1 h 50 min · 12,015 words · 11 April 2007 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 110-minute dialogue from the 2007 Mind and Life Institute meeting, His Holiness the Dalai Lama engages with neuroscientist Richard Davidson on bridging first-person meditative experience and third-person brain measurement. Davidson presents laboratory data showing that highly trained Buddhist practitioners meditating on open presence and compassion display strong neural-experiential correlation: as their subjective clarity ratings fluctuate during practice, gamma-frequency oscillations in the frontal brain regions track these changes with striking precision, a pattern absent in novices. The Dalai Lama then offers an extended Buddhist explanation of consciousness across three dimensions—gross, subtle, and extremely subtle—describing the eighty mental processes that dissolve at death, the intermediate state, and rebirth as a continuum grounded in pure awareness. He discusses advanced practices involving lucid dreaming and yogic breath control as potential research avenues, and addresses how meditative mastery relates to consciousness independent of brain activity. The dialogue concludes with clarification from Buddhist epistemologists on how perception and conceptualization form a spectrum, and Matthieu Ricard on bare consciousness as a primary phenomenon with its own continuity.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Mind and Life XIV Dialogue on The Universe in a Single Atom; April 11 2007 (D….mp3
UUID: 1090f9e1-7eb5-441b-a4ec-22c52575cd08
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Dalai Lama Talks
Date: 2007 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~12,010
Your Holiness, we will continue with the theme of consciousness. And what I’d like to do for the next few minutes is to give a short presentation that follows directly from a theme that you introduced in your book that really very much comes from the work of Francisco. And I’d like to begin with two quotes, and this is in regard to the integration of first and third person methods. And these are two quotes from your book. The first says, a comprehensive scientific study of consciousness must therefore embrace both third person and first person methods.
It cannot ignore the phenomenological reality of subjective experience but must observe all the rules of scientific rigor. Here, I feel a close collaboration between modern science and the contemplative traditions such as Buddhism could prove beneficial. And the next quote, I believe that it is possible for Buddhism and modern science to engage in collaborative research in the understanding of consciousness while leaving aside the philosophical question of whether consciousness is ultimately physical, but we’ll come back to that. By bringing together these two modes of inquiry, both disciplines may be enriched. It is in that spirit that, I would like to show you some actual data that we have collected in our laboratory that is inspired by these comments, by this view, and by the work that Francisco, began.
And this is work that’s been continued in my laboratory by Antoine Lutz, who is a graduate student of Francisco’s, who who I think is here somewhere. There’s Antoine. So in this experiment, we have long term practitioners, and they are engaged in meditation practice. And we have them rating with a keyboard. So they, they have a keyboard which they are pressing during meditation, and they rate on a one to nine point scale variations in the clarity of their experience.
And so what we see is that through their experience, there is some variation. They may begin during meditation to start at a low number, like one or two or three that we see here. And then as their meditation deepens, it can go to five or six or seven and so on. So it changes during the meditation period. During the meditation So what kind of you are talking about?
You are they meditating on single pointedness? We have done this with with open presence meditation as well as with compassion. What do you mean by here? So It says that, you know, there could be the clarity of the object, the image of the object, or it could be clarity of the actual subjective experience. So the clarity can mean two different things.
You change. Change Oh, I think in this case, it was the clarity of the experience. Yes. Yes. That’s right.
Object is meditation, and principle is meditation. So, as we have seen, we I showed some of these results, before. But just to remind you, your holiness, during meditation, what we see is there is a change in a signal in the brain that is the kind of signal that Wolf Singer described in the oscillations, in this high frequency range, the gamma range of brain, oscillations. And, if you look at the right hand graph, we have the novices and we have the long term practitioners and you can see that during the meditation practice, there is a much larger increase in this gamma signal in the brain of the long term practitioners compared to the novices. The question though is how does the variation, the changes in the brain oscillations relate to the changes in the experience that the practitioners report in in the clarity of their experience.
And so here is one example. Now the red line is corresponds to the rating that the practitioner gives for the clarity of his experience during the the meditation. So as this red line goes from low levels to higher levels, the clarity increases. But we encourage the practitioner to report with total honesty about their experience. And so if there’s a dip in the clarity momentarily, they should tell us that there is a dip.
And so you can see here the red line goes down and there’s a dip, and then it goes back up. And there’s some variation over the course of the meditation. The blue line is the gamma signal, the signal from the brain. And what we see is really a remarkable close correspondence between the variation in clarity and the variation in the brain signal that we record. So as the clarity goes up, the brain signal goes up, and as the clarity goes down, the brain signal goes down.
And for this kind of research, this is a very close correspondence between a a first person report and a third person measurement. This is not unique to just one practitioner. We have seen this pattern in every long term practitioner that we have studied. So here’s another example. This is from a different practitioner, but it is across different days.
So we had the practitioner come back on several different days and different meditation periods each day and each time. What the difference is between morning and afternoon, morning and evening? Not systematic that yeah. We haven’t studied that. So we don’t know.
It’s the Mhmm. But, generally, morning is thought to be better for the clarity of the subject of experience. We did most in the morning. Yeah. Most of them have been in the morning.
But what is really striking Oh, He was wondering whether they’d eaten or not. Breakfast or not. We feed our practitioners very, very well. Yes. Of Of course.
My only question was, yeah, when the experiment was being done, you know, is it just soon after what they have eaten? Only. No. For example, some of you see yoga practice prefer empty stomach. So it’s just some because of the relations about our because of brain activities.
Brain activity. And digestion. And digestion. Yeah. And and digestion.
Oh, okay. It’s a good question, your holiness. We have not studied that. But what again, what You want to explain that? Yeah.
His Holiness was requesting, you know, and that’s something we have been very aware of. Is in the meditation of compassion. There are two kinds. One is based on focusing on the person who is suffering and giving rise to a powerful feeling of compassion that is the wish that suffering may be removed and the causes of suffering. And then what we try to, in this case, the non-referential or unconditional compassion, which is a general feeling of loving kindness and compassion, but not specifically with an object.
And what I mentioned to his own is that we definitely need to study both because they’re probably quite different. And one of the reason why we decided to choose, I think, the beginning whether this was the right choice is because if we have an object, then it will also involve visual areas, memories, all kinds of other emotions. Exactly. And our idea was if if the practitioner can generate a very pure feeling of compassion, we have more chance to sort of isolate what compassion alone could do in the brain. But definitely, we should extend to empathic compassion, which is really based on the on the suffering person.
