the distinction between presenting loving kindness and and not just letting being a doormat?

Because I’ve I’m watching that in my own process. I just had a recent experience where I had a certain thing happening for a while. I’m giving love and kindness, I think, and giving space for a shift to happen over there, but it didn’t. It just escalated. So does loving kindness often evoke that in someone?

And if so, you know, I ended up saying, exactly what is it you want? Right. I will give it to you. But I’m not sure what you want. She said, Well, I don’t know what I want to do.

I said, Well, there we are. There we are. Yeah, yeah. You know, it’s hard to say. Don’t know if there’s any sort of set thing as to where it leads.

But I think, again, when we talk about it from the perspective of having control over our own minds and what we’re doing, at some level, obviously, again, there are some ramifications where things can go too far people definitely abuse others, and we know this from the world that we live in. And we should kind of be party to that in a sense because, not just because it’s harming us, but because it’s harming the other person, you know. They are perpetuating these patterns of behavior that are not going be beneficial beneficial for them in the future. Well, and I set a boundary. I said, you know, you may choose what you want to do while you’re here, but I will choose if I want to do it, I’ll do it.

If I don’t, I won’t. And I want you to do the same. And that’s kinda how I I didn’t know where to go with it because So I think that this is the the key is if we have that sort of more all embracing compassion and loving kindness where it’s not just this kind of blind, I want you to be happy, but it’s recognizing that we’re both involved in this. We’re both a part of the circle of how do we find the greatest good for all of us. How do we make sure that all of our needs are met?

I think that this is an important kind of component of that, where it’s not just this sort of selfless, stupid, you know, pulling Well, that’s where I don’t want to be. It’s embracing the reality that, you know, in the end, what we want is for all beings to be. The end, it’s what we want is for the relationships relationships that we do have to be fruitful for everyone. Know? And so that kind of helps in in that regard.

But, yeah, I think we have to be very careful in not kind of overdo it. I do too. And I have to say, as a mother, can’t help but pass hodgepodge. Everybody here really knows that. Yeah.

Yeah. I think so. When you see a variety of Oh my god. There’s no doubt. There’s no doubt.

You. Sure. Sure. Sure. Oh, for No problem.

It’s for this printed material. Oh, no. No. No. No.

That’s the that’s that’s if you get the printed material of all of these readings. Oh, okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Is that something I can do? Yeah. You can order that. I’ll I’ll put it down. See, basically, there’s there’s this CD ROM that contains all the required readings for all the modules.

And so you can get this, and then you can print them out yourself or read them on screen, or I can actually photocopy just the pieces for this module for you. You. Okay. Is like twenty in tax, but or in shipping. I’m sorry.

Not tax. But I may have to order it for you for next week just because yeah. The the other three that were ordered, there’s people here that will probably take them. But yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. I’ll be great. Okay. So I just realized I left the recorder on the whole break. Tom will have to go in and edit it out.

Okay. So questions on this topic of the continuity of consciousness, kind of how we have minds that go back without any beginning. And then the other end of it and part of the meditation I’m going to pass out in a moment is looking at it in terms of projecting forward. Imagine your consciousness a day from now, a week from now, all the way up to your time of death, when this life ends. What happens after death?

So again, the idea in Buddhism is that there’s no end to our consciousness, no beginning to our consciousness. It’s arising through the force of that mental continuum that is a substantial cause for every single moment, a previous moment of mine giving rise to it. Questions on this? Yeah, Claudia. There’s a question that Israel actually asked a couple years ago.

Uh-huh. I don’t remember what the answer was. He’s asking I hope I do. He’s asking about first mud. That was his language.

How did our minds first become or why is it that our minds are Why are we here? These negative habits that we’ve accumulated over time. Was there a previous time when they were less fettered, or they became more fettered? How is that? Yeah.

