Mind Training – 2016-03-27 – KR

1 h 52 min · 4,937 words · 27 March 2016

Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Mind Training - 2016-03-27 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches the 37 facets of enlightenment and how they link to the Lam Rim path of the middling scope, which is centred on the four noble truths. It covers the four close placements of mindfulness, the five paths from accumulation to no more learning, and how the afflictions are abandoned through the antidote of emptiness realisation. It ends with a question and answer session on grounds and paths, emptiness, and renunciation.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 52m

UUID: 66f042bf-d99e-4131-8ae2-f801f8279482

Date: 2016-03-27

Words: 4,933

Within one day irrespective of when we get up in the morning and when we go to bed at night, what is really important is to generate continuously a worthy motivation. So if we are able to generate such a motivation, then whatever physical and verbal deeds we engage in within the day will be influenced by it and we will have said to ourselves, this and that I shall not do to another person. Then the ideal is to take a strong resolve at the beginning of the day. I shall not engage in any non virtuous deeds of body, speech and mind. And if we are able to do this, then it is very powerful.

However, this will not happen by itself. It can only happen if we understand the faults of the afflictions and of non virtuous deeds if we identify their faults as faults. Otherwise it does not happen. Then to do this 100% during the day is difficult but if we can do it in this way for fifty, sixty, 70%, that’s okay. So there are differences between the higher and the lower realms.

Then we can see for instance animals, dogs, cats, pigs and so forth, When they are hungry they eat, when they are thirsty they drink, they go about their own business, but it is very important for ourselves to realize I am a human being, I am not an animal, then I will not behave like an animal, I will behave like a human being. Then all of us, not just human beings but all living beings wish to be happy. We wish to find a means for happiness but here it is important to distinguish between physical and mental happiness and the happiness we should be aiming for is a happiness which is rooted deep within the mind and we should ask ourselves who needs this happiness? What is this happiness? How is this happiness generated?

How do I go about it? These are the questions we should ask. So when we speak of happiness and the elimination of suffering, the elimination of suffering such as the suffering of hunger, the suffering of thirst, the suffering of being too hot or too cold, that is quite straightforward to do. So if we analyze our mind to see what disturbs, what troubles our mind, we will find this something which is called the afflictions. It’s in the nature of the afflictions to disturb the mind.

Then we have to identify the opposite. So in our cases obviously we are busy, we have to work but there is no one in this room who works all the time. We have free time. After we add the time needed for work, for eating, for sleep, there are many hours a day of free time. This free time could be used for something meaningful.

Instead, we use it to satisfy our physical needs. Our physical needs are impossible to satisfy. Physical happiness is impossible to reach, it is an endless pursuit. Instead, we should be seeking for inner mental happiness which can be obtained and for this we must distinguish between putting permanently an end to the afflictions which trouble the mind, to attain a state of permanent mental happiness, this is called liberation, or a temporary surcease of the afflictions and if so we should seek for means for this. So it is not the case that we can take an hour off for a cup of tea or going for a walk.

It’s good to do this but we must remember that our foremost goal is targeting the afflictions within our mind stream which is or which are what disturbs our mind stream. These afflictions must be seen as enemies. We refer to arhats, The Tibetan tradition of Arhat is drachompa. In other words, someone who destroys his enemies as someone who has destroyed the enemies of the afflictions. We have received many teachings on dharma.

We have received teaching after teaching after teaching on the four noble truths and it is really vital that we see the thought of the afflictions and see the afflictions as afflictions. Then if you don’t want to do that, get out. Then let us take a car which seems to be the main object of fantasy. Our minds are constantly distracted at the thought of the perfect car we would like to have, a luxurious car. I have seen cars like this here with seats of leather in which people sit like kings with earphones listening to music and this is a big source of distraction.

