1 h 43 min · 11,153 words · 11 August 2013
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A talk by a public health researcher on mindfulness in Western therapy and its relation to Buddhist thought. It covers the breadth of the Satipatthana sutta, how mindfulness is defined and measured, brain networks and vagal tone, and training practitioners for mindfulness-based cognitive therapy. Guided exercises include a Necker cube attention task and the three-minute breathing space.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 43m
UUID: 699f49e2-bb28-44f8-9be3-a3a555fced25
Date: 2013-08-11
Words: 11,149
So starting at 01:23, it’s sort of halfway between 01:15 and 01:30. So one and a half hours, Graham, we will finish at three. So thank you so much, Graham, for your contribution yesterday. I’ll let you introduce your topic, and I’ll hand straight over to you. Thank you.
Thank you. Getting there. When I first took up a professorial appointment nearly ten years ago now, a good friend of mine said to me, who I know has a lot of sympathy with the way that I some of the causes that I try to promote in my work in Melbourne. A good friend of mine said to me, You know, it’s a good thing you’re a professor. It means that people will have to pay a little bit more attention to what you say about things and the kind of messages that you put across.
And he looked at me and he said, Of course that includes you. It was meant in a kindly way, actually. But here I’m about to violate one of the key rules about this. There’s a number of things that I will talk through in this and that I will introduce that are not in my key areas of knowledge or interest in research background terms. My main research background is in public health research and epidemiology.
It’s only later that I really come to mindfulness based work. And really one of the things about the, and something I talked more about last year, but a thing about the particular kind of contribution that myself and my group have been bringing to the mindfulness area is that we are really the first people in a sense to look at mindfulness based cognitive therapy from a point of view of what is essentially a health services research perspective. So we’ve kind of looked at it as an intervention for reducing recurrence and remission in depression with properties of transportability, generalizability, dissemination, health economics, those kinds of things. So and that’s an area where I’m on my relatively strong suit. Whereas this presentation is going to range across areas of neurophysiology, perceptual psychology, are into areas that I’m not especially strong on, but I hope to distill out some interesting things that I think are some of the salient areas as far as I see it.
And then, even more audaciously, I tread into the realm of trying to make some connections with Buddhist philosophy and scripture in a way that’s kind of venturing into a more scholarly exploration. And here I’m no deep Buddhist scholar. I’ve read a bit and I’ve had the privilege of having been to a number of Rinpoche’s teachings over the years and read a bit. But I’m attempting to make some connections here around this overall theme of mindfulness, art and science. I think that one of the things that is increasingly preoccupying me and that this is in a way an exploration of is the way that this thing called mindfulness is being used in Western techniques.
And I think that there is number of that there is a way in which we have this thing which is being brought in and which is being used. First of all, there is kind of an assumption that there is a thing that is mindfulness. You see this echoed and repeated in various ways in which people write about it and in debates about what it is and in different models of what it is. What it is, what its consequences are, what is seen as its core and then what is seen as things that might follow from it or otherwise things that might be incorporated in it. And, you know, at the most extreme point, it’s really as if it is purely just something about attention attention and that’s it.
And at a broader point, you have people who will just kind of say, well it’s the whole of dharma. And somehow the fact that you have mindfulness incorporated into a western technique then gives you a license in some people’s view to include anything that is dharma related. And so I think that it is in some measure in something of a state of flux and I will be trying to explore by ways of looking at some of the ways that it’s been operationalised in some of the western traditions. Traditions, what the mappings might be with Buddhist thought as best I understand it. Climate science has its j curve famously of changes in carbon dioxide concentration.
Mindfulness research has its J curve of citation levels of the frequency with which mindfulness is a search term crops up in major databases. This one is from PsycInfo. And is and this one is only up to twenty ten, it would be carrying up. So from something that really featured almost not at all in the literature before about the 1980s, it’s now something in which there is a huge flow of publications in the scientific literature. The term mindfulness has an English usage that goes back to the thirteenth or fourteenth century, which is as a term in regular English which reflected a degree of presence, a degree of focus, a degree of attention, a degree of poise.
Was used and it’s been used since the late nineteenth century as a translation particularly of Sati from Nepali. And so it in a sense is term which has a baggage of an English lay definition onto which you then introduce a translation. And I know that there are a number of authors who prefer, who are kind of writing about Buddhist philosophy, who prefer to not use it as a term at all and prefer to stay with the original terms from the other languages. Mean that we need us as English speakers to in a sense learn the new terms and adapt to them. And I think that if you look at the four mindfulnesses in the Satipatthana sutta, this is something which is developed by a series of approaches, meditations, reflections, which are quite broad and quite far ranging in their nature.
They range they include mindfulness of the breath, mindfulness in different postures, but also then reflections on repulsiveness of the body, reflections on material elements, symmetry contemplations. Charnel ground contemplations do not as yet feature highly and implementations of psychological approaches to mindfulness. We don’t typically speaking do mindfulness based cognitive therapy groups where group four is in the local morgue. But, as we know, death and impermanence, very, very powerful meditations and very much part of the system when one looks at it in this particular source text. Mindfulness of sensations as pleasant, unpleasant or neutral.
Mindfulness of different types of feelings, worldly or spiritual, so mindfulness of sensations. Awareness of contents of consciousness and focusing on contemplating the nature of those in terms of those features. And other approaches to mental contents including the factors of enlightenment and the four noble truths. So we already have something in the which if one looks at it in the Mindfulness in Satipatthana sutta is extremely broad in its definition. Usually the western writers that write about and try and encapsulate mindfulness don’t spend quite as much time writing about actually articulating it.
