1 h 47 min · 5,739 words · 3 October 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk introduces the Four Noble Truths as taught in the first turning of the wheel, covering their enumeration and sequence. It explains how the first two truths, suffering and its origin, relate to the twelve links of dependent origination, and how the last two lead to cessation, or nirvana. The speaker asks listeners to examine afflictions and contaminated aggregates in their own minds, and the session ends with questions on pure lands and the twelve links.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 47m
UUID: 7e4093f0-93cd-4992-be7c-9d7ec3ef761f
Date: 2015-10-03
Words: 5,735
So for the next two and a half days, we shall be covering an introduction to the four noble truths. These are presented within the first turning of the wheel of the law and there is not that much material actually inside the first turning of the wheel of the law concerning the Four Noble Truths. There were some sutras such as the Lamp Sutra and so forth which contain expositions. So just as the foremost topic of the the first turning of the wheel of the law is the four noble truths which means that the foremost topic of the sutras in this turning of the wheel of the law are the four noble truths. Likewise, the foremost topic in the middling turning of the wheel of the law is non establishment by its own characteristics.
In this context, we have works which draw on this such as Nagarjuna’s root verses on Madhyamika, the Mula Madhyamaka Karika. These are said to be root verses or mulla precisely because they draw from the root which is the great sutras. Unlike treatises with a poetic intent whose purport we seldom can understand from the title, Great works such as Dharmakirti’s Pramana Vartika, the commentary on Pramana or valid cognizers, Maitreya’s Abhisamayalamkara, the ornament of realization and Chandrakirti’s Madhyamakavatara entering into the middle way all make their import explicit through their very title. For instance, Dharmakirti’s Pramanavarttika, the commentary on valid cognizers is a commentary on valid cognizers which draws from Dignaga’s Pramanasamuccaya hence the term commentary. Maitreya’s Abhisamayalamkara is a treatise on the realizations of the six or the 10 perfections.
Hence the term realization and Chandrakirti’s Madhyamakavatara, Entering into the Middle Way is a commentary on the root verses on the Madhyamika. Then what can one say of the the graduated stages of the past to full enlightenment whose title when we reflect on it is extraordinarily profound. It directs us towards full enlightenment, the stages of the path to full enlightenment. It’s an extraordinary title since the topic of the graduated stages of the path, Lam Rim Chenmo, is none other than complete enlightenment. In other words, the object of attainment is complete enlightenment and the means are also taught.
These are the graduated stages. Ishida was saying that if the title of a work is poetic, then it’s a bit like an address. You can’t quite understand who the person whom you’re sending this to is basically. Then in the case of the perfection of wisdom sutras, the 100,000, 25,000, 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sutra, as you know they are subdivided in chapters which give the topic. Then regarding the topic of these teachings, the turning of the wheel of the law, the four noble truths or the four noble truths, There is no specific work I will rely upon.
I have drawn obviously from Jetsun Chokyi Gyaltsen’s Prajnaparamita Damcho, the first volume on the perfections on the four truths and from the various Lamrim treatises but I will try to explain that as much as I understand it and I will explain them in a very simple way. So don’t worry, it will not be difficult. So within the commentaries, the outline for the four truths is subdivided into the necessary enumeration of the four truths and their sequence. Necessary enumeration is the listing of the four truths, in other words, noble truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation and of the path. Then the Four Noble Truths are famous so I assume you know about them.
However, it is not so much a matter of focusing on the words. The words, the truth of suffering, the truth of the origin of suffering, of cessation of the path are easy to pronounce. One has instead to try to gain some type of experience, some type of taste when one reflects on the full truth. This is extremely important. Then you have heard hundreds, thousands, perhaps hundreds of thousands of times about the Four Noble Truths except perhaps with the exception of Diana.
However, this is not what matters. What matters instead is to check within our own minds and to see that within our own minds, we can identify the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering. None of us has within our minds a noble truth of cessation or of the past. And then to try to find a means to go from the noble truth of suffering and the origin to the noble truth of the cessation and of the past. And Steve, perhaps this is for you the first time you receive a presentation of the Four Noble Truths.
I’m not sure. So your lesson, be careful. No? So listen and be careful. Oh, that’s good.
Good idea. Thank you. The necessary enumeration of the four noble truths in Gyaltsab Je’s Namshey Rinpoche Gyen, the ornament of explanations is extraordinarily powerful. It is said for a being who is striving for liberation, the sequence of training in the four truths is initially study followed by practice and realization. All of us in this room are beings who are striving for liberation.