We should not do this. So in my own case, when I wake up in the morning, I recite my commitments and then after this I listen to whatever news and so forth there is to become accustomed a bit to accustom my ear to all of this. But I do try to practice then for yourselves, you see how you want to proceed. I’m not saying you have to proceed one way or the other. So how can we become aware of the presence of the afflictions within our mind stream?

Through vigilance. Then through vigilance we become aware of their presence and then how can we oppose them? How can we counter them? For this, we need to meditate. Now regarding past and future lives, reincarnation in other words, why is reincarnation so important?

It is because the path of the being of the small scope focuses on the period from the next life onwards. So for this reason, one should, if one does not have an ascertainment of reincarnation by valid cognition, at least understand So Buddhist scriptures have a series of reasons proving the existence of past and future lives. The first of these is the following syllogism. The subject, a knower proceeds onwards to future lives because it is a knower. Now this syllogism states basically that it is in the nature of a knower to be a continuum which is uninterrupted.

The second line of reasoning hinges on the distinction between sensory and mental consciousnesses. We both have, we all have both sensory and mental consciousnesses. Now, sensory consciousnesses could only, it seems very diff with great difficulty proceed onwards to future lives. Then the mental consciousness must. So it is therefore the mental consciousness, the subtle mental consciousness which proceeds onwards uninterruptedly from life to life.

Now this is something which is very difficult for us to understand at present, we don’t have access to this consciousness but we will have access to it through meditation. So meditation is extremely important. Meditation is said to be the mental base of all qualities. It is definitely the mental base for the generation of mental certainty or mental definiteness. If we have generated mental certainty with regards to past and future lives, this will be very beneficial for us.

So we have heard many Lamrim teachings but what is really beneficial now is to link the teachings on the Lamrim with the teachings on these 37 facets of enlightenment and specifically to link the scope of the being of middling scope, the path of the being of middling scope with the 37 facets of enlightenment. So what is therefore very important is for us to link the topics of the Lam Rim with other topics. In our case, we are, we suffer from forgetting, from this. If we do not link the topics of the Lam Rim to other topics, we will forget them. So we have to link these topics to the 37 facets of enlightenment and so forth.

So as I explained yesterday, some of the 37 facets of enlightenment, we have to link these 37 facets of enlightenment with the lamrim and specifically the path of the being of the middling scope. Now if we take for instance the four close placements of recollection, how are they linked with renunciation or definite emergence? So it is therefore very important to link the Lam Rim to these topics and specifically with the 37 facets of enlightenment. Therefore, I’d like to ask you, what is the relationship between the four close placements of recollection and renunciation or definite emergence? Can you answer?

So indeed, the four close placements of recollection, the close placements of recollection on body sensation, mind and phenomena And through recollecting these, we gain an understanding of the specific and the general characteristics say of the first object of observation, the body. And we therefore gain independence on the understanding of the contaminated of the nature of the body which is its specific characteristic and understanding of the general characteristics. So independence on a progressive reflection on the four close placements of mindfulness, we gain an understanding of the four truths. So the topic, the object of observation of the path of the being of the middling scope are the four noble truths. When the first two noble truths, the truth of suffering and of origin are expanded, they can be understood in terms of the 12 links of dependent arising in the forward direction.

And when the two latter truths, the truth of cessation and of the path are expanded, they can be presented in terms of the 12 links in the reverse direction. So totality of the 37 facets of enlightenment are contained within the presentation of the path of the being of the middling scope. The main focus of the path of the being of the middling scope is the four noble truths as was explained. The Four Noble Truths are what is meditated upon, the object of meditation. The meditator or that which meditates is none other than the 37 facets of enlightenment.

In other words, Four Noble Truths are the object and the 37 facets of enlightenment are the subject. So the 37 facets of enlightenment as has been explained over the last two days are subdivided into seven subdivisions. Each of these subdivisions is presented in terms of eight topics. One of these eight topics is the boundaries of a given subdivision, let us say the boundaries of the four close placements of recollection. Now in the case of the four close placements of recollection, they are generated from the path of accumulation up to the attainment of full enlightenment.

