40 min · 1,939 words · 26 November 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains emptiness as the non-existence of an independently existing self, understood through dependent arising. It contrasts entry into the path of accumulation in the individual and Mahayana vehicles, and distinguishes the object of negation of the Autonomy and Consequence Middle Way schools. Questions cover why attachment varies among beings, and the talk ends with a dedication of merit.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-11-26
Duration: 40 min
UUID: 9937d871-1801-4d61-a22a-a95d16ca3cde
Words: 1,935
So as you said, the self arises in dependence upon many causes and conditions. That the self does not exist independent of causes and conditions. There is no self which does not exist dependent upon causes and conditions. When the self is established through the aggregation of causes and conditions. It is through this very reasoning, that is to say that the self is established in reliance upon causes and conditions, therefore it does not independently exist, that we come to understand emptiness.
If we meditate on that, then we will understand the non existence of the independent self. Now, slowly, slowly we will come to understand the non-existence of a self, which is emptiness. If we don’t meditate on that, then we won’t understand it. So the self arises in reliance upon causal conditions. Therefore, self is a dependent arising.
If we understand that the self is a dependent arising, then this self as a dependent arising is incompatible with the self being independently existent. The self being a dependent arising and the self being independently existent, these two are mutually incompatible. When again and again meditating on this, coming to the understanding which thinks there’s no self which relies upon nothing other than itself. There’s no self which is independent. The self does not independently exist.
This is the understanding of emptiness. Along those lines, one of the teachings, Rinpoche said that through the first realization of selflessness of persons, enter the path of accumulation. And that through subsequent realization and cultivation, we enter the higher paths and grounds. What is the nature of the realization of the selflessness of persons that which one enters the path of accumulation? Is that the only measure of entering the path?
You mean the, is that the path of accumulation of the individual vehicle or the Mahāyāna? No. You say that is not correct. Is not correct. No. Okay.
Would you like to yeah. It’s the yeah. But maybe you’d like to reshape the question. I don’t know. Well, basically, I wanna know what the nature of the realization of selfless selflessness of persons is and which one enters the path of accumulation.
If it’s if if there are differences between the Hīnayāna path and path, perhaps those could be addressed. But, basically, I just wanted to know what I mean, what did you have to realize? What I mean, you know, in in order to enter the path of accumulation? And if What do you think that realizes Oh, that’s a different question. Okay, okay, that’s good.
That’s what you want to ask? Yeah, ask that one. Okay, so what is the how does one enter into the path? Path accumulation. Of both vehicles?
Sure. How about those? First, with respect to entering into the path of accumulation of the Hīnayāna or the sometimes lesser vehicle individual vehicle. So the individual vehicle practitioner does not have a powerful concern for the welfare of others. He is very much concerned with his own welfare.
They have a dread of their own cyclic existence and they, seeing the various faults of cyclic existence and seeing the benefits liberation develop a longing to be freed from cyclic existence. And when, again and again, by meditating on this, such a longing arise spontaneously, that is effortlessly, then they have entered in when they develop the determination to awaken, or renunciation, then they have entered into the first path, the path of accumulation. On the other hand, in entering into the path of accumulation of the universal vehicle or the Mahāyāna, when through having meditated upon the determination to awaken, renunciation, then meditate on compassion, exceptional resolve, generated the awakened heart which wishes to lead all living beings to the state of Buddhahood, cultivated that again and again through meditation, when this arises in a non-artificial manner, effortlessly, spontaneously, then one has entered into the path of accumulation of the universal vehicle. So as was explained previously, when having seen the faults of cyclic existence and developing a longing which seeks to be liberated from it night and day, one has developed renunciation and the determination to awaken and has entered into the path of accumulation.
Because wisdom is generated through the activities of listening, studying, reading books, meditating, making requests to Mañjuśrī. Then upon the development of wisdom, with respect to what one has developed wisdom to, one develops a valid cognition, newly realizing that object. So through wisdom, we can come to know hidden phenomena. Phenomena such as impermanence, emptiness, selflessness, through a process of using reasons and then develop a valid cognition with respect to those objects. So, there are three levels of phenomena.
There are those which are obvious which can be easily understood. We can generate a valid cognition with respect to them easily like a flower or a table. These are quite easy to realize. But then there is a second level of phenomena, slightly hidden phenomena. And these require the in order to realize them initially, that rely upon reasoning.
And here it is necessary that in order to develop a valid cognition with respect to slightly hidden phenomena such as impermanence or selflessness, past and future lives, the paths and grounds, in order to realize these, we have to have wisdom and then out of that wisdom we will generate a valid cognition realizing these slightly hidden phenomena. With respect to the third level of phenomena, extremely hidden phenomena, only a Buddha can realize those. Those objects which are extremely difficult to realize, it’s necessary that one have removed the various obstacles which prevent their realization such as the afflictive emotions and the knowledge obstructions. Various faults which prevent their realization and only a Buddha has done that.
