Calm Abiding – 2012-10-01 – KR

1 h 58 min · 4,829 words · 1 October 2012

Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding (Khensur Rinpoche)
Calm Abiding - 2012-10-01 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches how to train in calm abiding (shamatha), starting with the five faults (laziness, forgetting the object, agitation and sinking, non-application of antidotes, and misapplication of antidotes) and their antidotes. It then presents the nine mental stages of placement and the six forces (hearing, thinking, recollection, vigilance, enthusiasm, thorough habituation) that lead through them, with a meditation on the Buddha image and a brief question session. It is said to be a continuation of earlier sessions.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 59m

UUID: 7defd88f-3078-45a5-9d66-098821bdc065

Date: 2012-10-01

Words: 4,825

If you want to train your mind in calm abiding, the first step is to memorize the terminology. If you haven’t memorized the terms and you don’t know what they mean, there is no hope to practice. As is said probably in a quote of the great Sakya master of the thirteenth century Sakya Pandita, without hearing, in other words, study, how can there be recollection? Without recollection, how can there be practice? All of us want to attain calm abiding and we actually need to attain calm abiding.

However, once we realize that without the collections or the preconditions for the attainment of calm abiding, the six preconditions, there is no attainment of calm abiding. And once we inspect our own lives at present and see that in our lives at present we do not have them, we will generate the wish to have them. Then here Geshela feels that all of us should be able to take two weeks off, give up our work, give up all connections, retire with those six preconditions, and train in calm abiding. This should be most meaningful. We can see that it is difficult for us to do this now.

However, if we look at Je Tsongkhapa’s works, we can see that Je Tsongkhapa himself gained these realizations through a combination of personal experience and systematic study of the great text, checking his experience against the text. This is what we ourselves should do. Then there are places close to Adelaide such as Kangaroo Island, for instance, where you could go for a two week retreat. Geshe-la has heard that there are retreat centers there. You could do this.

He said that when one is training for calm abiding, one should abandon all worldly activities. Now in India, there is a tradition for the Hindus to give up all worldly affairs for a month or two, including all relations with their wives and while they are living as celibate to train their minds. Then I mentioned to Geshe-la that the Christians do this or used to do this as well during Lent. Geshe-la saw this among the villages which surround Sera Je where the Hindus will give up worldly life for a month or two, cut their hairs, and go to try to realize dhyana. And therefore for ourselves, if we train in this way, irrespective of whether we attain the seventh or the eighth level of mental abiding, we should combine this practice with our study of the nature of these levels of mental abiding.

We see for ourselves the relevance of calm abiding if we take an example meditating on death and impermanence. When we meditate on death and impermanence, we meditate on the transience, both coarse and subtle of our own aggregates, starting from the crown downwards and reflecting on the fact that our aggregates are aging instant by instant and that our death is a given. Now if we meditate on this, the way we do it is first we engage in analytical meditation and then once we have this strong sense of the impermanence of the aggregates, we focus the mind single pointedly on this. However, focusing the mind single pointedly on this, if we lack vigilance, the mind will actually within a matter of a minute or two get scattered outwards by agitation or collapse due to sinking. Because we lack vigilance, we will be unaware of this and even though we meditate for one hour or so on death and impermanence, we will be lucky if we have three minutes of continuous meditation.

Once we have attained calm abiding, the totality of that one hour of meditation will be one continuous and uninterrupted stream of meditation on death and impermanence. Understanding this, we can understand the importance of calm abiding. Otherwise, it’s just a matter of claiming calm abiding is important because it is a famous topic. Even if agitation does not arise during our session, sinking may arise as a result of which we will simply fall asleep. And therefore, for us to practice, we must understand the faults which hinder the development of calm abiding, specifically the five faults which Geshela has explained over the last two day two days.

Starting with laziness, then forgetting the instruction, then agitation and sinking, followed by the non application of the antidotes and finally, the inappropriate application of the antidotes. Now if we have just studied the texts and we know the meanings of the word but we have no experience at all in their meaning, then we end up in a very strange situation where we know the words but have no experience. So when we choose to train in calm abiding, we should train in calm abiding sequentially in keeping with the instructions, which are very nicely given in this chart which was handed out to you. In the sort of same way as, for instance, when we choose to generate renunciation or bodhichitta, we initially generate the causes for renunciation. And then having generated the beginnings of renunciation, we choose to focus either on our own welfare alone, in which case we have entered the Hīnayāna or on the welfare of others, in which case we have entered the Mahāyāna.