When the Buddha was asked everyone probably heard Claudio’s question, this idea of, well, was there an initial sort of pure state that we were in, and then we fell from grace, if you will, and now have these deluded minds that we need to clean up to return to some sort of pure state? The Buddha never made any comments on this. And if we look at the Buddha’s teachings, I don’t think that we can posit that there ever was a moment that we were fundamentally pure in terms of not just fundamentally, but totally free of all of this. If we look at what the Buddha’s saying, that we have a mind that has this nature, but what we have done, in effect, is through the force of our own delusion, continue to cloud the mind, continue to make the mind under the influence of these deluded states. If there was a moment when we were completely free of them in the way that the Buddha posits that we can be free of them because the mind by its nature is pure, is clear, then there would be if that’s possible for us to attain that state, then that state in and of itself has to be a state that is irreversible.

Or I don’t know that the Buddha’s teachings would make much sense. And if we really talk about and again, I can’t in the course of this kind of introductory module where we look at the mind, I can’t really go into all the depths of what is explained in terms of the levels of delusions and the antidotes to those and how we’re able to remove all that. We’re going to touch on that briefly. But in essence, what the Buddha says is that we have had a mind that has been clouded by ignorance since beginningless time, just as we have had mind since beginningless time. So there is no beginning moment to our delusion, just as there is no beginning moment to our mind.

Now, you might say, Well, then, well, yeah, well, kind of, how did we end up in this situation? Why have we always had these minds that are under the influence of delusions? And the reason why the Buddha didn’t say much about it, I think, is because, for one thing, it’s impossible to answer. Because if we do consider that things are beginningless, then you can never sort of posit that there’s any cause for why we ended up in that other than the fact that there was a previous moment of us being in that. It’s kind of by default, it’s just always been there.

The other side of it is that if we do follow the Buddha’s teachings, and the Buddha’s teachings allows us to be free of all of that, to experience the true nature of our mind in this unadulterated pure state in the form of complete enlightenment. Well, then, isn’t there more isn’t the more important aspect of the Buddhist teachings doing that as opposed to wondering why we’re in the situation that we’re in? They often compare it to if somebody, you know, told you that the building you were in was on fire, would you stop and kind of go, Well, god, I wonder if that was an electrical fire or And you just sit there and kind of, you know, spend the whole time, like, trying to investigate why there’s a fire in the house versus following the advice of the person who’s telling you, you know, hey, there’s a way out over here, you know. You’d be much better putting your energy into getting out of the burning house than analyzing why it’s on fire. So I think there’s a lot of truth to that in terms of if we look at the Buddha’s teachings and this is, again, why last week I talked a bit about how this is called discovering Buddhism, because we each individually have to go about that process of discovering this truth for ourselves.

And eventually, the truth that the Buddha teaches, you know, is the truth that will set you free, the truth that will completely remove all these negative tendencies to where you experience unbelievable bliss and well-being and no longer under the control of all these states of mind that have been perpetuating your own stay and this cycle of life after life. Dissatisfaction. So anyway, those are the best way to encapsulate what the Buddha’s words on that are and what message. A lot of times when the Buddha was asked these sorts of questions, like, you know, is there an end to all of it for everybody? Will we all attain Buddhahood and abide in some unbelievable state of well-being?

Buddha just kind of remained silent because, again, these sorts of questions are not as important, I think, as your own individual response to these teachings and what you do with them. And if they resonate for you, if you’re finding that the teachings that you’re hearing over time resonate with you, then the proof will be in whether you are able to achieve the same results through these teachings that many beings of the past said that they have. A lot of times they don’t necessarily profess to having done that. I know His Holiness Dalai Lama, whenever he talks about himself, he says, I’m just a simple Buddhist monk. You know, I don’t have any great qualities.

Well, he has a reason for being humble, too. So we can trust that that humility is a sign of actually him having pretty great realizations, pretty far along the path if not already having achieved these great results. Other questions or comments? Thanks for bringing that up. It’s a good one to deal with at some point in here.

Other questions? Okay. So let me talk about the other aspect of this that is kind of related to the continuity of consciousness, which has to do with the mind body connection. You know, what’s the relationship between these two? If we already have posited that there is a continuity of your body that comes from, again, two cells that came together.