Then there is for us three steps. The first is study, the second is practice and the third is some type of realization and this hinges on an understanding of only two things. One is cyclic existence and the other is nirvana or liberation. And even though we are unable to study, carefully for months or even years the four noble truths, how fortunate we are to focus on this for three days. And therefore the two topics, cyclic existence and nirvana must be understood.
Cyclic existence is presented in terms of its cause which is the noble truth of the origin of suffering and in terms of its result or foundation which is the noble truth of suffering. And regarding nirvana, nirvana itself, in other words, the noble truth of cessation is presented in terms of the means to attain nirvana which is the noble truth of the path and in terms of that which is attained, the object of attainment which is the noble truth of cessation. The great treatises present typically the object of attainment, the result in other words nirvana at the beginning since it is through an understanding of the qualities of nirvana and an introduction to its qualities that trainees can be motivated. So here when we speak of nirvana or liberation, we are not referring to full enlightenment. We are referring instead to an abandonment which is the abandonment of the afflictions.
To put things very very simply, once through the application of the antidotes, the afflictions never again arise. Then one is said to have attained liberation or nirvana. The state of liberation is none other than the attainment of the state of an Arhat. This is something which with courage, with determination, we can attain within this very life. However, a doubt may arise.
All we have heard of Arhats who have simultaneously abandoned all objects of abandonment. Nonetheless, none of us have probably seen or met an Arhat. Times have changed. Nowadays, it is difficult to meet such beings. A couple hundred years ago when the circumstances, material circumstances were less good, people were more focused inwards.
As the material circumstances were less good, they had fewer conceptions and fancies and when an idea arose, it had particular power. So for such persons, the attainment of these states was easier. Now things are more difficult. A couple of hundred years ago, it was said that in Nalanda, there were 500 Arhats. This is definitely the case.
So we can definitely attain the state of an Arhat within this life. This state of an Arhat, liberation, means that we have attained a state of permanent and stable mental happiness. It is an interior transformation. All of us is the same, we have all been born in this life. Therefore, when we attain the state of an Arhat, these contaminated aggregates, we have this body in other words, is still there.
There is no change in the body. The transformation is mental. So we still get to walk or to totter on two feet. So when we attain the state of an Arhat, we are in a state where there is only happiness, inner mental happiness. There is no change in our course physical aggregates.
Then in this context, there are numerous discussions within the Mahayana only regarding the Pure Lands. Nothing is said in the Hinayana about this and for that matter, not a lot is said in Chitamatra about the Pure Lands. The topic is mainly discussed within the context of the Madhyamika School of Tenets. Now, from my personal perspective, the Lands are a matter of appearance. We are in a state of total mental happiness.
In the Pure Lands, we have no contaminated aggregates. Then it is said that our bodies are naturally adorned with flowers and so forth. This must be the case. Do you understand? Really?
Okay, okay, okay. So once we have attained liberation, there is extraordinary inner mental peace. So according to the two lower schools of Buddhist tenets, the Vaibhashika and the Sautrantika, the Hinayana schools of tenets, once one has attained the state of an Arhat, then at the end of that life, one’s mental continuum is severed. In other words, one ceases to exist. This is not the position of the higher schools of tenets, Chitamatra and Madhyamika which assert that the mental continuum is never severed, never interrupted.
As a result, Chitamatra and Madhyamika must assert that the Arhat at the end of their life move on to what are known as the Pure Lands and it is here that there are extensive discussions of the Pure Lands. So if we reflect that in this world of ours, there are some 7,700,000,000 human beings. The Tibetans count this by tens of millions. It’s 70 times 10,000,000. Then when we realize that every single one of these living beings could become an Arhat, what would the world be like if all living beings on this earth became Arhats?
Very different, wouldn’t it? And even if a couple became Arhats, very different. So it is mainly due to laziness that this does not happen. So imagine how comfortable or happy we would be if just three of us in a group of three all meditated in forbearance and patience. How harmonious the relation would be.
Then imagine what our life would be, let’s say in this center, if we all applied the aphorism of the old Kadampas. Set your gaze afar, travel without worry, do not despair. Then we would be very different. Then imagine what the world would be like if every being in this world was an Arhat and that is difficult. So this topic, the Four Noble Truths which is none other than how to attain the state of an Arhat is definitely part of the path of the being of the middling scope from within the three paths taught in the Lamrim.