Probably the most famous, the one that is cited again and again and again and again from Jon Kabat-Zinn is this one. The awareness that emerges through paying attention on purpose in the present moment and non judgmentally to the unfolding of experience moment by moment from Jon Kabat-Zinn. John actually, I’ve heard say that he takes exception to that being regarded as a definition and that it was stated rather as an evocation than a definition. And but a number of other people have been more forward in this. And I think that what one sees in this is that you have the, there is a very strong emphasis on the attention, on the placement attention onto a particular object.
And then an element on nonjudgmental, sometimes expanded more into curiosity, openness and acceptance. But often really stated quite sort of in a very concise and unelaborated way. And I think that sometimes there is a bit of a pitfall there because when, I think a lot of the time when Western psychologists have looked at mindfulness, they have seen things like the way that it’s developed by a relatively simple process of paying attention to the breath or paying attention to an object. What I think they often neglect in their consideration of what the how we need to consider mindfulness is all of the subsequent instructions. Because, of course, you invite someone to place their attention on the breath, but then you invite them to notice if their attention is distracted and you give them some suggestions about how they respond if they notice their attention is distracted.
And that includes, in a gentle, kindly way returning your attention back to the object of meditation. And you may use metaphors like saying it’s a little bit like training a puppy that you care about, that you might be just encouraging them to come back and return and do something that you wanted them to do in the same way you do that with your breath. And so you definitely are communicating through it a feeling of a sense of self compassion in the way that it is communicated. For some reason, the notion of people are very loath in western techniques to engage in inviting people to take part in compassion meditations, in a way that still perplexes me somewhat. I know that I’ve spoken with John about this and he very much says that he felt that had they tried to introduce something like this twenty, thirty years ago, a compassion meditation as part of any clinical technique twenty, thirty years ago that they would have been just regarded as completely flaky and dismissed.
But he still holds back from doing it as do the people who put out MBCT. And I’m not quite sure why this is. I think there is a pervasive sense that when you are dealing with people who have often got severe health problems, physical or mental, that it may be something that is just too much to expect of them. That there is a sense that they so depleted and they are damaged or they are diminished. You can’t expect them to struggle to produce something like compassion.
And that is an interesting position, not something that I necessarily think is correct. But I think there is also a question that we do, as I spoke about yesterday, we do have to steer this line of being aware that what we are doing is in secular tradition and that we need to be making sure that we’re not taking positions that are in a sense partisan and it’s different different kinds of spirituality. And I’m by no means sure that universal loving kindness and compassion are features of all spiritual traditions. There are spiritual traditions that certainly differentially favor the people that are within your tradition over the people who are outside it. So whereas it might seem, it might feel from sitting within a Buddhist perspective that universal loving kindness and compassion are universal shared values, I’m not actually sure that they are.
And I think that people hold back on it in part because of the risk of confronting other spiritual traditions that may be less committed to that. But I don’t really know. It is interesting how people are very there’s a strong resistance to actually going to the realm of including compassion. One of the ways that the it’s interesting. I think I’ve reflected on a number of things in a lot of the training that we’ve been doing on meditation.
One very challenging issue, one issue that is source of quite a degree of conflict and tension within the community of people who are working with mindfulness based interventions is how do you train the practitioners to deliver them. Because we are looking at the issues, we are looking at settings where, you know, we are looking at what is basically, say with mindfulness based cognitive therapy for depression, you know, it sits within the broad family of cognitive behaviour therapy techniques. It’s something which people are in contact with public mental health services should be able to get access to. It’s got an evidence base. We know that it makes difference to relapse and recurrence.
It’s in major guidelines. It’s in the Beyond Blue guidelines. It’s in the NICE guidelines in The United Kingdom. It’s in the guidelines. Guideline Adherent Therapy, which we all say we should do, should deliver this.
But then how do you how do you then train people to deliver these interventions? And there are very different camps on this. There is one camp that really says that people should have very extensive meditation experience before they even start training in the techniques. They should maybe be meditating for at least three years. They should have been on multiple retreats.
That they should then learn how to deliver the intervention. And then you have, say, a British model where really the only clear trajectory for becoming fully qualified in doing mindfulness based cognitive therapy is to do a full masters degree in mindfulness based cognitive therapy. So you have someone who may be a clinical psychologist, may already have done an undergraduate degree and then a four year doctorate of psychology, have post graduate qualifications but in a sense they are not going to be viewed as being able to deliver mindfulness based cognitive therapy until they have invested in doing a full masters on top of that. And there’s so a real problem with this in The United Kingdom because if you talk to people there who are trying to just get the intervention going in The United Kingdom and get it available to people and they say the problem is the training is like a Jedi model. You know, by the time you are ready act, by the time you are ready to do this, you are just about short of being able to walk through walls.
And so in contrast to which, what we are exploring and exactly how it is, you know, exactly how is what will work out as the best. I mean, we’ve done a number of training courses and we invite people to take part in a version of the eight week group that is somewhat adapted. We do an intensive four day retreat which is very much we then encourage people to keep a meditation practice up for a couple of months to come and to take part in maybe a day retreat. We encourage people to come on a residential retreat. We do an intensive four day training which includes a lot of coaching and role playing of the exercises and then actually the rest of our trajectory is again encouraging people probably for the rest of the year to go on with the meditation practice to do a group shared with someone and then with an experienced practitioner then to do a group under videotape supervision.
So we reckon probably in about a year, some people will get there. Some of the people who and then we can look at their videotape group and decide whether we feel that they are really meeting the fidelity criteria. Some people, of course, have extensive backgrounds in meditation. But one of the interesting things about this is that when you specify an extensive background in meditation, you of course don’t know what on earth people have done, you know, the range of things that you had. When I first went to training this, which I did with Zindel Segal and others in North America, maybe ten years ago now, it certainly although been in Tibetan Buddhism and around the Gelug tradition for a lot of years, it certainly introduced me to some very different meditation techniques.