But the the choice was made for experimental reasons to to first start with nonreferential compassion. So what this life shows, your holiness, is each, label here, a one, a two, a three, each of those is a different practitioner. And, the blue line is the correlation between the gamma signal in the brain and the phenomenological report, the first person report, and, for different meditation blocks for each of the practitioners. And what is striking is that, virtually every one of these blue lines is really quite high. And so there’s considerable consistency across all of the practitioners in showing this very striking association.
Usually, when we do these kinds of studies, we have to average across many people to see results. What we see here are significant results in each individual practitioner in showing a significant association between their first person report and the third person measurement from the brain. So this this summarizes the the findings from nine long term practitioners. Now here, if you just pay attention to the right side of the figure, which is for the gamma, activity, what you can see in one second. Maybe we should.
Can someone switch off that light over there? No. No. No. Over there.
There’s a switchboard on the back there. It’s okay. So what we very good. Thank you. What we can see is that the the correlation between the first person report and the third person measurement is stronger in the this is looking down at the head.
It’s stronger in this is the frontal region, and you can see it very clearly here. So, in this red area is where you see the higher correlation between the reports of the practitioners and the changes in the brain. So it’s not something that you see everywhere. You see it in most striking in the, frontal region of the brain here. So those are the findings that we have observed relating the third person measurement to the first person reports.
And, one of the hypotheses which motivates this work is that among individuals who have cultivated their mind, who have spent years training their mind, we actually should observe a much stronger correlation between the reports of their experience and changes in the brain. And this is exactly what we are finding here. The correlations between their reports and what we observe in the brain are quite striking and higher than what we typically see in individuals who have not trained their mind. Sure. So I wanna end this very short presentation with two questions for your holiness.
The first question is according to the Buddhist view, there there is a certain kind of primary or fundamental consciousness that can be separated from separate from biology. And if this is true, can you provide a Buddhist account of how consciousness and changes in the brain can become so intimately correlated as we’ve just seen here? Yeah. Of these are really we are talking at the level of what Buddhist would call gross level of consciousness. So Your Holiness, can can you I understand that the in the Buddhist conception, there are three different dimensions or or, types of consciousness, gross, subtle.
Yes. And and I wonder if you can help the scientists understand more about this so that we can understand what our measurements may actually be relating to. So yeah. So we already had We already had some reference to this idea of different stages of dissolution of consciousness, you know, finally converging upon this very subtle state of consciousness which is this nonduality of subtle energy and and awareness. So we spoke about from the Buddhist point of view a point where there are there is a dissolution described of what is known as the eighty conceptions indicative of mental processes.
Conception is not the right term, but for for want of a better word. So eighty types of thoughts that are indicative of mental processes. So so, basically, the various levels of consciousness are really seen as expressions of the different levels of activity of this energy, vāyu or lung. And within this reality of the mental experiences, we speak of different types of thoughts or or mental states. There is a list of 80 that are indicative of the mental processes that dissolve
The point of death. So this has been, you know, listed by Nāgārjuna in one of the texts. Texts. So these are the these are the mental processes identified by Nāgārjuna that dissolve that the dissolution of which marks the point of death. And then so up to that point, you know, the mental processes would be all seen as being based upon biology, on on brain.
So when that point arrives, the con conscious experiences cease and breathing processes come to an end. So and and then the next stage is referred to as appearance. And then there’s another stage increasingly now subtle. So the appearance So again, this English term appearance is is is dangerous. So even in the Tibetan term, we have this ambiguity and and misleading kind of potential for misleading, but it is it’s not in the sense of a a a conscious perceptual experience that has appearances to it.
But the term appearance is used. The the next stage after that is known as the increase. There’s a different way of describing these different four stages of dissolution that marks the important points of dissolution which uses the language of emptiness, the term emptiness. Now, this is different from the philosophical concept of emptiness. Here, emptiness is the emptying of mental processes.
So when the 80 conceptions indicative of mental processes sees, that’s the first stage of emptiness and then simply referred to as emptiness. The next stage is attained when a kind of a slightly subtler levels of consciousness and the medium or or the vāyu, the energy ceases. So this stage is referred to as great empty. And then Yeah. The great empty.
Well, then you have empty. Extremely empty. Sorry. Very empty. Very empty or extremely empty.
And then the next phase is referred to as the great empty. And so the final phase is referred to as the total total emptiness. So that marks the the subtlest most state of awareness and that is referred to also as the clear light. And that’s the nondual, you know, energy and and consciousness. So just as there is a a dissolution process, you know, we kind of converging upon increasingly subtler state, you know, culminating at a point where there is total emptiness and just the clear light, this non dual energy and awareness.
Similarly, emergence of of embodiment is also seen in the total in exact opposite cycle. So from this total emptiness, the clear light state comes to a gross you know, comparatively grosser level, which is the next stage that evolves into a slightly grosser level. You know? At what point does it make contact with biology again? Yeah.
Okay. So after the fourth stage? The four period, the brain activity is completely stopped. So I think clinically that, but still some process. Some processes.
So it’s a it’s a it’s a complex it’s a it’s a complex question. And and also there an explanatory gap? And and and also we have to, you know, take into account the multiplicity of explanations within the Buddhist tradition itself. So you have, for example, with respect to the dying moment of consciousness in the Abhidharmakośa, which is the standard Abhidharma text, there is a discussion that the dying moment mental states can be a non virtuous, you know, kind of afflicted state of mind. Whereas when you move on Well, in the there is Well, the you know, his was saying that since this question has not been explicitly addressed in the text, so he has to speculate and he was saying it could be partly kind of a hit and miss, you know, shooting in the dark Mhmm.
In in the dark. So drawing from the various sources and one source is Abhidharmakośa which has a lot to say about the the the last moment of dying consciousness and the first moment of a rebirth, the consciousness at the first moment of a rebirth. In system, the first moment of the consciousness is the first moment of rebirth is defined as necessarily afflicted because rebirth is, you know, connected. The connection into the next birth is made through an afflicted state of mind. And in Asaṇga’s text, there doesn’t seem to be any explicit discussion of this.
But in so in other perspectives like in perfection of wisdom perspective, we tend to adopt the which is explicit statement. But to bring the perspective, then it is understood that advanced meditator can consciously take rebirth. And and in that way, they can actually the the first moment of a consciousness in a new birth can be also a virtuous state of mind. So to go back to the question of how does this subtle awareness of consciousness connect to the the new body. In in in the Buddhist language, it is the new the new body.
So so imagine so a person, a human being dies, goes through this dissolution processes. And when reaches the final state of total emptiness, which is the clear light, then from that state, the next level of evolvement, you know, evolution would be to connect with the re intermediate state. The end of the clear light. End of the clear light. Then depart from the body.
