Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0220 – KR.mp3
UUID: 2e0e0690-d900-489b-b672-683887093e1c
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Awareness and Knowledge (Khensur Rinpoche)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 2m
Words: 2,658
So as usual, in keeping with Kenser Rinpoche’s teachings, we will spend a minute or two to generate the appropriate motivation to listen to these teachings since the motivation is capital in, attending teachings of this nature. And our motivation should be to place all sentient beings in a state of full enlightenment. So last time Geshela started to explain Lorig and Lorig is principally dedicated to the study of mind. Now there are many forms of mind. Mind principally is to be understood as consciousness and minds are divided into principal minds and mental factors.
And these various forms of mind are what transmigrates from life to life, what progresses upwards on the path, and what is to be understood as the main constituting factor of the lower vehicle, but also of the greater vehicle within the greater vehicle, both of the vehicle of perfection and of the Tantrayana. So it is mind which is led upwards all the way to the state of full enlightenment. And specifically, this study of mind from the Buddhist context or what we would call psychology and epistemology is a fundamental importance in the dialogue with modern science. And there are many points of contact in this respect. So last time, we had covered the definition of valid perception or valid cognizers from within the twofold division of the mind into valid cognizers and non valid cognizers.
So this is on page 15 of your English translation. The definition of discerning perception of what Geoffrey calls valid cognizers is non mistaken cognition free of conceptuality. Actually, we are a little bit further back, Excuse me. Page 14. The definition of valid awareness or valid cognizer is new non deceptive cognition.
This should explain what the meaning of new was. This excluded the second moment of consciousness. What the meaning of non deceptive or unshakable is. And this excludes valid cognizers being, for instance, subsequent cognitions, wrong views, doubts, and so forth. And finally, the meaning of cognition.
This excludes, for instance, sense consciousnesses which are formed, which are accepted by one of the Buddhist schools being valid cognizers. So what is the meaning of the of giving a definition of valid cognizers? The meaning of postulating such a definition is to separate clearly between what are valid cognizers and what are not valid cognizers. And to make very clear which minds become valid cognizers and how they become valid cognizers so that in turn it is possible to train one’s mind to give rise to these valid cognizers. Then valid cognizers or pramanas are divided into two subdivisions, direct valid cognizers, Pratyaksa Pramana and inferentially valid cognize, Anumana Pramana.
The question here Geshela says is what exactly is understood by a direct valid cognizer, specifically what is understood by the term direct in this context since we know what a valid cognizer is. Direct here refers to the fact that this is a non conceptual cognizer. So generally speaking, there are two broad categories of minds, conceptual and non conceptual minds. The difference between them is that conceptual minds apprehend phenomena through a meaning generality, whereas non conceptual minds, which can be sensory minds or minds which arise through meditation, apprehend an object without depending on a meaning generality. And these non conceptual minds are generally minds which arise from the standpoint of the object and in this sense are perhaps somewhat less stable or certainly as far as sensory, cognition is concerned, then the conceptual minds which themselves are, minds which arise with the process of imputation from the sign of the mind of qualities or phenomena onto the object.
So generally speaking, it is said that conceptual minds are of greater benefit to ordinary beings than non conceptual minds. And it is precisely the definition of direct valid cognizers on page 15 of your text. Non mistaken cognition free of conception that the issue of non conceptuality arises. And at present, the division of direct cognizers, what Jampionian calls direct perception on page 15. This is not a direct valid cognizer, but just a direct cognizer.
There are four divisions, sense direct cognizers, mental direct cognizers, reflexive direct cognizers, which he translates as self perception, which is very unfortunate, and yogic direct cognizers. Now, regarding sense direct cognizers, this is self evident in as much as the sense organ itself is not afflicted. Regarding mental direct cognizers, mental direct cognizers are that mere one instant of mental consciousness which follows immediately upon a sense consciousness which impels it and precedes the arising for instance of a conceptual consciousness. In the minds of ordinary beings, it’s an inattentive mind. Then the third category is reflexive direct cognizers.
This is that capacity of the mind to know itself in addition to knowing whatever phenomena it is focused upon. And Geshela says it can be compared very much to the crystal the glass cup next to him containing water. So, it can be seen in two ways and both of those ways refer respectively to the mind’s cognizing its object and to its cognizing itself in the act of cognition. And then the final category of direct cognizers are yogic direct cognizers. These will be explained later on.
