DB Mind and its Potential 2010 – 2010 10 17 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 17

2 h 3 min · 19,222 words · 17 October 2010

DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 - 2010 10 17 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 10 17
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher opens with a short breathing meditation and then explains the nature of mind as mere clarity and knowing, its continuity, and the mind-body relationship. The talk then covers the traditional study of mind and awareness (lorik): gross and subtle levels of mind, sense and mental consciousness, perception and conception, and the three levels of wisdom from hearing, contemplation and meditation. It ends with a dedication and prayers for those experiencing obstacles, illness, or death.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2010-10-17

Duration: 2h 4m

UUID: 23f63ffd-3761-4c84-9db6-06d048908208

Words: 19,222

So let’s go ahead and start today’s class as usual with just a short meditation. So again, the next module will go into a lot more detail on meditation, but for now just find a comfortable posture. And one of the key elements of having good posture is just to have the back straight. So if we’re sort of slouched over or leaning from side to side, then there’s just kind of more congestion in the energy of the body. And with the back straight, then the mind’s much more alert and awake, attentive.

So the head should also be upright and then you can just tilt it forward slightly and you want to bring the gaze downward. This will help to diminish some of the discursive thought in the mind. And if you can, keep the eyelids just slightly open. That will allow a little bit of light in to once again keep the mind awake and alert. You can place the hands wherever they’re comfortable in your lap.

And this is probably enough in terms of our posture for now, just as long as we’re comfortable in this. So let’s just take a couple of deep breaths together, and as you breathe in, just feel every cell of your body expand, particularly those parts of the body that are tense. So we hold a lot of tension in the muscles in the face, around the eyes and the mouth, also in the neck and shoulders, and sometimes even in the chest and the abdomen. So as you inhale, just feel all of these areas filling up with the air that you’re breathing in. Then as you exhale, let all that tension out.

Just really relax the body in this upright posture. Again, let’s do this together, just breathing in really deeply And then exhaling, letting all the tension out. Again, inhaling, filling up every cell of the body, expanding, and then eventually letting go, breathing out, exhaling all that stress, tension, tightness in the body. And then one more time on your own, breathing in and then letting go of tension with the exhalation. When you’re done with this, just resume breathing normally.

So we’re going to begin as we usually do with just a few minutes of watching the breath. So we’ll learn a lot more about these various meditation techniques in the future, but the primary purpose of this is to begin to calm the mind, to diminish the amount of distraction that we have by bringing the mind to a single object. And the object in this case is the breath and particularly the sensation that you feel at the tip of the nose. So bring your awareness now as you’re breathing in and out through the nostrils to this very subtle sensation that occurs just inside the nose. It’ll be different for each of us, perhaps where we feel it.

But there’s sensation as the air comes in when we inhale, and then the sensation when we exhale. And just paying attention to that, beginning to hone in on that very subtle sensation. So for the next few minutes, what we want to do is to try to keep our mind there, just as if we’re training a dog to stay. Just gradually pay attention to the breath, moment by moment. But when we notice that the mind has wandered away, which we’re inclined to do, we have minds that aren’t perfect in terms of concentration.

So when we notice that all of a sudden we aren’t watching the breath, we’re thinking about what we need to buy at the grocery store later today, or what we need to do later in this week, or maybe we start recalling something that happened yesterday or last week, So many things will distract us, pull us away from watching the breath. And when we notice that, just let go of that. Don’t give that any more attention or energy. And then gently guide the mind back to the breath, back to that sensation at the tip of the nose. So we’ll do this for three or four minutes, just a short period of time.

I’ll ring the chime and then we’ll begin this breathing meditation. After that, I’ll lead you in a short meditation to set our motivation for being here today. So you can let go of watching the breath. I’d like to begin this meditation on setting our motivation by bringing up what we talked about last week. The very first thing, the definition of mind or consciousness.

So we talked about two elements, that the mind is clear. It’s in the nature of this mere clarity, meaning it’s nonmaterial, that it’s luminous, kind of reflecting the things that we experience. And also that mind has the function of knowing, making us aware of things, understanding, experiencing things. Imagine what it would be like to sort of rest in that natural state of the mind. Just kind of be in a state of pure awareness, clarity, luminosity, and seeing how a lot of the content of the mind, particularly those disturbing emotions, are really just like clouds passing through the sky of the mind.

And just as the clouds eventually dissipate or blown away, no longer appear, We can also be rid of all of these mental afflictions. And these mental afflictions, just like the clouds in the sky, don’t fundamentally change the nature of the sky. That the the clarity and the purity of the mind is kind of resting there even when the sky is entirely filled with clouds. So in setting our motivation for today, we can turn our attention towards this idea of freeing our mind from all of these disturbing clouds And the potential that each and every one of us has to do that, because we have a mind that is free of these innately, because we have a mind that has the potential to develop the positive qualities limitlessly, we can achieve those results. And so in your own heart now, turn your attention to that motivation or intention for being here, listening to these teachings on the nature of the mind and how we develop the potential of the mind so that we can do that, accomplish that result.

And in this way, help others to do the same thing, be a greater influence on their peace of mind, and help them to have all the qualities, all the happiness, all the peace that they seek. So good morning. Those of you who don’t know me, again, my name is Dondrub. I’m the resident teacher here at Tuśita Norbulingka. And we’re in the third class of Mind and Its Potential.

This is the first module of Discovering Buddhism. And it’s a really important one and I think one of the kind of a really inspiring module in some regard because we begin to look at what we’re all dealing with, which is the fact that we all have a mind. And mind, as we talked about last week and what I mentioned in the definition of mind in our meditation today, that mind has its own kind of entity that we can Although we can’t point at it, we can’t say, Oh, there’s your mind, we know of our mind because it’s with us all the time. Again, the definition that we used was mind is that which is mere clarity and awareness. That which is clear and knowing.

And in this way, when we talk about I didn’t mention this word last week so much, this word mere. Even His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, sometimes talks about how mind is in the nature of mere experience. What mere usually does in Buddhism is it kind of says, This is all that is required for it. There’s nothing else necessarily involved. And though, while with this human body we often see that our awareness or our consciousness is greatly dependent upon the brain and our physical senses, When we use the term mere, we mean that there is an element of consciousness that can abide without all of that.

So mind and matter, if you will, or mind and body, have interdependence, and we spoke about this quite a bit last week too, about how these are connected and related and how oftentimes have effects upon each other. But in the end, we can posit that there is an entity of awareness, consciousness, which has its own thread, which is independent at some level of the body. Now, again, last week’s class we also went into quite a discussion then on the theories in Western science as to the more materialistic theories in particular that make consciousness or awareness nothing more than a byproduct of having all this electrochemical stimulation in our brain and in our nervous system. And the Buddha would disagree with this idea that we’re simply aware of things as a byproduct of having a body that has all of this going on. That in essence, consciousness, though it is greatly linked with this body, as I’ve said earlier, has its own entity that runs from one moment to another.

And this was the other main idea that we talked about, the continuity of consciousness, that we can never find a beginning or an end to that. So if we were to posit from a Western science point of view that consciousness began when this physical body and brain were capable of having the electrochemical stimulation enough to produce awareness, well then this would mean that we have something that is non material, that is in that nature of clarity, arising from something that is material, purely. That that’s its main cause. And the Buddha would disagree with this, saying that there is a law of causality that runs through all phenomena. Just as we can posit again, last week it was the Gerber daisies that were here, this week we have some sunflowers.

So this sunflower didn’t arise from its own respective causes and conditions. The principal one, the substantial cause being the sunflower seed that gave rise to this flower that is appearing before us now. There were lots of other conditions involved in that. What we would say for consciousness is that there is a substantial cause, too. That substantial cause has to be in the fundamental nature of the experience of that in the present.

So just as a sunflower is arising from a sunflower seed that has kind of a similar essence to that, and all of the programming for producing a sunflower is within that seed. In the same way, our consciousness has its main cause, its substantial cause that has to be in the entity of consciousness or something extremely similar to it. We don’t find that consciousness can arise from something that is purely matter. All the other things help produce consciousness, just as water and sun and soil and so on help produce a sunflower. But all of those alone are not capable to produce a sunflower.

We need the substantial cause. The substantial cause is the main one, and assisted by all the other conditions. So in the same way, we would say that there has to be a mental moment that can certainly depend to some degree upon this brain, our five physical senses, but in its own way has its substantial cause of a previous moment of consciousness. So the moment right now was preceded by one just before that. That one by one before that.

That one by one before that. And this was the meditation that I passed out for everyone to work with and that we did in the meditation this morning together. So any questions on this idea or on doing this meditation? What was this experience like for you, those of you who had a chance to do this meditation? To kind of go back in time, recalling particular moments, seeing where that relationship and continuity is going back, and then going forward and kind of saying, well, what comes from here?

What if there is a stream of moments going forward, particularly when we get to death, and each of us will die, and what happens to our consciousness at that time? Any reflections or experiences from doing that? Yeah, Rita. I’ve done this before, and each time, I’m just interestingly struck by the fact that, you know, I can follow things after that. I quickly realize, wow, if I just go here instead of there, this is where I end up instead of myself.

In other words, if I’m following disturbing or negative mind, then I’m off someplace else that’s entirely different than than if I try to water some seeds that are a little bit more positive. Mhmm. I’m always struck by all the different directions that one can go in, that one mind can go Yeah. And in in the space of that, you’re still seeing kind of the connectivity between wherever it goes and wherever it has been, that that’s all part of one stream. Yeah.

Good, good. Yeah, Rowena? Well, I’m somewhat in the same vein as Rita because though I can distinguish successive moments, each moment seems to have so many components that you can bounce off in any direction. So, each tiny little dot of a mind moment has ten zillion things that branch into ten zillion things. It’s not very linear.

Right. Right. There’s absolutely no linear for me on that. I don’t know. I’m just hyperactive.

Yeah, I want to share a quote based on what Rowena said, because I think this is kind of a nice one. I was looking at this book yesterday, Consciousness at the Crossroads. I think I mentioned this one last week. A little bit heavier going as far as This was from one of the mind life conferences that His Holiness participated in. And he’s commenting here.

