1 h 24 min · 13,431 words · 11 August 2013
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The speaker argues that lucid dreaming is essentially a form of calm abiding, and that reaching lucidity follows a process similar to entering meditative absorption. He surveys the scientific research on dreams and sleep, then describes the MILD and WILD induction techniques and compares the stages of lucid dreaming with the signs (nimitta) and countersigns described in Pali texts.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 24m
UUID: 0503c309-c3f5-46a5-a255-ed51a29148ba
Date: 2013-08-11
Words: 13,427
Welcome back, those who were here yesterday, and a warm hello to those who weren’t. At the end of the day yesterday, said I wouldn’t be here, but such as is impermanence, my wife is returning from England tomorrow, not today. So I said don’t worry about it. Everything works out alright. So here I am.
I won’t go through Professor John Powers’ bio again, but just to say that we are very honoured to have you, John, to come as recently from Alaska where you have been travelling and I hope that you might be a little bit more recovered from your jet lag, although it takes a while from my experience. Well, Alaska is nice, but Adelaide is obviously the high point of this trip. And I’ll leave you to introduce your topic. But thank you so much. I’m still waiting for an adapter.
Sorry. Okay. Now we had the adapter yesterday, didn’t we? Well, apparently there is one here. And the other thing is if somebody has a flash drive, I can just put it onto a computer that is hooked up.
Well, I think we can probably do it more easily than that. I’m just gonna put this on my flash drive, and then I’ll put it on I could just put it on your computer. Is that No. It’s easy for me to Oh, I know. Well, yeah, I’m just gonna do that now, then you can do your thing, I’ll do my thing, and everybody will be happy.
Oh, it’s okay. I I’ve already put it on. Is it okay? Yeah. Well, was talking about impermanence and change.
We can take a teaching from everything. So we particularly appreciated your presentation yesterday, Ralph. And we look forward to your input this morning. And I will allow you to introduce your topic for this morning, Professor Ralph Zubrick from Adelaide University. So first of all, I’m a bit out of breath because I’m extremely unfit.
So me just simply running 50 yards down the road is enough to basically pull me out of whack. So you have to excuse me if I’m heavy breathing. Something I do definitely want to change, I might add. So I actually purposely had planned to actually give this presentation at the end of the day because I wasn’t quite sure how well people would take it. So me volunteering to actually giving it at the beginning of the day provides, for me at least, some risks.
The reason being I’m going to say something that is quite contentious, at least in my view. Okay, so what is it? That lucid dreaming, and I’ll explain what that is in a minute, is in fact nothing more than calm abiding. And there are thousands of people around the world today that actually participate in lucid dreaming, and it’s a relatively well, I won’t say easy subject to learn, but anyone can basically do it. If you can dream, you can lucid dream.
If you can lucid dream, you can enter into a meditative absorption relatively easily. And so it’s going to be quite contrasting to what Ilya presented yesterday. Dependent on your views, I’ll very interested, and I’ll leave my email address right at the end of the presentation, because I’ll be very interested to get feedback, even if it’s negative, because I’m waiting for someone to critique what I’m going to say. I’ve been involved in lucid dreaming for close to twenty years, longer than I’ve been a Buddhist. It came to my attention through a person who I’m going to introduce to you shortly called Stephen LaBerge, who had an institute called the Lucidity Institute, which is based in Stanford University.
Through there, I participated in the experiments that still to today I’ve written and talked about. So have a read of this little cartoon whilst I catch my breath. Right. So many people don’t even think what happens when they sleep, But effectively, this is exactly what takes place. You go comatose for a few hours.
You hallucinate vividly. How many of you can remember your dreams from yesterday night? We’ve got a few people here, about 30% by the looks of it. What about for the last month? Can anyone remember a dream over the last month?
So the numbers go slightly up. We’ve all can remember, hopefully, at least one single dream. Would I be correct with that? The reason being we all dream naturally on a daily basis. The problem is, of course, we all generally suffer, unless you learn some techniques, amnesia from actually what we actually dreamt, and that causes problems in actually recalling what actually took place during the sleeping period.
So I’m going to explain and explore what actually occurs during sleep and what it means to be lucid. I’d like to also ask the audience here how many of you had a dream where they were slightly aware that they were dreaming? Excellent. That’s very common. It’s not uncommon for you to have some form experience that you are actually in a dream when you’re sleeping.
The difference, though, between what I’m going to be referring to as a lucid dream and simply just having some bare awareness is that lucidity implies complete awareness of what’s going on and that naturally then therefore leads on to actually dream control, which I’ll talk a little bit about as well. So the term lucid dream was coined by a Dutch psychiatrist called Fredrik van Eeden and there are personal individual counts spanning centuries about people who became aware that they were dreaming in a dream and then manipulated their dreams. Unfortunately, it’s only until recently that modern scientific and philosophical communities actually accepted the fact that you could actually be aware in a dream. Norman Malcolm was probably one of the people that stopped lucid dreamers in their tracks up until the 1970s. He was a disciple of Wittgenstein who had a lot of conversations with Freud as well, but basically it is impossible to actually be aware and control a dream because actually what’s occurring is that you are dreaming that you’re awake in a dream.
Does that make sense to everyone? Rather than actually more subtly actually being awake, so mentally awake. So that sort of dialogue actually broke down in the late 1970s. And primarily, guess you could say that the tables turned when a person by the name of Keith Hearne came around. He was a master’s student at a British university.
I can’t recall which one. And he had a really cool insight. His view was that random eye movement, and I think everybody is sort of familiar with this term REM, where basically that’s the time you actually are dreaming, wasn’t actually random, but rather your eyes moved dependent on what you actually were seeing in the dream. This gave, I guess, the idea of how he could actually prove whether people were truly lucid aware within the dream. So he trained a few people up in how to become lucid, which we’ll talk about very shortly.
And the technique was very simple. As soon as the dreamer was aware that they were dreaming, he or she would signal to the outside world by either blinking their eyes, their dream eyes, or alternatively, moving their eyes from left to right. Now, in the dream world, if you do that with your eyes, it has the same effect as in the physical body. Your eyes will also move. So he was therefore able through an EEG chart to record the eye movement.
So this is the first recorded proof of a lucid dream and it’s still available. It’s on show. It’s been framed at the British Museum of Science in London. And what you can it’s very hard to notice here, but there are little numbers here. One, two, three, four, five and six.
LOC and ROC stand for left and right eyes and what you can see is that the actual dreamer is blinking. I think they programmed they were going to blink five or six times to indicate the start of being lucid within a dream. And sure enough, you can see activity here where it basically reverberates more. One, two, three, four, five and there’s a slight six movement here. So that basically was the first, you could say, scientific proof that you are actually able to be aware, lucid, within a dream.
Hearne’s interests moved quite rapidly away from dreaming. When he actually produced this evidence, the reverberations around the academic world were quite astounding. And at the time, I do remember that he was offered a, for my understanding, a whole dream laboratory with research assistants at the University of Liverpool, and he turned it down. The reason being he decided that he wasn’t really interested in it anymore. He wanted to move to hypnotherapy and he’s actually very famous to this day for his techniques.
