1 h 40 min · 10,385 words · 12 April 2007 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This 100-minute dialogue between the Dalai Lama and Western psychologists, held in April 2007 as part of the Mind and Life Institute’s fourteenth meeting, examines the nature of compassion and the mental qualities that sustain ethical action under real-world conditions. The speakers move from neuroscience evidence about empathy and its variants—recognizing others’ pain, resonating emotionally with them, and offering compassionate concern—to practical questions about cultivating emotional awareness and equanimity in high-stress professions like emergency medicine and conflict zones. They discuss a provocative proposal for “compassion gymnasiums” where people could train emotional resilience through meta-attention exercises, loving-kindness practice, and exposure to stories of compassionate heroism. A central tension animates the conversation: whether anger can be wholesome if directed at an unjust act rather than the person, and whether Buddhist practice demands the complete absence of anger or merely its redirection. The Dalai Lama emphasizes wisdom, humility, and a realistic assessment of what any individual can accomplish as essential complements to compassion.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Mind and Life XIV Dialogue on The Universe in a Single Atom; April 12 2007 (D….mp3
UUID: 4868ab31-cf2e-4166-9c7a-0bac3569f1b4
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Dalai Lama Talks
Date: 2007 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~10,379
Now part of my research is studying deception. And in every country I go, they believe the other countries lie much more than we do. Give them all the answers there. Not alone. There is no such thing as a bad group.
There are only different groups of people who share a common humanity. And this one, there is forgiveness of even the most vile deeds. The last there was no choice. They had to do it. It’s incomprehensible.
You say, well, what made you choose to do it? I didn’t choose. They needed help. I did it. I had to do it.
Now what I think she’s identified very well are some at least tentative criteria, but we need to find out more about what characterizes the compassionate person. If we are to develop a global compassion, a global compassion is a more western way of saying for all sentient beings. And I think it is increasingly clear, even on a pragmatic basis, that if we care about our grandchildren, we need to have a global compassion. We need to be concerned about everyone’s welfare. Or even if it’s not our welfare, it’ll be our children’s and our children’s but we’ll be in jeopardy.
It has become a global village. Now none of these people, as best you can determine, had any training. And you heard Ben say all the things that they didn’t differ on. Many things. No difference.
This is the only thing she found. Well, I would like to see much more study of both three kinds of people. The first, the people who do this in a situation which is out of context in an experiment. That’s how we usually do experiments, is it doesn’t matter to your past or your future. It’s not related.
But you act in a compassionate fashion. The second? The second are the people who have acted as heroes or heroines impulsively. And the third are people who, even today in many parts of the world, are continuing over time to put their own lives at stake to relieve the suffering of others. And that’s happening in The Middle East, and that’s happening in Africa.
It’s it’s not unique to the nineteen forties. It happens today. And for each person we identify, we need a control person who has as similar in characteristics, the schooling, where they grew up, their parents’ background, as we can do so that by comparing each pair, we might begin to discover with psychological methods, with neuroscience methods, what differentiates these compassionate people. How did that happen without training, without it being cultivated? They are natural compassionate people.
We need many, many more. And if one way of trying to get more is to find out how does it happen naturally. So I want to give as an example a study by Tanya Singer, Wolfram’s daughter, who’s sitting here. And can everybody read this? Because I hate to read PowerPoints, but I will if you can’t read it.
Should I read it? Yes. Read parts of it. Read parts. Okay.
Well, what she’s done is to use a method of brain scanning, best we have today, and she finds that the part of the brain that’s involved when you have pain is the same as when you perceive someone else’s pain. That same part of the brain. For my pain or if I saw you in pain? Same part. That’s a very important discovery.
We thought that. Darwin and others wrote about that, but this is evidence on a very specific level. The second is is wondering whether this is, you know, you could say that this is the same across everybody. And also and also whether the feeling would be equally intense as well. Is it really the same feeling as pain?
I don’t I don’t believe it’s been replicated cross culturally, but I don’t know any reason. I mean, clearly, which should be examined in radically different cultures. Where are you? Because his was saying that he can understand for a practitioner who emphasizes the practice of Tonglen, giving and taking, and as a result, gets to a point where there’s almost no differentiation between someone else’s pain and his or her own experience of pain. There are individual differences.
Individual differences. Some people more than others. But in some people, you do find comparability. Now that opens up, of course, a extremely important research question is what’s the difference between those who show very similar and very strong and those who show very slight? And what can we learn about that that might help us train people?
Because my focus today and at this point in my life is the practical, is how can we use this to increase compassionate behavior. I’m interested in it intellectually, but much more focused on how we could apply it, but we need more knowledge. And this is a method. Now there’s she’s got another result, which is up there, which I’m hesitant to report because it makes men look so bad. If the other person acts unfairly, women still respond more compassionately, not the men.
They want revenge. Now I bet you though there, there are some men who are more like the women and some women who are more like the men. And so once again, that’s a harder test. You’ve been cruel to me. It’s hard to say.
But you’d suppose you have been cruel to me, and yet this is fundamental to your notion of forgiveness, which I have come to it took a long time to come to believe that that is the right notion, that every act is forgivable. You remember, we spent a long time arguing about that. But there’s no if you’ve been nice to me, that’s no test. It’s when you haven’t been, when you’ve been unjust. And many of the examples you use and you describe in your book with Victor Hof are for most severe injustice and cruelty and yet to still.
Well, that’s what we want to cultivate. And some people from this experimental paradigm can help us to identify some people where it’s there naturally. So we need to study those people. Can I ask one question? Please.
In the study, was the the difference between how did the difference between men and women compare to the differences within men and within women? Yeah. So first, I want to say that it had to be replicated. Yeah. Because in fMRI study, we study not huge population and not across cultures.