So, what are the elements of the 37 facets of enlightenment are present within the Namibyam, the grounds and paths and so forth, but not necessarily explicitly. To give you an example, let us imagine we have to go from Adelaide to Melbourne by train. Then there are numerous train stops from Adelaide to Melbourne, aren’t there? So we won’t fly, we’ll go by train, by bus or by car. Train’s the best in my opinion.

So when we travel by train in this fashion, it’s a relaxed way of traveling. We have tea on the train and so forth. Now in the same way, within the lamrim, you have a an implicit presentation of the five paths. These are listed on your chart here. The path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation and of normal learning.

When you travel by train as I did many times from Bangalore to Delhi, then you have a large number of stops or you should go by bus, bus stops. Sometimes you stop for fifteen minutes, sometimes half an hour, sometimes one hour. You have tea, you relax, you chat. So if we take grounds and paths, Salam, then the explanations are very relaxed. We do not get uptight when we hear to them, when we hear them because one is told well first when you have generated renunciation for the first time, you will have entered the path of accumulation.

Then later on, when you generate this and that realization, you will have entered the path of preparation. Then after that one is told and then when you have generated this and that criteria, you will have entered the path of seeing. After that, when you generate this and that criteria, you will enter the path of meditation, and these are the abandonments to be abandoned on the path of meditation. And finally, at the end of the path of meditation, you will enter the path of no more learning, you will have become an Arhat. This is very relaxed presentation.

Then this presentation of grounds and paths is very helpful for us. It’s a very relaxed presentation which does not stress us out. For most of us, it is not possible to attain the state of normal learning that of an Arhat within one life. Only beings who have great enthusiasm and single pointed focus can do this. Normally, it’s attained over many lives.

And that is why we shall start this Tuesday to teach grounds and paths or Salam. And I would encourage you to attend if you have the time to do so. This is an important and profoundly meaningful topic Then if you don’t have the time to attend, there’s nothing which can be done. Very important, know. Then we will study the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation and of no more learning and if you can memorize the terminology, that would be all the better.

If that is not possible, then what matters is understanding the meaning. And let us generate at present the motivation for receiving teachings on this topic through thinking if I practice recollection, a close placement of recollection on the body and focus on the specific characteristics of the body, then its thoughts become evident and when the thoughts become evident, one comes closer to liberation. So we will generate the mind of refuge and bodhichitta, invite the guests, Generate the four immeasurables. Perform the seven limb offering and then offer the mandala. And then page five, the first and third verse of Mandala So as you remember, there are seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment and these extend from the path of accumulation through all five paths up to the path of normal learning.

So one might wonder why precisely are there or is there such a complex set of subdivisions? So when we meditate on the four close recollections of body, speech and mind upon generating definite emergence or renunciation. What is the object of these foreclose recollections? What is the purpose of this meditation? The purpose is to generate a stable striving for liberation, a stable striving for liberation from the afflicted aggregates, in other words cyclic existence.

Then the thought arises, what precisely should such a being do to attain liberation, to attain a stable liberation? What is it which keeps us removed from liberation? What separates us from liberation and acts as an interfering factor for attaining liberation? It is the afflictions. How do we get rid of the afflictions?

We do not get rid of the afflictions by wishing to get rid of them. We must target them. How do we target them? We target them with their antidote. What is their antidote?

It is the wisdom realizing selflessness, the wisdom realizing emptiness. So, either the wisdom realizing emptiness or the wisdom realizing selflessness is the antidote to the afflictions. But this direct realization of emptiness is not sufficient by any means. There are numerous levels of the afflictions from the coarsest to the most subtle and they must all be abandoned by applying their requisite antidotes ever more powerful meditations on emptiness. One must therefore meditate on emptiness or selflessness for a very, very long time for this to happen.

