Four Noble Truths – 2013-08-10 – KR

1 h 1 min · 6,879 words · 10 August 2013

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths - 2013-08-10 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The speaker, a psychiatrist, explains the origins and structure of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for preventing relapse in depression and its links to mindfulness-based stress reduction. He leads the three-minute breathing space and an exercise called opening to the difficult, and notes that the approach lacks a direct compassion practice.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 1m

UUID: 2bdad410-ab95-4978-afd7-b0627beca876

Date: 2013-08-10

Words: 6,875

Welcome, everybody, to twenty thirteen Tibetan Buddhist Institute Symposium. It’s lovely to see you here. Special welcome to our guests, Graham, John and Ralph, of course, and Ilya, and to all of you. Thank you, Natalie, for leading us in a lovely meditation this morning. We’ll be having a break shortly, but there are programs dotted around.

If you’re not already aware, taught us through the kitchen. Graham has presented here before in a previous symposium. And thank you so much for coming over from Melbourne. Graham has graduated from medicine in 1980, pursued clinical training in general practice, internal medicine psychiatry in The UK and South Australia. I won’t read his entire bio.

You can see it in the newsletter. I don’t want to take up any more of your time, Graeme. You can speak to your topic. But once again, thank you so much, and I’ll hand over to you. Thank you.

And it’s a great pleasure and honor to be here again. So thanks very much for the invitation to come and join you. And hopefully try and go through an exploration, maybe shed a little bit of a light on a kind of interdisciplinary perspective in terms of trying to make connections between some of the work that we’re doing and the ways that we are applying meditation techniques to helping people with mental health problems and difficulties. This one will include a little bit of I will be leading some of the meditations that are part of the part of the technique that we’ve been working with. And maybe I can I might just map a little bit of the the background to that for people that might not be familiar with it?

Maybe just to get a bit of a sense of it, how many people sort of would know would have a fairly good sense of what mindfulness based cognitive therapy is or isn’t? How many people would have a sense? So a few. Okay. And does anyone lead?

Is anyone an MBCT instructor? Or no. Okay. The so what I will do for those who are not part of it, is I will include a little bit of a summary of what MBCT does. Well, actually, what it does is a very complex question, but where came from and how it’s been created, what it actually does, we’re really still trying to work out.

But this was the abstract that I put together. And I’ll give you a chance if you haven’t already absorbed that. Can people read that? I know it’s fairly small, but I’ll just give you a bit of a chance to read that and absorb what my intent is in this. Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy.

In the late nineteen seventies, Jon Kabat-Zinn started developing mindfulness based stress reduction from the University of Massachusetts. And that was a technique that drew on a lot of his teachings that he’d taken particularly with Thich Nhat Hanh. So quite strongly grounded in a Theravadan Buddhist approach and applying mindfulness in that context to people with mainly with pain or with cancer or a little bit later with HIV. If anyone actually wants a quick introduction to the work that Jon Kabat-Zinn did, if you didn’t know about it, up on YouTube now is the video that Bill Moyers made on the Healing and the Mind series, which for a long time was appallingly difficult to get hold of. It’s very much a kind of nineteen eighties piece of work, very dated now.

But actually, it’s an exquisitely beautiful insight into the work that went on. And Bill Moyers, of course, a very well, Bill Moyers was a very prestigious commentator and that video was a bit of a watershed in that work. Mindfulness based stress reduction acquired quite a bit of well, quite a lot of currency in health care in The United States, particularly in general hospitals, particularly in people. And and it was appealing because it had a high consumer acceptability. People liked it.

And because it could be delivered in large groups, they were often done in groups of 30 or so. And so it actually took off and was often it’s been offered quite widely across The United States. And it it uses a platform of mindfulness based techniques which start which goes through a series of exercises, some of which are more formal meditations, but a lot of which actually are everyday actions which are followed through in a mindful way. And this course was developed, mindfulness based stress reduction, two hours a week, eight sessions, sometimes and not always with a day’s intensive practice in the middle. In the during the nineteen nineties, really early nineteen nineties, a group of psychologists started looking at how you could approach preventing relapse in depression.