So that’s but the astonishing thing I really saw is in each of the men I studied, there was a desire of revenge. If they saw someone being punished or getting pain which had cheated on them before and in the in the women, there were variation. There were three women which behaved like the men and then most of the women didn’t felt any desire for revenge. So there there was a striking difference between the group I tested, but that, you know, it might be very different in groups of patriots or also in other cultural groups and that’s what we have to look into that. And what perhaps I could say is that we found instead in the man on average but also individually, we’ve said instead of empathic brain responses, we saw reward area lighting up.
So ventral striatum which is a reward related area And the more they subjectively express the desire for revenge, the more this area lighted up so that and that’s an area which is activated if you get chocolate or something you desire. Desire for revenge. And that makes sense because there is a strong desire there. So I had mentioned this study as an example of the kind of research that could start once repeated and extended and replicated, that could start to identify for us people that we who show the most compassionate behavior under the most adverse circumstance in an experiment who we could then study with other methods to try to learn why this is so. Just as we can take people from the world who do this And can that give us information we can use in a practical level, which I’ll get to in a moment?
I want to distinguish between, since this is talking about empathy, three kinds of empathy. The first is to recognize how the other person feels. If you don’t if I don’t know that you’re suffering, then how am how am I gonna respond? Empathy level one.. Now knowing how you feel, we don’t Tanya’s study and real world shows.
I may know how you feel and not care about it. I may know that you’re suffering and wanna make you suffer more. It feels so good. It gets you so unhappy. So it’s the first step, but not sufficient.
The second is totally different. It is to feel what the other is feeling, and I’d like to distinguish two types. I love to use my wife as an example. If you remember seven years ago, I used my wife as an example also, and she has forgiven me for that. So I now feel I can always use her in my lectures.
So you have seven more years to be. She comes home, and she’s had a meeting with the head of the university. And she asked him for support for students, and he was not sympathetic. And she’s very angry. I can use this example because she is now resigning as dean.
Yes? Okay. So she’s very angry. She comes home, and she tells me this, and it’s clear. She’s angry at him.
Well, one kind of resonance is I get angry too. Not angry at her, with her. Oh, that chancellor. What a mindless person. How could he act that way?
I’m furious. I’m gonna write him a letter. So I’m resonating with her feeling. Another kind of resonance is I say, oh, you poor baby. How could he act?
How could he not see the merits? Now I’m having a feeling. It’s not the same feeling, but it’s a resonant feeling. K? People like both.
Sometimes they want Now the third is a compassionate concern to relieve the suffering. What can I do to help you think of other ways to deal with your problem that the chancellor hasn’t met? How can I help you? How can I help you with your anger so that it doesn’t distract you from what you so this is now you don’t need step two to get to go from step one to three? And in fact And in fact, it is the belief of some people that if you always go through step two, if you’re dealing, let’s say, on a cancer children’s cancer ward, and you’re seeing these children who are dying all the time, when you deal with their parents, they don’t want you to cry.
They’re crying. They don’t want the resonance. They want the compassionate concern. And just a momentary digression, another thing to thank Adam for is the amazing group of people that he’s invited here that I’ve been able to talk to in the break who are so involved in different aspects of compassion, whether it be in the prisons or with the social workers. It’s just a it’s an amazing audience.
So thank you for that too. So it’s a we don’t really know for these heroes and heroines, for these rescuers, for Tanya’s subjects, are they having the resonance? Hers suggests they’re having the resonance. But are these others? Or is it just from step one to step two?
Let me turn to a second way science can help us, and that is in evaluating the efficacy of different approaches to cultivating compassion. Seven years ago, Alan Wallace was sitting where you’re sitting. And at one point in the meeting, Alan said, we need emotional balance gymnasiums where people can go and learn emotion. Why you just go to the gym to work out physically? Why not go to a gymnasium to balance your emotions?
So with thanks to Alan, how about compassion gymnasiums? Where instead of weigh seeing how much you weigh, you monitor what is your level of calmness versus stress today. Where there is like, there are different exercise machines in the gyms we have now. There’s a meta-attention exercise room,. A loving kindness exercise room, a biofeedback mind training room, a cinema room where you will see the suffering that results from violence because the studies that have been done have shown that all the violent acts average child sees 10,000 acts of violence by the time they’re 13, but they don’t see it in the context of the suffering it causes.
That’s the programs. Violence. Another movie room where you see
The heroes and heroines of compassion. Reading this — Jonathan Haidt, the moral psychologist — just talked about a feeling of elevation. When Yes. Jonathan Haidt. You you read about what others have done that are deeply compassionate, it starts to help transform you.
And the compassion game room, I I’ve gotten to know the designers of two half billion dollar games. And one of them is very interested in developing a game that you play with other people where you learn compassion and the benefits of compassion. In the young generation, a lot is learned through games, not through books, not through movies. There’s no reason not to try this. Now we don’t have evidence for any of these, But I don’t put this up as a joke.
No. No. I mean, Paul, we we realize that this is this is kind of a a wish. Yes. But, would you say they are feasible?
I think we need to to mount a program of research on compassion that begins to use some of the methods you’ve heard about, some of the neuroscience methods that uses the methods that Tanya has used experimentally, and we begin to see what’s effective. My bet is that just like I prefer the treadmill to the exercise bike, that people will find one there won’t be one technique that’s the best for everyone. People will find what’s useful for them, and you give them a free array and do it within a research context. So I I hope that you will say at one point, is this just going to be good talk, or is something going to happen? Yeah.
No. I think really was worth making effort. Yes. No. So this time I look at Adam.
Okay. And there are people beginning to work on each of these. It’s not as if we start from scratch. I will switch topic. Sure.
Justice your law goes on. Now my research is on emotion. And so when I think about consciousness, I think about it in four different ways. And I start with the belief, not the scientific fact, but the belief that nature did not make it easy, didn’t equip us to make consciousness to any one of these four easy, that they all have to be cultivated. Would you explain to I will.
