1 h 33 min · 12,549 words · 12 August 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A visiting psychiatrist introduced by the host talks about mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) for preventing depression relapse. He covers its origins from mindfulness-based stress reduction, the evidence base, training clinicians, and ethical questions such as side effects and informed consent. He also argues that compassion and some Buddhist study should be included. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: b124d8af-b0b3-4893-8bd2-5d1ce22797e8
Date: 2012-08-12
Words: 12,545
Professor Graham Meadows, who has very kindly come all the way from Melbourne. I’ll allow him to ask if you could introduce yourself and what you do. Thank you so much. Thanks very much. I’m delighted to be here.
It’s my connection with Khensur Rinpoche goes back twenty four years. I’ve had the very good fortune to move to Adelaide in pretty much the same month that Khensur Rinpoche arrived here and I spent a couple of years here and was able to immerse myself in some of the first teachings that he gave in Australia which was absolutely fabulous and I’ve kept well I’ve moved away in a range of different countries and cities since. I’ve managed to keep some degree of contact with a very wonderful teacher. So I’m Professor of Adult Psychiatry at Monash University. I’m a doctor, a general practitioner and a physician and then a psychiatrist by training.
I have a strong background in services research and epidemiology in policy applied use of data in relation to health economic and policy based questions. But also for about ten years I’ve been working in the area of mindfulness based practice as applied in clinical populations. And I guess for me that journey really began when I for many years had a Buddhist practice. Actually first encountered Buddhism and started a meditation practice in a quite purposive approach to managing the as a way of managing the stresses of psychiatry. I’d actually done a little bit of psychiatry in my very early years and I graduated very young from medicine.
I first did psychiatry when I was 22 or so and thought that it was very appealing for me but also felt I wanted to be a bit more mature and have a bit more experience and do some other things before I settled into it. So I went away and did a few less stressful things for a few years like coronary care and emergency medicine and things like that Then came back to psychiatry. Living in London I started a meditation practice with the Western Buddhist Order. They actually have some very beautiful economical teachings that are can some ways into some very nice easily sustainable meditation techniques. But then over the years I got more interested in the philosophy, more interested in the Buddhist, more interested in the more fully Buddhist and Tibetan teachings.
I spent a little bit of time in India and then as I said connected with Khensur Rinpoche in the late 1980s. So but then I really kept that very much out of my professional life. This is my spiritual life. It wasn’t something that I talked about or really brought into my professional life in the way that most of us wouldn’t. Whatever your spiritual persuasion is, that’s something that you keep aside from your clinical life.
But then I put a book off the shelf in a bookshop in Melbourne which was a piece of work a mixed Canadian and British group, Zindel Siegel, Mark Williams, John Teasdale, who produced this technique called Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy. Sitting as I was in Melbourne some psychologists that I knew and some others who were both people with meditation practices and also with strong clinical skills, I looked at this manual which was a set of techniques that had been built up into a group based course and I realised which had been developed in North America and had some studies done on it and I realised that there was a really good opportunity there to make a contribution by actually bringing it here, doing some research on it, extending the research agenda and bringing it over to a different country, different part of the world. And also actually bringing in some of the kinds of research skills that I’ve got to it. For instance we’re on the verge of publishing the first ever health economic evaluation of MBCT because we’ve actually done a substantial research study which is going down that track. In a way there was something a bit different that we could contribute to it.
So that’s the kind of background that I’ve got with this and with that I’ll start talking through the abstract. And really this was the abstract that I sent in and in a sense there’s four sentences in the abstract and I’m just going to go through them. These techniques have been growing and I’m going to spend a fair bit of time talking about the mindfulness based techniques and the kinds of ways they are delivered and the range of them and some of the kind of theory behind them in relation to the way they are applied in at least some kinds of psychological problems. Talk a bit about the range of evidence base and in some respects the limitations of the evidence base at the moment. Then in a slightly more discursive section I’ll be talking about some reflections from my side about the way in which some of the interventions seem to be shorn of what I would regard as from my Buddhist background of some very important components and talk about what the implications of that might be.
And then I’ll talk a bit about how the thinking is evolving about what the reasonable training requirements, expectations, preparations and issues about duty of care and how we might actually think about how we prepare people to do these kinds of techniques and what some of the issues are in the broader issue of dissemination. Okay, so step one. Various different forms of this graph appear in a lot of presentations. Basically this is what happens if you run mindfulness in a couple of the key search engines and look for papers on them. Mindfulness of course was a term in English that goes back to the fourteenth century.
It was coined as a translation of the Pali term Sati in the eighteen eighties but it didn’t make much of a presence in the medical or psychiatric or psychological literature until the late nineteen eighties but since that time it showed pretty much an exponential growth. It has just been progressively going up and now sort of there in a year there are many hundreds or thousands of papers using the term published. Mindfulness The has a number of meanings in psychology. Not all of them actually related to meditation but it’s the way in which it connects with understandings from meditation particularly Buddhism that I will be concentrating on. One of the key people in this is and there’s probably a little red light here.
There we go. There we go. One of the key people and probably the most famous and influential single single figure in this has been Jon Kabat-Zinn. Jon Kabat-Zinn many people will have heard of, I would imagine. Anyone not heard of just a few one or two.
Okay. Jon Kabat-Zinn, Jewish by origin, of course, but as as a number of these as a number of the key people who are putting forward, who are involved in the advancement of mindfulness are, know, is, I guess a lot of them are kind of North American intellectual Jews. And there is quite a long history of kind of interest in Buddhism from within Jewish culture. And Jon Kabat-Zinn himself became interested in Buddhist culture in his twenties and spent some time travelling overseas, immersed particularly in Theravadin teachings and came back and developed this technique called Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction which has been extremely influential in a sense sits at the base of the techniques that I’ll be talking about of MBCT. Because there are a number of different approaches to a number of different things have emerged.
Mindfulness based stress reduction. Now Jon Kabat-Zinn really from the 1970s onwards. He was working at the University of Massachusetts. He was actually a microbiologist by original background, not a mental health clinician particularly. And that’s relevant to the way that some of the later developments happened.
And he began working with people with chronic pain and with people with cancer and then a bit later with people with HIV. And he developed and refined a technique which became an eight week course two to two and a half hours a week and which concentrated first of all on introducing people to mindfulness based practice with a range of exercises. It starts off with a careful and the very first exercise is a careful and mindful eating of a raisin. And then you move into a body scan, breath, mindfulness mindfulness of breath, body sounds, thoughts, choiceless awareness. And then there’s a fair amount yoga, fair amount of mindfulness of daily activities and he basically set up a structure which really involves giving people opportunity to familiarise themselves with quite a wide range of different mindfulness practices with tapes, later CDs of course, homework.