And this was a group really led by Zindel Segal at the University of Toronto, also with John Teasdale, Mark Williams. And they embarked on a quest for how you could actually adapt cognitive behavior therapy, which by that time had been shown to have quite a strong effectiveness in helping people can maintain, get out of depressive episodes, so in acute phase treatment. But there wasn’t a very clearly operationalised approach to actually helping people stay well. So what they did was they started exploring possible opportunities for how they could do this. After a while, they realized they wanted to go down the line of a group based therapy for cost effectiveness reasons.

And then they realized that a lot of what they were trying to do in maintenance cognitive behaviour therapy didn’t actually seem to be about, as it were, teaching people the techniques that were necessary in terms of the conventional cognitive behavioural techniques about challenging thoughts and about working on your belief system. It was more about actually having people retain the presence and the ability to apply those techniques when they were hit in trouble. And hence, they started looking for something which would directly leverage and work on the possibility of making people more aware of their own mental content. A process psychologists call metacognition thinking about your thinking, being aware of your thinking and developing habits of being aware of your thinking. And that’s when they made contact with Jon Kabat-Zinn and started on the track that led to mindfulness based cognitive therapy.

And what mindfulness based cognitive therapy really did was it took much of the platform of MBSR and of mindfulness based stress reduction, particularly the aspects of it that are really about the mindfulness training sequence that John had developed. And they then adapted it to the process of attempting to help people stay well out of depression. Now the targets then became a little bit different from the targets of mindfulness based stress reduction. A lot of the primary driver of mindfulness based stress reduction is around the idea that people with pain or with distress have maladaptive avoidant coping styles. That they do not as it were they they try and avoid the suffering and that the avoidance of that suffering is ultimately fruitless, and it comes back worse.

And John, in the video, if you ever watch it, does captures this with a a big former hockey player who had terrible back problems, and he does it by sort of grabbing him by the shirt collar and saying, want you to bring your pain up here and, you know, come in have it come in close to push it away, bring it in. And so that was very much an emphasis of mindfulness based stress reduction. The orientation of mindful ness based cognitive therapy is a little different or at least some of the key things are a little different. One of the things that is very problematic for people who’ve had multiple episodes of depression is rumination or worry, rounds of negative thought. You know?

A lot of a lot of people who’ve had who’ve had negative who’ve had experience of multiple episodes of depressions have very negative underlying senses of self. It’s not uncommon for them to have had traumatic childhood histories. Not always, but it but it’s not uncommon. And there are there is commonly a tendency for them if they experience negative thoughts for those negative thoughts to cascade and become more intense and ultimately potentially retrigger depression. This can be simulated the process can be provoked in the laboratory.

There is now a there’s a standard task which has a task which has become the industry standard for for assisting people to feel rather miserable for a while as an experimental intervention. And there was a whole range of different things that were tried to do this, but ultimately the thing which has become, as it were, the industry standard is that people are invited to recall some negative autobiographical event, some sad event, and and and to reflect on it. And then you play a particular mute piece of music. You actually play a piece by a piece composed by Prokofiev called Russia Under the Mongolian Yoke from the Alexander Nevsky Suite, which listened to which listened to normally as a quite poignant, quite tear jerking piece of music, but then you play it at half speed. So these people are sitting there reflecting on some sad event, and they’re being played played this poignant and rather dirge like piece of music at half speed.

And this will very reliably make people rather miserable for a while. And generally speaking, if you haven’t had multiple prior episodes of depression, you bounce back from that fairly quickly. And if you’re putting if you’re doing questionnaires, recounting your thoughts, you’ll get miserable for a while and then you pick up again. But if you’ve had multiple prior episodes of depression, you’re more likely to go on having prolonged intensive rounds of these thoughts and there is a certain possibility that and and so actually you can demonstrate that people’s rounds of negative thoughts is more prolonged and more intense. And this is then held to be part of the process whereby in response potentially to relatively everyday fluctuations in mood, people who’ve had prior episodes of depression can trigger subsequent episodes of depression which relates to the fact that the more prior episodes of depression you’ve had, the more likely you are to get them again and the sooner you are to get them again.