And at present, this is on page 15 of your text always in the very bottom part of the text, I will retranslate the definition however. A direct sense consciousness is defined as non conceptual unmistaken knower which arises independence on a form sense organ which acts as its uncommon controlling condition. So this definition broadly speaking, Geshela says, is divided into three parts. First, this consciousness is unmistaken. Secondly, it is non conceptual.
And thirdly, it arises independence on a form sense organ which is its uncommon controlling condition. Now here generally speaking, when we speak of conditions, are to be understood in terms of the threefold division of conditions presented in the collected topics in Dura. And the uncommon controlling condition of an eye consciousness is that material sense organ, in this specific case, the eye sense organ, which can only give rise to an eye sense consciousness and cannot give rise, for instance, to an ear sense consciousness. So this is what is to be understood by the term uncommon here. And as to the divisions thereof, they are divided into three.
Valid cognizers which are direct sense perceptions, subsequent cognitions which are direct sense perceptions, and inattentive minds which are sense direct perceptions. Regarding the first, in other words valid cognizers which are sense direct perceptions, the classical example given is the first instance of a sense perception perceiving form. Regarding the second, which is subsequent consciousnesses, which are sense perceptions, the classical example is a second instant of a sense direct perceiver perceiving form. Regarding the third, in other words, inattentive minds, which are sensory direct consciousnesses. The example given is the sensory perception of form in the mind stream of a being who is obsessed by a beautiful sound.
So to such a being, form indeed does appear, but the consciousness is obsessed by this beautiful sound and the form which appears is actually inattentive. It is perceived. It is it appears, but is not perceived. And there is at present after the threefold divisions of direct sense perceptions, a fivefold of direct sense perceptions. This is in the middle of page 15.
Sense perceptions holding form, which you could better translate as sense perceptions apprehending form. Sense perceptions apprehending sound, smell, taste, and sensation. Now generally speaking, Geshela says, all of these five categories of phenomena form, sound, smell, flavor and sensation are an in actuality form. They are in actuality matter. So why would one refer to the first consciousness, the eye sense consciousness here, as a sense perception holding form or perceiving form?
This is because form is actually the principal object of this consciousness and therefore in that sense one refers to the eye consciousness as a sense consciousness apprehending form. Generally speaking, every single sense consciousness has three conditions which cooperate in its arrival. The first of these conditions is its uncommon controlling condition, which in the case of an eye sense consciousness would actually be the eye organ. And what is referred to here is not the coarse eyeball, but a subtle organ within the eyeball which is constituted of subtle matter and Geshela says is perhaps in the nature of light or akin to light. And this is actually the uncommon controlling condition for the eye sense consciousness.
And the second of these uncommon conditions would be for instance for an eye consciousness perceiving the color blue. It’s so called reference condition or the object condition. This is the actual color blue. And the third condition is called the immediately preceding condition, this is the immediately preceding instant of an eye consciousness. Geshela says that every single sense consciousness necessarily arises in dependence on these three conditions: an uncommon controlling condition, a referent condition, and an immediately preceding condition.
And it is capital to understand this. Now, most obviously, the sense consciousnesses would constantly be aided in their process of perception by the mental consciousnesses. And for instance, when we speak of the eye sense consciousness perceiving a man, the main function of the eye sense consciousness is actually to perceive colors and shapes. So the eye sense consciousness itself does not necessarily understand the phenomenon perceived as a man. It merely sees the body of a man, the shape of a man, and the color of a man.
It is actually the mental consciousnesses which after can give rise to this realization. The same thing is true of the other sense consciousnesses which actually perceive qualities more than perceiving the totality of phenomena. These definitions are listed towards the bottom third of page 15. Will retranslate it. Here’s a definition first of a direct sense cognizer.
Cognizing form is a consciousness which is non mistaken and non conceptual and which arises independence on its uncommon controlling condition, which is the eye sense organ, as well as upon its referent condition, which is a form. This is a definition of an eye sense consciousness. The definition of an auditory sense consciousness is consciousness which is non conceptual and unmistaken, which arises independence upon its uncommon controlling condition, is an ear sense organ, as well as independence upon its reference condition, which is sound and so forth. So, Geshela says in the same way as for a nice sense consciousness and near sense consciousness arises in dependence on three conditions of which two are mentioned in the definition. The first is its uncommon controlling condition which here would be an actual ear sense organ which is a subtle sense organ, it’s not the coarse organ of the ear.
