Nature of Mind — 2015-08-08

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Nature of Mind (Ilia Durovic)
Nature of Mind (Ilia Durovic)
Nature of Mind — 2015-08-08
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-08-08 – KR.mp3

UUID: b501300f-89d7-4eb0-9e4c-57530a2658c8

Teacher: Ilia Durovic

Collection: Nature of Mind

Date: 2015-08-08

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 57m

Words: 13,993

A very warm welcome everybody to the Tibetan Buddhist Institute twenty fifteen Symposium on Reincarnation and Karma. It’s my great privilege to welcome Doctor Ian Coughlan, Jumper Inyan, as our first speaker this morning. And just by way of introduction, Jumper Inyan is adjunct research fellow at the School of Philosophical, Historical and International Studies, Monash University, Melbourne and works as a translator for the Institute of Tibetan Classics, Montreal, Canada. He holds a PhD in Asian Studies and his specific interests include Buddhist metaphysics, phenomenology, humanetics and psychology. He trained as a monk in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition for twenty years and completed his studies at Jay College Sera Monastic University in 1995.

His present projects include the translation of the first book of the Compendium of Buddhist Science and Philosophy in Dharamasala and his published translations include Principles of Buddhist Tantra, Stairway to the State of Union and Hundreds of Deities of Tushita. He lives in Churchill, Victoria with his partner, Rula and Dog Pillar. And so the topic this morning is the philosophical foundations of rebirth and its central proofs and I’ll hand over to you, Jumper Inion, to talk about that. Thank you so much. I wish to welcome everyone to this presentation, the first paper on the Philosophic Foundations of Rebirth and its Central Proofs.

This is a very ambitious title. I don’t think we’re going to get anywhere near achieving that. However, we’re going to raise points that help us put rebirth into context. That would be my goal. And at the same time, not only putting the foundations or the philosophical foundations of rebirth into some sort of context, but to look at some of the proofs that exist in the traditional Buddhist literature regarding rebirth, how rebirth is proved.

So, within this, I have six basic chapters or parts: the categorization of phenomena, the epistemology of the five categories, the ontology of substance, substance as a continuum and some conclusions that may be drawn regarding substance. And the fifth one, there is more or less some elements of the philosophy underlying rebirth. And then the sixth point will be proofs of rebirth. So, if we begin with the categorization, and I think this is something that we’re all familiar with. Buddhism is full of lists when you go into it, and these lists at times appear like a barrier to understanding the meaning, but of course they’re there in order to give some structure to the statements of the Buddha because all that existed initially were these conversations that the Buddha conducted with students, with opponents and so on.

And these were recorded later. They were put down on paper. Initially, were recorded by his attendant, Ananda, and other monks he had as attendant as well. And then later, the early community tried to make sense of these statements to try and sort out what the Buddha was actually talking about. It all seemed very complex.

And so we have, from the beginning, this endeavor to understand the purport, the basic meaning of what the Buddha was getting at. And if possible, it needs to be simplified and put into really easily digestible terms that we can apply. So the project of Buddhism is not to make everything complex, it’s trying to make something complex very simple, but this process appears complex. So this is what we’re dealing with. So the categorization of phenomena.

The principles underlying Buddhist philosophy are subtle and far reaching principles that pervade the very foundations of Buddhist philosophy. These principles may be discerned by examining the ways in which phenomena were classified and defined from the very beginning of Buddhist metaphysics, such as the early period of collating the Abhidhamma, the development of the literature, the perfection of wisdom and the refinement and synthesis of tantra. These three vehicles, really the vehicle of the lower lower schools, the Hinayana vehicle, the great vehicle, the Mahayana vehicle and the tantra vehicle are basically all concerned with this process. And perhaps the greatest degree of refinement occurs in tantra. An intermediate degree of refinement of these principles occurs in the great vehicle.

And in Abhidharma, you have the beginning of the project to understand the basic meaning of what the Buddha taught. Continuing then, for instance, in Abhidhamma, was a great impetus to classify the teachings of the Buddha according to any system at hand, such as in dyads and triads and so forth. So if you look at the early Buddhist sutras, especially in the Theravada canon, you find these lists of twos and lists of threes and lists of fours and fives and these were attempts in order to make this material intelligible and memorable. If we memorized these lists, then later, you know, we could remember them easily and apply them in our ongoing meditation. However, it’s not easy for us to go back and unpick all of that, so we rely on later commentaries that condense this early information.