So if you’ve everybody’s got a lifetime risk of around about twenty five percent or if you go up to having a major depressive episode, if you look at going from a clinical perspective, once people have had one episode, they’ve got at least a fifty percent likelihood of having another. Once they’ve had three, they’ve got about a ninety percent likelihood of having another. And those episodes will tend to occur quite often such that if you look at populations that have been enrolled in studies, it’s often the case that people without further treatment who’ve had at least three prior episodes, about sixty percent of them will have another episode in the first year. So they developed this so that they were really looking at saying can we use a mindfulness based technique to help people avert this the onset of these depressive feelings and these thoughts? And if we can change how people intuitively respond how people how people habitually respond to ruminations, then can we reduce the extent to which they will actually get depressive episodes?

And so they developed this they developed this package of interventions, which was really grounded in the based in the mindfulness based approach, but also then includes a lot of exercises which come out of somewhat conventional cognitive behaviour therapy, but are then adapted in the context of the MBCT setting. And there’s been a number of randomised controlled trials. We’ve run one of them in Melbourne And it’s been shown that it has actually about the same kind of effectiveness as a prophylactic regime as antidepressants do. And we’ve shown that antidepressants and MBCT appear to be additive in their impact. So it’s now getting quite a lot of credence and quite a lot of established evidence behind it.

It features in major guidelines in United Kingdom, for instance, the National Institute of Clinical Excellence has put it into the put in their guidelines for people who have had at least three prior episodes of major depression. They should be offered this. And so it’s actually something which is progressively coming into the mainstream mental health care. And there’s actually quite an established set of practitioners in Adelaide delivering it. Adelaide is probably one of the places where it’s easier than many others to get MBCT.

And it has this structure which has a series of series of session titles. And in the and the exercises are and there’s a whole set of exercises which are used which are about the, about which are the ways in which the mindfulness skills, mindfulness habits are encouraged. As I said, people are by and large introduced to this technique while they’re in remission from depression. It’s very hard to I mean, I I don’t, you know establishing a meditation practice is something that a lot of people find a bit difficult, And it is something which can be quite demoralizing if you don’t, you know, if you are in in the early phases, often you find that you just don’t manage to sit in the morning or you find difficulty making the time or other things distract you. This I’m sure is a common experience.

And so there’s a real risk when you if you try and take people who are currently really depressed, you know, if they’re currently overwhelmed with negative thoughts, if their current sense of self esteem is very poor, if they are currently unable to motivate themselves enough to get to work, to engage socially with people, then that’s a difficult time to start saying, Come along to two hours a week and we’d like you to do forty five minutes of meditation, practice once a day. And there’s a real risk that what happens then is that people just fail and they have a sense that the rest of the group is going on without them and they get demoralized and potentially you can be looking at triggering another depressive episode. So there is some so you really wait until people are well. And what are the exercises? These are structures of this is something of the structure of the content of MBCT.

And it really builds through a series of exercises. Most of the exercises here are really the mindfulness platform. There’s actually quite a few exercises which are more in the CBT realm, which are actually about encouraging people to notice better thoughts, feelings, and bodily sensations in the context of their of of everyday life, and to be more aware of their responses and how those how those things connect. But one of the things that MBCT introduced, which wasn’t part of MBSR, is this thing called the three minute breathing space. And this is a brief meditation which is purposefully intended to make a connection between the more formal practices, which traditionally you might do in the morning but people will find their time, and everyday life.

There are activities that are done, there are things that are done that are particularly homework tasks, as I described in MBCT, are about encouraging people to be more mindful of daily activities. But then in about the middle of the course, the three minute breathing space is introduced and it’s firstly introduced, described as an exercise to be done on a regular basis three times a day. But it’s actually then developed as a coping strategy in that it’s really encouraged that people are encouraged to do the three minute breathing space as an exercise if they’re facing a difficult or stressful situation. And then, a sense, the potentially the worst of the rumination or the negative or the flow of negative self talk temporarily interrupted by the three minute breathing space to make a wise and mindful, skillful choice after it. And so the way that the the exercise is first introduced in session four, and it’s actually it’s interesting that it it’s although when it’s introduced in session four, it is introduced with the instruction that people do it on a regular basis.