I’m not a hypnotherapist, so I don’t know very much about it, but supposedly he’s one of the prominent figures in that area. He’s also did a lot of other research. I might just quickly mention one, which is on premonition. Very interesting from my perspective. He didn’t think it would be possible to prove whether people have premonition or not, so rather he took another way of looking at the problem, which was scanning a large sample of the population.
I don’t know which town he was in The United Kingdom when he did this, to check to see who claimed they had premonition lot, and then look for characteristics of what made up that sample of people that actually had premonition. He noticed two very interesting cases. First, that predominantly they were female and premonition here I’m talking about the example that he uses is having an idea of an event before it actually takes place. That’s simply how he defines it. And he showed they were primarily female and also had three or more children, which was actually quite rare because I think still that maybe people had more children than they do have now, but it was still roughly about two as an average per family.
So he came to the conclusion that there was an evolutionary biological advantage for women who were likely to have more children to have premonition because they’re more likely to succeed in growing up because they have basically an advantage in knowing when there’s a danger approaching. So he comes with this background of evolutionary biological research that he basically incorporates in how he comes to conclusions with regards to premonition, and also he uses it with hypnotherapy as well. The thing goes on for quite a long time in terms of the stuff he’s done, but I just wanted to give you a rough idea of what he was involved in. Now the person that has probably revolutionized lucid dream research is a gentleman by the name of Steven LaBerge. He was the first person to actually write a peer reviewed journal article, and it came from his PhD where he was studying at Stanford, and he again was able to prove a year after Hearne did himself that you could actually lucid dream.
In other words, be formally awake within a dream, because the neurological model that existed before that is that either you were asleep or awake. You could not be awake whilst asleep. It’s fundamentally changing the model, and people just refuse to accept it. So he established the Lucidity Institute where he wanted to try to get people around the world involved in doing studies for him because the problem was there were very few people at the time who were interested in it. Nowadays, if you go online, there are thousands and thousands of people actively involved in lucid dreaming.
There are hundreds of message boards which are updated on a regular basis where people exchange their dreams. There are apps you can download on your iPad or iPhone for lucid dreaming. It just goes on forever nowadays. Alan Hobson is probably the most prominent neurobiologist or psychiatrist as well who works in this area who basically showed the neurological differences that exist between a lucid dreaming state and a dreaming state, a non aware state. So I’m just going to read out the bottom bit here in case you can’t read it.
During a lucid dream, the frontal lobe, and again, this doesn’t really mean very much for me because I’m not a neurologist, I don’t really know what these different colored sections mean, but I do record it because people like to know. The frontal lobe of the brain, which is this red part here, is more active than in ordinary random eye movement sleep, with a consistent synchronization of neuron firing at the 40 Hz frequency. I just thought I’d stick that up there. People generally will refer to the fact that if you’re actually lucid in a dream, then, in fact, your frontal lobe is actually far more active than it would normally be in sleep. How widespread are lucid dreams?
Well, a couple of recent studies that look at different samples of the population indicate that it’s quite common. However, the lucid dreams that are being referred to here is just simply some minor form or semi elusive awareness that you’re actually dreaming. It’s not full awareness. But as basically indicated just by the number of people put their hands up here in the audience, you’ve all had some form of experience as well. So sixty percent of the interviewees, this is United States, reported experiencing at least one lucid dream.
Seventeen to thirty six percent of Japanese college students reported one lucid dream per month. This is not an uncommon event, Although I guess as mentioned before, what I’m looking at is actually full lucidity, which is slightly different to semi lucidity that they were basically examining. So what happens when you sleep? Well, we go through a sleep cycle and I think some of you, if not nearly all of you, would have an understanding of this. So the sleep cycle consists of randomized movement followed by light sleep, well, actually then followed by what we call NREM movement.
And that’s split up into two parts. You’ve got light sleep and deep sleep. And it’s only been recently in the last decade that scientists have been able to accept the fact that you dream even when you’re not in random eye movement sleep. So people have shown that you can actually dream whilst in light sleep. Scientists still I’ll talk about this a little bit later on.
Scientists still to today do not accept the fact that you can be awake in deep sleep. And I’ll talk about that in a few minutes. Our sleep cycle leads us to have greater light sleep and random eye movement sleep during the end of the sleeping period. What does that mean? Well, as we sleep, let’s say over a six, seven hour period, we start off with by experiencing a more deep sleep cycles.
And as we move closer to the end of our sleeping period, let’s say, make it up to six, 07:00 in the morning, you’re going to be spending far longer periods of time in light sleep and random eye movement sleep. So the cycles switch from REM, light sleep, deep sleep and then they repeat. Actually, deep sleep and REM, it’s not uncommon for you to wake up briefly. Many people have brief moments of actual full awakening and they go back to sleep. That’s also not uncommon.
Furthermore, it’s been shown that negative emotionally based dreams occur primarily at the beginning of the sleeping period of your six hour, let’s say seven hour period of sleep, whereas positive based dreams occur at the back end. That basically means just as you’re going to wake up in the morning. From an evolutionary perspective, that sort of makes sense. You don’t want to wake up feeling crap, right? So it’s better to have all your positive based events and dreams right at the end of the sleep so you feel up feeling refreshed.
What is a dream? Well, part of the brain processes visual stimuli in waking life plus the language centers are known to shut down. So this is from neurological experiments. In other words, it’s basically refuting what Sigmund Freud stated, which that dreams were a verbal construct. They’re not.
We know that the language centers actually completely shut well, completely, but have very little activity in those areas. Also, the idea that the visual part, the brain that processes vision actually shuts down is quite interesting because we have very vivid hallucinations in our dreams, yet it’s actually not related to the processing of our brains to what we see externally. So it’s completely, purely, as we would know, mental imagery. Dreams are a metacognitive function of waking life cognition patterns. What does this mean?
Well, what most dream academics conclude is that the way in which we act during the day has a definite correlation with what we do during our sleep in terms of what we dream. And to a certain extent, it’s a processing matter of redoing how we think and how we acted during the day. Changes in waking behavior replicate in dreams. If there’s something that happens traumatic to you and you psychologically have changed, it will have an impact on your dreams. That has definitely been shown as well.
The other thing that’s worth mentioning is that people also consider dreams as a sort of residual unresolved emotional activities. Dreams generally tend to be emotionally based. Although you might not know this, even the most bizarre dreams tend to actually be quite bland when you start interpreting it. There are different ways of interpreting dreams where dreams try to express an emotion in a physical object or through an activity, and once you sort of translate what’s actually occurring, it tends to be something that you actually experience during the day, which can be just a general ordinary event. So the residual are sometimes things that you haven’t been able to resolve in your waking consciousness.
It gets sort of stuck in your unconsciousness and gets processed in the dream state effectively. Okay, so now we come to examining how do you actually lucid dream, and there are two techniques that I’m going to introduce you to, and the one that I’m going to spend more time on, and again, I’m definitely going to say this is going to be quite contentious, at least I was thinking whether I should present this or not, is the WILD technique. But I’ll begin by talking about MILD, Mnemonic Induced Lucid Dreams. It is the most popular technique to induce a lucid dream. To give you an understanding how successful it is, there have been experiments that show that people who have not had any experiences of full lucid dreams before, if they go into a one week immersion course to learn to lucid dream, forty to sixty percent of the participants will come out with at least one lucid dream within the week.