So this long habituation with meditation on selflessness or on emptiness is necessary. The mere realization of emptiness does not allow us to abandon ignorance within our mind stream. In the self same way as the object of abandonment, the afflictions have numerous gradations of coarseness and subtlety. Likewise, the wisdoms realizing emptiness have numerous gradations of intensity. So the reason for which among these 37 facets of enlightenment, the foreclose placements of mindfulness extend from the path of accumulation up to the attainment of full enlightenment is because the corresponding afflictions which are to be abandoned range in coarseness and subtlety and one must therefore apply corresponding antidotes.

So as was said, the four close placements of mindfulness extend from the path of accumulation to the path of normal learning to full enlightenment or liberation. Now the questions and there are numerous debates which arise here is, is it necessary for a being who has fully qualified close placements of recollection to have realized emptiness directly or not? Does this induce necessarily a direct realization of emptiness or not? It does not. So as was said, one generates a fully characterized close placement of recollection on body, speech and mind at the level of the path of accumulation.

Now, is it the case that there cannot be an experience of emptiness on the path of accumulation? No, it is possible to have an experience of the selflessness of persons. Then as was explained yesterday, through repeated familiarization with these topics, one progressively generates an insight which enables one to enter into the path of preparation. At this point, one will focus on the fourth of the three categories, the seven categories of these 37 facets of enlightenment which is the five powers which we explained yesterday.. So then as one progressively generates the five powers from within the 37 facets of enlightenment, one’s focus on emptiness increases, one’s habituation with emptiness increases, and one is able to counter the ignorance of self grasping although one is not yet able to abandon it.

So on page two of your definitions of the seven subdivisions, you have a definition of a thoroughly purified force within the seven facets of enlightenment. It is a sapience unable to be led by that which is discordant with itself, that which is discordant with itself of the afflictions. So at present, we move onwards to the seven branches of enlightenment of an arya being when through repeated familiarization with the object of observation which is emptiness, a wisdom arisen from meditation gains a direct experience of emptiness, one has entered on the path of seeing, one has become an Arya being, in other words, literally a hero and one will be training in the seven limb branches of enlightenment. So once one has attained the seven branches of enlightenment, the sixth of the subdivisions of these 37 facets of enlightenment, one has become an arya being, one has entered the path of seeing. And this means that one has for the first time gained a direct perception of emptiness.

One sees emptiness in the self same way as the visual consciousness sees an exterior form. One sees it nakedly. One sees it or one’s consciousness and emptiness are blended in the way that water is blended with water. The final subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment are the eight branches of the path of an arya being. This is obtained mainly on the path of meditation from within the five paths.

Since the path of meditation arises after the path of seeing and the boundary of the eight branches of an arya being are from the path of meditation up to full enlightenment. There are numerous subdivisions of the branches, the eightfold branches of the path of an arya being, but in a nutshell, what has happened is through familiarization with emptiness from the path of preparation, the second path, upwards to the path of meditation, one’s behavior has become more and more noble, more and more elevated. So ideally one would have memorized these 37 facets of enlightenment. Otherwise, if one is unable to do so, one should at least know the seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment, which are the four close placements of mindfulness, the four correct abandonments, the four legs of magical emanation, the five powers from within the 37 facets, the five forces from within the 37 facets, the seven branches of enlightenment and the eight branches of the path of an arya being, which makes 37. And the minimum is to know what the four close placements of recollection are and how to practice.

So if you take your chart, the 37 facets of enlightenment, you have the 37 facets of enlightenment subdivided within the five paths. During the first three subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment, the four close placements of recollection, the four correct abandonments and the four legs of magical emanation, it, is no definiteness regarding realization of emptiness. You may or may not have an experience of emptiness. Then from the path of preparation onwards up to full enlightenment from the five powers therefore, you will have an experience of emptiness. Then at present, we have time for you to ask questions in a relaxed fashion.