So then that connects with the intermediate state, So we believe those people who remain the although clinically dead, but body still remain fresh Mhmm. Because of clear light, still there Mhmm. Mhmm. In the body. Although brain work because of the brain function completely ceased.
So and then so from this, once the clear light state ends, then the consciousness leaves the body and then connects with the intermediate state which is a subtle state of embodiment and goes through this kind of reversal process. And when the intermediate state existence connects with a new birth, it’s saying a conception, that first instance of consciousness in that conception is thought to be actually the clear light state. And then from there, it, you know, evolves into this grosser levels. So when the 80 conceptions indicated with mental processes begin, that’s when the the the full embodiment, you know, the the kind of biological processes begin from there. And then from that point onwards, there is a much clearer description in this text.
For example, there is a text called the entry into the womb, Nanda’s Entry into the Womb Sūtra. And there’s also a text on dependent origination which describes in fairly quite detailed way the developmental processes of the fetus and when the sensory faculties develop and the limbs arises and and all of these are developed, presented in a developmental process. His Holiness is asking one of the monks here whether he has a clearer memory of a particular text as this text explicitly talks about the the these processes that we have been discussing. So once the connection is made This raises a very difficult question and complicated question about whether or not this kind of phenomena can be, you know, observable through the the scientific experiments that we are talking about. One way is to to, you know, make the observation based upon a person who is dying going through the dying process and is in the clear light state, which is, of course, raises some other ethical questions and so on.
First person a chairman, do I? Because one of the downside of that is that disadvantage of that is that there is no first first, you know, possibility of a first person as, you know, self report over there. Now, the other option is to really find an advanced meditator who has attained this state realization. But here While still alive. No.
So That’s that’s very high sort of the experience. We are at a stage. But it is from the the Buddhist understanding. It’s a very we’re talking about a highly advanced state of realization, and there’s a technical term. So in fact, now so Oh, yeah.
So it will have to be someone who has attained a state which is referred to as the illusory body attainment. And and and you’re talking about such an advanced state. In fact, in in in the tradition, according to the tradition is who can actually dissolve all the gross level of mind as As it it occurs at the time of death. Then that person reach that experience, then almost certain within lifetime, he can enlighten. Become fully enlightened.
Yeah. So his holiness was saying that So that is very rare. I think regarding our circumstances, I think almost impossible. But you see the training of that stage by stage. So there are different So some yeah.
Preliminary way. Yeah. Preliminary stage. So Or practice that, I think possible. We may find some person.
But so I don’t know. Maybe. We should find. I don’t know. So his holiness was saying, for example, like Then also, you see the I think very good sort of basis to investigate person who actually control dream.
For that, firstly, is it the cap capacity realized dream is dream. Recognition of dream is a bit like lucid dreaming. Yeah. Then during dream, they according their own wish, Mhmm. You see, can perform with different dreams.
Direct their dreams. Oh. Mhmm. There, I think we can test some of these such persons who have actually power of control dream that eventually very possible to to to Go through the resolution process. Right.
To experience deep sleep. At that moment, clear light state of the sleep experiencing. So some way, there are some possibility to test. Test. The point is all I’m just making is that somewhat analogous processes do occur naturally when we, you know, in our day to day life when we go to sleep through the dreaming.
So from a waking state, when you go through the sleep state, the dream state is a slightly subtler state and then the deep sleep state is a state is a comparatively subtler state to this. So we are we go through sleep state. An analogous pro a process. Three years ago, I met one French. He claimed to me he had a very clear sort of experience about dream body depart from his usual body.
I was skeptical. I don’t so so sometimes some westerners is a little bit dizzy. So really, don’t know whether that’s reliable or not. I don’t know. But in Tibetan, some Tibetan also used to have some strange sort of experience.
Old body remain here one week, but the dream body depart actually from that body and visit different places. After a week, you return, then that person clearly describe what happened other places. But during that period, whether you see the one one the one official, now no longer, he served with me in in fifties like that, his own mother. So, actually, it’s happened that kind of experience. So body all body remain here.
Looks like that. But but but yeah. Now if such things happen today, then I think a very good opportunity to test what’s the brain Mhmm. Brain movement. So so his was to to conclude the translation How do you say?
So in a sense, Holiness is saying that although we we do not have these advanced realized meditators, but he’s kind of, wetting your appetite and to tease you. What what So to finish the translation, His Holiness was saying that although from the kind of a a a a textual description point of view, for for example, like in the Guhyasamāja Tantra, many of these capacities are characteristics of a very advanced state. But somewhat analogous processes do occur naturally and particularly with yogis who may have the capacity for lucid dreaming and also regulating their dream. For these kind of individuals, it may be possible that they can once they have attended capacity to then go through the dissolution processes in the dream state and then have a a somewhat similar experience. And sleep state.
Sleep state. Deep deep sleep. Deep deep sleep And state. Then it might allow some possibility of doing some kind of experiments. What is the prevalence of that in the population?
That is the capacity to to do this during the dream state. Roughly, what percentage? There might be individuals, but There was some experiment done on was a great practitioner. He was And also And also some practitioner. And now most of them gone.
They are not waiting. Our experiment. Yeah. May may I ask a question, his holiness? Some of the states that you have just been describing, they can be occurring under pathological conditions.
There are certain psychosis where you have these out of body experiences. There are certain neurological diseases especially with lesions in the parietal lobe where people report exactly what you said, that they have their body lying and they see themselves floating above. And they can be mimicked. States can also be generated now with virtual reality by making you behave and experiencing you through goggles and television systems in a completely different coordinate system. And if you do this for a while, you get you get the illusion that you leave your body and walk behind yourself.
Some of the of these states you described like this clear light state is reported by people while they faint and when they come out of coma. Now, the worry I’m having a little bit is these are all borderline conditions where the brain processes dissociate, where the normal coordination of brain processes doesn’t function anymore. Now, is it a goal of deep meditation to dissociate brain processes, to keep things apart, to make them fall apart so that you are left with isolated modules that then give you these very, very impressive but very rare experiences. And this probably could be investigated whether you can, by internal training, decompose what is normally linked because I just wanted to say one thing about the term meditation here. Just a footnote that, this is a particular kind of meditation, that is actually not that widely practiced and that we wouldn’t want to say, for example, that meditation on simple mindfulness on the breath would have the same types of effects or that it would have anything to do with probably more integrative than it is about dissociation.
So just a footnote in terms of what we mean by meditation there. And also one striking feature is the few very exceptional meditators we are speaking about, we are mentioning a few names. Those are the most remarkable human beings among all those whom we have met. So in another way, they don’t exhibit any of, say, fringe sort of behavior or state of mind or being at the edge of being whatever you might say. From other aspects, they’re extremely well emotionally balanced, serene, peaceful, and whatever.