It’s very successful. Wake induced lucid dreaming is a different matter. It’s the holy grail for lucid dreamers. It basically means you can lucid dream at any point in time that you like. In order to do that, it requires a lot more training.
Think the surveys that from what I’ve read, seventy percent of people lucid dream through a mild, which basically means you wake up within the dream, and less than thirty percent actually are able to induce a dream through a WILD. Now wake induced lucid dreams mean you actually start from a completely waking state into a dream state. Also, as I said before, we’ll be discussing that in little more depth. So to begin with mild, you have to start preparing. You can’t just simply say, Okay, I’m going to start becoming lucid in my dreams.
So how do you do that? Well, the first thing that you need to do is have the ability to recall your dreams. If you can’t recall your dreams, how do you know if you’ve ever been lucid in them, right? Furthermore, and there’s evidence showing this, that people, and this is another benefit of actually getting involved in this, people who actually have better dream recall seem to have better memory function. So there’s a distinct advantage for actually trying to recall your dreams.
What you want to aim for is to remember at least two dreams per night, but your goal really should be closer to three to four. Now there’s a number of techniques in order for you to do that. I haven’t got time to discuss them all, but just to give you a feeling, the first thing that you want to really do is make sure that you can wake up directly after a dream. And if you’re a very heavy sleeper, that can be a problem. So just as an example of the techniques that existed, are a variety of things that you can do.
One, for example, is to drink lots of water. You’ll naturally want to wake up during the sleeping cycle to pee. And, of course, as soon as you wake up, you have gone through, even if it’s just intermittent and short, an REM period where you’ve actually been dreaming. Now the trick is not to move. You have to stay completely still and you’re therefore more likely to actually recall the dream.
As soon as you record a dream, don’t think remember it when you wake up later on in the morning. You need to actually get your journal out, your dream journal, and write it down. Only if you become experienced can you actually start recalling dreams without the need of a dream journal, but to begin with, you’re going to need to rely on that. There are other means of waking up through an alarm clock. I don’t think particularly it’s accessible because you might not be in a dream state when the alarm goes off.
There are actually dream alert devices you can purchase. Some of them are quite expensive. They do function quite well, but I don’t think they’re necessary. Need to stay motionless as soon as you wake up and you need to start a dream journal. The next thing after you collected about 20 to 30 dreams, you need to start analyzing them and pick out what we call dream signs.
Although you may not realize this, we all have recurrent themes that occur in our dreams. Now those recurrent themes may be very different from one person to the next, so you need to find out what they are. For some people, they’re always driving in a car, for example, or they’re running. Others might be a house or it was close to water, whether it’s a sea or a swimming pool. Whatever it is, you need to pick out what those dream signs are.
Optimally, you want to identify two to three dream signs. Then we come to what we call our daytime practice, and this is probably the most crucial part of the MILD technique and basically gives the name, Mnemonic induced lucid dreams. Mnemonic basically meaning you’re going to train yourself in a cue. And we refer to this as a reality check. It was originally devised by a German psychiatrist called Tholey for a completely different reason.
Maybe it had something more to do with mindfulness techniques where he wanted to get people to wake up to the state that they were currently in. So it’s also referred to as the critical state test. Basically what you do throughout the day, every time you come across a dream sign that you’ve identified as a recurrent theme in your dream, you conduct a reality check. Literally. Can you fly?
So this is a great example. I’m under some form of stress because I’m presenting to the audience. This could be in a dream, so I’m going to test. Can I fly? Unfortunately not.
I look like an idiot, right? But basically, that is a dream check. I don’t particularly recommend this type of dream check because people will think you’re quite odd. Can I pinch my nose and still breathe? So literally, in waking life, if I pinch my nose and try to breathe, it’s impossible, right?
But in a dream, you can. You can breathe very nicely without any problems. Does time change too suddenly? So you look at your watch, see what the time is. It’s now 09:30.
Take two seconds, look again. It’s still 09:30. If you’re in a dream, it’s very likely the time has dramatically changed. It’s suddenly 03:15 or 09:00, whatever it might be. Counting the number of fingers you have in the hand, that’s also quite popular.
You’ll find that suddenly you might actually have an extra finger or one less. Poking my finger into the palm of my hand. So can I actually stick my finger through the palm of my hand and it comes out the other side? Many years ago, I used to do this, but I stopped because my wife got very angry with me because once I was actually in an argument with her and I thought, okay, this might just be a dream. And it turned out it wasn’t.
And she knew what I was doing. She said, this is not a dream, Ralph. I am telling you off. So you want to be quite subtle in what you use because people will think you’re a little bit mad. Finally, you also need to train in what we call prospective memory.
This is actually very important. Prospective memory training, you see a lot of work done particularly for people who suffer from dementia, and the concept basically is that you try to train yourself to do a certain activity if a specific event takes place. So the way we would actually practice this is, for example, every time I hear the telephone ring, I will conduct a reality check. Am I dreaming or not? Every time I walk through an archway of a door, I will check.
Am I dreaming or not? Now the key is this. You don’t want to get into, into habituation, which basically means I’m just going to use the same event time and again because you’ll naturally then start doing the reality checks. Every single day, you want to you want to change what that event is. That’s true prospective memory training.
In other words, you wake up in the morning and you decide today, every time I see a red car, I’m going to do a reality check. The next day, you might come up with something completely different. Every time I sneeze, I will conduct a reality check. The concept here is that you get used to the idea of making a decision of when you’re going to perform a reality check on a new event. If you notice you’re roughly 70 to 80% successful, you know you’ve basically trained yourself quite well in that.
And perspective memory training is very important if you want to become fully lucid. So I’ve provided this diagram to, I guess, reinforce what I’m basically trying to state that the MILD technique does. Through habituation of encountering dream signs in waking life, which we know we encounter very regularly during our dreams, and conducting a critical state check, a reality check, at same the time when that dream sign occurs, you’re habituating the two together, right? There’s an association that forms. Because we know dreams are metacognitive function of what we do during the day, it will naturally seep into the dream state.
And particularly due to prospective memory training, if just before you go to sleep, keep on repeating yourself, I will know I am dreaming when I am dreaming. You just keep on repeating that little mantra to yourself and then fall asleep. You’re lining yourself up for success because sure enough, during the middle of a dream, there will be a dream sign that you regularly encounter during your dream and lo and behold, you’re starting to do the reality check. And the only difference is, rather than not being able to poke your finger through the palm of your hand, to your surprise, you actually are. And that changes the ballpark.
That changes the game entirely, entirely. Becoming lucid. Most people relate the first few times of becoming lucid to being more awake than in waking life. The feeling is just ecstatic. And I’ll give you a quote from a poet, not a particularly famous one who lived in the early 1900s, Oliver Fox, but he also dabbled a lot in lucid dreaming.
Never had the sea and sky and trees shown with such glamorous beauty. Even the commonplace house has seemed alive and mystically beautiful. Never had I felt so absolutely well, so clear brained, so inexpressibly free. Most lucid dreamers would actually relate entirely to this. Steven LaBerge, who takes a far more scientific view to this, he himself actually said roughly the same thing.
The common characterization of lucid dreams are that of being more real than real, a perception of complete freedom, increased perceptual vividness through increased hyper reality sensory facilitation. All your senses feel as if they have been sharpened. That’s the best way to basically describe it. There are three different dreamscapes that LaBerge describes and that lucid dreamers would also agree is the case. I’m going to go through each of them with you.
