Mind Training – 2015-10-03 – KR

1 h 29 min · 4,848 words · 3 October 2015

Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training - 2015-10-03 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching covers the three types of suffering and the two-fold division into physical and mental suffering, showing how afflictions trouble sensation, mind and the self. It explains coarse and subtle impermanence, the characteristics of the noble truth of suffering and the origin of suffering, and how calm abiding and the wisdom realizing selflessness relate to eliminating self grasping. Much of the session is then taken up with questions from students about calm abiding, the three principles of the path, definite emergence and paranormal powers.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: a0f4fa69-0957-498f-80c5-aeeefedf8d86

Date: 2015-10-03

Words: 4,844

So generally speaking, most of the students here know the present material but I will cover it again for the sake of the new students we have. Suffering is generally subdivided into three, the suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. So within these three fold subdivision of suffering, the suffering of suffering is for instance if we take physical suffering, the suffering of a stomachache or of a headache. The suffering of change would for instance be any experience such as let us say eating in excess which initially is pleasurable but turns into suffering. And all pervasive suffering would refer to the continuous experience of suffering for so long as we experience the 12 limbs of dependent origination because of not having abandoned the first limb beginningless ignorance.

In addition, there is a two fold subdivision of suffering into physical and mental suffering. There is no particular relationship between wishing to be free from physical suffering and striving for liberation. Since physical suffering depends mainly on exterior physical entities. However, there is a very strong relationship between wishing to be free from mental suffering and striving for liberation. So if we analyze the experience of mental suffering, we can see that mental suffering is rooted in this experience of the I or the person.

Now at present, our person is under the sway of our mind and our mind itself is under the sway of sufferings which if we analyze carefully arise out of the afflictions. So if we analyze carefully what is happening, we can see that when this suffering sensation arises in the mind and I don’t know what commentaries you have received on the mind, there is a relationship between the sensation of suffering and the mind. The sensation of suffering is a mental factor. It is said to accompany the mind. What this means in practice is that it is actually a part of the mind and therefore, we would have the following sequence which would unfold.

The I is under the sway of the mind. The mind itself is under the sway of the sensation of suffering and this sensation of suffering is under the sway of the afflictions whose function it is to trouble the mind. Do you understand? So I present this in sequence, that’s how it’s helpful. Could you repeat?

I couldn’t hear. All the afflictions are what? The mind is under the influence of the afflictions. So therefore, the I is under the sway of the mind and controlled by the mind in other words. The mind is under the sway of sensations such as sensations of suffering and these are under the sway of the afflictions.

Now here, the mind itself is the basis of imputation of the I. The sensations themselves are parts of the mind as mental factors and the afflictions are mistaken states of mind. So in as much as the afflictions are mistaken states of mind moving backwards. These afflictions in turn trouble the influence of sensations which trouble the mind generating hardship with the mind and this impacts finally the I or the person. Do you understand?

This is a very elegant presentation. The reason for which we find it difficult to understand how our body is controlled or under the sway of the mind is precisely because the relationship is not evident. Here however, the influence the afflictions have on sensation, sensation has on the mind and the mind has on the person or the I is much clearer and very elegant. So, these emotions or these sensations are under the sway of the afflictions and in turn give rise to hardship in the mind. Now most probably under analysis, the object of observation, in other words, the basis of the afflictions and the object of observation, in other words, the basis of the mind would be different here.

So in brief, we are under the sway or controlled by the mind and the mind is under the sway or controlled by the afflictions. Then clearly, this basis of imputation of the I is none other than the five aggregates. So whatever troubles the five aggregates will trouble the person or the I. Ideally, we should abandon the afflictions as well as their seeds. But if that is not possible at the very least, we should try to abandon the coarse afflictions and this is done through meditation.

Through meditation in as much as the mind, the I is controlled by the mind and the mind by the afflictions, we can progressively reduce the influence of the afflictions on the mind. Then the mind becomes clearer, clearer, clearer. This is definitely the case. As His Holiness has repeatedly quoted from one of the Tathagatagarbha Sutras, do not focus on the ordinary mind, focus on the clear light. And in the mind is not the afflictions, the mind is that nature of clear light.