It’s actually introduced in the context where immediately before it, there has been an exercise that a lot of people find quite stressful. So what is actually done is that from the very beginning with the way the exercise is introduced, it’s actually modeling the process of going through a stressful event and then doing it even though it’s not actually introduced overtly as a coping strategy, but that’s actually the context in which it’s first done. Because just because about halfway through the early part of session five, you’re going through this thing we call territory of depression, which is actually a review of the diagnostic criteria for major depressive disorder clinically and a review of some negative thought schedules, which a lot of people do find quite provocative as a as a task of reading through these thoughts. It depends a bit how you lead it. You can lead it in a slightly lighter, more playful way where you’re encouraging people to actually, in an inquisitive way, as it were, lighten up.

But quite often, depending but also you can lead it as a more heavy exercise where you immerse where people really do immerse themselves in their experience of depression. So often it’s it not uncommonly, it’s a bit of a stressful exercise. And so one introduces the three minute breathing space at that point and then you also actually model what you are wanting people to do in in their their regular regular kind of context, which is to say that you it’s then followed with something which is in a sense a somewhat pleasant event because what you then do is you you go and read a poem, read Wild Geese by Mary Oliver. And and so actually, you are from from the very beginning, you’re introducing the technique in the way that you’re going to encourage people to use it. So so the three minute breathing space has often been described as being like an hourglass.

But let me invite you to join me in a three minute breathing space. And for this, I’d like to just invite you to take whatever for you is just a comfortable meditation position in the chair that you’re in. Often, this will be you know, the way that we would lead this is often this will be evenly balanced on the chair, often reasonably reasonably erect, often with your feet planted just gently on the floor, probably with your back reasonably erect. You can choose if you like to have a sense of a cord going from your head up to from the top of your head up to the ceiling. But essentially choosing a posture that is comfortable for you.

Now this is obviously a group of people who are well familiar with meditative practice, so you’ll make your own choices. But I’m in a sense doing it in a way that we would do it in clinical group. So just settling yourself into a comfortable meditative posture. So firstly, let me invite you just to pay attention to whatever is happening for you at the moment, whatever is unfolding in your mind, your awareness of your body, awareness of emotions, noticing whatever thoughts you may be having, whatever preoccupations, whatever things you might be thinking about, about what’s gone before or coming after. Just noticing whatever is in your mind, in your awareness here, right now.

From that open attention to whatever’s unfolding for you for you now. Let me now invite you just to bring your attention to the breath. Particularly, you may wish to bring your attention to the abdomen, the belly as it rises and falls. Just noticing the tension on the breath. And if you find your mind wandering, just gently return to the ebb and flow of the breath and breathing.

Now let me invite you to expand your attention from the breath to the whole of your body, reoccupying with your awareness as it were, your physical presence, solidity, stability of this posture, opening your attention to you and your body as it is here now. Can I just ask if anyone has any reflections as we move now from this? Because that’s the end of that practice, just that little three minute sequence. Opening to noticing whatever’s happening here now, bringing the attention to the breath, opening up to a full presence, and then returning, as we will do now, into the current flow of what we’re doing here this morning. And just before we move on in the way that I would in a group, let me just invite if anyone has any comments on that practice.

Familiar, unfamiliar, anything that’s different, interesting, any comments that we might have just on the experience, anything that unfolded for you that you could share with us? Please. Yeah? So helpful to have that helpful to have that that that reminder about the points. Yeah.

Okay. What’s your response to that? Do you have any particular response to the three dings? It’s it’s very often how it how these meditations are led. And I think that I I have my own quite kind of grounded thing.

It it it seem it seems to me that actually why I like to model it and why I find it useful is simply that if you’ve completely lost track of where you are in a self guided meditation, then the first one wakes you up again. The first one basically enables you just to, you know, just reminds you that you’re actually doing a meditation and you’re not compiling the shopping list or worrying about why I’m yesterday. So the first first one wakes you up again or or the first one re alerts you. The second one then enables you to remind yourself of the motivation of what you’re about to do, and the third one is when you reset. So I I personally always use three, and I think it’s a good way to model.

Because if you just use one, it’s actually quite easy for people to you know, if you just have one coming, people aren’t quite sure if they’ve heard it. You know, you can miss it. And so if you just have one, it’s it’s easy to miss. And so you can be left adrift with knowing whether you should go on into whether you should be moving on into the next stage, which is a which is what seems to me to be a good rationale for the three. Any other comments on the exercise?