And those cells, again, have their own continuity, right? They came from matter material that was in your parents’ body. They came from matter material that was in their parents’ body, and so on. We have this continuity of matter. But we have now in this existence this body that has various components to it in terms of a nervous system, a brain, all of the various aspects of that.

What is its relationship to the mind? Well, you know, when we as a preface to this, I think it’s important that we begin to look at, well, how does even Western science see mind or awareness? And I don’t claim to be an expert on this, but I have read some. And His Holiness the Dalai Lama, at least once a year, gets together with neuroscientists and all sorts of people from various disciplines in what’s called the Mind Life Conference and talks about these sorts of issues kind of Buddhist thinking versus Western science thinking. And when you ask most Western scientists what mind or consciousness is, there’s a lot of differences in opinions in this regard.

I mentioned Cartesian what would be the word for it? The sort of philosophy or understanding in terms of a real duality of mind and body that sprung up quite a few centuries back that really spoke to them being very quite distinct entities. Then we have kind of the more materialist approach that has come out of a lot of Western scientific research, where they basically find that, in essence so there are variations on this what we know of as consciousness or awareness is what they call an emergent property. So remember I mentioned water earlier, and how you have two molecules of a gas that’s called hydrogen, and one molecule of a gas that’s called oxygen? These two gases get together in that quantity, in that combination, and they become something liquid.

Well, this is a similar analogy for what Western science says, many scientists say about consciousness, is that when you bring together all of this functioning stuff that’s got electrochemical responses going on in the brain and all this functioning, that then you have an emergent property that’s called consciousness or awareness. What are the implications of that type of an approach, a materialist approach? It means that your consciousness started when all this started functioning, right? It also means that when all this stops functioning, when you go flatline at, you know, death and your brain is no longer functioning, that basically you no longer have any consciousness. So the materialist approach is a pretty hard edged approach, and Buddhism is definitely not falling into that camp.

On the other hand, the sort of dualism that Descartes proposed is not quite as strictly defined in Buddhist thought either. There certainly is a mind body connection, and we certainly can understand that it’s multidirectional, that influencing the brain, for example, which they have found in Western science, can cause you to, for example, to, like, have a memory of something that you completely forgot about, but that memory was lodged in that part of your brain, and there’s a correlation when they stimulate that. All of a sudden, you have this memory of eating ice cream when you were five years old or something. Well, on the other hand, we would say, again, it’s multidirectional because we also have to contend that the changes we make in our consciousness or awareness can also affect the brain. And they are finding this in Western science.

And so it’s kind of challenging a lot of these materialist approaches. Many of you have heard of neuroplasticity, where basically there are several books, one I’ve read most of. It’s a little bit of a hard read, particularly when it talks about these Silver Spring monkey experiments. But a book called The Mind and the Neuroplasticity and the Power of Mental Force, where they are finding that in a lot of behavioral disciplines, they are able to make measurable changes in the brain on the basis of changes in our behavior, conscious decisions that are being made with our awareness that have a physical ramification in terms of the content of our brain. In many of these mind life conferences, they’ve had meditators.

They’ve shown the results of doing these analyses of what’s going on in someone’s brain when they’re meditating in these deep states of meditation, both Westerners and Tibetans. And they have found that there’s profound changes in the quality of what’s going on in the physical brain on the basis of the meditative states that are being induced by the practitioner. So there’s definitely a multidirectional flow. The mind having an effect on the body, the body having an effect on the mind. When it comes down to it, though, when we really define, well, what is consciousness or awareness?

Although it has an interdependence with the body, we do not find that it can be equivalent to the body. And this is, again, where it diverges from materialist approaches, because of the ramifications of that, as I said earlier. If we say that consciousness ends at death, well, then life is a party, basically. Do whatever you want to be as happy as you can in this life because it’s all over when the final act comes. So again, I don’t think that Western science has completely settled any of these issues by any degree.

But it’s kind of an interesting field to explore. There are several books, just so you know, that have come out of these sorts of dialogues that have occurred between scientists and His Holiness. One of them is His Holiness, on the basis of a lot of these dialogues, has produced a book called The Universe in a Single Atom: The Convergence of Science and Spirituality, which I highly recommend. It’s a really good read. But I would like to read a little bit from this, because I think it does give some insight into this debate, if you will.