And so here, for our purpose, we shall take the system classifying all phenomena used by the Sarvastava Bada School, where all phenomena are summarized in the five basic categories of the 75 phenomena. Okay, just to recap, why we’re looking at these categories is that we’re trying to understand rebirth. And in order to understand rebirth, we really need to understand a number of things. And what I would like to put forward as a prominent category here is substance. And so the substance does figure quite prominently in the five basic categories.

And then those five basic categories are expanded into 75 phenomena. So although these five basic categories that we’re going to deal with first are were formulated by the Baibhashika, which were the really the Abhidharma schools. They have also proved useful for the Buddhist schools of later periods, the higher schools, so called higher schools, such as the Chitamatrans, who took the format of the five basic categories and expanded on these and so forth. So it’s something that we can use ourselves even though it’s a product of the Sabastavadens, it’s something that we can use. Our purpose here is to highlight the idea of substance that was central to the early development of Buddhism and a category whose existence was accepted, but whose ontology was profoundly reinterpreted by later Buddhist schools.

So you may well be familiar with this division into five categories. So basically, if we take all existent entities throughout the universe, on that first level we have either conditioned phenomena or impermanent entities and unconditioned phenomena or permanent entities. So that’s rather obvious to us. Although the unconditioned phenomena are not things that we think about very much, we’re not that interested in what’s permanent in our everyday lives, but in a way that is an extremely important category. Now underneath that, I’ve got a further category, primarily scientific categories and then primarily philosophical categories.

So the impermanent entities are, even in Buddhist view, they really form part of, in general, of what we may call Buddhist science. Then these other categories, primarily philosophic categories, include permanent entities and then what I’ve listed there as associated substance. Now across from associated substance, have fundamental substance. Now we will explain this more as we go along. Now fundamental substance really refers then to external substance and internal substance.

If we can look at it that way, this, I think, does help us to, what, generate a structure for our investigation. So, then we have the five basic categories and we can see then that form is external substance, minds and mental factors are internal substance, non associated formations are associated substance and permanent entities are not substance at all. Right, and then in 75 phenomena, these are really an expansion of the five categories. So we have 11 types of form, one type of mind, 46 types of mental factor, 14 types of non associated formation, and three types of unconditioned phenomena. Right.

So in a sense, anything that exists must be included in one of those five categories or in one of those 75 subcategories. Right. Now again, in looking at rebirth, what we’re looking at why we have this here is we’re looking at fundamental substance. We’re looking at the substance of form and the substance of minds and mental factors, and we’re trying to understand just the continua of these two entities, what a a material continuum is, what a mental continuum is. Now, just in brief, to expand on the meaning of those five categories, form has 11 categories and that includes the 11 types of coarse form, the five sensory objects and the five sense faculties, that is the eye sense base, the ear sense base, which are types of physical form.

And the eleventh category is a type of subtle form that appears to mental awareness alone. For the Sarvastavadans, they were referring to non indicative form. Non indicative form for them were the vows that they took as lay or ordained an ordained person. Those vows for them are regarded as non indicative or non revealing form, very subtle type of form that exists within the mind stream and acts like a levee wall or a dam wall to prevent one from engaging in non virtue. They had a really practical matter of fact idea of, what the vows were.

They were actually a physical barrier to committing negative actions. Higher schools reject this. In higher schools, the vows for instance are types of mind. They’re not physical. But the Sarvastavaans asserted them to be a type of non indicative form.

Non indicative form here meaning it doesn’t indicate the motivation creating it. The type of form that doesn’t reveal the motivation that caused it. Other types of non indicative form include the form of a dream, or these are types of form of the phenomena base. Anyway, without going into those, there are subtle types of form as well. Or for instance, the form of the four types of mental body that are asserted in higher schools.

The arya body, the body of an arya being, which are bodies of the nature of consciousness itself. Anyway, without going into those, we’ll now look quickly. We’ll now look actually at the mind. Now for the Sarvastavadans, they just clumped all the minds together in one category, all types of consciousness into one category, because they’re quite similar. In other words, for them, mental consciousness, eye consciousness, ear consciousness and so forth, the six categories are all basic basically similar in just being the simple engagement of the bare nature of an object, in accordance with the definition, for instance, that’s given in Lorig of what a main mind or a mind or consciousness is.