He says, According to Buddhist theory, there are some things that belong to subtle consciousness or subtle mind that are in dependence upon the body, from the brain. There is no assertion in Buddhism that there is a thing called a soul or a thing called consciousness. Some thing that exists independently of the brain. There is no such thing existing independently of the brain or being dependent upon the brain, but rather consciousness is understood as a multifaceted matrix of events. Some of them are utterly dependent on the brain, and at the other end of the spectrum, of them are completely independent of the brain.

There is no one thing that is the mind or the soul. I think that this is something we have to be cautious about in this whole course when we’re looking at mind. We’re not talking about an independent thing. We’re talking about, as he says here, this kind of matrix of events, this combination of things that has a wide spectrum to what we mean by mind or consciousness. So while there is this stream and we can pick apart these individual mental moments, even in an individual moment, there’s lots of complexity and richness to our minds.

We’re going to be talking about this in today’s class to some degree, but particularly next week’s class when we start sort of examining the Buddhist view of psychology of the mind and all the mental factors within the mind. You can sort of pick apart and isolate, but many of these are arising at the same time, making sort of for the richness of what we call experience. So that quote I mentioned earlier, it’s actually from the other book I’ve quoted from Mind Science. His Holiness, Dalai Lama, describes mind as an entity that has the nature of mere experience. So is there an experience without the mind?

What do we mean by experience? Can you have an experience without a mind? Get to be sounding quite identical. You know, when we talk about it being in the nature of mere experience, experiences, again, can have many facets to them. So this is, again, just to give some flavor to what we’re talking about, to not try tack down mind and say, Okay, here, I’ve gotten what it is.

But to rather be more open to all the various levels of the experience of mind, what that means. Comments on that? What that might mean for you? Any other comments on the meditation? Continuity of mind.

Or anything that we talked about last week. Again, we went into those three main subjects, kind of really defining what mind is and talking about it in terms of the Buddhist point of view, looking at the continuity of mind, and then looking at this mind body relationship. No? No questions? Okay.

Well, if you think of one, you can bring it up later. So today’s topic, if you look at the agenda for the class and the course outline, we have two things that we’re going to kind of touch on, and these actually take a little while to kind of get through because this is where we perhaps get a little more complicated in terms of looking at the mind. There is a much more traditional study of the mind that’s called Lorik. Lorik in Tibetan, lo means kind of mind. Rik has similar flavor, but we often define it as kind of awareness.

So that course is often called Mind and Awareness. It’s part of our Wednesday night program, the basic program, but we haven’t actually taught it here at Tuśita Norbulingka. It’ll probably be a while before we teach it. But it’ll probably occur sometime towards the end of next year or beginning of the year after. But this traditional study goes into, as I mentioned last week, what we might call the epistemology of the mind, how the mind works, and then the psychology of the mind, kind of the content of the mind and looking at how the content of the mind influences our experiences.

So this traditional study, again, can be quite complex, but I’m going to touch on some of the key elements of it to give you an appreciation for the way in which Buddhist study looks at the mind, but also to really look at the quite practical aspects of doing this. To pick apart how the mind works just for the sake of looking at the mind and saying, Oh, that’s how it works, isn’t really that relevant. But if we look at it and pick it apart and understand that this is how our minds are working, and we need to become more aware of how our minds are working, particularly when we join it with next week’s class, when we look at sort of the psychology of all of this, and really understanding that if we begin to take more control over our minds and what the processes that are going on in our minds, then we will have a much richer experience of life and of everything beyond this life. So one of the things I’d like to proceed this with is a little discussion about This is often thrown out in the meditation class, but I’m going to bring it up here as well, and I’ll revisit it in the meditation class.

But we can talk about how we are generating wisdom in our own minds. And this is a part of our process of engaging and discovering Buddhism. And even in this very first module, I would hope that even through the few classes that we’ve had, some wisdom has been gained. And we can talk about three levels of wisdom. And these really speak to some of the advice I gave last week, too, about how we need to be mindful of what we’re doing with the information that we get as we go through discovering Buddhism.

So the very first level of wisdom they call the wisdom that arises from hearing, listening. Or it could even be from reading. We get a lot of information by reading these days. In the past, texts weren’t quite so numerous, and so people mostly got their information through listening to someone teach that information. That’s the first level at which information or wisdom gets generated, when we begin to open our minds to what we’re hearing.

But if it stopped at that, if you kind of just took it in as raw data, and then could go tell your friends, Oh, I was at this Buddhist class. They said, Mind is that which is clear and knowing. And you just give them all these facts. Well, can you really speak to knowing that information? It’s one level of wisdom.

But the second level is where we begin to think about, to contemplate what we’ve learned. This is what I was really focusing on last week when, at the end of class, is how we need to not just take these teachings as something that we can file away and say, Oh, this is a wonderful thing to know. It’s only wonderful if you actually contemplate it and think about it and say, Well, what does this mean for me? What are these teachings about in terms of my own experience? So this second level is a very important one.

And even a lot of what we call meditation is that, is kind of looking at it and kind of beginning to digest. It’s like the continuity of consciousness meditation. And we looked at this idea last week, but then when you actually spend time with it yourself, thinking about it, examining it with your meditation, you find that this becomes reality for you a bit more. Well, then we talk about a third level, which is technically called wisdom arisen from meditation. So it’s not just hearing listening.

It’s not just thinking or contemplating, reflecting on it. It’s developing a really profound change in your mind through meditation. As I said, this is why we often bring this topic up in the second module on meditation, is because it’s with really deep meditation that we’re actually able to change our minds. But the other two are really important. If you haven’t heard things, thought about them, how can you possibly develop a deeper understanding of them through meditation?

So in today’s lecture, we will be touching back on this idea when we begin to look at the various ways that the mind can know, the ways that the mind can come to understand truth. Really, all of the Buddhist teachings, in essence, are about helping us to discern truth for ourselves. That’s why these three wisdoms are so important, is because we have to examine critically what we’re hearing through thought and contemplation, and eventually meditate on these topics in order to find the truth for ourselves. And once we do find that truth, the truth has an implication in terms of the ability for that truth. You know, they use this phrase, the truth will set you free.

Well, is very much an idea that is incorporated in Buddhist thinking. There is this big word called soteriology. We could say that there’s soteriological implications of Buddhism. Soteriology is often connected with theology in terms of an element of salvation involved. Well Buddhism, we don’t talk about the term salvation because salvation almost implies a savior, someone who’s going to save you from everything that you’re experiencing that’s unsatisfactory.

But it’s soteriological in terms of our own ability to free ourselves from what’s causing us pain, difficulty, problems, confusion. So these teachings, what I’m going to go into today, is within the context of understanding that there is this soteriological implication of what we’re looking at. That Buddhism, if we digest it through these three wisdoms and really incorporate it into our lives, has the ability to have a profound impact. Everything from a slight impact to a profound impact on your life, on your well-being, and on the well-being of others. So with this idea of looking at mind as central and key, we see that and that’s why, again, this idea of salvation isn’t really talked about, because we’re not looking at something outside of us to save us.

Buddhism is an inner science. It is one in which we look within our own minds and try to pick apart what is going on so that we are able to remove and diminish those tendencies that are causing us problems and difficulty, and increase the ones that are positive. This was, again, an idea we spoke about a bit last week. And we do see, and I’ll just remind everyone of what we talked about last week, that when it comes down to picking these apart, that the ones that are wholesome and good and a part of nourishing us are actually concordant with truth, with reality. Whereas the ones that cause our mind to be disturbed, that cause us to not have a satisfactory experience and to even feel confused and disillusioned, are actually in discord with reality.

So again, this will be something we’ll explore more next week when we look at the psychology. But I think it is important that we understand that everything kind of is intended to help us to develop our own minds, to use this as inner scientists to look within and try to solve all the problems that we’re experiencing within our own minds. As I said last week, this is totally opposite to how we normally go about living our lives. Most people, ourselves included, are really fixated with trying to get everything on the outside into a proper place. The right person in our lives for a relationship, the right job, the right home, the right city to live in, the right this, right that, thinking that if we get all those pieces correct, we like win.

You know, there’s some great prize from having done that. But we find that the prize is rather elusive. And the satisfaction we might gain from it can be there, but it can be quite temporary. Why? In part because all of this is constantly changing.

But the Buddha says at a deeper level the reason why is because we haven’t really looked at the true sources of those feelings of happiness and contentment, that they’re actually within us. So I want to quote from Geshe Tashi Sering, a wonderful Geshe who teaches at our center in London, Jamyang Buddhist Centre, is it called? Jamyang Buddhist Centre, I think. He’s actually coming just so you know, he’s coming again next year for a Lam Rim they call it Kopan West. We have a Kopan monastery outside of Kathmandu that does a Lam Rim retreat for a month, a really big one that’s from mid November to mid December.

But a lot of people can’t get to Kathmandu to do this type of retreat. Geshe Tashi’s been coming. He came last year, and he’s coming again next year and doing a two week Lamrim retreat at Vajrapāni, our sister center in Boulder Creek, California. I highly recommend him. He’s a wonderful guide and teacher.

He has a book that’s on Buddhist psychology. And he says Buddhism is an inner science because everything the Buddha taught, and hence everything within the Buddhist canon, is meant to help us relieve suffering and achieve happiness, and that only happens through the mind. So again, this is just a prelude to what we’re going to get into in terms of looking at, you know, what we are about in our minds, how the mind is functioning, and then what the content of our minds are, which is next week’s subject. So what I’d like to start with, any questions before we Okay, let’s go ahead and pass out the handout that we’re going to be working with for the rest of today, as well as for a good portion or some part of next week. Maybe send that around.

And then send some that way. Now there are a few things on this handout that we probably are not going to get into in that much detail, in part because this might be kind of beyond the scope of this course. This handout was developed for Module One, but there’s obviously quite a bit on here that we won’t really have time to get into in this class, but I will touch on most of what’s on here. Let me see one other thing. Yeah, that one I’ll read after we get into this.

