DB Mind and its Potential 2010 – 2010 11 07 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 11 07

2 h 18 min · 22,061 words · 7 November 2010

DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
DB Mind and its Potential 2010 - 2010 11 07 DB01 Mind And Its Potential 2010 11 07
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The final class of the Mind and Its Potential module explains Buddha nature as the fundamental clear light mind present from the beginning, and the Buddhahood that develops from it. It covers the two wings of wisdom and compassion, the three principal aspects of the path (renunciation, bodhicitta, and the wisdom of emptiness), and how sutra and tantra differ as paths to enlightenment. It closes with a discussion period and a dedication.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2010-11-07

Duration: 2h 18m

UUID: cde5f2d1-f5c3-4d11-a47d-dabbf1d7776e

Words: 22,061

So good morning. Welcome to this is actually our final class in the series that we this first module of Mind and Its Potential. So as usual, we’re just going to start with a very short meditation in order to calm the mind a bit, focus our minds. And then we’ll meditate for just a bit on developing a really sincere altruistic intention for being here. So we’ve talked about this briefly, but I’ll guide you through this.

So in terms of getting into a meditation posture, if you’re sitting in a chair, they say it’s ideal maybe to move a little bit forward in the chair, because if you’re leaning back in the chair, then the back isn’t straight. This is one of the key elements of our posture. In the next module on meditation, we’re going to go into a lot more detail on meditation posture. And again, in sitting in a chair, it’s ideal to plant your feet firmly on the ground in front of you. And, again, just maintain an upright posture with the back straight.

Sitting on the floor, just find a place where your legs are comfortable. And if you need to adjust your posture, this is a relatively short meditation, but if you need to, that is fine. So again, with the back straight, we want to make sure that there’s this kind of relaxed quality to the body. So our head should be upright but tilted forward just slightly, bringing your gaze downward. If you can keep the eyelids very slightly open, just allowing a blur of light in, this is said to be ideal.

Keeps the mind more alert and awake. But if you need to close the eyes, that’s fine as well. And then just start to bring your awareness to the tone of the body and see if there is any tension in parts of the body. We tend to hold a lot of tension in the muscles in the face, maybe around the mouth, the neck and shoulders, sometimes even in our chest and abdomen. So just bring your awareness to these places and just allow this relaxation to occur there.

Try not to hold on to any of that tension or stress. If you need to, maybe take a really deep breath and kind of breathe into those areas. Feel the body expand when you inhale, And then when you exhale, let all of that tension out. So we’ll begin with just a few minutes of meditating on the breath. So you’ll get a lot more instruction on these meditation techniques in the next module.

But this first form of meditation is to help us to make the mind more stable. Right now we have minds that are very distracted, that easily get caught up in other things. So we need to train the mind to be more focused. So bring your awareness to the tip of the nose and begin to pay attention as you breathe in and out through the nostrils to this very subtle sensation that appears just inside the nostrils. So it’s very slight and paying attention to it initially might be kind of difficult.

But once you tune into it, just allow your mind to rest there, paying attention to the sensation when you breathe in and when you breathe out. And not controlling the breath, not evaluating the breath, just simply being with the breath. So, that’s the very basic instruction for this first part of the meditation. But the problem is, is we don’t have perfect concentration yet, so the mind will wander. And whenever we notice that the mind is getting caught up and thinking about things we need to do or things that happened last week or maybe we start hearing sounds from outside or from inside the room.

You know, there’s no shortage of things that will distract the mind. And when we notice that we’ve been distracted, that we have wandered away from the breath, then the job is to let go of that and whatever was distracting you, allow it to dissipate and bring the mind gently back to the breath. So we’re just training the mind to be focused, training the mind to have better concentration. So we’re going to do this for a few minutes, and then after we’ve done that, again, I’ll lead you in this short meditation where we can set this really positive intention for the time that we have together here today. So, I’ll ring the chime to start the meditation period.

So you can let go of watching the breath. And to set our intention for being here today, we can recollect last week’s teaching. When we spoke about the incredible opportunity that we have with this human life. Having been born as a human, we have the ability to use this life to create results. And the results that we can begin with is to at least acknowledge that we have the opportunity to plant the seeds for good rebirths in the future.

So this is based on the concept that the mind is continuous, that our mind is beginningless, only arising from prior moments of mind, And our mind is endless, always giving rise to future moments of mind. And if this is the case, then we need to be concerned about what happens after this life. So in this human existence that we have, we can learn how to create the causes to get another good rebirth. This is ideally where our motivation has to start, is to at least acknowledge these more temporal results. But then, as we’re going to discuss even further today, we have more ultimate results that we can accomplish with this life.

Our minds are simply polluted right now by delusions, by misunderstandings, by misconceptions. But our minds are fundamentally pure. So, these delusions, all the way down to the most fundamental level of ignorance that’s driving the whole show, all of these can be removed. With this life, we can obtain the more ultimate results. The result of our own nirvana, having completely removed all these afflictive states.

Our own Buddhahood, where we go on to not just work on our own mind at that level, but to even remove the deeper levels of stains and obscurations that keep us from being fully enlightened, keep us from being a Buddha. All of this potential is here in this life. So, can see that there’s various levels of motivation that we can bring to our Buddhist practice and study. Initially saying that we’re intent on creating the causes for happiness the future in this life and beyond, additional human lives or other fortunate lives. Eventually, we must also go beyond that to think of more ultimate results, the results of liberation and enlightenment.

And we do this because we see that we are connected to other beings, Connected to those who are in our lives directly, but also connected to others indirectly. And so the best possible use of this life and the best possible use of this time is to think about benefiting others and achieving a result where we can do that. So this will be the topic of today’s lecture is looking at the result of Buddhahood and how we envision that and how we aspire to attain that. For now, just in your own heart, determine to be here to achieve your greatest possible potential, to use this time well, and in that way, be able to help others to do the same. In this way, we take the real essence, the real value of this human life, and the results we achieve will be unbelievable.

We’ve got quite a few new faces for this last class. I usually do a review anyway of what we’ve talked about, but for those of you who are new, I’ll try to touch on some of the key points of what we’ve been discussing over these last five classes prior to today’s class. So this course is called Mind and Its Potential. It’s the first of the Discovering Buddhism series and it really sets the stage for the arena in which the Buddha’s teachings are meant to be practiced. So the Buddhist teachings aren’t about fixing the external world.

They’re all about fixing our internal world. And by that we mean our minds. So mind in Buddhism, how do we define mind, those of you who’ve been here? What is mind? Mind is that which is Clear and knowing.

Very good, Jane. Thanks. So, clear refers to the nature of the mind, the clarity of the mind. This is going to be a subject we’re going to talk about today as well. Go back to that to some extent, is this clear nature of the mind.

So we’re talking about something that’s non material. While it’s very much interdependent in this human life with our brain and our senses, the tactile sense, the visual sense, auditory sense, and so on, we don’t have consciousness purely in that realm of the physical. Consciousness has its own continuity, constantly arising from a previous moment of mind. So, did speak about this idea of the continuity of mind. If we do posit that there is a beginning to this mind in this human life on the basis of what’s going on in the functioning of our brains, well then the implication is when we get to the end of this life and all that electrochemical stuff stops happening in the brains, then consciousness too ceases.

Implications of that, again for a more materialistic view, is that well then, there’s really not much sense because consciousness starts, consciousness ends, so you have to find some other way of positing some form of spirituality. Well, in Buddhism, all of our spirituality is focused on the mind with the understanding that mind has its its own continuity, its own substantial cause, always giving rise to future moments of consciousness. So again, the implications of this we discussed to some degree last week. I’ll jump around a little bit in how I’m introducing some of these topics. But we were looking at the whole idea of karma and intention.

How with our minds we then create the causes for our future experiences. There will be a whole module of Discovering Buddhism where we go into a lot more detail on karma. karma is, in essence, the mental intention that we set that guides us into various actions, whether they stay mental or whether they also manifest in our speech or in our physical actions. So there’s lots of things that spring from this, but in the end, that mental movement, if you will, is what dictates our future experiences by planting these sorts of seeds or imprints on the mind that give rise to our future experiences. So in the Buddhist perspective, everything, the whole body of what we experience, is arising through this mechanism of cause and effect, the law of karma.

That what we do is constantly giving rise and planting seeds for future experiences. And what we’re experiencing now is the result of what we’ve done in the past. So in this context, when we look at this topic that we briefly meditated on this morning in terms of the human life that we have, we can say that this human life arose from its respective causes and conditions, which were very positive. You can congratulate yourself on having created the causes to get a human life. But now that we have this human life, what do we do with it?

Because our mind will go on, we need to be concerned about the karma that we create. And so we looked at this idea then of acknowledging with this human life the incredible potential that we have to create good results within this cycle of being reborn again and again, but also to transcend that cycle, to attain liberation, to attain enlightenment. And so this will also be, again, a topic we’re going go into more today about kind of how we can attain that. What is the mechanism for doing that? How is it possible, and how do we aspire to do that?

So the other topics that we’ve looked at besides this idea of the continuity of mind and mind having its own entity, it being separate from body, and that it’s not physical. We also examined some of the epistemology of the mind. It’s a big word, but it basically means how does your mind work? We talked about the different ways that our minds function. The primary point I was making in that lecture was the fact that our conceptual mind, our thinking mind, has its own way of operating with things.

It’s our conceptual mind that actually gets us into trouble. That’s when we transition into Buddhist psychology, when we begin to understand that all of the disturbing states of mind that we have, whether we call them anger or desire or jealousy or pride, hatred, many different states of mind that we have that disturb, that upset our minds. All of these are actually conceptual minds. They are our way of thinking about things. They feel like they just arise from nowhere, like they’re emotions that just pop up and we have no control over them.

But that’s simply because we’ve gotten very habituated to them. That habituation has made that thought process very quick. It happens very swiftly. We immediately think in a particular way. Last week we did look at some of the other factors that contribute to the arrival of these states of mind.

There are actually six of them that we looked at. One of them was this idea of mistaken conceptions, mistaken ideas, mistaken ways of thinking about things. Let’s use an example of having someone difficult in your life. Somebody who maybe puts you down, says negative things about you. We’ve all probably experienced this to some degree.

Some more than others, perhaps. But when we have that in our life, we see that what plays a role in the arrival of our anger at that time is some mistaken idea about how that whole situation is transpiring even. We kind of think that person is kind of an inherently evil person, that they’re doing these things to hurt us and that they’re always negative. But if we look at it from a more logical perspective, we see that this actually isn’t correct. This person might have a unique relationship with us that we could agree isn’t so favorable.

But do they have that relationship with everyone? Is that really a logical conclusion to come to that we kind of consider them to be an evil person? We also have to look at, again, other ideas that we’re bringing into it. Again, we’ve gone into this in the past. I don’t want to go too far with it today.

But the idea is that our mistaken ideas are a big part of why we have delusions like anger. Because we’re choosing to think about things in a very different way than how they actually exist. So what are some of the other factors that we said play a role in this? Again, we looked at these six factors that stimulate the arrival of our delusions. Anyone?

Attachment to the object? Okay. Well, let’s go to the object itself. That’s one of them. So this person plays a particular role in your life.

This is an object of aversion for you or of some sort of anger, that type of energy. Well, we might need to, from an understanding of that, find a way to work with that object then. Find a way to distance ourselves from that object. Maybe create some space there, because it’s hard to work with it without having a little more space initially. Eventually, might be able to be with that person or be around that object and have it be okay.

