1 h 48 min · 12,540 words · 10 April 2007 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 108-minute dialogue from the Mind and Life XIV conference in April 2007, the Dalai Lama joins physicist George Greenstein and Buddhist scholar Matthew Ricard to explore fundamental questions about the origin of the universe. Greenstein presents the Western scientific picture—an expanding universe that was once dense and hot, with evidence from cosmic background radiation and helium formation—before asking whether the Big Bang was creation from nothing or a phase in an eternal process. Matthew Ricard articulates the Buddhist logical objection: that nothing cannot become something because transformation requires something to abandon, and nothingness has nothing to abandon. The conversation then pivots to how Buddhist philosophy envisions a beginningless universe through endless cycles of contraction and expansion, governed by karma and causation rather than a single uncaused cause. The Dalai Lama and his translator Thupten Jinpa unpack the subtlety of how material and conscious evolution relate, the role of karma in universe formation, and how space, time, and physical laws are conceptual constructs dependent on phenomena rather than independent entities. The dialogue examines whether we can maintain efficacious reality without objective grounding, and concludes by anchoring these cosmological questions to Buddhism’s ethical aim: alleviating suffering through right understanding.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Mind and Life XIV Dialogue on The Universe in a Single Atom; April 10 2007 (D….mp3
UUID: 4b2fdf7d-5917-45a3-8d9c-18b285b37a70
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Dalai Lama Talks
Date: 2007 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~12,546
This afternoon, we’re going to turn our attention from the very small individual particles of the universe, namely the quanta that we talked about yesterday afternoon and this morning with Anton Zeilinger. We’ll be turning our attention to the largest features of the universe. Right? From the atom to the cosmos. And we’re gonna be telling that story of the cosmos.
George Greenstein is a colleague of mine at Amherst College, who you know from 1997 meeting when he was here also with you and presenting on similar themes. We’re gonna be coming back to those themes because they seem to pose such important questions and issues, specifically around the beginnings of the universe, the questions of beginnings in Buddhist cosmology, and the differences that we often find between Buddhist cosmology and Western thinking concerning the origins of the universe. So what we’re going to do then is to invite George to tell his story, to raise some of the large questions that we experience at the hand of that story, that we discover at the hand of that story. Then following that summary, we’ll then turn to Matthew Ricard, and he’ll give a short precis of observations from the Buddhist side concerning again the same the same theme. And then we’ll open the discussion and invite your holiness as well to speak concerning these large questions.
So without further ado then, George, we’re Good. In your hands. Thank you. Anton Zeilinger yesterday began his talk and peppered his talk at many points by reference to the great thinkers who had influenced his thinking. Little quotations from Bohr and Einstein and Mach.
I would like to begin my talk with a quotation from somebody who has influenced my thinking, namely Anton. Anton began by saying, I want to know why the world is so strange. I need new concepts. The old concepts that we have simply don’t allow us to understand the quantum. And perhaps these concepts will come from this collision between two different cultures.
I wrote that down. And I feel the same way about the question of the origins. The two ways of thought being the scientific way and the Buddhist way. When thinking about the origin of the universe, we have a lot of facts that we know, but they lead us to a gigantic question, which is not which is a scientific question, but it was also a question that takes us beyond how I know how to think. And I think it’s a question that takes all scientists beyond how they know how to think.
So what we need is a new way to think. So perhaps out of this conversation, some some new way to think will emerge. So I thought I’d begin just by describing what we know about the origin of the universe. It’s completely not well understood. The origin of the universe is not well understood.
I don’t understand. There it is. It’s not well understood. But we have evidence, and we have several kinds of evidence. One piece of evidence is we have evidence that the universe is expanding, and the second piece of evidence that I’m emphasizing right here is that the universe was once compact and hot.
A little background. When you go out at night and look at the sky, everything that you see is contained in our galaxy. This is a picture this is a picture, a photograph through an astronomical telescope of a galaxy. A galaxy’s all stars, all moons, all planets, all comets, everything we could see with the naked eye, and more than that is a member of our own galaxy. There are other galaxies.
Galaxies are extremely large. They are 100 there we are. 100,000. There are something like 100,000,000,000 stars contained in a galaxy. A galaxy is around a 100,000 light years across.
That means it takes a ray of light one hundred thousand years to cross a galaxy. For comparison, it takes Not light year. Light year. Light year. For comparison, it takes a ray of light a tiny fraction of a second to circle around the Earth.
It takes around one second to go to the moon. Takes around eight minutes to go to the sun, but one hundred thousand years to cross from one end to another of our galaxy. And as you can see, these galaxies, the stars seem to be organized in these very pretty spiral patterns. Okay. Okay.
Yes. Good. This picture here, it looks like little smudges of light, but actually, each of these smudges of light is a galaxy. Each of these tiny little smudges is 100,000,000,000 stars. Each of those smudges is a 100,000 light years across.
And as you can see, there’s a lot of smudges in this picture. There are many billions of galaxies that we know of. In 1935, Edwin Hubble discovered that galaxies are all moving away from each other. Every galaxy is moving away from every other galaxy. If they had been moving at a steady rate, we can calculate how long ago they were closer together, and the answer is 15,000,000,000 years ago.
Fifteen billion years ago, the galaxies were all jammed together if they’ve been moving steadily. So that’s one piece of evidence, namely that 15,000,000,000 ago, all the matter in the universe was very close together. That rests on an hypothesis that the motion has been steady. And here we have two observational checks. Here we have two more pieces of evidence that this general picture is correct.
We have two pieces of evidence that the universe used to be extremely dense compacted, but also that it was very hot. The first piece of evidence is the remnant of the heat radiation from the hot compressed universe. Anything that is hot emits light. A flame emits light because it is hot. These lights up here emit light because they are hot.
And if the universe had been hot, then it would have emitted light. And we’ve detected that light. That light still exists. It’s been detected. A very faint glow filling the entire universe, which is the remnant of the superheated state of the universe.
And the light was that light was emitted around ten thousand years after the Big Bang. The Big Bang was this original state of extreme compression. So that light is evidence. The fact that we have discovered the fact that we have detected that light is evidence that we understand all the way back in time till around one hundred thousand years after the Big Bang. Our general ideas seem to be correct.
They are confirmed by observation starting around one hundred thousand years after the Big Bang. We also have evidence, a different kind of evidence that we understand what the universe was like ten minutes after the Big Bang. And this comes from the fact that ten minutes after the Big Bang, the universe was so hot that nuclear reactions took place. And these nuclear reactions created certain of the chemical elements, and they created and we can if our ideas are correct, we can predict how many of these chemical elements were created. And then when we go out and observe the universe, that’s exactly how many chemical elements we find.
This evidence specifically refers to the one single element, helium. Helium seems to be have been created during the first ten minutes of the Big Bang. So these three pieces of evidence, first, that the universe is expanding now. Second helium is Big Bang. Third, But, I mean, you mentioned that the helium Yeah.