So one type of mind. Then 46 types of mental factor, these include all the emotions, positive emotions, negative emotions, love, compassion, hatred, anger and so forth. All of those are included within the 46 mental factors. And of course, we’re more familiar with the 51 mental factors of the Yogacharyans, of a Sangha, which are in a way an expansion of the 46 mental factors of the Sarvastavadans. And the Theravadans have 52 mental factors.

Their presentation of mental factors is extremely interesting and they talk about the 17 moments of consciousness and so on. But here, the main issue is that we recognize that mental factors are included there. Non associated formations, it’s an odd name, Dimin Duchi in Tibetan, non associated composite states. It really refers to any impermanent entity that is not form and not a mind or a mental factor. Anything else, what remains is a non associated.

Here non associated, the non there refers to not being formed. Non associated means non, what, non concordant with mind, or it doesn’t share five things in common with mind, so therefore it’s not any type of awareness. And the Sarvastavadans asserted 14 types and the Chitamatrans add a further nine types. We’ll touch on those a little bit. Permanent entities are included, are an unconditioned phenomena that exist outside of time.

This is hard for us to imagine, because everything we are familiar with exists within time. But permanent entities do exist, such as space, such as analytical cessation, non analytical cessation, and higher schools also add suchness, emptiness, thusness and so on, which are again permanent states. All of these permanent states, which are extremely important, are negations. They’re either implicative negations or non implicative negations. For instance, space is defined as the non implicative negation of obstruction.

So just the lack of obstruction anywhere is a permanent state. It’s not composed of any substance. Substance, on the other hand, pervades all impermanent entities. All impermanent entities are regarded as a type of substance. And this view continues from the lower school of Abhishekar through the Sattrantika, through the Chitamatran and through to the Madhyumika.

They all accept this. Impermanent entities are a type of substance. Anyway, we’ll progress to there soon. Now we’ll go on to the next part here, the epistemology of the five categories. So here, we’re looking at those five categories and how they are understood.

How do we know the existence of these five categories? So, categories are really understood in three different ways And they are subsumed in the three types of phenomena, that is perceptible objects, obscure objects and extremely obscure objects. So if it exists again, we have this three fold category of all existent entities. They’re either perceptible, obscure or extremely obscure. Perceptible is everything that we see in this room with our eye consciousness.

It’s all perceptible. And eye consciousness itself is able to eliminate doubt about its existence or not. If we have any doubt about the existence of a physical entity that is an object of eye consciousness, we just look at it and just by looking at it, that eye consciousness is able to establish its existence or not. This is self evident to us. It’s common sense.

So they are perceptible objects, Obscure objects such as impermanence because even though we look at we could look at a glass of water for weeks and weeks, but that eye consciousness is never going to discern the impermanence of that glass of water. It’s too subtle for eye consciousness to engage. Impermanence can only be engaged through conception, our conceptual awareness through valid inference. So only through valid inference can impermanence be understood. And extremely obscure objects such as karmic results, the fact that a positive feeling of happiness arises from an action committed eons ago in a distant, far distant place, this is extremely obscure, but again, this can only be established through reasoning.

Right. So then we can just skip down to how the five basic categories are apprehended. Now if we look at the basic category of permanent entities such as emptiness, selflessness and so on, these are obscure objects which must initially be apprehended through valid logic. Thus, Sarvastivadins assert three categories to which other schools add a further category such as such. We’ve covered that point.

They give space, analytical cessation and non analytical cessation as the three types of permanent entity. These are important categories. Non analytical cessation is a cessation that arises or that exists merely due to the lack of conditions coming together to produce a result. So the fact that, you know, something doesn’t exist in front of us like there’s a table not in this space here, is that someone has not brought it there. So the lack of a table being there is a type of non analytical cessation.

So we deal with these all the time. They are permanent. The syllogism proving the existence of space is something like take space in the East, it is space because it is the mere non implicative negation of obstruction. Now that reasoning itself is able to produce an understanding, a correct inference of what space is, a valid conception of space. But in order to generate that correct conception of space, we have to meditate or contemplate that type of reasoning over a period of time.