Certainly having the seeds, the imprints of these delusions, you know, and this is a deeper level that we’re going to talk about a bit today as well, is that we’ve got kind of the imprints of these on our minds. We’ve been in these states of existence, according to the Buddhist teachings, since beginningless time. So we’ve accumulated a lot of garbage. We basically have imprinted in our minds a whole lot of stuff that just keeps coming up. We have the patterns for ignorance and attachment and anger and so on.

All these things are there. And that’s another factor that plays a role, is these kind of imprints. So we have the imprints, we have the object, we have our mistaken ideas. We also have some external influences. One of these was kind of the people that we hang out with.

There are some people who help delusion to arise by their behavior, by their suggestions, by the things they talk about, by the places they take us to, and so on. So again, that’s another factor that plays a role. We also have things that we kind of gather from what we hear from other people. We might hear this in our families, our upbringing. We might hear this in society at large.

You know, there’s a lot of ideas that sort of infiltrate into our minds on the basis of just kind of being a part of society. And we also might have other religious or philosophical, spiritual ideas that we’ve brought in that kind of influence how we perceive things as well. For good or bad. I mean, some of them are probably just fine, but some of them can cause us to think in false ways and incorrect ways. The last one.

Look at my notes. Did pretty good with five. Let’s see if we find where the sixth one is. Anyone remember the sixth one? I’m sorry?

Habit. That’s the big one. Yeah. Thanks, Amy. Okay, so habit.

Habit means that we have gotten very used to doing these things. This was the force that, as I said earlier, when you’re in the presence of that person who you find annoying, the anger comes up like it’s this motion just welling in us. It just pops up, we don’t have any control over it. Why? Because we’ve done it over and over and over again.

Now, the good thing about habit is that we can actually create positive habits. We can actually create habits that are more wholesome, that allow us to be in the presence of somebody who’s saying negative things to us, who’s calling us names or whatever the case might be. And we can be patient. We can be calm. We can not react to that.

We might even react with loving kindness in that situation rather than hatred or aversion. So this is, again, speaking to the influence that we have on our own minds. Habit means that we have, in the end, we are in the driver’s seat. In the end, we are in charge of our own minds. It’s just that we have made bad decisions in the past.

We haven’t been good drivers. We’ve been doing things that haven’t really supported more wholesome states of mind that simply lead to more positive results in our lives. And the whole mechanism of all this isn’t something the Buddha created. The Buddha didn’t say, I’ve determined that this is how your mind is going to work, and this is how karma is going to work, and so on. It’s simply his observation.

Looking at our minds and determining from his observation how our minds work and how those mental movements then influence our behavior and influence the results that we experience. So last week’s class was, again, one to give a little bit more practical advice about how we look at these things, how we work with these states of mind. But we can’t expect that it’s like it to be like flipping a switch. Well, all of a sudden we know how not to be angry, so there’s no excuse to be angry anymore. Well, the reality is, is most of us are going to find that we still get angry, that we still have these delusions.

But we will begin to catch them sooner. And this whole process is one of becoming more familiar with how do we actually work with our minds day in and day out. So if we know that we’re going to confront that annoying person, kind of know that this is the day when I have to see that person, well then we have some awareness we bring into it about how we can think about that, how we can choose to be in that situation. And we may lose it within the first few seconds and all of a sudden become angry again. But at least we brought some awareness there, and eventually we will catch it, you know, quicker and quicker.

At some point we will have the ability, and again this comes through our repeated practice of these types of attitudes, as well as our meditation, which again will be the topic of the next module where we look at how formal meditation practice helps us to have these attitudes during our day. But eventually, we’ll get to the point where we’ll catch it before it even arises, or it won’t even have the impetus to arise at all. That when we see that annoying person, we actually have a thought of compassion and loving kindness towards them, rather than a thought of, Oh my god, here comes that annoying person. I know I’m going get angry, I hope they don’t say something and trigger me and what have you. All that sort of stress and anxiety.

So questions about what we’ve talked about then? I realize it was a pretty quick overview. Did anyone have any experiences from the last week where those factors became more evident to them in their own mind and how they’re working to create delusions and how you might stop them? Anyone want to share anything? No?

Okay. All right. So the meditation for last week was looking at this idea of the perfectness of this human existence that we have. With the context that I just explained, that this is a result that we’ve created through our past actions, and now we have this result, but it is the forum, the means for obtaining future results. So we looked at this in terms of, as I said, this idea of there being a temporal value, that with this life we can plant seeds that lead to having a good rebirth, a good existence beyond this life.

Now we may not believe in rebirth yet. There are some of you in the room, I’m sure, that need to put that on the shelf for a while and say, Well, you know, I’m not sure I can kind of get behind that. Well, that’s okay. I mean, some point, I think most of us have some idea that there’s something after this life, though. There’s something that we want to have some influence on.

And so whether it looks like the Buddha’s view of being reborn in another realm of existence or as a human again or what have you, I think that we can all acknowledge that there’s some impetus that we can have to doing something for something beyond this life. Most spiritual traditions teach some form of that so that we have some awareness then of what we do with this life in terms of how we practice good behavior, good morality, how we have wholesome thoughts and so on so that these influence that state of existence beyond this life. Now, in the Buddhist teachings, there’s that more, again, ultimate result that we have as well. And this is the idea that we can actually be free from this whole cycle of being reborn. And we can be free in terms of our own situation.

This is what we mean by the state of nirvana, liberation. But also we can go beyond just our own liberation and achieve a state where we can help others. And this is the main topic of today’s lecture, kind of looking at this idea of the result of Buddhahood and Buddha nature, this idea that each of us have the potential then to accomplish this result. This is, again, quite unique to the Buddha’s teachings. This isn’t something that you find in other spiritual traditions.

But with that understanding that we have a temporal value to this life, we can create the causes for another good experience beyond this life, we can also achieve an ultimate value out of this life, achieving these more profound results. This leads us to acknowledging that every moment of this life is quite precious. It’s quite important. Because every moment is an opportunity to work on our minds. Every moment is an opportunity to choose behaviors and states of mind that lead to happiness, temporal or ultimate, rather than continuing to choose what we’ve been choosing, which hasn’t really resulted in our ultimate well-being.

I mean, if it’s worked for you, then I’d say, you know, you can be quite content and you don’t need to listen to these teachings. But I think most of us come to these teachings with some understanding that what we’ve been doing, even in just this life, even if we don’t have any idea of prior lives before this, simply hasn’t led to the peace and happiness that we’re seeking. So today’s talk is going, well, how is this possible? What is it that we need to do to achieve these more profound states of peace? Because this is all, again, coming from our own minds.

As the topic of this whole module refers to mind and the potential that we have to be able to experience these very profound states of well-being that aren’t just temporary and fleeting. And this is one of the things that we found in our lives. We might feel like everything kind of lines up for a bit, and we have maybe a few moments or a few days, if we’re lucky, of some sense of kind of well-being. Some real inner peace. And then the world kind of rears its ugly head, and we’ve got all sorts of stuff going on, and our minds lose it.

And we don’t have that any longer. So we need to find ways to attain these states in a more lasting way. So one of the most important teachings then that come up in this tradition of Buddhism are the teachings on Buddha nature. Buddha nature, and probably have to pick this set of words apart and even look at what do we mean by Buddha. But let’s first talk about Buddha nature in general.

In a lot of spiritual traditions, we even use this word spiritual. Buddhism is interesting because Buddhism doesn’t fit neatly into a lot of categories, but it kind of branches into a lot of different categories. So is Buddhism a philosophy? Is it a psychology? Is it spirituality or religion?

I mean, it’s kind of all of those things because it’s working with this platform of the mind. But when we use the term spirit in the West, I think that probably the closest thing that we can find to this concept in Buddhism is our Buddha nature. You know, some sort of sense of Let me read actually from Tukten Yeshe, who again taught the Buddhism, Discovering Buddhism at Home module on this. He says, When we refer to Buddha nature, it is an utterly pure spiritual essence or consciousness present within us from the beginning. It is eternal and uncontaminated by any of the activities of our grosser level of consciousness.

Even the most evil thoughts and deeds cannot make an impression on our Buddha nature. So, you know, when we use this word spirit or soul even in the West, this is probably the most equivalent thing in Buddhist thought. Buddhism doesn’t say that there is something called a soul that is apart from consciousness, but rather says there is a individual level of consciousness that is there all the time that is this very foundational consciousness that is our Buddha nature, that is this sense of spirit or sense of soul, if you will. And the reason for not positing anything other than that is the Buddha simply didn’t find from his observation that there is anything other than that. That in the end there is mind and there is physical things like our body and what have you.

But mind in and of itself has all of that potential that we might ascribe to the soul in Western thinking. And so when we kind of pick it apart, all we find is that there is this fundamental level of consciousness that plays that role in spiritual development in Buddhism. So let’s look at this idea of spirit or soul because I find it kind of interesting. We started touching on this last week, and I know that almost all of us come from some form of a Judeo Christian tradition. Some people don’t and have other spiritual backgrounds.

But we use this word soul quite a bit in the West. And so, as I mentioned last week, I don’t know that I’ve ever really gotten clear. I grew up Roman Catholic, and I never was clear what a soul was. I kind of couldn’t really picture it. Wasn’t really sure what it was.

But let me read from some dictionaries which are not intended to give the full conveyance of a Christian idea, but give some idea of what we’re talking about here. And we can then get a flavor for what elements of that apply to what we’re talking about in terms of Buddha nature. So this is two definitions, first, that come from the American Heritage Dictionary. The first one, the animating and vital principle in humans credited with the faculties of thought, action, and emotion, and often conceived of as an immaterial entity. So there’s some interesting things in there that I think those of you who’ve been attending these classes go, well, there’s already some of this.

It sounds like mind in Buddhism. So the idea of kind of credited with the faculties of thought, action, and emotion conceived of as an immaterial entity, non material, non physical. These are very common. The animating and vital principle in humans, this not quite how Buddhism would talk about Buddha nature, in part because we say it’s not exclusive to humans. There’s this in the Judeo Christian tradition, as I understand, the soul is really just a property of human beings.

Only humans have souls. Animals have no such property. So, again, in Buddhism, because we’re talking about all sentient beings, all beings who have consciousness, awareness, and who experience the world around them through their feelings and thoughts and so on, then we enlarge this idea of Buddha nature to include all those beings. Now, can an ant, for example, really access their Buddha nature and work with it? No.

This is what we talked about last week is the good fortune we have to have a human life where we can actually begin to cultivate qualities in our mind that help our Buddha nature to manifest. Again, we’ll be talking about this more today, but the idea that soul is an exclusive domain of human beings is really foreign to Buddhism. Buddhism would say, any sentient being has Buddha nature. Any sentient being has a mind and therefore has the potential, if not in that life, in some future life, to achieve their full potential, their full manifestation of Buddhahood. So let’s look at the second definition.

The spiritual nature of humans, once again we get that human context, regarded as immortal, separable from the body at death, and susceptible to happiness or misery in a future state. Well, that’s kind of interesting, you know? You’ve got a lot of very similar ideas again, and that one’s looking at it from the perspective of some immortality to the soul. And in Buddhism, again, our consciousness is endless. It goes on and on and always is giving rise to future moments of consciousness.

So you do have that same idea. Separable from the body at death. So it’s kind of interesting. They don’t say separable from the mind and body at death. So it seems like, I don’t know, maybe in some level this idea of soul is quite close to what we mean by mind.

