Awareness and Knowledge — 2015-08-09

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awareness and Knowledge (TBI)
Awareness and Knowledge (TBI)
Awareness and Knowledge — 2015-08-09
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-08-09 – KR.mp3

UUID: c447587a-0c31-47b1-a47c-e54a578db38a

Teacher: —

Collection: Awareness and Knowledge

Date: 2015-08-09

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 2h 1m

Words: 12,903

Welcome back everybody to the second day of the TBI twenty fifteen symposium. We had a wonderful day yesterday, so I hope you’ve had a good rest. And we all commenced with Jumper Inion. The second topic for him, the nature of karma, how it establishes karmic seeds and imprints and how such seeds mature within the mental continuum to produce individual experience. Thank you, jumping in.

Discern. That’s flatter. Course form is, you know, relatively easy for us to discern and subtle form much more difficult. But great progress has been made over the last century in the West to discern subtle form. And yesterday, Ilya referred to quantum theory and some of the issues relating to the problem of the observer when engaged in observing form and observing subtle form and how the observer does interact with the object observed, that form that’s observed.

Coming to terms with that subtle level of form is not easy, but it’s a great of great credit to our culture, our scientific culture, that they have developed indeed great insight into the nature of form. Consciousness is even more difficult to understand because it’s subtler. By its very nature, it’s not composed of particles. So it’s quite a it’s a different level, different type of substance. But in a way that’s more important for us to understand the nature of substance of the mind, mainly because it continues where form doesn’t.

It boldly goes where, in a sense, form doesn’t. It continues. And just understanding this continuation of of awareness is extremely important. We have doubt about rebirth because we don’t understand how the substance of awareness continues. But, of course, that’s not to say that all awareness continues, whether it’s coarse or subtle.

Of course, gross sensory awareness does arise and stop. Its continuum stops. But when consciousness is said to continue, it’s really talking about the subtle level, especially the subtlest level of mental consciousness such as the clear light and so on. That level of consciousness doesn’t stop. Although it’s not necessarily manifest, it doesn’t its continuum is unending.

Form is a little bit different, although form does continue, and we can see a continuation of matter and the conservation of energy that’s described in physics, that energy does continue in one form or another, it continues as matter or matter converted to energy and so on. But the interesting thing with our existence is that we have these two substantial streams that form the basis of our existence, and these two streams link through the what? In the process of generation of existence of a sentient being. And there are many, many issues there, especially to deal with tantra as came up yesterday briefly. This idea that on the subtlest level, consciousness and form are of the same entity, the same identity, or the same sub you could say the same substance.

On a very subtlest level, they’re almost indifferentiable. But that’s a particular view of tantra that is not discussed in the others other vehicles like the great vehicle, the mayana great vehicle, the sutra great vehicle, or the hinayana vehicle. So these two substantial streams form the basis for our discussion on rebirth. So today, we’re going to continue that, again, using the classical Buddhist presentation of the 12 links. The 12 links really was taught right from the very beginning by the Buddha, and in fact, it’s an outcome of the four noble truths.

In fact, the 12 links are an expression of the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering, and this we will touch on below. We’ll use some charts just to look at this process. So, we’re going to look at how rebirth is depicted in the 12 links of dependent origination. So, in the previous paper, we looked at the five basic categories, that is and it’s good if we can remember these five basic categories, that is form, mind, mental factors, non associated formations and permanent entities, and the substance of formant awareness and their continuum. We’ve also examined the logic of rebirth in this paper.

So we looked at the logic establishing rebirth, is to do with the continuum of consciousness itself. And this whole process is described in the 12 links. So the 12 links in terms of the progress of the mind body continuum. So rebirth of the person involves the transformation of the two streams of substance that form the basis of designation of a person, the psychophysical aggregates. Death is the severance of the physical continuum while the mental continuum as subtle mental consciousness remains or continues.

For this reason, some schools of Buddhism, such as the Sarvastivadins, have depicted the progress through the 12 links of dependent origination as a progressive change in the five aggregates. So the 12 links by some schools are described in terms of the mind body continuum itself. So the Sarvastivadins make this sort of a presentation. So I thought to include this here just in the beginning. So this presentation comes from Chimzu.

Chimzu was a text composed by a well known Kadampa master called Chim Jambeiang. He lived in the thirteenth century prior to Je Tsongkhapa. He was a monk at Nhao Tang monastery. He was quite a brilliant scholar. He was a student of Namga of Chomdan Ripa Reltri, who was something of an opponent of the proponents of Kalachakra and so forth.

But he was a great collator of Tibetan texts, and he was instrumental in establishing the canon, the Buddhist canon at Natang Monastery. Jian Bei Young was his student, and they set up a dialectic college there under the Abbot Namkadrak and also with the help of some other great scholars. Anyway, Jumbay Young was a student there. He was quite a precocious student because one night he chased his teacher around the debate yards wearing a protector mask, and he was then expelled from the monastery. And he was then advised to go to Sakya, so he went to the monastery at Sakya, the seat of the Sakya tradition.

And from there, he went to China. He was invited to go to China, and he became a tutor to the emperor, the Yuan dynasty emperor, Puyantu Khan. But while he was in Beijing, he composed this particular text, which is a great and a very extensive commentary on Abhidharma, specifically the Abhidharma kosher, the treasure of Abhidharma composed by Vasubandhu. So that’s just a bit of a background to this particular these words that appear here now. So ignorance, according to the Sarvastivadins, is the mind body continuum when affliction was activated in a previous birth.

So what that implies is that affliction had a support, its support was ignorance. So ignorance is the universal support of any afflictive emotion. When that affliction arises, it is supported by ignorance. So that’s ignorance as the first link. Then formation.

The mind body continuum when any of the three types of karma, virtuous or non or meritorious and so on are activated in a previous birth. So in our case now, on the basis of ignorance, whenever we have a virtuous mental, verbal or physical action manifesting, we will tend to lay down karmic seeds in our mind stream. And this process is really quite mysterious because these imprints, these seeds are not physical. They’re really types of, what could one say, discrete potential states that remain on the basis of mental consciousness. Yep.

Oh, sorry. Yes. I was trying to oh, I’m not sure how that. How can I move it across? It’s in the middle of my page.

I’m just I can’t shift it one way or the other. Hold on. Yeah. I guess we’ll have to yeah. Yes.

Yes. They said to mark or be deposited upon or imprinted upon consciousness. But all of these terms are using, in a sense, a physical example. But, of course, in our mind stream, we in our mental consciousness, we have infinite karmic seeds abiding there together. They abide discreetly.

They don’t lose their identity. They don’t fade away. But they’re impermanent. Anyway, we’ll cover this thank you. We’ll cover this a little bit later.

So we have ignorance, then formation. The formation is the process by which karma is manifested on a mental level and then potentially on a verbal level and a physical level, and those actions or the mental actions specifically imprinting itself upon the mental consciousness as a karmic seed. Now where it’s the mind body continuum at the moment they now dealing with consciousness. The mind body continuum at the moment they link with the womb of another of one’s mother in this life, but the link of consciousness and link of birth exist for a moment and the others are continuer. So the consciousness there is the mental consciousness upon which those karmic seeds are imprinted.