So it comes more as an apex of developing qualities rather than going sort of weird symptoms of pathological states. I wouldn’t I am not saying that it is pathological. We know, for example, that people who had been in these extreme states Yeah. I mean, there may be a virtue to it because there are these many reports that people who have, because of a disease process or a trauma or whatever, gone into these extreme states, they have changed personality. They have become very, very integrated, humble, and because they learned the borders of their existence.
So can get that experience also. It could be that getting yourself into these extreme experiences helps you enormously to manage your normal life. You can have both. I don’t think it’s mutually exclusive. So, Your Holiness, I’d like to just end with a with, I think, a less controversial and and more mundane question for you, which is, we in the experiments that I described, we had practitioners rate the clarity of their experience.
And I wonder just in terms of helping us with the research in the future, what other dimensions or qualities of experience do you think could be most profitably studied in this way? Qualities that might vary within a practitioner and that may have important consequences for for our life. I don’t know. Do you mean do you mean especially Do you mean especially characteristics that would you would be have and are are you interested in other kinds of of phenomenally reportable first person characteristics that might track very clearly onto neuronal correlates? Is that what you’re asking about?
Yes. That that may vary over the course of meditation practice or may vary as a practitioner gets more advanced But then it will contrasting terms of different brain correlates. So we’ve looked at just one dimension, clarity, but there are many, many dimensions presumably of reportable experience. So the the first thing probably would be to find people that you can experiment on and then see how basically it’s kind of a trial and error. You keep asking the different aspects, but the problem is It’s so difficult to find first person.
I don’t know. I think this morning is we touched secular ethics here. Ethics law. My interest is in the secular ethics on that level, not just this Buddhist Buddhist Buddhist thing. Oh.
So then, I think secular ethics means religion-public. Some of these individual special case of individual’s experience. In any case, not much of a use for public. So for normal way or average way to to to investigate about mental function, I think we already usually carry. So one thing that might be helpful is that to find practitioners who specialize the the the kind of the We call it energy.
The practice of the energy, the prana or vāyu. And these exist among non-Buddhist schools as well, institutions as well. Oh, non-Buddhist. In remote place, some sadhus there. I met few.
I don’t know. With really reliable or not, I don’t know. If we find, you know, some people who already have the ability of control breathing and without breath, remain, say, one hour, two hours. Two hours without Breathing. Without Breathing.
So is the oxygen done? So that means there is no intake of oxygen. So that also really worthwhile to experiment. From a Buddhist viewpoint, these are not necessarily, I say, because of the spirituality. It’s simply, see, exercise, physical exercise.
Skills. Skills. Skills. So given that we are talking about something that could be applicable in the secular wider secular ethics kind of context, those skills that are cultivated through the the practice of the pranayama, the the energy manipulation or whatever you Breath control. Breath control.
These because they are not tied to specific religious ideas and they will be, you know, much more amenable to this kind of secularization. His Holiness is asking Professor Samdhong Rinpoche who’s the director of Central Institute in Sarnath. His Holiness was asking whether he has seen or heard Varanasi is the center of ancient Indian Spirituality. Spirituality. And the munis usually used to gather there.
So in any case, I met quite I think in the one time I mentioned, usually, some sadhus, I think a few dozen over there. No. Right. Right. But, you know, thirty forty thirty forty.
Probably naked. So I was told that some of them remain whole year in snow mountain. So unless, you see, there’s some practice, yoga practice, and usually we call inner heat Mhmm. Or tumu. Without that practice, impossible to remain whole year in the mountain, in snow mountain.
Oh, some may be very. Liar. Liar. Liar. Yeah.
But some very possible. I think the the I mean, worldwide. You see, you should invest in that. Enquire. Enquire.
If we find someone, then eventually, of course, firstly, we should get permission from that person, perhaps with some money.
We go to Adam for that. Oh, yes. Yes. Yes. I think if we find this is some such person.
I think really worldwide. Yeah. That’s who will not be. Your Your Holiness, the plan for this afternoon is for John to give a presentation of for the scientists to about consciousness from the Abhidharma perspective. Or yeah.
More or less. More or less. Mhmm. And then Matthieu is going to talk also a little bit about consciousness from the Buddhist perspective to familiarize the scientists with the with these views, and that will hopefully stimulate some discussion. Before we get to that, Ben wanted to make a comment about some of the, the information that you presented to us, some of your comments from the, last session just before the tea break.
So I’ll just ask Ben to make these Your Holiness, as a physician listening to the states that one can get into in the clear light state of suppressing so much of the body’s metabolic function, it seemed initially to me that this was so miraculous that it was hard to imagine how it would occur. And during the tea break, Joan Halifax and I were talking about this. She suggested that there might be great medical utility if one could If one could do this for people, for example, undergoing life threatening surgery or people suffering wounds where they might be having excessive blood loss if one could voluntarily induce this. When, of course, the stories are anecdotal, so it was hard to know how one could ever do that. But in the conversation, I remembered that, that, in fact, we have the capability in our bodies to synthesize hormones that will suppress metabolism.
And one, we we have we synthesize many hormones in our body that do different types of processes. Some of these are gases. It turns out that we have the capability to synthesize hydrogen sulfide gas, which in high concentrations is a toxic gas, but we can make that in our bodies. Chemically, we have the capability of doing that. And I just participated Doctor.
In, in beginning a company that is using hydrogen sulfide gas administered to people to suppress metabolism so that they can undergo surgery. So only when I thought about this in the context of these people did I realize that this might be an avenue to understanding how these people are able to do this remarkable thing. It is it is reasonable. It is scientifically reasonable that somehow in the practice, these people learn how to change their metabolism. It would be a very unusual thing.
And and and they if they could elevate their levels, we all have hydrogen sulfide gas in our body circulating all the time. That’s just a normal but it’s at a very low level. If we could elevate that to the levels that we’re using in this company therapeutically, one would have the same effect as you’re describing, not necessarily on the mental side, but on the physical side of maintaining the body in a suppressed metabolic state and allowing it to go on with no evidence of respiration, no evidence of heartbeat. Animals put in this position and so forth, we’re bringing this into human clinical trials now. But animals in this position have no heartbeat.
They have no respiration. When you remove the hydrogen sulfide gas, they come back and are perfectly normal. So it’s conceivable. This is a high obviously a wild hypothesis, but it is conceivable that these people have have learned with their practice a way of regulating the amount of this gas to bring it to a level where it would do what we’re doing in this company pharmaceutically as a drug, but they may be able to do it on their own. And I just thought that was an interesting link with the with physical reality of this miraculous behavior that that you’ve described.