Some of the things that I led yesterday were kind of quite different from things that I would have encountered before in what was a relatively extensive exposure to meditation. When we went and did the training up in the Hudson Valley, it was quite clear that there were people from a whole range of backgrounds. There were Christian contemplatives, were Yoga, people from Yoga, people from different Buddhist traditions. So I actually think there is an argument in introducing people to the techniques and then supporting them and deepening their practice, which may be more economical because at least then they are deepening their practice in the context of knowing what the particular meditations are that you want them to be able to lead in the course of this. And the experience is that there are some people who have got strong meditation backgrounds who make very quick progress.
Some people who have strong meditation backgrounds who make rather slower progress and who may still have some difficulty or obstacle. There are a few people who don’t have very strong meditative backgrounds that just make really rapid progress in a way that is quite surprising. There are some people that just get it, even if they haven’t meditated. And I think there’s a comparison. I find myself often when I’m doing talks about mindfulness, drawing on Michael Leunig’s cartoons.
This one is very much about capturing the idea of the way that people with multiple prior episodes, or at least I use it, capturing the idea that people with multiple prior episodes of depression will just torment themselves with ruminations about things. You know, this ought to be fun, but, you know, oh, what’s he going through, you know, as he’s trying to execute this. This one, I just I’m very fond of it. Oh my goodness. It’s so beautiful.
Just a tiny piece of gravel and a brick, but it’s so perfect. It catches the light. It glistens. It gleams. I see heavenly colors.
My head swims. My vision blurs. I see the universe. Everything makes sense. It’s magical, wonderful, it’s beautiful.
And you see where the character is. I know Michael Leunig. He lives locally to us in Melbourne. And assume everyone Michael Leunig is not just a Melbourne person. If people know who Michael Leunig is, think.
Yeah. And he is. He’s a wonderful guy, very gentle, unassuming guy. I know him quite well and he was one of the speakers at the conference that we did in March in Melbourne, which I sort of was convener for. He’s not a meditator by background.
He’s actually starting to do some meditation. He’s coming along to some mindfulness days that Doctor. Nacho is running over in Melbourne now. But he’s not a meditator. He grew up in a rural environment with a connected sense of presence in the world.
And yet I think his ability to evoke and to kind of portray things that are very close to mindfulness is I think extremely powerful. There’s a number of other ones that you can dilute. And that comes from his rural background, his artistic observation, his focus which I suppose is a kind of single or a kind of a kind of mental focus on things that he needs to hold for his art. And I also feel, my experience is that some of the people, I’m developing a theory that some of the people that come into the training with us and make very quick progress, I actually think have a, to me, one of the things that goes with most of them is that I think that they are actually good people. And I think that these are people who may be from a different cultural background, from a spiritual or religious background, or just from a strong moral grounding.
They just have a life long presence of awareness in action and ethics and of the effect on others and of noticing. And that is a kind of mindfulness, you know, a practice of ethics which may not have been accompanied necessarily with a formal meditation practice, nonetheless, seems to me to be something that sits behind some people who then make very rapid progress with meditations. In a sense, it maps a little bit, Ilya, to some of what you were talking about I think and some of what was the sense I got when got to know you in 2006 at Sera the Gelug tradition works. That the young monks spend so much time studying. Study, study, study, study, study, they don’t do much meditating.
But when they actually sit, they make dramatic progress because they’ve got they know you know, there’s things that they know about what they should be doing. And I think that and maybe there’s kind of purification that have gone on. You know, I think and they haven’t got too much negative karmic baggage or whatever we might regard as the analogue of that. So I think there is an issue for me about, you know, because in terms of measuring mindfulness, we’re thinking about how do we prepare people, how do we decide whether instructors are ready and how do we because that’s an important issue at the moment in terms of how we are disseminating the techniques. My impression is that what we are doing works quite well but only a fraction of people will come through and come out the end of it actually competent and able to do it.
But I think the ones who, the coaching is tight that the ones who aren’t really ready know it. But anyway, that could be a whole other discussion about how we prepare things. How we prepare people for the practice. What we, of course, have with that J curve of mindfulness papers going on is more and more people who are wanting to work out how to measure mindfulness and how to do it. And, you know, you have people trying to look at mediation analyses in psychological treatments and say, was a change in mindfulness necessary in order to produce a change in the outcome of depression?
Which of course means that, you know, can you measure depression? Well, you kind of can. But can you measure mindfulness? Well, it is this very complex mixed entity, but or set of skills. But one of the but there are things that can be measured in relation to some of the aspects of it at least and in terms of the stabilization of attention stages in the sense of Samadhi.
This is a Necker cube. Who’s familiar with the Necker cube? Anyone seen these before? Yeah. And if you what’s happening to that as you look at it?
Is it one stable image or is it moving? It’s moving. How is it moving or changing? Yeah. Okay.
And the here’s another one. Yeah. Now let’s let me let’s try something. How many, if you are seeing that, first of all who is seeing that clearly moving in one or other direction? Is anyone seeing it moving in both directions simultaneously?
Okay. So can I I’m going to ask you to try something? If you’re seeing it, it can be rolling away like a tire rolling away from you or it can be rolling that way like a tire coming towards you or it can be kind of doing both, can’t it? It can be like a snowstorm. Is anyone seeing it not moving at all?
Okay, no. So everyone has either got it, it’s either moving one way or it’s moving the other way or it’s going both. Can I just sorry? Going in and going out. Okay.
Can I just try something? If it’s rolling away from you, can you put your hand up? Like that. And if it starts rolling towards you, can you put your hand down? If it’s doing anything else, can you put your hand in the middle?
And just keep let’s just keep bearing it. If it changes, just change and just look at it. Let’s call that in the middle. Okay. Thank you.
Any comments on that experience for people? Does anyone find it frustrating, interesting, intriguing? How do you find that image? Okay. You can control it.