I’m gonna take them one by one. Yes. Yes, sir. Yes. Sometimes when I become emotional, it’s through a process of thought.
And I think about, why is John looking at me in that way? I don’t know. It’s yes. Okay. So he’s pleased with what I’m saying, but is he really pleased?
Okay. He’s raised one eyebrow. So the whole process But I don’t think that that’s either the only or the most common way emotions begin. And there is evidence to suggest that very complex evaluations, like in the near miss car accident, which involves a lot of calculations about the speed of that other car and the angle and how much you have to adjust the steering wheel and the pedal pressure incidentally all learned behaviors, and that happens in milliseconds without thinking. If you had to think about what to do and is it really a problem, should I slow down?
You’d be gone. So we are capable of this extraordinarily fast appraisal awareness. This incidentally is Dan Goleman’s phrase, appraisal awareness. And usually, it isn’t till afterwards. Now this can save us our lives or get us into a lot of Sorry.
Appraisal appraisal awareness is is can is this your example of that is the cars? Near car accident. But it can be very it can and often is. Let me clarify the No. My friend, Richie, points out, and I should put it more precisely, is that the appraisal is something we can usually not be aware of.
It’s impenetrable. Now the appraisal gives rise to a set of impulses, but let me just call it one pulse for simplicity. What I believe in, Buddhists write about as the spark before the flame. Fifty years ago, exactly Fifty years ago, I was completing Fifty years ago, I was completing my training as a psychotherapist, believe it or not. And my supervisor said, if you can increase the gap between impulse and action, you will have helped your patients.
And what he should have said to me, and that’s very hard to do, and it’ll certainly take more than one hour a week. But impulse awareness is possible to become and there’s a lot of writings of yours, of Matthews, of others I’ve read about being able to be aware of the impulse and not engage you with it. Now even someone like me who’s only a sporadic meditator, I can sometimes, not always, but sometimes detect the impulse and let it pass. Yeah. Like, I I visualize anger as a ball of cactus that is rolling very fast, and I step to the side, and it just goes away.
Mhmm. Mhmm. Yeah. So I wish that happened all the time, but that it’s possible some of the time, And I would presume with more regularity of practicing, you can achieve it more of the time. Behavior awareness is the third.
You didn’t recognize the impulse. The flame has happened. You point out that words come faster than action. So you’re already starting to say things. Let’s use anger because that’s the emotion that we most often regret.
So you’re already starting to say things that if you thought about, you either wouldn’t say them at all or you would say them in a kinder fashion directed more at the act than the actor as you point out. But in order to do that, you have to be aware that that’s what you’re doing. Now you would think that if you’re acting emotionally, you have to know it. Not the case. But there are these same exercises, the same practices that help behavior awareness help impulse awareness, and there are Western approaches to this, some of which I’ve developed and some others that mesh perfectly.
For example, we have a set of exercises to teach you to be more aware of the sensations in your body so that when those sensations begin, it registers in consciousness. And you say to yourself, I’m getting upset. You have no opportunity to disconfirm, to disengage, or if you engage, to engage constructively unless you’re aware. And it’s my belief, supported only indirectly, is that for most people, it doesn’t come naturally. It needs to be cultivated.
The last, the empathetic awareness, the recognition of how another person feels, that’s very easy to acquire. We’ve developed technology that virtually everyone can learn to be much more aware of the feelings of others in an hour in an hour or two. And that can be very useful to knowing how you feel. Because if I recognize the look on your face, it tells me something I’m doing is causing you to respond. So it can it can help me to know how you feel, to know myself.
So I would change my heading here to consciousness is a primary characteristic of a good emotional life or a constructive emotional life, but not a given. Well, we’ve already talked. I’ve already terms of emotion, suggested, and you haven’t disagreed with me, that consciousness is not given by nature. It has to be cultivated for each of these or for at least the three, the words possible. Now the appraisal, the impulse, the behavior, the empathy empathy to to So wouldn’t you say in the case of, the the three, you know, kind of earlier consciousness that you’re talking about, wouldn’t there be individuals who would be naturally capable of doing this?
Wonderful question. I don’t know whether there are. I mean, we’ve studied Matthew in our laboratory like like many scientists in America. The was he always like this? You see, now there is research of Ritchie’s of Cliff Saron’s.
There’s research that’s looking before and after. And there is some evidence, I believe, in Richie’s data and in other data that suggests there might be some people just like those exceptional, compassionate people. There might be some people who have exceptional consciousness, and I would expect that which you would find different neural circuitry, that they’re they’re not like the rest of us. Matthew’s mother said that he had wasn’t always like that. But but Matthew told me, don’t trust what my mother said.
Matthew was a lab mate of mine forty years ago, and he wasn’t like this. Well Confirmed That’s very that’s important. We really need to round up the whole circle of acquaintances who knew him. But this is a general methodological issue if we’re going to study people twenty or thirty years later as we’re doing is to find out systematically about their earlier life as well as the longitudinal studies that need to be done. And as I knew it would occur, but I didn’t know exactly where, this idea that there are people who have emotion consciousness naturally.
I can think of tasks we can develop to identify them, and then we can find out how it happens. And maybe that can help us bring this about more quickly or effectively for other people. The next issue I wish to address is really quite different. And so I’ve suggested to Ritchie that perhaps we take a tea break now and then come back to this issue of whether there are emotions that are fundamentally afflictive or whether all emotions can be enacted in a wholesome fashion. Okay?
Thank you. Fifteen minutes. I want to return to the gymnasium because I did not mean this in jest. And many people in the break told me how eager they are to see this started. And the the commonest stress weighing scale is only one element, but it is an element that the American government has asked me to try to develop so that we don’t keep putting people into dangerous situations who then act in an regrettable fashion.
And I’ve recruited Richie, and we will be working on the development of that component. It’s the easiest. I wanted to ask you if Under under which ministry? Defense. Defense.
