Compendium of Valid Cognition – 07 CoVC 1993 07 09

47 min · 2,506 words · 9 July 1993

Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition (Khensur Rinpoche)
Compendium of Valid Cognition - 07 CoVC 1993 07 09
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk comments on a verse by Dignaga that establishes the Buddha as a valid, reliable person through his causes of compassion and wisdom realizing emptiness, and that he taught the Four Noble Truths without error. It explains the first noble truth, true sufferings, with its four characteristics of impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness, contrasting these with non-Buddhist views of a self controlling the aggregates. It closes by stressing the need to develop a wish to abandon true sufferings.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1993-07-09

Duration: 48 min

UUID: f02aeb69-6426-4c6e-aaf1-407823116e5c

Words: 2,502

We are going to comment on a verse by an emanation of Mañjuśrī by the name of Dignāgā. This four line verse — of these four lines, the first two lines establish or prove that he is a valid person, a reliable person. And then the latter two lines express compassion in that he wishes to correct those mistaken Indian schools of ancient India.

There were numbers of schools, for example, the Samkhya — in Tibetan called Grangs Can Pa — and the Vaisheshika, in which they had mistaken understandings of what an valid cognition is. Their definition of an valid cognition was an error. So out of his compassion, he was seeking to correct their mistake. So in the first two lines which establish that Śākyamūni Buddha was a valid person, it is trying to set forth a proof which establishes that Buddha Śākyamūni is a reliable person.

And this is not done in a haphazard manner, but it is set out in terms of the nature of the cause, let us say, practice which brought about the result. If one if there is all the complete causes of the of the practice, then this can ensure that the a complete type of result, fully qualified result. And if we can ascertain the type of causes, then we can understand the nature of the result. So in relating this back to the non Buddhists of that time, they did accept the existence of valid persons. But these valid persons were valid by their very nature.

That is say, they did not rise out of any cause. They were permanent in nature. They were self arisen, not dependent upon any practices, not in order to bring about a result. And so this is one the first point of contention. On the other hand, within the Buddhist tradition, is said that the Śākyamūni Buddha became a valid person.

He was not self-existently a valid person. That it was through bringing about all the necessary causes that he, through his practice, achieved the result of becoming a reliable person, a valid person. That through his practice, was able to remove his various faults and bring to consummation all his excellent qualities. And basically, these two causes are are comprised of the intention, that is to say, the great great compassion, and the conduct that of the wisdom realizing emptiness. So another way of putting that is in terms of the causes are constituted of method and wisdom.

The method, great compassion, the wisdom, the wisdom realizing emptiness. And and depends upon completing these two causes, he achieved a result whereby he was able to bring about the welfare of both himself and others. So in dependence upon the complete causes in terms of practice, these two components, he was able to bring about the complete result and thereby become a valid person. Having become a valid person, Śākyamūni Buddha began to describe to others the various detriments of cyclic existence, its various faults. Upon their arousal of a longing to be liberated from such a situation, he taught them an unerring, unmistaken method of what is to be adopted and what is to be avoided.

Through these methods, he led them to liberation, which was freedom from suffering. To present unerringly the methods of liberation from cyclic existence. That is to say, to those who had a longing for liberation, he was able to present in an unerring, unmistaken fashion what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected. So in dependence upon these teachings, which were non-fallacious, he has become a valid person. So if we understand this position this situation well, the way this the layout of this description, then we will understand we will be able to develop a faith and a belief in on ascertaining the nature of these three refuges.

That is to say, the Buddha — Śākyamūni Buddha — who is the shower of the path to refuge. The Dharma, which is the actual refuge. And the Sangha or the spiritual community, which are those practitioners which assist us in in this process of going for refuge. So if one understands their nature and and and the the way in which they are presented, then in ascertaining that, one will develop a powerful faith and belief in these. So, it’s extremely beneficial if we understand how Buddha Śākyamūni taught an unerring path to students, those who wish to be free of their suffering.