But the idea that we talked about last week is that when we do approach the end of this life, our consciousness does separate from this body. Consciousness has its own continuity. Again, the materialist point of view is they would say, Well, no, this is ridiculous. Mind ends when the brain ends. When the brain ceases to function, consciousness ends.

On the Buddhist point of view, some grosser level of consciousness absolutely will end. But this subtler level that we’re gonna to touch on today, we’re going to spend most of the rest of this talk looking at the clear light mind, this very subtle level of mind that’s always there, has its continuity that cannot be gotten rid of or destroyed at death. It simply, again, is there in this very subtle form, eventually leaves this body, and goes on to a future experience. So this idea of a soul is really quite close to, again, what we mean in Buddhism. Susceptible to happiness or misery in a future state.

This is, again, from a Judeo Christian point of view, they might say, Well, in the afterlife, which would be a state of eternal damnation or a state of bliss in heaven or some holding area of purgatory or whatever the case might be. There’s a lot of different teachings about what comes in the afterlife. But they hold it as kind of not one in a series of lives, but actually the end of this life and the beginning of what they call the afterlife. In Buddhism, we would say after this life, there is another life, but that is another one in a chain of many, many, many lives. Unless we’ve done the deeper work to actually create these more lasting states of peace and happiness that we’re going to be touching on today.

So again, the idea of it being only humans was in that definition as well, but I don’t need to talk about that much more. There’s one other definition that I’ll bring in. This is from a different dictionary, the Collins Essential English Dictionary, that says the spiritual part of a person regarded as the center of personality, intellect, will, and emotions believed by many to survive the body after death. So there’s not a lot of newness to that, but it’s another way of kind of examining this idea of it being the spiritual part of us. That there’s some essence to us that does survive, that does go on.

And by Buddha nature, this is really what we are talking about is the part of our experience of who we are that has some continuity, that has an ability to always be there. And in that way, the potential is always there for that being to completely awaken. Maybe not again in that particular life, but in some future existence where all the conditions come together for that to occur. So when we talk about Buddha nature, we are in essence and in the most profound teachings of the Buddha, we are talking about what we call, as I mentioned earlier, the clear light nature of the mind. So there is this very subtle Some of you recall when I passed out that one appendix.

And those of you who are new, I can get you a copy during the break. But we began to pick apart mental consciousness, we found that there are three levels. There’s the gross level, which is what most of us are operating on a good portion of our day. We are going about being entertained by our five senses, and we’re thinking about things, entertaining ideas. All of this is on a very gross level.

Well, the subtler levels and the very subtlest level don’t really manifest that frequently for us. They say that they do at sleep and in various other times, but they’re very brief, very of minute ways, or else we’ve got this cloudiness to the mind that we don’t even understand them. They do manifest at the time of death, and we’ll look at this in the death module when we kind of go into the very specific way that those states of mind manifest as the grosser levels of mind peel away. They kind of fall away, And in the death process, you actually do have those minds manifesting in their more pure state for longer periods of time, if it is a gradual death. But the idea here is that when all these fall away, what is the essence of our state of mind?

Is the clear light mind. The clear light mind is a mind that in, as that quote from Thubten Yeshe said, it’s kind of the eternal and uncontaminated by any of the activities of our grosser level of consciousness. It’s kind of got its own fundamental purity. Some of you may recall how there was, in the video way back when we started this module, the one monk, Thubten Dondrub, he had taken a glass of water, he was shaking the water like this. This is how our minds usually are, is they’re all kind of upset and disturbed.

Then he put it on the table, and it all kind of smoothed out and became very calm. Well, that’s one way of kind of working with this idea of a glass of water, but I’m going to suggest a different analogy. Say you took that glass of water and you took a spoonful of dirt, and you poured the dirt into the water and you began to mix it up. It would lose its clarity, right? It would become dense with the clouds of all those sediment and what have you.

But has the fundamental clarity of that water disappeared? Its propensity to be clear is still there. And we know that because we can run it through purity, a purifier, whatever, remove all the sediment. We can even leave it set on the desk for a while, and over time, the sediment will fall, and the purity, the clarity of the water will return. This is kind of indicative of the nature of our mind.

At this fundamental level of clear light, we have none of these impurities at all. The impurities are all in the grosser levels of mind and kind of the way in which we are functioning, which are influenced, again, by the states of mind that we’ve perpetuated. All the factors we looked at last week, all those things that are kind of the seeds of the afflictions, all of the habit that we have, the mistaken ideas that we have, these keep our if you want to compare our minds to these glasses of water, they keep our minds very cloudy and very opaque. We can’t see out of them. We can’t recognize our fundamental clarity, our fundamental purity.

And the whole purpose of Buddhist practice at some level is to tap into this fundamental purity of the mind and to remove all the sediment, the impurities that keep us from abiding in that state of mind. And this is sort of, again, from a Buddhist perspective, with us constantly and really is, in essence, if I dare use the word birthright, not just in this life, but in countless rebirths. This is who we are meant to be, in a sense, is this pure fundamental consciousness awareness. So I did want to share a little bit. I realize this is kind of nice about this module.

This module and the very last module of this set of Discovering Buddhism Teachings, module thirteen, is all about tantra. And I’ll talk a little bit today about sūtra and tantra and these differences because it’s important even in this first course to get some understanding of this in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition. But the book we use for that is called Introduction to Tantra. And tantric techniques in Buddhist thinking are all about accessing this level of mind. And so it kind of comes around as kind of a nice circle, if you will, from this very first module to the last module, which joins back up with this first module by understanding that in all of these practices, the most profound practices, were really about accessing this Buddha nature, this clear light level of the mind.

So I wanted to read a little bit from this book, at the very beginning of this book, where he talks about the fundamental purity of the mind. So bear with me. I’m going to read for a little bit. It says, According to the Buddhist teachings, no matter how confused or deluded we may be at the moment, the underlying and essential nature of our mind or our being is clear and pure in the same way that clouds can temporarily obscure but cannot damage the light giving power of the sun. So too, the temporary afflictions of body and mind are confusion, anxiety, all the suffering that they cause can temporarily obscure but cannot destroy or even touch the fundamentally clear nature of our consciousness.

Dwelling deep within our heart and within the hearts of all beings without exception is an inexhaustible source of love and wisdom. And the ultimate purpose of all spiritual practices, whether they are called Buddhist or not, is to uncover and make contact with this essentially pure nature. Lama Yeshe is here referring to this idea. This goes back to one of the earlier classes that we had where we were talking about how His Holiness was saying that these afflictive states of mind, when we have anger or hatred and we look at it, see that it goes against the grain of our fundamental being. Whereas if we examine emotions like love and compassion, by love here we mean the sincere wish for the happiness of others.

Compassion, we mean the sincere wish for the freedom from suffering for others. These are totally concordant with the nature of the mind. They don’t go against the grain of the nature of the mind. They kind of support and enhance our fundamental being. Whereas, when we are in states of mind that are in conflict with others, or we are in conflict with the way that things are, then we are going against the grain of our fundamental being.

I find this really interesting, his comment. And the ultimate purpose of all spiritual practices, whether or not they’re Buddhist, is to tap into that sort of fundamental, essentially pure nature. So from a Buddhist perspective, His Holiness talks about this all the time. Think we have to get over this idea of being really kind of dualistic around spiritual traditions and thinking, mine is better than yours, and yours is better than mine, blah, blah, blah. This kind of one upmanship on spiritual traditions.

In the Buddhist point of view, everything that exists in a spiritual dimension is to fundamentally help beings to tap into their true goodness. And by this Buddha nature, this is really what we mean. It’s kind of our ultimate way of having our own well-being and being about the well-being of others, being a source of well-being for others. So now let me read a bit more about what Lama Yeshe says, because I think it gives even more of a flavor of what we’re talking about in regard to this Buddha nature. It says when we have developed our own inner purity, inner compassion, and inner love, we can then see the reflection of this purity and loving kindness in others.

But if we have not contacted these qualities within ourselves, we will see everyone as ugly and limited. For whatever we see every day in our outer reality is actually nothing more than a projection of our own inner reality. We touched on this to some extent in this module as well, is that kind of we experience what we bring to the table. And some of that is this karmic influence that we have, as well as these mistaken ideas that we have. And we all know, I’m sure, at least one person in our lives who lives their life with a fairly negative state of mind, who chooses to see their experiences in the world around them through dark colored glasses rather than rose colored glasses, who’s making a conscious decision to be difficult with the world because they see the world as a difficult place.

They see the world as contradictory to their well-being. And it’s very sad to see, but we see how they are the They’re flavoring their own experience through the decisions that they’re making in their own mind. Now, again, we don’t think of them as conscious decisions. We don’t think that this person’s actually waking up and saying, Today, I’m going to choose to be a miserable person in the world. It’s the habit and the force that they’ve created through having thought that way, having seen the world that way.

What we’re talking about here in terms of our spiritual transformation is bringing those qualities into our minds that actually help us to be more at peace with the world around us, to see the world and the beings in it in a light that actually complements their qualities rather than hones in on their negative tendencies? These are decisions that we can make, and we have the potential with this fundamental nature of the mind that’s pure and clear to do this. Another bit from Lama Yeshe that gives even more flavor. He says, The existence of this deep, essentially pure nature of mind is not a matter of belief or a blind acceptance of dogma. It’s a matter of experience.

Countless people throughout history have discovered this great treasure of peace, love, and wisdom within themselves, and countless great teachers and guides have skillfully shown others how they, too, can discover their own deepest nature and experience the unsurpassed happiness this discovery automatically brings. Among these exceptionally kind spiritual guides is Śākyamūni Buddha, and the aim of all his many teachings and methods is the fulfillment of our highest human potential. So this is, again, something that I would encourage as you’re going about those of you who are continuing to study here and go into discovering Buddhism in more detail in the modules to come, is to really have that idea that this is about experiencing this. This isn’t about learning about it. Learning about it is a tool to help you to experience it, but it is about your own experience of your own fundamental purity, of the qualities that you will cultivate, hopefully, that resonate with that, that enhance that, that cause that to be more and more of your being, rather than the sort of artificial, superficial ways that we’ve gone about creating who we are.

Our personality that we feel so attached to, how we need to be in the world. Well, there’s a choice there about being in the world in a way that, again, is more complementary to this fundamental nature. And we know beings that do this, right? We don’t have to look that far to see people in this world that have made that who they are. His Holiness at Dalai Lama is perhaps one of the greatest examples in this world, who chooses to live every moment in this space of spaciousness and loving kindness and compassion for others.

With everything that’s happened to the Tibetan people and to His Holiness himself, so many years in exile and so on, there’s no anger there. There’s no resentment at what has transpired. Because he’s choosing to have thoughts that complement this fundamental purity, to stay and abide in that space of mind and not waver from that. So this is, again, something that all of these teachings, everything else in Discovering Buddhism, is really all about helping you to do that. Now, it’s a framework, and some of it might, again, seem a little bit dogmatic, even these teachings on karma and rebirth and so on.

People have a hard time getting behind them. But go back again to the essence. The essence of everything that this approach to Buddhism is about is to really help you to become your own inner scientist, to kind of go inside and look at your own mind and see what really helps me to be a better person in the world. And what you are doing in that way, as Lama Yeshe was saying, it’s not belief or blind acceptance. It’s a matter of experience.

Experiencing your own Buddha nature. Experiencing your own pure divine being, if you will. Your own sacredness. Your own spirit. So all these ideas that we might have from other traditions, it’s not like, because this was when we got into the conversation a little bit last week, I even missed the opportunity to kind of mention that that will be something that we’ll be touching on to a greater degree today.