So the first is the typical perceptual environment, as LaBerge refers to it, is where you have this heightened sensory environment that you’re exposed to through what we call our dream body. You can control most of the dreamscape. So it takes time to learn how you manipulate things in dreams. As soon as you become aware, lucid in a dream, doesn’t mean you can control the environment. It takes a little while to learn how to do that.
Through multiple studies, what people found out is that you can control everything with one exception, and that’s the amount of light that actually is in the dream. Keith Hearne was actually the first person to notice this, and he refers to it as the light switch experiment. It’s a very fascinating experiment. Basically, he would get lucid dreams to go to a switch, this is in their dreams, right, and try to switch a light on. Now, technically speaking, you should be able to therefore see brighter light, but no.
The amount of light within the dream stays the same, and usually what happens, what lucid dreamers recall, is that the light switch failed to work because there was a mechanical error. This is all, of course, in the dream, right? The bulb was broken. There’s always some excuse why the light would not actually get brighter. I’ve got a little quote here just to give you an example.
This is actually one of Steven LaBerge’s subjects, if I can find it. I remember the light task and look around for a switch. I find a table lamp and flick its switch on. It dimly illuminates. I switch it off and it goes off.
I try willing it to light, so using willpower basically, focusing my willpower on the bulb, but nothing happens, which is quite rare because in a dream, you basically think of something and it usually appears. Then I try another lamp, a halogen desk lamp. I turn on the knob and it dimly lights. Twist off and it goes off. Magical will power has no effect again.
This is a standard report from subjects who try to influence the amount of light in the dream. No experience has been done on this, but what people generally conclude is that the amount of light that a lucid dreamer experiences in the dream is somehow related to the amount of activity that’s actually taken into the frontal lobe. So the more activity, the more brightness it will actually be. But no one’s actually been able to prove this as yet. But that’s the theory why it’s actually very hard to increase the amount of light in the dream.
There are ways you can actually do it, but it’s not spontaneous. You have to wait a while, usually things are quite spontaneous in a dream with the exception of light. The second type of a dream skate is a surreal environment. You’ve got colorful, swelling vortexes. People that look at this relate to the effects that people notice from those that take hallucinogenic drugs or LSD, etc.
Very similar. In fact, they’re identical. The final dream scape, which has only actually become of interest recently to researchers, is the imageless lucid dream, or as LaBerge refers to it as a minimal perceptual environment. Generally speaking, it’s jet black, and I’m going to explain, very shortly to you, and hopefully I’m going to be able to prove it to you. I don’t know if I can convince everybody, but it is impossible for any of you to see a true color in waking life.
The only way you can see a true color is through a dream. I’m going to explain how I’m going to do that shortly later. So what you see is jet black. Some describe it as a glowing darkness. There’s also a perception of extreme depth.
But at the same time, and this is what I find fascinating, there’s no recognition of a dream body. You actually have no sense that you actually have a body or actually have a being. So this can lead to what we call the dislocation effect, which most people get very frightened of. People that end up in an imageless lucid dream usually freak out and they generally wake up within about twenty seconds. And they actually stop lucid dreaming from there on because they’re just too scared of what they experience.
The way LaBerge describes it is a little bit more technical. Kinesthetic sensations may be present. That basically means the feeling of movement. Somesthetic sensations are typically absent. That means the sensation of actually having a being, having a body does not exist.
There are perceptions of visual depth, e. G. The darkness has a sense of depth and size to it. Now, most people would agree that this image lucid dream is a period between one dream ends and the other one begins. Things just basically go blank, but it is still a dream because there is the perception of a color, which is black, and also there is perception of depth.
That depth basically has both, as Leberg describes it as, size to it as well as a three-dimensional aspect to it. So what can you do in a lucid dream? Well, most people, and if any of you are tempted to go into this, will find that the experience of flying to be probably the first thing that most people like doing. Flying, you might think, well, how does that feel? The only way to describe it is you actually do it.
It’s very illuminating. It’s free, liberating, dare I say. And you actually do feel as if you’re doing it. It’s more real than real. You have to remember that you think that in waking life you are experiencing as real things can be, but in fact it’s actually in the dream world people will say no, that’s actually what’s real.
Sounds contradictory, but that’s the case what most people would report. If you want to control dreams, it takes time. The biggest obstacle, and I’m going to talk a little bit more about this as well, is waking up. Thinking that you’ve woken up and it’s called a false awakening. And I’m going to relate this very shortly to alien abductions and out of body experiences, because they’re all interrelated, in my opinion at least.
There are techniques for making sure that you don’t wake up, because the problem is once you’ve actually gained some form of experience in actually waking up in a dream, the beginner’s luck runs out. In other words, the experience of having complete freedom comes to an end. Why? Because my personal opinion is that you start bringing in things from the real world. You think, I can’t really fly because there’s gravity, and sure enough, you can’t fly anymore.
You actually put obstructions to yourself. The other thing that’s probably really bad, and I’m referring to here, is the fact that that when you are dreaming and you suddenly realize that you’re dreaming, you’re more likely to to actually physically awake because you’re thinking, well, this is all rubbish. So you need to actually convince yourself that the dream state is real knowing that it’s not. It’s a balancing act. So how do you do that?
One method that’s proven to be quite successful is to stare at your hands and focus on your hands and solidify it. You want to solidify something in the dreamscape to keep you there. Another technique that actually works quite well is to fall backwards. The reason why is because you wouldn’t normally do it in a in a waking environment, but falling backwards puts you in such an awkward position, you’ll likely actually be swelled into a new dreamscape. So the problem is just making sure that you’re still lucid.
Another technique is referred to the spinning method, where literally you just stand still and then you just start spinning around physically in your dream body. That also seems to work quite well. There are many things that you can do in the dream. One thing I’ll just probably mention, and Hearne liked this technique, was actually to switch on a television set and sit down on a couch and watch TV. Another more traditional method is to read a book.
Now Hearne’s practice was that you set a goal, what you actually want to think about and what sort of a problem that you might have, so that in the dream, you actually then switch on the television and the television channel, what you watch, the program will give you an answer to it. Now that doesn’t always work, and I’m going to just read out a couple of quotes from experiences that Oliver Fox had, and it’s followed up by a quote from LaBerge about reading a book and how things are very transient. So, let’s have a look. Reading in lucid dreams is a very difficult matter. The print seems clear enough until one tries to read it.
Then the letters become blurred or run together or fade away or change to others. If comprehended initially, the text upon rereading can change in either form. Lexical structure, semantic structure are based on rhyme or alliteration, and I’ll give you one example where it does actually work here. I really like this one because not all the time do you read something and it completely changes. Sometimes there are little gems that actually appear, which I find fascinating.
So this is a subject that had a dream and got a very nice quote from it. Exploring around the grand old hotel that for some reason I take to be Freud’s hotel, Fully lucid, I find a piece of paper that appears to at first be a prescription, but upon clearance inspection now seems to be the will or legacy of Anna Freud. So for those of you who might not be familiar, Anna Freud was only the only child, I think, out of six that actually followed Sigmund Freud’s footsteps into psychology. She did a lot stuff with child psychology from my understanding. On the paper, I read the words, to dust we must, to light we might.