Please, Geshela would like you to ask clear questions and questions without unnecessary developments, short questions. Then obviously if there is no time, we will only take a couple of questions. The grounds and path, are they presented the same for Hinayana, Mahayana and Tantrayana? Yes, the division into path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and normal learning is the same for Hinayana, Mahayana and Tantrayana. The realizations of hearers and solitary realizers are the same albeit the accumulation of merit is different.

However, the realization of Bodhisattvas is totally different since the backdrop is a generation of love, empathy and bodhichitta. So the central pillar of the Mahayana is the generation of bodhichitta. Geshela, how through habituation can one progress from coarser to subtler levels of realization of emptiness? So it’s a bit like peeling the bark off a tree. You peel layers and layers of bark and you get into the wood and you keep peeling.

So the same thing occurs with emptiness. There is no difference regarding the object of meditation which is the same but the mind becomes more and more subtle and profound. So the mind which realizes emptiness becomes ever more subtle and since it becomes ever more subtle, it is able to counter ever more subtle ignorances which grasp at a self. I find a small confusion with regarding the first for close placement of recollection. I assume that people who people who practice that has already entered a path of accumulation, which necessarily means that they have already realized uncontrived renunciation.

And but, however, the the purpose of meditation on this step is still to attain a stable vision for liberation. I find this is a big contradiction. This is a very good question, it’s Andy’s doubt, right? So indeed to enter the path of accumulation of a hearer or a Pratyekabuddha, you need uncontrived renunciation and after this, one meditates the fully characterized four close placements of recollection on body, on sensation, on mind and on phenomena. But it is not the case before one has generated uncontrived renunciation and therefore when one is a being who has not yet entered the path that one does not meditate on the four close placements of recollection.

One trains in this, but it is not a fully characterized training. Was precisely the answer to your question? So ask yourself, have you entered the path or not? Then are the four close placements, do you train in the four close placements of recollection? People like yourself do.

They don’t train in fully characterized four close placements of recollection because they don’t have renunciation and have not entered the path. But they still train in this and when they have generated uncontrived renunciation, then these will become fully characterized close placements of recollection. I just want to ask the question is the curiosity. This 37 emphasis of enlightenment is a, you know, like when you learn this topic, do monastery give retreat, you know, like to practice on this? There has to be since basically when one does a retreat on whatever let us say, a deity, a tantric deity, then the basis of that retreat is the shared or the common path.

And that is the path of the being of the small, of the middling and the great scope. And within this is the path of the middling scope. Now the focus of the path of the being of the middling scope is the four noble truths, which when expanded are the 37 facets of enlightenment. However, it is definitely not the case that one has to engage in tantric retreats. When one does retreats, it is excellent to do Sutrayana non tantric retreats and focus exclusively on sutra.

Specific and specified, but can Geshela comment on the influence of karma and merit on realizing emptiness anywhere along the path. I know, said it can’t be realized early, but you know, what about these factors? What about what? What about the factors of merit and karma in realizing emptiness either directly at an earlier time? So, if we look at the paths of the three categories of beings, hearers Prateka Buddhas and Bodhisattvas, it is perfectly possible to gain a direct realization of emptiness before one has attained the path of seeing of a bodhisattva.

Since, hearers and pratyaka buddhas on the path of seeing have gained a direct realization of emptiness. However, if you are asking for one given category of being, let us say a hearer who is progressing on the path and you are asking whether such a hearer can gain a direct realization of emptiness before attaining the path of seeing that is impossible. I don’t really understand the distinction between the Hinayana presentation and the Mahayana presentation. But it seems that the Hinayana presentation would assert that liberation is attained upon attaining the path of seeing. If that is the case, then there’s no need for a hearer path of meditation because they’ve already attained their goal, they have no motivation to practice further.