But it’s important that we don’t because, as I said, many of us do come from other spiritual traditions. It’s important that we don’t become aware of how some of those same essential ideas that are common to all these traditions are to be found here within Buddhism as well. With a different understanding, different concept about what we can do with that. But very, very similar ground. Very, very similar ideas.

So let me read the last little bit of this bit on the fundamental purity of mind from Lama Yeshe. So he says, According to Buddhist terminology, the ultimate goal of our individual human evolution is enlightenment or Buddhahood. This state, which can be achieved by everyone, is attained when all the delusions, greed, hatred, ignorance, and the like, that are presently obscuring our mind have been completely removed, and when all our positive qualities have been fully developed. This state of complete enlightenment, or I’m sorry, complete fulfillment, of full awakening, is characterized by unlimited wisdom, unlimited compassion, and unlimited skill or power. So at this point I want to transition into kind of talking about So we have this term Buddha nature, and I’ve mentioned that this is referring to this sort of clear light level of the mind, this fundamental purity of the mind.

What do we mean by Buddha? What do we mean then by Buddha nature? The idea that it’s kind of this naturally abiding part of us. So the word Buddha, the Buddha is a Sanskrit word, and it technically means awaken. And the awakened one is a Buddha.

So we also use this term bodhi, which is driven from the same Sanskrit root, which means awakening or wanting to achieve that state. And so we use bodhi, such as in the term bodhicitta. And you’ll hear this term quite a bit. We’ll be discussing it throughout. When we make this aspiration to become awakened, this is bodhicitta, bodhi mind, mind of awakening.

And this is the fundamental driving force that helps us to tap into our Buddha nature, because it’s like your own desire to achieve your greatest potential. And what do we mean by being a Buddha? So besides the Sanskrit idea of being awakened, it’s real interesting. When they took the Sanskrit words from India, when all the texts came into Tibet, in the Tibetan language, they found very rich terms to encapsulate what is meant by that. So for the term Buddha, the Tibetan word is Sangye.

Sangye consists of two syllables. So sang means fully purified. And ge means fully developed. This kind of idea that what you have done, just as Lama Yeshe was saying, is you have fully purified, fully removed this sangh, this energy of kind of taking all the impurities, all the garbage out. And you have fully developed everything that is positive beyond any further development.

You have a compassion, a wisdom, loving kindness, patience, generous spirit, all of this beyond any limit. You have it constantly for all beings. And all of the negative states of mind have been completely removed. So this is what we mean, and this goes back to, again, all those same analogies. The glass of water with all of the dirt that we put in it.

The bed of soil that we talked about earlier that is kind of this blank slate in which we can let weeds grow or we can consciously make a choice to plant a beautiful garden. And remove all the weeds, remove all the rocks, all the things that get in the way of having a beautiful garden. And by rights, that bed of soil is intended to be a beautiful garden. All the amazing things we can grow in it really complement that, bring it to its fullest potential. Whereas the weeds, the things that are undesirable, simply get in the way of that potential.

So this is, again, many of these ideas that we’ve thrown around that speak to the fact that we, in and of ourselves, have the ability to do this. To do the sangh, the complete purification, and the gye, the full development. And all of the Buddhist path, even as Lama Yeshe says, all of spirituality, some level, is about movement in that direction. To be able to access this sort of essence of who we are that is the ability to manifest as a Buddha. To manifest as a fully enlightened being.

Now the third element, or the three elements that he talks about here at the very end that he speaks of the state of complete fulfillment of full awakening is characterized by unlimited wisdom, unlimited compassion, and unlimited skill or power. We often talk about these as kind of like the three elements that speak to what a Buddha is. Sometimes they get narrowed down to just two because we talk about, in terms of our spiritual development, being focused on these two wings. The two wings of a bird. So a bird can’t fly with one wing.

We would never be able to get a bird to get up in the air with only one wing. In Buddhist thinking in this tradition, we say that we need these two wings of wisdom and compassion. We need to have kind of really a highly developed state of mind that knows all things, actually. And this is kind of an interesting thought in Buddhism. In a lot of other spiritual traditions, they do not ascribe omniscience to any being but the divine creator.

They all say, Well, yes, I believe that God knows all things. Well, you too can know all things in Buddhist thinking. You can develop this wing of wisdom to a point where you have no boundaries, no borders of your knowledge. You can know everything. Now, why do you want to know everything?

It’s kind of to be a know it all. Not much point to it without the other wing, Because the other wing, although this is the fulfillment of our own potential, kind of that essence of who we are, this clear light mind that is completely pure, that can be boundless, can expand to knowing all things, the main purpose for doing that is because of our compassion. And in this Mahāyāna tradition, the compassion practices are absolutely essential to keep that in check-in terms of understanding why we want to develop our own minds. There’s a temptation a lot of times to say, Well, you know, I’ve just had enough of it. I don’t really want to suffer anymore.

I don’t want to die. I don’t want to go through all this suffering. That’s an important step. But look around the room. Look around this world.

Every other being is in the same situation as you. And in this tradition of Tibetan Buddhism in particular, a lot of other Buddhist traditions embrace this as well. We need to enhance this wing of compassion to a degree where we feel a strong connection to all beings, where we feel that in the end, the happiness of all of you is worth so much more than my own happiness. This is this altruistic intention. It doesn’t mean that you’re not going to be happy in the process.

This is actually the means for attaining your happiness, according to these teachings. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, often talks about being wisely selfish. Well, if you want to cultivate your own mind into this unbelievably blissful state of wisdom consciousness, you have to be focused on the welfare of others. Because the welfare of others is the means for accomplishing that. That’s how you are wisely selfish.

That’s how you will actually accomplish fulfillment, your own potential, is by enhancing it with this compassion that is for all beings. Not just our friends, not just those people close to us, not just those people we like in the world, but all beings. Those who we know, those who we don’t know, those who we don’t even see, don’t have any contact with at all. So these two wings complement each other greatly. And the whole purpose of developing the wisdom is to be a benefit to others.

The whole purpose of having this mind that wants to benefit others is so we can develop the wisdom. Without that, you cannot accomplish this goal of Buddhahood. You cannot hope to fully purify your mind or fully develop all your qualities. Now, the third element that was mentioned there, kind of this being with limitless skill or ability. Well, this is a whole another dimension to it.

It’s not like you get into this state where you have this unbelievably wise mind, completely omniscient, but you also have this amazing compassion that really wants to help others. I mean, imagine if you didn’t have any ability then. You’d kind of sit there in this state of knowing everything that every being needs to work on, knowing their minds, knowing everything in the world, and wanting to help but not being able to. So this is the other aspect to a Buddha’s experience, is that we talk about them to some degree. This is what I would call a limited form of omnipotence, ability to act, ability to do whatever needs to be done.

Now once again, in a Judeo Christian tradition, for someone to think that they could be even partially omnipotent, to have some sort of ability to help others in that way, goes against the grain of most of those traditions because they believe that this is a quality only attributed to, again, a divine creator of some sort. In Buddha’s perception and what he has discerned from his own experience, this is a quality that every one of us can have, too. We can not only have this very wise mind, very compassionate heart, but we bring them together with an ability to act for the welfare of others. Now, does that look like? How does that work?

Because I did call it kind of a limited form of omnipotence. Basically, the analogy they often use is, and it’s kind of interesting, Lama Yesha used the analogy of kind of the clouds and the sun in terms of our minds. But if we talk about the Buddha as being like the sun shining, you know, and here in Santa Fe we get lots of sun. Most of our days have some good amount of sun. But the idea here is that the sun is always shining, right?

Even when the Earth is rotated so that we don’t have the sun here and it’s night time, the sun is still always shining. This is kind of like what a Buddha is in terms of their limitless skill and ability, is that they’re constantly sending out light rays. Those light rays, again, are directed based on the omniscient mind knowing how beings need to be helped, what they need. Just like the sun is giving this planet all the light rays, the things that it needs for things to grow, for beings to be well and what have you. The Buddhas are doing the same thing, constantly sending out through the force of their compassion and their wisdom things to help sentient beings.

Well, problem, and this is why it becomes limited, is because from their side, there’s no limitation. It’s limited in terms of what we can experience. Sentient beings who aren’t enlightened, who the Buddhas are trying to help, constantly trying to help. And just as with the sun, not everything is out in the sun, right? A lot of things are inside, under rocks, in caves.

There’s a lot of places where the sun doesn’t reach. Well, what the Buddha says is that these are sort of our own karmic obstacles, our own obscurations to experiencing the Buddhas in our lives. So when we talk about a Buddha, we mean a being who is fully dedicated twenty fourseven. They don’t have anything else in their job description. There’s nothing else they need to do.

They don’t need to go home and make a meal and go shopping and all this other stuff that we have to do. They are this essentially pure, completely expansive awareness that is compassionately connected to all beings and sending out whatever energy needs to be sent out to help those sentient beings. But we’re the ones that put our blinders on. We’re the ones that put the limits to how much we can experience that. We’re the ones that decide, you know, I’m only going to experience this much of the Buddha’s power and energy in my life.

So this is why, to some degree, and we will talk about this in the next module as well, In the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, there is an emphasis on some devotional practices. One student who’d been coming here for the meditation classes was talking to me the other day, and he said this is for meditation classes he was doing on Thursday night. He said, well, what’s with all the statues and all the flowers and all this other stuff? Buddhism isn’t really a religion, is it? And I’m going, well, again, how you classify Buddhism, as I said earlier, is really pretty subjective because it’s in a lot of different disciplines.

But there’s a devotional aspect to this practice as well. And that is driven by the fact that if we are aspiring to this goal and again, I’m not saying everyone in the room is necessarily all signed up for this or anything, and you don’t have to sign up. It’s your own decision about what you think of these teachings. But if we decide that, yes, there is within us this fundamental spirit, this fundamental Buddha nature, and we are striving to attain it, well then we need the energy of those who have already achieved that goal to help us on this path. And they actually say, and this is again one of the modules where we will focus on this idea, that our spiritual teachers, particularly again these great lamas, these great spiritual teachers in this tradition and in many other traditions, are manifestations of that energy in our lives.

That we’re not kind of here all alone, abandoned by the Buddhas. That the Buddhas are actually finding these skillful ways to work with us right now. Again, an idea, something that we might entertain and think about, and we will look at this in a lot of detail in module four, which won’t come sequentially. That one we’ll do a little bit later. Because this is a hard concept for some of us to get our heads around, these beings that are manifestations of that energy, that enlightened mind.

But devotional practices from our side are all about aligning ourselves with the energy of these beings so we can experience the benefits of them in our lives. Because they’ve accomplished this goal. You’d be negligent if you were trying to become a great neurosurgeon, if you went to a school and any previous people who had studied there and were neurosurgeons themselves, if they were offering their services to help you to become a better neurosurgeon, you would say, No, thanks. I’ll do fine on my own. I’ll learn to be a neurosurgeon without your help.

Thank you. I don’t know what it means to be a neurosurgeon. I’ve never gone on that track. But I imagine it’s a pretty difficult road because you have to learn an awful lot before you are really competent at doing it. Well, why not learn from people who’ve done it before you?