There are two. Because the meditator is actually an embodied person whose existence is directly tied to the physical Absolutely. Body he has. Yeah. Thank you.
So this morning, Richie Davidson asked me if I would speak a little bit about, some basic aspects of Buddhist models of consciousness. Obviously, this is not for the edification of or, as I said, or any of the collected scholars here, but rather primarily for, the audience members and for the scientists to help facilitate a little bit the discussion that might clarify some issues as we go forward. And the first one I’ll be speaking about is is the notion of the mental stream of consciousness, which is the concept that consciousness flows through time as discrete moments. And I see we lack a little contrast there. You.
Hopefully, it’s alright. So what we have are, one moment of consciousness, causally producing the next moment of consciousness, cause causally producing the next moment of consciousness. This is the basic Buddhist model of consciousness when consciousness is considered from what would would be considered the conventional perspective. And when we take So from a conventional perspective, we would speak of consciousness as moments of each moment, a discrete moment, causally producing the next moment, causally producing the next moment. And we can take one moment of consciousness and discuss it, using a system what is of what’s called mind and mental functions or, and I’m drawing on a particular text by Kachen Yeshe Gyaltsen.
And in that in that context, we would say that in each moment of consciousness, which remember is a causal product. Too bad about the contrast. I think the the projectors are said wrong, actually. There are five there must be five corded mental functions with each moment of consciousness. Then these five are called feeling or feeling tone, which is going to be positive, negative, or neutral, or we can even say pleasant or unpleasant or neutral.
Discrimination, which has to do with somehow picking or picking out or selecting out the object, attention, contact with the object, and then, intentionality or cetana. Now in addition to these five, these must be minimally present for a moment of consciousness to occur. In addition to these five, at least under normal conditions, there will be another five. And these other five will occur, which are aspiration, interest, mindfulness, which is often translated as mindfulness, although that’s incorrect, really, You really call it samadhi or focus? Right now.
It’s better than mindfulness anyway. We won’t get into it, will we? We can. And this the problem just to mention briefly, this is the term Smriti in Sanskrit. The problem with the mindfulness is that there’s a usage of mindfulness in the psychological literature that that does not at all map onto Smriti.
So it’s very confusing to translate it as mindfulness, especially in this context. Charlotte, slow down. Okay. So we have aspiration, interest, focus, concentration, and discernment. Now the reason I’m mentioning these and going rather quickly through them is that I’m not sure that the details of these particular functions are of of great importance.
What is important is the distinction between a, consciousness which only has these five and a consciousness which has the other five, a moment of consciousness. Because when all of the other five are present, then that consciousness produces a kind of cognition which is fully determinant, which fully determines its object. That is to say, it’s going to be a conceptual cognition that correctly characterizes its object in a conceptual fashion. Whereas when only the these first five are present, that kind of conceptual cognition is not occurring. Alright?
Now it’s not necessarily the case that all five need to be present for conceptual consciousness to occur. You And there are many details and much discussion, and this this is debated on the debating grounds. And we could certainly get into those details, but I’ll avoid them for the moment since I I wouldn’t win any of the debates anyway, I’m sure. A basic model of perception in Buddhism is that an object interacts with the sense faculty to produce an image in consciousness. So we have an external object, and this is based on assist a lower system, again, a conventional account.
I’m going to be following a system that’s often thought of as the Sautrāntika system or Dharmakīrti system. And so an object interacts with the sense faculties to create an imaging consciousness. And if we think of this as a causal process flowing through time, what we really have are three discrete entities. We have, first of all, here, a physical object, then we have the sense faculties, which are gonna be made of a subtle kind of physical matter, and then we have consciousness itself. Now this is represented as an empty box.
So then what happens is that this, that we have we get an interaction in this first moment between the sense faculty and consciousness. And then in the next moment, although it may take more more than just one moment, it may take more than one moment, we’ll be represented at this at as the second time, we get a representation of this object in consciousness. So consciousness is flowing along, and it because of the interaction of the sense faculty with the object, it’s that interaction changes, conditions consciousness in such a way that it that it arises with an image. Now, of course, also the the faculty, the body, in effect, is also flowing through time, and the object is flowing through time. Now, technically, in this system, we don’t what we’re actually contacting in in sensation, this representation called the nampa in Tibetan, is the effect of this object in consciousness.
This object presumably continues to flow through time, but we no longer have direct contact with that object. Now in a subsequent moment, which we’ll say is time three, but in fact, there may be many moments between the two. In a subsequent moment, what happens is that this this image, which will be called perception, this is a perceptual image. Okay? So an actual moment of perception is this image.
So that will be called the object image. And in fact, the box, we could say, represents subjectivity. It’s kind of that which is holding or apprehending the image. So there would both be a sense of subjectivity and a sense of this representation as the object. In a subsequent moment, which we’ll call time three, this image is, go goes through a certain kind of operation, which is called an apoha or exclusion and is then conceptualized.
And part of what happens when the image is conceptualized and that conceptualization of the image is represented by the quotation marks here. And when it’s conceptualized, it actually becomes a little bit vaguer, not quite as clear. The conceptual process renders it somewhat less clear, and that’s represented by the dotted line and the slight change in the color. So this distinction is very important. There’s a distinction between what is basically a a sense datum, an un in uninterpreted sense datum, and then an interpretation of the sense datum conceptually.
At this point, conceptual operations have not occurred. At this point, it’s now conceptualized. And one can be aware at this point, but one is not necessarily aware. It’s not necessarily the case that one gets a conceptual interpretation of a sense impression. Okay?
Then if we so this is non conceptual, and this is conceptual. A couple other points. When this there’s something that we can call using a term from phenomenology, the notion of intentionality, which is that when this arises, when this image arises, it’s actually arising in consciousness, but it arises in such a way that it seems to be external. Mhmm. And secondly, when we have these conceptual image, again, even though the cons this is actually occurring in consciousness, it also seems to project out into objects as if it were referring to something in the world.
So that’s intentionality. One other important feature is conditioning. We have a kind of conditioning which is basically the conditioning of the body. In other words, just as an example, humans have certain types of sense faculties as a result of their karma, and individuals will have in different physical states. Their sense faculties may be impaired by disease or what have you.
And this will also affect the way the sense faculty interacts with consciousness. Then there will be kinds of cons conditioning that are that are preconceptual. For example, if one is in a very intense emotional state, the kind of image that arises, if one is very angry if one is very angry at someone. That can that can condition the way the perceptual image looks as to as opposed to being in a very equanimous state. And then there will be conceptual conditioning.