Exist after ten minutes after the Big Bang. But Big Bang itself, isn’t it is it it’s an explosion? Heat. Immense heat. You put in you said there is an immense heat there?
Immense heat and very highly compressed. To the helium doesn’t exist at that time. So the helium doesn’t exist at that time? It was created at that time. Yeah.
It was created. One minute. At ten minutes. At ten minutes. Mhmm.
Prior to ten minutes, there was no helium. After ten minutes, it was created not created. It was synthesized the way. But the difference is by reactions. Yeah. Two.
Three reactions. I know. It was not creation out of nothing. Right there. Yes.
So three pieces of evidence just to repeat. The universe is expanding now. In the past, it was very dense and very hot. And, at a 100,000 years ago and at ten minutes at at a 100,000 after the big bang, we know it was very dense and very hot. At ten minutes after the Big Bang, we know it was even denser and even hotter.
These are the three pieces of evidence we have. But we also have a theory, and that theory is Einstein’s theory of the Big Bang. This is part of his theory of relativity. Einstein’s theory of relativity has been extensively tested experimentally, but this element of his theory has not been tested experimentally. So if we believe Einstein’s so what I’m gonna tell you now is what Einstein’s theory says about this hot compressed universe.
It has not received too much experimental test, but here’s the theory. The theory is Einstein’s relativity, and the bottom part here is the important point. According to that theory, the expansion of the universe began in a state of infinite compression and infinite temperature. Compression. Now we call that state the big bang.
It doesn’t mean anything. It’s simply a phrase we use to describe it. Infinite compression, that means that all matter, every speck of matter that existed occupied exactly the same space, and there was no distance whatsoever between objects. The distance from one object to another was literally zero. Infinite temperature means that everything was moving with infinite energy.
Energy, physical energy. So can we speak about the size of this compression that causes them The size of the the size of the space occupied by all matter? Is there a size or is it zero? It is the size is zero. So you cannot really talk about the the the the special location of this.
That’s right. Mhmm. It is this infinity that’s the hard part. But let me just keep going. So what caused the big bang?
What came before the big bang? Oh, that’s it today. Yes. Was the big bang creation or was it simply a stage in the evolution of the universe? Did the universe exist prior to the big bang and pass through this state and then come into the current state, or was the universe created at that instant?
These are the questions. And the answer to the questions is we don’t know. And I’m gonna talk So what do you mean by creation here? I mean As as prior to the big bang, there was nothing. Yeah.
And after the big bang, there was a lot. Creation survey. So would you say something that is caused event is a creation? If you say that the universe is comes from a cause, would that be considered a creation? My expression.
I wanna ask you that question. I came here to ask. Let me just continue and then we can talk about this. Let me just continue with there are a few more things we can say. The reason why we do not know how to answer this question is that we do not know how to deal with all matter occupying exactly the same space.
And we also do not know how to deal with all matter having infinite energy. We know how to deal with matter occupying a small amount of space, but not zero. And we know how to deal with matter having a very high energy, but not infinity. And I don’t think we’re ever gonna find out because we are finite beings. But the reason why we don’t know how to answer these questions is the infinity, and the infinity comes from Einstein’s theory.
But there are speculations, and we can all have whatever speculation we want, but here are some of the speculations within the framework of the Big Bang theory. One possibility is that before the Big Bang, the universe existed, but it was contracting, coming together, and boom, and went out. And we live in the out phase. There’s nothing in Einstein’s theory that says this would have happened, but there’s also the nothing there is nothing in Einstein’s theory that says it didn’t happen. Einstein’s theory has no way to deal with this, so we can say whatever we want.
A second possibility Second possibility. The universe existed. It was contracting to this state of infinity. And at that instant, all the laws of nature changed, and then it expanded outward again. There are some theories of physics that what we call the immutable laws of nature are actually not immutable, that they can change.
The force of gravity suddenly changed. The charge on the electron suddenly changed. Things like that. A third possibility A third possibility is that the universe existed and was tracked. What’s the difference between the first and the second then?
In the first, the laws of physics did not change. Oh. In the second, the laws of physics did change. Okay. That’s the difference.
Okay. Laws of nature physics A third possibility. The universe existed, contracted to a bounce, expanded, stopped, contracted to another bounce, and this way endlessly. An endless series of cycles like that. A fourth possibility that nothing existed at all before the big bang.
Nothing in the sense of well, nothing existed. Now if we raise that possibility within the context of physics, there’s a whole series of enigmas. Enigmas. No. For example, if we hypothesize The fourth possibility is that nothing existed prior to the big bang.
Within the context of physics, there’s a whole lot of questions about that. Here’s here’s one question. Do the laws of nature exist if nature doesn’t exist? For example, Newton’s theory of gravity, Newton’s law of gravitational attraction says that any two objects attract each other with a certain force. Was that true if there were no objects?
Einstein says that the speed of light is constant. Was that true if there was no light? Thermodynamics says that energy is conserved. Was that true if there was no energy? Did time exist prior to the big bang?
I don’t happen to understand time, but, what naive understanding I have of time is that it refers to the passage of events. But if there were no events, was there time? I don’t either I also don’t understand space, but it has to do with how far away I am from Arthur. But if I don’t exist and Arthur doesn’t exist and nothing else exists, then did space exist? So all of these speculations lead to the idea that if the big
Bang was creation. It was not just the creation of matter. It was the creation of laws and concepts. Concepts of time and space, laws of physics. So if we really the concept more.
No. Do you do you go to the concept? You define what you mean by concepts? Of nature. Laws of nature.
But I also mean time and space. If time did not exist, then why am I worried about what came before the big bang? Before has no meaning. And so now I would ask you to instruct me because right here we completely run out of understanding. Now there is one technical possible solution to this problem, which is that all of this is based on Einstein’s theory of relativity, and Einstein’s theory of relativity does not include quantum mechanics.
It does not include the insights of quantum mechanics. So everybody knows that we need another theory, a theory that includes quantum mechanics and the Big Bang theory. And perhaps if we could create that theory, that theory would say that the Big Bang was not infinitely dense and not infinitely hot, but only very dense and very hot. And that theory might tell us what came before the Big Bang. But people have known about this possibility for seventy five years now, and no one has succeeded in creating that theory.
So it may be that we’re never gonna succeed in creating that theory. So I don’t think we should just wait until physicists come along with a new theory to start answering these questions. So here, I, all science has run out of understanding, and this is the current status of the question of the origin of the universe. Thank you, George. So this is in a very brief telling the whole history of the universe.
That was remarkable, George. I think that was fifteen minutes. Now what we’d like to do is to take these questions, especially these last questions. You know? Did did time exist prior to all material existence?
Did space exist? Were the laws by which the whole universe were constructed? Were they anteced or prior to the universe itself? Did this all come into existence? Does it make any sense to even speak about before and after if time doesn’t exist in such things?