People are encouraged to do about forty five minutes of homework a day for this eight week course. Having worked with a variant of it now, I must admit I’ve been astounded by the progress that people make. I think it was a very carefully crafted package and as a way of really giving people a wide range of different exercises that give them an introduction to mindfulness based practice. Often even by the end of kind of three, four, five weeks you can see palpable changes in their self experience and the way that they’re able to articulate and obviously demonstrate some kinds of stabilization of attention and ability to habitually be in a more mindful way in the world that I found quite surprising with the kind of speed I was used to used to models that were a lot slower. So developed this technique which was delivered in large groups often groups of twenty, thirty, 40.
It became immensely popular in The United States and has remained immensely popular in general hospital particularly. And I think and in some respects its popularity has gone quite a way ahead of its evidence base really. It’s actually a bit difficult to study an evidence base because the groups are so heterogeneous, they’re so mixed that you’ve got people with cancer, people with psoriasis, people with multiple sclerosis, people with back pain, people with HIV. How you actually study such a complex collection of participants and get some really firm data out. So there is data on it, is data on pain, there is data on psoriasis, is data on multiple sclerosis but in terms of the kind of sequence of the way things developed, way that you’ve got hundreds and hundreds of hospitals around The US that are doing this is really a bit ahead of its evidence base.
Acceptance and commitment therapy is a much So the next up would be dialectical behaviour therapy really which Marsha Linehan who was a Californian American with a Zen practice background developed which is orientated towards assisting people with personality disorders particularly borderline personality disorder and which uses a range of mindfulness techniques. And acceptance and commitment therapy more lately is a set of techniques which are given, which are used for acute phase treatment in a wide variety of disorders which is often referred to as including mindfulness. A thing about both DBT and ACT is that neither of them actually directly teach people meditations in a group format or really they’re settings in which people are given CDs or actually led through meditations or helped to really develop practice. They’re more introduced as kind of snippets. And this is one of the things that is and also ACT is one which is very much something the mindfulness practices are things that you kind of do to someone in the session.
You initiate them, you do them. They are things that little exercises and things that you do which are intended to promote mindfulness. So it’s quite different from actually getting a group of people in a session and saying right now we’re going to do a body scan or we’re going to sit and do breathing meditations. And I’m less drawn to act although it’s becoming immensely popular because I’m actually very much drawn to techniques that are quite explicit about their rationale and that give people things that they can take away to self manage with. You know the fact that MBCT which we’ll talk about shortly does actually enable people to really develop a meditation practice something that they can hold, they can take forward, get a relapse signature or a lapse drill.
They’ve got a certain degree of control and autonomy over it and that has an appeal to me. But also there’s an issue that because of the way that ACT and DBT use it in little snippets there is a way that it’s easy for practitioners to get an idea that people who aren’t directly involved in mindfulness practice and haven’t done much practice that mindfulness is a simple thing to convey, a simple thing to treat. You just give a few simple instructions and people will get it. You don’t necessarily need to be a practitioner to be able to do it and you can just tell people with an anxiety disorder that it’s a good idea just if stay with their experience rather than trying to avoid it and focus their attention on it and that will kind of help. A lot of the time there’s a risk that people trivialise and minimise and go into getting engaged in it without necessarily all that much in a way of background.
Moving into the area of depression. The mainstay of a lot of treatment of depression is in our society of depressive disorders which is to say mood disturbance lasting several weeks or months with loss of interest, loss of energy, loss of concentration, sleep disturbance, quite possibly suicidality, weight loss. Those kinds of constellations of things that are held to constitute clinical major depression. There is a mainstay of it which obviously is the medications and I’m a psychiatrist, I’m not averse to prescribing medications but they are not the whole story as Michael Leunig I think very nicely puts it here. They may make the doctor often feel wonderful but they will by no means always actually resolve the problem.
One of the key things about major depressive episodes is that they’re pretty common but once you’ve had one your chances of having others get progressively higher. And so if you’ve got someone who’s had say three or more prior episodes of major depression they’ve got a very high risk of getting it again and they’ve got a very high risk of getting it again particularly if they’ve just recovered from the third episode quite soon. So there’s a real argument for preventive interventions which actually target people who’ve had three or more episodes and try and reduce relapse rates. Now there is evidence that the kinds of results, the ways that depression onsets changes with time. If you look at people’s first or second episode of depression they tend to be very closely related to negative life events.
Later episodes of depression tend to get more and more decoupled from negative life events. People seem to be able to it were self initiate major depressive episodes once they’ve had a few. There’s a number of different explanations of this. But you can do exercises with people which involve inviting them to tell you something about their experience of their thoughts and ruminations and negative worries in different contexts. One of the specific things that you can do is you can use some techniques to actually make them slightly miserable for a while.
And there’s a whole story about the exploration of this. There’s little clips of movies of sad things happening to a child. But there’s been but there is now an industry standard way of making people consistently slightly grumpy and that feeling low and it is that you invite them to recall a negative life event, some sad event in their life and you ask them to concentrate on the memory of this while you’re playing them a piece of music by Prokofiev from the Alexander Nevsky suite called Russia Under the Mongolian Yoke at half speed. It’s actually a very poignant and beautiful piece of music, but at half at half speed it is an absolute dirge. And this combination consistently will make anybody just rather miserable and alone and happy for a while.
So this is done deliberately to people with consent and with advance notice. But what’s interesting about it is that if you look at people who haven’t had depression or who’ve had maybe one episode then you don’t get very intense and what you then do is you ask people to fill in questionnaires about their thinking or you sample their thoughts afterwards for a while and if people have only had one episode of depression or none then generally speaking what will happen is that you’ll get you may have some thoughts emerge they may get some ideas about feeling miserable about a negative self referential thought but usually that will sort of disappear after a while Some minutes or periods of time. In contrast to which if you get people who have had three or more prior episodes what’s much more characteristic is something like this. That they will have a kind of reverberating intensifying set of thoughts which will develop into words sentences with this kind of content and that that will then trigger a negative mood state. What you have is this role of rumination as a very potent influence on relapsing depression.