Then this is not the case for most but it is possible for those with very pure pure minds to have such experiences. Children for instance with very pure minds can remember their previous lives. Most children do not. And in our own cases, we may not have met such people, but, actually, there are substantiated reports, in written documents of the existence of such people in this world of ours. Then if there are such persons who are able through the clarity of their mind to recollect previous lives, how is it the case that we ourselves seem unable to do so?

Clearly our coarse personal habits are at the root of this. We stuff our faces in the evening and then obviously we fall asleep. You all do, don’t you? Then as time goes on, one becomes coarser and coarser, duller and duller. Then some of you may have had experience of this when one rises early in the morning at dawn or before dawn, the mind is extraordinarily clear and whatever one focuses upon, one understands with greater ease even if it is something one had not understood previously.

Then obviously if it’s cold, you might want not to rise from bed but to reflect on these topics in bed, that’s perfectly okay. But why should it be possible to understand things better at dawn in this way? Simply because the heaviness which is due to digestion and so forth has passed. Then for those who memorize, this is a well known experience. If we memorize something in the morning and try to recite it in the evening, it is very difficult to be able to recite it correctly.

But if we wake up the next morning at five or six or even better at 04:00 in the morning, then when we try to recite this memorized text, it will come very easily. In your own cases, you are students of the Lamrim. If you are unable to understand a topic in the evening before going to bed, then get up early the next morning around four or 05:00 and you will find that you will understand it with great ease. Then obviously you have to get out of bed first, don’t you? What can be done for those who sleep in?

The best is to go to bed early at night so that one can rise early in the morning. Then however many hours of sleep you might require, for some it is five, for some it’s six, some even seven or eight, sleep what you need and then rise early. Therefore, our mind is under the sway of the afflictions and if we analyze carefully, we can see that it is actually a part of our mind sensations which are under the sway of the afflictions. Therefore, we have to find a way to cause these afflictions to subside. Since the function of these afflictions, the nature of these afflictions is to trouble our minds.

The way we cause the afflictions to subside is meditation. This means to focus the mind on an object of observation, a virtuous object of observation and to keep it there in a relaxed and clear fashion. So clearly, we can see that it is only when our minds become clearer and clearer, we’re being focused on the observation, the object of observation that this happens. At present, our minds if we analyze them carefully are totally controlled by the five sensory consciousnesses. Then for instance, even though I happen to know that there is a wall on the outside, I cannot see it.

I may have seen it before but I cannot see it now because my visual consciousness rests or is grounded on a coarse basis which cannot see through the wall on the outside. However, as the mind becomes more subtle, this becomes possible. Then in our own cases because we are almost totally overwhelmed by the five sensory consciousnesses. When the five sensory consciousnesses are interrupted for whatever reason, we fall into unconsciousness. We cease to function if you wish.

As we continue training our minds in meditation, eventually the clarity will lead us to attain calm abiding. At this point, we can focus on an object of observation however long we wish to do so. This mind of calm abiding is a very subtle mind which in turn rides on a subtle energy or a subtle wind. And then, if let us say, as previously, we wished to know the thoughts of another person, in other words we wished to train in telepathy, then thanks to the subtle mind we would be able to do so. Do you understand?

Are there food for thought here and if we train in calm abiding for this reason then it is the result of thought and analysis. There is no great benefit in this context in prayers and faith. Then once one has attained calm abiding at the time of one’s death in as much as through calm abiding, there will be no coarse afflictions left. They will not be manifest. One will be reborn in the higher realms.

Then if you wish to be reborn in the higher realms, in other words, form and formless realms, you must train in calm abiding. Then rebirth in the higher realms is a happy and pleasurable rebirth simply because it arises in dependence on calm abiding. And therefore, one should study and then one should meditate, meditate, meditate, become accustomed, become accustomed. This is how the mind improves. And therefore, through reflecting on the thoughts of the afflictions, the deficiencies of the afflictions and understanding that they give rise to sensations of suffering within our mind stream over and again we must generate the wish to be free from the afflictions until it arises from deep within us.