This would have to do, for example, with the type of language one is learning, one has learned, the type of language one is using, cultural, conditioning, and so on, and that is going to affect the way in which the concept arises. And then finally, in terms of concept formation very briefly, what happens in this, in this system is the use of what’s called an exclusion process, which I represent as a black box because exactly what happens is a bit mysterious. But, But, basically, what happens here is that the perceptual image And the percept the the point here is that the the concept so for example, blue, if we think of this as being identified as blue, in fact, the concept is built upon this perceptual image. It is not an apprehension of some blueness that’s the same of all as all blue objects in the world. In other words, it’s not the case that all blue objects are actually the same.
In fact, every blue object, every object that we call blue is actually unique. We construct their sameness through a process of exclusion. And very briefly, this process works such that a blue object, what we call blue, is really excluded from that which is nonblue. It’s excluded from that which does not have the causal characteristics of something that we call blue. That’s a very complicated philosophical issue that we don’t need to go into.
So So I think I’ll just leave it there. The the basic causal process one one more time is that you get an object interacting with the sense faculty. Initially, you get an uninterpreted perceptual image arising in consciousness. One can have awareness at this time or not. And when we talk about when we were using the term conscious this morning, really, the question is whether or not this is brought into awareness or not.
And if it is conceptual, it one will always be aware of it. But it’s not necessarily the case. I don’t have that represented here. It’s not necessarily the case that the perceptual image will move to a be interpreted conceptually. Alright.
I think I’ll just leave it there. John, can you say in what sense You want me to put that back up? Yeah. Yeah. Maybe there’d be some questions about this.
In what sense the preconceptual is you said you used the term uninterpreted. Oh, yes. Okay. So maybe you put the conditioning is actually important here. What it what it says that it’s unin when I say that it’s uninterpreted, and I’m actually, I’m sure his holiness would have a lot to say about this.
But when I say it’s uninterpreted, that simply means it has not been conceptualized. So it has not been labeled, if you will Uh-huh. With a term. But that doesn’t mean that it’s completely unconditioned. Again, your emotional states, the type of physical faculties that one has, the unique character the what one is thinking about before the arrival of the image.
Everything that’s going on in one’s mental continuum here is gonna have some kind of effect on the type of perceptual image that arises. So, at least on my interpretation, as I understand this, when we all look at something, you know, red, for example, we don’t all have exactly the same image or number in our consciousness. We all have slightly different images in our consciousness because each of our consciousnesses is slight are slightly different. Any other? So if we saw a a a red apple That’s what I’m.
Something They said. Yeah. Easy. Well, I’ll ask this.
Then you can ask yours. So, if you took a red apple, for example Yes. If if you were hungry and you saw the red apple, we would say from the perspective of psychology and neuroscience that there would be, mechanisms in the brain that would interpret that, if you will, as, as a food cue, and it would have a different relation than if you were filled to satiety, if you were if you were no longer hungry. I So how how how I I think probably on this system. This is actually an interesting question.
I think it’s subject to Yeah. It’s probably the same. Oh, See, one one question here would be by the time the the the quite an interesting question here would be, would that type of state, let’s say, of intense hunger condition the act the perceptual image? Or, his holiness was saying, actually, by the time you if I’m identifying it as something desirable, I’m already at their conceptual level. And it’s certainly the case that there would be a distinction.
If I’m hungry or not hungry, I might not even get a concept. I might not even it will go I will have this perhaps as my eyes pass over the table, but I might not even interpret it as anything. Or I might interpret and say, oh, yes. You know, that’s a red object or there’s an object there. But if I’m hungry, then I’m definitely going to interpret it as something edible or an apple.
So, certainly, there would be a difference in interpretation at the conceptual level, but there might not be a difference, at the perceptual level. Well, the neuroscience would say definitively that there would be a difference at the perceptual level unequivocally. But then here, maybe there’s a difference in the way in which the term perception is used. Yes. Yeah.
I mean, it would affect the Actually, this is a good thing. Yeah. Let me can I say one thing? I mentioned the other day, there’s and I don’t know the name of this study, but, I know that there is a study in which they took pigeons, and they trained them to wreck and pigeons have no evolutionary need to identify fish. So they took pigeons, and they trained them to identify in postcards fish, and they could repeatedly identify fish.
Now on the Buddhist view, they are using concepts because they repeatedly have something they know to be, but they don’t have the word fish, but they have a conceptual function which repeatedly identifies the same kind of thing. Now generally, way the word concept is used in cognitive science, that would not be concept on most usages, I think. But this is something that we might call a proto concept or a very primitive concept. So Although there’s a lot of work showing the concept development prior to the onset of language Yes. In human development.
Yes. Okay. So in any case I think that would be helpful. But so so I think the point here would be that there may be some disagreement about there were no you’re saying in neuroscience, definitively, there would be a difference. But the argument might be here that in neuroscience, you’re not actually get detecting this.
You’re not detecting the the raw percept. The claim would be most ordinary people don’t we’re not generally aware, rather. We’re not generally aware of this at this level either. For example, in neuro in in terms of neuroscientific data, if you record from, from the primary from primary visual cortex, the first relay station in visual cortex as the information comes up from the periphery. Yes.
There will be a difference there Correct. Right at the beginning. Right at the beginning. Blind sight, is there a difference? Pardon?
Something like blind sight or the kind of situation that Wolf was speaking about of a forced choice situation, will there be also be a difference in conditioning? I’m not exactly sure of the question in terms of blindsight. Well, if he says that you’re not aware of you’re not seeing anything. K? It’s prior to any conscious red apple out there.
And yet if you force a choice to react one way or the other, then there’s a precognitive or subliminal, some sort of subconscious process which allows you to do that. Well, I mean, you can record activity a hundred and fifty milliseconds after a stimulus that will differentiate between certain conditions of the organism. For example, whether the the organism is is hungry versus sated or if the stimulus is accompanied by reward versus punishment. So it happens extremely quickly, and it happens in the primary sensory cortex. But I think Wolf had a point.
Where there are several. But I would say myself, and I think there was some even a little bit of doubt whether there would be a difference or not. I don’t I don’t think that that is really contradictory to this system. Entirely possible that that would be considered a kind of preconceptual physical conditioning. The organism is prepped, and will respond in that way.
So, whether or not that’s conceptual might be a matter of I mean, and then the other question, of course, is is there a deeper deeper level that is not being captured? And, also, some of these processes can be so fast. So fast. Very, very, very fast. So that needs to be taken into account.