His Holiness even approached one of these scientists once and asked about this kind of multidirectional, like, can the mind influence the brain and so on. And he says he said to one of the scientists, It seems very evident that due to changes in the chemical processes of the brain, many of our subjective experiences like perception and sensation occur. Can one envision the reversal of this causal process? Can one postulate that pure thought itself could affect a change in the chemical processes of the brain? And His Holiness explains, I was asking whether, conceptually at least, we could allow the possibility of both upward and downward causation.

The scientist’s response was quite surprising. He said that since all mental states arise from physical states, it is not possible for downward causation to occur. Although out of politeness, I did not respond at the time, His Holiness says, I thought then and still think that there is as yet no scientific basis for such a categorical claim. The view that all mental processes are necessarily physical processes is a metaphysical assumption, not a scientific fact. I feel that in the spirit of scientific inquiry, it is critical that we allow the question to remain open and not conflate our assumptions with empirical fact.

So again, as I said, I think a lot of what scientists have found has proven that this is really quite opposite. But if we start to define consciousness as a result of physical causes alone, it does create that dilemma of kind of, well, if that’s what’s happening is you’re talking about a result of a cause, well, then how can that result actually produce an effect on its own cause? Mental states are always preceded by physical states. We do run into some problems. One of the most fundamental principles of Buddhism is this idea of dependent arising, of things coming into existence on the basis of their causes.

In this way, Buddhism is probably one of the closest philosophies or religions to science in terms of understanding that everything has its own respective causes and conditions that lead to that particular result. And that’s why, in what I was explaining earlier in terms of continuity of consciousness, it’s very much defined in those terms. So we do run into some dilemmas when we start thinking about, well, what’s causing what? What is the relationship between these? And as I said earlier, we think most Buddhists would basically define it as having those two directions, that physical processes can affect our mental states.

And we do see this. It’s certainly when people have impairment to the brain that they do act differently. They do have behavior that follows differently, thoughts that follow differently. But also the contrary, the opposite would hold true that what we do with our thinking, with our thoughts, can actually affect matter, can actually have an impact on that. Another part of this book that I think is really important well, I kind of talked about this a little bit earlier.

Yeah, I think I’ll just skip this because I touched on most of that earlier. But this is, as I said, a really intriguing book that has about three or four chapters dealing with consciousness, as well as several other that are dealing with kind of matter and what goes on in the world around us. Questions on that before I collect my notes and see what I missed in covering this? The Universe and a Single Atom. No questions, okay.

One of the things, too, we can understand in terms of the mind body relationship is, as we’re going to go into this next week, when we begin to delve into the Buddhist view, what we call Buddhist epistemology and Buddhist psychology, we begin to explore kind of the way that Buddhism looks at the mind, is that there is, obviously with regard to some of our levels of consciousness, a strong dependence on the body. And in particular, I’m referring to our five sense consciousnesses. So in Buddhist thinking, as we’re going to see I think we’ll be touching on this next week we basically talk about six levels of consciousness, or six types of awareness. And one of these, mental consciousness, can be divided further. But the five basic ones that we talk about as being related to our senses are greatly dependent upon the physical body.

Can you have a visual consciousness, a visual awareness without the eye organ? Being operative, again, we do see there’s a strong dependence upon that physical matter being there for us to have that awareness. Can you experience the sound of my voice without having an ear functioning, without all the various elements of the ear organ that give rise to that ability to have So certainly when it comes to these grosser levels of consciousness, particularly these five sense consciousnesses, there’s a strong interdependence between mind and body. But when it comes to mental consciousness, the domain of primarily our thinking, but also as we see there’s ways that we can even transcend thinking, this is where we tend to, again, although there’s a reliance to some degree upon a functioning brain, we cannot say that that is completely the case. That a brain plays a role in terms of our ability to process information, retain information, what have you.