At this point, we generate incrementally the causes for bodhichitta either through the seven fold cause and effect system for the generation of bodhichitta or through the interchange of self and other system for the generation of bodhichitta. In either case, it is this incremental generation which we also have to apply to calm abiding. Now if we reflect on the five faults, we can see that the first fault, which is laziness, has actually four antidotes, whereas the four remaining faults have one antidote each. Why is this the case? This is actually an important question.

So once the mind has been affixed, connected, fixed to the object of concentration, the object of observation by the rope of recollection, one applies the three following antidotes which are recollection, vigilance and the application of the antidote to ensure that the mind remains fixed on the object of observation. The coarsest thought at the beginning of one’s practice is forgetfulness. This is the coarsest type of thought in the generation of calm abiding. Then if you reflect on calm abiding in the traditional presentation, you may get a sense that there is an overwhelming burden on recollection. It seems as if recollection has to do all the work and keep the mind on the object of observation.

Geshe-la does not feel this is a helpful way to look at things. It is more helpful to see all of the three antidotes following laziness. In other following the antidotes to laziness. In other words, recollection, vigilance, and the application of the antidote as collectively enabling the mind to stay on its object of observation. Otherwise, you might think that recollection does all the work and vigilance vigilance is in the background popping up occasionally.

And therefore, after actually having found the object of observation, whichever object of observation we choose to become accustomed to meditate upon, we then progressively have to extend the session of meditation. At first, we will find that we will be able to remain fixed on this object of observation for no more than a minute or two, after which it will progressively fade. This fading accompanied with dullness in our mind is the manifestation of coarse sinking. Alternatively, we may totally forget the object of observation and our mind may shift from the object of observation to a totally different object. This is something which you probably have experience of.

This is coarse agitation. So these this is the first pair we have to struggle against, coarse sinking and coarse agitation. The following obstacle we will face which only arises once we are able to extend the session a fair bit is subtle sinking. Subtle thinking is much more difficult to identify because in subtle thinking, the object of observation appears clearly and it is stable. The mind is withdrawn inwards.

However, even though the object of observation appears clearly and is stable, there is a certain intensity which is lacking in the object of observation and this is a sign of subtle sinking. It is said in Liberation in the Palm Palm of Your Hand by Pabongka Rinpoche in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand that this is akin to holding a cup. When we hold a cup, we need not just to hold it, we need to hold it tightly. Otherwise, if we hold it loosely, it will waver in our hand. Holding it tightly is visualizing the object of observation with good concentration.

Holding it loosely is having subtle sinking. So Je Tsongkhapa in his Lamrim Chemo has warned over and again of the dangers of sub subtle sinking, which is the worst possible obstacle to calm abiding. Then Geshe-la says, frankly, from his own side, he feels that if you have subtle sinking, it’s good enough. Don’t get worried about it. His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, has explained this very clearly in two books.

One, the translation of the stages of meditation and the other, the Dalai Lama at Harvard. Regarding the dangers of subtle sinking, subtle sinking causes one to waste a tremendous amount of time meditating when one is actually making while one is actually making the mind duller and duller and more and more stupid. Then what mental factor has as a function the ascertainment of the presence or the absence of sinking, subtle sinking, agitation and even subtle agitation. It is none other than vigilance. Then it is said that once recollection has been fully perfected, vigilance is there as well.

And then within the five faults according to Maitreya’s Madhyantavibhaga, once we have eliminated the laziness, we are left with three major remaining faults which are forgetting the object of recollection, agitation and sinking and non application of the antidotes. Once we have eliminated the thought of forgetting the object of observation through the power of recollection, then we must examine using vigilance whether or not agitation or sinking are present. If vigilance determines that agitation or sinking are present, we must then apply the antidote to the fourth fault. The fourth fault is a non application of the antidote. Therefore, we must apply the appropriate antidote to either agitation or If sinking arises, we apply the typical antidotes Geshe-la explains, such as splashing water on one’s face, visualizing light and so forth.

And if agitation arises, since agitation means that the mind is going outwards, we have to draw the mind back inwards and cause it cause its elevation to abate. For instance, through meditating on the thought of cyclic existence. And then once and it is something all of us can do if we practice, once we have attained the point where we no longer suffer from sinking or agitation, in other words, sinking or agitation no longer have the capacity to interfere with the focus of the object of observation, it is no longer necessary to apply the antidotes. Then the fifth fault is the inappropriate application of the antidotes through our habituation in applying antidotes to sinking and to agitation. We apply them even when sinking and agitation are not present and this disturbs the continuum of the meditation.