Okay. Okay. Let me just try and do something now. Let me just invite us to do a brief meditation, and we’re just gonna revisit the three minute breathing space. So just settling ourselves into a comfortable position, settling our awareness into the body as it sits here and just paying attention to whatever else is happening for us now.
Whatever is going on, whatever is presenting itself to our awareness, thoughts, feelings, sensations, whatever there is to notice. And then from this, just bringing the attention gently to the breath. Perhaps the rise and fall of the abdomen. If the attention wanders, just gently, in a kindly way, return the attention to here and now, the breath, and breathing. And then let me invite you just to expand the awareness to the body sitting here.
Reoccupying your physical self, reconnecting with your physical presence. What I’m now gonna do is to invite you just in you reset in a sense from that, just having perhaps just calmed and settled our mind streams a little bit to return to the figure, return to the image. And this time in a purposefully way, in a purposely mindful way, pay attention to it. So just take this as the object of attention in a mindful way. And then I’d like you to again repeat the exercise of saying which way it’s moving.
So just when you’re ready, place your hand in the position either up if it’s rolling away from you, down if it’s rolling towards, or that way if it’s doing something else. Does anyone have a sense of a difference between the two exposures to it? What did you find? Okay. And it’s just staying there.
It’s not it’s not switching. Okay. Others? Other observations? Okay.
And was it was that changing? Was it flipping? Okay. Any other? Just loads of loads of stuff going around.
Okay. Right. Okay. Would you say, of the two exercises, in which one did it flip more? First or second?
First? So it flipped more in first. Did it flip more for anyone in second? Okay. That’s interesting.
There’s a few. The overall, I mean one of the things that is an approach that’s being explored is to looking at ways that we might I’ll come back to One of the ways that’s being explored of measuring stability of attention, which has been done by Jack Pettigrew, who is the guy at the top left who is a physiologist at the University of Queensland who does a lot of work on birds and Alva Noë who is at Harvard. They actually took exercises like this to Tibet and they took them to, this is Jack doing some of his field work looking at experienced meditators. The exercise had been done with people with different levels of experience. What is generally found is that first of all experienced meditators will, with tasks either like flipping of the Necker cube or with this kind of task, first of all more experienced meditators will tend to have a slower flip rate or slower switch rate than people who are less experienced.
And also that people will tend to have greater stability if they are in a purposive way paying mindful attention to it. So this is one area which I think it would be interesting. We are looking constantly for working we in the mindfulness area and we are exploring what are the things that we could do to actually try and do relatively quick and compact ways of assessing things like stability of attention and the like. And this is certainly an interesting candidate, not least because it’s the kind of thing that you could set up fairly readily online and so that you could actually invite people to take part. So that’s one promising way.
The idea of perceptual rivalry, is obviously what this is exploring, where you have different interpretations of the same image, of course, is something that is commonly encountered in art. We’ve already seen a bit of Salvador Dali earlier in this conference, I think. Was that a Dali or was it? Yes, it was a Dali. There’s one or two others it could have been, but it was a Dali.
This is a Dali painting titled The Bust of Voltaire. Can you tell me when you can you put your hand up when you see The Bust of Voltaire? Where’s where’s the bust? Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. It’s interesting. I don’t know about you. The more the more I look at it, the more that image becomes really concrete. I now I now can’t look at it without seeing that image immediately.
And in fact, each time I look at it, it becomes more solid and clear. And I actually now find it quite difficult to reconstitute the image which went before it, which initially I didn’t see. So this is another example of how with ambiguous mental images we have a task of stabilizing them. This could be argued to be another one, the famous enigmatic expression of the Mona Lisa. There are different ways in which one can read that expression very famously.
So one approach, there’s one facet, at least one component of mindfulness, which is to say the stability of attention which can be measured potentially with particular perceptual tasks. One of the things, of course, that’s happened with mindfulness, one of the things that has given its huge boost in recent years, or the last decade or two, has been the massive expansion in imaging and neurophysiological studies. It is a strange kind of materialist, it’s a reflection of the strongly sort of materialist, physicalist nature of our society that you can clearly demonstrate psychological terms differences in attention, in mindfulness, in well-being, in experience and things like this and get clear accounts of them. But you have deep skepticism in the communities, in many of the communities. But if you actually show a scan where you’ve got a brain, what looks like a bit of a brain lighting up in some particular, all of a sudden, you know, I mean, Matthew Ricard stuck in a scanner and the happiest man in the world now has the happiest little bits of brightly lit brain in the world and all of a sudden everybody goes crazy about it, which I think is a little bit of a mixed blessing I think.
But it is anyway what’s happened. Now of course, what has emerged with progressive the development of imaging and other approaches to neurophysiology is that there were various conceptions that we really would expect specific functions to be located in particular areas of the brain. This goes back to phrenological notions. But also I grew up in Britain with the Beano which had this cartoon series called the numbskulls. Does anyone remember the numbskulls?
Am I completely alone in remembering them? There were one or two nods. Don’t suppose the Numb Skulls got to Australia. I think they were English kind of 1950s and 1960s kind of stuff. But here we’ve got the brain department, the eye department, the ear department, nose department and mouth department.
So there are notions of localization which however haven’t really stood, have stood and clearly there are areas of the brain, Broca’s area and the like, if you ablate them you will get serious damage to speech centers or the like. And there are things that happen if destroy frontal lobes and the like. So there is a degree of localization. But there is also much more of a there has been a shift in more recent years from localization of function to much more looking at networks across the brain. One of the things that has changed is that for many years a lot of the early work on things like functional magnetic resonance imagery which gives us blood flow, us measures of different kinds of blood flow activation for instance in the brain.