When it arises from deep within us in the same way as we naturally have breakfast upon rising, then in my opinion, we will basically be close to have generated definite emergence. Spontaneous definite emergence. As is said in Je Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the Path, it’s your handout page two, the back. If through such habituation, longing for the marvels of cyclic existence does not arise for even an instant and if the mind striving for complete liberation arises day and night, at that point definite emergence will have been born. Then it is in this context that doing retreats is so important and doing retreats with a good discipline of retreat.

It is a discipline of retreat which ensures that in turn we will gain some type of experience of retreat. At present with the lifestyles we have, meeting people all the time, running around, what experiences can we hope to accumulate? Then we should retreat, read the retreat manuals of experienced practitioners before engaging in retreat. This will give you an idea of how to practice retreat and then as a result of this definitely, we will gain or experience the most extraordinary dreams during retreat. The sort of dreams probably nobody here has under normal circumstances.

So at present, once one understands the faults of cyclic existence, the faults of the noble truth of suffering, the faults of the afflictions. In other words, the faults of this sensation of suffering within our minds which we wish to be freed from. At this point, one generates a heartfelt wish to be freed from this sensation and this is the mind striving for liberation. Here at this point, if one has studied, one must analyze carefully this suffering which is present within our mind and this is why these four characteristics are mentioned in the definition of your miscellaneous notes. This suffering, is it permanent or impermanent?

If it is permanent, there’s nothing we can do about it. It is not going to change. It’s there all the time. If it is impermanent, it has a cause. What is its cause?

Now within the Great Treatise on the Stages of the Path, there are two presentations of impermanence. Coarse and subtle impermanence. The focus on coarse impermanence occurs within the context of the path of the being of the small scope where we reflect on death and impermanence and on our own death and impermanence which arises through the absence of the conditions for life. Then the topic of death and impermanence is one of the uncommon topics within the path of the being of the small scope. There are four objects of meditation or topics of meditation within the path of the being of the small scope.

These are death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realm, causality and refuge. On the other hand, subtle impermanence focuses on our nature as a disintegrating phenomenon and the fact that as such we have a substantial cause. So therefore, the first characteristic of the noble truth of suffering on the page one of the miscellaneous notes in the four noble truths is impermanence subdivided as I explained into coarse and subtle impermanence. The second characteristic is suffering. The suffering nature here actually teaches that suffering arises in dependence on karma and causality.

It is of the nature of suffering because it arises in dependence on the afflictions. So suffering, therefore, the characteristic of suffering and the noble truth of suffering indicates that the noble truth of suffering arises from the afflictions. This is the meaning of the second characteristic and as such, the second characteristic ushers directly the topic of the noble truth of the origin of suffering. The afflictions themselves in turn are rooted in self cherishing in the sense of an I. The afflictions, self cherishing, self grasping, all of these are included within the second noble truth.

The noble truth of the origin of suffering. Do you understand? 100%. And therefore, the afflictions, in other words, anger, desire, jealousy, competitiveness, as well as self cherishing and ignorance are part of the noble truth of the origin of suffering. All of these afflictions are ultimately rooted in the ignorance of self grasping, which is probably one and the same as beginningless ignorance ignorance which is the first limb of the 12 limbs.

Then if this is the cause of the afflictions and we wish to eliminate the afflictions, we must eliminate this ignorance. We must therefore target this ignorance. What targets this ignorance? Nothing else than the wisdom realizing selflessness. This is the main means to eliminate this ignorance.

The other practices such as meditation on forbearance, meditation on love and so forth are only of occasional benefit. They are not of fundamental benefit and therefore tomorrow, I will start explaining interdependence and emptiness. And therefore tomorrow I shall explain the noble truth of the path and the noble truth of cessation. Then in as much as these are rooted in an understanding of emptiness perhaps that presentation is not really a dharma presentation but reflects the actual nature of reality. Regarding the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering, These are already present within our mind streams.