And there are many factors that need to come together. But this is this type of reasoning is like, you know, in a very real sense, it’s just the formalization of the common sense that we apply regularly in our everyday lives. If we take something like the non associated formations, we find in that category both obscure objects and extremely obscure objects. So let’s have a look briefly at some of these categories of non associated formations. So within that category, we have such things as obtainment, non obtainment.

This is according to the Sarvastavaartans. Homogeneity. Homogeneity is the fact that this really is also indicative of a continuum, that things continue to exist similar to the previous their previous moment. There is a tendency for things to continue to exist in a homogeneous state. Non discriminator, that’s a being who possesses the meditative attainment of non discrimination.

Then meditative attainment of non discrimination, the meditative attainment of cessation. So these are meditative states that are attained through generating calm abiding and upon that developing insight and entering particular states of the form of the formless realm. So they’re also regarded by the Sarvastavaadans as non associated formations. The faculty of life force, the life force that we possess in our mind stream, is also similar. It’s also this type of it’s not consciousness, it’s not form, it’s something other.

The four characteristics of conditioned states such as arising, aging, abiding and impermanence are like that and the collections of words, sentences, letters and so forth. So these are this fourth category. And then we also have nine categories that are added by the Yogacharyas, and they include things like continuance. These all are to do with causation, and it shows the Chitamatran, the mind only school’s focus on causation. So continuance, the unbroken continuum of causations since there can be no causation devoid of momentariness and continuity.

Distinction causal virtue and non virtue producing distinct pleasant and unpleasant results and so on. Wealth wealth is a subject that they include here. Compatible and appropriate resources that are the result of generosity. So actually, this is looking at karmic causation here. Speed, the swift occurrence of cause and effect.

Sequence, cause and effect arising serially and not simultaneously. Time cause and effect in terms of having ceased after arising, having not arisen and having not ceased after arising and so forth. Those are the past, present and future. Place physical causation existing in the 10 directions, enumeration, collection and so forth. So the type of syllogism that’s applied here to prove or to generate the correct conceptual understanding of this category of non associated formations would be something like the following: impermanence.

Actually impermanence is included as the eleventh of the 14 categories of non associated formations. Take a thing or take anything. It is impermanent because it is momentary. Now that syllogism, if we contemplate it, eventually is able to establish the correct conceptual understanding of impermanence. In general at present, we don’t understand impermanence, Even though it appears to us continuously, the fact that everything is momentary does appear to our sense awareness.

Otherwise, these objects couldn’t appear. Their subtle impermanence appears to us, but we don’t recognize it. It’s as if it’s an object that appears that is not ascertained by us. In order to ascertain it, we’ve got to go down to a conceptual level and contemplate the nature of impermanence. And so this type of reason, there’s many reasons that would establish impermanence, but we have to think about its momentariness, the momentariness of everything, and establish what being momentary means.

So we prove the existence of impermanence. Now, Syllage is improving the existence of an extremely obscure object such as distinction or continuum. We can take the subject. Now here’s a take the scripture stating, from generosity comes wealth, from ethics comes happiness, which was a statement of the Buddha. It is non deceptive with respect to the meaning it teaches because it is scripture verified through three examinations.

Now without going into what the three examinations are, in other words, it’s saying that the speech of the Buddha is valid because that scripture is verified through the three examinations. It is not harmed by any of the logic supporting the three types of phenomena. In other words, we can also say the Buddha is a valid being, so therefore what he states is valid scripture or valid speech, so it can be accepted. At the same time, we need to remember that the Buddha said, monks and scholars, just as you test gold by burning, rubbing and scratching it, so too test what I say. Do not accept it merely out of respect.

So we really have to investigate scripture itself to develop conviction that those words are valid. We can’t simply accept them as valid without this type of proof that a description verified through three examinations. Otherwise, it can’t help if we don’t basically understand the how it is valid, how it is authentic, in reading it doesn’t help us much. We really have to penetrate to that deeper level. Now the basic categories of form, mind and mental factors such as a tree and so forth, the disturbing emotions and so on, are in general regarded as perceptible.

Right. In general, they are not established by logic but by the process of sensory perception itself and so forth, not only sensory perception, but therefore in general, coarse form, now we’re looking at these three categories and why we’re looking at these three are they are the substance which is imputed as the person, mind, form, mental factors. And rebirth itself depends on the continuer of those three. So how do we establish they exist? We establish they exist because they are perceptible objects.