So this is the idea, is that if we really are intent on achieving our greatest well-being and helping others to do the same, well then we need to rely on those beings who have done this before us, who have actually had the experience of working on their own minds and developing their own qualities, and can help us, inspire us, give us the energy that we need to do the same spiritual practice. So this is what we mean by a Buddha. A being who has fully potentialized their mind, completely removed all the negativities, completely enhanced all the positive qualities, and is this wellspring of support and energy for all sentient beings to achieve happiness. I don’t know all spiritual traditions. I don’t claim to.

But I have not heard in any other spiritual tradition a result as far reaching as this. I’m not saying that makes it better. I’m just saying it is interesting. It is a concept that I think goes pretty far. And consequently, is not necessarily the easiest to practice.

I mean, I’m not up here just kind of selling Buddhism. My idea is, from my own practice, is that it’s a challenge to do this. We are talking about really going against the grain of the way that we have lived our lives so far. But the potential is there. And that’s what kind of keeps you going in the end.

Understanding that you, yourself, and all beings have the potential to experience that, to awaken to that, to become that, because you already have that essential Buddha nature. It already is a part of you, undeniably, and never will be, as was pointed out earlier, it’s never contaminated or tainted by all the other peripheral stuff that’s going on. So again, this is a concept that’s probably not that different from those of you who come from a Judeo Christian tradition of understanding what a soul might be. I’m curious what thoughts people have at this point. Maybe just open it up for some dialogue, discussion, questions, and then we’ll take a break.

Any thoughts? Yes. What’s your name, by the way? Iana. Iana?

Yeah. Good. Welcome. However, I’d like to hear your thoughts on my perception of this. The way I tend to feel comfortable working with this is to think about intention and alignment within a mind, a universal mind, so to speak, the Jñāna Pada.

Right. This mind that you’re speaking of. And within that mind, in all knowingness, there exists these these concepts, but like the medicine Buddha. Uh-huh. There’s there’s this sense of healing and goodness.

Right. So it’s not so much about, for me, a statue. Statue. Right. It’s more about an alignment with a mind stream that has this quality that I am trying to connect with.

Right, right. And that’s another dimension to this practice, practice, absolutely. I didn’t touch on it specifically when I was talking about these objects, but absolutely. I mean, when we talk about the Medicine Buddha and the healing properties, or we talk about green Tārā here in the thangka who is sort of this enlightened activity, this energy power cutting through all the nonsense, or we talk about Chenrezig who is compassion embodied in that form. These are all to awaken these same qualities in ourselves.

That we, again, have at their most fundamental level in this pure light mind that is our essence. Allow that to awaken. Allow that to come forward. Now, one of the things that you mentioned I don’t know that Buddhism would quite completely subscribe to is the idea of a universal consciousness. But when we start talking about what we mean by the mind of a Buddha, we’re not kind of a part of that Buddha’s mind, but a Buddha’s mind, being omniscient, all knowing, is encompassing everywhere, is knowing all things.

And there’s very little, in the end, to distinguish one individual Buddha mind from another because there’s no longer, again, any of those kind of boundaries around the mind. So in that sense, it’s not to say that you lose any sort of distinctive continuity to that individual mind. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, actually says that your mind does continue as that identifiable Buddha mind. But because the qualities of that are so expansive, it doesn’t really matter. It’s not like we’re holding on to some sort of personality of who we were in that state.

Because when we’re in that state, there’s no real confinement. There’s no grasping to something really tight. So the idea of there being a universal consciousness may not be quite accepted in terms of us all being a part of something that’s bigger than us. But when it comes to this full result, the full result is so wide and encompassing that I don’t know that you’d really have any sense of separation from other Buddhas or from other beings for that matter. In that way, you would have that more active as a resultant state.

But where we are at right now is in some sense of separation, some sense of this grasping that we have to some separate individual identity that is apart from all of that. These teachings in this tradition are very much about loosening all of that and becoming connected to everyone. That’s why we need the compassion. That’s why we need all these qualities, is because we have made our lives limited. We have limited our own experiences.

Something concrete rather than having something so intangible as a mind stream. Absolutely. And this is why, again, if we think that the Buddhas are this energy trying to manifest in ways that help us, well then, if these are archetypes and things that we can resonate with that reflect and enhance our qualities, well then, these are ways to look at this, to make them a part of our spiritual practice. One thing you touched on, which I’ll share a story when my father was ill and dying about ten years ago was the summer of two thousand, and I was working with him. I actually had worked with him previously.

Don’t know if this was during that summer, but one of my previous times spent with him when he was declining, his health was declining, I was working with him with a meditation. This practice that in Tibetan Buddhism is called Tonglen. Tonglen, as some of you may be aware of, is a very powerful means of developing compassion and loving kindness in our hearts. And I was trying to give him some space to work with this, and not putting it in a Buddhist corner, but just really allowing him to be with these very common human feelings of compassion and loving kindness. And at the end of the meditation, he said, I’m not sure why I want to do this.

And I said, Don’t you Again, was Catholic as well. I said, Don’t you want to have the same qualities that Jesus Christ has? Because that’s how I choose to see Jesus Christ, as loving, kind, compassionate, merciful being that is just totally connected to all beings. And he said, That’s for Christ. That’s not for me to do.

So I think that there is again, I’m not putting any spiritual traditions down. I’m just saying that there are limits sometimes put by other spiritual traditions on our capacity, on our potential. We talked last week about these factors that influence our delusions. Well, also That’s one of them. One thing that we might get from a spiritual tradition that kind of limits how we even see ourselves.

That I’m just mere little human me, and who can I be in the face of a divine being? Well, Buddha nature is about destroying that myth or destroying that paradigm and saying, Guess what? You have the potential in your essence right now, in your mind, to become this compassionate being that’s just totally connected to others, that has great wisdom and loving kindness and is able to manifest through enlightened activities to benefit others. You can be that divine being because you have the essence of that divine being. Now, doesn’t mean that you’re that divine being already, but tantric practice is all about doing that.

When we come back after the break, I’ll talk a little bit about these differences between sūtra and tantra and introduce this concept already. Even though the tantra module isn’t until the last, it’s important that you get some flavor of these two different approaches to working with our Buddha nature, of sūtra, the more common teachings of the Buddha, and tantra, the more esoteric hidden teachings of the Buddha. But these are very good points that you brought up. I thank you for doing that, because they really enlarge on this discussion in terms of these paradigms that we might have about who we are and who we are meant to be or who we have the potential to be. This goes back to the video.

Remember the video, those of you who were here, how Venerable Rubina was talking about an acorn. An acorn is very cute, and you could assemble a whole little bowl of them, go out in your yard and collect them all from an oak tree and make a nice little display. That’s great. Those might be a pretty thing for people to look at. Or you might design a little weapon out of it, even with a slingshot, you could probably do a lot of damage with acorns.

But is that the potential of an acorn? No. The potential of an acorn is to become an oak tree. So we have the same thing. We’ve been blind.

We’ve been using our acorn mind for all sorts of things, and we haven’t really used it for what it is intended to be, which is the oak like Buddhahood that is our essential nature. Great. Other comments or questions before that? Yeah, Mark. So then the idea of Buddha nature can be present from the acorn state to the massive one hundred and fifty foot tall Absolutely.

Oak tree state. Yeah, yeah. It’s kind of like the potential just begins in a more obscured and hidden way and not so manifest, and becomes more and more manifest as the oak tree grows, and eventually, yeah, is the full glory of that oak tree. Yeah. Yeah.

I think we all have those moments in our lives when we felt some of that kind of got a glimpse of what we mean by our pure fundamental nature. Sometimes it happens outside in nature, you know, when we have those kind of moments of stillness and peace and connection with the world that we live in. Sometimes it happens in the presence of beings like His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, where you get a sense of your purity being reflected by a being who is in that state. Sometimes it just happens with a genuine love for someone in our lives, where we just feel this real openness and spaciousness to our heart. They’re all glimpses of that.

Again, I don’t think there’s anyone in the room who can deny that they’ve ever experienced that. We all have some experience of it. We all have some taste of a deeper dimension to who we are. Buddhism is really precious, I think, from my own experience in giving us techniques to work with that. So it’s like all of the stuff you need to get from the acorn to the oak is laid out here.

Not missing a thing. You’re not going to get an oak tree missing a few branches because you didn’t do it all right. It’ll give you everything you need to be the full glory of that oak tree in all of its splendor. Good. Thanks for sharing that one.

Right. Let’s take a little break and there’ll be more room for people to ask more questions or comments after. It’s about ten minutes or so. A few more if you need. If you need the restroom here, by the way, the restroom is upstairs next week, I think.

This coming week we’re going to bust a hole in this door over here and actually have a ground level bathroom because there’s a bathroom behind this building, and we will be able to access that in the future. So, before we get started again, I just thought I’d open up to any other comments or questions on what we’ve talked about already today. Okay. So when we talk about this idea then that we want to kind of fully develop our qualities, fully remove all the negative tendencies, this speaks to, in a sense, kind of two levels of what we might talk about in Buddha nature. So Buddha nature, at some level we can talk about this sort of naturally abiding level where it’s just kind of always there, and that’s what I’ve been mostly referring to is the idea that in the continuity of our mind is always this very fundamental clear light mind, this mind that is free of all the impurities that is untarnished by any of them.

But when we talk about Buddha nature, we can also add a dimension of what we call sort of the developmental Buddha nature. And that’s what we’re referring to in terms of the way in which we move from point A to point Z, or whatever you want to call Buddhahood. It might be further down the alphabet than just B. As Mark was pointing out, there’s kind of this idea of moving gradually towards achieving that result. So in this way, we could say that there’s an element of our Buddha nature that’s also developmental, that’s also about our spiritual development.

And this spiritual transformation is a process of, again, complementing all the things that are resonant with that Buddha nature, that complement the Buddha nature. Producing those in our minds through meditation, through other practices that help us to cultivate these positive qualities, and then removing all the negative tendencies. Now, negative tendencies at their deeper level need to be removed at something that actually addresses them at that fundamental level, that root level. And this is why, again, this wisdom wing, going back to these two wings, the compassion wing really helps us to generate more qualities, to be more fulfilled in terms of what we’re doing with our minds. But the wisdom wing is really also about counteracting, contradicting this fundamental level of ignorance.

So we did speak about this a few weeks ago. And I want to just touch on it one more time because I think it’s worth bringing up. As I said, we will talk about this again and again and again throughout Discovering Buddhism. And there’s one whole module where we’re dedicated to this level of wisdom that we need to cultivate. But the ignorance that is kind of driving the whole show, the Buddha says, is the fact that we’re not really seeing reality correctly.

We’re not really thinking of ourselves correctly. We’re not thinking of others correctly. We’re not thinking of everything that we experience correctly. That there is an illusion going on. The way that everything appears and the way that we think about it in the end isn’t how things actually exist.

So the Buddha, in his wisdom, saw that you can develop a state of mind that is contradictory to that, that actually goes to the point of removing that ignorance. At some point, we begin to develop this, and it just acts as a counterforce to it. But at a very deep level, it actually removes it. It actually, kind of just in the same way that if we had that glass of water with all the dirt poured into it, we put it through the purifier of wisdom, and all of that gets removed. And the fundamental clarity and purity of that water, just as of our minds, is completely manifest.

So this wisdom that we have to develop is the wisdom of emptiness. And we’ve mentioned this before. Again, I’ll just touch on it a little bit. But when we say emptiness, in the English language it has this feeling of being vast nothingness, voidness, what have you. But the idea here is that it is a negating, a complete denial of how things seem to exist, how we think they exist.