So the idea with teaching so when Zindal Siegel, Mark Williams, John Teasdale together with John Cabotzin were developing, They were actually working on developing a relapse prevention form of CB, of cognitive behaviour therapy to try and reduce relapse rates in depression. And they started going down the track. They got interested in mindfulness and they started talking with Jon Kabat-Zinn and a lot of what they were interested in was that they were hoping that through being able to with mindfulness techniques improve people’s attention control that they would be able to move these people from being in a sense the victim of their ruminating mind to being able to by virtue of the mindfulness based skills of a developed metacognition of a monitoring of the content of consciousness and a better attention control and a better sustained concentration. That rather than this elaborating network of negative thoughts the person would notice when a negative thought was arising. However in the context of the mindful mind it would not have the same power to then generate that reverberating network of ruminations.
The person would recognise that they had been through something which was a risk factor for the resumption of depression and they would bring their attention back into the present moment. So this is part of the theoretical background and there’s another way in which the theoretical background would indicate that mindfulness might be useful. This relates the concept of consciousness as an attentional workspace. That the workspace, the information processing content of human consciousness is not infinite, is bounded. That if you have a work space which is actually filled up with this collection of rumination that that’s actually occupying a large amount of the processing capacity.
What mindfulness training does is that it actually introduces other content mindfulness of body, breath, seeing, sound into the attentional workspace leaving less room for those ruminations which then proceed with less drive, potency and are diminished in power which means that their power to give you a sustained sad mood is also diminished. So you have at least these two theoretical constructs. One of actually attentional control and concentration, metacognition, noticing when rumination arises and the other is the process of occupying the attentional workspace. So you have a situation where if the attentional workspace is offered more with a more mindful presence then the ruminations are less likely to develop and also you have developed metacognition to notice them when they arrive and a better attention control to bring your attention back into the present moment if they occur. So a reasonably strong theoretical rationale for why mindfulness might work in assisting people who’ve had multiple prior episodes of depression to resolve it.
And out of that we had mindfulness based cognitive therapy. And this is that green book that I said which I picked off the shelf in readings and have been working away with for ten years ever since. Although mindfulness based stress reduction had been around for a long time, had never actually had it still in its much longer history has not anywhere near as well researched as mindfulness based cognitive therapy because mindfulness based cognitive therapy was developed in a manual produced by people who were really serious professional psychology researchers. Zindel Siegel, Morgan Firestone Chair of Centre for Addiction and Mental Health at the University of Toronto, Mark Williams at Cambridge, John Teasdale was at Bangor. These are really some of the most senior figures in understanding psychological approaches treatment of depression before they got involved in MBCT.
They’re very, very serious researchers and very, very good at doing manuals and the like. Actually much better at that than John Cabotzin was even though he had obviously made pioneering work in actually developing the techniques. And we have now this book which the one on the left is the therapist’s manual. The one on the right is now a self help manual which is a book that is given to people while they are doing the course but is actually fairly much a self guided approach to teaching yourself a lot of these skills. The course distills down into these sessions.
The course is an eight week, two hour a week course. And you need quite a range of skills to do it. It’s got quite a tightly scripted curriculum. There’s quite a lot of things that you’re intended to get through which is one of the strengths because one of the strengths is that it actually provides people with a very wide range of exercises in relation to mindfulness based practices from which in a sense they can find what works for them and what they find most conducive to their practice. But it also involves exercises which are much more in the way of the cognitive therapy exercises, whiteboard educational exercises about depression.
Towards the end you work with people on a relapse signature and a relapse drill in relation to their depression. So actually you need some fairly strong teaching and or group work skills in actually keeping an agenda going. You need to be able to deliver meditations and you need to be able to deliver meditations in different ways sensitive to the needs of the group and particularly with a fairly strong track on actually just reducing the extent to which you’re prompting as you go on through the group as they get more familiar they need less in the way of instructions. You need to be able to deliver meditations and modulate the delivery of that to do these other exercises. You need ideally to be able to use sort of non verbal skills and the like to actually move between these different kinds work.
You need to be able to run this process of inquiry which is about when you do an exercise, it a meditation or homework, there’s then a process in which you then invite discussion of it. And that’s actually quite a it can be argued that what is done in that is quite important to be able to model because mindfulness based cognitive therapy is really done with typically with groups of eight to 10. And what you do then is that once you say done a meditation you then invite the group to talk about it. And the content of what unfolds there is important but the other thing that is important is that the person running the group in the way that they respond to the content that arises in that discussion responds to it in a way that is non judgmental without attachment doesn’t move into inviting elaborations. And so in that you are actually modelling the way that you want people to encourage themselves to respond to their own experience of their own meditations.
So the group is a metaphor for the mindful meditating mind. And you want people to have enough experience of mindfulness to be able to draw on, to be able to do that with a degree of authenticity. So there’s a degree of subtlety to it. You need to be able to read poems because these crop up. Who made the world?
Who made the swan and the black bear? Who made the grasshopper? This grasshopper, mean. The one who has flung herself out of the grass. The one who is eating sugar out of my hand, who is moving her jaws back and forth instead of up and down, who is gazing around with her enormous and complicated eyes.
Now she lifts her pale forearms and thoroughly washes her face. Now she snaps her wings open and floats away. I don’t know exactly what a prayer is. I do know how to pay attention, how to fall down into the grass, how to kneel down in the grass, how to be idle and blessed, how to stroll through the fields, which is what I’ve been doing all day. Tell me what else should I have done.
Doesn’t everything die at last and too soon? Tell me what is it you plan to do with your one wild and precious life? Poems crop up in a few places. In it, there’s a few by there’s some by Rumi. There’s Mary Oliver crops up quite a lot.
And much of this work is very much shorn of Buddhist symbolism. Strangely, exception is tinctures which have become the standard for for little bells, bells that you just ring to invoke things and to actually invite the starts and ends of meditation or signal transitions. So there’s a range of different content that goes into MBCT. There’s a short technique which is used called a three minute breathing space which is intended as a bridge as it were from formal practice in the morning or other times. It’s a quite simple practice where people are just encouraged to notice their current feeling state, body state, their current experience and then bring their attention in onto the breath for a while and then expand the attention out to the body and then return into the moment.
The intent here is to help people in actually learning how better to handle what they will experience from time to time as this kind of cascade of negative thoughts while you’re trying to do something even something that you might otherwise really quite enjoy. So there it is, a technique. It’s had a number of randomised controlled trials. One of the things that people do is they do evidence based reviews which look at the aggregate effect across randomised controlled trials and essentially what it looks like is that it makes a substantial difference to relapse rates so that if you pool all the studies overall you’ve got about a twenty percent reduction in relapse rates in the first year in depression which is about equivalent to the kind of difference you get with antidepressants. So it’s actually a pretty potent treatment.