So over on the left hand side, everyone has a copy? Did it make its way all the way back? It’s not quite there yet? Okay. Good.

Yeah, if there’s any extra copies, can just set them aside and we’ll collect them up during the break. So what I’m going to start with is talking about most of what’s over on the left hand side and the top of the left hand side. First of all, you will see that there is kind of this definition of mind given there. Mind is that which is clear and knowing. Again, knowing refers to the subjective awareness or experience of an object.

Clear refers to the formless nature of the mind and is what gives rise to the appearances of experiences of phenomena, the kind of luminous quality of the mind. We’re sort of reflecting what we’re knowing. Sometimes they might even talk about the mirror like quality of the mind. The mind is simply a whiteboard upon which other things are projected. So most of what I’m going start with is this idea of kind of main mind being divided into three different levels.

Mental factors is mostly what we’re going to talk about at the very end of class today and then go into next week, because the mental factors get more to kind of how the mind is functioning with regard to various objects, and so that speaks more of the psychology of the mind. But when we talk about main mind here, we’re talking about kind of the holder of our various experiences, that kind of blank canvas upon which all of the experiences occur. And we speak in general about consciousness in terms of six different levels, and that’s what we mean by the gross up here. So when you see that there is a gross consciousness that’s divided into mental consciousness and then the five sensory consciousnesses, this is the grosser level of mental consciousness. Everything you see below it where it says subtle and very subtle are actually still part of the mental consciousness, but they are subtler levels of mind that we can sort of experience at various times, but are sort of underneath the current of what we’re experiencing.

His Holiness of Dalai Lama, and before I go back to this, I do want to share this was, again, from one of the Mind Life conferences a book called Destructive Emotions. And in it he says, When we say various levels of consciousness, it’s not like three streams running in parallel, like you have separate streams. Over here is your gross mind. Over here is your subtle mind. Here’s your very subtle mind.

Rather, it’s like the ocean with its different depths. So emotions concern the gross and the subtle level, but do not affect the most subtle one. So it’s sort of like the waves at the top of the ocean are the grossest level of mind that we’re working with. And this is where most of us hang out pretty much every minute of the day, is kind of in this very gross, discursive, wavy level of the mind, with all the various things that arise there. Then we have kind of a going deeper into the ocean a little bit, kind of the subtler levels of mind.

And then when you get to the very depths of the ocean, you have the subtlest level of mind. So as I was telling this, they could be compared to waves on the surface of the ocean, all these emotions, while the fundamental nature of the mind corresponds to the ocean’s depth. So this is the reality of our experience, is that while we have kind of this thread of a very subtlest level of mind, that as it’s identified on this sheet, the mind of clear light, We’re going talk about this in a later class. This isn’t something I want to touch on too much today. But that’s kind of underneath the surface all the time.

It’s just like the stillness of the ocean while we’re sort of bobbing around on the waves at the top. But what we have to acknowledge is that that is sort of capable of being tapped into. But it’s only in our life probably certain times that we’re going to experience that. And so for now, it’s not as relevant. And again, I will talk about this in one of the classes yet in this module, where we kind of identify these deeper levels of mind as being really key to some of the Buddha’s main teachings as to how we are capable of becoming enlightened.

But at the grosser level, when we talk about this gross level being divided into six consciousnesses, we are again talking about still something that, you know, we can pick apart and find some great value to looking at. We don’t have to go down to these subtler levels of mind to begin to work with the mind. And actually, we’re going to have a harder time doing that if we haven’t learned to work with the grosser level of the mind. We have to hang out on the surface and get more control so that there’s not as many waves, not as much emotion, and then we actually can tap into some of these subtler levels. So let’s talk about these six.

When we talk about the five sense consciousnesses, as I mentioned last week, these are very much dependent upon the body, right? If we don’t have properly functioning eyes, there’s no way we can have visual consciousness. If we don’t have ears that are capable of registering vibrations and so on, then we won’t have the ability to have an ear consciousness. And the same can be said for our taste, for our touch, for our smell. All of these are dependent upon physical organs.

When it comes to mental consciousness, though, you know, this is sort of like the processor, if you will, if you want to talk in computer terms. This is your CPU. This is, you know, what is going on as you’re taking in various data from the five sense consciousnesses, as well as processing data and thinking about things yourself. The mental consciousness is kind of in this state of not necessarily working with a physical basis and with the relationship to physical matter. Now, certainly we do think a lot about physical things.

It’s not to say that that’s outside of the picture of what we mean by mental consciousness. But what happens in particular is mental consciousness has access to so many other things that the visual consciousness doesn’t have, that the ear consciousness doesn’t have, and so on. And that’s because we have the capability of using thought processes and experiencing things through our conceptual mind. Now I’m not equating conceptual mind here with mental consciousness, but for most of us right now, this is the majority of what we do with our mental consciousness, is we think about things. We use conception.

So if you go to the other side here, to where it says mental consciousness, it’s divided into perception and conception. This is to point out the fact that while just what I just said, that most of what we deal with is conception, thinking, thought processes, we actually do have an ability to use perception. So what is the distinguishing factor between these two types of awareness when we talk about kind of two ways of knowing? Perception is what all of our sense consciousnesses are doing all the time. So when I have a perception with my eye consciousness of the blue of the Medicine Buddha there, the blue color of the Medicine Buddha, I am knowing that directly through what we call perception.

There is a color blue that is appearing to my eye organ that is being processed by my eye consciousness and seeing it as blue. Now, the thought of it as blue is a whole another level of knowing, and that’s where we bridge over into what we call conception. So while perception is simply the direct information, the data we’re getting, that comes in through our various sense consciousnesses. Conception is the thinking about those. Now, the point of kind of dividing mental consciousness into both perception and conception is to show that we actually do even have an ability within our minds to know things more directly.

But as I said earlier, most of what we know in our mental consciousness, most of what we experience, we’re experiencing through thought, through conception. So you again, we’ll get to kind of what the point of a lot of this is. But let’s look at kind of these two ways of knowing in a little bit more detail. Geshe Rabten, who’s written a book that we use for Lorik for the study of mind and awareness, A book called The Mind and Its Function says, Perception is essentially a receptive, non reflective form of cognition, whereas conception is responsive and reflective. So let me read that again.

Perception is essentially receptive and non reflective, whereas conception is responsive and reflective. So we’re kind of talking about two different ideas here. One is receptive, meaning that when we are in a perceptual mode, we’re just receiving things. As I mentioned earlier, the blue of that medicine Buddha. My eye consciousness simply receiving it in this perceptual way.

Whereas, if I start thinking about blue, if I start thinking about the blue of that Medicine Buddha and go, maybe that blue should be a little bit darker, or maybe comparing it to other things, well then what’s happening is I’m reflecting on it. I’m taking my raw data and processing it, analyzing it, comparing it, distinguishing it, discerning qualities about it. These are all the roles of conception, whereas perception is simply taking things in rawly, receiving things. So then to the second part of that, where it says that the one is non reflective, where the other one is reflective. Perception is non reflective in that when I simply take the data in, there’s no reflection going on.

But the reflection happens almost instantly when my conceptual mind takes over and begins to think about what I’m experiencing. Well, there’s one more element that’s kind of key to understanding the distinguishing features of conception, this thinking mind. And that’s the way in which conception works with all of these objects. So let’s go back to this blue. So as I said, when my eye consciousness sees that blue, that blue, that raw data, is appearing in a form that there’s nothing kind of in between that.

So it’s sort of like, you know, if I take my glasses off, I’ve got just a direct perception of it. But once I put on my glasses and I have my conceptual mind involved in it, then I’m sort of trying to relate to the object, but I’m not even seeing that it’s through the lens of my glasses. And in the same way, when I start dealing with things conceptually, I begin to work with them with something in between. And what we call this is sort of a generic image or mental image, meaning generality. There’s lots of translations for this term.

Yulchen is the term, I think, in Tibetan. No, I’m sorry. Yulchen is for object. Anyway, I have to look that up. But the idea here is that if I asked you all, for example, to think about your mother of this life, you know, the person who raised you as your mother, you know, we have an image in our mind of that person.

Are we knowing our mother directly at that point? No. Because our mother probably isn’t here in the room with us. Maybe some people have their mother in the room. I don’t think so.

But our mother of this life, you know, is an image that we’ve created in our mind that we can work with conceptually. Just as I could say, I mean, if we’ve all looked up at that medicine Buddha, the blue color, ask you to think about that blue color now. Are you knowing that blue color directly? You’re working with it, and it’s not necessarily incorrect in terms of the object that you’re getting at. But it is sort of mistaken in that all of a sudden you’ve taken what you experienced directly and made it into something that you’re working with indirectly.

You know, all of a sudden you’ve got this mental image, something coming between you and your direct experience of the object. And this makes our conceptual mind, to some degree, what we might call mistaken or erroneous, but it doesn’t mean that all of our conceptions are mistaken or erroneous. And this is an implication that we’re going to look at shortly. But again, the idea here is that you are always, whenever you are engaging in thought processes, working with some sort of mental image of that. Now I used a visual image here, but I could use an auditory image just as easily, right?

Most of us, I think, are familiar with the opening notes of Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony. Right? It’s coming to mind right now, okay, for most of us. If you don’t, then think about your favorite song. But you can have an auditory image in your mind.

You can have, are you knowing the sound of that directly? No. You are working with your own remembrance of that. It is somewhat recollection, but the idea is that that is your thought image for that. That is kind of how you’re relating to it.

So this is already speaking to the fact that, again, we are blocked from directly knowing the object, but as this chart points out, we do have an ability, through our mental consciousness even, to know things directly. And that is why perception is listed here, and I’m going to talk about kind of these levels of perception a little bit later in class today. But what I’d like to move to now to further kind of give some flavor to the distinguishing features between perception and conception is to go down to what’s on the lower right hand side of your chart there where it says conditions for awareness. So what we’ve been talking about in the past, in the last class when we kind of were talking about the substantial cause for consciousness, in effect what we could do is say that that is really this immediate cause. There are three levels of causes here, as everyone can see: object, base, and immediate.