So I found that quite interesting, a nice little quote that actually has a lot of meaning. So not always do you just read gibberish. Sometimes there actually is a real meaning behind it. Okay. So the MILD technique is the most successful technique to ensure someone can actually become lucid in a dream.
It’s through habituation of associating a dream sign that occurs regularly in one’s dreams with a reality check that you perform during the day that seeps through into your dreams. Is everybody sort of happy with that sort of model, right? The WILD technique is completely different. It’s not something that you can do automatically and does require some training. As I mentioned before, less than 30% of people who lucid dream are able to wild.
So it’s not that popular, but there is a significant body of people that do it. So in order to prepare, it has the same criteria, you could say, as the mild, but there are some extra exercises that need to take place. The first is concentration. You need to have the ability to focus on a particular object and stay with it. Now, I’m not referring to here the meditations that we’re talking about before where you’re going to enter into some calm abiding.
The concept here is very simple. You focus on any object and you try to stay with it. That’s simply minutes is sort of what your goal is and there’s a reason for that because the process of getting from a wakefulness state to a complete dream state for most people to begin with takes 20. Actually, some people takes a lot longer, an hour, an hour and a half because they’re so perturbed. For other people who are experienced with it, they can actually do it very rapidly.
You need to also learn to observe and break trains of thought. This is actually very important. There’s little games that you can play during the day in order to do that. So I’ve got a little side swipe here at someone. Does anyone know what that means?
Very good, ma’am. So I think, therefore I am. So Descartes basically says, well, proves that you exist fundamentally. I’m saying, well, actually, that’s not the case. You actually, from the dream perspective, that’s the worst thing you can do.
Thinking basically will destroy any chance you have of wilding. And the reason being that as soon as you start following trains of thought, you’re not focusing on what’s actually occurring as you move into the dream state, you’ll be soon in cloud cuckoo lang singing with the fairies, right, unawake of what’s actually occurring. The best time to wow is early morning, and there’s also another technique which is referred to as wake back to bed, or WBTB for short. It’s proven that’s the most likely chance of you actually having a lucid dream. Why is that?
Well, I’ve already presented the reason because we’re most likely to actually be in a dream state closer to the end of our sleeping periods than at the beginning. We are more likely to be in light sleep and REM, let’s say, to 05:00 in the morning than we are at one a. M. Also, and I wasn’t able to put this into my presentation until recently, I only put things in which I can scientifically back up, so if any of you want proof, I can provide you with a quote from a paper: You increase your chances of a lucid dream around the full moon. Two weeks ago, I was just reading a general newspaper, and there was a great article that caught my attention, which was from the University of Basel that were trying to work out why there were more people coming into emergency wards during the full moon.
And what they established after doing some research is that they actually hooked up people to EEG machines and all that, that you’re more likely to have far less deep sleep during around the full moon than you are during other periods. So light sleep and random eye movement sleep actually increases. So to optimize the chance of you having a wild, you want to try to practice this around the full moon, plus also in the early morning. That increases the chance of success. It’s a balance between being attentive and yet at the same time feeling relaxed.
You have to get that balance right. You are going to trick your body into thinking you are asleep, when really your mind is fully awake. That’s essentially what the goal is. You’re going to shut down all external stimuli information, and therefore all that you’re left with are internally manufactured material. That’s basically your dreamscape, which you can then slowly learn to control.
So I’m going to read this little passage out. I didn’t write this, but it’s quite commonly quoted in lucid dreaming sites, and it sort of sums up what actually occurs, but I’m going to break it down far more distinctly, at least I claim that I’m going to do that. Lay down and go to sleep. This works best if you’re extremely tired. Lay on your back with your arms at your sides and eyes closed.
Stay perfectly still. You must stay awake. Your brain will send signals to your body to see if you are ready to sleep. These signals include getting an itch, changing your body position, wanting to blink or move your eyeballs. Remember, your eyes should be closed.
There are reasons why you want to keep your eyes closed because I’ll talk about this. There’s a crossover effect that you can actually occur. You must ignore all of these impulses. After twenty to thirty minutes, you will feel a weight on your chest. You may even hear weird noises.
You are now in sleep paralysis, spelt badly, might add. If you open your eyes, you will begin to hallucinate, and this is what I’m referring to. You don’t really want to do this because some people just get too scared. You’re dreaming basically with your eyes open. There’s a crossover between you’re still able to actually see what’s actually there in the room, but it’s what’s superimposed are actually dream images, which causes a problem for some people, and you will not be able to move your body.
Now the reason why you have sleep paralysis, of course, is it’s a very healthy function. You don’t want to be acting out, you know, in sleep what you’re actually dreaming. So sleep paralysis is very important. People who don’t go through sleep paralysis end up sleepwalking and such and can end up in a lot of trouble. Now that you are aware of your dreaming, you can shut your eyes and begin to dream instantly.
You will be fully aware you are dreaming and you can, with now some practice, control your dreams. Okay, so I’m going to break it up into different steps. The first one is that you need to assume a sleep posture. Now through research involving babies to determine the best position to place them in to avoid cot death, it’s been shown that getting them to sleep on their backs is optimal. The reason being they are more likely not to enter into deep sleep.
Lighter sleep actually occurs by sleeping on your back. The other thing is a slightly elevated head actually does help as well. There’s some research that suggests I don’t know what it’s for. It’s maybe to help with sleep apnea. I’m not quite sure.
But there’s these special pillows that have been designed for some people, which actually you’re not sleeping vertically anymore. You’re sort of in between a sitting posture and a vertical posture, a bit at an angle, dare I say. Some empirical evidence also suggests that sleeping on your right side actually helps better because it places less stress on the heart. However, there’s some research that LaBerge is actually conducting at the moment that tries to see whether that’s actually going to help you more likely to have a lucid dream or not and it’s actually partly related, in his opinion, whether you’re left or right handed. There’s also a link with the nasal cycle.
Many people don’t realize this, but usually you only breathe through one of your nostrils during your sleep. And what scientists have actually found out is that it seems that as you switch your nasal cycle, you actually change your sleeping posture from the right to your left. So some people connect it with actually how you’re actually sleeping and it may be a function of getting you to move once in a while during your sleep. Okay. So the first thing that you need to do, and there’s many ways of actually wilding, but the way I’m going to show you is actually what happens if you just simply view what actually is occurring in your field of vision and basically in your dreamscape as you go through the various steps.
The first thing that you need to do is become familiar with what we call visual random noise. And you want to focus at the back of your mind constantly. Your focus is I am dreaming. I am dreaming. For a beginner, this is quite hard because literally you have to say this, but if you become a little bit more experienced, it’s a little bit more subtle.
There’s just something in the back of your mind that you know, okay, I am dreaming. You don’t actually have to mentally repeat those words. Now visual random noise is not a hallucination. We all experience it on a regular basis. It’s something to do with the retina.
I don’t know the medical function behind it, But just to maybe hopefully give you a feeling of it, if you look at the orange wall behind me or maybe just the whiteboard that’s not highlight illuminated here and just stare at it for maybe ten seconds, twenty seconds, can you notice that there are there is a certain snow effect like an old television screen? Yes or no? I don’t know. You’ve been at least some of you, right? Okay.