We’d like we these are un unsolved mysteries. We’d like to ask Matthew, if he would not mind, to speak a little bit to us concerning how the Buddhists understand, on the one hand, the origins of the universe or the beginnings of of of this story. But, also, we understand from your book and from other conversations we’ve had with you this whole question of beginning. Yeah. George has emphasized on the one hand, the big bang as an event, we simply don’t know whether there was anything beyond that event.
How do you address that question from your own perspectives? Yes. So I’m in no way accomplished scholar, so I will say a few words, but I would like my colleagues to complement on that. Basically, we have this feeling that it must have begun somewhere. Now we are ready to go fifteen billion years back, but we said, oh, it has to begin somewhere.
And the western mathematician and philosopher Bertrand Russell said, there’s no logical problem with the notion of having no beginning. There’s just a problem of imagination. He said, it must be something before something before. Wait. It must have begun at some point.
So but now what’s the opposite? The opposite is to have nothing. Otherwise, no. See, we have no beginning. And then go from nothing to something.
So there, we perhaps have no problem of imagination. We say, oh, well, nothing can become something, but we certainly have logical problems, ex nihilo sort of production or creation. So what is the nature according to the Buddhist scriptures of those logical problems? Well, for instance, in So now one of the greatest classic Buddhist philosopher, Śāntideva, in the ninth chapter of his way of the bodhisattva, the wisdom chapter, said that a million cause cannot make nothing become something. So why is that?
What is the reasoning behind that? It is that the process of becoming implies a kind of transformation. You have to leave a state to go to another state. Red becomes blue. It has to shed its redness to become blue.
So now nothing, what does it have to abandon to become something? It is nothing to be transformed there. And if you think a bit further, what is nothingness besides a concept? It’s simply we imagine that there could be no phenomenal world. And purely in in our mind, we say, well, if there was nothing, then this if nothing of this would be there, there will be nothingness.
But that’s just a concept. The idea of the absence of the phenomenal world, which is a given phenomenon, a primary sort of evidence of that there is being a phenomenal world. So how can simply the idea of the absence of phenomena be something that can become a cause of creating something? So that’s one of the main argument is that nothingness is just a pure concept, and it cannot become a cause of production. So that’s one of the main and also, it would have to abandon its condition of nothingness, but nothingness has nothing to abandon, basically.
So that’s one of the logical reasoning. So then the other extreme is that it has to be if if we don’t want to go to big absence of beginning, that there have to be a primal cause. So all the civilization that envisage I’ve been envisaging a creator or some kind of primary cause, what no matter what names you give to that, say, okay. There was a cause which itself is without cause. Otherwise, you know, then we’d need a further cause, we go again back to being in this list and which has in itself all the necessary cause to bring about the universe.
It cannot have the need to get help from somewhere else. Otherwise, it’s not the initial cause. Again, you go to a former cause and another cause, and then we’re back to no beginning. So then what would be the characteristic of that cause? It does have to have all the causes and conditions to produce the universe.
Right? Now what happens in such a case? Why something happens or does not happen? When something does not happen, it’s because some causes and condition are missing. If you try to make tea, if you have no fire, you can’t boil it.
When you have everything for something to happen, then it’s it cannot not happen. Therefore, the logical reasoning, if that all the causes and conditions were present within this first cause, which has to be as a first cause, it would have to produce the whole universe all the time because otherwise, it’s missing something. It needs some other triggers. It’s it’s incomplete, whatever. It’s not the initial cause.
Or it cannot produce anything because basically there’s no change in that changeless causeless cause. So those are the the basic sort of logical reasoning on the one hand to say that the the can nothing is not something that can turn into existence. And that a primary cause, which has all the cause within itself, which is not itself not cause, either is completely static or has to produce the whole universe all the time. What do you mean all the time? Over and over again?
Just at every moment because it has all the cause and condition for producing. Why should it stop? It’ll be instantaneous causation. Which other Everything has to come come into being instantaneously. Well, because all the information are fully complete there.
The big bang was instantaneous. Yeah. But not only once because It have to be Okay. So what would stop it to do so? If it’s if it’s a self contained initial cause that have all the causes, which it it must have.
Okay. But but it presumes that all the causes are all the all the causes and conditions are present. I mean, making tea was the example you gave. It required all the causes and conditions to present. Doesn’t have, then where does it get it from?
Yes. So but all of them had to be present. So then would it be the same also for the universe if you were missing as it were one of the elements, one of the causes and conditions? It would never happen. Would never happen or only until that causing condition Where would it get it from?
Would it come from? I see. Because it’s part of the universe. So at every instant of time, somewhere there’s a universe being created is the idea. You were saying No.
No. All the time doesn’t make any sense. No. That’s So the only an absurd an absurd conclusion. It’s it’s a reductio ad absurdum of certain approaches.
So the for the only thing that makes sense, even it’s hard to imagine is that it’s always So this set of causes and conditions, are they matter? Are they energy? Well, that’s that’s not the main issue. But also It is the main issue because if they are matter and energy, then they’re part of the universe. Yes.
So, anyway, big no beginning means there’s always been something before no matter the state of there’s only states of transformation. Yes. Yes. Yes. Nothing becomes from nothingness to something.
Yeah. And something also will not go to nothingness. There’s no such cause that can completely make something to become nothing. K. And actually, this same reasoning apply not to the only to the universe, but to the bit of your atom disintegration.
Because in a way, it’s the same reasoning of something having no cause coming to existence. Whether it’s the big bang or a single particle, the reasoning is exactly the same. It’s a kind of ex nihilo production if you say that an individual particle has no cause. And so I hope that Thupten Jinpa will elaborate on the argument against causelessness. But one beautiful one is if something including the universe or a single particle doesn’t need a cause to be appear, then what stops elephants from appearing in the sky?
They don’t need cause. So not just one particle, anything. The sky will be filled with elephants, with everything else. Because they don’t need cause, so what’s the problem? So then the whole history of, I think, the production of the universe and all that, the beautiful formation of galaxies, that’s not any problem for, according to Buddhist philosophy.
One thing I would like to mention, however, is that the idea of our planet being the center of the universe is anthropocentric was never in the picture. From the from the sutras, they speak from the beginning of billion fold universe. Ours business is small unit, a thousand of those being secondary unit, a thousand of those secondary unit being a tertiary unit, means a billion fold universe. They speak of universe being like curtains of lights, like torches spewing fires, wheels of lights, all these beautiful images that you seems to be already looking the Hubble telescope. So, of course, it doesn’t mean that they were somehow someone looking at that in some way, but still the idea that there was almost infinite possibilities, universes, And now for bigness also as another thing, there must have been life.
There must have been consciousness in all those billion universe. So the problem also of this single localized so in a way, our big bang is a very, very small part of history history from that perspective. And so in that sense and also it solved another problem, the famous intelligent design. If it’s always been there, what do we need for an intelligent design? And what do we need for the so called fine tuning of the constant of the universe to make it happen so that life could be there and we could be there to observe the beauty of the universe?