In general, they are not established by logic, but by the process of sensory perception and so forth. Therefore, general, coarse form is perceptible since it is established to exist by sense perception directly or explicitly. So for instance, we know that a table or the wall here is painted orange. We just have to look at it and the doubt, any doubt we may have had is eliminated. When the doubt is eliminated, we know that we have valid perception or a valid awareness of that object.

There’s only valid awareness will eliminate doubt about it. And in our lives, we’re continually trying to overcome doubt about things. But sensory objects are very easy. We just listen, we look, we smell, we touch. If we don’t know if something is water or glass, we’ll put our finger in it.

If we don’t know whether something is hot or cold, we’ll put our finger near it. Maybe in it as well, but so often we’ve done that rashly. So here, external form, we know to exist because we can what is external form? It’s divided into five categories and its external form is the object of one of the five physical senses. And each of those five physical sense faculties engages a different object.

But we won’t go into that. That’s an extremely important area as well. Subtle forms such as form of the phenomena base, it’s got an ugly name. It’s a complicated name. Just means subtle form like the form of a dream or fundamental particles that even though those fundamental particles appear to our hand when we touch something, we can’t discern a single atom or a single molecule or even a subatomic particle.

It’s just far too subtle for our hand to register. And that must be therefore, subtle particles and so forth can only be ascertained through valid inference, through valid reasoning. Coarse awareness, such as sense awareness, is perceptible since it is established as existent by a sense perception directly or implicitly. Our awareness itself, we don’t have to formulate a reason to say, ah, this morning I’m very happy. What reason could we and we look at it.

It’s absurd. We don’t. We know when we’re happy. It’s an internal reality. No one else experiences it.

It’s a qualia. But we don’t need a positive reason because indirectly, the awareness itself understands that it exists. Is this true? Something that we need to examine. Okay.

So generally, sense awareness will prove its own existence. Conception also. So we can prove the existence of awareness. The only doubt about awareness we may have is is awareness physical or mental? Is it physical or non physical?

And of course in our society today, there’s a lot of doubt about this area whether awareness is in fact physical or not. And many do assume that it is physical. It’s just the brain. And of course, in thinking in that way, from a Buddhist perspective, it’s the worst possible philosophic approach because it instantly denies rebirth, denies karma. So it’s not a view that should be lightly taken up.

It is in fact it falls into the category of wrong view, very destructive wrong view. So anyway, subtle awareness is imperceptible and must be established by valid inference. For example, an example of this is mental perception, one of the four types of perception asserted by all schools. It lasts for one moment at the cessation of sense perception and cannot be detected by those who do not realize impermanence. So the four categories of perception, we have sense perception, mental perception, yogic perception and self perception.

Self perception is asserted by the mind only school and so on. But here, mental perception, we have it, but we’re always it’s imperceptible or it’s subliminal for us because it only arises for a moment at the end of sense perception, where there’s a moment of mental perception registering the object at the very end of mental perception sorry, sense perception. It only lasts for a moment, so we don’t we’re not aware of it because we don’t understand impermanence. If we understand impermanence, we can detect it. So that mental perception for us is imperceptible.

It’s not something that mental perception itself can verify for us. So this brings us to another question, how is awareness established? How do we know we know? According to all schools according to the schools that assert self perception, such as the Sattarantikas and the Chittimatrans, awareness itself is an internal reality whose existence is established by self perception. Why these schools assert self perception is to establish awareness.

They assert another type of awareness that confirms the existence of awareness. Other schools who do not assert self perception, such as the Prasangika, assert that the existence of coarse awareness is established by awareness itself indirectly, without relying on valid inference. So there is this differentiation in Buddhism about how our awareness, our simple awareness, is established. None of these schools regard coarse awareness as obscure or something that requires the formulation of a syllogism in order to first establish that it exists. For these schools, the act of awareness itself is self evident and the fact that it exists as a non physical substance is also generally regarded as self evident.