But police have also Hopefully, under education. Police have also
Ask, how can we tell when we should tell a officer, don’t go out on the street. You’re not in good shape to go out on the street with a weapon. It’s an important question. So it’s not a bad you know, similarly, if we could not have soldiers go out into combat or dangerous situations where they commit atrocities because they’re all they’re they shouldn’t they they don’t have the calm. You have to get them to a level of calmness so they can act in a considered Yes.
Conscious fashion. That’s right. I wanted to ask you if you would take some time now before I go to the end of my presentation, which is only about five or ten minutes at most. But to tell us whether what are are there any things in this list that you think are is aren’t worth trying? I think it’s the third.
Loving kindness exercise. Loving kindness So when we speak of loving kindness, we are talking about a state of mind that is beneficial. The first, second, can be either. Yeah. So you can have another attention towards both negative and positive.
Mhmm. Do you think it’s necessary, though, to for it to be developed? So what would be helpful perhaps is to keep loving kindness exercise as the key, and then you can have different aspects of the practice. Oh, in order to do that? In order to do that.
Not because of methods like matter attention and then Some kind of instrument to improve loving kindness. Maybe. Good. What else is should be here that isn’t on the list? Really?
Unless you this audience was saying, unless you tell me, you know, I wouldn’t remember. Someone else So when someone else starts the discussion, then it triggers his memory. Your Holiness, just in in relation to that one the the first thing on Paul’s list is the calmness stress scale to evaluate the extent to which a person is maintaining levels of equanimity. And one of the things that and this is something that Arthur pointed out just just now. One of the things that is so well developed in Buddhist practice are methods to cultivate equanimity.
But also I’d be interested in what your holiness has to say about how we can assess equanimity in others. How can we tell? The No. So Right. This So there is a Not it.
Oh. There is a statement in one of the text where it says I think it’s Yeah. It’s text where in in in describing the quality of the Buddha’s compassion and equanimity, there’s a statement, and there’s a line which says that someone who treats equally without discrimination, You know, on one side of his body, someone is trying to, you know, kind of, you know, anointed with, you know, sandalwood perfumes and so on and and and pamper it. And on the other side, someone else is chipping away with a with a knife or a dagger. So maybe that’s the test.
Too cruelty. Yeah. It’s too cruel. Too cruel. That guy who tested.
Who passed the IRB? Tested. When pass human subjects committee? Human subjects committee would disapprove. Yeah.
I think the usually is to be cultivate. Cultivate. Visualize someone who don’t like, dislike Who you dislike. Or agony me, and visualize one friend, visualize one neutral person, then check the attitude of our mind. Firstly, Of course, we’re talking about subjective experience.
Yeah. Yes. Then a person so therefore, maybe media. So maybe one way of doing this is to show the person as someone that the person dislikes. A photograph of a of a That is a friend.
And then a, you know, image of a friend. What’s the reaction from other side? Mhmm. Mhmm. More or less, that is an indication..
Then it’s an indication. And we can measure this physiologically. It’s actually a wonderful suggestion for a for a measure of equanimity. The the the the fewer the differences between friend versus enemy, the more equanimity. So we’re not talking about So, of course, we’re not talking about someone who’s totally, you know, like a zombie who has no recognition of who is an enemy and who’s a who’s a friend.
We’re talking about, you know, ordinary people who have clear recognition of someone as an enemy, someone as a as a friend or someone that you dislike or someone that you like. But on the basis of that, what we are trying to see is whether the person is capable of responding equanimity with equanimity so they’re not responding out of that consideration of the discrimination. Yeah. I have developed an exercise that I use in my teaching called respectful disagreement in which we ask the person to imagine the other person is a particular political leader that they can’t stand. Very easy to do in the room.
And to try to talk to that person in a respectful way and express your disagreement to for many people, there’s so much hatred involved. Let me let me go back in time. There were people who were so disappointed when Nixon was out of office because they thrived on their hatred for him. Oh, man. It’s very dangerous.
It’s becomes addictive. And Matthew. You know, when we speak of love and kindness exercise room, I think we really like to request his holiness to know what what are you going to exercise? So we would like to know some of us may not be all aware of how do you actually cultivate loving kindness? What different types of loving kindness and compassion can offer a secular training in human quality, but inspired by the wisdom and experience of religious training.
So two years ago in Stanford, you really clearly gave wonderful picture of different kinds of compassion and how to develop them. So I think it’ll be very timely if we could request you to give us occasion. I This is I think, sessional discussion. Yeah. But you should speak.
I I think thousand times, I think I I because of the speak, you see I speak. Without compassion. I think thousand times, I think, at least at a few 100 in many places. So it’s still So is it you can if someone is very serious, then you can collect. Okay.
Next trend. Okay. Then maybe one more precise question about what Paul was saying. Know, when he he described the two types of empathy and concern for his wife being very upset. And one was to somehow feel the same anger and share her anger.
Resonance. The other one was to be extremely kind, but not necessarily feeling the emotion. So in a way, it seems that the second one is maybe slightly more attuned to Buddhist approach of just overwhelming kindness, but not necessarily feeling the anxiety or the anger or the fear of the other person. Actually, it’d be very comforting. So So here, I mean, this is with response to your, you know, question of resonance and and so to Matthew’s point.
We can still maintain a distinction between the act that was done by someone that is that you you disapprove And you can have based on that a sense of outrage and even anger necessary. About the action. About the action. Mhmm. Is it?
Mhmm. But not to the not to the actor because there you can understand that, you know, perhaps the person was compelled to do that. There was no other choice. There could be all sorts of reasons why the person had to act in a certain manner. When someone As far as the action is concerned, someone have to oppose.
Sure. Otherwise, injustice is always because of gain. Right? With gain. So we have to oppose.