That you have a situation where for a long time, basically what people looked at was task performance in the machine. They put people in the machine and they asked people to do something while they were in the machine. It was what they were doing while they were doing the task that was interesting. It took a while for anybody to get really interested in what happened between the tasks while people were, as it were, resting and not being asked to do anything specific. What emerged from that is what is now a very influential concept called the default mode network, which is a set of brain areas because we’ve moved in a sense from an interest in a sense that you would expect that with any one activity, you would just get one part of the brain lighting up to or increasing blood flow.
So more of a sense that you tend to get networks where there’s multiple areas that actually tend to activate together. And there’s a range of cortical and cingulate areas which are called the default mode network, which activate. But an interesting thing about that is that they are is that if you try and relate that to the tasks that also activate those networks that are specific tasks, so the things that you ask them to do, they are the kind of things that represent self reference. So for instance, if you ask someone to look at a house and then you ask them to look at a house and imagine it as their house and imagine it as them doing things in this house, then that second one has a set of areas which become more active compared to the first one. And those areas are the same areas that are active in the default mode.
So that what people tend to do, at least when they are stuck in these rather big scanners, but the best evidence we have is you just invite people to quietly be at repose and not do anything particular, then most people are just musing about themselves. And so what you have is this negative, is self referential thinking. They are people thinking about themselves and including in their relationship to others, but they are diffusely and gently preoccupied with their own self image. We are most of us habitually narcissistic. Unless we are meditators.
Because actually what happens if you look at, there’s another mode which is called the executive function which is much more focused, which is much more associated with specific task oriented activity. And so it’s much more the kind of node mode that is active when someone is deliberately setting out to perform a specific task according to a rule set. And this is actually much more regularly activated rest among experienced meditators. So you can both activate the executive control network if you ask someone to meditate, but also longtime meditators tend to have greater activation of this and they have less activation typically of that default mode network. So in terms of trying to measure and quantify this, we’ve got something else which is starting to pick up a different kind of change through imaging in relation to what, in relation to demonstrating how our habitual modes of thinking can be changed by, or certainly how our habitual modes of brain function can be changed by Lojong meditation.
Now another thing that is emerging that is starting to become a bit of a focus and there is a lot of this very high technology work going on. But there has recently been a focus back on something which actually can be assessed and measured in much more basic terms. If you vagus nerve, the parasympathetic nervous system, sympathetic nervous system very much about fight and flight, largely spinally mediated, the vagus nerve, the tenth cranial nerve comes out of low down in the skull and is actually more associated with feeding, sometimes with sexual arousal but with much more about repose, much more than the fight and flight system of the sympathetic nervous system. And there are some quite simple ways in which you can actually measure vagal function. Anyone know how to take your pulse?
Can you just take your own pulse for a minute and just notice your pulse as your breathing is moving. You may already be familiar with how your pulse varies according to your breathing. But just noticing as you are breathing in, what happens to your pulse rate. And then as you’re breathing out. What do people notice?
Does anyone have no difference, no change with Not really? And then does anyone have a marked difference? What were you finding? Well, that’s interesting. There’s a couple of things.
Firstly, this does tend to change with age. It’s often actually the case that sinus arrhythmia, which is what that is, is present somewhat more in people who are little younger and less in people who are slightly less young. But it’s also the case, it’s a measure of vagus function that if you have a marked sinus arrhythmia, you’ve got a high vagal tone. Interestingly, particularly compassion meditation is increasingly being recognized as being associated with a higher vagal tone. Not so much mindfulness meditation but compassion meditation.
Mindfulness a little lesser. Well if your vagal tone is high, which is to say the parts, there is a lot of firing, the vagus nerve which is largely, which means that you are more preparing, your body systems are being geared up more for digestion and repose than fight or flight. And so that arrhythmia, that would be more pronounced. Sorry, yes, the uneven. If it’s if you have, yes, well that is quite that reflects that probably reflects that that will reflect the fact that your vagal tone is not especially high.
If you got a higher vagal tone, you will be you will have a greater variation because of with the breathing. So that as you’re talking about yeah, you breathe in, it will speed up and as you breathe out, it will slow down. And that’s direct measure of vagal tone which is one of the effects of particularly prolonged compassion meditation. So you might Faster when in. Faster when you’re breathing in.
Then it slows down when you’re breathing out. If you want to if you hold it, if you really want to slow it down, then you hold your breath against a closed, you know force, you sort of press the breath to come out but don’t let it come out. You’re holding it against a closed glottis. And that’s a Valsalva maneuver which will slow it right down, which is a classic way of forcibly pushing vagal function up. It’s one of the physiological changes that you might explore perhaps if you’ve been doing a more prolonged meditation or the like that you might actually explore whether or not you can pick up whether your vagal tone is changing.
This is something that’s happening and there’s now there’s some more subtle work going on about activation of particular genes in relation to compassion meditation. But some of that may mediated by shifts in a way that shifts in physiological shifts in things like vagus function. So we’ve talked a little bit about different physiological changes and a little bit experientially of how you can look at mindfulness and other features of meditation being measured. But one of the other things that you can do in relation to looking at meditation and mindfulness experiences, ask people. And there’s a huge, there’s a very substantial kind of industry in psychology now getting involved in being able to, in doing measurement of measurement of aspects of what’s getting called mindfulness.
And what happened with this is that during the early part of the last decade, the early 2000s, there were a number of late 90s and early 2000s, there were quite a lot of questionnaires developed that were intended to measure mindfulness. They were developed from a range of sources. Some of them were developed from people going on retreats that hadn’t been on much. Some of them were developed from people taking meditation courses. Some of them were developed from questions to advanced meditators about how they described experience.
So by about thousand and three-two thousand and four, you had a series of different things. There was one from Toronto, one from Kentucky. There were various places that these things had been developed. And what a group led by Ruth Baer did, and Ruth Baer is an author who has written an enormous amount and done a lot of good review papers on mindfulness based interventions, is they took all the items from all the different scales that existed at the time, pooled them all together into one great big battery of questions and then asked them of a large number of people, 500 or 600 people. They largely students, but they and the work has not yet been done in more generalized samples.