It’s not necessary because it has always been together. So, of course, they are mutually they cannot be mutually incompatible. So the fine tuning is almost perfect. It has to be. Okay.
So this is, I think, these a few Thank you. Ideas, but I wish that you might complement on that. I know. I do I’d I’d like to hear what his holiness has to say. I don’t really have anything to add in particular.
I would say only that the one one interesting point that might come up eventually would be the notion that causality requires change, as you pointed out, and that if something changes, then it changes by its very nature, which means that at least on some Buddhist accounts, this means that all things are instantaneous, which would also be they only exist instantaneously for a moment. They are all momentary. So this would be yet another argument against the notion that the big bang is an absolute beginning. But I don’t wanna go on there. I’d like to hear what his holiness might have to say here.
I don’t know. Your holiness? May I I pose a a more leading question? So his holiness is that he has 100% support for Matthew when he contrast the problems, the concept the imagination problem versus the logical problem with respect to beginning and beginninglessness. So the idea that we can imagine it’s easier for imagination when we say there is a beginning, but logically we have more problem.
But it’s harder to imagine when you say it’s beginningless, but logically, that seems to be more in tune with reason. So here, His Holiness is saying that he He would sort of he would concord with Nāgārjuna in his precious garland where Nāgārjuna says that when the Buddha was asked whether the universe whether there is end to the beginning the starting point to the universe, the Buddha did not respond. He remained silent. So So I follow that. I really don’t know.
I really don’t know. Yeah. Let’s see. Very interesting about that. Very difficult to make conclusion.
Very difficult. Well In any any case, the present is present. It’s really effect. So that’s more important. And, accordingly, future is important.
Vast. Okay. Well, here Didn’t I warn you the other day? Instead, it’s better to have a nice sleep. If you wanna lose a little sleep, here is one instance of the future, Namely, if the current expansion of the universe turns into a contraction, then the question is, what is our future?
Is our future that we simply pass out of existence in the second big bang or somehow get transformed into a third big bang? This also these these mysteries refer to the future also if the universe’s expansion reverses into a contraction. Now the the technical So No. So to relate this story, know, that you told the different options, the speculations that physicists have come up with, the Buddhist positions seem to be much closer to the third option where there is this constant, you know, expansion and shrinking and and then coming into being again. This this kind of repeated dissolution and the origination of the universe.
And, of course, in the text, this arising of a new universe is explained in terms of a process of the arising of the different elements. You know, for example, like from the starting with the wind element, it may be more kind of metaphoric. But, you know, for example, like, if we relate that to the idea of a compression, you know, infinite this this initial state of total compression, that can be seen as a a state of tremendous energy. So wind in the sense of energy, which then, you know, give rise to to kind of the future unfolding. So that that seems to go quite well with the the the standard Buddhist position on the beginningless universe.
So sometimes. So having said that, one thing that we need to bear in mind is that this this idea in a rep repeated kind of dissolution and origination of the universe does not necessarily suggest that, you know, the same kind of universe will come into existence over and over again. Same elements already. And also kind of elements as well. Oh.
So you you can envision a new universe with a whole set of new properties and elements that may not, you know, be the same as the one that existed before. And here, of course, from the Buddhist point of view, karma has a has a role to play because the origin of the universe is tied to the kind of the karmic causation of beings who are going to futurely inhabit that universe in the future. Yeah. So, for example, within the Buddhist text, there are discussions of different realms of existence. And within these different realms of existence, beings have different constitutions of existence, you know, physical embodiments with different faculties.
So there’s this notion that, you know, depending upon the environment in which one inhabits, there’s going to be a difference in the physical constitution of of the sentient beings. So similarly, one could imagine a world where it could be very different from the world that we inhabit. A universe. A universe. Yeah.
So once so once again, if we understand this correctly, there is a now not a mental causation, but there is a karmic factors which can influence a physical Order. Unfolding. So, again, there’s this the the two levels of, we might say, causation. So I take it as we go back in time, we go back in time not only with the story that George told concerning the concerning the material universe, but we also go back in time concerning the consciousness part of the universe. And that these one thing that So, His Holiness was saying that, you know, we already had discussion about causation.
And and from the Buddhist point of view, when we speak of causation, it is important to bear in mind that we’re not immediately meaning karmic causation right there. Not immediately meaning karmic causation. Okay. Because karmic causation is a subset of the general law of cause. So you can imagine the unfolding of natural process of causation in the natural world, which may have nothing to do with karma.
But karma causation only is relevant when there is a cause and effects kind of, you know, factors involved where there is an intentional act of a sentient being, an act of a sentient being with an intention. Then that is related to the karmic causation. Now how you know, at what level this kind of karmic causation intersects with a natural law of causality is a difficult, you know, a difficult point. For example, in the formation phase For example the universe. Yeah.
Exactly. You mentioned there might be karmic factors. Yeah. But at what stage and At what stage and how specifically and so on. Influence.
And then here, His Holiness was saying that he would the traditional approach is that when it comes to the subtle workings of the karma, it’s only the omniscient mind detailed workings of the karma. It’s only the omniscient mind of the Buddha that knows all. I like to clear up one. I didn’t know. So for example So No.
Oh, Yeah. One of the things that we have to remember is that from the Buddhist point of view, the fact includes not just evident facts, but also inferred facts, which could be not so evident, cannot be immediately observed, but we have to infer it on the basis of the observed phenomenon. Then there is a third level of facts which are recognized in Buddhism referred to as the extremely hidden facts or concealed facts. And with this regard, know, it’s the only the omniscient mind that will be able to understand. And and in some sense So here Third for many, you know, for many for ordinary people, the only avenue of knowledge is the testimony of a third person.
So that that becomes the only available source of understanding of that particular fact. But then that also brings up the question of how do you accept the the the authority of that third person. You have to you know, it just cannot be any evaluate the third person. So that brings up a whole set a host of questions. And one of the criteria used in determining in evaluating the authority of that third person in the Buddhist context is, of course, we’re talking about scriptural authority here is to how far the scriptural descriptions are internally consistent.
Now with regard and and how whether or not they contradict, you know, confirmed realities, you know, that are So there is a very complex criteria of evaluating the authority of this third person testimony. And for example, you know, with regard to a particular scripture, when we exam evaluate it, it needs to be with respect to the first two levels of facts, the evident fact and the inferred facts. The statements should be logically inviolable. They should confirm to our, you know, evidences and so on. And and even with respect to the the third level of facts, which is extremely concealed, first of all, the speaker should be someone who doesn’t tell a lie.
And furthermore, the statements that are made within that domain, which is the domain of the extremely hidden or concealed phenomena, they should it should be internally consistent. So there are all these criteria which are used to determine whether or not the testimony can be taken as as as valid. So but this Holiness was saying that with respect to the what is important is to appreciate the overall approach. It’s important so the to use No. What may be helpful in in, you know, appreciating the Buddhist perspective here is to look at what in in Buddhism, we speak about four principles which provide an avenue of understanding nature of reality.