This is actually the way things are. Probably this is not dharma at all. This is reality. So we have finished the presentation today of the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. If you have not understood something about these topics, please ask your questions at present.

I would like at present to take questions from people who have not asked questions during the morning session. And please make your questions simple and clear. Otherwise, you will fall asleep, I will fall asleep and the translator will fall asleep. And then those who have not received So those who have not asked questions this morning, please feel free to ask questions now. Geshela taught that a happy rebirth arises in dependence on calm abiding, specifically rebirth in the form and formless realms.

But given that you can attain calm abiding focusing on any object of observation whether it’s virtuous or non virtuous, how can that in and of itself eliminate the course afflictions? So one has to distinguish. It is possible to focusing the mind in on a neutral object such as a flame or a horn to gain calm abiding, then this would lead to neutral karmic results. If the mind is focused on a virtuous object such as the body of a Buddha and so forth, then this would obviously lead to virtuous results such as rebirth in a higher realm and so forth. However, if the mind were focused on a non virtuous object, it would not be possible to gain calm abiding on that basis since a non virtuous basis of observation would induce agitation within the mind stream which is something which prevents attaining calm abiding.

In addition, it is not possible through meditation or through training in calm abiding alone to create the causes for rebirth in the higher realms. One must with calm abiding focus on the object of meditation which were taught by Buddha Shakyamuni and on this basis, one can gain rebirth in the higher realms. Since the presentation of the four noble truths involves understanding that the second noble truth is the cause of the first and the fourth noble truth is the cause of the third. Isn’t this dharma? Is it correct to say that this is dharma?

Because in the section on having faith in the law of cause and effect, Pabongkha Rinpoche says that dharma is the act of modifying one’s behavior according to the law of cause and effect. Yes, obviously in general, the four noble truths are dharma that is self evident. However, what I’m doing is trying to provoke you to think a bit. You have to think on your own side. Maybe not so relevant question.

In a lot of teachers including Dalai Lama and some very prominent Nimampa teachers. The preliminary practice is very important. Which practice? Sorry. Preliminary.

But it seems from from the meditation of that described, I don’t really think that I think the practice that described can directly target the the grasping of the self while the preliminary practice cannot really target at grasping of the self. So what’s the use of the preliminary practices? So there is great benefit in the preliminary practices and in training in states of mind such as love, compassion, bodhichitta and so forth. These enable one to accumulate tremendous waves of virtue. However, these are completely unable to eliminate self grasping.

They cannot target self grasping. Self grasping grasping can only be targeted by the wisdom of realizing emptiness. The preliminary practices such as offering a 100,000 prostrations or offering a 100,000 mandalas will not lead to any decrease in self grasping at all. How about Guru Yoga? Guru Yoga.

Yeah. You are probably thinking of reciting Guru Yoga text. This is of no benefit whatsoever in eliminating self grasping. One must have a profound understanding of the common path, in other words, Lamrim to understand that actually the foundation for practice becomes eliminating ordinary appearances in on this basis in the context of tantra arising as a deity. But all of this is only possible on the basis of the explanations of the spiritual teacher.

Otherwise, not Guru Yoga. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.

Okay. And Yeshua, this morning, you said only a small section of the population like the feeling of anger, for example, accepting, therefore, that there is a small section of the population sorry. The I beg your pardon. Only a small section of the population yeah, only a small section of the population likes the feeling of anger. So on that basis, it is accepting that for most of us, it is an unpleasant sensation, but for some people, it isn’t.

A simple question. Why is that? Yes. I mean, it is clear that it is impossible to fight another or go to war, target another, in other words without anger, isn’t it? Then in this world, there are people who like to do that.

But why is it a pleasant sensation? That’s a very good answer. That’s exactly how one should answer this one. Yeah, reach out. Is it great?