The path shared with the being of the small scope, the path shared with the being of the middling scope and the path of the being of the great scope. Now certainly, I don’t know for yourselves but for us, when we speak of the stages of the path leading to full enlightenment, it is something huge. Then when we speak of the Four Noble Truths, it is something quite small. I would almost say a bit inconsequential. This is a very inappropriate understanding.
Actually, when the Four Noble Truths are developed, they contain the totality of the Lamrim. When they are summarized, it is the Four Noble Truths. So the foundation is that the Four Noble Truths include practices of both the smaller and the greater vehicle. Then Geshe Puchongwa, one of the great Kadampas of yore said, one should exclusively study the 12 limbs of dependent origination or if you prefer the the two truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering. Then the best way for you to understand this is to realize that when the 12 limbs are summarized, they can be summarized into the two first truths.
The truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. When we summarize the two first truths, we end up with psychic existence. Then when we expand psychic existence, it turns into the two truths of suffering and of origin and when we develop these, we end up with the 12 limbs. The 12 limbs are difficult to understand because there are quite a few of them. So here in the context of the two first truths, we are referring to the 12 limbs from the standpoint of ingress into cyclic existence or the 12 limbs in the forward sequence.
Ignorance giving rise to composition of factors to consciousness, name and form and so forth. Now from the standpoint of egress out of cyclic existence, the 12 limbs are presented in the reverse order. The cessation of ignorance gives rise in general to the cessation of the afflictions and specifically with the 12 limbs, the cessation of ignorance gives rise to the cessation of compositional factors, the cessation of consciousness and so forth. So the 12 limbs in the reverse order when summarized can be presented in terms of the third and the fourth noble truths. The noble truth of cessation and of the path and these when summarized can be presented as nirvana.
Reciprocally, when nirvana is developed, it is the noble truth of cessation and the path and when these are developed, it is the 12 limbs in the reverse order. Do you understand? So we’ve got a solid two hours to spend, together this morning. Therefore, please listen carefully because if you start dozing off, you’re going to get mixed up on the sequence of the stages and then you will doze off even more. So when we were at the monasteries, it was so pleasant to attend Petri, to attend teachings on Buddhist philosophy especially if one understood what was happening because then one did not fall asleep.
Then if one doesn’t understand what’s happening, one falls asleep. Therefore, it is important to concentrate. And when our holy teacher, Kensur Rinpoche was giving puja, etcetera, he was abbot at the time and I was a new student and Rinpoche was teaching a difficult topic on consequences in Buddhist logic. Then I didn’t understand a thing, so I started drifting off and falling asleep. And Rinpoche had a very long switch by his side and he would tap me on the head periodically.
It was a very skillful method because first there was obviously the pain of the switch which has a tendency to wake you up instantaneously and then lots of people were observing what was happening. So one was tremendously embarrassed and then therefore one ended up wide awake. Then obviously when one studies, it is necessary to proceed in this fashion. A good teacher will have mainly good students and somehow, sometimes a certain amount of force is necessary to keep the student on the right path. Then obviously different countries have different traditions.
In Tibet, we do things one way. Here I think it may be rather different. Geshe Potowa, the great Kadampa Geshe of yore taught that the presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in terms of how one is reborn in the lower realms is specific to the scope of the being of the small scope. The presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in terms of how one is reborn in the higher realms is specific to the being of the middling scope. This is a presentation of samsara in general.
And the presentation of the 12 limbs of dependent origination in which one reflects that just as oneself is reborn, embassy and psychic existence, likewise are all being, all beings and independence on this, one generates love and empathy. Is this presentation specific to the being of the great scope? So this is how one should reflect on the Four Noble Truths, on the 12 limbs in the forward and the reverse sequence and on the presentation of the four noble truths for the beings of the small, middling and great scope. Now, as you remember, the two main outlines of this topic are the definite enumeration and the sequence of the Four Noble Truths. Passing onwards to the sequence of the four noble truths.