These are the principle of nature and principle of dependence and principle of function and principle of evidence. So and and and the first principle is is really we get to the, you know, primary level of reality where we get to a point where we simply say that’s the way it is. And and in other words, you do not that the Oh. So when you So when you get to that point Mind the level. Now that which is the the the principle of nature, when your discourses has reached at that level, then basically, in a sense, it’s the given.
That’s the way it is. You do you cannot go beyond that boundary. So he’s holding up a saying that if he is forced to accept objective randomness that Anton is talking about, then he would have to interpret it in terms of this, you know, this Nature. Nature principle of nature. Beyond explanation.
No need for So the investigation. Okay. So based upon this principle of Oh. Based upon this principle nature, then you have principle of dependence where then the explanation has more to do with the interaction between the different elements. So here, there’s a some parallel with the notion of chemistry where you have new properties that emerge as a result of interaction of different.
And as one can see these as kind of simultaneous causation, but causation in a loose sense, one mutually reinforcing and complementing each other so where there is a kind of a inter interrelationship. So Invisible in the subtle way effect So there might be kind of a mutually kind of reinforcing effect even at the galaxy level. Very subtle in case. Subtle. Yeah.
And then the third principle is the principle principle of function. And here, we are talking about law of causation, cause and effect, function in the sense of producing something. So at the previous level, we’re not speaking about the law of causation. Subtle influences Yeah. That are not They are more like interconnections.
Yeah. Interconnections. And then based upon these three principles, then the principle of evidence comes, which is the use of logic, you know, reason because of a, b, and so on. So that takes into account the principle of nature, principle of dependence, and principle of, function. So that may be helpful, as His Holiness was saying.
I think Richie has a point of clarification he’d like to ask. I just wanted to go back to the, issue of karmic causation and the notion that intention is critical for for karmic causation. I wonder, Your Holiness, if you can talk to us and help us understand what you mean by intention. That’s something that’s very important in the Western mind sciences and neuroscience. And I think it would be of great interest for us to learn more about the Buddhist understanding of of the notion of intention.
No. So Yeah. Yes. The the the concept of karma is actually a very complex one. So His Holiness was saying that he was just making a very broad generalized statement of karmic causation versus natural gen normal causation.
So to take an example of say, a grown growth of a tree from a a a a seed, a fruit tree from a seed, that natural causation that is involved, the processes that are involved on the part of the seed, there is no intention. So that process is in, you know, a kind of a natural process. But when we speak of karma and causation, karma generally literally means an act. And act here presupposes an agent, a person who is committing the act. So therefore, intention of an agent already comes into the very understanding of the definition of the act itself.
So are are all acts intentional? So however, within the karmic action, there are different types of karma. You have some which are committed but not accrued, then some which are accrued but not committed, intentionally committed, and some which are both. And do these connect back coming back to what George was describing? You mentioned that there are these karmic factors or influences with regards to the formation of a new universe.
If there are always agents, does that imply that there’s always even in the very early stages of the formation of the universe, that there is all also agency? So this is This is the problem. This is actually a very difficult question.
Shall we translate what this is just what all has transpired here? Well, His Holiness is this Let me first translate. Translate the first part and then give us a sense of what the discussion will make sense. And then we also have to remember we have a tea break coming. Yeah.
But we’re at an important moment. So as always, we’re saying that Arthur, your question really takes us to the heart of the the difficulty here. And the difficulty is, for example, if you take, you know, this body, for example, from the point of view of the material continuum of this body and you if you trace it all the way back to the origin, the material, you know, factor Before Big Bang. Before Big Bang. Yeah.
The material factors that constitute the existence of this body and the material factors that constitute the existence of, say, rock or mountain or something. There’s no difference at all. So there is no difference at all. So it’s simply a processes that involves and and takes different forms. Now the question is, at what point does this process that is naturally evolving come to be affected by karma?
So here, His Holiness was saying that his own personal view is that at that point where the the the processes evolved where it can sustain a consciousness of a sentient, that’s when karma has to come in. And then the the karma in involves from that point onwards. And and once the sentient beings evolve in in the natural world, then, of course, environment also has a karmic connection because the, know, the environment has a direct effect upon the the happiness and the suffering of the sentient beings who are inhabiting in this. And even in the Buddhist text, there is a notion of environmental effects of karma. You know?
And so here so that was the general point. And so His Holiness was saying that it’s very difficult to pinpoint where the simple natural process of, you know, evolution intersects Yeah. With the karmic causation. Then he was asking the question to the monks here. What do they think?
And, you know, for example, like, if they agree that so far as the material continuum of this unfolding is concerned, there is no karma. The, you know, the process is natural and so on. Then what about when a visual perception arises? Okay? Visual perception arises on the basis of the sense faculty.
Would you say that is a karmic effect? And one of them has said, no. That’s that’s part of this natural non karmic causation. And then about the environmental effect of karma, for example, like, today we are experiencing this this, you know, this room here and participating and enjoying the facilities here. So since His Holiness was saying this is part of his own residence, maybe he is the one who had made most of the karma for this.
But since all of you are, in some sense, participating and you you using this facility, there has to be some karmic connection. Now if we push that far, so he’s he was asking the monks that, what about, you know, some of the monks, they may have body lice. The lice is also now in this room. Thus, the lice also have some karmic connection with this. So you can go, you know, keep pushing.
So, of course, if the karmic link there, when? So even in the case of this house, this environment. Yeah. So the where does the karmic comes in? You know?
Is it after the house has already been built? Or how do we take it to the causal stage? And if so, how far are we gonna take it, you know, all the way up to the beginning? Well, I think one of the most important places where karma can happen is during a tea break. Oh, really?
And we are in fact That’s a. This a fruit of the positive karma. So positive karma. We’d like to bring you much positive karma. So in as much as we are in your house and home, we thank you for that, and we also thank you for the tea that we’re about to about to enjoy.
So we’ll come back in about fifteen minutes, if that’s alright. So by quarter of, by this clock, please. That is a Sautrāntika school position. Forget that. So, Ravish.
Ravish. Ravish. Ravish. Ravish. Thank you.
I used to have them to service you. Okay. I think we’re all reassembled Yeah. I really find that. For the last part of the session this afternoon.
Sounds good. I’m sorry. All of you are part of the the tea break here because the conversation concerning the origins of the universe and karmic factors was was indeed completely clarified and solved. But paper quarters were off, so I’m afraid it’s lost. Unobserved.
Unobserved phenomena. Unobserved insight is out of Yeah. I’m not sure if the inside is outside. We’d like we’d like to continue the conversation and perhaps some elements of our tea break conversation if we might naturally find a way into the discussion that we continue this afternoon. But we’d like to first ask Matthew to say just a word or two in direct response to something George Greenstein brought up concerning space and time and whether these began with the big bang when there was no matter, no energy.