So the immediate cause means that the only the main reason why you are having a consciousness right now of any particular thing is because immediately before it you’ve had another moment of consciousness. And immediately before that, another one, and so on. We did that last week in terms of looking at that continuity. But most importantly, if you were to, for example, let’s start with the eye consciousness, observing the blue of the Medicine Buddha on the Tanca there, the painting. The object that is appearing to you is the blue color.

Okay? So that’s pretty straightforward. The base is the sense organ. Now, Buddhist sinking, they say that actually even within the sense organ, there’s this very subtle matter which is what empowers you to be able to utilize that sense organ. Now in Western science, would say that this is kind of a silly idea, that actually the reason why the eye works is because light is reflected in.

You’ve got your retina and your cornea and all these other parts. I don’t know anything about the eye. Not an ophthalmologist. I think when Steve was here, Steve Walker was here, he was explaining some of it. But basically, the idea is that you do have some physical matter involved in here that we call a base.

And that physical matter allows or empowers you that’s often called the empowering condition rather than the base condition to be able to know that color blue, that object. On the other hand, then, again, the immediate condition is the fact that you’ve had some moment of consciousness prior to this. And it could be an auditory consciousness, it could be listening to me, and then all of a sudden you look up at that and you see the blue of the Medicine Buddha. But that prior moment of mind is always needed. So this is said to be exhaustive in terms of the conditions that are required for a single moment of awareness.

In this case, it was a moment of our eye consciousness knowing the color blue. Does everyone get that? You think of a condition that’s outside of this? I mean, do you need a fourth condition for there to be an eye consciousness apprehending blue or becoming aware of blue? Okay, so it seems pretty exhaustive, these three conditions.

We need an object, the color blue in this case. We need some sort of sense organ that will allow us to have that perception. And then we need a previous moment of consciousness. So at the moment of death, when our consciousness is incapable of sustaining that, then we wouldn’t have that immediate condition. So while we might still feel like we’ve got an eye organ there and there’s plenty of objects, we no longer have that immediate condition that allows us to know any of those phenomena.

Let’s talk about this in regard to conception. Okay. Well, first let’s of pull back a little bit in terms of look at it as thought when I’m thinking about the blue that I’m experiencing through this process of kind of looking at the Medicine Buddha, seeing the blue, and then I begin to think about it. Well, we can say that the color blue is still an object condition. Though for most of us, again, as soon as we experience that, it immediately bridges over into conception, and we begin to think about that object that we’ve experienced.

So in a sense, we could say that the object condition here, while it is the blue that we experienced, could even be the mental image of blue. You know, what is appearing to our thought consciousness. But in terms of when we’re thinking about blue, you know, again, there’s an object that we’re experiencing, but the thought of blue is entertaining a different object. This is the point of kind of understanding conceptual mind. But all of our levels of mental consciousness aren’t really dependent upon a base condition.

What would be the basis for a mental consciousness? You might think, well, it’s the brain or the nervous system in some degree, but in essence, in Buddhism, we say that there is no object or no base condition for our mental consciousness, because mental consciousness is simply an arrival of a moment of consciousness in dependence on a previous moment, and doesn’t require an eye organ, nose organ, and so on. We don’t need those physical organs in order to experience our mental consciousness. Just as I said, I could ask you to think about your mother of this life. There’s nothing that’s needed in terms of a physical organ to do that.

You simply are bringing it to mind, and that image is appearing. So in essence, for mental consciousness, both of these end up being the same. Again, whether we’re talking about conceptual or perceptual, either type of knowing, the base and the immediate consciousness or immediate condition are the same. So again, understanding this and people might go start scratching their head and saying, Well, why are we going here? Why are we looking at this?

What is this about? Well, it’s, again, beginning to understand the processes that are involved so that we can delineate more clearly what’s going on in our mental consciousness and what’s going on in our sense consciousnesses. Most of what we find when we begin to generate some of this awareness is that while our sense consciousnesses are certainly kind of part of the picture, and we’re experiencing all sorts of things in this world, there are lots of tastes and lots of smells and lots of visual things that entertain us, lots of auditory stimuli that we can partake of. What is mostly going on is that our conceptual mind is working with all of that stuff. And our conceptual mind functions in a slightly different way.

Our conceptual mind, again, has this coming out of just a mere experience of the moment before, not really dependent upon any of these physical organs, and furthermore has this meaning generality, this way of kind of placing something between us and the raw experience of that object. And the implications of this are, you know, pretty major. So what they say when this occurs so let’s go back to the blue. First, any questions on this so far? Because I realize I’ve just gone through a whole bunch of information in a very quick time.

Yeah, Claudia. You might come to this later, but it seems there’s a time gap in information that we work with between perceptual and conceptual. That time gap is potentially go your separate ways. You’re still upset. Then that person and you’re maintaining the conception of that person.

Right. Right. And then you walk away and you go, it wasn’t that was a good action. Regret They moved on and corrected it. If you could perceive that and maintain, then you would have released it.

Conceptual minds can lead us into false ideas about other people or situations or those time gaps could be an It definitely is. And I think to kind of add to that, what they say is that this image that we have again, it’s not just a visual type of thing. It can be, again, an experience that we’re recalling. It can be a sound that we’ve heard, what have you. That we sort of fix that.

It becomes somewhat unchanging in our mind until there’s new data that changes that. So for most of us, when I use this idea of kind of recalling your mother of this life, you probably have a mental image of your mother that is somewhat fixed, that’s somewhat static in terms of recalling a moment of the past of your mother, perhaps even the last time that you experienced your mother. And that’s the image that you sort of hold to. And while we can certainly think that there are changes in that, every time we bring up another moment, in a sense, is working with something that is still quite static. And so to what Claudio is saying, what happens is when we start conceptualizing around what we experience, we create sort of fixed ideas in our mind about what things are.

And those ideas, we then sort of continue to live with. And we don’t ever sort of change them unless there’s new data, as I said, that sort of comes in. We run into this person that we had this horrible experience with, and our mind is still thinking, Here’s this person that wronged me, and so on. And then they’re totally in a different space. And then we maybe are forced to reevaluate that and kind of go, well, am I ready to sort of let that image go and start to see this person in a new way, or do I still need to hold on to my conception of who they were based on that prior experience?

So there is definitely a role that time plays in it in terms of what happens is, although it’s quite fluid and time is constantly moving and changing, and we’re all constantly moving and changing, this is the Buddha’s law of subtle impermanence, that it’s just an observation that the Buddha has made, that everything is constantly changing. When we develop conceptions or ideas, they’re quite fixed. They are removed from that process of time and stand still. Then we work with that until, again, we get a new image. Then we replace that one, we throw that one away, we’ve got a new image of that person or that event.

Then we go forward and maybe something else changes and so on. Yeah, John? Well, yeah. How is it the aggregation of a long history of sense perceptions? Yeah, you know, I don’t know if that the question was ever entertained in any of the studies I’ve looked at about where does conception conception come from?

We simply are I suppose in this study of the mind, we simply are acknowledging that this is a way that our mental consciousness knows that is unique to mental consciousness. It’s a valid distinction, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I think it’s just sort of the way that it is. But, you know From the nature of existence.

Yeah. Because we would even posit that other sentient beings have conceptual minds, too. I mean, certainly we know. I found it kind of curious. I was looking further in this book, Consciousness at the Crossroads, and some scientists seem to kind of question whether animals can have a conceptual mind.

And I find that kind of radical to think that they don’t, Because we know that they have some images of their master, for example, of a dog. They react to that sound of a voice or the visual presence of that person in response to a conceptual idea that they’ve carried forward of that person. Know, just as when they hear a particular sound, like my dog always gets really excited when the UPS truck arrives on the street somewhere. Whenever she hears it pull up, she just starts barking like crazy. Well, she’s got a meaning generality of the sound of UPS truck that causes a trigger that makes her bark.

You know? My dog has the same thing. Maybe it’s just UPS trucks. So yeah, I don’t know kind of I would just say that this is, again, just the way that it works, that we do have a mental consciousness that tends to lean on the side of conceptual experience. But not to say that we can’t have a more perceptual direct experience, but just that this is how our minds have learned to function and process things in the world.

That leads to perception, to the nature of the mind. Yeah, yeah, Definitely. Yeah, let me go to Steve first. I’m speculating as to where we’re headed with this. You’re one of the people that opens the book to the last page and reads it.

Just kidding. Yeah. I mean, can jump to that at this point and kind of begin to talk. But let hold on to that and see what the other comments, because I don’t want to get too far away from what we’re currently talking about. Now let’s go with Judith.

I don’t even know if this makes any sense, but if someone’s color blind, how would you have this conversation? About blue? Particularly? Not Beetho. Yeah, well, I mean, I’m thinking of people who don’t have hearing, don’t have sight.

Or yesterday, I said something to this mechanic about I love the color of my car. And he said, I have no idea what color it is. I’m colorful. Right, right. How do we teach this when people have different obstacles?

Well, again, I don’t think that it requires someone to have fully functional sense faculties for them to understand this kind of distinction between the unique way that mental consciousness works in terms of conception and the quite limited way, to some degree, that sense consciousness works in terms of only perception. So if you were working with somebody who was color blind, you would simply speak to them about auditory stimuli. And if you were talking to somebody who couldn’t hear, you would simply point out to them visual stimuli. But I don’t think there’s a single I can’t imagine a single human being who has no sense consciousnesses whatsoever. I mean, even if you had some damage to your taste and smell and sight and hearing, you’d still have a body consciousness that has some tactile sensation.

Now, how you’d communicate with somebody who has only tactile sensation would probably be pretty difficult, I suppose. I mean, look at the movie Miracle Worker with Helen Keller, who was quite limited in terms of her ability to process data from the outside world with sense consciousnesses. So how is this conversation about perception and consciousness, how does that help me become a better bloomer? Well, that’s what I’m kind of getting to in terms of Yeah, yeah. Everyone has to be just a little more patient.