The way to counter this fifth thought is to generate the equanimity which does not apply the antidotes. Then when we once we have reached this stage, we are in an uninterrupted continuum of good concentration. Therefore, the fifth fault which is the intemperate or inappropriate application of the antidotes when neither agitation nor sinking are present is to be countered by an equanimity which does not apply inappropriately the antidotes. When we have reached this point, we have reached the ninth level of calm abiding where the mind is continually and uninterruptedly focused on its object of observation. And we should not leave it at this, but we should understand precisely why one has to attain calm abiding.

We will put aside those for whom the goal is the development of liberation for their own sake through renunciation and assume our goal is the attainment of full enlightenment for the sake of others. For such a full enlightenment, we need to generate bodhichitta. But in addition, that bodhichitta must be conjoined with a direct realization of emptiness, which can only occur through an insight, a vipassana, which is focused on emptiness as its object. This vipassana which analyzes emptiness can only arise independence on a calm abiding which is focused on emptiness. This calm abiding in turn can only be generated through the nine stages and through an understanding of the five faults and the eight antidotes which oppose the five faults.

Thinking about this for some couple minutes will be of great benefit to us. Otherwise, if we just reflect on the words without ever gaining any experience, then we will go from teaching to teaching without ever gaining any real benefit. Mhmm. Now we will meditate a bit. Let’s meditate.

It is critical and this is something Geshe that I would like to emphasize over and again in the light of the fickleness of Western students to settle on one single object of observation and never to change ever after. If you settle on one single object of observation, you can hope to gain attainments. If you keep changing objects of observation, you will never gain any attainment of calm abiding. Then having chosen as Lamrim Chenmo suggests an image of the Buddha as object of observation, should uncertainty regarding the color arise and when one has chosen to visualize a yellow image of the Buddha, it turns red, then one has to bring it back to the original color one has chosen. At present, Geshe-la will present the generation of calm abiding in the light of the nine mental stages and six forces and the nine mental stages, which is an easier presentation.

For this, one must initially memorize the nine stages of generation of calm abiding as well as the six forces to know how to apply them. Then this is done in Lamrim Chemo through a careful presentation of the nine stages in the light of quotations from the great texts. Our teacher, Kensur Kangur Rinpoche, has said that really one has to correlate this with one’s own practice. And then if one does this in terms of one’s own experience, one will gain a profound understanding. Then we have to gain experience in progressing on the path of these nine stages.

And then obviously if we meditate on calm abiding and somehow our own development of concentration is completely different, then this is very awkward and inappropriate. So, Geshela, hopes that you will meditate and develop on the path of the nine calm abidings. So these nine levels and you have them in your chart of the development of calm abiding are number one, mental placement. Number two, continuous placement. Number three, repeated.

It’s often translated in English as patch placement. It’s repeated placement. Number four, close placement. Number fifth, taming. Number sixth, pacification.

Number seven, close pacification. Number eight, single pointedness. And number nine, karma. And number nine, equal placement. Then these nine stages must be progressively incrementally attained through the application of the six forces.

The six forces, which which you can find in Lamrim Chenmo, are the force of hearing, the force of thinking, the force of recollection, the force of vigilance, the force of enthusiasm, and the force of Then the first force is the force of hearing. Then regarding your practice, since we are starting with the practice, Geshe-la would like to ask you, When you focus your mind on whatever object of observation you have chosen, does it appear clearly or not? It doesn’t appear. Then please, would you look at the statue of the Buddha on the altar carefully? Try to memorize its aspects from the crown down, and then close your eyes partly as was explained in the posture and try to make this appear in your mind’s eye, in your mind, in other word.

Is it appearing? It is appearing. For who? Appears? The mantra.

For whom doesn’t it appear? All. Does it appear for all or not? A rough appearance, a gross appearance is enough. Rough appearance is enough and then you focus the mind on that rough appearance.

Can everyone stay on this clear this appearance, this rough appearance of the Buddha statue for ten seconds? Wonderful. Should be able to stay ten seconds. What about you? Does it appear?

Does it appear? Appear? This is my expression. The mind. The mind.