But but in case of his wife being upset, and for empathy, do we need absolutely to feel the person’s emotional state? That’s very important for the research in empathy. Do we have to feel the other person’s suffering or anxiety or fear? Or we did we simply need to be extremely kind without necessarily Concerned. Yes.
So for example, there’s some in some cases, for example, the Garrison Institute is working on people who when they’re working with people who have trauma, they start to get traumatized. They get what’s called vicarious trauma. And so they’re trying to be compassionate, but they get so much they feel the trauma of the other person. They feel the anxiety or the suffering of the other person. And because they feel the suffering, then they have difficulty having compassion.
So is it how do we train compassion? Do we need to feel the emotion of the other person? We just try to be more and more compassionate. So do we if someone is is very sad, do I need to feel their sadness? So there is there is a recognition in in the Buddhist tradition that So there’s a recognition in the Buddhist tradition.
So there is a recognition in the tradition that compassion actually necessarily involves taking upon some kind of pain of the other. Mhmm. And in fact, the in the very etymology of the Sanskrit term for compassion, which is karuna, has the notion of Stopping or suppressing happiness or stopping pleasure or is one could almost as interruption of pleasure. Interruption of pleasure. Interruption of pleasure.
And the idea here is that in in experiencing compassion, you are taking on the other’s pain, which has this interruption of one’s own, you know, experience of happiness and joy. So that’s part of the the understanding of compassion. So so in in in Śāntideva’s text, you know, recognizing this, he emphasizes the role for wisdom. You know, the compassion practice needs to be complemented with, you know, greater insight and, you know, a stronger use of intelligence and insight, the wisdom component. So if I may ask a question then.
If we are going to have compassion for someone else, do we always have to feel their pain first to have compassion? Because So in response to John’s question, his answer is yes. Because in the in the kind of order of cultivation of compassion in the Buddhist tradition, one of the supposition made is that first of all, the individual needs to have the capacity of experiencing one’s own pain and feeling unbearable. So without that basis, you cannot empathize with others’ pain and suffering. So on that Do you have to do that each and every time?
So if you see 10 people get brought into your emergency And therefore, there was this story of So there was this Tibetan master, a master of a compassion practice known as Tonglen,, and he was known as the Weeping One because he was constantly contemplating on the sufferings of, you know, countless numbers of sentient beings. So apparently, he was weeping most of the time. And it is said that It is said that he he laughed only three times in his life. His holiness was saying that this can’t be true. He must have laughed a lot, at least when he was young.
Did the weeping prevent him from acting? Oh, that that that no. No. No. That is the question now.
Oh. That’s then. So what is required is that, you know, when thinking about other suffering and when you have this strong experience of pain, what is required for strong compassion is the lack of Discouragement. Discouragement. There is danger, discourage or happiness.
Uh-huh. Yeah. Yeah. Because if the doctor No. No.
What what would be a better how do you translate? Just medulla. To lose one’s inner strength and and and you feel hopeless. Some discourage is actually kind of good because it means not having You feel despondent and powerless. Yeah.
Despondent. Because if the doctor on the battlefield is crying all the time, he’s not going to cure anybody. So that need the. So he needs?
So in the case of example of, you know, doctor working on the field, you know, constantly crying, not being able to do anything. Here, a verse from may be very helpful where he says that if there is a if there is something that can be done, then there’s no need to Get upset. To get upset. And if there’s nothing can be done, then there’s no point in being upset. So that kind of realistic perspective would be important.
Now, with respect to the Buddhist practice practitioners who are cultivating compassion, but in their case, they are talking about they are cultivating the altruistic aspiration and which is really grounded upon, you know, when they for for the Bodhisattvas, when they generate compassion to see that aspires all sentient beings to be free from suffering, Here, the the the level of suffering they are concerned with is not just what we would ordinarily, conventionally characterize as suffering. They are actually Buddhist understanding of suffering, the perception of suffering that they wish all beings No. To be free practitioner. So here, the suffering, the meaning of suffering is the conditioned existence within unenlightened saṃsāra. So and and this kind of wish to see others free from suffering is really accompanied with a very clear recognition that there is a solution to the suffering.
There is a possibility. So and this is the wisdom component. Mhmm. So there is a there’s a strength. There is a sense of confidence that this can be done.
And and and therefore, the compassion is accompanied with the the kind of a feeling of courage. Actually, he fully expounded three kinds of suffering, the obvious suffering that we all witness and the suffering of change. We are happy and then suddenly someone some catastrophe happens. And at the deeper level, which is dealing with ignorance, with ego clinging and grasping and all those basic ignorance, that makes suffering being able to happen all the time. So that can be antidoted by wisdom.
And if I may recall a wonderful example that is on this gave once in France. He said, if you just see someone that’s fallen in the ocean from an aeroplane and you know that you can’t do every anything, You feel great pity and sorrow for that person, but it’s not quite the same if that person has fallen in the ocean and you see that in the mist, there is an island very nearby, and that person could reach the island. So then your compassion and may that person reach that island will be thousand times stronger. So to know that there is an a way out of suffering to relating to ignorance, that magnify your compassion much more than just simply wishing that this immediate suffering be removed. There’s another element I would like to get your reaction to because on this topic, because I’ve been talking with my daughter a lot about it, who you’ve met, because she now works in a emergency room.
And every week, she deals with the parents of teenagers who’ve been killed in gang warfare. And the issue of her she has to help these parents deal with the loss of their children. She also has to deal with the fact this happens two or three times a week, week after week. So she helps this parent, there’ll be another one two days later. And I think there are two things that she needs.
One, and I’m getting this all from you and giving it to her, but I wanna be sure you would agree. One is She must enter his state of calmness. Well, if she comes to work agitated, then it’s gonna be much harder for her. Yes. She’ll be more likely to be overwhelmed by the situation.
So you it’s the preparation. Before you enter, you must prepare yourself to enter such a situation. You agree on that? Do yes. And the second is a harder one, particularly for, well, for many people, is for your goals to be modest.