So how are we to understand this? Initially, Guru Śākyamūni taught in India the Four Noble Truths. For the attainment of liberation, for the attainment of Buddhahood, it is necessary to ascertain the four noble truths. Therefore, these are these are mainly these are necessary this is the main knowledge necessary in order to achieve both of these ends. But even in terms of our practice itself, if the essence of our practice has to be based within this four noble truths.

If our path practice is to be powerful, if it is to be profound, then it has to include an understanding of the four noble truths. And also, therefore, it is necessary to investigate this teaching. So we have to examine these four noble truths. The first two presented in terms of what is to be abandoned. The the latter two presented in terms of what is to be cultivated.

We have to see, well, is this Are these actually the case? Is Are these to, in fact, be abandoned? Is Are these to be cultivated? Is this the way it actually is? You know, if it’s not upon examination, then let’s we can just set it aside say that Śākyamūni Buddha was not a valid person and then leave it at that.

But on the other hand, once we begin to to and we see that, in fact, there these are presented in a non mistaken, unknowing way, that we understand their infallibility, then we can generate we can having seen the infallibility of these teachings, we can develop a strong belief in the infallibility of the So if we, upon examining these teachings, come to see that they infallible, that they moreover they are have been presented in an unerring, unmistaken fashion. When we generate that wisdom realizing understanding this fact, then we can come to an understanding that the person who taught them must likewise have had the same un quality since they realized the actual nature of the situation, and they’re they were able to describe it in an fashion. So, therefore, the the the teacher of these must likewise be a valid person. Without the wisdom understanding what is being described, then there’s no way that what is to be cultivated and what is to be abandoned could be explained in an unerring, unmistakable fashion. If we don’t understand something ourselves, then we cannot understand we cannot explain it to others in an unmistaken fashion.

We can we can understand this quite readily that in order for a teacher to be able to explain to their students nature of the studies, in an unmistaken fashion, the teacher themselves must understand the subject. In order to have developed that final wisdom in one’s mind, it is necessary to eliminate all the various faults of the mind which would have inhibited that generation of that state, that understanding. If faults were there, then this final wisdom would not have arisen. How was he able to abandon these faults of the mind? It was through his practice and the practice of the generating the wisdom realized on selflessness.

And as a preliminary to that, it was the development of great compassion. These two, he cultivated these two over eons of time. And by means of which, he was able to rid his mind of all its various faults and bring to consummation his excellent qualities. So in order for those who long for liberation, those who understand the suffering nature of cyclic existence, that they understand what is to be abandoned and what is to be cultivated in non mistaken fashion. What was taught would have thought the four noble truths, the first two which which set forth what is to be abandoned.

The latter two set forth what is to be cultivated, and these teachings he taught in a non mistaken fashion. We must mainly generate these four noble truths. We must identify what is the truth of suffering. We must understand what is to be abandoned in truth in terms of the second noble truth, the true sources, understanding what what is to be abandoned if in fact these are to be abandoned, and understanding what is to be actualized in terms of truth, cessation, and understanding what is to be practiced in terms of true paths. And we should make use of analytic reason, reasoning in our investigation.

So the Buddha, you know, has a method for understanding the nature of the four noble truths, but most specifically, the understanding the the first noble truth, true sufferings, thought that true sufferings has four characteristics. The four characteristics are impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and selflessness. So, we have to understand what to understand. We have to identify the what true sufferings are. And first off, with respect true sufferings, sentient beings have three types of feelings.

They have feelings of pleasure, feelings of displeasure, and feelings of indifference. So feelings are not established out of reasoning but established through our own experience? So the suffering that we time to time experience is the truth of suffering. So the first characteristic of true sufferings is impermanence. It means that true sufferings arise occasionally.