Did space and time exist? Yeah. I just forgot to mention the the position the Buddhist position about laws, time, and space. Basically, as being relative phenomenas belonging to the phenomenal world of cause and and effect of instant events and impermanence and not existing on their own besides phenomena. The argument being there that if they were existing somehow out there without phenomena or the changing transformation of phenomena, that would require that they exist autonomously or independently as imminent entities.
And like almost like platonic ideas or universals. And the critics of that is that they were independently existing, whether it’s mathematics, physical law, time, which trouble. They’re already broadening. Mhmm. Okay.
Our space that will if they add an independent autonomous existence They being, I’m sorry, space and time that you’re talking about. Yes. Yes. One all of those. Okay.
Including mathematics and law of physics. That means they will be a autonomous existence independently of phenomena. And that the logical conclusion that is absurd would be that, therefore, they could not relate in any way to changing cause phenomena that has to do with cause and effect. They are being autonomous and therefore permanent and imminent or existing outside phenomena. We have no way of relating to a conditioned world, conditioned by cause and effect, by permanence, by being interdependent, and so forth.
Again, causality requires change, and And dependence. Can’t change. Mutual things can’t change. And mutual causation and dependence. So in a way, they are intimately linked to the very fabric of impermanence, causation, what time is the the link to the transformation of phenomena, space, the the special dimension, which they they sort of occur.
Laws are the the laws that that are connected with the causation and the independent arising and so forth. Mathematics would describe the evolve transformation of phenomenas, but they will not exist as independent ideas or entities outside phenomena. That’s the Buddhist position, I think. So do I understand you to mean that anything that is autonomously existing in and of itself cannot affect anything else? Cannot be affected or cannot affect.
It’s just doesn’t exist for us. Yeah. So Exists in its own little universe all by itself. Well, it’s all So it’s very of it. Very often, those things such things are considered to not be truly existent.
They’re only conceptually existent. So for for example, time will not be thought to be actually a real thing in the world, but rather a conceptual construct and not a real thing in the world. How about a number? Now there will be Buddhist systems in which time does exist. Numbers.
There will be Buddhist systems in which time does take into exist, in fact, or substantially, but the higher the higher philosophies, they will not real. For example, from the Buddhist point of view, time would be contingent upon temporal phenomena, whether it is physical or mental. And independent of the temporal phenomena, the concept of time doesn’t really make any sense. But we should then be clear. You say either physical or mental.
Alright? So since the mental stream goes all the way back through their earliest formation and even beyond since it’s there is no beginning, there are mental phenomena that are always available. So there are always mental change. Therefore, time would always exist even as a conceptual construct. Pardon me?
Relative to those phenomena. But never forget. And when we speak of existing. Let let’s let’s just However, the time is a construct of a temp you know, temporal continuum. So and then independent of the temporal phenomena upon which it is constructed, you cannot conceive of time as an independent kind of Right.
Entity. So as I understand it then, time doesn’t quote have a beginning, but it is it is code codependent on the temporal phenomena that it is, emergent from or something of that sort. Alright? Wolf? I’m sorry.
I just just I think I should clarify something here. Maybe we just sort of drop down into a simpler level of explanation. So for example, the concept of a glass. Alright? We’ll drop down to a lower level of explanation.
These are all called a glass. Why are they all called a glass? Well, one sort of platonic approach would be that they all had they all instantiate a universal like glassness, and that would be a position that would be taken by a non-Buddhist school, an Indian philosophy like the Naiyayikas. And the Buddhist response would be, we cons and glassness with the Naiyayikas school would be a real thing. But for Chittamatrina.
Chittamatrina. So but but for Buddhists, talking especially at really at all levels of Buddhism, there is no such thing as glassness. It’s something we construct conceptually in order to use language, but there is no glasses. There’s only individual particulars, individuals, which are actually all unique. We make up this sameness for the particulars.
Likewise, time is is is conceptually constructed. So it doesn’t exist in the way that glassness. It’s a product of our conceptual construction. That’s, I think, a key point here. But but glass the glassness is a product of our conceptual construction also.
Yeah. Glassness is a product of conceptual Yeah. Glassness, time, things that generally are distributed over many things are understood to be conceptually constructed. Wolf? This is an observer’s comment.
It seems to me that of what we have heard today about the different approaches to reality, that our different cultures certainly share the categories of space and time because they are the issue of our primary perception. We perceive the world as such. We perceive the world of classical physics. And I think mankind so far has exhausted the possibilities by mere reflection of dealing with those categories. Because some of the things I have heard about the Buddhist position sound familiar to me.
It’s in Greek philosophy, in the Stoa, for example. You find a lot of this. It has been taught already. So and now we have the problem that these physicist people, without providing final answers, raising more questions than they actually solve. Yeah.
Because because they count they they go against our primary primary experience of the way in which we perceive the world. They produce very contra intuitive conclusions questioning the validity of these classically believed canonical categories of space and time And I don’t know which else. There may be a few more of those. So maybe we have to abandon those concepts. Wouldn’t that be a solution?
Wait, it’s not a solution, but we may have to abandon them, which will put us into a very strange world because this world will no longer be intuitively graspable. And the question is how do we feel in a world in which we play with categories which are intuitively no longer plausible in everyday life. We’re already in that world. Yeah. Some of some of some of us others know.
I mean, you you have the privilege of being in this strange world at home. So what’s your question? What is it like? It’s like what it is to be me. That’s what it’s like.
And it’s not very different. No. The question is not whether we we have a collective problem that is not a specific problem between Buddhist culture and Western culture. But it’s a problem that we all deal with categories that we have derived from intuition and primary experience. And in this respect, we resemble each other.
There are different positions, but they have all been exhausted more or less. And now we see that these primary categories may not be valid, and this puts us puts us in the same trouble. We sit we row in the same boat. Yeah. So There we are.
That was the point. Yes. Yes. Thank you. So this really raises a very critical point.
And here, probably, the Prāsaṇgika perspective may be helpful because the the challenge being raised is how can we maintain a notion of reality, you know, that is that is is efficacious Workable. Yeah. That is workable, that is efficacious, and that doesn’t lead us to this kind of extreme while not positing some kind of essence independent reality out there. So the where the tension is coming from is often when we are trying to define something, when we are trying to find the nature of something through a process of inquiry, often the this process is really led by a quest or some kind of assumption that we should be findable, something that can be objectively grounded. So here So here, there seem to be a kind of a a certain parallel between the the process of analysis that you find in the Madhyamaka deconstruction or an the kind of disconstructive analysis of a concept and then the kind of analysis you find in the
Quantum level where you’re really kind of, you know, going at a very deep level. Although the quantum physicists may not use the language of the the logic of emptiness, but seems to be pointing towards the same. And that that similarity is you are going beyond the boundary of kind of sensibility of language and concepts. No. It’s not And and under you’re not you are you’re not staying within the domain and at the level of experience, mere experience and mere Phenomenal appearance.