I don’t want to be patient. No, it’s interesting because this whole idea I mean, if I go to my own experience in studying low rick many, many years ago, I found it at times to be, yeah, kind of a dry exercise. Sort of like picking this apart and going, Okay, well, this is how the eye knows. This is how the ear knows, and so on. You kind of get this sort of somewhat removed from the relevancy of it all.

And when it comes down to it, when we talk about our sense perceptions and the fact that they’re all direct, this is only really to point out, as I see it, the contrast that we have with conception. Because when it comes down to it, the sense faculties in and of themselves, in that they’re just sort of taking in this raw data, is just the way it is. It’s sort of like, again, all this is just simply stimuli that are coming in. But how I am thinking about these things is really the key. So the only reason kind of going into that direction and kind of pointing it out was to provide the contrast with how conceptual mind works, which, again, already has kind of its own little domain that it’s in that isn’t dependent upon kind of receiving data through physical organs.

Plus, it’s always working with something that is not quite the object already to begin with. It’s an idea of the object. So let me go to what Tukten Yeshe says. Tukten Yeshe is the I mentioned her previously. She’s the woman who taught the mind and its potential home course, home study course for discovering Buddhism. And she teaches in Australia.

She’s a I met her once or twice before. Really good teacher. She says, You are unable well, first I want to talk about what happens before I go to this quote is that what they say happens is that your mind actually kind of mixes your idea of the object with the object itself. So as my eye consciousness perceives that blue, it then, when I start thinking about it, when I start having my conceptual mind involved, I’m sort of mixing the two and not really seeing any difference between them. And I’m sure for most of us, if we’ve never heard this idea before, we didn’t think there was any difference between them, right?

You thought that the blue that you’re thinking about is the same blue that you’re seeing, and the sound that you’re thinking about is the same sound that you heard. Well, they’re mixed in our mind to the point where, once again, we hold the one to be the other. We hold the idea of that object to be that object. And and Tukten Yeshe says, You are unable, under normal circumstances, to separate your projection from the object itself. You cannot discriminate the objective reality from your own subjective opinions and projections made on the basis of an image you have created yourself.

So you, in your conceptual mind, created an image about Let’s move away from blue, because the blue of the Medicine Buddha we’re probably not going to have a whole lot of feelings about. Let’s go to a person that we know. And a person has got a lot of elements to our experience of them. We see what they look like. We might hear what they say.

We might have other ways of experiencing them in the world. But we create an image of who that person is. So think about maybe not trying to raise any emotions on this, but think about the most difficult person you have in your life right now. You know, somebody who really pushes your buttons. Maybe you’re fortunate and don’t have anybody like that, but even think about a political candidate who pushes your buttons, you know, or somebody in office who pushes your buttons, or, you know, a public figure of some sort of celebrity who you can’t stand, who you don’t like.

Well, you have a mental image of that person that you have mixed in your own experience of that, however you’ve come to know that person, with the object, that person, and you think that that’s who they are. You have a projection based on your own thought processes. So what does that do then? That forces you, every time that you think about them, to think about them in that particular way. As we were pointing out with Claudio’s example, we have an interaction with somebody, we create an image of them as being, Ugh, this person’s horrible, disgusting, I can’t stand them.

And we carry that image day in, day out. That’s our thought of them. That’s our projection of them. Is that who they are? What would be the ramifications I mean, the proof, really, that they aren’t that?

Katherine was saying no. So what’s the proof that Those are always changing. We’re never the same. This is true. What would be another way of proving it?

Because other people like that person. Exactly. People don’t like that person. Yeah. So this is a really important thing to understand, is that even though we might have a mental image of so and so as being this negative person, if they really were that person, every single person that knows them would see them in the same way, right?

So we see this is our own creation. This projection is something we are doing through our conceptual mind. That our conceptual mind takes this image that we receive, all this raw data through our senses, and processes it into our own idea of who that person is. And that idea of who that person is is how we relate to that person, how we think about them, how we have emotions about them. So the conceptual mind is playing a pretty major role in terms of really shading and giving flavor to what we are experiencing.

Our thoughts are what get us into trouble. You know, spoke last week about and I touched on it a little bit earlier today about kind of how we can validate or invalidate certain states of mind by what they are doing, whether they are in accord with things or whether they are in discord with things. So last week I had that quote from His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, that basically said that the mind of anger is not a valid mind. Or hatred. I think he used the word hatred.

Whereas he said the mind of love is a valid mind. Now both of them are conceptions, right? So you can have a conception of hating someone. You can have a conception of loving someone. So what is the difference between those two types of conceptions?

The conception of hating someone is looking at that person, taking what is negative, and exaggerating it, making it more important than anything you might happen to see that’s even remotely positive. And you are making that person into a horrible person that you have complete justification for hating. Is that in accord with reality? Just as we saw Catherine’s answer, not everybody sees them as a hateful person. There are people who love that person, people who care about that person.

So that means that we’re missing something. We have focused on something that is only a piece of the picture, elevated it to this important status, made them into a hateful person, and that’s the conception we carry around. That’s the idea that we have, the mental image for that person. And we create a mental conception towards them of hating them. We create all of our own problems within our own mind.

Whereas, if we choose to take that person in their totality, look at them in terms of understanding, Yes, this person said these hurtful words to me. Yes, this person did this particular thing that I don’t like. But this person also can be seen in many different dimensions, can be seen as someone who does have people that they care about, that they tend to, that they are kind to. And so many different experiences that maybe we aren’t directly seeing, but we can, you know, with a little bit of research, find out that that person doesn’t have just horrible qualities. I think Venerable Rubina’s point, I mean, even Adolf Hitler, you know, loved his dog.

We might vilify somebody like Adolf Hitler and make him into an inherently evil person. But he loved his dog, and he loved the people around him, and they probably loved him. There’s a trick set of questions when you’re dealing with a history class of putting out a list of qualities of person A, B, C, D. And so many people will think Hitler is a positive person. Because of his love of animals.

He was a vegetarian. I mean, all these things are so hip, you know? But it has nothing to do with what Hitler did or who he was, whereas you have some other people that are popular in history for a variety of reasons that have characteristics that are completely, completely unpleasant. And it just depends which characteristic you think. Yeah.

Yeah, so we see that it’s, you know, we filter. We look at things through our own experience in terms of our conceptual mind and what that raw data coming in, and how it interprets it, how it looks at it, and chooses to look at things in a particular way. Now, again, I’m using this term choose in a really kind of a loose way, because we’re not using much choice at all. We’re simply continuing to see things in the way that we’ve always seen them. We’re not making much choice, we’re just continuing that sort of distorted way of looking at things.

This is why, again, when I was delineating these two types of mind a mind of hatred, a mind of love. The mind of love is actually quite concordant with things, and is a choice we can make at that time. We can choose to have love for Adolf Hitler. Why? Because we can see Adolf Hitler as a suffering sentient being, who, at the very, very base level, simply wants to be happy and doesn’t want to suffer.

And that’s what the thought of love is. I would, you know and I mentioned Osama bin Laden last time. You know, I would love for Osama bin Laden to be happy. He would probably do a whole lot less in the world to harm others if he was happy. I would love for all my enemies to be happy.

This is the attitude that is actually concordant with things, because it’s simply observing all these beings, whatever their situation, as being in a state of lacking real happiness and wishing for them to have that. So there’s nothing wrong with that state of mind. And it’s a conception as well. It’s not the conception we usually choose, though. It’s a conception we have to learn to have in our own minds.

Yeah, Rowena? Well, you’re talking about the Dalai Lama’s objective, compassionate love. You’re not talking about attachment at all. Right. Correct.

And I’m going through this disappearance of my son because he’s right there all the time. He’s not right there all the time. Thank you. So whatever I’m feeling is just completely conceptual at this point. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. And if they’re they’re pleasant or unpleasant, it’s it’s it’s a form of love, but it’s not the Dalai Lama’s objective. Yeah, yeah. It’s not either.

Yeah. No, and I think an understanding of kind of the way that the mind’s working can help us, particularly in times when things are difficult, because we can begin to understand how we have a choice in the moment as to what types of conceptions we want to propagate in the mind. And, you know, sometimes we won’t have a lot of control over it. You know, when we deal with loss, oftentimes grief just kind of rears its head. And we can pick grief apart, though, even, and understand the components of grief that are quite healthy, and the components of grief that maybe are unhealthy.

But, you know, I think an awareness of the conceptual mind the way that the conceptual mind works is really key in Buddhist thinking. And I’m going put up on the board when we come back after break kind of the process that the Buddha taught as to how we can move away from what we would call sort of the wrong way of thinking to even this level of mental perception of truth, of reality, of what is in accord with the way things are, both conventionally and ultimately. Yeah, Israel, you had your hand up earlier. Well, I’m just kind of fondling the idea of anger and love are on the opposite ends of the spectrum, but particularly makes love a more valid delusion. Well, first I would call love not a delusion.

I would call love a virtuous state of mind. No, that’s an opinion. That’s conceptual. Absolutely. But what how are you defining love?

Well, okay. Let’s define awareness. A previous moment of awareness? This is like this doesn’t make sense. And that’s a jump of faith.

Well, but we talk about what we mean by awareness, mind, consciousness are all equivalent. And we define them as that which is clear and knowing. Yeah, and you’re gonna put love in that list, too? Well, love is a specific type of awareness, but it is a conceptual thought, yeah. I mean, it’s just conceptual, correct?

Think. But I guess, again, I would ask you, how do you define love? Well, I’m not answering that. But I’m not sure what you’re asking. That’s the is that I’m wondering if love is a conceptual just as much as anger or hatred.

I’m not denying that they’re all conceptions. I’m saying that there are conceptions that are in accord with reality, and there are conceptions are in discord. That means just as true. That’s giving them value. They’re valid.

Well, so how does it get valid as opposed to anger not being valid? By doing the analysis and understanding that it is in accord with how things are. How would you I guess the question is, how would you validate hatred? Well, I mean, I’m just Or invalidate love, for that I’m just saying. I’m just you know, it’s a conceptual thing.

