Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Line in 0243 – KR.mp3
UUID: 994fe8c2-b9bb-4fc0-b9f9-833e6b3aebda
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Duration: 1h 1m
Words: 2,145
To attend and to listen to these teachings we must first generate a good motivation. A motivation in other words to benefit others. And we should do this reflecting on the fact that while we ourselves are but one, we are alone. Others are actually vast in number, they are actually infinite in number. And thinking of it in these terms, we will also realize that others are similar to us in that both ourselves and others aspire to happiness, and both ourselves and others aspire to be free from suffering.
Therefore it behooves us to try to help others on this path of freedom from suffering and endowment with happiness. And the way to do this, is first and foremost for ourselves, to eliminate all the faults within our continuum, and to perfect all the qualities within our continuum. Because even though at present we may have the wish to place others in a state endowed with complete happiness and bereft from all suffering, nonetheless we lack this capacity. And we lack this capacity because of the force within our mind stream. So just as Buddha Śākyamūni himself attained the state of perfection and then placed countless tens of millions of others in a state of ultimate happiness.
Likewise we ourselves should strive for this and listen to the teachings with this as a motivation. And therefore let us meditate for a couple of minutes on generating the Mahāyāna motivation, which hinges on the twin development of bodhichitta and the correct view themselves rooted in the generation of love and great compassion. And with this as a view, let us then listen to the teachings which the teacher shall bestow. In your prayer book, we will do refuge one b. Verse three.
You if you can’t follow Tibetan phonetic, you can read on the English on the next page too. On page five, verse six, Mandala offering. And we do the first verse and the last And in keeping with the famous quote of Aria Candrakīrti, which Rinpoche mentioned last time, indicating that the very foundation of the training in the Mahāyāna is great compassion, and teaching the mode of meditating on great compassion. We ourselves should rely on this quote to generate great compassion within our mind streams. Khedrup Je himself said that this quote of Candrakīrti is fundamental to train in great compassion. Generally speaking, as Acharya Candrakīrti explained in his great commentary, Madhyamakāvatāra, there are three different modalities of compassion or three different ways of generating compassion. The first is through generating compassion merely for sentient beings. The second is compassion which is generated dependent on phenomena in general.
And the third is objectless or referentless compassion. These ideally should be generated in turn and incrementally. Now in as much as compassion is the root of all qualities, it is necessary for us to train in meditation on compassion, and this is best done in keeping with Candrakīrti’s instructions, which are both reliable and which are very beautifully formulated. Candrakīrti, as you know, was a great scholar of ancient India. And in ancient India, and those of you who have travelled to India may have seen that to this day, there was an irrigation instrument called a noria, which is a circular irrigation system, where the flow of water leads buckets filled with water to then pour water again in the irrigation channels.
Candrakīrti used the Noria as an example of the predicament of sentient beings. In the same way as the Noria is impelled by the flow of water, which triggers the endless stream of buckets pouring water ever and again in irrigation channels, likewise sentient beings are impelled from life to life, up and down in the cycle of cyclic existence through the flow of karma and specifically through the flow of non virtuous karmic imprints. Specifically it is that constant sense of, or constant powerful sense of self, which impels beings through the cycle of lives. Here it is capital to distinguish between that self, which is nominally existing, which exists as a designated phenomenon. And this is for instance, the self of which we say, I have had a meal, or I go downtown, this I exists.
And the self which is an object of negation. This is that self which is perceived as inherently existing, or existing by its own characteristics. This very powerful self subsisting sense of I. This is a non existent phenomenon. For instance, if we were to take the case of Khensur Rinpoche’s cup, Khensur Rinpoche’s cup does exist, but it does not exist in the way it appears.
It appears as a phenomenon which exists by its own characteristics. It does not exist in the slightest in that way. However, dependent on its appearing as being a phenomenon which exists, dependent on its own characteristics, it is in turn apprehended as a phenomenon existing by its own characteristics. This example of the cup can be extended to the self. The mind which apprehends the self as inherently existing, the mind which apprehends the I as inherently existing, is that which gives rise eventually to desire and to lust.
And these in turn bind beings to the cycle of life through the fetters of karma. And returning to the example of the noria, on a noria the wooden buckets are tightly fastened to the wheel of the noria, and otherwise, obviously, they would fall away from the wheel of the noria and not fulfill their function. The ropes which tie the buckets to the wheel of the noria are in our example similar to the chains or the fetters of karma and afflictions which bind sentient beings to the wheel of cyclic existence. It is because of the karma, the fetters of karma that beings are chained to the cycle of lives and cannot escape. Likewise, in the same way as the bucket of anoria goes up and then back down, up and then back down endlessly, and has nowhere else to go but this endless cycle of moving upwards and downwards.