Phenomenal appearance or experience of the individual. You’re going beyond the boundary of that. And when you search for something by going beyond that boundary and and basically, the assumption is that you’re looking for something that is objectively groundable. So when you proceed in this manner, the end result is nothing is found because nothing can be findable in this in this way. So then the question is, how do we then make sense of the reality?
How can we, in some sense, create a notion of reality that is efficacious? No. Function is. I ask. No.
Upon on the let on the basis of which we can accord our law of causality, all the functions that we all agree and and so on. The existence. So in other words, reality, the existence. So here, the suggestion has been to say that that criteria has to be not objective. That criteria has to come from purely from the subjective perspective.
The observer. Here, the role of observer and observation comes into the picture. And so what would be that subjective criteria? The first one that that observation or observer would be, it could be a person’s experience. It could be a shared convention and and language.
And and, you know, what else would be shared language Shared language. Convention I guess so. And experience and and That’s no. That’s commonly accepted? Yeah.
Convention that is based upon, common experience, and and also shared language. So that would be the first criteria. But here, of course, if we just simply say a personal experience, then you can have all sorts of crazy people saying, well, I’m gonna call this, you know, I, you know, I I would say this exists because I I feel it, I see it. So how do you counter that? So you have the second criteria, which is that this this So sorry.
We have to step back. So there there is therefore, we cannot speak of reality independent of an observation by a subjective experience. However, that doesn’t mean that anything goes so long as you mentally want to designate. So you have how do you keep the middle way between a subjective criteria but that that also doesn’t slide into anything goes? So so here, the you need the second current criteria, which is that it has to be a convention that is not only affirmed Or phenomenal appearance.
Phenomenal appearance that is only that is not only shared, but also something that does not contradict another valid Conventional cognition? Conventional cognition, actually. Another valid. So so Like a lot of third person or even one person in different time. Subsequent realization.
So so that this way, someone’s egocentric kind of, you know, you know, conventions can be negated. But even here, we need a third criteria because we may all share a convention and a belief in some kind of objective independent existence. So then we can all mutually reinforce each other’s perception, but that doesn’t really accord with reality. So here, the third criteria is that that convention should not be also contradicted by an inquiry into the ultimate nature of reality. Because when you presuppose intrinsic existence, objective intrinsic existence, that can be contradicted by an inquiry into the ultimate nature of things, which is basically emptiness.
So, for example, within the Buddhist context, there are debates between the various schools. And from the Prāsaṇgika’s point of view, some of the postulations of the lower Buddhist other Buddhist schools are grounded upon this assumption of objective findability of things. And for example, when you ask what is the true nature of the person, what is the referent of the first person term, you know, I, Then other Buddhist schools, some of them who are motivated by this assumption of, you know, findability, you know, something that is groundable in objective reality would say, well, it is the totality of the the mind body complex. Or someone may say, it is the mental mental consciousness. And then some school even postulate the idea of an eight completely different stream of consciousness called the foundational consciousness or store consciousness.
And and so although from their point of view, these may be taken as conventional realities, from the Prāsaṇgika’s point of view, the postulations of these ideas are motivated by an assumption that person must be findable objectively. Therefore, from Prāsaṇgika’s point of view, they have stepped beyond the boundary of this, you know, convention and and language. Therefore, that these postulations can be negated by inquiry into their ultimate nature of things. Even though they wouldn’t be negated by others sharing the same convention. So if a bunch of persons who share this convention of the eighth consciousness that there’s a foundational consciousness, if they get together and talk about it, they’ll say, well, I don’t know.
Sure. There’s the eighth consciousness. It’s not gonna be something that will be negated by conventional cognition, but it would be negated by a cognition analytic of the ultimate. No. Yeah.
And let me just clarify. So this presents the criteria of what could be accepted as conventional reality. What exists? Can I just make one comment? And there’s a very interesting term that comes up here in Tibetan, is ma tsim pa, not being satisfied.
We’re not satisfied with just going with what appears to us phenomenally or what is in terms of our experience. We think there must be something more there. And when we go for the something more, that’s when we’re looking for this objective reality. So it’s being satisfied with the conventional and with phenomenal appearance and with experience that allows us to remain at the level of conventional. And if we keep stopping satisfied by that, we need something more, that’s when we head toward the ultimate and toward essentialization, toward objectivity.
Evan, would you like to make a comment? Yes. I’d like to pursue the discussion of, the the status of the conceptual constructs, particularly with regard to the example of space. It seems to me that it’s not sufficient to say that space is a conceptual construct. That’s true, but we need to go deeper.
And we need to ask, how does that construct arise and come to be in our experience? And it seems to me that what’s crucial there is that we are embodied beings. We have certain kinds of bodies. So I experience things as up and down and back and front and left and right because I have a certain body with a certain symmetry that makes me inhabit space with an egocentric structure. But I’m also a social being, and I can cognitively adopt your perspective and mentally imagine how things look from your perspective.
When I do that, I transpose my egocentric perspective over to yours. And a further development of that then is the realization that there are many possible egocentric perspectives. And so space has to contain all of those different possibilities. When we make that further step, then space is no longer my perspective or your perspective. It has to be this further medium that contains these perspectives.
All of which though, in terms of experience, go back to my egocentric space. Now, we know also in biology that the brain codes space egocentrically, also codes it non egocentrically. So there’s a biological basis for this. So we can give a phenomenological story or account of how the construct emerges out of our experience from the first person perspective of our bodies. But then we can also relate it to the biology that we have, to the way that our brains work, to our our evolutionary history.
And when we do that, I think we go to a deeper level of account of where these constructs come from. This is what I was trying to get at earlier this morning when I raised the question about where do these constructs like space, time, and so on, where do they come from? To answer that question, we need this kind of developmental phenomenological and biological account. Are you in basic agreement with this comment? Do you wanna make any statements?
Or Yeah. But the whole universe is centered, so sort of iron. It is true because, in fact, this egocentrism is even one could say that the the center of the whole universe is actually one’s oneself. East, west, In centers, do it. Centers.
So when we speak of east, west, and so on, you know, it’s always from the perspective of the person and you become the center. Right. Although, I think you could also ask whether there is in this explanation, you’re no longer being satisfied, you know, whether you’re Ma tsim pa here and you’re really looking for some kind of objectivity or instead, you’re just looking for a richer explanation of your phenomenal experience. So if it’s a richer explanation of your phenomenal experience, then it’s just a kind of way of us understanding our conventional reality more clearly. If it’s really a kind of covert search for objectivity, then it’s going to end in in the same set of problems.
Can I just quickly respond to that? Then I think we have we have the physics side of this come on. Go ahead. Well, I would just say that from the perspective that I articulated, we would want to be able to account for how it is that we come to have a concept of objectivity that may mislead us. But nonetheless, we have this concept.