But the work that they’ve done has actually been enormously influential. And they did what psychologists do with this kind of thing, which is they got this huge pool of items and then they ran a factor analysis on it which picked out the items that tend habitually to run together and the items that tend not so. And so they went through the process of psychometrically isolating in a sense what are the items that run together. And they came up with what’s become the five facet mindfulness questionnaire. Now what so they have got these five facets and I’ll go through these and invite you to sort of read them and reflect on them a bit.
Because these are basically the range of items that came up in factor one, which they commented on as non reactive to inner experience. Back to two, observing, noticing, attending to sensations, perceptions, thoughts or feelings. I’ll carry on through them and I’m actually going do two cycles through this because I will go on through them and invite you to just spend a bit of time reflecting on them. And then what I actually want to do with this is I would like to have a discussion about how these different factors might map to to some of the Buddhist concepts. Because quite a lot of the people who were part of the original item pools had had a degree of, as well as being doing meditation, had a degree of exposure to other aspects of Buddhist philosophy.
So in a sense, what one was doing was in a sense sampling strings, words, sentences from them that reflected their experience guided by their training and their teachings of the experience of meditation. It wouldn’t be kind of surprising if through a rather convoluted route you extracted some themes or some baskets, some collections of Buddhist teaching. And when we go through this a second time, it would be good if I could share some thoughts as to whether you can make any connections there. Anyone finding this one rather similar to the previous one? But any difference?
This one is a bit more about attention in action too, isn’t it? It’s a bit more about I think it’s a bit more about doing things. The other one was a bit more about in repose. A high score on this is being pretty damn tough with yourself, isn’t it really? It’s a very self critical thing.
The scale on this, the actual questionnaire, the five facet mindfulness questionnaire, didn’t include all of these items. It just abstracted it. If you are interested, it’s extremely easy to find on the web and there are a number of implementations on it where you can go and score yourself. And basically, you score yourself on each item from strongly disagree to strongly agree and then it will give you an overall and some of them are reverse scores and they will give you an overall score on the different facets out of five. So you can go along and find out how mindful you are.
I suppose there’s are they telling themselves they shouldn’t? Well, okay. That’s interesting. Yeah. Now when I had a go at doing a map of this, when I had a go at trying to think about for this, particularly for this one, this relates to this issue that I must admit I’ve had that I think that there is a way that it feels to me like when we have a situation as we do have that although we don’t explicitly include things like loving kindness meditation in the way in which mindfulness is communicated, there is nonetheless clearly an expectation that the instructor will model a compassionate and self compassionate attitude with how you respond to things.
So that although the overt and there is this question if you go back to those western definitions about accepting things in a non judgmental about non judgmental and accepting that actually what you’re modeling is something which is a kind of gentle and kindly self compassionate approach. So I was wondering really when I was trying to do some mapping whether I would find much of what was in the five classic mindfulness questionnaires in some of the trainings about shamatha. Actually, didn’t much, really. I think that if one thinks about the kind of nine stages, really in the course of a mindfulness based cognitive therapy course, I think, you know, it’s that, well, you know, there’s probably occasionally someone who gets up about four. Most of the time, you’re working in the kind of two to three range in that context.
You’re not now what is a real question is whether people who then go away and maybe meditate for years, as some do, because some succeed in establishing practices and then go away and meditate for years, quite where they might be getting. And I think one of the things that is a really important piece of future work for us in this area is looking at how we support people and how we support the challenges that people might come across if they continue meditation practices after two, three, four years. But I had a look in this and whether I could find bits of text that were very much related to the five facets and didn’t do very well. But I’ve had a go with some of the others. But first of all, me ask for other people’s impression.
What kind of teachings would you say, what kind of teachings would this relate to for anyone in the group? Okay. I wonder how that this is what it conjured up for me was patience. It just made a lot of it kind of resonated with texts from the Bodhisattvacharyavatara. And it felt to me like most of these things were some of the things were conjured up in that.
I mean, you know, particularly yeah. Does that make sense? Sure. Okay. Okay.
Okay. Okay. Sorry? Okay. Okay.
Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. Next one.
What does this one, where would people go with this one? And which particular aspect of the Satipatthana? Yep. Okay. So this one is a kind of this one is more of a pure, in a sense, pure mindfulness one without so much in the way of other From a different origin, this picked up to me with Shantideva’s chapter on guarding alertness, but I think is that much the same sort of origin and context?
So this one. I break or spill things because of carelessness, not paying attention or thinking of something else. Find it difficult to stay focused on what’s happening in the present. It seems I’m running on automatic without much awareness of what I’m doing. I rush through activities without being really attentive to them.
I get so focused on the goal I want to achieve that I lose touch with what I’m doing right now to get there. I do jobs or tasks automatically without being aware of what I’m doing. I find myself listening to someone with one ear doing something else at the same time. I drive places on automatic pilot then wonder why I get there. I find myself preoccupied with the future or the past.
I find myself doing things without paying attention. I snack without being aware that I eat I’m eating. I get easily lost in my thoughts and feelings. When I do things, my mind wanders off and I’m easily distracted. I repeat of a drive one in similar texts.
I don’t pay attention to what I’m doing because I’m daydreaming, worry or otherwise distracted. When I’m doing chores such as cleaning or laundry, tend to daydream or think of other things. I tend to do several things at once rather than focusing on one thing at a time. When I’m working on something, part of my mind is occupied with other things such as what I’ll be doing later or things I’d rather be doing. It’s easy for me to concentrate on what I’m doing.
I’m easily distracted. I’m able to pay close attention. Thoughts or comments? Yep. Okay.