The sequence of the two first truths is that initially one teaches the noble truth of suffering and thereafter the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Now, if these were taught in a causal sequence, this would be a reverse order from the previously mentioned one. In other words, the noble truth of the origin of suffering would have to be taught first and the noble truth of suffering which is its result would have to be taught after. There is an important purpose in teaching the noble truths in the sequence which follows first teaching the noble truth of suffering and thereafter the noble truth of the origin of suffering and this is explained by Aryadeva in the Chatuhshataka in the 400 in which he says, how could one who does not see the faults of existence aspire to liberation? Or as Je Tsongkhapa says in his Hymn of Experience, If one does not strive at thinking about the faults of suffering and the origin of suffering, how will it be possible to generate the mind striving for liberation?
So whether it is for two or for three days that we cover these topics, let us try at present to understand clearly the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering within our own mind stream. In the case of the noble truth of cessation or of the path, we do not have them within our mind stream. But we do have the noble truth of suffering and we do have the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Let us therefore understand them and ask ourselves what precisely is the noble truth of suffering, what is the noble truth of the origin of suffering, is there a cessation for these or not? So let us not therefore waste time over this weekend.
Time is priceless. As you know, time cannot be bought nor can you obtain time once it has been wasted. Let us therefore spend our time wisely together and from your side, please focus on the Four Noble Truths. If you don’t understand anything, please ask questions. We will discuss and try to understand together.
In addition, during these three days, please do not focus your minds on anything else. Do not waste your time in conversation. Focus your minds exclusively on the four noble truths then you will all be beings of one type. And obviously, we can see each other’s bodies so we know where we are. But our minds we can’t see so it’s difficult to know where our minds are at present.
Therefore draw them back in and focus them on this topic. Then the four noble truths may perhaps not be part of dharma at all. The four noble truths reflect the actual reality of phenomena, the way things really are. The noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering reflect the way this world really functions. Then if we analyze carefully, we can see that the noble truth of cessation must exist and some schools of tenets consider that cessation are ultimate phenomena.
Some consider that they are conventional phenomena. But that is irrelevant. In either case, cessation should exist and if they exist, then the noble truth of the path becomes logically the way to lead to it. Now in as much as cessation arise independence on emptiness and emptiness is something which is analytically accessible, perhaps this as well is not part of dharma. Then for karma, perhaps the situation is different since we need to have conviction in karma to accept its mode of functioning but the four noble truths, the four noble truths are entirely rooted in logic and analysis.
Perhaps they are not part of dharma. So very important. So the four noble truths. So from your own side, study this topic, four noble truths. Study the sequence of the four noble truths.
Ask yourself is this true or not? Now regarding the first noble truth and noble truth of suffering, after having identified it, one must understand its deficiencies and to do this one must reflect on the aggregates. Now as we presently are rooted in contaminated aggregates, it is often difficult to understand their deficiencies. So regarding the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering, it is defined and you have this in your handout, miscellaneous notes on the four noble truths. It is defined in Jetsun Chokyi Gyaltsen’s Prajnaparamita Damcho as follows.
A truth from the standpoint of the thoroughly afflicted which is thoroughly differentiated into features by the four. Impermanence, suffering, emptiness of a self of other objects and selflessness of persons which is its nature. Page one. The example of the noble truth of suffering is contaminated aggregates. Characteristics of the first noble truth of suffering impermanence suffering, emptiness of the self of other objects and selflessness of persons.
However, I would like to focus on the example of the first noble truth of suffering, the contaminated aggregate. Now we can find clear examples of the noble truth of suffering within our own aggregates and we can see that these are rooted in the afflictions. We can see for instance the noble truth of suffering in the context of the contaminated form aggregate. In other words, this body of ours of flesh and blood. In this body, we can see that when it is hot, the heat is immediately insupportable and when it is cold, the cold is immediately insupportable.
When we are hungry, the hunger is insupportable and when we are thirsty, the thirst is insupportable. Therefore, various sufferings are rooted in this contaminated body of ours. Now think carefully from your own side that clearly there are all these sufferings which are rooted in this body of flesh and blood of Oz, sufferings of hunger, of thirst, of heat and cold. But how do we abandon them? To say we abandon this body that seems difficult.
This body is the product of the union of the spermatozoa which arise from one’s father and the egg from one’s mother. Then if we examine carefully, we can see that all the sufferings we experience within this body are intimately rooted with the afflictions. It might be possible to abandon the afflictions. Examine from your own side. So examine for yourselves clearly this body of flesh and blood of ours, these contaminated aggregates, they come from somewhere.