But here it’s described as the mind body continuum, or the five aggregates at that point. But the process itself is the mental consciousness being imprinted with actions, imprinted with the residue in a sense of the action. Here it’s mentioned consciousness. That could also include foundation consciousness that is asserted by the mind only school. So the mind only school assert eight types of consciousness or even nine, but the eighth is foundation consciousness.

Foundation consciousness is or the mind basis of all, alaya vinyana. For those who accept the mind only view, karma imprints their foundation consciousness. For those that don’t accept cittamatran view, then it imprints mental consciousness. Then we have name and form, the mind body continuum from the moment of linkage until the development of the sixth sense basis. So, again, we have these two substantial streams.

We can see the stream coming from the past life to the present to the future. So the name and form is really the first moment of the new life at the point of conception, at the point of linkage. Linkage there meaning, the point at which the Bardo being dies and that being is conceived, reborn in the womb of their mother. Name and form there refers to the four types of awareness and the physical body. The five aggregates again.

Name and form just means the five aggregates. And name refers to the four aggregates of feeling discrimination, karmic formation, and consciousness. Anyway, we’ll just keep this simple in the beginning. Then we have the six bases. So the six bases six sense bases, like the eye sense base, the ear sense base, and so on, or the mind body continuum that exist in the utilization until the utilization of the objects through the assembly of three states, the object, the sense faculty, and consciousness.

So from name and form on, we’re dealing with the embryo in the womb of the mother. So this, we should also add that there are four types of birth. There’s birth from the womb, birth from an egg, birth from heat and moisture, and birth that is supernatural or miraculous. For most human beings, birth is by womb, but there are various instances in scripture that speak of egg egg born humans or heat and moisture born humans, and, of course, miraculous or supernatural birth among humans. For instance, Aryadeva, who was the main student of Nagarjuna, was said to have been born supernaturally, miraculously.

For a miraculous birth, then the womb is not required. Of course, the being is born complete with all faculties and so forth, just like a hell being. If we’re born in hell, we’re miraculously born. And when we’re born, we’re born complete with all our faculties’ body. There’s no gestation in a womb and so on.

So the six bases. So this is a further stage in the within the womb of the development of an embryo, especially for beings such as ourselves who were womb born. Then we have, contact. So the stage of contact, this is really stages in the development, in our development through the whole of our life of a being. So contact then is the further development of that embryo, for instance, in the womb with a mind body continuum from the point of determining the object due to the assembly of those three states, those three, the object, sense faculty, and consciousness, until the capacity to recognize that the engagement or rejection of pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral objects is the cause of bliss or happiness, suffering, and equanimity.

So it’s just a further stage in the development of that embryo when that embryo is able to begin to detect what makes it happy or not, in other words. So feeling, the seventh the seventh link is that of feeling. So this is the the mind body continuum from the time it develops the capacity to utilize the causes of those three feelings until the capacity to engage in sexual union arises. So feeling is generally regarded as that stage. So that goes beyond the embryonic stage to the birth of that being up until they reach puberty and so forth.

Then we also have now those four there, name and form, six basis contact, and feeling, are form a resultant stage of the first three, but this will come up in another chart that I’ll bring up in a minute. So then we have craving, grasping and existence, the eighth, the ninth and the tenth link. So the eighth craving is the mind body continuum associated with attachment, which exists until one enters the path seeking the pleasure of sense objects and sense sexual union. So this also focusing on craving, which is a type of attachment, but that craving is central in the, in a sense, the life cycle of a being and the existence of a being and the continued existence within samsara of a being. So this is illustrated here in the eighth link of craving.

Then grasping, the mind body continuum when intensely pursuing pleasurable objects, which are objects of craving, in order to obtain them. So this is an enhancement of the eighth link. Grasping is really craving on steroids, in a sense. Craving is the beginning of strong attachment, and grasping really enhances that. And then the tenth link of existence, the mind body continuum that activates virtuous or non virtuous karma, which are the cause producing the result of happiness, suffering, and so on, in a future birth.

Anyway, it doesn’t matter too much at present. We will go through these again. But to get a basic idea of their meaning is is very important for us, where it allows us to see allows us to begin to see how we got to where we are at present. What are the causes of our current status as a human being? And then what is our future?

It’s often said that you look to your physical body to see the state of your past mind. Look to your present mind to see the state of your future, physical basis. So our current mind is really determining our future in the present, the state of our present mind and the habits of that mind. And we can look at our current physical body and our physical situation and so on to see, to gain an indication of our past karma. So then we also have birth and aging and death.

So birth the eleventh link is the mind body continuum that connects from death or death existence to future rebirth or what is and prior existence. Don’t worry too much about that. Aging and death is the mind body continuum that constitute the four links from name and form to feeling. So aging and death really refer, we can say, to the four links from name and form up to feeling. So there is a duplication in the links.

They overlap. But it’s a causal process. This depicts the continuum, the continuum of the mind body. Now in this process, the body is given up at certain stages, like certainly at death, the physical continuum ceases in the twelfth link. And, generally, there’s a cessation from consciousness.

The third link consciousness marks a point at which also the physical, basis stops and consciousness continues. Name and form marks the point at which a new form, a new body is established. So that’s the first moment of birth in this life, just as birth itself, the eleventh link, is also marks the first moment of birth. But birth there meaning the first moment of conception in this life. Birth here means birth in the womb, not the commonly understood meaning of birth.

Right. So we’ll just move on. To another chart. So this chart of the 12 links also includes causal sequences, and it also has a column for two lives and three lives. So in a sense, it’s showing how the 12 links play out over either two lifetimes or three lifetimes.

And in fact, it’s quite a complex process because we are laying down karma all the time that may just be stored in our mind stream and not produce a result for a long time. So we have the options of almost infinite possibilities in our mind stream for playing out or manifesting as the 12 links. So this is why the practice of virtue is so important. Ethics is so important, because when ethics is manifest in our mind stream, it doesn’t create a conducive condition for black karma to awaken. It tends to prevent the awakening of non virtuous karmic seeds.

And perhaps to a degree we are aware of this, because when we’re in a bad mood or, you know, when we indulge ourselves in some negative train of thinking, at times it appears that negative things happen. But this is more on the level of completing karma. But we’ll cover this a little bit below. So we have again the 12 links, and it’s good in fact if we know what the 12 are, even if we can memorize them, and just reflect on their meaning. Now we have a causal phase.

The projecting links are ignorance, formation, and consciousness. So these are called or projecting links, something like that, throwing karma, because they project the identity of our future rebirth. So ignorance as a basis, then formation formation is karma here, karmic formation, which is referring to intention, the intention to act in a positive or negative way. That karma there is not neutral action either. It’s not neutral intention.

Neutral intention, tends is not included within this format here because maturational causes, what are defined as maturational causes or karmic causes, must either be contaminated virtue or non virtue. Contaminated virtue is fine. We should practice contaminated virtue. That’s the only option we have. We haven’t got access to uncontaminated virtue.

Why? Because we haven’t understood emptiness directly. Once we achieve that level, then we understand the uncontaminated state. All our virtue is contaminated, contaminated by ignorance, ignorance that grasps things as being inherently existent. At present, we don’t think it’s a contamination because we have a tendency to think that things actually are inherently existent.