Yes. So both middle schools accept emptiness. There is a difference in subtlety of their presentations of emptiness between the two middle schools. And this subtlety is in terms of the subtlety of the object which is being negated in terms of emptiness. The Consequentialist Middle Way School’s object of negation is more subtle than the Autonomy school.
The Autonomy school does not negate, does not refute as subtle an object of negation as does Consequence. For example, the object which is negated, the object of negation according to the Autonomy Middle Way School is this: the absence of an object existing objectively by way of its own uncommon mode of subsistence, appearing without being posited by the force of appearing to a non-defective awareness. That is the object of negation of the Autonomy Middle Way School. The non-establishment of an object by way of its own uncommon mode of subsistence without being posited by the force of appearing to a non-defective awareness is the object of negation of the Autonomy Middle Way School. In terms of the Consequentialist Middle Way School, what they are trying to get at is the emptiness of self-defining existence or natural existence.
So they are saying that the object which is the conventionally existent object — the nominally existent object — upon analysis: the unfindability, the non-finding of the nominally imputed object upon analysis, is the subtle emptiness. The absence, the non-existence of the existence which is found upon analyzing for the nominally imputed object is subtle emptiness. I don’t know if you follow on that. I don’t.
The final point is that really what the Consequence school is saying is: even the nominally existent object doesn’t exist inherently. So the nominally existent phenomena do exist. If the nominally existent phenomena did not exist, then the nominally existent skillful actions would not bring happy results. Nominally existent unskillful actions would not bring suffering results.
There would not be the karma as actions and the results would not exist. There would be no past and future lives. There would be no liberation or omniscience. Living sentient beings have come in contact with the same objects. Why then are there varying degrees of attachment?
Can I say? Is that what you said? Attachment to these objects. Since they’ve all experienced the same objects, why are there different degrees of attachment to these objects? Something like that?
Something like that. Not like that. What? Consciousness being the same nature. Since all living beings’ consciousnesses are the same nature, why should there be varying degrees of attachment having come in contact with the same object over infinite numbers of lives? Something like that?
So you said that we’ve we’ve met with all phenomena. You mean that we’ve understood all phenomena? Like emptiness? We’ve all we’ve all understood emptiness in the past. So then all sentient beings were free from cyclic existence previous previously?
It’s because we don’t understand emptiness that we continue to circle within cyclic existence. If from beginningless time that we have understood emptiness, then we would not be circling within cyclic existence. In the Three Doors of Liberation it is said that which is emptiness — he says because sentient beings do not understand emptiness, it is because sentient beings do not understand emptiness that they continue to circle within cyclic existence.
And it said that upon understanding emptiness, one is freed from cyclic existence. So amongst human beings there are different degrees of the force of their attachment and anger. This is due to different degrees to which they have been habituated to these in past lives. You know, some in previous lives have been very forcefully habituated to have been habituated to very forceful anger, others to very forceful attachment and not having applied antidotes. Then they have these very forceful, they have very powerful attachment or anger.
Some people go on to meditate on the antidotes, for example, for attachment, and they lessen their attachment. Or they meditate on the antidote to anger, they lessen their anger. So there are all these possible varieties of degrees, variations in degrees of attachment, anger among even humans. Though it would be difficult for them in this way to completely eliminate anger. So these days, there are many people people writing books and many teachings are set out in books different types of teachings.
Some of them are mistaken some of them are distorted. And so we just you can’t believe everything that you read. We we if we rely upon in our reading if we read those books by the that were come coming from the Buddha and the various Indian masters then we can be sure of benefit from reading such texts. So tonight you you’ve asked good questions and I’ve enjoyed your questions and it seems that over the course of the year you’ve gained some understanding. Thank you very much.
And now we’re going to dedicate? So you should, you know, through having involved ourselves explanation of the teachings and listening to the teachings, we’ve accumulated skillful actions, created potential. So this, as it were, this drop of creative potential that we’ve generated. We’re going to place it, in the ocean of creative potential of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, combine it with their vast ocean of skillful action. And dedicating all of that skillful action, the creative potential, that we ourselves might, for the sake of all living beings, remove all our various faults and bring to consummation our excellent qualities and that we might generate an awakening heart.
By placing our drop of skillful actions in in this great ocean of skillful actions until that ocean is exhausted, our drop will remain. And therefore, the results will always be impending for however long that ocean is there. It will it will always be forthcoming.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How does one enter the path of accumulation in both the individual vehicle (Hīnayāna) and the universal vehicle (Mahāyāna)?
In the individual vehicle, the practitioner is concerned mainly with their own welfare. They dread cyclic existence, see its faults and the benefits of liberation, and long to be free. By meditating on this again and again, the longing arises spontaneously and effortlessly. When they develop the determination to awaken, or renunciation, they have entered the path of accumulation. In the universal vehicle, one first meditates on renunciation, then on compassion and exceptional resolve, and generates the awakened heart that wishes to lead all living beings to Buddhahood.