Okay. The hourglass analogy is because it starts off with a open somewhat spacious awareness, narrows in, focusing on on on the attention on the breath, then opens out again as a prelude to, in a sense, potentially to to making to making an a choice that is less less overwhelmed by what might have been going on beforehand, especially if you are if you’ve got a lot of negative thinking going on. Now the one of the there’s this thing there’s this term that is being used called mindfulness in in Western, you know, that’s that is so widely used and is so widely used in Western psychology. And it’s really going through a whole lot of morphing. I’ll talk a bit more about this tomorrow, but it’s going through a whole lot of changing about what people think it is, how how broad or narrow it is.

And I think that there I think that this is very this is very complex because there really are there there are kind of schools that are trying really to work around schools in psychology that are trying to work around an idea that it is really about attention control, stabilizing attention, focused awareness, and then and that’s all that is mindfulness. And that other things then unfold because of that, but are in a sense consequences of mindfulness rather than mindfulness itself. The exercise, of course, by which mindfulness the initial exercise descriptions by which mindfulness is cultivated can seem simply simple. Let’s just focus our attention on the breath. However, what it’s then followed up with is a whole lot of coaching points in relation to how the meditation is led.

It’s led it’s followed up with instructions about noticing distractions and about responding to those distractions in a gentle way with yourself and about returning your attention. And it may well be followed up with it’s then used in many ways to bring, say, attention in a concentrated and stable way onto things that are difficult or tricky or painful, including pain itself. And the way that you are encouraged to encounter that is something which draws on a whole lot of background, which is more than simply let’s just build our concentration so that we can hold our attention on something for a longer period of time. And the so because after all, you know, these techniques were you know, they really they really have been brought in from Buddhism into modern psychology. And they so they draw on teachings like the draw on a range of teachings.

One of the influences that I think is important at the moment in how we make the bridge between traditional Buddhist teachings and psychology is the is in is in a sense the exploration that are going on around around secular Buddhism and how we can think about re exploring or refinding or looking at Buddhism from the perspective of the modern world. Because of course, one of the challenges for the delivery of clinical interventions is you really have to strip it of any religious paraphernalia. You can’t you you cannot sit in a you know, it’s really tricky to be sitting in a public mental health service and start having Buddha images on the wall or start or start chanting. You know, this is this is really tricky. We have to we have to be very much neutral on faith related terms.

So some of the explorations that can be useful come from this sort of strand of work which is trying to look at Buddhism from Buddhism anew. But also, we have we have the core teachings. We have we have in the background the the four noble truths. Life is life is in its nature unsatisfactory. Our existence here has kinds of suffering associated with it, which are very strongly conditioned by our attitudes, our approach, our ways of responding, and it’s possible to change that, and there are ways to to change that.

We also can draw on teachings such as the five aggregates or skandhas, which can be framed in various ways, but when we are leading meditations, for instance, we may lead a meditation in a way that is conditioned by noticing that there are things that we may notice. There are perceptions and then that we may have a tendency to begin to make a judgement about what the perceptions are and that may lead to the arising of feelings and that may lead to the arising of urges, inclinations to do something which is bound together by by attention. So this may also guide how we lead meditations. I want to before I return to the three minute breathing space and some of the connection on this, I just want to briefly do with you another one of the exercises which I think connects very strongly with the with the way the three minute breathing space works. And it’s an exercise called opening to the difficult.

And so I do want you just before I commence this to start thinking about something that’s a little bit difficult. So the so which is to say something in your life which is a bit stressful, something which is a bit tricky, something which causes you a little bit of concern. What I’m not going to invite you to do is to pick the most difficult thing, the most painful thing, the most challenging thing, the thing that may that that might that might horrify you or disturb you most or that’s most painful to you. Just something that’s a little bit of a struggle, that’s a trouble. So so as per this, you know, just kind of difficult but not more difficult and not kind of terribly ferociously probably screaming your hair out difficult.

But let me ask you for the purposes for the purpose of this, just having in your mind something that is that causes you a bit of trouble. And I’ll go through briefly the exercise that that it of open to the difficult. So, again, setting ourselves into a meditation posture as you’re comfortable. Starting off then with some attention on the breath. Rise and fall of the abdomen.