But I think you’re I mean, I can appreciate what you’re saying, Israel, but I have the feeling that, again, it’s you’re getting stuck in yes, they are conceptual things. They are sort of mistaken in their own way by being conception, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t valid conceptions and invalid conceptions. They are inferential as we’re going see when we come back, inferential cognition is a perfectly fine way to understand what is correct and what is incorrect, what is valid and what is invalid. I think this comes down to, yeah, mean, the end, we can talk about the results of these states of mind, and what the Buddha is challenging us with is that there are unique results to these states of mind. The results are not uniform.

You can experience huge pain out of something you’d call love. Know, love is not always just your bond. Yeah. But again, I think that the Buddha would say I can’t speak for the Buddha necessarily, but my feeling is the Buddha would say that if it is genuine love, there is no way that the result of love is pain. So I think one of the problems that we have that’s one conception.

One of the problems that we always have with a lot of this, and this is the topic that we’re going to touch on in, I think, the fifth class, is the role of karma in all of this. Because we are really quite intent on thinking that the most immediate experience that we’re having is a result of what we are doing, and that’s not necessarily the case. So you might be having me see if I can find an example. I’ll think about an example during the break. But the idea is that your own individual experience at the moment, you might try to relate to what your state of mind is.

You know, for example, if you have a genuine thought of love towards somebody, and they call you, you know, some dirty name or something on the basis of that generating that thought towards them, does that mean that you’re experiencing the pain of those harsh words towards you because you generated love? The Buddha would say that these are two different isolated events, that your generating love for that person has its own positive result, while that receiving the harsh words from them was a result of something else that you did in the past that was not in accord with love, that was actually hateful. So again, karma plays another role in this that we’ll examine in the fifth class. I don’t want to go too far into that, because that’s so there’s a lot of shades of what you’re talking about that I think are worth exploring, and I’m not in any way denigrating what you’re saying because I think this is an important thing to look This is an important thing to look at, is kind of really understanding. Because the Buddha says and this is, you know, here are my notes here.

It says, you know, conception itself is not the problem. What we have to do is discern what conceptions are healthy and good for us and others versus what conceptions are simply taking us down the toilet. Okay. Yeah, Rowena. We get so fixed around the terms, but you’ve got to remember that anger or hatred and attachment are both on the same level.

And the love that’s being talked about isn’t on that level. It’s on a very objective level. And so you’re not hanging in there and clutching it or bouncing off of something. So it’s different. But I think you need to be clear.

You’re talking about attachment then. Yeah, I’m talking about attachment as being on the same level. Attachment, we call love attachment all the time. Well Or we call attachment love all the time. And that’s where they don’t seem very different.

Mhmm. Say, I love you. Well, I’m attached to you. Well, great. But that isn’t the love that we’re talking about in this particular instant.

I don’t think it’s so much an an objective, you know, thinking process that checks out how everything is. It’s not the kind of love that, you know, I love my dog. Yeah. But it’s not Right. That that’s Well, and this is why I have to quote Venerable Rabina again.

She says, Buddhism is very precise. And I think we have to keep going back to that precision. When I use the word love, and I generally try to define it, it’s a very precise attitude and conceptual mind. It is the wish for one’s own or another’s happiness and well-being and the causes of that happiness. So, you know, it’s not attachment.

It’s not about kind of, What am I getting from you? I love you because you do all sorts of wonderful things for me. I mean, this is the way we use the term love in Western culture, because we confuse attachment with love. So once again, all these discussions are all great, but they go back to we have to be quite precise in what we’re talking about and make sure that we understand these concepts so that we can utilize them in our lives. And this is a conception.

I mean, conception’s about conception. We’re thinking about conception, and there’s nothing wrong with that. We actually have to start thinking about conception, or we’re never going to use our conception well. Bring up last year, which clarified it for me. And I’m not gonna get the warning right, but it’s like, yes, hatred and love are perceptions, but it seems that when you do the work, and you kind of dig down deep deep and analyze, love seems closer to the nature of reality, and therefore, that’s why it’s positive.

It’s more valid than hatred. So there’s an experiential work that causes us to then do that, then go, oh, This is why this conception seems more valid than this other conception. Absolutely. And we’re going to talk about this next week when we get into kind of picking apart these mental factors, these various ways that we relate to things, some of which are wholesome, virtuous, some of which are not so productive. And these are all different ways that we use our conceptual mind within the context of how we’re relating to reality.

And so we do need to pick them apart. We do need to have pretty clear ideas of what is in accord with reality, what is totally in discord, what is not looking at things correctly. This is why we call these afflictive states of mind delusions. They are deluded. They are ways that are distorted.

Let’s get from space and then Oh, I was I mean, you define love very precisely, but I think with our Western concepts, sometimes maybe using compassion. Yeah. Yeah. But I think there can be even confusion about compassion, too. Sometimes people have somewhat distorted views of what compassion is.

But I think, yeah, love is a really tricky word in the Western world, because it has a lot of different flavors of meaning. So yeah, Steve. Another way I’m looking at this is love versus hatred. Hatred, anger, self will produce agitation. Love provides more peace of mind and equality.

I mean, is peace of mind and equality more of a natural state versus agitation? I don’t know. Yeah, yeah. No, and these are all part of the discussion we’ll get into next week, kind of looking at these emotional content of the mind and seeing what are positive, constructive emotions, what are destructive emotions, And really understanding that, again, these are conceptions. This is the bridge that from this class to the next class it’s really important to get, is that think about it the next time that you get angry at somebody, that that was a conception that you had.

That was a thought process that you, in a sense, chose to follow. As I said, most of us don’t have much choice. Why? Because we’re so ingrained to being angry or having these particular emotions that that’s just the track we go down. But we are choosing to think about things in a particular way.

Very quickly, it’s happening kind of instantaneously. Oh, this person’s an a hole, you know, whatever. It’s just going on like that the second that we encounter them. But it’s a thought process. The reason why anger arises is because we are thinking about things in a particular way.

And next week we’re going to get into more analysis of kind of why that is what is all going on there, what is all happening, and further invalidate anger. I’m sorry. Yeah, invalidate anger. Just quickly, when I work with my students indirectly, and we always teach Buddhism, and one of the things that I tend to do is listen to the chatter in their minds. Yeah, yeah.

And to tune into that every time they can, possibly, and to hear the judgments, to hear the categorization. Mhmm. And where is that coming from? So it’s that question of what do know and where did you get in this life? Right.

Who conditions you to have these beliefs that could be very harming to yourself or others? Absolutely. I think it’s another part of the process. You have to pick it apart and say, Where is that coming from? And the thing about dogs, by the way, they have to talk to the scientists because there’s studies that dogs have upwards to, and cats too, six hundred words in their vocabulary.

Yeah, yeah. I found it quite shocking. Mean, I could point out the part where it says here, Is the function of representation, kind of mental representation, having a linguistic representation even, common to all higher animals, at least the more intelligent ones, or is it unique to human beings? She says, Nobody oh, wait. That’s a different phrase.

That’s where she actually was saying that there was some of was some yeah. I don’t know. I mean, I’ll find the section in here. Sorry. We need to take a break real soon, but There’s a book somebody was talking, I guess, on Mary Charlotte about a book about bird dogs.

And evidently, they have this language, and they have a very sophisticated way. Like, they ran some experiments of running cards of different colors and shapes of the wire and cloths and the color of bird dogs, and they could develop words to describe the different card. Now that they’re sounds. We call them sounds, but they were able to say they were distinguish the different ones. Yeah.

Sure. And then they actually because they were given a a picture or or shape that was totally different or totally different color, they changed the tonalities and responses. Mhmm. And I think that’s signifying some kind of intelligence that a All right, let’s take a short break, and when we return we’ll resume this discussion. So any questions on what we’ve talked about so far today?

Or comments? I mean, was really glad the discussion that we had, because I think it brings to bear what we’re really trying to do here. Kind of understand what the practical applications of these sorts of teachings are. When we sort of pick apart you know, how conception works in that, I mean, it’s good to know, but you have to kind of begin to work with that and look at your own conceptions. Look at your own thought processes and see how you’re making a particular judgment or assessment of what you’re experiencing.

And we’re doing this all the time. And it’s, again, quite by rote that we engage in whatever. Even when we meet a stranger or just see somebody on the street and just look at their face, we decide, you know, angry person, content person, nice person, difficult person. I mean, we go through this almost instantly. And these thought processes, as I’m going to explore in the second part of class, often start out as being kind of wrong ideas.

And we have a lot of wrong ideas. And as I said earlier, we could say all the Buddhist teachings are to help us to cultivate more correct ideas. Now, we have to keep in mind that there’s no real absolute with any of this. Everything is relative. All the Buddha’s teachings are in this context of just understanding how the ideas and the thoughts that we have have repercussions.

I think this is what was being brought up earlier, kind of looking at it and saying, Well, if these are more disturbed states of mind, then that’s part of the result of having them right from the beginning, is that we have a mind that’s not at peace. I think it was Steve that was bringing this up. You know, this idea that if we pursue more healthy, positive states of mind, we do find that the impact on our mind is much more contentment, much more just feeling at ease with ourselves and the world around us. There’s these amazing stories. I wasn’t really even going to share this, but there’s quite a few amazing stories that have come out of occupied Tibet.

Most of you know that the Chinese occupation began in like nineteen fifty one and came to a head in nineteen fifty nine when many of the great lamas left Tibet at that time, including his Hawaiian, Saddai Lama. But many of them were left behind. And one of the most amazing teachers that we’ve ever had here at Buddha House, Ribur Rinpoche, Khamti Rinpoche, who’s on the left hand side up there who died some years ago, relates stories of his time when he was in prison, Chinese prisons in Tibet. And he was able to use what most of us would find to be an absolutely miserable situation of being imprisoned against your will, being tortured, being starved, have all sorts of physical and potentially emotional things inflicted on you. And he wasn’t even bothered by this in the sense of he always was using everything as an opportunity to cultivate more love and compassion for his captors in particular, those people who were the instrument of torturing him.