But the mind in and of itself would naturally have some of these abilities already. The mind has a strong influence in terms of this human existence having a human brain. Whereas if we brought a dog in here, again a dog would not have the same abilities to be able to process language, to be able to process concepts, to understand various things that we’re teaching. All of that would be outside the domain of that brain of a dog. But does it mean that by nature the dog’s mind lacks that ability?

This is where we get into, again, some of this idea that we are definitely influenced by the body, but consciousness in and of itself still has some of these qualities that it’s sort of carrying forward. If we subscribe to the idea of there being continual consciousness, then we’ve all had many, many dog existences. We’ve all had many, many human existences. So we’ve had different levels of intellect operative, but the mind in and of itself still had that ability. Again, it goes back to this idea of being clear and knowing.

It has an ability to be aware of things, and it has a clarity, a luminosity. So the physical, mental, interrelationships, again, are not completely settled in terms of how this works. But Buddhism, again, embraces some form of duality, some form of understanding mind as having its own substantial causes that give rise to it, and the physical world having its own causes. But there’s a great degree of interrelationship. So let me go ahead and pass out the meditation on the continuity of consciousness, because again, I think this is an important one to work with.

Let me send these in a couple of directions, and then I’ll go through this meditation just to make sure everyone’s kind of aware of what’s involved in this. Any questions while this is going around? Yes. Uh-huh. To a degree, yeah.

I mean, at least in terms of mind and matter kind of being talked about as two separate phenomena. But not in terms of, again, if we looked at the Descartes I mean, Descartes lived in an age when scientific exploration of the brain was not at its greatest. I I don’t know a lot about what he was attributing, but he had a lot of focus on the pineal gland, and this being the conduit for where mind, which is this other entity, becomes involved with the body, which is a separate entity. Buddhism doesn’t go so far as to it’s understanding an interrelationship. And even when we talk about some of the most advanced teachings in Buddhism, when they talk about the very subtlest level of mind that we will explore in this course, they’re not positing it as having a completely independent identity, because it’s always together with some level of physicality, Very subtle physicality in its most subtle state, which is what they call kind of a subtle wind energy.

But usually together with quite a large amount of gross matter, you know, Something made up like this body is of the various physical elements of earth, water, fire, wind, and what have you. Yeah. So it’s not really as dualistic. It’s kind of interesting. Buddhism falls in between these two views of kind of strictly dualistic versus completely materialistic, where consciousness is only arising on the basis of a physical body having all of this going on.

Okay? Does that Yeah, it does. There’s two things. Certainly in these disciplines of yoga and other techniques of working with the body at subtler levels, you begin to understand that at subtler levels, you even have stronger connections between mind and body in terms of what you’re doing with prana, with wind, and the body, and what have you. You know, so we do see that these things are extremely interrelated and not independent in any way.

Catherine? This is correct. Yeah, I know this is a hard one for some people, because they do see that we ascribe some feelings of sentience to plant life. There are actually it’s kind of interesting. I don’t know a lot about Thich Nhat Hanh and his teachings, but if you read the book Old Path, White Clouds, there’s one part of there where he seems to be ascribing sentience to plant life.

And everything I’ve read, again, doesn’t include the plant kingdom in terms of an individual sentient being. I think it gets to be kind of hard to limit what is a sentient life when it comes to plant life, because you could take a branch off of a tree and put it in water and cultivate a whole new tree from it. Now, does that mean that that’s the same tree as the other tree? And if it was one consciousness, then people bring up the worm earthworm too, where you kind of split an earthworm at a certain point, and they become two separate little beings that are capable of functioning. And I don’t know about that either.

I’ve never asked a Tibetan Buddhist master what happens to the mind of that earthworm when it gets split into two. But I don’t know. It’d good one. It’d be a good one. But in terms of plant life, it’s not to say that plants aren’t an important part of the biology on this planet.

And they need to be respected in that regard in terms of finding a complementary relationship with the environment around us. But in terms of them being sentient, if you’re chopping down a tree, you are not killing a sentient being. But then when you get into looking at amoebas and single cell organisms, do they have consciousness? Do they Yeah. If it’s in the animal kingdom, basically, yes.