And that way of thinking that they exist, we attribute a lot of different terms to that. It isn’t real because, again, these teachings show us that we can actually contradict that. But what we mean by that false way that we think things exist is that we think that things have independent existence, inherent existence, intrinsic existence, existence from their own side, existence by way of their own character. There’s lots of different terminology for these in Buddhism. And it’s a difficult concept to get our heads around, and it takes repeated exposure to the subject and repeated meditation on emptiness to get to that very deep level where it actually removes the ignorance, where it takes the sediment out of the water.

But right now we can even begin to kind of question, well, are we really seeing things correctly? And we’ve already touched on some ways that even conventionally we aren’t seeing things correctly, right? When we talk about anger, as we did earlier, and how we have this tendency to get angry at somebody who’s belligerent with us, And we are holding them to be this belligerent, awful person. But that is not in alignment with everyone’s experience of that person. It’s our own experience that we then exaggerate and elevate to a status where we feel like we’re totally justified in getting upset at that person.

Well, again, we’re not seeing the whole picture there, but the Buddha says at a deeper level, we’re also not seeing the whole picture. In fact, we are putting a picture on it that is totally contradictory to what actually exists. And that picture is, again, this idea of it being an independent, inherently existent person. And an independent, inherently existent me that’s having this interaction that is, again, has another level of kind of power to it because we are holding myself and others to exist completely apart from each other. And in the end, there is nothing but interdependence and a dependently functioning thing as opposed to this very strict separation.

Now again, this way of relating to these wisdom teachings, again, I could go on about this. I don’t want to spend too much time on it, because in the emptiness module we will go into all the reasoning, Cause it’s analytical. It’s not like the Buddha just says, Oh, believe in emptiness and you’ll be fine. And then you kind of sit there and go, I believe in emptiness. I believe in emptiness.

You have to discern emptiness for yourself. You have to analyze and find that the way you’ve been thinking about it is actually not correct. And you do that through very set analytical meditations, very set reasoned logic that gets you to a point of saying, This is what I’m believing, but I can’t actually find that things exist that way. So this is, again, the way that we develop our Buddha nature at a more fundamental and deeper level. Yes, we do need to generate compassion, and we do need to have more loving kindness, and we do need to be more patient, and we do need all these other kind of worldly skills that help us to be in the world in a much different way.

But without this deeper level of change in our minds, where we actually counteract that ignorance and completely defeat it, completely get rid of it. And all the things that arise from that ignorance then topple. There’s nothing to support any of those states of mind or any of the other problems that we have. So when it comes down to it, in this glass of water that is our mind, all the dirt that we’ve got there, the most pervasive level of dirt, the one that’s behind all of it, is this ignorance. And when we talk about developing our Buddha nature, we are mostly talking about, at that deeper level, removing that.

But you can’t really get to that without some of these other things that complement it. Again, that wing of wisdom, or I’m sorry, compassion, that complements our wing of wisdom. That helps us to generate these additional qualities. Now, this whole I mean, I introduced Discovering Buddhism way back at the beginning, at the very first class that we had on this module. But Discovering Buddhism is laid out in terms of what’s called the Lamrim in Tibetan.

Lam means path, and rim means kind of gradual or stages. And the idea here is that with this presentation that has come down in this tradition from the teachings of Lama Atisha, who was an Indian Buddhist master who came to Tibet about one thousand years ago. And he had, again, been a part of this whole Indian Buddhist tradition that had sprung from the teachings of the Buddha and was firmly entrenched in the great monasteries of India and the Nālānda Monastery. And he came to Tibet and brought this very systemized approach. He wasn’t the first Indian to come to Tibet and teach Buddhism, Mahāyāna Buddhism, but he was one of the very significant ones.

Why? Because he brought what is called this Lamrim stages of the path approach. Stages of the path is set out in terms of a very sequential you enter here, begin thinking about these sorts of things, you develop your mind according to them, and you keep moving along this path until you attain the goal. The goal being enlightenment. Now, for most of us, again, it’s going to take a lot of effort to actually accomplish this.

As I was saying earlier, it’s not the easiest path in the world, but it’s one that we do find that our minds get more and more peaceful and content and happier the more that we practice, the better we practice. So discovering Buddhism is kind of like giving you the entire map of the terrain. It’s kind of looking at, well, are the initial meditations, and this is what you do in the middle, and this is what you do at the end, and this is the result, and these are the various ways to accomplish it. And it goes through the entire terrain and gives you that overview. Your own individual practice, of course, is not just to get these overviews continually, but to actually start at some ground level and begin to work your way up through generating what are called realizations.

Now what do we mean by a realization? We mean that you are, in a sense, kind of fundamentally correcting a misconception in your mind or generating a more profound understanding of something. So right now we all do have some misunderstanding going on. As I was saying earlier, this ignorance that’s driving the whole show is a misunderstanding. It’s a mistaken conception.

We think we exist in a very concrete, independent way, but we’ve never existed that way. Never. And we can go through the reasoning to prove that. But we also use kind of our meditation and our development of our mind to enhance what we already do have. We already do have compassion.

Every single one of you in the room has compassion for at least one being in your life. Even if it’s just a pet, a dog, a cat, that you feel really strongly towards. Most of us have compassion for many beings in our lives. A sincere wish that they not suffer, that they not have to experience dissatisfaction, hunger, thirst, whatever in their lives. So we have the seeds of those.

So when we talk about a realization of compassion, we’re talking about a deeper way of appreciating that quality that we already have and bringing it to a higher level in our minds. So the Buddhist path is all about realizations of the stages of the path, realizations of these various contemplations and ideas that move you away from your unenlightened state where your Buddha nature is obscured to the awakened state where your Buddha nature is fully manifest, fully present. So when it comes down to the approaches that are taught within this, we can say that there are basically these two approaches I mentioned earlier, the sūtra approach and the tantra approach. Now both of these are kind of two parts, if you will, of the whole of the path to Buddhahood. And you can’t really practice one well.

Well, you can’t practice tantra well without sūtra. Sūtra, I think, could probably be practiced okay without tantra, but is it capable of getting you there fully? According to the tantra teachings, it isn’t. It’s not sufficient to take you the whole journey all the way to enlightenment. Most of what we talk about, however, in our Discovering Buddhism, from here to just about the end, is all what we would call sūtra, is all what we would call the common, more exoteric, the general teachings that the Buddha gave.

So these teachings that the Buddha gave, though, as I said, are absolutely essential to get to the practice of Tantra, which is where you utilize the more hidden teachings that Buddha gave, these esoteric teachings that he gave only to those people who were really ready for that level of spiritual practice. Now, sūtra and tantra the word tantra has gotten used an awful lot in the West. And what you mostly see in the West when the word tantra is thrown around is referring to Indian practices that come out of the Hindu tradition. In the context of Tibetan Buddhism, which is one of the few traditions that has held onto the tantric teachings of the Buddha, we are talking about techniques that help us to utilize this human body in particular, tapping into very subtle energies in this body to be able to make this clear light mind manifest. As I said earlier, whether we talk about sūtra or tantra, your goal is to really get to that clear light mind being fully manifested.

Well, in tantra, techniques are taught to help you to manifest that mind in this life, rather than waiting until either the death process where it does manifest. I mentioned this earlier. You do have the clear light mind there. But maybe we won’t have all the wherewithal when we die to be able to utilize that mind. But there are very rare occasions that we have where we can actually access that mind.

And that is the level of mind that we need to generate to purify all the impurities in the water. With all the understanding that we bring from sūtra, which is understanding emptiness, understanding this wisdom, having this motivation of Bodhicitta, this wish to become a Buddha, having all the practices that support that so that our practice of tantra has the juice behind it, the energy behind it, to actually be successful. So I wanted to was there a question or a comment? Did you have something? Me just oops, wrong book.

It’s over here. Introduction to Tantra. Again, this is right at the beginning. I read pages two and three before. This is pages three and four.

So, again, bear with me with a little bit of reading here. It says, According to sutrayana, the sūtra vehicle, the path to fulfillment is a gradual process of cleansing our mind of all its faults and limitations and developing in their place such beneficial qualities as love and wisdom. This path consists of creating specific causes, behaving ethically, developing our own powers of concentration, training in meditative insight, and so forth, for the future attainment of full awakening. So it’s very much kind of investing now and creating the causes so that some way, some place down the road, we can have that manifest for us. We can become a Buddha.

Because of this emphasis on creating causes for a future result, the gradual approach of sūtra is sometimes known as the causal vehicle to enlightenment. It’s kind of, again, creating the causes throughout your practice so you can eventually have that result sometime in the future. Just like, you know, the way that we go about achieving education in our school systems. Let’s go back to neurosurgery. So say you do want to become a neurosurgeon.

You don’t start practicing as a neurosurgeon the day that you enter kindergarten, if you have that motivation, or preschool, whatever it is these days. I’d say kindergarten, but I don’t They still teach kindergarten? Is it called that? Okay. I don’t have children, so I don’t know these things.

I know there’s a lot of auto emphasis on preschool, and preschool goes even, what, younger than kindergarten age, right? Anyway. So you have preschool. If at preschool you said you had this determination, or your parents had the determination you were going to be a neurosurgeon, and you started practicing neurosurgery at that age, it would be ridiculous. You need to go through all the education in your preschool, in your grade school, in your high school, in college, through the medical school, into internship, and whatever.

It’s a very involved process before you actually start practicing neurosurgery, before you see yourself as a neurosurgeon. That’s the sūtra approach. It’s like you have to create all these causes so I can be a neurosurgeon someday in the future. All right, let’s talk about tantra. Compared to this gradual sūtra approach, tantrayana the word yana, by the way, just means vehicle or means of getting you there.

So tantrayana is the means of using tantra to get you there is a far speedier path to enlightenment. Although tantric practitioners do not neglect creating the same causes as the followers of sūtra, they take the future result of full spiritual evolution as the very starting point in their practice, in their path. To put this in other words, the tantric yogi or yogini, as these supremely skillful practitioners are called in Sanskrit, learns to think, speak, and act now as if he or she were already a fully enlightened being. Because this powerful approach brings the future result of full awakening into the present moment of spiritual practice. Tantra is sometimes called the resultant vehicle to enlightenment.

So this is a pretty revolutionary concept. Because like I used my example, I mean, you imagine, you know, five year old being a neurosurgeon, seeing themselves as a neurosurgeon, doing the actions of a neurosurgeon? This is pretty revolutionary. Well, in tantra, this is what it’s all about, is that you think that you’re a Buddha now. And through a process of what’s called tantric empowerment, you kind of become to identify with a particular aspect of the enlightened mind.

One of these tantric beings or other tantric beings that we don’t have the images of here, but that are taught in various levels of tantric practice. And you begin to see yourself in that way. You might think, well, this sounds like pretty delusional, like somebody’s walking around thinking that they’re a rock star or something and they really aren’t. Well, this isn’t what we mean. We mean that you have Buddha nature right now, so practice being a Buddha right now.

Practice being that, being that you have the essential components of creating right with you right now. So practice being that. Practice being a compassionate being that’s connected to all beings. Practice being this wise being that knows how to help others. Practice seeing the world and all the beings in it in that fully potentialized state.

Tantra is a very profound, very difficult practice, too. I’m not in any way saying these things are easy. And its speediness comes when we come to the conclusion that we’re tired of being incapable of helping others. As I said, you need those two wings of wisdom and compassion. While in tantra, you need a really, really powerful wing of compassion.