And even if we superficially, stop asserting that, still we have innate, tendencies to see things or to grasp at things as being truly existent or inherently existent. So then consciousness. So that consciousness is extremely important, the third of the three, because, again, it’s the consciousness and the continuum of the subtlest level of mental consciousness that has no beginning and no end, just acts as the storehouse of all our negative actions and our contaminated positive actions. So nothing goes to waste. We forget about all the negative things we’ve done, of course, but those imprints remain in our consciousness.

And as it comes up in the wheel of sharp weapons, we tend to think when something bad happens to us that it’s the cause of some other being because we can’t remember how could I have committed such an action to get that result. We feel like a tend to feel like a victim in the circumstances we’ve created. But the consciousness does not, what, allow the decay of that negative karmic seed. It retains it. It keeps it.

And when the conditions arise, it will manifest like a like a thistle in a field or something like that. Something with sharp edges create problems for us. And it’s only because we’ve forgotten that even in this life, we we commit similar actions, we forget them. But here, in the main, these are coming from past lives, actions committed in past lives, and those that residue is retained in consciousness. So they’re the projecting links, and they project the mere identity, the blueprint of our future rebirth.

So that’s the first life. As I mentioned here, the first life. And there’s also a three life scenario that these 12 links can play out over two lives or over three lives. Then the next group are the projected links. Name and form, the six bases contact and feeling are regarded as, the resultant phase of the projected links.

So they’re coming directly from ignorance formation and consciousness. And again, name and form, six places, contact and feeling, are really the very earliest stages of the embryo through to the birth and development of that adolescent and so forth being. However, it doesn’t mean to say that feeling only exists at that point. Feeling then continues to the rest for the rest of the life. The six bases continue for the rest of that life.

Also, name and form in general continue for the rest of the life of that being. But these particular stages are given those names because of the prominence of name and form at that stage, six bases at that stage, contact at that stage, feeling at that stage. So we’ve been through these stages in this life already, but we probably don’t remember. Name and form stage, really difficult. Six bases stage, difficult.

Contact, so forth. But feeling, yes, we remember and so on. So they’re the projected links. Then we have a second causal phase, the eighth, ninth, and tenth link, which deal with craving, grasping, and existence. So these are stages that what are they doing?

They’re also acting as a cause, linking in a way with the first causal phase. They’re the establishing links. So the imprint that is laid down on the on mental consciousness by karma is now being awakened, established by craving, grasping, existence. So those two causal phases can occur in the first life. One can lay down a karmic imprint, and in that very same life, through craving, grasping, and existence, one can establish that karmic imprint.

And establish here meaning awaken. Awaken so that it produces a result in the second life. Now the result in the second life, again, is birth, aging, and death. So that’s the primary result. First, to be reborn there, and then from the second moment of birth, we have aging arising until the point of death.

So they’re the established links, the resultant phase, link of eleven and twelve. Now link link eleven and twelve and link four, five, six and seven really occur at the same time. They’re in a way different ways of describing the same process. They’re bringing out different, elements in a way of those of that one, stage, that is from birth to death. Now the other possibility here with the 12 links is they can occur over three lifetimes.

So that would be, if we look at the three life column, in the first life we have the projecting links. In the second life, we have craving, grasping and existence which awaken that karmic seed laid down in our mental consciousness. And then in the third life, we experience the result of name and form, that is, the establishment of the five aggregates of a third life, and so on. So this is accepted in all schools of Buddhist philosophy, the Vaibhashika, Sautrantika and so on. But there’s no other possibility.

The 12 links are either they can’t be awakened. They can’t be completed in one life. It has to be two lives or three lives and not more. It can’t be four or five. Okay.

There’s underneath, I’ve just written just something from JetSimba there, but I think we’ve basically covered that. And so what we might do is move on to another chart, which is not going to fit. Wait a minute. If I go down a bit to one fifty. Yep.

So just to have a look again at these, the 12 links. And again, this is something that if we can understand the context of our life in the 12 links, then it helps our practice. Because in in a way, it’s a blueprint to how we should act. And it’s a blueprint or it’s a guide for how we should conduct ourselves in the present moment and the necessity to keep our mind virtuous at all times, or at least to recognize when it’s not virtuous. Because we’re in danger at that stage if the mind is non virtuous due to entertaining something like anger.

We get angry about something, we start down that long, well trodden path of justifying why we get angry, then that whole process is is problematic because it’s laying down while we’re affirming the anger, we’re laying down karmic seeds. We’re staining the mental consciousness with black karma. The mind is non virtuous. The karmic seeds are black. And if we realize this, that we’re laying down karmic seeds in the mind stream, we should stop because they’re gonna remain there until they’re purified.

So there’s no nothing good or useful for us in this process. Better to stop it before we have to purify it because the only thing that’s gonna purify it is the application of the four opponent powers. So it’s either we apply the opponent once the karmic seeds are there, or we just let them manifest, which has been our our technique up to this point is let them manifest and then blame others when they manifest. Not a good strategy because blaming others, then they get angry. They start abusing us again, and we get angry again.

And in that process, it becomes extremely difficult even to get a human rebirth in future. So the 12 links are essential to keep in mind as a, a framework for ethics. And in fact, even in the studies in Sera, what came last was Abhidharma and Vinaya. And Abhidharma and Vinaya are really focused on this process. Abhidharma is very much on focused on the 12 links and the necessity of purifying our karma.

And Vinaya, again, is just the same thing. Vinaya is purifying karma by, you know, in a way from bottom up, from our physical actions, then to verbal actions, and then purifying mental actions. Abhidharma is more like the analytical approach of let’s look at the mind stream. What’s what sort of awareness is in my mind stream at present? Is it a virtuous or non virtuous?

Because that’s a difficult one. We look at our mind stream, and it’s often hard for us to discern. Is it is the mind stream neutrally present or is it bit is it virtuous? Or is it, you know, non virtuous? Or is it a mixture?

And if it’s a mixture, what’s it a mixture of? Of course, at our level, we don’t have any pure virtue. It’s all mixed. Mainly because we don’t have, the mind stream of a being of the form realm or the formless realm, or we don’t have achieved on this basis of a being in the desire realm, we haven’t achieved calm abiding or Samatha. If we attain Samatha, then we can actually generate a pure virtuous mind.

But without Samatha, without calm abiding, without control of the mind, the mind tends always to be mixed with a degree of non virtue. And I think if we look at our normal everyday mind, we can see this. There’s always we can’t fully control our negative tendencies. Negative tendencies, afflictive tendencies. The afflictive tendencies are are in Sanskrit or the.

The is another category that is explained in Abhidharma at great length. And they’re quite simple. They’re the six root afflictions. And the six root afflictions have five afflicted views, and the five afflicted views are mentioned here, wrong view, afflicted view of the self, extreme view, supreme view, and holding ethics and ritual as supreme. So with the mercy of these anusha, in Sanskrit, they’re called anusha, or in Tibetan, they’re called trage.