I mean, in anything, they say that the microorganisms in our body. We have several thousand sentient beings living within this one physical body that we have. They’re part of, yeah, your fauna. If it’s flora, not sentient. If it’s fauna, it is sentient.

That brings up an interesting question. Are we constantly at war with those other consciousnesses? Hopefully not. They have an interdependent relationship with us. I mean, this is why, again, the death of our body will also be their death eventually, because they cannot be sustained outside of our bodies unless they’re in another body.

There are agents, too, that do enter the body that are harmful, that are microorganisms that can cause disease. And so at those times, again, if we learn to respect sentient life, ideally it means not killing them. But there are occasions when we have to make decisions based on the greater good in terms of whether it’s better for a single celled organism that doesn’t have much chance of attaining enlightenment with that life to continue to infest our body and cause our death versus using this body and this mind wisely while we have it by staving off death through treatment or something. So these are, again, issues of morality that there’s no clear guidance on, but we have to follow some form of logic and not completely go to the extreme one way or the other. Yeah, sentient life in Buddha’s terms, as I mentioned earlier, pretty much anything in an animal kingdom in this world.

And of course, human beings, which according to science have evolved from the animal kingdom. Mean, there was a point, obviously, if you subscribe to evolution, where plant life became animal life, right? Something had to evolve from it being green and growing to moving and thinking and what have you. So there was that bridge that occurred. Buddhism doesn’t have a problem with saying, you might say, well, is that when consciousness started?

Well, Buddhist thinking doesn’t hold that this is the only world system that exists. So there is sentient life throughout countless universes and who knows what kinds of forms. And even, again, things that aren’t necessarily a part of our physical universe. And we will look at these. We are going to have one class where we will examine kind of what Buddhism says are the various forms of existence.

And that may be another one of those teachings that we kind of put on the shelf for a while, because we have to understand also the implications of karma in terms of playing a role in that process. That we basically, through the force of our own behavior, experience a world that kind of meshes with that type of behavior. So, yeah. I spent several days with my sister in the teaching in North Carolina. And she has a yard that goes way down into a creek bed in North Carolina.

And she has this massive bamboo. Right. And she was quite convinced it has intelligence. Yeah. My sentient being.

We went for days. And, of course, I ended up talking a whole lot, but it seemed to me simplest thing I could come with up with. You could be reincarnated into a dog or even a meme, but you can’t be reincarnated into a bamboo. Right. Because just that nature of consciousness, whether you’re talking about intelligence, it was a totally different thing.

When you’re talking about sensitivity, it was a different thing. But we have we have sort of, like, our jet genus of of sentience or whatever it is. We’re this kind of Right. Bunch, and those are those kind of bunch and whatever. I’m not sure what it means.

This difference between an evil and a Buddha is so vast, you know, then what? I couldn’t explain all that. And these are hard things to kind of get our heads around. She wasn’t gonna give up on the bad Buddha. Yeah.

Well, lot of people don’t give up on their house plants. They think, well, you know, my house plant reacts to the environment that it’s in. And when I play calm, soothing music, it even kind of seems to flourish better and what have you. Well, again, the Buddha doesn’t have a problem saying that these are cause and effect on a material level. Whether sentience is involved, the Buddha says no.

And I don’t know. It’s another debate for another time with another person, probably. I’m not so sure I’m the right one to debate that. So again, if you look at the very end of this meditation, I just want to go over this note with you and say, read this together, because throughout this reflection, watch whatever arises carefully. Because you’re going to be looking at kind of, again, going back, regressing into various experiences previous to the current moment, and you’re going to be kind of extending forward into future experiences.

Do that without expectation or judgment. Stay open to the possibilities, just looking for the connections and relationships between one mind moment and another, between one sequence of thoughts and another. Don’t get involved with the content of your thoughts. This is a big one. Because when we do this meditation, all of a sudden we’ll find that we’re remembering something that happened and then we want to kind of go visit it for a while.

We want to kind of hang out with it. And that’s not the point of this meditation. The point of this meditation isn’t to show that you’ve got a memory and can recall events from your past life and relive them. The point is that you want to continue that process, continually unpeeling, going back further, and not dwell in any one of these for too long. Then the other point that’s at the bottom is this reflection is not a regression exercise.