Yes. Extremely quick. Which is consistent with how we would think. Yeah. Yeah.
The conceptualization is is an ordinary person’s system. For example, like, a distinction is made in Buddhist epistemology of perceptions that are perceived but cannot lead to kind of, you know, awareness. And then there are They can’t they can’t lead to this, basically. Yeah. They cannot lead to this.
And then there are perceptual experiences that can lead to awareness. And the difference is whether or not the person is attending to to the object being perceived. So to take your example of someone who is very hungry and because of that that state of mind when, you know, there’s going to be much stronger attention, that is going to lead to immediately to this conceptual level. That’s going to have an immediate effect. This is just a question of clarification in how you’re using the the terms.
So as I understand it, the image the preconceptual image is in consciousness. Yes. But the, conceptualized image is you’re you’re describing as an object of awareness. So the They’re both well, it depends on how we define awareness, but if we just there’s a term shepa. They’re both occurring in shepa in in awareness.
So the question then that I have is They are part of awareness, actually. Okay. The the question then that I have is, what is the defining characteristic of consciousness such that the image, the preconceptual image is conscious? I don’t know. It’s to you.
No. That’s not your question. What’s your question, Evan? I think that’s his question. The question is, the image is said the pre the pre conceptual image is said to be conscious rather than not conscious.
So in this system, it’s it’s a conscious state. So within this system, what is the defining characteristic of consciousness? So because the object is experienced. So that’s that’s there is an awareness there because the object is experienced, and it’s cognized, actually. Experience.
I think there’s a possible argument there. If we consider definition of consciousness It may be more to do with terminology, the way in which we’re using the terms conscious. Yeah. But maybe to exemplify, is consciousness is a stream of momentary events of what we we call consciousness, but of which we not be aware of all of them. Now what will be why do we say that even we are not aware of that that moment too, but it’s still part of the stream of consciousness.
To prove that, if you were to remove that moment and put the unconscious instant there, then the stream will be blocked and you will not see the rest. So it’s integrant part of that flow whether you are fully conceptually aware or not. It is still part of what we call the stream of instant of consciousness. It doesn’t have to be come to your perception or Yeah. Intelligence, But it is an integral part of the stream because without that, the stream will be broken and you will not perceive the the conceptual thing.
Yeah. That’s and so there is a difference here in terms of the way con to be conscious or or consciousness is used. It’s certainly not the case that if we’re gonna use consciousness to translate this term simply, it’s not necessarily the case that one is aware in the sense that one can report on each moment of. But still it’s part of stream of consciousness because without those moments, then it will not work. So they will affect aware They will just not happen.
Yeah. So the the this is a necessary moment in the momentary continuity of what we call instant of consciousness. Because the very fact that the awareness has arisen in in taking on the aspect of the object, that that defines its it as a a moment of consciousness. So here, I’m using the term what John has translated as percept perceptual image as sometimes it’s also translated as aspect. It’s an aspect of the object that is assumed by the the awareness.
Yeah. The model here, just to clarify, is that each that what happens between this moment and this moment is that consciousness itself takes on the form of the object. But But not a concept. Yet But not conceptual. If it’s conceptual, it will always be something that you can report on.
Which is manifest, actualized. You can report on this too after you conceptualize it. In other words, you can be aware at this level, although most ordinary people are not aware at this level. So there’s really a big difference between our view and this view because we would see a continuous stream of processing going from a to b to c to b, which never ends as long as the brain is working. And only glimpse out of this permanent stream are selected by attention and pushed into the workspace of consciousness.
And only those can be conceptualized thereafter. So these would be sideways bifurcations that need or need not occur because what happens here if if one doesn’t make it into the stream if one out of the stream doesn’t make it into consciousness, then then your chain breaks. No. No. No.
No. No. No. No. Because as as John said, there could be many moments in between t one and t two and t other moments.
And and the stream, of course, definitely goes on. But what you’re saying is that there’s sort of a parallel stream here that maybe something is bumped into this level, which would be not conceptualized? Yeah. Yeah. No.
It’s You could run-in this stream for as long as you want. If you keep in the other stream, the conscious stream, something that you want to maintain in working memory, for example, then many of these blobs would run parallel, not going to consciousness at all. Then you shift your focus of attention. You select another one out of that stream and then you’re in another conscious state. So I think I don’t think there is a contradictions I don’t think I can speak in my voice because let’s not forget that there are five sensory modalities.
So it’s not just one you know, when one sensory modality operates, the others are shut. So you can imagine all the five sensory modalities, you know, these awareness are taking place. Now where the conceptual thought arises, that is the function of selection. And only one at a time. So you can be, for example, watching and the typical example given is you be you could be watching a a theater show where you may be smelling some beautiful, you know, you know, fragrant flower.
You are watching this beautiful attractive dance that is being performed and you hear the music. So all the five sensory modalities are active, but what the thought, what you attend to is gonna lead to that stream. Another way of thinking about this is that there are times when you’re when one is just has these minimal functions that should have been the one hit. This. And then there’s a time when Okay.
Right? So that’s another way of thinking about this. Martha, did you have a Yeah. I did. I I wanna kind of question head on the assumption that there is a categorical difference between perception and conceptualization.
And I think this is very sort of in keeping with what, Wolfe was saying, but maybe I’ll be more, you know, even more direct about it. It’s tempting to want to believe that you can draw a sharp, bright line between perception and cognition. I think for epistemological reasons, somebody actually used the word sense data earlier today. That was you. Okay.
So if you believe that there is perception that is the interaction of a part of your body, your eye or your ear with the outside world, and then later you operate on those representations with thought, you have some possibility of of correct knowledge about the world. You know, this is kind of the the positivist program in philosophy. Right? But I think everything we know empirically tells us that, in fact, it’s a it’s a very long, kind of cascade step by step by step going from the most peripheral perceptual representations, in the case of vision, the retina, to the most high level conceptual representations. And if I can if you’ll indulge me for a minute, I just wanna elaborate that a little bit.
So, perceptually, if see this white piece of paper, if I see it from here or if I see it from here, different photoreceptors are being stimulated on my retina. So those are really two different perceptual representations. Right? Yes. And likewise, even at the level of primary visual cortex, the representation of that and the representation of that are totally distinct.
That’s right. Totally nonoverlapping. Also on this part. However, at a slightly higher level of visual representation, somewhere down in inferotemporal cortex where Wolf showed you before, the representation of this object here and here becomes identical. And It sort of that’s time three.