Let us say from time to time — they are not permanent. We experience sufferings not continually in a permanent fashion, but they arise from time to time, and then they cease from time to time. So this is the quality of impermanence of true sufferings. So anything which arises on occasions — that comes and goes, rises and disintegrates — is termed an occasional arising. So this occasional arising applies to many other objects such as houses, rooms, feelings of pleasure, sufferings of pain, living beings themselves, the ground, the world.

These are all occasional arisings. Sufferings is suffering or dissatisfactoriness. And this is because they do not arise independently, but arise under the control of karma and afflictive emotions. They arise uncontrollably under the under not under not under their own power, but under the power of karma and afflictive emotions. So any that which arises under the under the control of karma and afflictive emotion is a nature of suffering.

The feelings of suffering arise under the control of karma and afflictive emotions and therefore are in the nature of suffering. For example, the body itself. Anything which arises under the control of karma and afflictive emotions is in the nature of suffering. That which is not arise under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions is not in the nature of suffering. So we’ve talked about two of these characteristics of true sufferings, impermanence and suffering.

And then there are the remaining two. Thirdly, empty, which is more difficult to understand. And then fourthly, selflessness, which is more difficult to understand. So the non Buddhists accept this third characteristic of being empty and implement methods whereby to bring about its cessation. So there are five aggregates.

The aggregate of forms, aggregate of feelings, such as pleasurable feelings, unpleasurable feelings, the aggregate of perceptions, or sometimes called discriminations, that is, say, the thinking process which discriminates this is this, this is this. Then there’s the aggregate and mental constructions, which is the the secondary mental factors other than the other than the first the second and third feeling and perceptions. So mental factors other than mental that then feeling and perceptions. And then the aggregate consciousnesses, which is the thinking mind. So according to the non-Buddhist So the non-Buddhist assert that the that the five aggregates are the factor which is controlled, and that the self is the controller of the five aggregates.

So, they’re the five aggregates which are under the control of the self. And that these two are of separate natures. They’re different natures. Whereas, the Buddhist position is that such a self of a different nature does not exist. Therefore, is said to be empty.

The person is said to be empty of such a separately existing self. So, the example if we illustrate this, a Tibetan illustration would be that if a business person has a store in which there are many articles and employees, and this this the owner there is an owner of the store. Owner is under is is the controller. And these the articles and the employees are under are that which is being controlled. They’re under the owner’s control.

So there are these two. That which is that which is subject to being controlled and the controller. So these two are individual or have separate entity are separate or individual entities? And so this is the this is analogous to the the assertion of non-Buddhist schools in terms of the nature of the person. They say that there is the five aggregates, which are the that which is being controlled, and there is the self which is the controller of these five aggregates.

And these two are separate entities. They’re different entities. Where as the Buddhist position is that no such type of separate entity exists and therefore that the person is empty of such a separately existing entity of the self. So if we if we if we exemplify what we’ve covered up to this point in terms of of a suffering feeling, a feeling of suffering, That it is impermanent. It it arises under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions, and it is not another basis than the self which is experiencing the suffering.

So it has we’ve covered these three characteristics in terms of feeling of suffering that is impermanent, that it is under the control has risen under the control of afflicted common afflicted emotions, and it is not a another a separate basis from the person who is experiencing the suffering. So the the fourth characteristic is that of selflessness, and here, it is the fact that the the suffering feeling is selfless, that it it does not have the nature of a self. That extends to all phenomena. Because suffering feelings are a basis for all four of these characteristics. Suffering feelings are termed true sufferings.

So it said that we are to understand or recognize or identify true sufferings. So understanding that true sufferings are a cause which bring about a result and that becoming in understanding true sufferings as as the the destructive nature of true sufferings, developing an attitude wishing to abandon true sufferings — seeing how detrimental they are, how destructive they are, developing a sense of wishing to abandon true sufferings.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Samkhya drang chen pa (Tib)
Early non-Buddhist philosophical school; the so-called "enumerators," because they advocate a definite enumeration of the causes that produce existents. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top