There was one Tibetan who came out of the prisons and went to visit His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, you know, made his way to India, to Dharmasala. And His Holiness asked him, you know, what was the worst thing you had to experience? And he said, well, the worst thing was my fear that I’d lose my compassion for others. He wasn’t talking in terms of his own experience of pain. He was talking about how that was the challenge, was to be able to continue to be in a space of compassion and love even in the midst of people doing all sorts of atrocious things to you.

So we can see that it is possible, and that’s the whole idea of this discussion on conception. It is possible to change your thoughts to a point where you could have a mind that is content and at peace regardless of what’s going on around you. And in that way, stop creating the causes for a perpetuation of all of these negativities and a complete reversal of that. Because this is the problem that we’re going to look at next week, and kind of a preview already of what we’re getting into next week. But when we begin to examine these disturbing emotions, we see that, you know, they are the source of all of our problems.

That when we engage and kind of follow these delusions, that we then perpetuate their stay in our minds, and moreover, we end up creating results that are more of the same. You know, more difficulty, more problems. And that’s even getting into the fifth class when we look at karma. And so many of these things are also interrelated. It’s kind of hard to break them apart and talk about them individually.

Because this whole study of the mind has to do with the fact that, as I said last week in that one quote from the Dhammapada, everything comes from the mind. It’s a pretty profound statement. And as we go through class by class, we begin to see more and more how our minds are the own instruments of our peace or of our hell. So any other questions before I go into what I want to discuss from here? Okay.

So on that sheet you’ll also notice that there is a little kind of breakdown in terms of when it says mental consciousness. We were in this section looking at the difference between conception and perception. We see that there are four different types of conception that are laid out there, and then we get up to perception, we see that there are two. Well, let me talk about these in brief, and then I want to put up a little schema that kind of gives you an idea of the Buddhist approach to how we need to work with correcting misconceptions in our mind. So in terms of perception, the very top one there, it says ordinary, a direct valid perception, an inattentive perception, and a clairvoyant perception.

I’m not going to talk about those quite so much, but know that they do say that we have moments of direct mental perception. Recall that, again, for our mental consciousness, most of what we’re doing is conceptual, but we do have moments or even the possibility of much more substantial amounts of direct perception, of knowing things in this way without having the mental image between us and the object. But what they say is that there is a bridge between, For example, let’s go back to my eye consciousness looking at the blue. That there’s a bridge between that direct perception of my eye consciousness and the blue where it’s kind of just a moment of knowing it directly, and then the mental image is already there. Because I’ve gone from a mental direct perception of that to a conceptual mind of that.

These are just fleeting moments that they say we really don’t even have any awareness of because they happen so quickly. Because most of the time we’re engaged in conception. We’re thinking about things. And so there is this bridge of a sort of direct, valid perception that brings us into the conceptual mind. There’s also inattentive.

That’s the second one on the list there. Inattentive perception. That means that there’s a lot of things that are mentally kind of appearing directly, but we’re just not aware of them. We just don’t even give them any attention. And I don’t want to go too far again into that because this is the subject matter of the more detailed study of mind and awareness, Lorik.

But they do even say that there’s clairvoyance that we can have where we know things directly. Now I know, again, with this idea of clairvoyance, a lot of people, you know, doubt the possibility of this. We spoke about clairvoyance last week in terms of having an ability to even see past lives through some form of clairvoyance. But, you know, again, I suppose the only way to disprove it is if you actually do what they say to achieve it, and you don’t achieve it. But if you do what they say to achieve it and you achieve it, well, then you’ll have your own proof that clairvoyances do exist.

But we do have a lot of levels of our mind that we’re just simply incapable of tapping into due to the fact that, as I said earlier, we’re hanging around in the waves. You know, we’re in this gross, gross level of conceptual mind that is incapable of knowing things directly. The main goal that we’re headed for in Buddhist thinking, though, is the other type of perception, which is called yogic. And we all know the word yogi. You know, yogi basically means, you know, someone who is practicing working on their mind, working on developing changes in their experience.

This is the goal of all Buddhist practice, Whether you’re talking about, you know, Tibetan Buddhism, Zen Buddhism, Theravadan Buddhism, whatever type of Buddhism, the goal is to develop what we would call a yogic direct perception. So what do we mean by that? We mean that through your meditation you are actually able to cultivate an awareness, an experience of the truth of reality at a level where you’re no longer using your conceptual mind, where you are knowing how things exist, the most fundamental truth of the Buddha, which I will talk about more in next week’s class a bit, having that understanding at a very profound level. And this is only done through meditation. We may have some sort of glimpses of this in our everyday life, but we don’t have the ability to penetrate really deeply into the mind without meditation.

That’s why, again, module two we will talk a bit more about the meditative techniques that help us to move in the direction of achieving that. But at that point, when you develop a yogic perception, they say that this sort of mental image that we have that is between us and what we’re trying to understand, which, again, I’ll get into that in more detail, this completely falls away. And the mind and what we are knowing kind of become merged, and you have a direct perception of your mind and that object with nothing in between. And this is quite profound. I mean, this is an experience that if you ever do have it, you will be changed beyond a doubt, and you will certainly have an awareness that you have gone through that sort of portal of your own mental development.

So, in effect, this is the goal that we’re striving for. So we could put that at the top in terms of this chart, is that we eventually want direct perception. Which, again, in here, in this context, is this yogic direct perception. But in order to get there, and this is the main point that I want to generate in the rest of what we’re talking about today, we have to use our conceptual mind. So you’ll notice that under conception we have four other different ways of kind of knowing.

And the next one is what we would call inference. Inference is when you have, through the force of your own thinking, come to a proper conclusion that also has an effect on your mind, but obviously not as great as if you directly know something. Let’s go back to because you can have last week I talked a little bit about impermanence and the changing nature of things. I mentioned it earlier today. This is one of the things that the Buddha taught that is his observation of reality, is that everything that we experience, particularly in this physical world, but also even our own minds, are changing moment by moment.

The Buddha calls the law of subtle impermanence. So we have gross impermanence, right? When we die, for example, we would You know, that’s an element of impermanence in our lives. But we also have the subtle impermanence that we’re living with every day. Well, we eventually need to get a direct perception of that impermanence, that subtle impermanence.

And that is part of the spiritual path. It’s not the final reality that we’re driving towards, but it’s an example of something that we would eventually want to be able to integrate an understanding of at a much deeper level. Well, why? Because the opposite idea, which is down here, what we call kind of the wrong ideas, The opposite idea that things are unchanging, that they’re static, that somehow this whole process isn’t going on, is a source of a lot of confusion and pain for us. A lot of people, once again we go back to that idea I was mentioning about kind of getting all your little boxes right.

Here’s my home life and my work life and all that. We think that once we get it all that we somehow are going to be able to get it to stay that way. We’re changing constantly. We’re growing older. Everything around us is in a state of flux.

And so many people find so much misery and suffering coming about because of this wrong idea that holds to things existing in this permanent, unchanging way. So if this is one of our problems, and the Buddha says it is, that this misconception is the source of some of our suffering, well then we need to move away from that wrong idea and eventually develop this direct perception. So how do we do that? We begin by hearing teachings on this, reading about it. This is everything that helps us to generate some level of doubt.

We start thinking, Well, maybe things don’t exist in this way. Maybe things are actually changing moment by moment. This doubt, they actually delineate this into three levels, but it’s not so important but this doubt kind of eventually moves away from our wrong ideas and starts moving to a more correct idea. Eventually we get to the point where we have it’s called presumption on here, but I’m going to call it correct assumption. Presumption, correct assumption, I don’t know what the big difference is, but at some point you start assuming correctly.

You’re no longer having any doubt about what you initially held, which was that things are unchanging. You now start doubting that, and you start correctly assuming that, yes, things are unchanging. Or things are changing. They are not unchanging. So you have that correct assumption at some point.

You haven’t yet sort of proved it in your own mind yet, though. You’ve heard enough about it. You’ve kind of thought about it a bit, and you’re assuming correctly. You’re in line with the truth. But the problem here is that this still potentially wavering.

You know, if somebody were to come to you and you’d be telling them about what you’ve been hearing and what you’ve been thinking about, and they say, Well, no, you’re wrong. There are a lot of things that are unchanging. This is totally wrong. Well, then you might start having doubt again and move actually maybe back to your wrong idea. This is what they call controvertible.

You want incontrovertible wisdom. This kind of is driving us back towards the three wisdoms we discussed earlier. That just hearing it isn’t enough. You have to start really thinking about it and eventually get to a point where you have an inferential cognition. This means that you’ve actually reasoned it through.

You’ve actually looked at it and understood that when we examine a flower, for example, if we were to leave this in this vase until next week, it would look very different, right? But did it look different than the next week when you look at it, but it looked as it is right now until then? You come in next Sunday morning and all of a sudden it droops and gets all wilted. We know that this isn’t what happens. We begin to use our reasoning analysis and develop an inferential cognition, understanding that this flower is impermanent, this flower is changing moment by moment.

Yeah, Steve. My goal is to take all this newfound knowledge and change my life. What if I believe that, you know, a lot of the stuff I actually understand is simple, but for something, habit, whatever Mhmm. So think one of my challenges is be to go from intellectual understanding to practice. Right, right.

Well, I think, again, that’ll come up to some degree next week. But already, what I would encourage people to do is, when you’re hearing these teachings is just developing more awareness, more mindfulness of what’s going on. Initially, what I certainly found in my own practice is that there certainly are no switches that you can flip and all of a sudden, I’ve got all correct thinking, and I’m doing everything kind of in accord with how things are. It just doesn’t happen that way. So what we have to do is train our minds gradually.

A lot of this involves meditation, and that’s why module two follows on the heels of this course, is because without the skill of meditation, it becomes hard to make changes in the mind. But at the same time, meditation is also, and I’ll point this out in that course, but the word for meditation in Tibetan is gom, and gom has the connotation of becoming familiar with something. So meditation isn’t just, Oh, I’m sitting on my cushion in a nice little posture and doing my sitting. No, it means, How are you becoming familiar with these concepts throughout your daily life? In every way that you can?