So the first thing that you want to do is just simply stare at that. Just become accustomed to seeing the visual snow effect. The reason being, after a little while, it can just take a minute or two, it depends how relaxed you are, that snow effect changes. It forms into basically what I call lava like blobs, and a little bit after that, you might notice something quite interesting, that you can actually partly direct their movement. Either you can try to move them all sort of clockwise or anti clockwise.
As soon as you’re getting to that stage, you’re slowly entering into a dream environment at the rudimentary level, the very beginning. So the other thing that you’ll notice that verbal dialogue is reduced, and the reason being is that the language centers within your brain are slowly shutting down, so things seem a little bit more peaceful, a little bit more clear. And we refer to this as us entering into hypnagogia. So I’m going to talk a little bit about hypnagogia and what that actually infers. Now please feel free to ask me questions questions as I go along.
Yes, I should point out that you can actually keep your eyes open if you want to, but the majority of people will recommend keeping it closed because it’s actually much more clearer to see. Absolutely. And the key is this. It’s very fundamental. If you’re thinking of different things, you will not see anything.
You won’t even see the speckles. You’ve got to stop that thought process, right? Get into habit of if you start seeing yourself thinking, just cut it out. So just focus, feel relaxed on what you’re actually viewing. Okay, so at this point, a few things start to happen.
The brain starts telling itself, am I asleep or not? It needs to do a check, and the common way it does a check, and not everybody experiences this, but it’s quite common, is that you suddenly have an urge to scratch itches all over your body. An alternative is that you have this desire to start moving your eyes or an urge to move. This is a natural signal of moving into dreams because your brain wants to make sure that you truly are out of it, right? Because if you’re not, then you want to keep your physical body working.
So it does these checks. You have to fool the body. You have to fool not the body. You have fool the brain that you are truly asleep. How do you do that?
You’re not thinking and you ignore the urges. You just stay still. You may then start to hear noises, incoherent voices, washing sounds, large claps. Images may also start to appear. They generally are only two dimensional in nature.
Now again, I’m assuming that most of you would have some type of experience of this. As you’re falling asleep, you might have heard background noises. Does that sort of make any type of record? Okay, good. We call these dreamlets.
They’re not real dreams. They’re just short little snaps of imagery, a transient state between waking and sleeping. When you move from sleeping to waking, we actually call this hypnopompia. It’s slightly different. There are slightly different effects.
So hypnogogia is when we’re moving from waking to sleeping. Okay, step four. We’re entering sleep paralysis. Sleep paralysis by itself is fascinating. I did a quick Wikipedia search for me and there’s a plethora of information.
I’m going to read out just a couple of things from it. There’s a lot of research that goes into this as well. It’s completely harmless, but at the same time for people that experience it for the first time, it is very daunting. And although we might laugh at it, it is so real that you can’t convince someone that what they haven’t experienced isn’t an alien abduction, isn’t a demon on the chest as this picture actually shows. So this is from Henry Fuseli in 1781, The Nightmare is thought to be one of the classic depictions of sleep paralysis perceived as a demonic visitation.
The reason being, as you slowly start entering into sleep paralysis, the body shuts down and the way I sort of describe it is through a heavy lead blanket that starts being pulled over from the bottom of your feet right up to your head. And as that progresses, you actually feel you cannot actually move physically. For most people, you’re already fast asleep mentally, so you don’t know what’s actually happening, so it’s not a problem. For people, and this is not uncommon, some people during their lives actually experience sleep paralysis and because you’re actually dreaming, your brain puts imagery in there that makes this out to be a very bad event. Commonly, it’s actually pressure on the chest because you feel as if you can’t breathe anymore.
The reason why you can’t feel your breathing anymore because your external environment is being shut down physically you are not feeling yourself breathing. You’re not. Even though you are, you are fine. You are breathing happily. You just don’t actually feel as if you are.
Pressure on attest, some people feel as if there’s electrical currents running down. I’ll give a quick quote and this is from a study on sleep paralysis and this is from a 14 year old girl who’s been experiencing these events recently. I’ll wake up in the middle of the night or morning. I can’t move at all. It is terrifying.
My body is just struck in a position I can’t move and when I try to call for help, can’t get my mouth to work. My head feels so heavy, like someone was sitting on it. My body feels like there are vibrations going through it and I feel like I’m going to die. The worst part, From what I heard and read, this isn’t uncommon, but I’ll hear and see things that aren’t there. Sometimes during these incidents, my eyes will be half open.
One time my room started to change color and it looked like sparklers were exploding everywhere. I tried to scream but couldn’t. Another time, a giant wasp swooped down and was hovering around my face. There are voices like children or a huge thunderous roar that will constantly be in the background. So this is a common experience for people who don’t know what they’re actually going through.
It becomes a very negative traumatic event. From Wikipedia, they actually cite examples of what sleep paralysis is called all around the world, so I’m just going to read out a couple of examples. In Turkey, sleep paralysis is called Karabassan and is similar to other stories of demonic visitation during sleep. A supernatural being, commonly known as the Djinn, comes to the victim’s room, holds him or her down hard enough not to allow any kind of movement and starts to strangle the person. In Thailand, it is believed that sleep paralysis and discomfort is caused by a ghost of Thai folklore known as, excuse my pronunciation here, pi am or fi am?
Pi am, thank you very much. Some people claim that this spirit may even cause bruises. In Chinese, call to sleep paralysis is known as pinyin, which literally translates to ghost pressing on the body. Here’s another example I like. There’s quite a few actually.
In Newfoundland, it is known as the old hag. In island folklore, the hag can be summoned to attack a third party like a curse. In his 1982 book, The Terror that Comes in the Night, David Hufford writes that in local culture, the way to call the hag is to recite the Lord’s Prayer backwards. There you go. So in modern contemporary Western culture, demons basically take a second place, a second role, because no one believes in them anymore, unfortunately.
So what has it been replaced with? Alien abductions. There’s been a number of studies that show that at least seventy percent of cases are situations where a person has just woken from sleep and then experiences aliens coming and fuddling around with their bodies. Well, the fact is they probably actually haven’t woken up from their sleep. That’s very likely what’s actually occurring.
Along with sleep paralysis, pretty much the straight after it, there’s a completely different feeling of your body. The reason being you can’t feel it anymore. The way in which your mind interprets it is that it’s completely light, as if you can basically start floating off. And here’s a nice little painting, I don’t know when it was actually done, but basically gives the impression that you’re having an out of body experience. In fact, what this essentially is what people refer to sometimes as a false awakening.
It’s where you actually think you’re awake but you’re not. What actually occurs is that, and this is a particular problem for people who are lucid dreamers, because you actually finish a dream and then you feel yourself as if you’re in your body in your bed and you’ve actually exited the dream state and you’re actually awake, when in fact you’re not. Basically, your brain is saying, let’s pretend that you’re actually awake. And so some people actually leave their bodies, in their dream body, and move around their room and it looks nearly identical, not quite nearly identical, to their actual physical room because your brain is trying to interpret, pretend that it is asleep. So that’s generally referred to in the lucid dreaming community as a false awakening as a very common occurrence.