Well, hang on. Hang on. Hang on. Now at yet later levels of representation, the representation of this and this, in other words, the the retinal image of, you know, the rectangle versus a parallelogram versus just skinny little line, right, are are similarly mapped onto, a common representation. And therein lies our, you know, what psychologists call shape constancy, the ability to see that this is actually the same shaped object, even though the image that it casts on our retina is totally different at these different angles.
Okay? This process of step by step by step making categories or concepts, like you were saying, right, goes on all the way up to the highest conceptual levels. So now let’s go to the other end of the spectrum, and that’s really what I wanna argue that it’s a spectrum. Conceptually, you might have the knowledge that
You know, paper, is made from trees. You know, it’s a wood product, that people write on it, and also that it’s typically white and, you know, flexible. Well, we know that patients with localized brain damage to certain parts of temporal cortex can lose just the knowledge of the visual characteristics of the paper. So you can say, what’s paper made from? And they will say, oh, it’s cellulose.
It’s a wood product. And you can say, and what color is it? And they say, I don’t know. White, black, purple? They don’t know.
So in other words, even at the other end of the spectrum, we continue to to to gradually transform the information from perceptual to to conceptual. There’s good computational reasons for doing that. If you try to train a neural network to go from a visual image to conceptual information, It turns out it works much better if you if you do it through these gradual steps rather than try to do the mapping in one step. Mhmm. So there’s good good reason to believe that our brains, you know, are designed like that for a reason.
Now I’m going on for so long. I’m losing my place. Let me just say, okay. So so, basically, there there’s a spectrum from perceptual to conceptual. There’s no place where you can draw a line and say everything under this is perceptual and everything over that is conceptual.
And that same Sure. That same kind of gradient, that same gradual difference, corresponds to the the relative balance of innate, you know, sort of hardwired determined influences on the representation versus learned. So, you know, basically, we all you know, we we can do see the equivalence of this and this just by virtue of being, you know, born with a full normal genome. Right? Maybe I give you one answer to that, and then and then let Jim put that translate.
Okay. The line Let me say one last thing just to Okay. So I sort of I apologize for going on so long, but I do think that some of the the problems that we’re having may actually, just come from the fact that we’re starting off assuming a categorical distinction. And I think if we admit that perhaps, perhaps sort of con the conceptual content of our representations and the availability of these representations to consciousness are all on a gradient, the the problems that we’re grappling with might be easier to solve. So this this could be actually quite true, particularly with respect to the conceptual thoughts that arises while you are actually looking at the object at the same time.
However, I don’t think that there would be a total abandonment of the distinction between the conceptual and the non conceptual. Just to say what the dividing line is, if you mentioned it, it’s when two things are made one. So at the point that there’s a process that takes two stimuli and interprets them as the same, that counts as a concept. And everything above that is a concept. Yep.
Everything above that. And then there’s not a lot of theory about how you get from their line. That’s very true. Yeah. And it’s concept.
In the last two minutes, I’d just like to ask Matthieu to make a few comments and help integrate this. Why is this not really that? Well, the ultimate nature of consciousness and dominant, that’s a nice challenge. Well, you know, we have been talking about the Buddhist perspective on what is experience and consciousness as opposed to the inanimate. And so here, also the notion of consciousness is a primary phenomena, which I haven’t referred to on the first day.
So quickly, what the primary phenomena might be. For instance, in the case of matter, we can go down to the most elementary subatomic particles or quarks or superstrings or quantum vacuum. And at some point, we stop there. We just have to acknowledge the phenomena are there, and we cannot really answer why there is something rather than nothing unless we bring, I know, a creator or something else. So this is what we call in Tibetan.
This is the nature of things and one of the category which we refer to in the first day. So what about consciousness in that case? Well, if we don’t mix the third and the first person experience. But we can describe perhaps with great precision what it is to feel love, what it is to see red, but without the experience of it, the very word of consciousness will not be part of our vocabulary. It will be absolutely no meaning.
So there is definitely a dimension of experience which has its quality of its own, which is very special. So now to be honest, we should lead an investigation. So if you really want to speak of the first person experience and experience as a phenomena, we should honestly pursue its investigation within its own domain of experience. Now what happens if we do that? Then we first come to mental construct, memory, imagination, hopes, fears, and all what emotions and whatever is our man fills our mental landscape.
But now if we go further down into that, say behind the screen of thoughts and mental concepts, there is definitely a a basic quality of cognition that is we call the luminous aspect of mind that is luminous compared to an object that is dark in terms of cognition. There’s absolutely no cognitive quality whatsoever. So now if we refine that experience to introspection, we can come to what we call pure cognition, pure awareness, pure consciousness, whatever we may call that, which is the mere the the purest faculty of cognition that allows every other type of cognition, whether it’s reasoning, emotions, feeling, without which we will not speak of experience, we’ll not speak of consciousness. So now when we come to the pure awareness, in a way we could say it’s also a primary phenomena in the sense that further than that, further than pure cognition without content, there’s nowhere deeper we can go. We cannot say why it’s there rather than not there unless we bring some extraneous explanation.
So from the perspective of experience itself conversation conversation So from that perspective of experience, this is a primary phenomena because we have no further explanation. Certainly don’t come to the brain on neurons. Even in ancient time, people who said it’s in the heart. That shows how little we have an insight at this it happens in the brain. So now that’s one point of this notion of what we call bare or pure consciousness.
And the reasoning for speaking of a continuum is the reasoning we mentioned of the first day of two we’re not talking in the long term evolution of, you know, the complexification of biology and nervous systems. But the instant causation of moment to moment, as we say that there should be a similar nature from one minute moment to the next in the law of causation. It just cannot happen. Anything leads to anything. So that continuity of nature requires that the very present moment of consciousness, the very immediately preceding one has to be somehow of the same nature.
It cannot come up something that is absolutely devoid of any conscious quality. So this led the this logic leads to have the notion of a continuum of consciousness. And in the same way that when we mentioned about ex nihilo creation, that nothing cannot become something, So in the in the realm of phenomenal sort of inanimate object, we cannot go from nothingness to something and then from something to nothingness. The Buddhist logic about that is that there should be also a continuum of consciousness that is also without which also beginningless. That’s the reasoning behind the notion of a stream of consciousness that goes on from state of of being to to another.
So that’s the ultimate first person experience also. Thank you, Matthieu. And thank you, your Holiness, for a very rich day, and we look forward to continue. Thank you. Very interesting to share.
Key terms in this teaching
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- eighty conceptions
- The subtle minds that exist below the conscious level, controlling our conscious mental activities. These minds dissolve during the latter stages of the death process. LYWA
- illusory body gyu lu (Tib)
- A subtle body generated through practice of the completion stage of Highest Yoga Tantra; the cause of the rupakaya. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.