The mind. Are you saying that when you after looking at it, if you close your eyes, you can’t actually see it? Can I ask you a question? You’ve all fallen in love. Right?

When you close your eyes, you see the image of your beloved or not? Okay. You can do it. If you think of the Buddha’s body in the same light, does it appear to you? So This is a function of your own experience of meditation. The question is asked why this is the case for Westerners. It’s almost unheard of among Tibetans. Then I told him that in my opinion memory among westerns is extremely underdeveloped. We do not memorize anything anymore.

And for instance, the great monasteries, one typically memorizes texts every day. The memory becomes very powerful. Secondly, there’s very much an issue of alcohol consumption. Then His Holiness has said that if you want to develop calm abiding, you must completely give up alcohol. Alcohol blocks memory in calm abiding.

Then the first force which has to be developed is the force of hearing in accordance with Lamrim Chenmo. And dependent on this force of hearing which involves a mental withdrawal, the mind actually can be focused upon its object of observation. When the mind is actually focused upon its object of observation, then one is on the first level of generation of calm abiding, which is mental placement. Then the generation of the second force, which is the force of thinking, is necessary to lead the mind to the second level in the process of training of calm abiding, which is continuous placement. Through the force of thinking, the mind is no longer just focused on the object of observation.

It is focused for a certain duration of time on the object of observation, perhaps one minute or so. Then the third force is the force of recollection or memory. This force of recollection or memory is necessary for the realization of the third and the fourth levels leading up to calm abiding, which are respectively repeated placement and close placement. Repeated placement occurs when the force of memory or recollection is sufficiently developed that in addition to having been able to place the mind on the object of observation and to do so for some time, the moment the mind is distracted and tries to move to another object, we bring it back. For this reason, it is called repeated placement.

This is why the English translation patch placement is a bad translation. And then through the force of memory, in addition, one can generate the fourth state which is a state of close placement. But Pabongka Rinpoche says in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand that once these are realized, one no longer loses the object of observation. What is the third force, the force of memory or recollection? It is that force which brings the the mind back to the object of observation when the mind is distracted from the object of observation outward and loses it.

The fourth force is the force of vigilance. And the force of vigilance is necessary to progress on the fifth and the sixth sixth levels leading up to calm abiding. In other words, the levels of taming and of pacification. During these two levels, whenever either sinking or agitation attempts to distract the mind from its object of observation, the force of vigilance immediately brings the mind back to the object of observation through enabling one to apply the antidotes to these thoughts. If sinking arises, since sinking involves an excessive withdrawal of the mind inwards, the force of vigilance notes this and causes one to elevate the mind through the techniques Geshela explained.

On the other hand, if agitation arises and the mind is scattered away from the object of meditation, vigilance notes this and immediately causes the mind of the level of the mind to drop through applying antidotes such as, for instance, meditating on the thought of cyclic existence. The seventh and the eighth levels leading up to calm abiding which are close pacification and single pointedness are accomplished through the force of enthusiasm. How is this the case? Because during the seventh and the eighth level, when subtle sinking arises in the mind, vigilance notes this and the force of enthusiasm is applied to dispel subtle sinking. The last stage in the generation of calm abiding is the ninth mental stage of placement in equipoise or equal placement.

This is accomplished through the force of thorough habituation. Why is it the case that the sixth force, the force of thorough habituation accomplishes or fulfills the ninth mental stage. This is because at the level of the ninth mental level, neither sinking nor agitation, either coarse or subtle are present. And therefore, the main activity is intensive focus on the object of meditation. For this reason, the force which is applied is the force of thorough habituation.

In other words, thorough meditation. At the ninth mental level, since there is neither agitation nor sinking, neither recollection nor vigilance are necessary anymore. Since neither recollection nor vigilance are necessary anymore, they have fulfilled their role, their application is inappropriate. And this inappropriate application of vigilance and a recollection at the ninth mental level is the main fault at this level. This fault is abandoned through not applying recollection or vigilance at the ninth mental level and the synonym of this non application which is the eighth, the fifth of the eight antidotes to the five faults is also known as putting the mind at ease.