She can’t change gang warfare, but she can help this situation. If she thinks, why So being real being more realistic. So right from the beginning, it’s better to set a goal that is more realistic and then make an effort. You’re putting it in very cognitive intellectual terms. I don’t know.
But Uh-huh. You know, but what I perceive in you and in other monks is there’s a level of fundamental modesty about what can be accomplished by any human being. I think of this when you often say, and with my little bit of knowledge about this, but I it’s not false modesty. So how do does one learn that kind of modesty in one’s aspirations that if we can’t all shoot to the moon, we can’t all be Mozarts, but we can be helpful. How does it isn’t just knowledge.
It’s, I think, more it’s a whole personality feature. He’s he’s only saying that our humility comes from the fact that we lost our home. We lost our country. Yeah. So we become humble.
I I think the most serious I think the So yesterday, we had a discussion about how and there’s a tremendous amount of synchrony that goes on at the brain level. Oh, I think one thought or one action. See, without karuna, not come just one single or something. Neuron. Yeah.
Mhmm. Thousands, millions, billions of the neuron, the cooperation. You are cooperation. Oh, then it’s a certain thoughts or certain actions that come. So so similarly, the changing or changing our view or changing our because of the mind.
Not really. Oh, now this is the Buddhist field. Right? Now in the Buddhist field. Not just one single course, single sort of meditation.
I think, hopefully, not billions, but at least thousands of different things. Practice, think, practice, then all these connected. Then eventually, our perception change. Really? And perception change or Outlook.
Outlook change. Outlook changes. It automatically bring changes in behavior. Affects day to day behavior. Of course, the negative emotions is a concern, but this is the there is some kind of feeling of reluctance.
Is it to to To embrace. Receive that. No. To embrace them. No.
So that makes a difference. Then, of course, the time factor also very important. I’m sure you see corona, see change that take place within one week. Isn’t it? Yes.
I think many years of meditation and also environment. How? Maybe if you remain a longer period in Paris, a nice monk may become a little bit distracted. So he would prefer to spend more time in Nepal in an isolated area. So Buddha Buddha himself also told you like that.
So just at at the low level, the environment influence also very, very strong. Mhmm. But I think But one more and more inner strength increase, then not much influence from external From the environment. Environment. I think we cannot stress enough the power of the inspiration that can come from wonderful human beings.
I mean, you mentioned how much has changed your life. Yes. And I can say that, no, I don’t have any special quality except the inspiration that I received from extraordinary human beings who are my teacher. I’m sort of a friend of mine described himself as an irradiated guinea pig. So much radiation of of of goodness, of loving kindness, of of, you know, strength, of, you know, freedom that somehow, you know, it says that the birds that fly around the golden Mountain, somehow there’s a reflection of that goal.
So it’s the inspiration, and that’s also in education. You know, unless you have Mhmm. Inspiration from the educators, how can you hope that, you know, it’s just do what I said. Don’t do don’t do what I am or don’t do what I do. Then how can it work?
Yes. So the strength of the inspiration of wonderful human beings somehow is the most powerful inspiration for transformation. And I’d also like to add, if I might, that, you know, there is an important feature of cognitive work. I mean, you’ve been saying, well, that’s cognitive. What’s practice?
But cognitive work is practice in the Lojong tradition, in particular, mind training tradition. That’s that’s part of the practice. So there’s a verse, for example, in the eight verses of mind training that says, when whomever I am whoever I’m with, I will always see myself as the lowest and hold others from the depth of my heart as better than me. And that’s a kind of way of proceeding to you can bring that verse into your mind when you’re starting to feel yourself yourself feel arrogant. You recall that verse to mind, and it’s a way of constantly making your day as you go through the day one in which you’re being humble.
But you do that by sitting first sitting and reading the text and thinking about it and meditating a little bit about it. It’s not as if the cognitive work is separate from the practice. It’s part of the practice. I wanna talk about three types of wisdom.. I yes.
So it basically, in the in the process of practice, one is trying to develop wisdom overall. But there are three actually, kinds of wisdom. One form of wisdom is the wisdom of learning. One learns a particular for example, in the context of mind training, one would learn different types of techniques that are meant to counteract, self-cherishing. One might read the Bodhicaryāvatāra, the guide to the bodhisattva’s way of life, and study it.
This is learning. And then having learned, for example, the verse that said, if there’s something I can do about it, why I get upset? If there’s nothing I can do about it, why I get upset? When then one then contemplates the meaning of that, why would what what is the point of this? Well, I’m not getting upset because I don’t get upset focusing on the small things as it were.
I have a larger goal that I’m trying to move toward, a realistic goal. And then when actually having thought about it and really understood the meaning of this, Then in meditation, one tries to actually directly understand it, not in a not in a conceptual way, but in a nonconceptual way. So there’s learning and then contemplation and then taking the mean the meaning that one is contemplating and trying to really directly understand. Familiarize? It’s not easy.
That process of familiarization, a very deep level of familiarization, such that it really becomes natural Yes. Or automatic. And you don’t have to think about it. Real effect to come. Mhmm.
Just knowledge. Can you say a little more about that third way? Non conceptual way means when you have reached to a kind of certainty that there’s no need to worry. There’s a kind you are put in a different mental state at that time. Or say, oh, you you arose loving kindness and compassion very powerfully upon an object.
You reach a certain feeling. But now, usually, it goes right away. Here, the third part, non-conceptual means to let it soak in for a while, not just to move to something else, but let it completely permeate your being, and that requires some time of remaining with that understanding. We don’t have to understand it further, but you have to remain for a while, cultivate it. Evan, you had a comment you wanted to make.