Tra meaning subtle, ge meaning extensive, meaning these problematic mental states that just start small and expand and tend to overtake our minds very quickly, easily, rapidly. And they’re all either non virtuous or the support of non virtuous states. So these are to be avoided as much as we can. So this chart again is looking at the 12 links, but looking at it from the point of view of the root poison and the associated afflictive tendency, the inertia. So the root poisons that are at play in the 12 links are ignorance and attachment.

And that’s why if you study the Theravada, it’s often attachment that is really brought to the fore as the first thing to eliminate, overcome lobha, overcome attachment. Because it’s really, in a way, the oil that lubricates the machine of the 12 links, its attachment. Ignorance is supporting it, but attachment is what is keeping samsara, you know, efficiently functioning. So anyway, when we look at this chart, we can see that ignorance there is also associated with the wrong view, afflicted view of the self, or that is the Yeah, just the view of the self. Jigtar in Tibetan, Jigsodla taa, the view of the transient collection is another way.

The view of the transient or the impermanent collection, meaning the view of the five aggregates. The transient collection refers to the five aggregates. The afflicted view of the self refers to the view of the five aggregates, in other words. Because the five aggregates are impermanent and a collection that are imputed as I. And then extreme views supreme view.

Extreme view is the view of permanence or nihilism, and then supreme view is holding those first three views as supreme, and then holding ethics and ritual as supreme is really just holding false paths to be paths, such as one can purify negative karmic seeds by sitting close to a very hot fire or lying on a bed of nails or punishing oneself or afflicting self harm in a way, one can burn up negative karmic seeds. So there, it’s really holding false ritual as supreme, false methods of purification as supreme. Wrong view there is the worst of all views because it denies causation. It would deny the causation of the 12 links. And the afflicted view of the self is really asserting there to be a on a coarser level, it’s asserting that there is a self sufficient, substantially existent self within the five aggregates.

So it’s what it does, it’s imputing a substance to I that doesn’t exist. There’s no because I has no separate substance. Oh, sorry. So it’s good that we know these five types of afflicted view because they also help us put into context exactly, what we need to avoid, what we need to challenge, because it’s only in a way, it’s a long struggle with these over this lifetime, our next lifetime, and next lifetime that we’ll begin to be able to oppose them and see the fault. Currently, don’t see their fault, so we can’t oppose them.

When we see the fault, that it in itself opposes them. So we have to understand wrong view, what the fault of wrong view is. All of these are supported by ignorance. Some assert that the second is ignorance itself, but there is I think Damocurty does assert that. But there is a difference between ignorance and these five views here.

They are all included within the truth of origin, and they are types of affliction. And then we have formation itself, the second link, and that’s the truth of origin as well, and that’s a projecting karma. And then consciousness, actually, it’s also it’s suffering, but it’s also regarded as a causal link there as well. Then we have name and form right down to feeling, our instances of suffering, the truth of suffering, The truth of origin and the truth of suffering, these were taught by the Buddha in the first turning of the wheel of dharma, and these are the things to be avoided. The truth of suffering is extremely important for us to recognize.

So what is the truth of suffering? If we understand the truth of suffering, then we’ll avoid it. Because we don’t understand the truth of suffering, we don’t avoid things like wrong view, afflicted view of the self, extreme view, and so on. We don’t avoid ignorance. The truth of suffering, there’s suffering it it actually could be called the truth of that associated with suffering.

Might be more accurate for us. Because all these things, the table, my body, and so forth, all of these are the truth of suffering. It’s just truth of objects that tend to produce the feeling of suffering in our mind stream. External objects, we look at them and we get attached to them. That attachment then produces it disturbs our equanimity.

We want something, and so it becomes the truth of suffering. So it’s extremely important also for us to recognize in understanding the 12 links what are truths, the truth of origin, what are the truth of suffering. In fact, they’re all the truth of suffering, but some are both the truth of origin and suffering together. So then, so that covers the first to the seventh link. And there and we notice on a causal level that ignorance is the root poison that is at work.

Then the eighth, ninth, and tenth link, eighth and ninth themselves are included within attachment. So craving and grasping are types of attachment, and they’re affliction. Of course, craving and grasping are an affliction. Why? Because, again, it’s hard for us to to to really see attachment as a problem.

We tend to think attachment we often mix love and attachment together, but it’s hard for us to see attachment as a problem and know when to, what, pull back from an object, stop the mind of attachment from engaging objects. If we understand the fault of attachment, we will do something about it. But at present, our understanding of attachment is weak, and so we don’t really appreciate the danger when attachment arises in our mind stream. What’s the danger? The danger is that when attachment is there, attachment in general is non virtuous.

So by attachment arising, it’s staining the mind stream, staining the mental consciousness with negative karmic seeds. Now some may think that this is hard on attachment. Attachment is not so bad. We can live with a bit of attachment, and it’s true, we can. But the bottom line with attachment is those karmic seeds that are laid down through attachment don’t produce happiness.

That’s all. If we understand that, then that will we’ll draw back just a little bit from attachment when it arises. It’s not in our best interest. We have to be selfish about that. It’s not in my enlightened self interest to suffer in future.

However, we have to understand the fault before we actually can act on this. And understanding the fault is extremely difficult. From beginningless time up until the present, we haven’t understood the fault of attachment. If that is the case, then it gives some measure to the difficulty. So we have attachment there and the link of craving and grasping, and they are the truth of origin, included within the truth of origin, and there are types of affliction.

Then we have along with attachment, have anger, pride and doubt listed as afflicted tendencies. So there, really the remainder of the six root afflictions are included there. Because at times, of course, anger does come up, but anger and pride comes up, and doubt comes up, but they’re not attachments. But they can be in the mind stream of a being who’s laying down karmic imprints, manifesting karmic imprints and so on. So then we have the tenth link of existence, which is the truth of origin, and that itself is establishing karma.

So there’s two kamas, two types of karma, formation and existence in the 12 links. And then we have birth and aging and death, which is just simply the truth of suffering. They’re resultant states, our birth in this lifetime, we’re born in suffering, our own suffering during the death birth process, our mother’s suffering, all the difficulties we’ve had, all this is the truth of suffering, even the happiness we have. Truth of suffering. And so on.

So this again is another presentation of the 12 links. Alright. Now we look just at the nature of karma and consciousness in a bit more detail. Now we’ll go back again just to look at these 12 links from the definitions given by Jetsunpa in his general meaning of dependent arising. Now the link of ignorance is the mental factor confused about suchness that motivates projecting karma in one complete round of links.

Right. The link of ignorance, the first of the 12 links, is the mental factor that is confused about suchness or the mental factor that just simply does not understand understand emptiness. Emptiness or selflessness. So that ignorance what is that ignorance? It’s just the unknowing.

It’s just the, you know, the bare base ignorance of of the way things actually exist on their subtlest level. So that’s the first link. So we have it at present. We don’t understand emptiness. We don’t understand selflessness.

So the first link is just there in our mind stream. The second link of formation is the mental factor of intention. So intention, again, is just that. It’s just the volition, the intention to act motivated by ignorance in one complete round of dependent arising or one complete round of the 12 links, which projects a future rebirth. So let’s look a little bit more at the nature of karma.

So I thought I would just draw on Jetsumpa, to give more detail about what intention is. So it’s the mental factor that guides the other mental factors to its object. So intention is like the ringleader from amongst all the mental factors that we have. It’s the one that gathers them together and urges them to pursue a particular object, like the sheriff and the posse. Go after this object.