Now expanding the awareness to the body, our physical presence as we sit here. And then let’s, for just a few moments, explore attention to sound, what we may be noticing in terms of noises in our body, outside our body, in the room, outside the room. But exploring, paying attention to it as bare an awareness as we can muster. Just exploring, noticing perhaps the sensation without the adornments of labeling. And then bringing attention to thought, noticing the arrival of thoughts and thinking in our mind.

Just noticing whatever the mental content is and exploring, allowing it to arise, abide, and pass. And now just inviting our thinking into this space of something that’s a little tricky for us, Something that some situation, some recurring issue or problem, some challenge, something we find a little bit painful. Not terrible. Nothing severe. Nothing that’s very distressing.

Just something that’s a little tricky that causes us some disturbance. Bringing that situation to mind and then seeking to notice as we’re imagining ourselves in that situation, the thoughts, feelings, bodily sensations that might be happening for us, that might be arising as a result of that recollection or imagining or focus. From time to time, perhaps refreshing the object and reminding ourselves of what it is that we’re concentrating on, and then just noticing, attending to what unfolds for us. Noticing thoughts, feelings, body sensations. And just bringing ourselves back into this current space, perhaps, if you like, with a little bit of focus on the breath and breathing for a minute, resetting our attention, returning here into this room as discussion.

Now I led that rather briefly. You usually run the the earlier phases for a few minutes to let people, in a sense, settle into a slightly deeper concentration phase, but a bit of time constraint. But can I again just invite any comments or thoughts on that that experience and that that meditation? Yep. So did you feel that you noticed some was there anything unexpected in what you noticed about how your body was responding?

Mhmm. Mhmm. Any other thoughts or observations on it? I mean, I think that’s very interesting, and part of the exercise is very much about encouraging people to be able to surface and be better aware of the way that bodily responses may intervene in the way that we respond to things and often then affect our behaviour and our thinking without us noticing it. So the simple awareness of that can be very powerful for people being more aware that as we you know, in a sense it’s bringing people into it’s people’s perception so they’re more likely to be aware of the way that emotions are then generating and the way that the body responses are there which gives you a degree of opportunity to intervene mindfully in a way that is more skillful.

Any other thoughts or Locate. So when you were trying to locate the thought or the feeling, it sort of disappears? Okay. Okay. Interesting.

Okay. Okay. Yeah. Well, that and that do you feel that that’s a helpful awareness? Oh, definitely.

Okay. In what sort of way? I think, hopefully, people might be getting a little bit of a sense of how this maps across into the way the three breathing space works. Because the three minute breathing space then, once you’ve taken people through this exercise this is a very important exercise. As I said, it’s done a bit longer.

An extremely important exercise in MBCT. It’s done three times. It’s a long exercise in in sessions five, six, and seven. And it’s it’s really emphasized as as very important. And it very much builds the builds, connects with the three minute breathing space because it means that when people are a bit more familiar with that exercise, they then are better able to notice the range of things.

So when we think of that top of the hourglass of the three minute breathing space, the noticing is enriched by this experience of having having several times explored this exercise of the opening to the difficult. So there is a connection here. There’s and I’ll I’ll move on from that. But what I’ve actually done is I’ve also been this process of inquiry, I’ll just write that for a second. This process of inquiry, which we just went through, is very is part of what you always do after exercises in MBCT.

And it’s quite interesting because in actual fact, you are encouraged as the instructor to explore things in an open, nonjudgmental way and to seek to be curious and to not necessarily reach closure and to be to be accepting and to be allow allow things to arise, abide, and pass away. And so actually as the instructor, what you’re aiming to do is to model the ways that you’re inviting people to respond to cognitions within their own mind and to feelings. That you’re inviting you’re actually setting up a situation where you are modeling the metacognitive awareness which you’re encouraging people to develop. And that’s and and that is very much the case. And it actually works very well in the typical MBCT size of group, which is eight to 12, where usually the kind of a risal of content is not at a furious rate.