No, let us say a hearer who has attained the path of seeing has not attained liberation and has not become an Arhat. He has just attained direct realization of emptiness, that’s all. Then there are numerous abandonments of the path of meditation and then the abandonments of the innate afflictions of the path, numerous abandonments of the path of seeing, and then the abandonments of the afflictions on the path of meditation, which still must be accomplished before he attains liberation in the state of an Arhat. But we will cover this later in grounds and paths. Another.

I’m not sure about what jhana actually is in this context. Is that a concentration? Dhyana. Dhyana. Yeah.

Is Dhyana here? So sapience is a term I use to translate the honorific term for knowledge in Tibetan kyampa. Now kyampa or sapience just refers to an understanding of the object of the path. It’s two different words. Yeah.

It’s completely different. There’s no relation. Yes. Of course. Yes, exactly.

Basically Pali is a precursor of Sanskrit then the spellings are slightly different. Meaning is exactly the same. My question is about the fourth subdivision definition of a power, the definition reading is sapience which has independently generated an aria path which is its result. Could Geshela elaborate on the meaning of the term independently within that definition please? So the term independently in the definition of a power within the 37 facets of enlightenment, a sapience which has independently generated an arya path which is its result, refers to the fact that when one has entered the path of preparation and therefore is training in the five powers, one has an insight which has become highly familiar with the object of observation, emptiness,

And this insight is becoming ever more familiar with emptiness and coming close to the direct realization of emptiness, it is actually impelling the direct realization of emptiness. That is the meaning of independence. So within the fourfold divisions of applications, we have one division called the application of signs and this refers to an application which leads its object of observation close to omniscience. And that is what is referred to here. Omniscience.

Omniscience is a difficult topic. Where? My apologies, my mistranslation. The path of application subdivided into four. Warmth, peak, forbearance and supreme phenomena.

So this refers to the third subdivision, the second subdivision excuse me, peak. It sounds the same in Tibetan. So signs have many meanings. One can for instance differentiate between ta and sema which are exactly translated the same way in English, but one basically means a reason, the other a sign or one can speak for instance of the signs or the characteristics of the afflictions. In what sense are we saying of recollection or of joy or of enthusiasm or equanimity that it is a branch of enlightenment?

So these are called branches of enlightenment or for that matter, branches of liberation because they are means or parts of what enables us to attain liberation or enlightenment. I just wanted to check that I got the mode of meditation on the four close placements correct, because I’ve been asked that question. And is it that, we meditate on the specific and general characteristics of body, etcetera, and from that we attain, a realisation of the four noble truths and of renunciation. So yes, renunciation can arise in dependence upon meditation on the specific characteristics of body sensation, mind and phenomena but not in dependence on the general characteristics. I wish I’ll stop here.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
five powers
The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Are the grounds and paths presented the same way for the Hinayana, Mahayana and Tantrayana vehicles?

Yes, the division into the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning is the same for the Hinayana, Mahayana and Tantrayana. The realizations of hearers and solitary realizers are the same, although their accumulation of merit is different. The realization of Bodhisattvas, however, is totally different, because its backdrop is the generation of love, empathy and bodhichitta. For this reason, the generation of bodhichitta is the central pillar of the Mahayana.

How can habituation take a person from coarser to subtler levels of realization of emptiness?

The process is like peeling the bark off a tree: you peel layer after layer of bark, get into the wood, and keep peeling. Realizing emptiness works the same way. The object of meditation stays the same, but the mind that realizes it becomes more and more subtle and profound. As the realizing mind becomes ever more subtle, it is able to counter ever more subtle ignorances that grasp at a self.

Do monasteries give retreats for practising the 37 facets of enlightenment once the topic has been learned?

When someone does a retreat on a tantric deity, the basis of that retreat is the shared or common path. This is the path of the beings of small, middling and great scope. Within it is the path of the middling scope, whose focus is the four noble truths, which when expanded are the 37 facets of enlightenment. However, it is definitely not the case that one has to engage in tantric retreats. When doing retreats, it is excellent to do Sutrayana, non-tantric retreats and focus exclusively on sutra.

Scroll to Top