But it does so by gathering certain other mental factors. Now if the intention is virtuous, it will gather virtuous types of mind to engage an object. If the intention is non virtuous, it will gather non virtuous mental factors to engage its object. So it’s like a ringleader. As Chim Jampay Young himself says, intention is like a magnet that attracts iron, for it is mental karma which activates the mind through focusing on the six objects and moves the mind to its focal objects.

So intention has this type of function, and if we stop and think about it, we realize that it does. When if the intention is negative, then it will gather to it hatred, anger, resentment, any any of the other mental factors that serve its purpose. Again, Prunavadana, another Abhidharma master, he says, how does mentation or the mental consciousness, which neither is an agent nor abides for another moment, come to have eyes as well as to act? In other words, how does the mental consciousness, which by itself doesn’t engage, initiate action, how does it come to have eyes and act? It is through intention, which is mental karma.

The mind itself, which is a bit like an elephant, is drawn to its object a little bit like a monkey leading that elephant around by the the trunk. If you’ve ever seen the chart on how to generate calm abiding, it’s a bit like that process. The mind itself is a bit like the elephant. It’s slow and sort of ponder it doesn’t move very quickly. But the mental factors, intention, leads the mind one way or another according to the interests of that being.

So anyway, now just continuing on with a little bit more information about karma, the second link. So contaminated karma is one of the three types of karma. It is, for example, a mental factor of intention motivated by cause affliction. So I’ve classified in three it’s classified in three according to its function. Projecting karma is, for example, karma merely acting to produce the nature or identity of maturation.

So this we covered. Projecting karma, which is the second link, projects the blueprint or just the identity of the future rebirth, but that’s established by the tenth link. Establishing karma is, for example, karma acting to definitely establish that nature of maturation. Okay. That’s the tenth link.

So these first two types of karma according to function. The first one is the second link, the second is the tenth link. So it gives a bit more information on that. Now there’s a third type of karma called completing karma. So completing karma is something that’s always coming to fruition for us.

Is karma acting to individually produce happiness or suffering on that basis projected by projecting karma and established by establishing karma? So our completing karma is on this current basis that we have, producing feeling, the feeling of happiness and suffering and so forth, is due to completing karma. So that’s just other karmic imprints that are laid down in our mind stream that manifest once we have a body and exist in a particular life to fill out our experience. They determine our experience. Now there’s a lot of debate on this issue as well, so anyway, we don’t have time really to go into that.

There are four possibilities. Project we can be projected by virtuous karma and completed by virtuous karma, virtuous completing karma. So we’re an example of beings who have good projecting karma and good completing karma, because we’re reborn as human, which is in the three higher realms. And we have the karma to engage in the study of teachings on our higher purpose, such as attaining liberation. We have a certain degree of wealth and comfort and health and all of these things are due to our past positive actions.

So we have good projecting karma and good virtuous completing karma. So then also we have projected by non virtuous projecting karma and completed by non virtuous completing karma is, for example, most lower migrators have both are negative. Then virtuous projecting karma and non virtuous completing karma is a short life a human being with short life and often not very well. So and then we have projected by virtuous projecting karma and completed by virtuous completing karma. Sorry, non virtuous projecting karma and virtuous completing karma is an instance such as a naga who is very wealthy.

A naga is a type of animal, like a snake or a serpent who possesses great wealth. So within Buddhist pantheon, nagas are asserted to exist. So then we have other types of karma, such as karma experienced in this life, in the next life, in the life after the next, and karma uncertain to produce maturation. So the karma experienced in this life is extremely potent karma that like the karma of Devadatta who tried to kill the Buddha, experienced that karma even in this life, which technically goes against the 12 links, but if it’s extremely strong, then it can manifest in that way. Then karma experienced in the next life, you know, there are various examples of this, and in a life after the next or in a life after the next, so not the next life, but in any further lifetime.

So we have all of those we probably in this life don’t have karma to be experienced in this life unless we’ve done something extremely positive or extremely negative. It’s only through that degree of or that type of karma, extremely negative, such as committing the five one of the five heinous actions, like killing one’s father, killing one’s mother, killing a liberated being, causing the blood to flow from the body of a Buddha, or creating a schism in the Sangha. If one were to commit those actions, then it’s possible a maturational result would occur in this life. And then classified according to how maturation is experienced, as happiness, suffering, or equanimity. And then they’re again classified in three, meritorious karma, non meritorious karma, and invariable karma.

There are many, many different classifications, and if one goes into the works on Abhidhamma, the classifications are seemingly endless. The the benefit of examining in great detail is that it just gives us more chance to understand the basic issues if we have the time to do that. But if not, you know, just to gain a good basic understanding of karma is absolutely essential for every being, really. Some people have a sort of intuitive understanding about karma, and they due to their past positive imprints, they avoid engaging in negative action without necessarily understanding the process behind it. Then we have meritorious karma, for example, the projecting and establishing karma of birth in the higher levels of the desire realm, such as a human.

Non meritorious karma, the projecting and establishing karma that is the second and the tenth link of birth in higher levels in the desire realm. Non meritorious karma, projecting and establishing of birth sorry, that’s in the lower levels, there’s a mistake there. And invariable karma, for example, the projecting and establishing karma of birth in higher realms, such as the form and the formless realm. So there’s, again, different types of karma generate rebirth in different realms, such as the desire realm where we live, then there’s the form realm, which is the subtle material realm, and then there’s the formless realm. But to be reborn in the subtle material realm, the formless realm, one needs to generate Samadhi or single pointed concentration.

And then on that basis, one is able to create immutable karma that will generate rebirth in the form and the formless realm. So then uncontaminated karma, we should also understand what uncontaminated karma is, and that is, for example, the mental factor of intention occurring through subtle exertion motivated by knowledge obscurations as its cause, but not motivated by the afflictions as its cause. This is explained as a as the cause of arhats taking birth in pure lands and bodhisattvas who abide on the pure grounds taking rebirth in samsara for the purpose of others. So bodhisattvas can do that because of the existence of uncontaminated karma in their mind streams. So that uncontaminated karma still is motivated by knowledge obscurations, but not by the afflictive obscurations.

And it permits bodysappers, highly realized bodhisattvas to take rebirth amongst us. There are other methods by which that is achieved as well. And karma which is neither is, for example, karma which is the is by nature non conceptual pristine equipoise, meaning it’s the direct perception of emptiness. That is the intention that exists in the mind stream of a being who’s directly perceiving emptiness. That intention is karma which is neither contaminated or uncontaminated.

Anyway, how karmic seeds come to imprint consciousness? The link of consciousness is the main mental cognition just marked with the imprint of projecting karma in one complete round of dependent arising. Tsongkhapa states, consciousness is stated in sutra to be the six fold collection of consciousness. So we’re here dealing with the third link again. We’re going back to the third link and just talking about it in a little more depth.

And accords with but here the main presentation accords with those who accept foundation consciousness. So that consciousness, for the mind only school, will be foundation consciousness. This, I think, is an extract from his text called Lekshe Sertrang, which deals mainly with the mind only point of view. According to those who do not accept consciousness, it is mental consciousness. Okay.