We’ve been doing work with it. We started off with a pilot study with $100,000 from Beyond Blue. Used that to get information, do the design process to get $600,000 for a four year grant from the National Health and Medical Research Council which ran from 2007 to 2010. Which was a multi site randomised controlled trial delivering MBCT. We developed our own training programme.
When I went over with a couple of the team we trained over in North America with Zindel Siegel and his group and it was quite interesting because they had prerequisites. They expected people to have a mindfulness some familiarity with mindfulness practice. So they had to write this rather unfamiliar CV which was all about your mindfulness practice. I haven’t done one of those before in one or two sins. Then they ran a one week course where you really spent the first part of it being exposed to the experience of the therapy and the second part doing teach backs and role playing it.
But an interesting thing about it was the very very wide range of backgrounds that people came to it from. Some were yoga practitioners, some were from contemplative Christianity, some were from different branches of Buddhism. Myself actually with the sort of strongly Gelug background that I had quite a lot of it wasn’t really very familiar. A lot of it was kinds of practices that I’d not had all that much experience of. But the people coming in there in the course that we did in The US were of very very different backgrounds.
Some of them kind of got it and some didn’t. The meditations that we’re talking about needed a particular set of backgrounds and some of those backgrounds were very well aligned with what was being taught, some were not so. We’ve changed it the way that we do it here. One of the things we were really keen about with this is that what they say with mindfulness based stress reduction and like often is they say you kind of have to have been doing a meditation practice for two or three years steadily and have done some retreats before they’ll even accept you. Then you have to do some training and some more training and some groups under supervision and to do a practicum.
That’s kind of all well and good and I’m pretty sure that when people go through all those steps the people that get through are pretty good. But it’s not really a way to generalise this treatment. You know there’s we’ve done I mean there’s if you want we’ve done some modelling work on this. There’s something like four point two percent of the Australian population who would have a history of three or more prior episodes of depression and being potentially eligible. This is getting on for a million people.
If this actually works it should be made available in high volume. So you don’t want put too much in the way of barriers to people actually training up. But on the other hand you want to make sure that people do actually know what they’re doing. We’ve turned the training around a bit and what we actually do is we invite people in to first of all take part in a slightly modified version of the eight week course and then we give them two or three months to consolidate their practice and then we bring them in for a four day retreat to actually go through the exercises and learn. And then we expect them to do a group with a senior practitioner to do a retreat of some kind the following year and to do another group under video supervision.
And probably by the end of that they are about there and that actually you can do in about an elapsed year with of the order of a hundred contact hours which is starting to get more feasible because one of the things that you get if you talk to people who are involved in trying to get MBCT up, a term that comes up a number of times about the training is that it’s a kind of Jedi model. In The UK, one of the key trainings is a full Masters in Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy. So people go away to Bangor and they do an entire Masters course in order to be able to deliver MBCT. But not many services are going to release a psychologist or someone to do an entire Masters so they can learn how to do one form of group therapy, which especially is preventive. Mean this is not, We need something more streamlined.
We’ve set up this model because otherwise people’s experience of the training models is that by the time people are ready to give MBCT they’re almost ready to walk through walls. They’ve had to spend years and years ploughing away at what seems like a very onerous training. So we’ve done this rather different approach and actually a number of the people who basically been through that approach were part of a team that delivered the MBCT in our groups. We’ve done analyses out of it. There were a few things that were quite different about the study that we did.
It recruited from more routine settings, we recruited people with a wider range of disorders, we recruited people who were on antidepressants as well, we recruited with bipolar, we recruited people with psychotic histories. We recruited people from primary care, from secondary care, from pain clinics. Were recruited from a wide range of things and stratified randomisation and all kinds of things. This is a survival curve which a monster study at the bottom and looking at the control group at the bottom and the MBCT group at the top basically which is just showing the way that they didn’t relapse as frequently as the others. We got overall people going through our study over two years had about half the recurrence rate of depression and they spent on average fifty days less in an episode of major depression over the course of two years.
Now there are some things that are questions about it though. One of the odd things about it is that you’ll notice that I’ve been talking about people with three or more prior episodes of depression. And one of the odd things about the first couple of studies was that the people that had less than well we didn’t include them in ours because most everyone else has done, we’ve shied away from it and also because we reckon we’ve more chance of getting good health economic properties where you’ve got higher recurrence rates. But there is a problem in the background of MBCT that if you look at the existing data, the people who had less than three prior episodes of depression not only didn’t benefit, they actually did worse than the controls. It looks as if there’s a potential that MBCT may actually have been pathogenic, it may have been iatrogenic, it may have caused some harm.
Now you might say, now one of the things that colors a lot of the discussions in the literature on this is there are quite a lot of people in the field who are very passionately, personally convinced of benefits of mindfulness, very passionately committed to disseminating those benefits and somewhat resistance to the idea that there might be side effects or potential for harm. It’s often viewed as a quite benign intervention which can’t really do any harm. It’s just a kind of gentle after all people just sitting watching their breath how could that upset you? And in contrast to which I find this quite credible, I actually find it I find this very credible on a motivational structure that if you think that people who’ve had who’ve at least had some depression are going to be sensitive to demoralisation, If actually you haven’t really built up your motivation to do what is quite a demanding course then there’s a fairly good chance that you will actually engage with it, that you don’t succeed in keeping up the homework, don’t get to the sessions, will drop out and you may experience a distinct sense of failure therefore demoralisation and potentially a consequential depressive relapse.
So there have been some more subtle processes approached but I think that starting this to get into some of the issues, some of the ethics in terms of selecting people and being cognizant of the various ways in which actually this thing which to a kind of distant observer might seem pretty much that you wouldn’t there wouldn’t be any credibility that could do any harm. Actually it does and I think probably most of us in this room have struggled with a meditation practice at one time or another in our lives that initiating it or sustaining it or regaining it that this can be a struggle and it can sometimes be demoralising and that meditation itself can sometimes result in a flood of negative thoughts that can be quite distressing, quite disturbing that this is not necessarily a kind of blissed out happy experience by any means. So and the other thing that a few things that emerged about from our study it looks as if it’s good for people with three with more than three but less than 10 episodes where people had had more than 10 episodes didn’t really do anything. It looks like it may well be that if you’ve had more if you’ve had fifteen, twenty episodes there may be such a strong biological driver to recurrence that it may be hard for a psychological treatment to overcome it perhaps.
