48 min · 2,491 words · 6 August 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk uses reasoning from the continuity of consciousness, the mind of a child arising from a similar earlier knower, to establish past and future lives. It then explains the twelve links, with ignorance and karma needing craving to produce rebirth, and urges practice of skillful actions for future happiness. It closes with the formless realms and the importance of a virtuous mind at death.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-08-06
Duration: 48 min
UUID: 15cb0000-c811-4ebb-9467-39fa403742a5
Words: 2,487
So these two — matter and consciousness — are mutually exclusive. Consciousness is like a mirror: it is clear, and any object can appear within it. The definition of awareness is that which is clear and knowing.
This quality of clarity is that it’s like light — it is clear, like light, luminous. And it also has the quality of knowing, in that it is able to know its object. Whatever object appears to it, it is able to know it. And if this knowing is developed, it will realize the object.
On the other hand, the brain and nervous system do not have this ability. A newly born offspring, whether it be that of a human or an animal, is able to recognize its mother and able to search for the breast and is able to nurse instinctively. And this ability arises through habituation in previous lives. It requires no learning in the course of this life. If the consciousness arose simply from the elements — earth, water, etcetera — how would it have this instinctive knowing?
But on the contrary, such an ability arises through habituation from previous lives. There are accounts of previous existences from past lives who, upon being seen for the first time, are able to give their names, are able to remember texts spontaneously, who are able to remember occurrences that happened in previous lives — “I did this” and “I did that.” This does not arise through the power of anything which has occurred during the course of this life, as one has not been able to familiarize oneself with this knowledge in the course of this life. So the reason that we’re making use of this to establish past and future lives — we can simply exemplify by thinking of ourselves as being adults, and as adults we can remember our childhood experiences.
We can remember where we played, our friends, our various companions. And the reason that we’re able to have this remembrance of our childhood experiences is that there is a continuum from the mind of the child to our present mind. The mind of the child and the mind of ourselves as an adult are not unrelated. If they were unrelated, then we could not have these memories. And also, we can look to the fact that the quality of the mind of the child can be very disparate from that of the mind of the parents.
It can be quite dissimilar, that the parents can be geniuses and the child is intellectually handicapped, where on the other hand the child can be a genius and both parents can be intellectually handicapped. The child can be quite loving compassionate, where the parents are quite argumentative, or the other way around, or the child can be quite altruistic. There are these substantial differences between the qualities of consciousness of children and their parents. And this is because the qualities of the children’s consciousness are dependent upon the habituation from previous lives. Then it comes down to the reasoning that there must have been a preceding similar type of knower, because it is a knower.
So the knower at present arose from a previous similar type — that is to say, a previous knower. And then that previous knower again arose in dependence upon a previous similar type, that is to say, another knower. And this continues back, and we can trace it back to where the continuum of our present knower arose in dependence upon the knower within the fetus in the womb. And that is a knower.
It arose in dependence upon a previous similar type, another knower. And then we can trace that back to the intermediate state being — the same continuum of that being — back to that previous life, to the previous life, to the previous life, and this is a beginningless process. We can never identify a moment when this continuum has initiated or begun for the first time. So we can understand the reasoning by which to establish how it is that we have taken numberless rebirths. And using this same type of reasoning to establish previous rebirths, we can apply it to establishing future rebirths.
In the case of an old person who at the moment of their death has a knower present — this knower will give rise to a similar type to itself subsequently, and this subsequent knower will be that of the being’s intermediate state. And again, that knower will give rise to a similar type to itself subsequently, and that will be the knower of the being of the future rebirth. So here, by the power of the result, we can understand the precedence of a cause. In the case of a knower, the existence of a knower as a result necessitates that there had been a preceding similar type to itself, which is another knower. For example, if we see in the distance in the sky smoke, then we can infer there must have been a preceding cause that has gone forth.
There must have been a preceding cause previous to that smoke — that is to say, there must have been fire. We can infer from the result of smoke the existence of fire. We can also infer in the opposite direction — that is to say, in dependence upon the previous aggregation of causes and conditions, a result arises.
So inferring from the cause that a result must arise, we apply it to the consciousness which is present in the mind of the dying person — that there arises a result similar in type to itself — because there arises craving and attachment, which is consciousness. So this is the preceding cause in dependence upon which a result similar in type to itself will arise. So in describing how we circle within cyclic existence as sentient beings, it is set forth in the twelve links of dependent origination. And the initiator, or the first of these twelve links of dependent origination, is ignorance. So this is the main cause which sets us turning in this cyclic process of cyclic existence, of rebirths.
But though ignorance is the main cause, in operative terms it is craving which directly brings the future rebirth. Craving — as the consciousness at the moment of death — precipitates a future consciousness. If we use a metaphor, then we have a field and within the field of consciousness there is the farmer plowing the field, preparing the field, and this is analogous to ignorance. And the seeds which are placed within the field are analogous to karma, actions. But it is necessary that there be moisture; without moisture, the soil will remain dry and the seeds will never germinate.
So upon the addition of water, the seeds germinate, and that which is the water is analogous to craving. There are many cases where a field has been cultivated and seeds have been planted, but because there is no water, nothing sprouts, nothing grows. And this is analogous to the situation where though there is ignorance and there is karma, but there is no result. Why? Because there is no craving.