I’ll just there’s a bit of information there about the nature of potential states. Seeds and imprints. Now these are different terms that come up in Tibetan, and there’s a difference between them. Potential states that are either seeds, which tend to be coarser and when awakened transform into other mental states, and imprints, which tend to be subtle and may produce subtle results when activated. So imprints and seeds are differentiated slightly.

So that’s just as for your own interest there. Actually, there’s quite a bit of debate about this point, but unfortunately, we don’t have time. Now two forms of consciousness are presented in Songkhapa’s Lamrim Cemo, the causal link of consciousness and the resultant link of consciousness. Now what he says, now I’m just in the third line of his of that indented quote there, consciousness of that life in which the imprints of karma are laid down is consciousness at the time of the cause. And consciousness that links with the birth process of a being reincarnating in lower realms in future, for instance, independence on that causal consciousness is consciousness at the time of the result.

So Jitsong kapa differentiates two types of the third link there. One in the causal phase, one in the resultant phase to explain how it endures that karmic imprint, That karmic seed imprints the causal consciousness but remains till the state of the resultant consciousness when it awakens. However, Jetsunpa rejects that view. He has his own reasons for doing it. He says consciousness can only be causal.

But we in a sense, it doesn’t matter which way we accept that to be. Both are very useful for understanding the process of causation here in terms of the 12 links. Now here we’ve got Jetsunpa’s definitions of the fourth to the seventh link. Now we’ve covered that basically in the conversation so far. Then the eighth, ninth, and tenth link show how karmic seeds mature to produce experience of the world.

So this is the process by which karmic seeds are awakened. Excuse my spelling there. So we have craving, grasping, and existence. The link of craving is the attachment that begins to awaken the imprint of projecting karma that come exceed in one complete round of dependent arising by means of craving any of the three feelings in one complete round of links. So when one one begins to awaken the karmic seed through attachment, through craving feeling now he gives three three types of craving, craving for desire realm objects.

For example, the desire for blissful contact. So that type of craving can awaken karmic seeds. Craving for destruction, for example, the desire to be separated from suffering. That craving for destruction also includes suicide, getting to the point where one wants to destroy oneself and craving for that state in so that one is separated from a difficult situation. That craving also can awaken karmic imprint.

Craving for existence, the desire for future rebirth, craving for existence. In a way, that’s the main one. We crave to exist. We have this craving to exist, and that really becomes very strong when we’re at the point of death. At the point of death, we fear not existing, so we crave to exist.

That craving for existence really begins the potent maturation, the potent awakening of karmic seeds in our mind stream. Then the link of grasping is the attachment that strongly increases the force to awaken the imprint of projecting karma through enhancing the prior link of craving. Grasping adds to the prior link of craving and even more strongly awakens that karmic seed. And then grasping has four types. The close grasping of desire, for example, the attachment to the five desire objects.

The close grasping of view, for example, attachment to the 62 perverse views or wrong or fallacious ways of looking at things, and then the close grasping of the view of the self. Close grasping of holding ethics and ritual as supreme or false being attached to false paths that will not produce a positive result for oneself or liberation for oneself, and the close grasping of the view of a self or the view of the self. For example, the attachment attached to grasping at the self of person and to the pride thinking eye. So in other words, there’s different types of grasping that can be classified here. And then the link of existence is the establishing karma.

Again, we come back to the second type of karma, establishing karma, that accomplishes rebirth through awakening the imprint, through fully awakening that imprint. It’s being brought to the stage of awakening by craving and grasping, and then existence completes the process. That karma is awakened, and one enters rebirth, enters the process then of rebirth. So existence has four types: intermediate existence or the Bardo. So the existence occurring between death the death existence of the former life and the birth existence of this life.

Between those two, there’s the intermediate existence. So that’s one of the four types of existence. Then we have birth existence, the maturational aggregates that develop in the in the womb in the first moment of conception. That’s birth existence. Then prior existence is really the existence of that being up until the moment of the establishment of death existence.

So from the second moment of birth existence to the establishment of death existence is prior existence. It’s called prior because it’s prior to death. And then there’s death existence. So these four types of existence we go through in a cycle, sometimes quite quickly, sometimes very slowly. Currently, we’re in the we’re in the stage of prior existence.

And then we have the final two results, again, link of birth and the link of aging and death. Aging and death, just looking at those two, is the second moment of birth existence up till death existence, and the link of death is the destruction of the maturational aggregates themselves. Right. Now I just very quickly wanted to cover this fifth part, the idea of discrete potential states and the importance of their function in the mind stream. Everyone has been incredibly patient so far.

We’ve covered a lot of material. But this is an important debate that occurs in Madhya Mika. And in Madhya Mika, there are eight great difficult points, kanege. So we’ll examine here a commentary on the eight great difficult points. Now one of the eight great difficult points is called it’s really called Shippa Mopo Yimba in Tibetan.

It’s a disintegrated functioning entity. Now why this debate comes up is because it’s dealing with this issue of the karmic seed. The karmic seed disintegrates. It has disintegrated, but it continues. How is this possible?

Now for us, we tend to think that what problem is there in that? Something is disintegrated, but it still functions. But really, something that’s disintegrated is gone. How does it remain there? Anyway, we’ll just look at what Gyaltsab Je has to say because this is of central importance in establishing the existence of karmic seeds.

So a dispute arises. The opponent says, if the karmic result of virtuous or non virtuous action remained until the result matures or ripens in one’s mind stream, this view would constitute falling into the extreme of permanent since that result would be permanent. But if it disintegrated in the second moment after that action was performed, then one could not assert that a disintegrated entity was functional since it had disintegrated, and it would be impossible to assert the generation of karmic maturation or karmic result. So there’s a genuine doubt there from the side of this person, and it’s an extremely good point to contemplate. And because of those two points, he therefore says actions performed would lose their potency and become ineffective or literally go to waste if you say they disintegrate.

So this is an example of not understanding impermanence nor understanding the way things actually exist. Now Geltzab Jay states, though we do not accept foundation consciousness and so on, meaning he accepts mental consciousness as the basis of the karmic seed, it does not follow that actions performed would lose their potency because it is not contradictory for karma to have disintegrated, yet its result be generated, even though foundation consciousness is not accepted. Now the opponent says that is not established since a disintegrated functional entity is implausible. How could something disintegrate but still function? Does anyone have an issue with that?

Okay. That’s good. But, actually, it’s not easy to for us to discern the point here and the importance of it. He says it’s implausible. Buddha okay.

Now the our our side here says, your assertion is not established established because even though disintegrated functional entities are implausible, if you accept real entities, Ranzen, still we do not accept real or self characterized entities. In other words, entities that exist from their own side or established by their own substance or essence. Even nominally. And both a disintegrated and a nondisintegrated path are equal in being functional entities. So the essential point here is that the problem arises if we think the karmic seed exists from its own side or it’s it is substantially existent or substantially established because it is a type of substance that can’t exceed because it’s impermanent.

However, because it doesn’t exist substantially, doesn’t exist by the very essence of its substance itself, there’s no problem. Alright. I’ll just skip ahead a little bit. Objection. I’ll just go to this point.