The other thing that is not uncommon are visions. Once you’ve actually completed the process of going through sleep paralysis, something definitely changes in that the dreamlets, which previously were two dimensional, are now three-dimensional. There is depth, definite depth within the perception. And if you open your eyes because the only thing that isn’t paralyzed are your eyes, hence the reason why we have random eye movement when we sleep, so you can actually physically open them up. There’s a crossover, a superimposition of your dreams upon the real world waking visual sense that you actually see.
And so people have various visions basically of various entities and other things that they come across. I’ll give you one example. My wife was talking to a friend of hers who had this passion to tell her that you should not use cling wrap on food anymore because it’s extremely toxic. And my wife said, Oh, yeah, guess it is. Okay, maybe I shouldn’t use it anymore.
And my wife’s friend said, No, no, no, look, I’ll explain what happened. I was actually just minding my own business and then suddenly an entity appeared at the end of my bed. And this entity told me many things about me, including not to use cling wrap. So there you go. Now once I sort of got a better sense of actually what was occurring, she was clearly actually not lying vertically down but basically hunched on the bed stool at the end.
She had, in my opinion, I mean, haven’t discussed that with her, she had fallen asleep and not knowing it and had obviously somehow opened her eyes and therefore there was that crossover between the dream state and the waking reality that we see now. So a lot of visions, I’m not claiming all, but a lot of them can be probably put down to this crossover effect. One thing also that people experience that can be quite traumatic is what I refer to as the fireworks show. Some people also describe it as the lead lights of like a Christmas tree flickering on and off. It can be quite daunting, some people feel as if their heads are about to explode.
You don’t have to worry. It’s not going to explode. It’s just a process that you’re going through. Some people relate this to I don’t know if it’s true or not. There’s no scientific evidence to back this up, but it’s neurons lighting up in your brain and that might give the sensation of, I don’t know, lights flickering, something like that.
So entering into the dream. Well, the problem for most lucid dreamers is convincing themselves to actually enter into the three d environment when they actually when they know it’s not real. There’s bit of a problem there. So there’s a number of ways of doing this. One common method is to imagine well, you can imagine, you can very easily create in the dream state the mirror, and you walk through the mirror.
As soon as you walk through the mirror, you convince yourself you’re in the dream. Other times, you can actually ask a dream character to pull you in. You literally put your hand out, not physically, mentally, that’s your dream hand, and ask the dream character to pull you into the dream. The problem comes, of course, is the fact that you know what you’re going to be experiencing is not real. You have to somehow convince yourself just enough that it is to get you into there.
That’s the problem that many lucid dreamers experience. If you’re in a void, that basically means all you see is that the image is lucid dream, so it’s just either usually it’s a color black and depth. You can just simply wait because things will start to appear or you mentally have to start creating objects, which then self perpetuate. Once you’ve got one object going, others will just start appearing. There’s no research scientific research in the West that’s actually been done on dreamless sleep.
I do mention it because there are Indians who work on this area and they publish in journals that, from my understanding, are not considered reputable enough, but basically they focus on something called Yoga Nidra, which is basically like a sleep yoga, and they basically contest the fact that, yes, you can definitely be awake, aware when in a dreamless state. One of the things that would be nice to see is that the scientific community actually picks this up a little bit more. It took many, many years to convince the scientific community you can be awake whilst asleep, and only from the light sleep perspective. Getting them to accept that you can actually be awake when you’re completely in a deep sleep is a completely different matter. Current research in lucid dreams, there’s a lot of stuff that’s going on.
There are dozens and dozens of papers that are published now every year in this area. One thing that people like focusing on is how dreamscapes morph. Keith Hearne started the process. He came up with a really cool way of actually testing how dreamscapes morph and change and that he was actually using people who were hypnotized. Basically, he asked people who were under hypnosis to imagine a scenery and then freeze frame it.
Go to a chalkboard and trace out the dreamscape, just roughly the outline of it. Then go sit back down again, go back to the the mental imagery that’s being created, let it ride for another ten to twenty seconds, freeze frame it, go back to the chalkboard, draw what you see. So he did this repetitively for a number of subjects and the outcome it came with is something which he refers to as the path of least resistance. The way in which dreams morph is not suddenly this glass turns into a car, but rather this glass might then, because it’s shiny, turn into a vase which then might slowly turn into a chandelier, but there’s always a similarity. There’s always a connect.
So it might not sound so profound, but it actually is quite influential in how we actually perceive how dreams change. You don’t have a glass if someone turns into an ant. That does not happen. You can also use lucid dreams to overcome fears. This is quite contentious.
Many people say, no, you don’t want to do this. You don’t want to encourage people who are experiencing high trauma or having bad visions to actually lucid dream because even though, yes, you do gain control once you can lucid dream, the process of getting there means that for quite a while, you’re going through having to practice dream recall and the more you practice dream recall, the more vivid your dreams become. And so it can actually lead to a negative outcome from that perspective. People suggest you can use lucid dreams to help sports athletes actually practice. So you go into the dream state, you practice running, doing a certain activity, and therefore you’re more likely to succeed in doing the activity in waking life.
That’s actually been proven through experiments. Also, there’s a need to develop better definitions of what lucid dreams are from a neurological perspective. I mentioned Hobson as one of the people who basically has spent most of his life focusing on that area, but there’s still a lot of work to do on it. And just as an example of the ludicrous things that people are doing now with lucid dreamers, remembering that scientists did not accept lucid dreamers more than thirty, forty years ago. Now they’re using them to prove or disprove other things that you can’t really actually ascertain whether they’re true or not.
One good example I read recently was to show that, in fact, near death experiences are completely fake and are just simply a dream. How did they do that? Well, they’ve got a group of lucid dreamers together. Well, they trained them up and said, okay, what we want you to do is imagine that you’re going through a tunnel and there’s a white light at the end. And sure enough, all the lucid dreamers would then take that into the dream, experience it, and in some actually would experience an ecstatic sensation.
And they wrote up the paper saying, this proves that there’s no life after death. It’s just simply a dream. From my perspective, you’re not proving anything. All you’re doing is proving that you can dream it. So but I find it fascinating because now you’ve got the scientific community so embedded in using lucid dreamers to disprove other things which haven’t been proven.
So that’s basically the gist of what’s going on. I’m not going to spend very much time on this because I knew I was going to run out of time anyway. I was only planning to talk for one and a quarter hours. But my proposition is that, in fact, if you’re lucid dreaming, you’re basically entering to a meditative absorption. And in fact, it’s not that hard as people make out it to be.
So I know this goes against completely the text that people read, but that’s basically my contention. So to begin with, and I’ve actually spent the last probably three years reading and collecting quotes and tabulating. Haven’t actually put it into the slideshow because I knew I wasn’t going to have enough time to spend on this, but all I’ve done here, therefore, is summarize essentially a little bit of how I see some of the connects exist. So firstly, if you want to get into a meditative absorption, and most of the stuff I’ve been reading is from the Pali Canon / Nikaya tradition. Ability not to be swayed too much by thought.
Well that clearly is the case. You need to make sure that you’re not following thought processes because then you’ll basically be in a dream state, not focusing on what’s occurring as you move into the dream. Make sure life is as simple as possible without too many distractions preferably be somewhere quiet and peaceful. Evidently that makes it easier to sleep. Not be too excited or also too overly tired.