The difference between the eighth and the ninth mental level is that whereas at the both the eighth and the ninth mental level, the mind can remain indefinitely for days, weeks or months focused on the object of observation. At the level of the eighth mental level, this is induced through powerful effort using the force of recollection. Whereas at the ninth mental level, such effort is not required. So moving backwards from the ninth mental level, The fact that at the ninth mental mental level, the mind can effortlessly focus on the object of meditation is due to the cultivation of recollection and vigilance at the level of the eighth mental level. Then there is an important question in this matter, which is why should recollection and vigilance be cultivated at the eighth mental level, since after all there is neither sinking nor agitation on the eighth mental level.

This is because this meant this recollection and vigilance are due are used to induce eventually the effortless focus on the object of meditation. The eighth mental level in turn is induced by the seventh mental level in which close placement, the close pacification in which subtle sinking is countered and the seventh mental level is induced by the fifth and the sixth mental level of taming and pacification during which using the force of vigilance, both subtle sinking and subtle agitation are countered. The fifth and the sixth mental levels are in turn induced by the fourth mental level in which using the force of recollection one begins to counter sinking and agitation. And the fourth mental level is induced by the third mental level of repeat repeated placement where one starts training in the force of recollection. Then regarding the first and second levels, there is nothing major to say.

Have you understood? Do you understand? Do you all? Do you all understand? It’s difficult to speak of experience at the beginning, but here we’re studying the topic then eventually through study.

Geshela has no experience. Experience. This is how I want you to train the mind in concentration. How is that? So in addition to the presentation of the six forces, there’s also a presentation of the four mental applications which is very difficult.

Then Geshela would suggest that you study these nine stages in the light of the nine levels leading to śamatha put out in this chart and the six forces which are presented at various points of the nine levels. And ask your questions in the function of this. This is a very, very good chart of generation of calm abiding. Oh, yeah. You should have find it amazing that you can’t visualize and we were talking of the courses.

It’s very important to take care of your bodies. Once you’ve destroyed them then it’s over, right? Yes, Annette, come. Geshe-la is not sure. That depends very much on your experience.

It is something you have to gain experience in. Having said that, obviously, if you take the case of the fourth level of training in calm abiding, you would have trained in the force of memory. Having trained in the force of memory, you would no longer lose the object of observation. Then it seems difficult to fall from the fourth to the third and definitely from the fourth to the second. The meaning.

The force of thinking refers to that mental activity which causes the mind to remain for long without losing the object of observation for ten, twenty minutes. This occurs through the force of thinking. And when that has been perfected, then one is on the second of the nine levels, the level of continuous placement. Does that control the answer? Your question is what’s the difference between the ninth, 11, and calm abiding?

Is that it? The difference is that at the level of the mind calm abiding, the mind is continuously and effortlessly placed on the object of meditation. But calm abiding itself has not been attained because this continuous placement on the object of meditation has not induced the bliss of bodily and mental pliancy. It’s when the bliss of bodily and mental pliancy is induced that calm abiding can be said to be attained. You wanna know about the difference between patch and closed, please?

So the uncommon feature of the fourth level of mental placement, is close placement, is the perfection of the power of memory or recollection. Training in the power of memory or recollection starts fully during the third level of repeated placement. But at that point, one is just a beginner in the application of memory or recollection. It is at the end of the fourth level, close placement that memory or recollection is perfected. And for this reason it is called close placement.

Then continuous placement, the second level, refers to the stage during which the mind can actually be placed on the object of observation for some ten to fifteen seconds. When we have the capacity when the mind has left the object of observation to bring it back and put it back on a bit like a patch, then we have reached the third level of repeated placement. Geshe-la will tell you this afternoon. Perhaps, Mark, yes? It’s perfectly okay for you to select an object of observation in function of your own meditative experience and this is why Geshe-la has explained numerous different objects of meditation.

There is no definiteness regarding the object of observation you should choose. It is suggested to take the body of the Buddha, but Geshela did mention that in India, the non Buddhist practitioners would generate calm abiding on the horns of a goat. Why not some visualize it within their hearts? If you lose the object of observation, then this is coarse forgetfulness. Then the first thing is to bring the mind back inwards and to focus on the object of observation.

You have to distinguish between coarse and subtle sinking. When coarse sinking occurs, it’s a clear sign that the mind is overwhelmingly withdrawn inwards. Then you have to push the mind outwards whatever the means. So put your minds at peace. As beginners, it is not possible to obtain this in one day, one week, one month, or even one year.

You have to go slowly, slowly, slowly, and you have to gain experience through practicing on a daily regular basis. Then you can ask the remaining of your questions this afternoon. 12:00. It’s almost 12:00.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top