Again, if disintegration is not asserted to be a fun functional entity, it would contradict scripture that states aging and death arise due to the condition of birth because birth is described as a condition for death. And the statement that disintegration is subsumed within the aggregate of formation would be untenable. So in fact, 12 links would not work if you hold that things exist from their own side, especially because the whole issue of a karmic seed enduring, although disintegrated, could not be established. Therefore, because the arising of karma is not inherently established, disintegration does not inherently exist. Therefore, since disintegration and nondisintegration that are merely posited by name alone are merely posited by name alone, they are equal in being functional entities.

So disintegration itself and non disintegration are both functional entities. And even if foundation consciousness is not accepted, one should remember the actions performed do not lose their potency, but a result is generated due to karma that has disintegrated. And as Nagajuna states, because karma does not arise, because it has no intrinsic nature, because it has not arisen, therefore, does not lose its potency. If it arose, if karma arose, then anything could happen. It could lose its potency.

But because it’s merely imputed by conception, there’s nothing there that everything becomes possible. Right. Look. I will leave it there. I just had another there was a commentary to that by Buddha Palita, but it just goes on to say the same thing, really.

Right. So we might just stop there and give everyone a bit of a breather for a few minutes because we have covered a bit of material. And, I think there’s time now for any comments on this subject matter. Any queries or? Thank you very much.

That was amazing. Can you just expand on the causes of karmic disintegration? I might have missed that. Karmic disintegration. It’s just that, in general, that which has disintegrated is generally regarded to not exist.

It has passed. The karmic So is the disintegration at the time of maturation, like where does it go as it matures turns into does it turn into the actual outcome or does it just disintegrate? Is that what that Well, it’s the basic point, if I can put it this way, is that because we think the object is existent from its own side, we tend to think that if it’s disintegrated, it does not exist any longer. So the question then is, well, how does this karmic seed endure if it’s disintegrated? Right?

If it’s What is the point of disintegration? Oh, it’s everything impermanent disintegrates. It’s one of the four characteristics of an impermanent entity. They arise, they abide, and they disintegrate at the same time. From the Sautrantika point of view, the disintegration of something is in the very generation or the arising of something.

If we understanding impermanence, we need to understand just that point. In other words, it’s not as if something arises in one moment, then abides for a certain period, and then disintegrates in the third moment. Right? If we had that view, we could never understand impermanence because nothing abides even for a moment. The moment of generation of something is its abidance and disintegration.

When we understand that, we understand subtle impermanence. The Vaibhashika schools assert that there are three phases, but the Sautrantika, the next high highest school above the Vaibhashikas, made a very clear point that this can’t be the case. The things impermanent entities just don’t remain. They don’t suddenly remain static for a moment. They just the very arising is their disintegration.

Now we have trouble with that because we think there’s something on the side of the object that’s, you know, in a way independent of the observer and so forth, but that is not the case. So it’s disintegrated, but it will travel to the next life. True. It has an outcome even though it’s disintegrated. I mean, I it sounds like a nonissue, you know, in many respects, and I was debating with myself whether I should tack that on to the end of this discussion.

But I was thinking it’s a good thing that you’ve heard of this point because it will sound odd and you probably remember it, this disintegration. What does that mean then? Something’s disintegrated, and of course it continues. We tend to think of a seed, oh, it just continues on and on and on even though it disintegrates in the first moment. How does it?

What is this process? It really points to the fact that if it existed from its own side, if it existed due to its own substance, that could never happen. It would be permanent. Everything would be permanently fixed throughout the universe if they existed from their own side. Right?

Existed due to the substance, their very substance itself. Yeah. This I was hoping we would get to that point of just having a rough introduction to this this point of disintegration. So that’s useful. Good.

Just on that point, the thing I was thinking of, as Glenys was asking the question, was we have an interest in something called reincarnation and that assumes an interest in incarnation. We have an interest in disintegration because that assumes an interest in integration. And presumably integration disintegration is there’s some notion of, like, failed integration, like breakdown because we have some notion that something is integrated. And, for example, in my life I was told I came from a broken family. And so the assumption was that there was a entirely functional family that became something called broken.

It’s a very coarse example of it, but it’s just a statement I’m making. I haven’t yet got a question, but I’m wondering if you could talk. Just in in answer to your statement or in response to that, using the word disintegration here in the sense of destruction, something being destroyed, And one of the issues we have in translating into English, these Sanskrit and Tibetan terms, is that you almost never have an exact match, and there’s always this whole, I don’t know, group of unwanted implications that arise from using particular terms. And so here, in a sense, disintegration and its opposite integration are not implied, you know, in the use of the term here. It just means destruction.

Right? The things are destroyed moment by moment. And so that state of being destroyed is just our com the common nature, really, the elements of our experience, the sense data that we experience. It’s all destroyed moment by moment. If it weren’t destroyed moment by moment, then there would be no continuum.

Right? It’s yeah. Yeah. We almost need another terminology. It unfortunately, but, yeah, this is the case.

This is how it is. And that’s one reason why I prefer using the word disintegration because destruction sounds a little bit more violent or but in a sense, that’s just what it is. Everything is completely impermanent. As they say, everything is nga mei sakje in Tibetan. Everything in this moment never existed before is completely new.

Right? No matter what we perceive by our senses, it is always absolutely new and never existed before, but it doesn’t last very long. In fact, the point of saying it lasts that long, we can’t say because there’s no limit to the shortness of a moment. Right? So in that context, we’re talking about disintegration.

But our general tendency is to think that things are fixed. And when we look in the mirror in the morning, we think, oh, that’s the same person that looked in this mirror last night. Still looks as bad as last night, but we have an idea we’re fixed, but we disintegrate moment by moment. This is extremely useful for developing detachment also. This is a in a way, it’s a fault of of impermanent entities.

They are always being destroyed moment by time. So with reference to karmic imprints, even though they’ve been added to the mind stream, they’re constantly changing, these imprints. These imprints, they are within a continuum. They’re maintained within a continuum even though they’re destroyed. They they’ve disintegrated.

But they’re not physical. They’re not physical, so that’s they’re probably a residue of the substance of the mind if one really had to decide what substance one was talking about. They’re not physical substance. If they were physical substance, we’d be full already of imprints. We’d be huge!

But they’re not. They don’t take up any room. Is disassociated perhaps closer to the meaning? Oh, karma is non associated instead of non associated. As in electrons electrostatically a little bit far apart, like just all floating in one spot but not form.

How do you mean? Sorry, I didn’t Disintegrated, look at as Sappho says, implies almost explosion, if it’s disassociated, it’s there, but it’s not all connected into a form and it’s just keeping on going. But just on that first point, disintegrated, I hope, doesn’t imply like an explosion. What it should imply is that things just, what, are destroyed naturally as one of the four characteristics of functional entities. It’s not like an explosion, it’s just they are transformed in each moment naturally and they endure as well.

I think you’re talking more there like in terms of particle theory, when you’re talking about separation of particles. But here in talking about imprints, karmic imprints, they’re not physical. They’re not even established by particles. They’re probably, I think we would need to say, they’re associated with the mind. Are they the substance of the mind?