It’s an exploration of how consciousness works from moment to moment. In other words, we’re not trying to get you in touch with all these things so that you can then heal your life now from recalling your childhood and your past lives and whatever. The point is just to follow the thread of consciousness, of awareness. Understanding the process involved is more important than seeing our birth or past lives. And understanding the relationships and links within the stream of consciousness is the key to understanding karma and the cycle of past and future lives.

So as you meditate, stay clear and detached like a cool, neutral scientific observer, watching the process with no investment in the nature of the content. Enjoy it and have fun. Now this is written by the woman who does the Discovering Buddhism at Home module of Mind and Its Potential. So any questions on that meditation? Okay.

Let me look over my notes because I know I’ve got more to cover that I probably have missed in the process of going through this today. So I did want to review what we talked about. Part of this class was to also review what we talked about in regard to meditation in general. As I said, Module Two is where we’ll go into a lot more detail about how to meditate. But those of you who have already begun to work with meditation, or those of you who even just started, can understand how important this skill is.

I mean, again, we’re talking about developing a skill in your mind, an ability that all of us have. You know, involves a couple of key things that I’m just going to touch on really briefly. As I said, in module two we go into this in a lot more detail. But one of them is the element of what we call concentration. And the initial meditation that I passed out last week is really about trying to enhance that skill.

Concentration in and of itself is nothing that wonderful. Somebody who is a really good jewel thief probably has incredible concentration and incredible other mental skills. Because for them to be able to be focused on what they’re doing and do it correctly so that they can get the results they want and steal the jewels without anybody detecting them, without getting caught, probably takes a lot of concentration. But concentration in and of itself, then, doesn’t necessarily have a good or bad value. It’s what we do with that concentration.

So while last week’s meditation was about beginning to cultivate that concentration, also another skill that we call mindfulness, which means kind of staying with what’s going on, being aware of it, not forgetting, kind of staying present. And then also some other skills that we would call kind of introspection, which is an ability to notice when the mind’s going away from the breath, when we’re getting involved in something else, and then to, through the force of our mindfulness, bring it back to that object. So all of these skills are there so that we can use them to reflect on things like this other meditation. You know, Buddhist thinking is that there are I mentioned I think I mentioned this last time that there are fundamentally two levels of meditation. That what we are doing in terms of the first one that I gave out last week is really what we call stabilizing the mind, making the mind very firm in terms of being able to hold it in one place.

Why is this important? Because if we have a mind that’s like a pinball machine and going all over the place and constantly distracted, involved in all sorts of other things, it’s not going to be very powerful. You simply won’t be able to change the content of your mind, because the mind is incapable of staying on one thing for a sustained period of time. So this is an important skill to develop, but that skill is only a basis, a tool that we use to then be able to go inside and analyze. And this is the second type of meditation.

So stabilizing or placement is a tool or a skill. The real changes occur in our minds when we analyze things, when we begin to think about things. So last week when I was talking about how discovering Buddhism is all about this voyage of discovery, of finding these truths for yourself, We’re mostly talking about that second type of meditation, that ability to kind of go in and pick it apart and say mean, you could reflect besides doing this reflection on the continuity of consciousness. You could also do a little reflection this week on what I mentioned about anger and these other states of mind being invalid. Say you get to the end of your day and you had a horrible encounter with somebody during the day.

When you get to the end of your day, take a moment to sit somewhere quietly. It can be in a formal meditation, but even just sitting outside in a comfortable chair and just relaxing a bit. And look at that. Pick that situation apart. See what was going on in your mind when you were receiving various words or actions from another person.

See whether those were all grounded in a complete picture of that situation. Was there a valid foundation for your getting angry at that person? You know, use these tools. I mean, is the most important thing about Discovering Buddhism and about any of our Buddhist practice, is that if we aren’t using this in our lives, then it’s just like they compare it to going to a baking class, learning all about how to make cakes, and then never using a single recipe. What would be the point?