So that’s a form of application. Application through mindfulness, through awareness. I haven’t really talked so much about this term mindfulness. I mentioned that we’ve got some skills that we use in terms of meditation. Mindfulness in a context of what we’re studying here means sort of non forgetfulness.

Being aware of what you’re doing and how you’re doing it and what’s going on. It’s another level that we bring. I know that there’s a lot of usage of this term mindfulness in some traditions, Buddhist traditions, where it just simply means presence. Present moment, wonderful moment kind of idea, you know, just being present with that. Well, Lama Zopa is really keen on kind of getting us to move to a degree of being mindful of what you’re supposed to be doing, not just kind of being present with whatever is happening, but kind of being mindful of infusing every moment of your day with more vigilance, more ability to make some changes in how you’re thinking and how you’re living your life.

And particularly in this whole idea of kind of how we’re moving away from our wrong ideas, is to have some reflection at those times when we find our minds going in those directions. Because our minds are doing this all the time. As I said, even when we just see somebody, we’re instantly making judgments, thinking things about them. Or they say one word, and all of a sudden we make them into the worst person in the world. Just it’s absurd how we are following these thoughts without even checking them.

So at some level, mindfulness is a skill we need to develop so that we are challenging what we’re thinking and saying, Why am I thinking this way? As what Don said in class on Sunday, Is this what’s going on? The other thing that happens then is then we begin to develop some conviction ourselves in the potential that our mind has to change itself. Because we begin to pay attention to it and actually start making the changes. So it’s a lot of different things.

Meditation in a formal way is important. That’s why we pass out meditation teachings that I encourage you to work with over the next week. Because if you don’t spend some time looking at these ideas in a more formal setting and sitting on a cushion, it’s kind of hard to bring them to mind the rest of the time. And in the end, as I said, with those three levels of wisdom, the deepest wisdom that we can develop is through meditation. So we need to develop that skill.

And the only way you’re going get a yogic direct perception of anything is by having good meditation. But in the meantime, yeah, start challenging wrong ideas. Start challenging what you’re thinking. Do it while you’re driving. Driving is a really good time, you know?

Particularly if you’re just driving alone somewhere. And see what happens to your mind as various drivers do certain other things that you might find annoying. You can have lots of different thoughts at that time, right? But how many of them are wholesome? Right.

Yeah, I mean, to kind of narrow the gap between all of that. This is, again, the challenge that we have with Buddhist ideals, that we have to narrow the gap between what we hear and understand as what seems I hate this word should because there’s nobody saying you should do this or should do that. But when we examine it, we begin to see that these make more sense for us. These are more constructive for us, these actually help us feel better about who we are in the world and how we’re living our lives, well then in that sense it becomes a should, simply because the result that we’re really seeking, when it comes down to it, is well-being, happiness. As we go back to the very first class, when I asked you all, What is happiness?

How are you going about getting that happiness? What are its causes? Well, in the end we find the causes are within us. And at that moment, when we’re making a decision to narrow the gap between how we hear happiness can be cultivated and how we’re actually going about trying to cultivate it. Israel was challenging me earlier in terms of this idea of people thinking that they’re happy in one particular direction, and these may actually be the source of suffering for them.

We’re going to see this when we look at karma in regard to how our intentions and the direction that we give to our minds actually becomes the instrument through which we have various experiences in our life. And nothing is lost. As I said earlier, every single mental moment is kept within the sort of storehouse of the mind that travels with us from life to life. So we have to be more selective about what we’re doing with our minds. Absolutely.

Kind of narrow that gap so that we have the results that we’re seeking. I mean, this whole thing is all about everyone, you all and every being, experiencing what they most desire, which is the peace and happiness that we have as kind of our fundamental birthright through having a mind. And our minds can be the creation of that if we tend to them, if we’re good gardeners, as I use this analogy of this bed of soil. If we really tend to our minds and make sure we plant what needs to be planted there to give a a beautiful garden absolutely will arise. Yeah, Claudia?

I was going to say sometimes our line is like a cruise ship, though. You’re on a cruise ship on a dime, so it takes time. Yeah, yeah. It’s very slow and you have Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. We have to correct course, yeah. No, I use an analogy, too, of kind of like there’s a stream that we’re on, and we’re the boat on that stream, or our mind is the boat on that stream. And we want to first turn the boat in the opposite direction and go against the current.

Because the current is what’s kind of keeping us doing what we’re doing, continuing to create the results that we want. There’s that phrase of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. The reality is, as the Buddha perceives, we’ve been doing the same thing over and over again, keep expecting we’re going to find happiness, and we simply haven’t. Well, that’s part of it, getting it to first turn your boat around and go against the current. But eventually you want to get the whole current to go in the opposite direction, too.

So it’s hard work. I’m not denying that this Buddhist path is hard work at all. In fact, it’s probably the most challenging, but yet the most important thing that you can ever do with your life, with your mind. But the results are there, and they will be experienced. I have no doubt that if you apply these principles, and as Steve was bringing, if you begin to bring them into your life and start seeing the changes, then they will produce more contentment, more well-being right now.

But the implications are even greater when we understand that there are results so far beyond what we’ve even tasted that we can experience. That’s, again, what we’ll be looking at in one of the later classes in this series as well. Any other questions or comments about this process? Okay. So again, this is the possibility for each and every one of us.

Now, as I said, next week I will touch on a bit more what is the fundamental wrong idea that we have that’s kind of guiding this whole process? Because there is a root one. According to the Buddha’s observation, there is one major misconception, wrong idea that we have that is at the source of all of this. And that’s the one that we really want to target eventually. But gradually.

I mean, again, we’ve got a really humongous, overgrown tree that has really deep roots. But you don’t just start by uprooting the whole thing. You have to begin to trim a bit. You need to work and manage the tree better so that you can eventually uproot it. So we’re going to talk about this in terms of how we begin to move away from that misconception and all the other misconceptions we have into more correct thinking, and eventually bridge the gap from thinking to a direct perception of that.

And again, that can really only occur through very deep meditation. All right. So I was going to cover a little bit more on this last little part that we haven’t talked about, mental factors, and just introduce them. But we’ve kind of run out of time for today. So I’d like to just wait on that.

But please bring this sheet back next Sunday if you have it with you. It will be really valuable. I also will have another handout that I’ll give you that goes into all these various mental factors and what they are. So we will go into a lot more detail on the mental factors. For this week, the meditation that I’d like you to do doesn’t really have as much to do with the content of what we talked about today, but is, I think, a really helpful meditation to work with this idea of the mind as a knower, kind of understanding this dimension of the mind in terms of knowing things.

Because it’s all about kind of bringing some sense of awareness of awareness, if you will. Okay. Let’s go ahead and pass these out. It’s a shorter meditation than what you’ve seen in the last few. It’s only the one side.

So hopefully people will get some time during the next week to practice that. Chances are I’ll probably be here to lead that next Sunday, though there might be someone else here to lead that. But we do these meditations together, along with some breathing meditation, from nine till about nine forty five before each of the classes. So feel free to join us for that if you’d like. Now there was a list that went around.

I meant to say something about the list. Those of you who are new to the center, we occasionally on Sundays we like to do this as a way of sort of sharing the positive energy that we’ve created here today with others who are in situations that cause our heart to open. So we have on the list this idea of people experiencing obstacles, people experiencing illness, or maybe even people who have died or are dying right now. And what we’re going to do is recite these names and just think that this is a way of generating this generous spirit, that whatever positive thoughts that we’ve generated here today, whatever seeds that we planted, we want to share this with these beings, kind of help them in some regard to be free from their obstacles, free from their illness, to be able to move from this life to what comes after this life in a way that will be beneficial for them. So first we can recite the names for those experiencing obstacles.

So as these are recited, just feel kind of your heart open to sending that energy out to these beings. Paul, Rita, space, Judith, Kimberly, Sean, Savannah. I’m not sure what that is. Bless Mason, Susana, Susan, Joe, Ali, Maude, Flora, Ed, Daniel, Lotus, and Cedar, my students, Catherine, TNL, Aileen, Eric, Cynthia, Timothy, Linda, Andy, Romina and family, Jeanette, Jordan, Karen. If there are any others that you want to add at this point, you can do that by reciting their name or simply thinking about them.

So the next group that we’re going to share this positive energy with are those experiencing illness. So as these names are recited, kind of, again, open your heart to these beings, particularly those that you’ve put on the list, and share this energy with them. Bernice, Anne, Stella, Anthony, Brendan, Lenore, Paul, Eric, Lynn, Chris, Sammy, Maria, Amy, Mike, John, Israel, Michael, Billy p, June p, Lotus, Jenny Quan, Mariah, Paul, Patrick, Sam, Sharon, Lilith, Jenny, Paul, Sarah, Rocky, Sheila. You can add names at this point, if you wish. Sunny, Scott, Reg, Marion.

And the last group, again, are those who have died or who are dying right now, and share this energy with them that they may have all the good conditions they need in their next rebirth to be able to find true peace and happiness. Barbara Jean, Don, Carol, Sean, Tenzin, Dawa. And then lastly, we just kind of seal and dedicate this energy for our own development of our own minds. And we do this so that we can then benefit others. Seeing that the source of happiness lies within our own minds, may we cultivate those causes and eventually help others to cultivate them as well.

Okay, thank you all very much. I enjoyed this.

Key terms in this teaching

clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Anger and hatred bring agitation while love brings peace of mind and equality. How should we understand the emotions behind this?

Emotions such as anger are conceptions, meaning thought processes. The next time you get angry at someone, recognise that the anger was a conception you had, a thought process you in a sense chose to follow. Most of us have little choice in this, because we are so ingrained in being angry or having certain emotions that it is simply the track we go down. Still, we are choosing to think about things in a particular way. It happens almost instantly, for example thinking 'this person's an a hole' the moment we meet them. Anger arises because we are thinking about things in a particular way.

Scroll to Top