I just feel a bit confused about what a typical middle scope meditation session would actually be made up of. Mhmm. Like, I understand that calm abiding is an essential part of it. Mhmm. So is that targeting the ignorance that we need to target or do we need to do analytical meditation as well?

Yours is a very good question. Indeed, we do need calm abiding on the path of the middling scope. However, through calm abiding alone, it is impossible to eradicate the ignorance which grasps at a self. To eradicate the ignorance grasping at a self, we must target it with its exact opposite which is the wisdom of realizing selflessness. However, once we have calm abiding, we can focus on selflessness with a far greater intensity than before and as a result, we can eradicate the ignorance grasping at itself faster.

Geshela mentioned that there were some retreat manuals. I was just wondering if he could please tell us what the titles are or? So these retreat manuals are manuals which explain how to engage in retreat then if you have the requisite initiations, you could look at the Yamantaka retreat manual which is translated by the LTWA. Krishna says they’re all pretty much similar. They explain how to do retreats.

Pabongkha Rinpoche composed several little texts like this. However, what is much more important than these retreat manuals is focusing on the ordinary teachings in other words, Lamrim and gaining an uncontrived spontaneous experience of this. Okay. And Just hold the microphone to your chin. I’ve got a question with respect to calm abiding.

You were saying that you could read people’s minds. So when you are reading people’s minds, are you just seeing their thoughts or if you are not familiar with their language, you can’t understand them? How does that aspect work? Telepathy is not dependent on language. I mean if language was the issue, we would use the sense organs such as sight hearing and so forth.

Telepathy enables us to actually see the thoughts, the intentions, the way of thinking within another person’s mind. Diane. There are numerous paranormal powers of which telepathy, clairvoyance, clairaudience and so so forth. Each of them is an instance of paranormal powers but for instance, all paranormal powers are not telepathy, all paranormal powers are not clairvoyance, all are not clairaudience and so forth. Okay.

Diane Diane, I thank you. Yes. Just on the sheet about the truth of the origin definition, what is utter generation? So I will explain this tomorrow in brief within the four characteristics of the noble truth of suffering, utter or extreme generation refers to the fact that independence on an instance of the noble truth of suffering such as the afflictions, suffering is powerfully generated. Lindsay Joker.

I have a question about the three principles of the path. I’ve read one translation that describes definite emergence as renunciation. And it’s always puzzled me the verse that says the desire for existence. Initially you will search for definite emergence which doesn’t seem to indicate that it’s renunciation. Then Geshe asked me to answer in his stead since he is not that fluent in English.

Renunciation is a traditional translation of term. It’s the translation which started to be used in Rinjung Lhantab around 1966. It is highly misleading because it means for westerner that one renounces typically worldly possessions. This is not the meaning of at all. The two Tibetan syllables ne and zhong, ne means definite, jung is to arise, refer to arising from the ocean of psychic existence.

Does that answer your question? Natalie? I was very moved by Geshe-la mentioning the Kadampa Geshe who gave us the advice to set your gaze far away or set your gaze afar, travel without worry, and do not despair. I was wondering if Geshe could talk a little bit more about travel without worry, which seems to be a very difficult thing to do. So you are probably referring to the first element of that aphorism look afar, look to the distance.

Now all of us know that when we have a goal and we fail to accomplish that goal, we typically get very uptight about it and when one tries to have a relaxed mind, what one does is when one does not accomplish one’s goal, one remains at ease and one takes the long view. In other words, one keeps working again and again until eventually things are accomplished. New question? First question is second. Okay, okay, okay.

That’s correct. Geshe-la, following on from what Anila said, When in the first verse it says, initially, you will search for definite emergence, I too have a confusion because in the noble truth of cessation, the fourth aspect is definite emergence. But that to me must be a result because the truth of cessation is a result whereas definite emergence is also the cause. So in this first verse, are we searching for the cause or the result or both? Before obtaining definite emergence, we must have some type of understanding of the truth of cessation.