Where do they come from? How do we abandon them? This is something which we should examine for ourselves. At present, I have tried to give a brief introduction into the nature of liberation and we shall generate the motivation required for receiving these teachings. So reflecting on the verses in Tsongkhapa’s Hymn of Experience in which he says, should one not strive at reflecting on the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering, how could one generate striving for liberation?
Then reflecting in these terms on the faults of these aggregates, these contaminated aggregates of ours, in other words, the faults of psychic existence, let us try to generate the motivation to be liberated from it. So we’ll do the normal prayers, generating the mind of refuge and bodhichitta, invocation, of four immeasurables, prayer of the seven limbs, and then the mandala offering requesting teachings. So regarding the mode of engagement of the Four Noble Truths, there are two ways to proceed. As much as there are broadly speaking two types of trainees, trainees of sharp acumen and trainees of dull acumen. Excuse me.
So trainees of sharp acumen and trainees of coarse acumen, . So trainees of coarse acumen would proceed as was explained through focusing on the four noble truths in sequence. Noble truths of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation and of the path. However, as His Holiness the Dalai Lama explained during the Blue Mountain teachings relying on the instructions of Maitreya’s Abhisamayalamkara, the ornament of realizations in which it is said from the two truths up to the four noble truths for trainees of sharp acumen, in other words, intelligence, it is possible through reflecting initially on interdependence to gain an understanding of emptiness and independence on that to reflect on the Four Noble Truths. Then what type of trainee one is, is up to oneself to examine within one’s own mental continuum.
And therefore, as this one has explained very clearly, one should for such trainees, trainees of sharp acumen initially reflect on emptiness and on the interdependence and such reflection, such ascertainment through thinking will eventually lead to an ascertainment through meditation and on this basis proceed to then an understanding of the Four Noble Truths. So although the goal, the object of observation, if you wish, liberation is the same. In function of the trainees, there are two different types of training the mind. The first through focusing on the four noble truths, the second starting with emptiness and interdependence. So we have finished the presentation of the definition of the noble truth of suffering and at present, you should reflect from your own side on whether there is a way to proceed from the noble truth of suffering to the noble truth of cessation, to the cessation of suffering.
And if there is a cessation of suffering, what are the means to enable us to obtain the cessation of suffering? Is it the case that the sufferings we experience are rooted in the afflictions or not? This is something one must also examine for oneself. It is difficult to view one’s own body, one’s own aggregates as of the nature of suffering. Especially if you are tall, then it’s very difficult to see your nice tall body as a source of suffering, isn’t it?
Then it is important to try to see whether there is a relationship between our contaminated aggregates and the afflictions. Then this is again something which is difficult to understand. But if we do not build such a relationship, we one cannot see how one will abandon the contaminated aggregates. For myself, when I first studied this topic, the Four Noble Truths as a young monk, I had considerable difficulty with this one since I took as instance of the contaminated aggregates, in other words, the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering, my own body, the contaminated form aggregate. Then how precisely to establish a link between my own body and the cause of the noble truth of suffering, which is the second truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
In other words, the afflictions and karma. This is not easy to do. Now, we have to try to identify within our own mind stream these two truths. So the noble truth of suffering is definitely there. What about the noble truth of the origin of suffering?
Well, this includes afflictions such as ignorance, anger, competitiveness and so forth. Then, assume most of you in this temple at present are not angry. If you were angry, I could probably see it on your faces since coarse anger leads to a transformation of the face. But all of us have had experience of being angry And we know that when we are angry, this in turn gives rise to an unpleasant sensation, interior sensation. Then this anger is the noble truth of the origin of sensation, the noble truth of the origin of suffering and that unpleasant sensation is the noble truth of suffering.
If it is difficult to posit our bodies as instances of the noble of truth of suffering for yourselves, then you can definitely posit the mental discomfort which arises as a result of anger as an instance of the noble truth of suffering within your mental continuum. Then I am sure that there is probably nobody or at least less than a fraction of a percent of the population who considers that that sensation of discomfort is a good thing. It is therefore something we should try to abandon. Likewise, afflictions such as desire when they arise within our mind stream can give rise to states of extreme discomfort. We can have desire for another person or the person’s body, but we can also have desire for things and for instance, when we go into a store and we see something which we crave, but unfortunately, we lack the money to buy it.