We actually got good results clearly from people referred secondary care not from primary care. Interestingly we had a look at people who chronic pain thinking that because this has a basis in MBSR which has some effectiveness in chronic pain we might get good effects in the context of chronic pain. In actual fact we found that people with chronic pain had rather low recurrence rates whether they were in the treatment group, active group or not but they got no benefit from MBCT and it may be that what’s happened there is that in the transition from MBSR to MBCT it took out a fair bit of the yoga. There’s not as much yoga in MBCT as there is in MBSR and it may be that actually the yoga is more important in the way in which people actually learn to cope with pain. It’s making a point about how quite sensitive these interventions are to relatively minor changes in the programme that you can find that the effects change.
And we don’t know anything much about side effects. And there is a bit of an and one of the reasons why we don’t know anything much about side effects is that they haven’t been studied. You can read people sort of doing reviews of the study saying and no side effects were reported. Well there’s no side effects reported because they didn’t look. They didn’t do what you would really do if you were looking for side effects where you don’t know what the side effects might be, is things like detailed qualitative interviews of people who drop out.
That’s what you want to do if you want to find out where the side effects are and it hasn’t been done. Part the second. So what is very much concentrated on in these techniques is mindfulness. Is this occupying of the attention workspace, this being in the present, being in the present moment here now bringing your attention into the moment. What is But of course in traditional Buddhist teachings which often the metaphor of wisdom and compassion is the two wings of the bird.
There is this way in which compassion teachings are very much interleaved with mindfulness practice. Now there’s actually some evidence coming out from work in Exeter in The UK that self compassion at least is an active mediating principle in the effectiveness of MBCT. It’s not mentioned much in the book but when you go and receive trainings in MBCT there’s rather a sense of lineage transmission in that you definitely are encouraged and taught to present a compassionate presence in the group and people will often feedback. This is one of the things that’s powerful in the group. But there is an interesting reluctance to go down the line of introducing compassion meditations into clinical work and I still don’t quite understand this.
I’m stepping forward towards an understanding and we’re actually probably about to start some systematic exploration of actually working with clinicians and leading them through a practice and getting their response to it and asking how respond and what their thoughts and feelings are about it. Think that John Cabot Zinn in the early days was very clearly resistant to it because he felt that it was putting forward a kind of set of spiritual values that wouldn’t be shared widely by everybody that that it was or more really that it would just look too flaky. And that so he resiled. He he held back from that. But it’s interesting that there is still such a reluctance even though there is some evidence coming out that it’s quite important.
And I’m not quite sure what it is. Mean it’s always seemed to me that surely compassion, loving kindness is pretty much a universal spiritual value isn’t it? But maybe it isn’t maybe it actually has implications which do side which don’t sit well with all of the spiritual traditions of people who it might be unfolded with. There are spiritual traditions that that hold to a notion of righteous anger. There are spiritual traditions that hold that there are people who are evil and, you know, there I I don’t understand it.
We need to explore it. A lot of, you know, John comes from a Jewish background, so does Zindel Siegel. I don’t know where universal compassion and loving kindness fits in a kind of Jewish philosophical position or where where things are culturally there. The so but it it is an interesting reluctance I think and it means that although I think compassion is very clearly there as part for instance of the way that MBCT is delivered, it’s very dependent on the lineage. You have to go to one of the trainings to get that which means that if you get people who self train or just pick up the book and decide to do it, They won’t get that and it’s very easy for them to be doing something which is a much more kind of tougher, more a set of tricks to avoid rumination without that sense of a building of a positive self regard and a positive and of compassion and of that modelling.
The other issue is that in the way that the inquiries are led there’s certainly aspects of the ways that the discussions unfold and the things that are transmitted, things you get drawn into that for many people will actually be drawing on ideas of dependent origination, of responding to people’s experience and of the bottom ideas of emptiness. And I’ve seen one or two people who have after they’ve been exposed to the I’ll turn this as anecdote rather than anything systematic but enough to give me concern Who after they’ve been exposed to these sort of introductory teachings over a course of time have found themselves doing deeper and deeper reflections without necessarily being formally exposed to teachings on emptiness but have then found themselves losing a sense of self, losing a sense of self coherence, starting to have difficulty with motivation, difficulty with maintaining their previous sense of self and doing something that sounds to me like dropping into a level of nihilistic fallacy. And yet there is no structure surrounding them to help them through that kind of situation. And so I think that there’s always a risk once you start people on this path that they will take themselves into the direction of teachings on emptiness which of course historically have been so secret and now so widely available.
But, you know, I’ve read I’ve read I’ve read text. I was trying to track this one down. I’m not sure whether it’s in the Lamrim Chenmo, Iliophra, someone else might know this. I I distinctly remember reading one passage where where one of the teachers talked about the fact that if someone was ready to receive teachings on emptiness, you could tell because you would start describing the concept and the experience to them and the hairs on their forearm would stand up. It’s in the Lamrim Chenmo, thank you.
You know, I mean this is so specific. You know, that’s pretty and I’ve I’ve had that experience with some teachings that that Khensur Rinpoche did. So I I kind of it was it was one that really came home to me because I thought, wow. Yes. This what this what’s happening.
You know the teaching of mindfulness in clinical settings doesn’t have anything like that. Most of the people who are doing the teaching don’t have any kind of familiarity with and probably most of them wouldn’t be able to help someone who was falling into that kind of problem. And often you would miss it because often it would be the kind of thing that someone would that would happen to someone if they basically gone on meditating for some months or years after the original course. If you’re not following up, you’d miss it. In terms of the There’s definitely evidence that people with different levels of familiarity manage the techniques better and differently.
When we looked at our experienced meditators which were the people in our training, the people in our course, the people delivering it in the big study that we did who had sort of 20 plus of meditation experience, they generally speaking this is a range of different fidelity measures. They were very consistent except that we probably didn’t emphasise so much in our training which was using narratively orientated material to communicate core themes. But less experienced practitioners did less well on this other item of introducing the differences between relating to experiences from the standpoint of acceptance as opposed to aversion which is probably something that takes a little bit more time and experience with meditation to convey. There’s been quite a lot of work then on what constitutes what might be. Because one of the real questions with the ethics of this is who should do it?
Know, MBSR often takes people who aren’t necessarily clinicians, certainly not mental health clinicians, teaches them up with an intensive practicum. They often have got strong meditation backgrounds and then teaches them up. There are certainly people who are just picking up that green book and going for it. Not all of them are necessarily clinicians. There’s challenges of course that actually the thing about an MBCT group is that while most of the time you’re leading a group which is exercises and cognitive behaviour therapies things which may be fairly straightforward exercises, at least superficially, though there are subtleties that I’ve probably already hinted at.