This actually connects, to what John was just saying about wisdom because, if we if we connect the present discussion back to the earlier discussion of altruism and we look at these six criteria for altruism that were given, it’s striking that there’s no mention of anything like wisdom. There’s no mention of anything like knowledge or ethical cognition or ethical know how. So to take the example of the man who runs after the mountain lion, I don’t know the actual circumstances of that particular action, but that action in general is quite consistent with something that is foolish and from another standpoint could be judged to be unethical. So suppose that this man had children who were dependent upon him for their welfare and he’s putting himself in danger or other people rely on this person critically, then this act, although impulsively altruistic in some sense, could be a kind of foolish altruism. So I think it’s very important that we remember that wisdom has to be in this in this conceptualization of altruism that we’re working with.
Otherwise, we’re not really working with something that has any real cognitive depth and and cognitive and emotional balance to it. And I I I just think that that’s that’s especially crucial for for Westerners in thinking about things because we focus in on something like compassion, and we have a tendency sometimes. I’m not saying you’re doing this, but I think that, in general, we often have a tendency to isolate it from other virtues, all of which together constitute wisdom or or ethical know how or knowledge. But the very quintessence of Buddhism is the union of wisdom and compassion. She has the very, very summary of Buddhist part.
Well, I like what Realistic. So we did mention the realist being realistic is one component, but being realism being realistic is actually Knowledge. Well, the deep that wisdom is real. Not really. There’s part of wisdom.
Is it? Is Mhmm. Is it wisdom? That should probably be wisdom. Well, and also, actually, the point here was also made that the practitioner who’s trying to practice the bodhisattva path is focusing primarily on a very subtle kind of suffering, which is the suffering that comes of ignorance.
And so what that practitioner is trying to do is actually study especially the nature of reality and then to contemplate that. And then their kind of the wisdom that they’re seeking in meditation is the wisdom that directly realizes the nature of reality itself so that they can eliminate their own ignorance and help others to do that. So, really, wisdom is is a major as Matthew just said, it had the Bodhisattva path has both compassion and wisdom, both method and wisdom. It’s key. Well, I like The same is true for Oh.
Good stuff. Yeah. Thinking of these as two things that get put together, I like a lot because in some of the examples of these rescuers where they rescued one 12 year old child and were putting in jeopardy their own three children. Was that wise to do? What they tell you is that they had to do it.
This is a so they you could say in some sense, the compassion itself wasn’t based on wisdom, which doesn’t mean that you don’t want to combine wisdom with compassion. I would like to switch to another topic, which is can all emotions and, of course, I have my own peculiar definition of what an emotion is. So hatred is not an emotion, and attachment is not an emotion. Emotions are Well, that makes things easy. Anger is, though.
Anger is. Yeah. The we could go into why hatred isn’t, but I won’t do that yet. We have spent a lot of time talking about that. You said, affective mental states create disturbance and a loss of self control.
We tend to lose our freedom to act in accordance with our aspirations and be caught in a distorted mindset rooted in a deeply self centered way of relating, and I couldn’t agree with you more that that’s afflicted. The question I’m posing is, can emotions, anger, and I think I already know your answer to this, be act in a way that does not eliminate the freedom to act, that does not distort our view of reality, and does not involve a
Loss of control. Albeit, Wolf mentioned, I think yesterday, I’m losing my sense of when things happened on which days, that the there is a narrowing of attention that can occur. I’ve called this a refractory period during which you don’t even have access to all of your own knowledge in memory, only to what fits. But that may only that can be useful if it’s only a very short period. And so there’s correction.
So the It’s focusing attention not to if we can distinguish that from distorting reality. Distorting reality, you see things that aren’t there Yeah. Rather than just focusing on this immediate problem and what seems relevant, but it has to that has to widen. But but distorting reality can include things phenomena, other things that aren’t there. It can also include misperceptions of things that are there.
Absolutely. Yeah. And I think that occurs for a systematic reason. That is it doesn’t occur by accident. But that’s still distorting.
I would agree. So what was the point about the refractory period? Just that it’s a it does narrow attention. It doesn’t messes but if it’s a brief narrowing, it narrows attention both to the outside and to what you know. But your point is that this is not necessarily a distortion of reality.
It’s simply a narrowing. A narrowing of attention. For example, you know, you can in the case of a a practitioner who has got a, you know, quite So he’s always saying that he actually knows some individuals who has this skill of, you know, maintaining single pointedness of their attention to the point where they get to a a state where, you know, even if they hear if there is a noise around or someone may be walking in the front, they’re totally oblivious because of the total attention paid to their object of meditation. So There was Oh, oh, glass. His Holiness was referring to a Tibetan master from a Drepung monastery whom he knew very well.
He I received teachings from him. A top scholar. Top scholar. And a good practitioner. So he had this tremendous skill of total focus.
So when he would be teaching and then he would be reflecting upon a chain of, you know, thought. And then when he he gets into this total absorption, then sometimes he is oblivious to what’s happening around him. If I can carry this to one more step, and that is if we take your definition, this is from your book, that wholesome mental factors are based on whether the acts give rise to one’s ethical well-being, then I’m envisioning even with anger that’s directed at the act and that’s compassionate for the actor but stops injustice, that would meet your criteria of ethical well-being Mhmm. So that anger as well as other emotions, if they facilitate further cooperation and collaboration between people, then they are wholesome. Right.
Now this is partly an internal discussion here about the Tibetan technical technical Tibetan terms for anger versus hatred. His was saying that in the case of anger, he can invest, you know and there is a recognition that you can have anger which is motivated by compassion, and then you can have an intermediate state of mind of anger that is, you know, that feels a sense of outrage to an unjust unjust act. And this is a very rough state of mind, but because it is motivated by compassion. So And it’s it’s actually the the the kind of the the quality of the mind and and its relation to the to the object, which is the unjust act. There is a a the state of mind is that of a repulsion.
It’s an expression of a repulsion. You want to you want to repulse that that act. And so it’s also a very kind of, you know, a rough state of mind, but it can lead to a positive consequences because it is motivated by compassion. But in the case of in contrast, he cannot imagine something similar with hatred. You cannot have a hatred that is motivated by compassion that leads to a positive action.