I go through all of this and learn how to make delicious, wonderful desserts, and then I never make a single one. So I really want to encourage you to use what you’re learning and to reflect on what you’re learning. And particularly, again, today we had some of these key ideas that our minds are fundamentally kind of clear, that we have various things arising in them, some of which are invalid, some of which are valid. Spend some time reflecting on that, beginning to develop that discernment yourself. What is a healthy, positive state of mind that influences you in a good way, that helps your mind to develop and grow in accord with how things exist?

Versus what is something that simply makes you more confused, makes you more frustrated in the world, stressed out, angry, anxious, whatever. You know, and if we’re not using the skills in that way or not using what we’re learning in that way, then there’s not going to be much value to these classes. And you also will find that your conviction in what the Buddha’s teaching will be waning because you’re not seeing it being practical in your own life. So again, I’ll emphasize this as well when we get into the meditation module. But since mind and its potential comes first, and you have to kind of meditate as part of it, I’m encouraging you to meditate as part of it.

It’s important to begin to look at some of these issues of what meditation is all about. So developing the skills is one part of it, but using those skills is the main part of it. Really analyzing, really looking critically at how you do things, how you think about things in particular. And if you’re not ready to analyze those very difficult things in your life yet, start with the small things. Start with the minor annoyances.

Why did my mind start to flip out when this happened? Some small thing at the grocery store or whatever. Versus, I mean, you might not be ready to tackle, well, why does my mind flip out every time I talk to my mother or my father or my brother or whoever it is? Work on those eventually, but begin to get a taste for it. Because if you don’t, then there’s going to be this gap that widens between what you’re hearing and how you’re living your life.

Okay. Questions on that? None? Should be lots. Okay.

All right. So let’s just take a moment to kind of conclude today’s class. We’re close to the end of our time together. And what we’d like to do, again, at the end of each of these classes, just as at the beginning, we spent a few minutes and we just tried to steer our mind in a particular direction. And just to refresh your memory, that direction pertained to the fact that we’re learning how to work with our mind so that we can achieve the greatest possible benefit, the benefit for ourselves, certainly, that we will have more peace, more calm, more control in our own lives, in our minds.

But also that we might be able to generate those qualities that help us to be of greater benefit to others. Because we see, again, the interdependence that we all have. That we’re not an island. We can’t live alone. That we basically are dependent upon others and they upon us.

So right now, at the end of class, we like to do what we call a dedication, which simply means sealing all of this positive energy that we’ve created, all these good thoughts that we’ve had, so that they create the result that we want. We can envision ourselves being more at peace, kinder, more compassionate, wiser, not so subject to all of these delusions. And we can envision a world where we are like that and influencing others to be like that. And so we dedicate for that result, for us to achieve our greatest potential, to be able to help others to do the same. Okay, so have a good week.

Next week’s topics will be on the functions of the mind. So we will start to look at these kind of levels of consciousness and begin to sort of pick apart the content of the mind. And this is what we call sort of Buddhist epistemology, kind of understanding how the mind works, as well as Buddhist psychology, kind of the content of the mind. So we’ll get a little technical at times, but I’ll do my best to guide you through all of that. So look forward to seeing you all for that class.

So thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Do amoebas and other single-celled organisms have consciousness?

If the organism belongs to the animal kingdom, then basically yes, it is sentient. The same applies to microorganisms generally: it is said that several thousand sentient beings live within this one physical body, as part of one's fauna. The dividing line given is between flora and fauna. If it is flora, it is not sentient. If it is fauna, it is sentient.

Are we constantly at war with the microorganisms and other consciousnesses living in our bodies?

Hopefully not. These organisms have an interdependent relationship with us, and the death of our body will eventually be their death too, since they cannot be sustained outside a body. Some microorganisms that enter the body are harmful and cause disease. If we learn to respect sentient life, ideally that means not killing them. But sometimes decisions must be made for the greater good: whether it is better for a single-celled organism with little chance of attaining enlightenment in that life to keep infesting our body and cause our death, or to use this body and mind wisely while we have them by staving off death through treatment.

Scroll to Top