The problem is that at the end of a group you can have someone break down in tears and you say let’s go talk about it and you can be faced with an acute relapse of a major depressive episode with suicidality. So you can just go from running a group setting into having to be able to function as a mental health clinician like that. The position we take is that you need to have those skills and you need to be able to make that transition even though you’re not taking over the care. You’ve got a group of very vulnerable people with you because they wouldn’t be in it if they weren’t fragile in relation to their disorder. In the study that we did we had a suicide in the control group about a year in.
We actually had an active control. The control group was getting an active supportive intervention. Because one of the worries about methods in this study is that if you just enrol people into MBCT versus treatment as usual then there’s a risk of resentful demoralisation in the control group And if you take in the worst case scenario it’s possible that what you’re looking at isn’t actually a beneficial effect of the MBCT. It’s the nocebo effect of encouraging people to join a study and then ending up allocated to the unlucky group that gets nothing. So we actually had an active control group as well which I was very pleased about because I would have felt much worse about that suicide.
I don’t think we had anything to do with it but it’s going to happen. So there’s a question about that probably in order to do these techniques you need to have the appropriate background skills in psychological treatment and then you need to have some appropriate level practice. And then there’s the issue about ongoing good practice requirements which probably involves daily formal and informal practice participation you know conventionally an annual residential teacher led mindfulness retreat. No one really knows how much you actually need to do to keep current but this is a reasonable guess. Then a commitment to a peer group and to keeping developing and adhering to the framework appropriate to your background.
So just to shift into a little bit more direct processing of the issues in ethics. You can think about ethics as existing at a number of levels dramatic specific acts, ethics in relation to specific acts and then underneath the surface the more persisting and enduring questions. Ethics in health and mental health care You can find codifications of guidance about acts, guidance about dramatic ethics particularly in a number of sources including codes of associations and colleges. Medical ethics is often one of the very popular and widely quoted set of principles of medical ethics is the four principles performed by Beauchamp and Childress of beneficence, non-maleficence, respect for autonomy, justice. And if we think about the issue of beneficence, one of the ways in which beneficence in a sense is ensured in modern practice is through reference to evidence based practice where we have a number of levels through a number of filters through which interventions we before we deliver them routinely.
So if we look at beneficence we have evidence it seems to make a difference although for some group of people it doesn’t and for people with less than three episodes of depression it may harm. Beneficence that’s kind of the parameters we’ve got on that but a fair bit of uncertainty. Non maleficiants raises the issue of side effects. This is one of a couple of slides from Maura Kenny because we certainly have found in some of the work that we’ve done we’ve actually found that generally in the non clinical range and this is in more occupational settings that sometimes mindfulness training actually gives people means that depression scores increase. It’s actually probably because self awareness is increasing they’re spotting it more.
But there certainly are risks of MBCT and things like post traumatic stress disorder where the meditation techniques can provoke flashbacks and the like. People have a vulnerability to psychotic symptoms that can stir things up. Demoralisation we’ve talked about. Some patients with personality disorders may find these quite reasonably long practices just too aversive. So those of us working in it are actually very interested in the side effects and it’s interesting how different clinicians respond to this.
As a general practicing clinician, treatments have properties. They have benefits, they count, they have positive benefits but they also characteristically have side effects or contraindications. This is just the way of it, you don’t get anything for nothing. There are things to watch and there’s a whole group of clinicians and I’d be among them for whom actually the credibility of the intervention is undermined if you can’t talk about the side effects and the contraindications and that you actually gain whereas there’s people in the field who want to say don’t worry about it, you can’t do any harm, it’s good but there’s a lot of others who are more I think actively skeptical and for whom when you start talking about the side effects profile it actually increases the credibility of it. And I also think it’s real.
Mean you know like I don’t know about you but I’ve done meditation for one it hasn’t always been very nice. Sometimes it’s you know it’s a bit of a rough ride. We have a situation where it is permissible to do MBCT under Medicare funding and psychologists say doing MBCT as a group item can claim Medicare rebates for it. But on the issue of some of the issues of the beneficence non maleficence respect for autonomy and the respect for autonomy really goes into that issue of side effects I think because that goes to the issue of informed consent. If you can’t tell people what the side effects are you can’t get valid informed consent.
So you have to tell people about the benefits but we have to do better at being able to understand and tell people what the likely side effects are and that’s going to involve a programme of research which hasn’t been done yet. And until it does we probably need to draw on what we know about meditation from the kinds of experiences that we’ve got in this room. In terms of justice there is questions about distributive justice and should one be doing MBCT rather than other things. One of the things that we’ve done in our work as I said is the first ever Health Economics. This is Health Economics from the top.
This is effectiveness on the x axis, this is cost on the y axis. So this is more expensive, that’s more effective. If you the most interventions sit in this quadrant, most new interventions sit in this quadrant which is increased effectiveness and increased cost. A really good place to be is down here which is increased effectiveness and lower cost, that’s dominance. And these aren’t so good.
We’ve done, we’ve looked at it and you can look at costing from a number of different perspectives. This is what we get, We get a positive result in that quadrant for MBCT if we just look at the cost of the MBCT. But from secondary care actually if we look at purely mental health budget alone and then more extremely if we look at mental health and productivity we’ve got it down in the dominant quadrant and we’re just preparing that stuff for publication. So I think that the advent of these techniques throws some challenges in relation to what we would know about the understandings of these techniques from a Buddhist perspective and also from the point of view of the requirements of medical ethics in relation to the techniques. One of the things that we are doing increasingly with the training is we started off really taking the line that Jon Kabat-Zinn and others had taken that was about really shearing it of the Buddhist background.
We’re putting it back in now and we’re actually requiring that the people that do our courses do at least a little bit of study of Buddhism. This is becoming more prevalent. I think people are realising that we don’t quite know what all of the active principles are of what we’re doing, what really works, that there are real risks that if you do this in ways that are completely disconnected from the philosophical backgrounds of it that you might be missing important things. So increasingly more and more of the courses, know the Banga course for instance, they do some studies in the arts faculties, do some sort of studies of Buddhist philosophy. And so this is in a sense coming in which is of course a challenge because we do still have to respect the range of spiritual persuasions.