It’s interesting when I talk to Tibetan scholars, Tibetan Geshis and so forth, this idea that awareness is non physical is just taken as a given. Really, it’s no one, at least in Tibetan culture, really seriously has questioned this or even, you know, in general in Indian cultures and so forth. Where the question does arise is from the materialists, those who have a materialist view or support a materialist philosophy such as the Charvaka or the Lokayata in Indian philosophy, or materialism as it exists in the West in its various forms. So in a sense, for us, in our culture, it’s not taken as self evident that awareness is non physical. And so this is something that we bump our noses against all the time, and it’s something that we need to question very deeply what, you know, when people assert that happiness is, you know, gonna be a pill at some stage or by manipulating the genes, one can or by investigating the genes, one will find the gene for happiness or the gene for sadness or the gene for whatever else.

That that type of search is predicated or it’s based on an assumption, a philosophical assumption here that feeling itself is a physical entity and so on. Anyway, this is something that goes against the traditional Buddhist view of these things. So then just as a few further points to tack on to those. However, although awareness itself establishes it exists, it may not be able to establish that it is valid or not with regard to its object. And so, for instance, in LORIG, we have these two categories of self ascertained or self determined valid cognition and other ascertained valid cognition.

And these are types of awareness that are able to ascertain whether they’re valid with respect to a particular object or not. For instance, Pervichog gives five categories here and within that, we can see that there’s valid sense perception, seeing function and so on and so forth. So the ascertain valid cognition are in fact things like valid inference valid inference oh, sorry, are things like if you see something in a distance, you know, like a shape or a color, you see a shape on a distant hill and you can see the shape clearly, but you’re not sure whether it’s a shape of a human or the shape of a stump of a tree or something. That sense awareness is valid with respect to the shape, but not with respect to whether that shape is a person or not. So it’s other determined valid awareness because you have to walk up closer to the object in order to determine whether it’s a human or not.

So we have these types of instances also, and these are debated at length in Lurie and so on. With respect to whether awareness is directly aware of itself, we should examine our own experience and whether we have doubt about our ordinary experience. If we don’t have doubt about what we experience, we can assume that we recognize or we ascertain awareness. The fact that not having doubt about it implies valid ascertainment and that we indirectly comprehend the existence of our mind. However, it is not asserted in any Buddhist school that the mind can directly or implicitly comprehend itself, explicitly comprehend itself, for this would invoke the fallacy of internal contradictions, such as a knife being able to cut itself and so on.

For this reason, even though the omniscient mind of a Buddha is said to comprehend everything, it does not do so explicitly or by the object appearing to that mind, for the mind of omniscience only knows itself indirectly and not by itself appearing to itself. The mind doesn’t directly or explicitly comprehend the mind itself, because that would be a bit like a knife cutting itself, but indirectly, through that object not appearing, it comprehends it. Is that okay? The mind itself can understand that it exists indirectly, right, But not directly. Here directly means that it appears as well.

The mind doesn’t appear to itself, but indirectly the mind is aware of itself. Right, so what we’ve looked at just briefly here are these five categories and how they’re ascertained. Primarily what we’re looking at is substance and we’re looking at the substance of mind, mental factors and physical form. And why we’re doing that is because it is the five aggregates, the what? Five aggregates which are the mind body continuum that we possess, are the basis of imputation of the person and it’s the mind body continuum that is the essential element of rebirth.

Now I have a further section here, the ontology of substance. Now, I think we’ll make a start on this. I’m not sure whether we’ll finish the entire section, but I want to continue with the sections after this. So we’ll look at this a little bit. So ontology of substance, we’re looking at just how in Buddhism, in the four major schools, substance is treated.

So we can start there with, It is difficult to find a formal distinction, definition of substance in Buddhist texts, implying that it is taken to be another self evident category. If we try and find what the definition of substance is, we don’t find it. However, it is referred to in different ways. For instance, it is described as not something merely imputed by term and conception, but something capable of function unable to establish the purpose of beings. Something practical, something that we can pick up and use, we can eat it, we can sleep on it, we can look at it, we can, you know, be heated up by it or all of these things that have a function that benefit us physically and mentally and so on.

These are what’s generally referred to as substance, substantive thing. However, this description of substance excludes schools such as the Prasangika, who themselves assert the existence of substance. The Prasangikas assert that substance exists, but they don’t regard it as something not merely imputed by term and conception, because the Prasangikas assert everything is merely imputed by term and conception. But the lower schools tend to think that these obvious physical objects that we use, they’re not just an abstract thing, something imputed by the mind, but they really exist, you know, substantially there. They exist by their very substance.