And the second which is a reference condition would be a sound. And the third, the immediately preceding condition would be whichever preceding instant of consciousness, whether it’s an ear sense consciousness or another consciousness is present. And the definitions of all of the other remaining three sense consciousness are posited in the same way. So for instance, if we take the smell sense consciousness, the alfactory sense consciousness, It is also posited in dependence on three conditions. The first of which is its uncommon condition, is the smell sense organ, which is a subtle form of matter within the nose.
The second, is its reference condition, is actually the smell, which can be, natural or composite smell, smells such as sandalwood or incense or whatever. And the third is its immediately preceding condition, which is whichever moment of consciousness immediately precedes it and gives rise to it. And now, for instance, regarding the gustatory or taste consciousness, it also rises in dependence on three conditions. It’s uncommon controlling condition is the taste sense organ, which is said to be shaped in the shape of a half moon inside the tongue. And its reference condition would be any taste such as the acid, the astringent tastes among the six tastes.
And it’s immediately preceding condition would be any consciousness which immediately precedes it and gives rise to it. And the final sense consciousness is the tactile sense consciousness, and this also rises independent on three conditions. The first is immediately preceding. The first is the uncommon controlling condition, which is the tactile sense organ. The second is its reference condition, is any sensation such as the smooth, the rough and so forth.
And the third is its immediately preceding condition and this itself is any consciousness immediately preceding it which gives rise to it. And at present, passing onwards to the mental direct consciousness. The definition of a the mental direct consciousness is a non reflexive consciousness which is unmistaken and non conceptual and which arises independence on the mental sense organ which is its uncommon controlling condition. So the mental sense consciousness also has three conditions which act as its conditions. The first is its uncommon controlling condition which is actually any previously existing instance of mental consciousness.
Generally speaking, Geshela says mental consciousnesses in ordinary beings are inattentive minds because it is only one there’s only one instant of mental consciousness which necessarily follows every single end of the continuum of a sense consciousness. So something which is not noticed. So generally speaking, one would indeed say that yogic direct perceivers are mental consciousness. They are mental consciousnesses indeed. Here we are actually talking of mental consciousnesses within the context of these mental consciousnesses in the minds of ordinary beings and therefore, it is more convenient not to include yogic direct perceivers within them, even though technically they are.
So the of these definitions is to eliminate the wrong views which see consciousnesses which are not direct perceivers as direct perceivers. And the other category of wrong views which sees consciousnesses which are direct perceivers as not being direct perceivers. Now, for instance, some of the wrong views involved would be those of the Vaibhashika School, which consider that the subtle eye sense organ and for that matter all subtle sense organs actually perceive phenomena. This is not accepted by the other schools or the wrong view Geshela mentioned previously, which is that reflexive consciousnesses can be mental direct perceivers, which is not the case either. So generally speaking, Geshela says that when presenting this material, it is often more convenient to present it in terms of the five sense consciousnesses and then proceed from there.
This is not the approach which is adopted in our text, but we can also follow the approach in this text, which continues with the second subdivision of mental direct perceivers into mental direct perceivers which are valid cognizers, mental direct perceivers, which are subsequent cognizers, and mental direct perceivers, which are inattentive minds. This is at the bottom of page 15 of your translation. And then regarding an instance of the first, an instance of mental direct perceiver, which is a valid cognizer, would be the first instance of a direct cognizer perceiving the mind of another being. In other words, the first instant instance of telepathic cognition, we would say nowadays. The second example would be regarding a mental direct perceiver, which is a subsequent consciousness, the second instance of telepathic cognition.
The third example would be that mental direct perceiver apprehending sound within the continuum of a being, mind is obsessed with the appearance of a beautiful form. In the mind of such a being, the mental direct perceiver apprehending sound would actually be an inattentive mind. Geshela says there would be five examples of these connected with each of the sense direct perceivers. Visual consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness, tongue consciousness and bodily consciousness. So we will stop here and we will proceed as formally.
In other words, we’ll have half an hour discussion, and then Geshela will return and answer our questions.
Key terms in this teaching
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
- valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
- A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.