We have to very clearly not impose or proselytise a spiritual tradition within the context of clinically funded services and yet we have to acknowledge and yet it’s also important that we acknowledge the origins of it. And there’s challenges in things like the need to set up retreats and things that are suitable for people because otherwise in a sense if someone’s got a strong prejudice against engaging with Buddhist studies then you can take them through this course and really if they’re going to advance and develop that they need some more support and they need some more abilities to go and do retreats and the like. In a sense if you don’t if the only way they can do that is through finding Buddhist organisations that’s a problem. And then there’s an issue about whether the Buddhist things that they find are actually harmonious with them. Some of them take themselves off for ten days of Vipassana retreats and if you’ve got a strong depressive vulnerability that’s a pretty tough gig.
They’re not necessarily very good at rescuing people who fall apart on those retreats. So you need a kind of setting that provides people with the ability to deepen their practice and rescue them if they get into trouble. Michael Leunig is a wonderful portrayer of mindfulness mindful experience. I don’t know if people can read that but oh my goodness it’s so beautiful just a tiny piece of gravel in the brick but it’s so perfect it catches the light it glistens it gleams. I see heavenly colors my head swims my vision blurry.
I see the universe, everything makes sense. It’s magical, wonderful, it’s beautiful. Interestingly Michael Leunig is not actually a meditator. He’s a friend of mine and he actually puts his I think sometimes he can portray things which convey an experience of mindfulness very powerfully but it comes out of a kind of rural background, a connection with nature and not a formal meditative background but he produces some lovely images. So that is an attempt to kind of sketch a bit of where we are on this particular journey with the way that this new set of techniques and particularly mindfulness based cognitive therapy and moving into psychological treatments and to look at some of the ethical questions that are being posed about really who we should be proposing to them for, how we go about doing informed consent, who should be viewed as appropriately qualified to do them and what we should be aiming, what the ethics are of what we should be trying to put in place as supports for people for longer term practice.
Thank you. And I think we’ve got some time for questions. Yeah. We don’t at the moment. And I mean I think that the what there are is there’s quite a lot of trainings in mindfulness based stress reduction.
For instance the Open Ground group would do a number of those and they are of good quality. I think that the but for MBCT at least we are concentrating on training clinicians for the reasons that I mentioned about the way that really you can suddenly find yourself unexpectedly cast into handling things. Can be dealing with things that crop up the inquiry. People will come up with experiences of depersonalisation, of of hallucinatory experiences and you’ve got to evaluate this and work out whether just how alarmed you should be about that. Some of that involves some of that I think is safer if you get people who have got a good degree of mental health care training.
So what we are looking at doing is probably in a couple of years time we’re hoping to move our training into an award course structure so that we can do it and probably will be part of the Masters in Mental Health Sciences at Monash which is a postgraduate course. So we’re kind of moving in that direction but I don’t think we’re going to move in the direction that they’ve gone saying Bangor of running a Masters Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy which you can come into if you’re not necessarily a psychologist and the like. I think that’s actually a very heavy training cost. Whereas I think actually our experience is suggesting that you can take people who are trained clinicians and in the course of about a year of elapsed time, about one hundred contact hours get them up to speed. Our focus is still going to be on Yeah, So working with people who are clinicians.
Which also means that you can then mobilise the existing funding structures. They can mobilise Medicare funding so that you can get supplemented, get it done in private insurance schemes. There’s quite a lot of it going on in day programmes in private private mental health care hospitals. There’s quite a lot going on. I think that’s our concentration at least.
I think you see quite a lot of different things. One of the things for instance that we see among they are more and less subtle. One of the things that is quite interesting for us is that we do the training with some people clinicians but also some people kind of academics. They are really driven people and a lot of them are driven by anxiety about not achieving or by a discrepancy monitor. You start getting them engaged in a bit of mindfulness and their motivation starts ebbing away a bit.
They don’t feel quite as fiercely committed to climbing up the academic ladder and getting more publications this year than they’ve done last year and getting the next grant. They can abide with it a little bit more easily either way. Which and they can get profoundly distressed by that quite seriously because their whole ambition, the drive that they were relying on to help them get somewhere, they feel just running away like water into the sand. So there are profound readjustments potentially both in the of acute phase and chronic phase because I also agree. Mean I’ve seen some people, not in MBCT groups but personally on retreats, I’ve seen some spectacular psychotic episodes arising out of people meditating intensely.
Really dangerous, potentially life threatening situations. And certainly you do see people you see people for who whom the onrush of negative thoughts is just so distressing that they can’t cope with it. You see people who very quickly find themselves reliving some trauma. You know with the body scan you see people who find themselves reliving some traumatic assault. Know these things happen and I think I guess that the position that we take is that well first of all you need to assess some of these things in intake.
So if you’ve got this situation where you know some of those vulnerabilities you can pick up in intake. Secondly I think then you need that’s why I guess we look at having both the skills of people who’ve got some reasonably advanced level of familiarity with the meditation practice and who’ve got a compassionate presence and who’ve got the mental health care skills and the ability to make a phenomenological assessment and actually work out what the best evidence is as to what’s going on. But because I think those reactions are not at all uncommon. That said they’re a minority. We often have groups where one or two people out of 10 to 12 drop out.
So we often get kind of, it’s not uncommon for us to get ninety percent completion but they’re still at one or two and even in the process of getting there some of them struggle quite a bit. So yeah look I think that in a sense you’re sharing the view that we need to be cognizant of, mindful of, careful of and I think one thing as a professional community maybe what we need to do is we now need to now that we’ve got the state where really we’ve got a wide acceptance that this is a valuable treatment maybe we don’t have to be maybe now we can take the confidence to actually look at the side effects And you know that that is that’s the important part of understanding the properties of the treatment. Yeah. Well, I mean, look, I guess I guess that there there is there is then a question in the TBI setting as to, yes, if, you know, you’ve obviously got a, you know, someone who’s got a huge level of skill in that, but it probably is sensible for many Buddhist organisations will have clinical psychologists or psychiatrists or mental health clinicians in them.
If you’ve got any substantial community of Sangha in Australia there will be a number of people with those kinds of skills. And it may well be that it is sensible to have some kind of a support structure. It’s an interesting question because there is an argument of course the Lama’s, the teachers can often help a lot But I think there’s also an issue that sometimes people need their issues responding to within the framework of their own cultural setting. I was at Kopan monastery quite a number of years ago now when a young European woman had an acute psychotic episode. The first thing that happened was that people took her to see the Tibetan lama who advised that she go down to Bodha and have some ceremony performed on her to deal with the demons.