Because hatred Hatred presupposes ill will. Evil. Ill will. Ill will. Ill Yeah.
I So there’s no place of Yes. Compassion. My conceptualization is slightly different but compatible that anger can be at an act, not at the actor. Hatred is at the actor fundamentally. It is for that person.
Whatever they do, you still hate them. And then And so therefore Charlie, I hate to use to worry. So in that case, you wouldn’t Charlie hated the unjust act. So you can’t you have hatred towards the unjust act as well? Well, I wouldn’t call that hatred because it would hatred the other characteristic of hatred is that it endures.
Anger can be just for a few minutes or seconds, but hatred is a permanent mental state. As long as you hate that person, you it’s always there. Yeah. But even with anger, if the motivation is to harm Yes. Then Then it’s no excuse whatsoever.
Yes. I would agree. Then it’s not constructive. Because when your aim is to harm. So if hatred is directed to the person and and and Then that hatred must remain till the death of the person.
But that’s not that long. No. You can it can One year or ten year. Then afterward, is it that hated person eventually become your best friend. I agree with that.
Same person. Yes. But you have changed. So why why how would the person change in the case of someone who has hatred towards? I think there can be many reasons.
But but in any case, the essentially, action and the actor, the person still separate. Yes. In hatred, the act the it in hatred, it it is about the person, not just the specific act. In anger, it can be just about removing the obstacle But, generally, when you have strong emotion of anger towards someone So the immediate Mhmm. Do target the person.
You you don’t make the distinction. You actually for you, the object of anger is that person. And not only that, but also that Any negative action, destructive action is based on cause of illusion. Right? Alright.
Because it the it is because of illusion, and the indication is when negative emotions come, you see, there must be some target. So negative emotions don’t really take into account complexity. It’s always focused on some Mhmm. Concrete target. Mhmm.
That target also absolute, independent, never changing, that kind of appearance, isn’t it? Well, that’s a very unskillful version of an emotion. But that may be the way the negative emotions typically arise. So we don’t know for certain, do we? No.
But I think that’s what your holiness is suggesting, particularly in the case of anger. Because when you when anger arises, His Holiness is questioning this distinction that hatred is directed to the person and anger can be directed to the act. Because when you have strong emotion of anger without hatred, anger, you know, it is directed to that person in its entirety. It’s just this you know, the person becomes the object of your anger. Well, there’s nothing permanent about what I’m suggesting.
It’s an attempt to make distinction. Distinction. It is very likely that you’re right that hatred that anger starts in all human life to hurt the actor. I would like to think that that isn’t built into anger. And that what the that what’s built into anger is removing the obstacle to my goal and that you can learn that the least effective way of doing that is hurting the actor.
And then because the actor will then unless you eliminate them, they’ll then be retributive. And when I asked a developmental expert who studies anger in the first year or two, this is Campos, he says it’s open question. That is to whether we learn to hurt or we have to unlearn not to hurt in anger. But we do agree, I think, on the fundamental point that if the anger is directed at the actor, it’s destructive. If it can be at the action with concern for the actor about how they can achieve their goal without hurting or blocking you, it’s wholesome.
Because there are many people in the West who believe that the Buddhist view is to never have any anger. And I don’t think that is the view that you’ve put forward, at least in some of your writings, where you talk about this anger at the action, not at the actor as and the necessity for stopping harm with force. Maybe there is something in what you are saying about the fact that hatred is directed to the person, not to the act. Because if you look at the way in which we experience anger, say, for example, towards our friends or family members as opposed to someone that we hate. So in the latter case, there is ill will in it.
And when whenever there is ill will, the the anger that you feel tends to be much more intense and and long lasting. And usually, think, among your friend, due to some of their misbehavior, you may feel anger. Yeah. But no ill feeling. Mhmm.
So this case, you see, as long as they are wrong because of the misbehavior, there are some anger, as soon as that behavior change, you see, no no longer that anger. Mhmm. But ill feeling, not that way. Mhmm. Even that person is showing you a smile or something, still you feel awe.
Such great performance. Could be an actor. So where does ill feeling arise? From the sky. Oh, okay.
Well, I think our our day has come to a close here. Guess I Sorry. Sorry. It’s alright. Yeah.
That’s no thanks. Thank you very much. Self centered setting No. So, yes. Ignorance.
Serious. This self centeredness was one of the factors that you listed as unwholesome mental state afflict. Yeah. That’s the source. So to me, it always comes back to the issue of the grounding or outlook that the person has in life.
That’s the fundamental. That is in some sense the answer to all the questions. So this is quite true because when you have ill will, what the other person does subsequently doesn’t seem to make much impact. You know, if you have a strong ill will, it’s very definite. You know, what the other person does later subsequently doesn’t seem to have much impact.
But on the other hand, if it is just an anger, when the the the object of the
Anger of the person. When something changes, your emotions changes too. I agree, though. Thank you. Thank you.
You’re holding this.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
To have compassion for someone else, do we always have to feel their pain first?
Yes. In the Buddhist tradition's order of cultivating compassion, one of the suppositions is that a person must first be able to experience their own pain and find it unbearable. Without that basis, it is not possible to empathize with the pain and suffering of others. Recognizing and feeling one's own suffering therefore comes first, and compassion for others rests on it.
Can anger be wholesome if it encourages cooperation, and can hatred ever be motivated by compassion?
Anger can be motivated by compassion. It can be an intermediate state of mind, a sense of outrage at an unjust act. It is a rough state of mind, an expression of repulsion in which one wants to repulse the act. Because it is motivated by compassion, it can lead to positive consequences. Hatred is different, and nothing similar can be imagined for it. A hatred motivated by compassion that leads to positive action is not possible, because hatred presupposes ill will, so there is no place for compassion in it.