You need a wing that is not intent on becoming a Buddha yourself for your own benefit, but one that is intent on becoming a Buddha because you can’t bear the thought that other beings are continuing to experience dissatisfaction, continuing to suffer because you aren’t enlightened. So it’s a very profound level of practice and one that requires even more of that kind of juice to get there, to really make it successful. But both sūtra and tantra are based on Buddha nature. They are based on this idea that you have within you right now the raw stuff from which your full enlightenment can be manifest. This sangye, this can come from your efforts on the path.

Sūtra, by a very meticulous cause and effect, that this leads to that leads to that leads to that leads Eventually, I’ll get to the result. In tantra, it’s about, Yeah, I’ll acknowledge that that’s a part of it, but I want to practice being that right now. I want to be a Buddha right now because it’s unbearable that other beings have to suffer, because I’m not enlightened. I’m not capable of helping them. I think we all know from our own lives one of the most frustrating things that we have in our lives is that we can’t help others to the extent that we’d like to.

Lama Yeshe talks about this in one of the writings that you’ll see when we get to the module on Bodhicitta. I mean, think about how many times you’ve had to deal with people in your life who were sick or who were dealing with a very difficult problem in their life, And you just felt so incapable, so inept. Like, well, what can I do? How can I possibly help this being? Now, as a Buddha, I’m not saying that you have a magic wand and you can just whisk away all of their problems.

One wave of the wand and they don’t have problems any longer. But you will be in a much different space to be able to truly help those beings. Right now, we often don’t even have anything we can say that really helps others. We stumble with words and actions, and we usually are quite inept. Well, as a Buddha, you will have the ability to benefit others.

This is a part of that picture, as we talked about. Limitless wisdom, limitless compassion, and limitless ability or skill. So the driving force behind both the sūtra and the tantric paths to enlightenment is this wish to make that Buddha nature manifest, to become a Buddha, because we see that right now we simply can’t help others the way that we’d like to. But it becomes even more profound on tantra. As I said, it requires an extraordinary level of compassion, but one that we are totally capable of generating.

So when it comes down to sort of summarizing, well, do we mean by this path to enlightenment? Because again, I don’t want to go too far into describing all the elements of that path to enlightenment, because that’s for module three. So module two, we’re going to learn more of the techniques of meditation, skill that we need to develop with our minds so that we can then focus on all these various meditations. In module three we’re going to do a full overview of kind of everything else that’s to come in discovering Buddhism. Then the rest of the modules are all going in-depth to the various topics, some of the key topics that help us to gain an appreciation for these teachings.

But at this point we could say that we could summarize everything that happens in terms of the Sūtra path, in terms of these main ideas that help drive you to achieving Buddhahood, in terms of three ideas, three concepts. And we will talk about these in module three again. But the very first one is some level of what we call renunciation. Now in the West, we have a really, almost a distaste for this word. Like, you you want me to be renounced.

What does that mean? You want me to walk around and eat nuts and berries from the bushes and wear sackcloth and live in a cave? Well, no, that’s not what renunciation is. That might be what it looks like for some people, but that’s not what it is because once again we’re talking about the mind. What is a renounced mind?

A renounced mind is a mind that has made the decision, through examining our situation very clearly, to get out of this situation. And we will be looking at this in detail in some of the other modules, where we begin to look at the Buddha’s very first teaching. When the Buddha became enlightened, he didn’t teach for about forty nine days, and then he finally started teaching. And his very first teaching was teaching on what’s called the Four Noble Truths, which some of you have heard of. And the first truth that he said was, Guess what?

The situation that you all are in, every one of us, isn’t so satisfactory. We like to think that we’re doing okay. We like to think, Oh, life’s going fine. How are you? I’m fine.

How are you? I’m fine. We all do that all day long. Are we really fine? Do we really find the peace and satisfaction that we’re seeking?

Have we found it yet? Mostly what we deal with is trying to keep the problems away and get more of the stuff that gives us some form of pleasure. Well, Buddha says that this isn’t a satisfactory result, because what do we have to show for it? We’ve been doing this all this life, and have we really found it? We’ve probably been doing it since beginningless time, if the Buddha’s teachings are correct.

And have we really found it? We’re still here, still getting reborn, still dealing with these lives. So at this level of renunciation, we mean kind of a turning away, a kind of acknowledging that what we have been doing hasn’t been satisfactory. And so we need to find a way out. We need to find some solution.

This is a fundamental level of spiritual realization that we all have to get to if we’re going to make our practice have any energy. Because if we kind of entertain Buddhism and we say, and again, I’m not putting this out there as a challenge to you right now, those of you who just started with discovering Buddhism, But at some point, we have to kind of, just as with any result, you have to make a commitment. You have to decide, is what I’m learning worthwhile for me to pursue? Is what I’m experiencing telling me that I need to find something to find a solution to this? This is the whole point of renunciation, is kind of acknowledging that the situation you’re in, as much as you might put blinders on or convince yourself that it’s okay, really isn’t okay.

Not to get you depressed. Not to get you to, you know, kind of go, Oh, what’s the point? It’s all miserable. Could take the Buddha’s teachings that way, but the Buddha didn’t stop at that first noble truth. He went on to say, Yeah, and there’s a reason why you’re in this state.

And that reason can be removed. And here’s how to do it. That’s the Four Noble Truths, basically. You’re in a situation that’s not so great. Here’s why.

You can be in a better situation, and I’ll tell you how. And the Buddha’s path to enlightenment fills out the rest of that. But at some level, it begins with this first of what we call the three principal aspects of the path: renunciation. Renunciation might start initially with some renouncing of this life, my strong attachment, just getting distracted by the pleasures of this life and totally caught up in the problems of this life, and acknowledging that there’s something beyond this life. And eventually wishing for the peace, the nirvana that we can have beyond this life.

The second principal aspect is what we call Bodhicitta. Again, B O D H I is the first part, bodhi. This is, as I said, that root word that means awakening, enlightenment. And then chitta, C H I T T A, is usually how it’s spelled in English. In the Sanskrit, it’s just a single C, but it’s got a diacritical mark, so it’s got that Chita sound.

Chita means mind. So mind of awakening, mind of enlightenment. Bodhicitta is the second principal aspect of the path, because we need that. As I said earlier, that’s what drives us to fully potentialize our Buddha nature. It’s a mind that is not only intent on getting out of the situation for ourselves, but intent on getting everyone else out of that situation.

Because we begin to acknowledge the connection we have to others. There is no such thing. I remember there was this song, I don’t remember what the musical was that it was from, called No Man is an Island. We like to somehow think that we’re our own little self sufficient unit. I can take care of myself.

I don’t need other people in my life. The reality is, is there anything that you have that isn’t dependent upon other people in your life? Might have to think a while to come up with an answer to that. In some way, yeah, we’ve got our mind that has this kind of continuity that is our own essence, if you will. But even this body that we have Did you get your body by yourself?

Was it fully you involved in this? No, there were two other people involved in this. Your mother and your father gave you this body. You were dependent upon them for this body. And when you were young, were dependent upon your mother, even if it wasn’t your birth mother, if you happened to get raised by someone who was not your birth mother.

You were dependent upon another being to take care of you, or you wouldn’t be here today. You are not self sufficient, I hate to say. And the clothes you wear, the car you drive, the food you eat. You might think, well, I grow my food on my own, and I sew my own clothes. You can become fairly self sufficient to some degree, but at some point you’re relying on other beings, too.

There are other beings involved in your welfare. Bodhicitta is about opening up to that connection and saying, I’m not apart. I’m not separate from all these other beings. Their welfare is as important, if not more important, than my own welfare. Because they are many, and I’m only one.

But as I was saying earlier, the Dalai Lama points out that actually my own fulfillment is manifest when I actually get focused on the welfare of others. Was really touched yesterday. I saw on the news this Canadian couple that won eleven million dollars in the lottery. They were interviewed. They actually talked about how horrible it was when they had all this money, and all the people that kept wanting it.

They eventually gave almost all of it away. I don’t know what they kept for themselves, but it was a very insignificant part of eleven million dollars And the man was saying how good this made him feel to just give all this money away. We know from our own experience that we have had those times when it’s felt really good to be genuinely concerned about the welfare of others. And oftentimes, that’s when we feel the most connected and most in touch with this sense of Buddha nature, this sense of who we really are, is when our hearts have opened up to the reality of the suffering of others. We’ve been able to be with them in a really genuine, compassionate way.

This is what Bodhicitta is telling us, is that our true potential is to be this immensely compassionate being that is concerned about the welfare of all. That’s what Bodhicitta is. It’s saying, Okay, I need to enact the welfare of others. I need to remove them from all their suffering, all their dissatisfaction. How will I do that?

The only way to do that is to become a Buddha. Because as a Buddha, you have this limitless compassion, limitless wisdom, limitless ability. All right. So that’s bodhicitta. That’s the second principal aspect.

We will go into again, bodhicitta is not an easy mind to develop, but there are techniques to do it, where you actually go through a process of thinking about various elements that enhance your love and compassion. One of the techniques involves this meditation called Tonglen that I mentioned earlier that I was introducing my father to. Tonglen is a very powerful way to create that compassionate connection to other beings that drives you to want to become enlightened. But it’s not the only way. There are other techniques that are taught.

The third mind that we have to develop, this third principal aspect that we could summarize the whole path to enlightenment in, is the wisdom of emptiness. And I already talked about that. It is a very profound level of mind that we eventually develop through our insight, our analysis of how things exist using reasoning, and eventually get that at a very deep level through our meditation. And it becomes the real mechanism for making fundamental changes in our mind. Because once we start removing that ignorance, then we start seeing things as they really are.

The compassion even is enhanced. The bodhicitta is enhanced because there’s nothing separating us from other beings. We are connected to everyone. Because we see how our minds have created that separation through my strong grasping at myself to exist in this way, and everyone else to exist in this concrete way. And in reality, that isn’t how we exist at all.

So again, I’m making these more kind of poetic allusions to emptiness. But when we get to the module on emptiness, it becomes very concrete and rooted in logic, rooted in analysis. This is what’s amazing, is we can gain an understanding emptiness and begin to live our lives with that wisdom to some degree. But it will need to be cultivated at a very, very deep level for us to make these fundamental shifts in our mind and our awareness. All right.

Questions? So today’s lecture was really about understanding, though we’ve touched on it here and there in this course, this idea of the potential. So we said mind and its potential. And as I said earlier, it’s not easy path to practice, but it’s one that we have to begin to move in that direction. And so all of Discovering Buddhism is to kind of help you put one foot in front of the other and begin to make some progress on that path.

I mean, the final result of Buddhahood I mean, I think we have this idea. This is another thing that I think we have to maybe examine is, well, I don’t want to be something other than what I am. People get quite content with some sense of their own identity. But a Buddha’s not that different in terms of the dimensions of their experience. Sure, they’re not captured and limited by the ways that we are.

But a Buddha has two aspects to their experience, just like we do. Each of us has our own personal dimension, our own minds that are ticking away as you’re hearing things and you’re processing in your own I’m using the brain up here but it’s wherever you have your consciousness, you’re kind of aware of all these things. And no one else has access to that, in a sense. You’re kind of in your own little private world. And then you have your interpersonal world, where you’re interacting with others.

And a Buddha, in a sense, is really not that different. A Buddha has their own kind of private wisdom dimension to their mind. Sure, it’s known by other Buddhas. Other Buddhas are all in that same state, as I was saying earlier. Kind of difficult to distinguish the consciousness of one Buddha from another.