There needs to be a balance between the two. The example I’m going to use is focusing on an object of meditation or concentration, that of the feeling or the sensation of your nostrils as air comes in and out. So I’m not necessarily flowing directly to the flow of air, breath, but rather just a sensation at the tip of your nose of the air coming or breathing in and going out. Now there sort are of events that occur theoretically from, I guess you could say, the readings I’ve gone through, and that there are the sign appears, a nimitta and then a countersign. So the sign is a clearer focus on the object of meditation.
Verbal dialogue is minimized. To me, that basically is a hint that you’re entering into hypnagogia because the language center is basically shutting down. And then suddenly there’s a transformation. The transformation occurs where you’re no longer feeling the sense of the sensation, should I say, of the flow of air in and out of your nostrils. The reason you’re not feeling it is because you can’t because your body is now moving directly into sleep paralysis.
It’s switching off the external stimuli. And so what it’s replaced by is what we call a countersign, well, in the Pali text at least, a mental interpretation of the object of meditation. If you’re focused just on one item, then your mind has to make that adaptation. If it can’t feel the sensation, it replaces it with something else. So in my opinion, it’s a mental object.
It doesn’t actually have to be literally a visual object. It can be a sensation as well. But a sensation is distinctly different from the actual feeling of your breath, the sensation of your nostril hairs, feeling the air going in and out. And as I mentioned here, is the onset of hypnagogia. In fact, if you read this Pali text, they’ll often refer to hearing voices and images and the yogi should avoid this.
Classic example, in my opinion, of the fact that you’re experiencing hypnagogia and, dare I say, with all due respect to Ilya, which I highly put up on a pedestal, when Ilya was referring to, I think, the omen of pliancy, you talked about heaviness in the head. Classic example of entering into sleep paralysis. The last usually it’s not always, but usually it starts from the feet, goes to the head. The last thing that you feel you can’t move is the head. It feels really like someone sitting on you or something really just can’t move, heavy weight.
Piti, which is rapture, the feeling of ecstasy, tingling sensations. The way I’ve heard it described in these texts is ants crawling over your skin. Again, to me, that correlates perfectly to your body sending message to see whether you’re really sleeping or not by having this scratch, the itches that you find all over your skin. Energy currents running up and down your body. Some even experience it as orgasmic, possibly true.
Then after that, there’s a feeling of tranquility. This rapture that initially is quite strong settles down to a constant calmness. All of the above I’ve written down here is a synonymous to the experience of sleep paralysis. Finally, I’ll finish up on sustained application. The concept here that after you’ve gone through and you’ve reached excess concentration or full absorption, there’s something that’s endowed within the object of your meditative concentration that draws you in.
It’s mesmerizing. It’s hypnotic. In fact, my position is that right from step three, when you start to have some form of control over those lava blobs, there’s a mesmerizing characteristic to it. In fact, in a dreamscape, if you’re a lucid dreamer, you can take any single item in the dream, focus on it, and it draws you in. There’s something that naturally brings your attention to it.
I’ve read a paper that suggests it’s related to dopamine or something like that when you’re sleeping. But essentially speaking, from my position, what’s actually occurring here is that you have entered to the dreamscape. The only difference is, of course, you’re focusing on one particular object rather any than form of objects to appear, which would normally be the case for a lucid dreamer. So from a neurological perspective, this is very tentative. Hobson has done some work on this suggesting that there’s heightened theta waves throughout the brain when you are actually lucid dreaming.
The only other state that has been shown in some very few experiments, there’s very few experiments that look at people that go into meditative absorption. Absorption. There’s hoars of experience that look at people that perform lucid dreams, but they also notice the same type of heightened theta waves that come through. It’s a bit contentious because I’ve read somewhere that not every, not the whole scientific community actually, except theta waves, exist in the brain. I don’t know the details of it, but clearly, Hobson, who comes from Harvard University, shows that it is, so I’m going to go with him.
So my proposition, if you can dream, you can lucid dream. If you can lucid dream, you’re in fact in a absorption. And I’d be very happy for someone to prove me wrong. That’s why I’ve included my email address here. I haven’t had the privilege of speaking to anyone that can calm abide.
So if you do know someone, let me know. I’m planning, hopefully, one day to make my way to Sri Lanka because I’ve got some contacts there who tell me they know teachers who can calm abide, so I’d like to enter into a dialogue. That’s basically my goal at the end of the day. But if you know someone or have a particular position, even if it’s contrary to mine, I’d be very happy to hear from it because at the moment, I’m actually very pleased I’m actually being able to present this. When I was asked to do a second presentation, what was provided to me didn’t really well go down with me, so I had to think really hard and I came up with the idea, well, I’d be doing a little bit of research on the relationship between meditative absorptions and lucid dreams, so this will be an excellent chance for me to get that out.
So there are I’ve still got my email address, Dave, you’re still writing it down. There are a couple of places I’d like to draw your attention to if you’re keen on this type of topic. The first is a great book that was written many, many years ago, but still today I think people would say this is the seminal piece of work in the area, and it’s written for lay people and it’s called Exploring the World of Lucid Dreaming and it’s by Steven LaBerge. It’s written probably about twenty five years ago. It’s been updated slightly.
More recently, there’s a guy called Tim Doull who’s done a lot of pro bono work, would say, in the area of lucid dreaming. He’s a lucid dreamer. He’s not a scientist. He’s got a great website called Lucidpedia. They’re message boards and blogs where people exchange dreams and exchange techniques and tricks to how to do various things in the dream state.
He also has created another website called snoozon.com. I think the last time I checked was a week ago. It cost €99 to sign up and it’s a lucid dreaming course. I don’t know if it how well it works or not, but I do admire the characters, so I have put that up there. The other thing that I will do I don’t think I’ve got enough copies for everybody.
I’ve made about 15 copies of just one article I printed off from a journal I haven’t heard before. It’s from the University of Heidelberg, International Journal of Dream Research. There’s loads of journals now that focus on dreaming and the like, but I like this little article because it’s a summation of what I’ve sort of talked about. It’s titled The Subjective Side of Lucid Research, a commentary on the neurobiological consciousness lucid dreaming wakes up by J. Allan Hobson. So Hobson had actually written a more technical paper and these people, which are lucid dreamers, they’re not scientists, were asked to comment on it.
And Hobson is very open to a dialogue between the scientific community and lucid dreaming community, which is very important. One reason, for example, is that many scientists who examine dreams and lucid dreams don’t accept the fact that you can control nearly everything in dreamscape, whereas lucid dreamers say, no, that’s rubbish. You can. You can control everything with the exception possibly of light. And so Hobson is one of the few people who actually maybe the reason why he’s willing to enter into a dialogue is because he also lucid dreams.
And he actually is very happy to take people’s views and try to incorporate that into his research. He’s quite old now. He’s over 80 years of age. So hopefully there’ll be another neurobiologist that come through and pursue this sort of line of research as well. So thank you very much for listening to me, and you’re welcome to take a copy of your paper.
Thank you. Yes? Okay, yes. Sorry, Adrian, to cut in. Perhaps what we will do is break now and reconvene at quarter two for Ilya’s presentation.
Is that alright? Because we will and then obviously talk to Ralph in the break and, we might just, shorten, lunch by a quarter of an hour just to catch up on some time and then, Ralph will be on the panel at the end because there is obviously a feast for us to be thinking about. So thank you so much Ralph, very interesting.
Key terms in this teaching
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.