That would be a very good one may have to assert that type of conclusion, but that’s alright because different types of form that or different entities which are the substance of the mind do exist. And in that regard, we can think about the dream form in a dream and so forth. What is that? We look at it. What is it?

So sudden states like that do exist. Not being sure if I actually heard something correctly earlier on at the very beginning of the session. Did you say that mental substance is coarser than form? Form in general is coarse substance. Yeah.

Yep. But so mental substance is more subtle. Mental substance is subtler than Yeah. Form. Yep.

Yep. I haven’t got this question quite clear, but I can sort of accept the Chitamantra view of, Alaya Vijanana, the foundation consciousness seems to make sense as a storehouse of karmic seeds and so forth. But I just can’t quite wrap my head around the Prasangika view or what, yeah, what they’re actually saying there. Maybe you could speak a little bit more about that. Well, the Prasangikas assert that there’s no need to come up with a foundation consciousness to explain where the karmic seeds collect, and they’re quite happy with just asserting that they abide, if we could say, within mental consciousness.

He doesn’t he doesn’t see or Prasangikas in general just don’t see the need for that. They can adequately explain the entire process of the 12 links without coming up with an idea of the foundation consciousness. Also, the foundation consciousness for the Chitamatrans is asserted also in relation to another type of consciousness called afflicted mentality. Or afflicted mentation is probably the term that’s agreed on. An afflicted mentation is a type of consciousness that focuses on the foundation consciousness and, what, grasps at an I, grasps it as I.

Yes, he’d grasp it as being it’s not the eye, but it so afflicted mentation. Sorry. Yes. Well, it’s klisthamanas. Klisthamanas is the one for afflicted mentation, yeah, grasping at the I, and the other one is alaya vignana.

So you’re correct. Yep. That’s right. In Sanskrit, they’ve given those names. But there is a great benefit also in holding the Chitamatran view because it’s a very subtle, profound way of looking at things.

And one of the things about the Chitamatrans is their great detailed presentation of causation and the fact that a karmic seed that exists in the mind foundation of all, when it awakens due to craving and grasping, it simultaneously produces the subject and the object. Right? So, like, the physical object we’re looking at and the sense awareness that engages that object. They come from the same substantial cause, which is the karmic seed that exists in the, what, a layer of vignana within the foundation consciousness. So it’s And for them, emptiness is understanding emptiness is just understanding that the subject and object are not substantially different.

So they have a coarser view of what emptiness is, and that is nonduality for them. Therefore, their presentation of nonduality, you know, is very, I think, very neat. Nonduality is just that the subject and object are not different substance. Again, it comes down to substance. For the Prasangika, nonduality is just that the well, they have a subtler view of what nonduality is.

Sorry? Really, that with the mind that directly perceives emptiness, no relative truth appears. So that really is nondual, non duality. I might be stuck in the view because it seems to me that the Prasangikas are just explaining the Chittamatra view from a slightly different position, that it’s not Exactly. And in fact, they’re just a refinement.

And in fact, the higher schools are often accepting a great deal of what the lower schools have said, and this is all the way through. What the Vibhashika schools asserted is in the main accepted, but it’s just reinterpreted by the higher schools, like the Sautrantikas, just reinterpreted, discarded some bits and reinterpreted the rest. But the great work there was a great work done by the Vaibhashikas in order to sort out the entire teachings of the Buddha and address all the major issues. A huge amount of work, unparalleled. Often we tend to think, well, the Vaibhashikas, you know, the lower school, what more needs to be said?

Unsophisticated. Unsophisticated. That’s right. Coarse and gross. All of these things, but really, it’s not the case.

The Vaibhashikas, even their very term, Chedak Mawa, the those that analyzed. So they analyzed in great depth, but they did make they did tend on the side of what? Interpreting substance in too coarser fashion. And so this had to be cleaned up by the high schools to reinterpret and discard some of their unsustainable assertions. And then the Chitamatrans looked at the Sautrantikas and said, okay, you know, you’re you’re pretty good.

You’re getting there, but your idea of substance is still too coarse. There is no no matter in the universe. There’s no nothing is composed of particles. Everything is composed of the substance of mind, which is a very subtle substance. So their view is Chitimatran view again is an improvement.

The Majumigans came along and then said, well, actually the Chitimatran’s are pretty good. Your idea of substance is quite fine, but still you assert things are truly existent. And that’s quite a coarse position to take. Better you assert they’re not truly existent. And still, in some of the substance you asserted like the mind foundation of all and so forth, yet that’s probably not necessary.

I just made a few adjustments. But there’s a great deal of common, there’s a common core. There’s a very broad common core that’s accepted by all the schools. Just a quick one, Jim. The, and the three types of craving, the craving for distraction, to be separated from suffering, is that virtuous?

No, I think it’s more a non virtuous craving to end one’s existence. But it’s not So the Theravadins, isn’t that their motivation? Oh, no, no. No, their motivation is nirvana, but it’s just that the definition of nirvana, again, is a little bit is good, but it’s probably not refined enough, because they want to destroy the contaminated aggregates, Right? But they lack the what could one say?

The philosophic acumen to be able to assert uncontaminated aggregates. Right? So what they’re trying to do is good. They’re trying to eliminate the contaminated aggregates, but they can’t posit there being anything else in its place. So it looks as if they’re nihilistic.

But one has got to be careful because there are those in the Theravada system who’ve attained liberation, and they attain nirvana with remainder and without remainder. And those who attain nirvana without remainder, of course, continue beyond death. So but, you know, and they realize that, but, and perhaps they would come back and teach that, but it’s not part of their philosophic overall philosophic view, so it’s it’s just an untidy philosophic residue there in a way. But no, they don’t crave for, non existence. They crave they seek I wouldn’t say crave.

They seek liberation. Sorry. Yeah. Just got yep. I was just wondering, you did mention that there was, some differences between karma seeds and karma imprints.

Could you just elaborate on those differences a little bit more, Oh, I think that seeds are often regarded as a little coarser than the imprints or the suburn and bachak in Tibetan, bija and I’ve forgotten the other one. So one I think one can say in general that the seeds also have the capacity to generate mental states when they awaken, but and they tend to be coarser. They include coarser levels of generation, whereas the imprints tend to be subtler. But there’s no hard and fast rule here because you find in the language them almost used interchangeably. But you talk of imprints, for instance, producing imprints as, knowledge obscurations and seeds as afflictive obscurations.

And even when the seeds all the seeds have been eliminated of the affliction, still imprints of that our knowledge obscurations remain in the the mind stream, and they can generate the appearance of objects. They don’t produce consciousness, don’t produce mental states. Again, there’s a lot of debate on these points. And what I’m saying now is actually coming from debates that I’ve listened to in Sera. And And at times you come across passages that verify that, but I’m mainly talking from that point of view.

Thank you so much once again jumping in for a power packed presentation and a lot for us to think about. And if you have questions over the lunch break, then there will be the opportunity to ask Ingan at the panel discussion at 04:00. Perhaps if you could join with me in thanking Jumper Ingan in the usual manner. So the next session will start with, Ilya at one point three zero and just a reminder for people who are able to, there will be a Pooja here at 06:00 and the monks will be attending. Thank you all the Geshe’s.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top