How did I get? I wondered if this would again be sort of cultivated by meditation practice, which I guess it would in that context. So now this one is describing labeling with words, which is kind of what’s people’s thoughts about that one? Sir? Okay.
Can you can you tell us a bit more about that? Okay. Reasoning. This is very much about expressing, about describing your own internal mental content, isn’t it? I mean, I any so but yes?
Sorry? Debating. Okay. Interesting thought. Okay.
Other thoughts? I mean where this took me a bit was that part of this sounded a little bit like more analytic meditation and I’m familiar with the idea that in kind of recognizing hindrances to meditation, one might label what the particular distraction is before you then bring it back. But I must admit, had a bit of difficulty with this one. It’s interesting because it’s one of the ones that actually in mindfulness based cognitive therapy at least, we don’t really explicitly do very much. We don’t directly teach people to put words onto things.
We teach we invite them to build up their or at actually, I thought we didn’t until someone reminded me, of course, that actually what we do in MBCT. And one the things that we do in MBCT, is, and these courses which is different from most of the Buddhist teachings I’ve been to, not all, most, is that we give people written homework to do. And some of that written homework, for instance, is that we invite people to go away and to notice, you know, for instance, first week’s part of the first week’s homework is to take a particular task that you do each day and to pay it mindful attention and then to write down your experience of that including writing it down in three columns which are about thoughts, feelings and bodily sensations. So actually although we don’t and then of course what we do is at some point in each subsequent session, we debrief on that. So that is actually an exercise that although we don’t specifically say in your meditation put words on this.
We actually do, in effect, ask people to go through an exercise which does involve them doing that. It’s just it’s writing rather than actually rather than talking. But any other thoughts about I had a bit more difficulty with this. What other ideas have we got about where that might fit? So that is well, which again, that goes a little bit to the idea exploring the nature of self.
Is there anything there anything in what we’ve seen so far that wasn’t in the Satipatthana as far as you’ve seen? Or does it all fit there? I mean the Satipatthana has got a lot of stuff in it. Okay. Okay.
Okay. This what’s thoughts on this one? Thoughts or comments on this one? Sorry? The evening review.
How do you sorry I didn’t Right. It reminds you of an evening review after not a very good day. Just a normal day. So, yeah, I mean, any other but okay, in terms of I mean, I this looks to me like a kind of low level of self compassion. There’s actually one of the things that’s been emerging in our mindfulness literature is that while these are the five facets that were done based on the instrumentation that was available up to about 2005, there’s been a bit more of an emphasis on self compassion.
There’s another scale which I haven’t got here, which is the self compassion scale. And which is emerging as potentially one of the stronger mediators as well as these specific elements. But this I don’t know what you think, but this seemed to me to be a kind of bottom part of the scale if you were extremely non compassionate to yourself. I mean, if you were reasonably compassionate to yourself, you’d score rather low on this stuff. And because this is really very intense, this is all a lot of this is very intensely self critical stuff.
John? Interesting. Yeah. It’s Yeah. Well, that you’ve actually quite nicely summarized up the classical process of cognitive behavior therapy for depression.
And what you’re describing is if you’ve got someone who’s got a major depressive disorder will have lots and lots of thoughts like this and you’re quite right that there is a very demonstrative, that it’s highly effective in depression to do that. That if you do uncover people’s, if you do uncover those thoughts and then encourage people to debate and discuss them, that that can be highly effective. But actually of course what the mindfulness based approach does is it actually takes well the mindfulness based approach in the management of depression invites people to add something else at least to their repertoire with that, which is simply to notice the thought arising and then to let it pass by like clouds floating by in the sky, like sticks passing by in the stream. So you’re quite right that it would absolutely be the traditional response of a clinical psychologist to do exactly what you’re describing. Yeah.
Yeah, I think so too. Look I think that first of all, picking up on what we said earlier, the conventional psychological technique about basically arguing, if we treat this as a set of negative automatic thoughts, conventional CBT would teach someone to, if they had a thought like this, they would say, ah, that’s a negative automatic thought. I will now rate my level of belief in this thought and I will say I think I believe that at 80%. I will now have a discussion with myself about whether I think that is actually valid or not. I will try and present myself with some counter arguments and I will try and reconsider that and I will have a little debate with myself.
And then at the end of the will re rate this and I will re rate it and I will find that it’s now gone down to 45%. It’s a kind of conventional of way of responding to NATS in this context. I get a bit sense of that mindfulness based approach to this, which would be more about with a cultivated metacognition, being aware of the contents of your consciousness, being aware that you had a vulnerability and a tendency to do that. And so I think in a quite positive way I think, is that you kind of are aware that some of the times you are a bit silly, you know, and that you really can tend to make a lot of trouble for yourself by just kind of rabbiting on like, you know, in a negative way. And so you notice it arising and you think, here I go again.
Okay. Let it go. Attention back to what I’m doing. You know, I don’t think that’s so bad. And John?
Yeah. Look I think so and in a sense that’s one of the ways to I think that’s very powerful. It’s one of the ways to do that is that it in a sense aligns with the CBT technique because in a sense it is a way of challenging the thought, particularly by the exception. You can point out that you can have a sense like this. I tell myself I shouldn’t be thinking the way I’m thinking.
Well, do I do that all the time? Well, no, actually there was this time when there was just that lovely sunrise and that’s how I felt. So actually that’s not there all the time. It’s not the whole story, to quote Rubina, who came up earlier. We’ve got some wonderful cartoonists in this country actually.
Judy Horacek, I think, does a nice job on some stuff and I think as we talked about Michael Lunig before. So I think that it’s what there is a part of Buddhist teachings though which as I have alluded to at the start was missing from all of that which is compassion to others. The whole all of it is about me. You know? All of it.