It’s usually at about the kind of rate that we just had. So it’s a little bit like the experience of being in your own mind and having thoughts arise and pop up and then responding to them. So part of the process of MBCT is actually in the group modeling the metacognitive mindful awareness, nonjudgmental, gentle, compassionate, self self compassionate acceptance. And compassion is something which I will talk about again a bit tomorrow. It’s the there is a real importance for an instructor in seeking to model a compassionate presence and a warm response to people’s content and to encourage people to respond to their own mental content in a way that is self kindly, that is self compassionate, that is gentle on yourself.

So many of the people you have in MBCT groups who’ve got long histories of struggles with depression are terribly, terribly tough on themselves. They will they will really given, you know, their their their habitual response is always to be contrasting, to be discriminating, to be finding ways to finding the points of devaluing themselves. And you’re really wanting to be gently encouraging people to be more self compassionate. However, there’s a certain resistance to people actually directly invoking loving kindness or compassion and we’ll come to that a bit tomorrow. A set of approaches to the way of bringing the Four Noble Truths into everyday life is an acronym, the ELBA acronym, which I’ve seen which I’ve I’ve certainly seen written up by Stephen Batchelor, though I’m not actually sure whether he developed it in the first instance.

But these these are not the four noble truths one, two, three, four, but they are a set of things in a sense which is about noticing our suffering, our struggle, and whatever is causing it. And the process that is going on and the extent to which we notice it is enriched by the extent to which we’ve developed introspection and constant ready awareness. So in a sense, that’s got elements of the first two truths. And then, an invitation to let go of that and to to bring and to to take control, as it were, of our attention. And then to pause so that one can then act informed by an understanding of the possibility of cessation of suffering and the means to that.

And this, I think, actually maps also quite well to the three breathing space. That in a sense, the three breathing space does encourage us at the start to embrace whatever is happening for us, including aspects of it that may be suffering. And then the breathing encourages us to let go, and and then focusing on the breathing breathing encourages us to let go of that. And then returning to the body and the presence here just allows a pause so that we can may then be able to go on and react in a way that is less conditioned, less driven by what had immediately gone before. And so I think that these all of these teachings, these ways of approaching things, the the Buddhist philosophy sits in the background when you lead something as simple or encourage something as relatively simple looking as the three minute breathing space.

And so I will then I’ve got a a few more minutes for questions. And so I will really just cease and invite you for comments or thoughts on any aspect of what I’ve said. Yes, please. Look. You’ve you’ve invoked a very rich set of teachings.

I think that and and thank you for that. I think that that that there is much subtlety in how these things are done, and there is a real pitfall potentially in in in that you can drop into a model which inadvertently can encourage people to promote rumination. And actually that’s not what you’re trying to do. So there are these exercises that are very much about encouraging people to learn how to respond differently and so not necessarily being analytical in the in the terms of thinking thinking thinking thinking. I mean, I’m talking about it in quite a lot of text here and and, you know, a lot of words, But actually, lot of MBCT is is relatively quiet, and people are encouraged to do to do practices in quiet.

I think that the but I think that one of the areas that is a real challenge is this area of compassion. And I will talk about I will explore that a bit tomorrow because I and I think that it is something that most of the people who have been developing these techniques have been it’s an area they’ve been loath to go to. There’s an idea that as the instructor you are encouraged to communicate a self compassionate attitude but there’s very few that most practitioners go through these exercises and say mindfulness based cognitive therapy doesn’t actually include a direct compassion or loving kindness practice. And I think that may be a profound error. I think that and and we can talk about it tomorrow because I I actually think we probably should be engaging more with encouraging people to do loving kindness meditations.

But as things stand at the moment, it’s not part of the suite of things that have really been developed and that sit within the evidence base. I have to bridge these two worlds. Work in public mental health services, there’s particular ethical constraints on what we have to do and what we have to do has to accord to a certain evidence base. And it is an interesting path to tread. But I certainly think, and as I said I will explore this a bit more tomorrow, there’s that there’s a risk that we don’t balance the mindfulness, which if you’re not careful, can be rather a severe thing with the compassion both to self and others.

Perhaps that would be a conversation that can continue over at morning tea. Unfortunately, we have run out of time now. But thank you so much, Graeme, for kicking off our symposium on meditation. And questions will arise and they can be directed. There will be a panel at the end of the day.

So you can put those to Graeme and others then. So thank you very much. Thank you. And we will be returning. We have a tight program, so 10:30, and Ilya will be speaking.

Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top