But she really had a right to the care that was accessible within her cultural setting. So actually we took her down to the psychiatric hospital in Kathmandu and they sorted her out. A few days later she came back and she was well settled. But there’s a question about how you navigate this issue of which framework you respond to it in. It may be that if it’s something relatively minor that it can be responded to within, it may be quite appropriate to respond to it within the Tibetan tradition.
But if someone is going acutely psychotic and potentially not eating or drinking, which was the case in that one, then probably the situation is that they are not able to express their preferences and it should be assumed that their preference is for regular medical care. So there is a question about balancing those two different sets of responses. Yeah. Well I think it probably is a good idea for a Buddhist center to think about that route and that trajectory, generally speaking, to have something that can be put in place and to acknowledge that possibility and be sensitized to it. I mean I think that it’s it’s an interesting it’s an interesting personal journey getting involved in the transition of sort of coming out in relation to the spiritual dimension and that’s been there’s there’s been there’s there’s there’s been of a sense of you can get a sense of expropriation that your practice has become your interest and commitment to this has become a kind of public thing rather than something which you could just hold to yourself.
And you also have to you also have seen as having to kind of notionally live up to these standards that you’re supposed to be kind of you’re a Buddhist so you’re supposed to be you know yeah. You know, so you’re just supposed to be uniformly really nice and decent humble all the time. And where’s that gonna get you in academia? And where’s that gonna get you as a professor in the group of eight? You know, if you’ve just been really nice and peaceful, not at all competitive, not at all striving.
Nah. Nah. Just Yeah. Fine. So so you you got yeah.
You gotta find a middle way. But I guess there’s also a question about, you know, if we’re building out from this from this bridgehead in a sense of mindfulness and there’s a question as to whether there is something that is actually an imbalance there, whether there’s something which is meaning that the practices aren’t in a sense stabilised properly balanced and so whether there is something else that should be coming in. I do have a feeling that compassion is missing and that I think that we should be working and we are actually starting to do some more. We’re actually starting when we’re doing mindfulness based trainings for clinicians on the basis that it is absolutely clear that clinicians have to have this positive self regard for your clients in front of you. You have to be able to turn on some kind of a compassion muscle in a clinical setting even if you don’t like this person in front of you very much, even there are many unlikable things about them you actually have to still stay with them and be nice.
We can legitimate that. We’re also going to look at this issue of what the views are that might be the impediments to it because I think if we are going to step into it we should understand it and I think that if people really feel that it is encroaching on an area that is too close to something that’s spiritual and so therefore that’s challenging or that’s unacceptable, which which I think may be the case. So I think there’s a question as to if there’s an imbalance what do we need to correct it. My feeling at the moment is I think there is a bit of an imbalance in relation to the compassion issues and I suspect that there is an issue of imbalance in the longer term need to support people where people might run into problems with nihilism as they get into that sort of space. I don’t think that in order if we’re trying to work within a secular framework, I think you can address both of those without needing to rely on teachings or a conviction about past and future lives.
I mean there are other ways of generating compassion and there are other ways of addressing the sort of existential questions which lie at the bottom of dropping into a nihilistic fallacy. Because obviously as soon as you started moving into something which required a belief in past and future lives you would be doing something which was clearly challenging and was clearly going to be at odds with many people’s spiritual persuasion. So it would be a really difficult thing to be working with in a clinical setting. In contrast to which I think we’re exploring the possibility that compassion might be It took me a while to realise that this could be in any way controversial. I kind of had a gut feeling that surely compassion is something everyone would be with but it’s not.
There’s a reticence and a concern about going there which I don’t fully understand but I think that it is know, but I one could explore in conjecture but I think it’s there. But I don’t think either of those necessitates. I think think that the Buddhist philosophical system is rich enough that there are resources that can be brought to bear which would be compatible with a more Western philosophical tradition without drawing on that particular referendum. In terms of the studies with MBCT so far, the rigorous ones, by and large haven’t included people who had histories of psychotic illness. We’ve done some work with people who have got histories of schizophrenia but who have also had multiple prior episodes of depression.
In our experience, and this is at the level of anecdote, a lot of them have actually done quite well. There has been some work gone on in The UK headed up by a fellow called Paul Chadwick who has done some work with people using meditation to help people manage positive symptoms, hallucinations and the like with schizophrenia usually with shorter meditation sessions and with working specifically on assisting people to bring attention back into the moment and to actually explore the nature of the apparent hallucinations. It’s showing promise but it’s not definitive as yet. We are working on that and what we are actually using is one of those practices that I referred to from the Western Buddhist order which is a very simply structured metta bhavana, loving kindness and compassion practice built around a kind of mantra of may I be well, may I be happy, may I be free from suffering, may I make progress and then a friend, a neutral person, enemy and then bringing everybody together and then expanding out. So quite a simple staged meditative technique that’s quite easy to learn, quite easy to sustain yourself.
But that can actually be led quite powerfully, I think. Also that does a mix of actually working with ways that bring things directly into people’s lives and their particular relationship but also works on a broader and more universal kind of connection. So that’s what we’re planning to do. I think that’s a very secular technique really. There’s no visualisations, it doesn’t involve a Buddha mantra or anything like that.
It’s very grounded. Think Sangharakshita did some very good work with that, with the Western Buddhist Order in putting those techniques together for being widely accessible in Britain. I think they are a storehouse of some very good simple techniques. So that’s where we are planning to go with that. I think I’ve heard to be quite honest I can’t quote that immediately.
I can say what Khensur Rinpoche said. Because in 2006 when I visited Sera I talked to him about the work we were just starting with the DARE project and he gave that his blessing and he gave it his support that he saw that it was valuable just bringing the benefits of meditation to broader people and that as far as he was concerned it seemed to be a good thing to be doing. So I know that I’ve been at certain meetings where His Holiness had it discussed with him but I can’t exactly quote his support. But I know Khensur Rinpoche was certainly happy to hear about it. And that’s good enough for me.
Yeah. And I know that His Holiness is very happy to share the stage with Jon Kabat-Zinn and with Zindel Siegel and people like that. He’s you know, I think that he’s he’s inquisitive about how it is unfolding and I think he’s inquisitive about the balance and the mix and the effects. And I think he’s clear that in a sense the goals of this are somewhat different. Obviously the goals of meditation practice and Buddhism are quite different.
They are different from merely not getting depressed. But yes, think as I said I’ve known His Holiness to share the stage and be in kind of animated and positive discussions with a lot of these people. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.