It’s all about what’s going on in my mind. There’s nothing there that is about goodwill to others. Others. I think that the idea of I you know, idea of I think there is a couple of things that are very much missing. One is the compassion side, but the other is, as you say, that or going in any great distance towards that idea of a non inherently existent self.
I think that sometimes in groups, with some groups that are moving quite quickly, you will get to some, you may get to discuss some of those issues. But one of the things about it, I think, is that one of the things about the whole mindfulness, the work with mindfulness at the moment dominated by interventions short and it’s particularly in terms of a lot of the empirical work. To set the context, ACT, which was just mentioned, is typically an individual based therapy which has a number of planks, one of which is said to be mindfulness. But actually it tends not to use mindfulness in the way that we’ve been talking about here or the way that NBCT does. It doesn’t teach people to meditate or invite them formally to take up a meditation practice.
It rather uses a series of exercises in the session which are intended to promote a more mindful way of being. I’m not an expert on that. I’m not trained in it. And it actually doesn’t intuitively draw me because I favor very much techniques that encourage people to self autonomous and develop their own self caring skills, which is one of the reasons why I like some of aspects of what’s going on in MBCT. But the literature is dominated by relatively short term courses and it’s also limited by relatively short term courses without very much extensive follow-up.
I think that one of the things about that would be that if you start introducing that idea of a non inherently existent self, as we all know, there are many dangers in that. And unless you have got many pitfalls and many ways that you can go wildly wrong and sometimes spectacularly dangerously wrong with that kind of thing. So if you gave if you took people and put eight weeks and just gave them a whiff of that and then closed and then that was it, I think you could be doing a lot more harm than good. But because really, you know, I think to pursue that path requires a much longer and probably more intensively supported thing. And probably, you know, you probably then I mean, know, also then would need a much more complex support structure in terms of the instructors who would need to know about they’d need to be informed about the different problems that can occur as people explore the philosophy of emptiness and dependent origination and the ways that that can go wrong with people and how to help them come out.
And I’ve seen this as I was talking to you about that, I’ve seen this with some longtime practitioners who have been introduced to the practice through work with MBCT and MBSR that they will start uncovering these kinds of issues and start getting involved. I had an interaction with one instructor who as far as I could see had fallen deeply into a nihilistic fallacy and had just become utterly despondent as a result. And the training structure didn’t have people in it who could help pick up pieces out of that. She herself got into quite a bit of trouble. And so I think that if one started working with those aspects of the teachings, you would need to set up a whole different support structure.
So I think at the moment, the system is designed to not go there because it’s not geared up, which does reflect very much this issue. But it is something with much more limited aims. Because, I mean, John, I hear what you were saying to return to your comment about the fact that the last of the factors looks like the kind of thing that you would say the system wasn’t built for. And I think you are absolutely right. Certainly someone who already had that, someone whose thinking was dominated by those kind of negative thoughts, you probably wouldn’t say, right, we’re going to do the next session in the cemetery.
You know? Let’s do death and impermanence today. You know, I think that yeah, you’re right. Sorry? Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Well, that’s right. You know, you might come back with one or two fewer members of the group that you went in with, might you? That’s right. And I think that So what you then have is you do have this context that actually what say MBCT/MBSR has got is it is, you know, although it does require a certain discipline, is also very, very staged. It’s very, very graded.
It’s the Raisin exercise, it’s a quite highly structured body scan to begin with and then it moves into breath, body, sounds, thoughts, choices, awareness but really with just a few minutes on each one. And so it’s really quite, you know, I think that if you look at the, you know, I say, if you looked at the kind of stages of Shamatha, it’s probably designed at most I don’t think it’s really a system that is designed to get anyone further than at most probably stage four. And it is now and it’s not really then intended to be leading people into places where they might get involved in needing to deal with the consequences of some of the disturbing aspects of teachings on emptiness, for instance. So I think you are right that that group of people wouldn’t be in a position to take on the fuller aspect of the path. Yeah.
Look, I absolutely agree. I think there’s a risk. I think that probably the reassuring thing in a way is that I think that the number of people that go on doing a sufficiently prolonged formal meditation to get themselves into that kind of problem is relatively small. I think what you have more of is people maybe doing a little bit of formal meditation or none, but taking a degree of mindfulness into their daily lives and maybe using a three minute breathing space. Actually, I think they do get some benefit from many of them.
For instance, we’re quite clear that the data that we’ve got is showing that the people did there’s about a twenty percent absolute risk reduction in days in depression. There was people in our control group spent one hundred and twenty days in a major depressive episode over the course of the next two years. People in the experimental group spent about sixty days. So they spent about half the time, about three months, you know, a couple of months less time in a major depressive episode gained over a couple of years, which is about as much difference as you get with antidepressants. You know, we are getting and there was a suicide in the control group.
So I think that it does seem, including in our hands here, it does seem to produce some positive effects. Look, it was interesting. We were talking over lunch and I think one of the questions is whether or not they do find out about it. And I was actually realizing that I think one of the things that would be interesting to find out is to what extent with their curiosity stimulated by this exposure, people do pursue other avenues. And it occurred to me that actually we got permission from the 200 people that we had in our group to follow them up and it would be interesting to follow-up with people who did MBCT and find out which and how many of them actually pursued perhaps other dharma teachings.
And we just might have a go at that because actually, as I said, we’ve got permission to follow them up and that wouldn’t be hard to do. So I think that the but I think but from my side, thank you very much for that exploration of that. I think it’s given me some thoughts to go away in relation to at least this kind of preliminary mapping of just what’s come out through the western side and what that fits with scripture as well as the other considerations. Thank you. Thank you so much, Graeme.
Let’s just give appreciation of our thanks. So we’ll have a short break and then reconvene for Professor John Powers. And it’s now six minutes past. What’s your suggestion? Fifteen minutes?
Can we manage toilets and drinks in that time? Okay, thank you. Thank you. So that’s about twenty five past.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.