Then as a desire increases within our mind stream, when we go home, we become profoundly perturbed at the thought of this object we lust for but are unable to buy. Then obviously, I would suspect that if one has no money whatsoever, the desire for the object would eventually dwindle. But if one had barely enough money, it would probably increase. Then we know very well for ourselves how irritated would we become when the time has come to eat and we can’t yet eat. So this is the suffering induced by desire.
Here desire is the noble truth of the origin of suffering within our mind stream and the suffering which arises from desire is the noble truth of suffering. Likewise, we have numerous other afflictions within our mind stream such as, let us say, envy or jealousy, which may or not be present within your mind streams at present. Envy or jealousy is a dislike for the qualities of another. The greater the qualities of the other person, the more our own personal unhappiness and discomfort. Then envy or jealousy are the noble truth of the origin of suffering within our mind stream and the suffering which results as a result of envy is a noble truth of suffering.
So how great you can see all the sufferings which arise within our mind stream from for instance, an affliction, jealousy or envy which is the noble truth of the origin of suffering which gives rise to great irritation and discontentment which is the noble truth of suffering. So I have covered this morning the definition of the noble truth of suffering and I will cover this afternoon the four characteristics of the noble truth of suffering, actually mainly the two first ones, impermanence and suffering. We will talk of emptiness of a self of other objects and selflessness of persons later on. So we’ll stop here for now. I would like to finish before twelve.
Therefore, we’ll take your questions but one question per person please. And are you tight? Really? Oh, that’s good. Thank you.
Sorry. Sorry, I’ll just get you to How many types of pure lands are there? If one is fortunate enough to go there, is it one’s consciousness that resides there? How long will one stay there? And then what happens after that?
So regarding the number of pure lands, it is indefinite since it is said that every single fully enlightened being through the power of prayer creates his own field or his own pure land. How one is born there? One can be born there through a variety of means including through the power of prayer. Now once one is reborn there, one is reborn in a realm of light and if one becomes an Arhat, then it is said that a supreme emanation being will manifest and tell us to leave the bliss of nirvana and enter on the path to attain full enlightenment. So Arhat would then be reborn once again in impure realms and it is said that among all the impure realms, this world of ours is supreme for the attainment of enlightenment.
So they would be reborn in this world of ours and then strive to attain full enlightenment. As Dharmakirti says in Pramanavarttika, for rebirth, there are only two possible causes, either karma or compassion. In the case of the Arhats who are reborn in this realm, it would not be karma, it would be compassion. So there are variety of activities and presentations of the Pure Land. Generally speaking, the Pure Lands are not places where one accomplishes activities.
Then obviously if we have generated happiness within our minds, we have eliminated the afflictions, we repeat, we reflect repeatedly on emptiness. Well, we already are in the pure lands. What else is there in the pure lands? You talked about before the 12 limbs presentation to the small, medium and great scope. Are there any different in the presentation?
Concerned, there is no difference when they are presented in the context of the being of the small, the middling or the great scope. What happens is for the being of the small scope, the first limb ignorance give rise to a second limb compositional factors which is non virtuous karma and then independence on this, the remaining of the 12 limbs unfold. For the being of the middling scope in the presentation of the 12 limbs, the first limb ignorance gives rise to a second limb which is virtuous karma. So I’ll only take one more question and after that we’ll break for lunch. If you have more questions, ask them this afternoon.
Yeah, after lunch. But then now just one question. Again, when you were having us quite wonderfully reflect on the world, all the beings in the world being Arhats, you mentioned an old Kadampa saying. Could you repeat that please? Because I didn’t catch So the saying is look afar, have a vast mind and do not despair.
Look afar means do not focus on the short term, look in the distance. Have a vast mind means do not be narrow minded, Have a vast mind. Do not despair means have a relaxed easy mind. It’s a great piece of advice. So we shall stop here for this morning.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How many types of pure lands are there, how does one get there, and what happens afterwards?
The number of pure lands is indefinite, because every fully enlightened being is said to create their own pure land through the power of prayer. One can be born there by various means, including prayer. Once reborn there, one is in a realm of light. If one becomes an Arhat, a supreme emanation being appears and urges them to leave the bliss of nirvana and enter the path to full enlightenment. The Arhat is then reborn in impure realms, and of these, our world is said to be supreme for attaining enlightenment. Rebirth has only two possible causes, karma or compassion, so for Arhats it is compassion. Generally, pure lands are not places where one accomplishes activities.