But once craving aggregates with these karmas which have been implanted by ignorance, then a result will arise. Without craving, no crop grows. So within the field of consciousness, just as in the case of planting seeds within a cultivated field — upon the addition of water, a sprout immediately arises. Now, within our mind, we have the cause of ignorance.
We have not realized emptiness. And each day, we are continually accumulating various types of karma. Each day we get angry or we have attachment. We speak hurtful words. We have harmful intentions.
Each day we are accumulating both positive and negative karmas. And so there are the seeds within the cultivated field with the condition of ignorance. So there is both karma and ignorance within our mind. Now upon the generation of craving, then just like the seeds in the field, there will immediately ensue a result — a sprout will arise.
And this will be a future embodiment as a result. The type of future rebirth, the type of future consciousness, will occur similar in type to what has gone before. Just as in the case of growing a sprout — when all the necessary conditions and causes are complete, in the case of the seed: earth, water — then a sprout arises. Likewise, we have within our minds the necessary conditions and causes of ignorance and karma. And upon the additional condition of craving, there will be produced a similar type of result, in that we will take a re-embodiment.
So actually, we don’t need two separate reasonings to establish past and future lives — one to establish past lives and one to establish future lives. In fact, upon establishing past lives, this same reasoning can be used to establish future lives, and the same is true for future lives in establishing past lives. If there do exist past lives, then there must exist future lives. And if there are future lives, there must exist past lives.
So it is useful to consider these reasonings in establishment of past and future lives, to try to understand the existence of past and future lives. And why? Because future lives do exist, and we do not want to suffer but want to be happy in future lives. Thus, through establishing the existence of future lives, we would practice the methods to achieve happiness in future lives and alleviate our suffering in future lives — that is to say, this would carry us through in our practice of Dharma. There are two possibilities upon our death: in dependence upon accumulation of skillful actions, we will have a fortunate rebirth; or otherwise, in dependence upon our accumulation of unskillful actions, we will have an unfortunate type of rebirth. And this is purely due to either our abandonment of unskillful actions and creation of skillful actions on the one hand, or on the other, not engaging in skillful actions but accumulating unskillful ones.
If we do not create positive causes, then we are not going to have positive results, a future rebirth on the one hand, but on the other, if we continue to create negativity, then we are going to experience a negative type of rebirth. So in view of the fact that we want to be happy, we don’t want to suffer, then it is necessary to make the effort in abandoning our negative actions such that we will avoid unfortunate types of rebirth in the future. And this constitutes the practice of Dharma, whereby we can eliminate our suffering as a means to achieve happiness. Previous to coming to an understanding of the existence of past and future lives, then in our doubt as to their existence, we will not really have a forceful practice of abandoning negativities. We will not have a forceful practice in accumulating skillful actions because we’re not sure if they’re actually going to bear any fruit or not in the future, and therefore a great deal of our time is wasted.
So by way of analogy: in order to ensure our future happiness and so as not to suffer tomorrow, next month, next year, we oftentimes make preparations today. We’re making some kinds of provisions for tomorrow, for next month, for next year, to ensure our happiness, to ensure some type of difficulty does not befall us. And this is the type of practice that we engage in. But if we were to simply go about our lives in a very haphazard fashion, then we can be assured that tomorrow, next month, or next year will probably come about — but how we’re going to experience those, we won’t be sure.
So likewise, with respect to that analogy — in the case of future lives, which in fact do exist — we want to be happy in those future lives, we do not want to suffer. So it’s necessary to make effort and make some preparations and provisions for those future lives, by means of creating skillful actions and abandoning unskillful actions. If we were to not do so and simply act in a haphazard manner, then there’s great danger that we are going to experience unwanted sufferings in the future. So, we all have the experience of last night going to sleep, and then during the course of our sleep having a dream, and this morning, waking up. So this process is analogous to where sleep is analogous to dying.
And all the various appearances which occur in the course of a dream are analogous to the intermediate state, and the waking up is analogous to the taking of rebirth. These occurrences are very similar. And likewise, just as tomorrow we want to be happy and we don’t want to suffer, the same holds true as to future lives. We don’t want to suffer.
We want to be happy in future lives, likewise. So if we develop a firm conviction in the existence of past and future rebirth, then it is extremely useful in developing a sense of liking for engaging in skillful actions and abandoning negative actions. So we’ll stop there, but we’ll take a few minutes for questions. Generally, beings have five aggregates: aggregate of forms, feelings, perceptions, thought constructions, and consciousnesses.
Formless beings have only these four latter aggregates. They do not have an aggregate of forms. There are three realms in cyclic existence: the realm of desire, form, and formless realms. So those beings who wish to take rebirth within a formless realm meditate specifically on developing the preparation for the achievement of the formless realm.
And they take, upon their death — without going through an intermediate state — rebirth within a formless realm as a result. As an actual preparation for a formless realm, they meditate on that specifically in order to take rebirth in such a state. So in order to do this, we need to have a great deal of attachment toward form and body, and in order to overcome and bring an end to that attachment, they seek to take rebirth in a formless realm. So if at the time of death a skillful state of mind is generated — one could, for example, see one’s lama, or see pictures of the Three Jewels, or someone could recite in the individual’s ear the name of the Buddha or something, in order to induce a skillful state.
Then while the coarse consciousness is still within the body, there will be activated a skillful karma. And even if there’s only one, that skillful karma will be activated because there is a skillful state of mind at the time of death. But that skillful karma which is activated has to be a skillful karma.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.