Where does it come from? It comes out of this intersubjective framework. That’s that would be the point I would want to make. We should say that, you know, space and time or nowadays, these are brought together in a single concept of space time. Again, analyzed through experiment, not conceptually in the way we’ve been talking philosophically, but simply out of the necessities of experiment.
That the concepts we have conventionally had proved to be insufficient, and we’ve had to modify them. So this idea of just convention, just be satisfied with what you have has worked out. Time. Space. Anton, would you like to make a brief comment?
Just to continue what you just said, this new notion of space time, of a unity of space and time is something which I think is a beautiful example of a successful new concept developed by physics, which did not exist before. I’m not sure whether any tradition the ancient Greeks certainly didn’t have it. I don’t know whether any other tradition did have this concept of unity, which was basically developed by relativity theory is extremely successful. So I agree with what Wolf said that we should give up these old concepts, these old notions, but we are on the way. We invent some new notions, which really work.
We have some new notions in relativity theory. We have I mean, like the picture I gave you of quantum mechanics was intentionally to point at the open questions because this is why I came here. I could talk for a week and you would not even realize that there are open questions about quantum mechanics. I could talk for a week, tell you the success and how precise everything is and how well it works. So the situation is not as bad as it sometimes sounds.
Think Wolf would like to A very brief example just showing that this is nothing new. We have been thinking that the sun is the center of is not the center of our solar system, but that it circles around the earth. We still perceive it as such. And when we write love letters and emotional stuff, we always say that the sun rises here and it walks and then settles down. At the same time, we know that this is wrong.
We live in parallel worlds, and we do this wonderfully. And we use the different descriptions of the world for different purposes. If you want to have a satellite fly successfully, we would be very, very poor if we did it, if we had this model. And so we will have different models for different purposes. And there will be nothing that will take us away our primary perceptions and the force they have because they are the only ones that give us the immediate evidence that something is true.
And I can give you examples tomorrow how strong these preconceptions are against which you cannot fight. Even if you know it otherwise, you will perceive it as God or who else made us nature. Well, concerning this sunrise or sunset that you see the sun rising, I actually personally, I worked on this. And now when I see the sunset, I really have the feeling that I’m on a rotating sphere. And the sphere rotates such that the sun comes out of sight.
It took some training, but it is another experience I have when I see a sunset or a sunrise. So so you can modify it. I can tell you because my wife is here. Your Holiness, I’d I’d like to I’d like to bring it bring our attention in some sense away from our love letters. We have a monastic community here.
We have to remember to respect and they have their vows after all. But coming back to this question of the the phenomenal domain, I’d like to make make sure one thing is clarified. We’ve been talking a lot about the sense phenomenal domain, the phenomena of the senses, the glasses, the sunrise, the sunset. But, of course, within your tradition, there is also a meditative tradition in which there is also, you could say, other phenomenal domains. Do you apply the same analysis to that level of reality as we do to the sense based level of reality?
Do the same conditions that you mentioned, for example, for their validity have to be proven to be the case, a consensual agreement, ultimate analysis, and so forth.
Same same would apply. And the same with regards to conceptual designation in that domain. We have talked about conceptual designation of these glasses. Yeah. It’ll be the same.
The same. Really? This applies across You’re the me, sir. Top levels of experience. Not as any.
This is really the criteria by which we judge whether something can be said to exist or not. So that applies across everything. Thank you. I think that’s important. One last issue which I think comes back to something that Jinpa mentioned at the outset.
Namely, that the entire orientation of Buddhism is towards the this ethical direction. Now we’ve been talking quite abstractly, quite conceptually, quite philosophically about existence and the early universe and all of this. In what way does this serve the relief of suffering of sentient beings? So the basic conclusion. The the the the the basic motivation is really this ethical motivation to seek alleviation of I think I think the in other word, I think nobody want suffering or I think the another way, nobody want enemy.
I think nobody from early morning thinking, oh, today, I want to create one enemy. I think nobody think that, isn’t it? Agree. Oh, but meantime, from early morning, oh, today, I wish I will find some good friend. So so now they ultimately, whether you find good friend or enemy is not dependent on external, but your own attitude.
Clear. So now the question is, what inner element creates enemy? Anger, hatred, jealousy, so on. Usually, we call destructive emotion. The the inner element which bring genuine friend is respect, love, compassion, sense of concern.
So now the thinking, yes, I want good friend. I do not want any single enemy. Even those enemy, I do not want to eventually forget to change. Change. So they finger point now.
Oh, must change. I remain always anger, shouting, fighting, then endless enemy will come. Isn’t it? So now how to change the negative emotion or destructive emotion or positive positive emotion. A positive emotion or constructive emotion.
Now here, we have to know the reality. Emotion, unless it’s a contradictory emotion, two emotions there, no possibility to change. So change will not come through prayer. Change through effort. How?
Knowing the reality Reality. And nature contradictory Oh. Opposing each other. Opposing forces. Oh.
It is causes. Knowing that, then there is possibility to develop enthusiasm or hope or vision, enthusiasm, then determination, effort. So then gradually change our mental attitude. So that’s the Lam Rim. So so that takes us to the actual path, the graded, you know, gradual levels of the path.
So in order to construct the path Path. The reality, we have to know. So the understanding of reality is part of that overall project of how how to know to change. And the change demands the understanding of the actual workings of reality. And then earlier, His Holiness was saying that while the emphasis is on understanding the nature of reality of the inner world, but because the inner world is connected with the outer world, so the Buddhist inquiry into the nature of the origin of the universe, they are ultimately ultimately tied to this project of seeking liberation and alleviation of suffering.
So in in on specific points, you may not see the direct connection, but they are ultimately connected to this ethical motivation. I think if there are ignorance, the destructive destructive, I think the No. Distorted views and particularly the the ignorance. If in order to remove that, it’s necessary to know the quantum physics, then Buddha must taught that. But since, you see, the the real kind of the counterforce of the grasping wrong view is the wisdom or understanding about ultimate reality.
That’s absence of independent existence. So Buddha taught, or emptiness. So like that. Mhmm. Of course, there’s Buddhist viewpoint.
May not be a 100% correct. Your Holiness, I think we’ve come to the end of the afternoon session. We wanna thank you especially also for this last contribution, which brings us, you might say, to the real purpose that we’re here working among many friends, I think, together for the kind of insight into the nature of reality that will indeed serve to relieve the suffering of all sentient beings. Thank you very much. Namo.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is meant by intention in the context of karma, and how does karmic causation differ from natural causation?
Karma is a very complex concept, and the distinction here is a broad, generalized one between karmic causation and natural causation. In the growth of a fruit tree from a seed, the processes involved on the part of the seed have no intention; it is a natural process. Karma, however, literally means an act, and an act presupposes an agent, a person who commits it. So the intention of an agent is already part of the very definition of the act itself.