This is a liberation we are seeking for. Otherwise, if we do not have an understanding of the truth of cessation, how would it be possible to generate definite emergence? I have your question. Mentioned about the clear nature of mind as by His Holiness. What is the clear light nature of mind?

When his holiness refers to the mind of clear light or the fundamental mind, he is referring to a mind which is completely unstained by the afflictions. So it will be helpful for you to study the topic of what is known as the lineage often translated in English as the Buddha nature. In this section of Parchin, there are numerous quotes from highest yoga tantra as well as the Tathagatagarbha Sutras on the clear light nature of mind. Alternatively you can identify the clear light nature of mind with the fundamental mind. Okay and jet?

What’s your name? For you. Yeah, yeah. Have you question? Okay.

And Joe? Okay and Chris? Hello Chris. Are you silly Jean? I will give Geshela the switch.

Really? Okay. Another question. Just one. Going back to these paranormal powers, are they do they confer any benefit for attaining liberation or full enlightenment or are they just a side effect?

There is tremendous benefit to the paranormal powers. Actually, is impossible to attain full enlightenment without a complete set of the paranormal powers. On the other hand, it is said that these are ornaments for the attainment of the state of an Arhat but it is not said that it is inappropriate to attain the state of an Arhat without the paranormal powers. In the case of arhats, these paranormal powers arise spontaneously whether they are wished for or not since their conditions specifically calm abiding have already been obtained. Yeah.

Yeshua, how can one enjoy a MOMO and have some renunciation for MOMOs? Of course. Difficult question. Tomorrow, I’ll debate with you on this one in English if I have a moment. But basically, the delight upon tasting a momo is not suffering.

It is the suffering of change. Then generally speaking, everything which is the suffering of change is the noble truth of suffering but not everything which is a noble truth of suffering is suffering. When you debate, have to be precise. I have to debate something like for instance, everything which is a noble truth of suffering is not suffering because everything which is suffering is a sensation, everything which is a sensation is a consciousness. And everything which is a noble truth of suffering is not a consciousness because a momo is a noble truth of suffering.

It’s not a consciousness. You were on page nine.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is the use of the preliminary practices, and can they eliminate self-grasping?

The preliminary practices, and training the mind in love, compassion, bodhichitta and similar states, are of great benefit. They enable one to accumulate tremendous waves of virtue. However, they are completely unable to eliminate self-grasping, because they cannot target it. Self-grasping can only be targeted by the wisdom realizing emptiness. Preliminary practices such as offering 100,000 prostrations or 100,000 mandalas will not lead to any decrease in self-grasping at all.

Can calm abiding alone eliminate the ignorance that grasps at a self, or is analytical meditation on selflessness also needed?

Calm abiding is needed on the path of the middling scope, but calm abiding alone cannot eradicate the ignorance that grasps at a self. To eradicate that ignorance, it must be targeted with its exact opposite, the wisdom realizing selflessness. Calm abiding is still valuable, though. Once it has been attained, one can focus on selflessness with far greater intensity than before, and as a result the ignorance grasping at a self can be eradicated faster.

When reading someone's mind through telepathy, do you only see their thoughts, and can you understand them if you don't know their language?

Telepathy does not depend on language. If language were the issue, we would be using the sense organs, such as sight and hearing. Telepathy lets a person actually see the thoughts, the intentions and the way of thinking within another person's mind. Telepathy is one of several paranormal powers, which include clairvoyance and clairaudience. Each of these is an instance of paranormal powers, but the categories are not the same: not all paranormal powers are telepathy, not all are clairvoyance, and not all are clairaudience.

Do paranormal powers help in attaining liberation or full enlightenment, or are they just a side effect?

Paranormal powers are of tremendous benefit. It is impossible to attain full enlightenment without a complete set of them. For the state of an Arhat, they are said to be ornaments, but it is not said that attaining the state of an Arhat without them is inappropriate. In the case of arhats, these powers arise spontaneously, whether wished for or not, because the conditions for them, specifically calm abiding, have already been obtained.

Scroll to Top