But that’s their private world. That’s the world in which their own consciousness abides. But then a Buddha has an interpersonal aspect, just like we do. A Buddha’s involved in the world, just like we are. A Buddha has different ability, different skills, but is definitely not without that dimension of an interpersonal connection.

So I think that there’s, again, we might have this idea of, and it comes to some degree from a Judeo Christian idea of God being somewhere out there hanging around in some sort of realm of heaven or what have you, and us being kind of here all separate and isolated. But a Buddha is not like that. A Buddha is fully connected with all beings. Like I said, like the sun shining. Yeah, Rita.

Question. In developing your Buddha nature, do you know when you’re supposed to like last week we talked about separating from recognizing their views? How am I not being compassionate? Right. I mean, how do I do that?

Well, I think that comes with experience. But you’re bringing up a good point, which is that when we turn away from people in our lives that we feel don’t complement the path that we’re on and how we’re trying to develop our qualities, we don’t turn away from the compassion and love for them. And I think it comes down to really understanding what we mean by compassion and love. Because actually, we may find that those misleading people in our lives, or the difficult people in our lives, or whatever, are the ones that really help us to enhance our compassion, but not necessarily in their presence. Because at some level, if we acknowledge, Well, they’ve got kind of a lot of bad ideas.

They tend to say a lot of things that get me kind of wound up and going in a wrong direction. Well, then we have even more compassion for them because we see that they’re going in a wrong direction, that they’re doing things that are contrary to their well-being, to their Buddha nature. So from a distance we should always, I think the main technique is to always try to bring them into meditation, into our thoughts, in ways that express that genuine wish for them to be free of all these states of mind. How much more wonderful it would be for them and everyone that they know if they were espousing ideas and things that were wholesome and beneficial. So we always can have that perspective.

I said I would love for some of the people in the world that tend to be vilified to have true peace and compassion and loving kindness in their hearts. Why not? The world would be a much better place if all those people who are raising a lot of the problems in the world would become that. Again, I think what I was saying earlier in terms of it comes through experience. The experience of not just shutting the door to them, but of bringing them into your heart in terms of generating those feelings of love and compassion towards them.

But as I said, probably not in their presence, probably in your meditation. At some point, and this is the thing, this a factor that can influence your mind, is having people around you who sort of take you astray. But at some point, you may be strong enough in your own mind and your own practice where you can be with them and maybe become the scent of the sandalwood that makes their plain wood smell more like you and not you smell like them. That idea that I brought in last time when we talked about that, that you kind of take on the flavor of the people that you’re around. Well, you might be the flavor that they take on eventually, because you can be with them and be strong and secure enough in who you are that you’re not influenced by them.

So that can also be something that helps us in cultivating that love and compassion for them, is because we see that we still have some care and concern for them because they were friends of ours. They did play some role in our lives, and we’d really like to be able to benefit them. So therefore, we’ve got to be more beneficial to them. We have to have that firmer foundation in our own minds. But it’s a challenge.

It’s a real challenge, you know? Because people often put their own spin or their own interpretation on what we’re doing, because it’s often hard to explain it to people if you are. You know, I’m really trying to work on my patience, and I hate to say it, but you don’t help me. You know? No one wants to hear that.

That’s the reality of the situation. But at some point, we may actually find that they are a boon to our patience, and maybe they become more patient because they see how we’re practicing patience. But if we don’t have that removal I guess, I don’t know, I’m trying to think of a worldly example. If you were handling dangerous animals or something, you wouldn’t just start doing it without kind of generating some skill to be able to do that. I’m not calling them dangerous animals.

I’m just saying they can be dangerous to us. That was the point of talking about it last week, because they can take us astray. Well, we need to have more skills. We need to be better equipped. And we do that on our own, in private.

And then when we feel comfortable, we can be with them. Maybe help them. But a Buddha, again, when we go back to this idea of a Buddha having that interpersonal dimension, well, they’re going to kind of reflect in the way that is best suited to whoever they’re with. And in that way, I mean, if you look at His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, again, he manifests in so many different ways and with so many different people. Exactly in accord, it seems, with what they need in their lives.

This is what we mean by a Buddha. It’s just kind of that ability to have that interpersonal dimension that feels this connection and genuine concern for other people, for all beings. So we can practice now, though. Thanks for bringing that up. Right.

So let’s any other last comments or questions before I kind of do my final thoughts on this? Okay. So this goal of Buddhahood and this ultimate aim that we’re aspiring towards, as I said, it might seem like it’s way out there in the future. In tantra, we even try to bring it into the present, but the reality is that it still creates time. But there’s a saying that some of you may have heard in the past, which is, you know, the journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.

And I think that we have to acknowledge that what we’re talking about in this course, in Mind and Its Potential, is a journey of a thousand miles, is a journey of continually working on the mind for quite some distance. But it begins with a single step. It begins with your commitment to working on your mind and doing what you can in the moment as best as you can, and not beating yourself up about it when you don’t live up to your ideals or your standards, but just getting back up, brushing yourself off, and continuing the journey. Continuing to do what you can to develop that. Don’t make this into a race.

I think that a lot of people approach spirituality in the same way that they do a lot of their worldly endeavors and think, Well, you know, I have to get there before everyone else and do it as quickly as possible. Well, mean, if the motivation is pure, that’s okay. But for most of us, we just simply need that diligence, that one step at a time. And to close, I’ll just share the words that Venerable Robina shared with me when I first started learning Buddhism from her back in nineteen ninety six in San Francisco. But she heard these from her teacher, Lama Yeshe, which is slowly, slowly.

I asked a question in middle of one class. I said, Well, Venerable Robina, if you really get all this and you really believe it, don’t you just get there then? Don’t you just do everything you can to get there? And she says, Well, yes, dear, but slowly, slowly. So we have to kind of acknowledge that we’re sometimes our own worst enemy.

And so just be very kind with yourself. Whatever you’ve learned from this module, applying it to your life, be very kind and don’t think that, again, you have to become this immediately. That you’ll get there gradually, gradually. We’ll all get there because we all have Buddha nature. So next week, next Sunday, will be our practice morning.

Those of you who, again, are new to discovering Buddhism and that, sometimes we do a practice morning, sometimes we do a full day. But the idea behind it is that it gives us all a chance for a more focused way of doing meditation and practice together. So what we’ll do is we’ll start at nine o’clock next Sunday morning, and I’ll introduce the outline of what we’re doing at that time. It’ll be mostly meditation for about the first two hours or so, hour and a half. Not straight on two hours.

There’ll be small periods with breaks. And I will guide meditation during that period. And during that period we’re going to have kind of a request for silence. So that means that while we normally come here and when we break from something, we go talk and chat and what have you. There’ll be time for that later.

But for the morning when we’re meditating, we’ll stay focused without too much chatter. Then we’ll probably have a break sometime in there, and when we come back, do more of a discussion. And that will go until just about twelve thirty. So it will be about two hours or so of meditation, and then a little bit over an hour of discussion and review and talking about it. So even if you’re new to these classes, if you haven’t been to other ones, feel free to come to this, because it’s a nice opportunity to kind of review through the meditation some of the main topics that we’ve focused on, as well as to discuss other things, ideas that we’ve been going through in this first module.

At twelve thirty, I’d really love it if everyone brought something to share. We usually do a vegetarian potluck as part of these practice days, practice mornings. And then we make them vegetarian just out of respect for those in our community who are vegetarian, who don’t want to eat meat, who made that decision. We don’t go so far as vegan. That would be maybe a little extreme for a lot of people that don’t have that in their lives.

But yeah, if you could bring something that you could share. And it’s weird, we don’t ever assign the dishes and somehow they all end up being complementary and a full array of stuff. So I think that will probably still continue to happen without needing to assign dishes. So just bring whatever you would like to share if you want to stay for lunch. And that will go from twelve thirty to about one thirty, at which time we actually are going to have a puja, a Tārā puja, which those of you who haven’t been to pujas, if you’d like to stay and do that, it’s about an hour and a half or so of a ceremony of working with green Tārā, this energy of enlightened activity in our lives, and reciting some praises to Tārā.

Can be a very lively practice. So if you’d like to join us for that, that would be great. Just so you know, the following weekend is Buddhism in a Nutshell, which I think Claudio announced. He didn’t, Judith Bailey will be here teaching that on Saturday and Sunday. That’s the weekend that I’m leading a meditation retreat away from here.

And then the following weekend is Thanksgiving, but we are doing a program here on that Sunday morning meditation at nine And then at ten o’clock, investigating the mind. It’s a video, some video excerpts from one of the MindLife conferences that I’ll be here showing the videos and leading a discussion on some of what’s discussed there between modern behavioral scientists and His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, in terms of this common ground that they’re finding looking at the mind and Buddhism. The next module, just the last part of the announcements, the next module will be the very first Sunday in December, which is, I believe, the third, is it? Let’s see. No.

No. It’s got to be Sunday would be the fifth or something. I think in my head, because November thirtieth is a Tuesday. That’s when my mom goes back. My mom leaves.

She’s coming for Thanksgiving. First, second, third, fourth, fifth, fifth, okay. All right. So the fifth will start how to meditate. And how to meditate, I think, is about five classes, so we won’t have the time to complete it before holidays.

But we will get at least three of the classes done in December. When we come back, we’ll continue those in January because we will have a break during the holiday period since a lot of people travel and have other commitments. We don’t usually schedule classes during that time. That’s just a little preview for those of you who want to know where we’re going from here. All right.

So I don’t think we got the list passed around for the dedications today. And I apologize for that. I’m not sure where it went to. It was over there before. Maybe it’s over there now.

I don’t know. But it’s too late for getting it. So let’s go ahead and just do a short meditation where we kind of seal this energy that we’ve created, and then that will be the conclusion to today. So we’ve spent about two and a half hours here together. And in this time, we’ve had this motivation we started with at the beginning of this class, thinking that we want to be here to use this human life well to create the temporal and ultimate results that will be the source of happiness and well-being for ourselves and for others.

So now we kind of seal this energy for that result that we now have this label of Buddhahood, sanghye, to become fully purified, fully developed, so that we can then help others. And everything that we did today, may this become a cause for us to be able to achieve that result, For all beings to be able to achieve that result. And moreover, may this also be the cause for the removal of suffering, the dissatisfaction that those beings that we know of in this world right now are experiencing. So, again, since we didn’t pass around the list, you can just mentally think about those beings in your life who you know who are experiencing obstacles. Or maybe they are ill, dealing with sickness.

Or maybe they’re dying even, or who have died recently. And think about sharing this positive energy with them. Just kind of send it out from your own heart and feel that it touches them. And if they were experiencing obstacles, they become free of those. If they were experiencing illness, all the causes of their illness, completely gone.

They’re in perfect health. If they’re dying or have died, they have attained everything that they need to go into the next life with perfect opportunity, perfect conditions to find the peace and happiness they seek. And then finally, to conclude, we can also dedicate for the good health and long lives of all the spiritual teachers in this tradition, His Holiness the Dalai Lama and our spiritual director, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, other teachers that have come here and connected with us and also for all the spiritual teachers in every tradition, those beings who are dedicated to helping others to find peace and happiness, to tap into that pure, essential nature that is compassionate and kind and loving. And in this way, transform this world and all the beings into it into an incredible place, a place beyond our imagination. Okay, thank you all very much.

Appreciate everyone being here. And if you have any other questions, I’ll be around for a little bit if you need to ask. Those of you who missed some of the earlier handouts and that, I have some of them here, but I might need to run upstairs and photocopy. But if you want to hang out for a bit, I’d be happy to get those to you.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
yana
Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top