In the same way, sentient beings under the power of karma and afflictions can only move up and down from the higher realms to the lower realms, back and forth. Therefore, sentient beings can be said to cycle powerlessly in the cycle. That’s the meaning of saṃsāra, of cyclic existence through the power of karma and afflictions. Likewise, in Candrakīrti’s example, the Noria is powered by a servant of the Noria, a slave, who basically pulls the rope endlessly, bringing the buckets up and down to irrigate the fields, And this slave, the poor man who endlessly pulls on the rope, is none other but our mind. It is our mind which propels us up and down in the cycles of lives, in the higher rebirths, in the lower rebirths endlessly.
In the same way as Noria does not operate without an agent to activate it, In the same way, we ourselves do not cycle in the cycles of psychic existence, in the endless stream of lives, if our mind does not create the causes therefore. So the force, the agent which propels us endlessly from the lower rebirth to the higher rebirth and back is none other but our mind. Through virtuous deeds we are impelled into higher rebirth, and through non virtuous deeds into lower rebirth. And therefore in the same way as in the example Khensur Rinpoche gave of the Noria, it is our mind which conditions whether we experience happiness or suffering, both at the mundane level, and at the super mundane level. Fundamentally from the practice of virtue, happiness and well-being will accrue, and from the happiness of non virtue, only suffering will be experienced.
This we can see at the mundane level within this very life, within the operation of our mind, but also more broadly at the level of the general state of well-being and happiness within this world of ours. It is largely contingent on mental activities. Those whose minds succumb to non virtuous deeds, such as killing, stealing, or sexual misconduct, will actually go down even at a mundane level. In a broader sense of the term, from an evil cause, from a non virtuous cause, there can never arise a happy or virtuous effect. So we must put effort in a nutshell, in training in virtue, and abstaining or abandoning non virtue.
It is dependent on this and on this alone, that we can hope not to go to the lower realms, and move upwards to the higher realms, through training our minds and through specifically training our minds in such virtues as love, compassion, and empathy for others. It is our minds and our minds alone, which will determine whether we go to the lower realms or not. As Śāntideva said in Bodhisattvacharyavatara, none of the enemies of this world can throw me into the lower realms. My mind and my mind alone can do so. Therefore, let us protect ourselves from unsuitable or inappropriate states of mind.
And as Śāntideva said again, it is the mind which must be protected. Therefore this mind of ours must must be led on the path of virtue and must be led to abstain from non virtue. There is nothing else to dharma practice than this. Unfortunately, this is not something we engage in. This is something we merely talk about.
Then in the same way as returning to Candrakīrti’s example, the peasant who impels the noria, our mind impels the cycle of lives through holding on the string of delusions. And if we wish to move upwards in the cycle of lives, then we have to train in the practices of patience and morality, the various virtues associated with this. On the other hand, if we allow within our mind such evil thoughts as anger, competitiveness, or pride, then we will just move endlessly lower in the cycle of lives. And the Buddha himself will be completely unable to extend any protection to us. It is exclusively this practice of the 10 virtues, which we call morality, as well as training in bodhichitta, the correct view, which can lead us upward to the cycle of life, to the state of full enlightenment.
Without this training, the Triple Gem cannot protect us in the slightest. In other words, we are our own protectors. As Je Tsongkhapa said, all deeds are initiated from within the white and the black. The white here refers to virtuous karma, and the black refers to non virtuous karma. In other words, the karmic import of every single deed depends on the intention or motivation.
Whether a deed is good, virtuous, or bad, non virtuous, depends exclusively on the mind impelling it. Good minds generate virtuous deeds, and evil or vindictive minds generate non virtuous deeds. As Buddha Śākyamūni himself said, the number of those going from the lower realms back to the lower realms, or from the higher realms to the lower realms, are equal to the infinite number of atoms this earth of ours contains. While those going from the lower realms to the higher realms, are equal in numbers to the motes of earth which I can hold on my thumb. In other words, the overwhelming majority of beings of the six realms, these three higher realms, the realms of the gods, the demigods of the human beings, and the three lower realms, the realms of the animals, pretas, and the hell beings, the overwhelming majority of these beings end up transmigrating endlessly in the lower realms.
These are, as Buddha said, equal in number to the number of atoms of our earth. In other words, the number of beings of the higher realms are infinitesimally small in comparison to these, and it is totally the result of non virtuous karma. So if we can say that from within the infinite sentient beings, since there are countless sentient beings, the overwhelming majority transmigrate in the lower realms, or go from the lower realms to the lower realms, and a very small minority is able to reincarnate in the higher realms. This is exclusively due to the force of karma. Some in the non Buddhist traditions believe that those who can protect us from this state of affairs, and this is especially in the Hindu tradition, are for instance Shiva or Vishnu, who is greatly venerated in India.
In which he says, your countries perhaps it is Jesus. But these cannot provide any protection to the mind. The only source of protection to the mind, the only source of protection from karma is actually protecting the mind itself. Therefore, we must protect the mind. A good state of mind is what is called dharma and an evil state of mind is what is called non dharma.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.