So there is a distinction here. Prasangika’s assert substance exists, but they say it’s merely imputed. There is substance, but it’s always merely designated by conception. So there is a development of an increasingly more refined modes of interpreting substance that you find within India from the earliest period right up to the fourteenth century when Buddhism more or less disappeared in its formal form in India. The unfolding ontologies of substance forms a yardstick in the evolution of Buddhist view, where higher modes of an interpretation of substance rest on earlier non final modes.

Further, this ontology is established only in dependence on the referent field of the phenomenology of substance. Though both phenomenology and ontology are mutually dependent, we will discuss the ontologies of substance here. Okay, the Sarvastavadas. Now this school equated substance with function, where all functional entities were regarded as substance since they were capable of function. This substance was functional or that functional essence which established the nature of an entity.

It’s a functional substance. The emphasis especially is on function. However, unlike Sartrannica’s Chitamantrums and Madhyamikans, they also held that unconditioned phenomena were types of substance. The Sarvastavadans were so absorbed with the idea of substance and the fact that if it had any value, it needed to be of substance that they equated permanent objects with a degree of substance such as selflessness and so on. But this was taking it far too far, of course, that could not really be accepted.

They asserted that functional substance was substantially established, which was tantamount to asserting that all entities were truly existent. However, they did not assert that all entities were substantially existent, for only those entities whose substance was separately established were substantially existent. These are subtle distinctions that the Sarvastavaadans made themselves. And also, substance was delineated as a relative truth or ultimate truth dependent on the way it was held by the mind itself or discernment. The Sarvastavaans asserted a relative truth was a type of substance which when destroyed or separated into its parts by the mind or discernment, was no longer held or engaged by that discernment.

So if you had a vase and you smashed it, it would no longer be observable as a vase because it would only be the parts of a vase there. So this was an indication that it was a relative or a conventional truth. On the other hand, ultimate truth was a type of substance which when destroyed or separated into its parts by the mind, it was still held or engaged by that mind. So things like space, no matter how small you divided space up, you would still come up with the same basic space. So that was regarded as an ultimate truth.

So what we can discern from this is that the lower schools had a very coarse appreciation of what substance is, and that coarse appreciation, they applied to the path, to the four noble truths and so forth. But this was an unskillful application of the idea of substance, because substance could really only ever be established as being impermanent. And there were different ways in which they asserted substance. Now here we have four different ways that the Sarvastavadans asserted substance. We won’t go into those four different ways.

We’ll just quickly look at the Savastivatan assertion of selflessness, which was the analytical cessation of the self of a person, was a type of permanent substance. And they had suited two types of selflessness, coarse and subtle. But again, even how they defined selflessness was very much associated with substance itself. So therefore, a single the denial of a single permanent self powered or autonomous self was a type of coarse selflessness for them. And subtle selflessness was defined in terms of a denial of a self arisen, substantially existent self.

So we can see in the level of subtle selflessness that the Sarvastavaadans assert, substance is absolutely central. And what they meant there is that within the five aggregates, the mind body continuum, where there was no separate substance of a self that was itself established by that very substance. Now for us, we have doubt about this, whether in fact within our mind stream, within this continuum we have, that there is a controlling self. There is a type of substantially existent self that’s come from the past and progresses into the future. But that sort of self is denied even by the Sarvastavadhanas.

So then we look at Sartrantica. The Sartrantica are the next school, the next higher school. And they originally were part of the Sattravadans according to Vasumitra. In India, there were schools that were initially part of the Sattravada movement, but later they separated themselves. And they rejected the reason why they separated from the Sarvastavadans is that they rejected this idea of permanent substance.

It just didn’t make any sense. Okay, we’ll just continue a little bit longer and then everyone is being very patient. There’s a lot of material that’s being covered here and I’m sorry because we’re skipping from one thing to another. Sometimes we’re able to come back to it later on, but so forgive me for that. There are many interesting and important issues that we’re not able to go into in great depth or further depth at present.

So they rejected the Sattrantika. We’re a great school of Indian Buddhism and a great improvement on the Vaibhashika or the early Abhidhamma schools. They rejected, in fact, they rejected all the Abhidhamma literature of the Vaibhashika schools and that’s why they’re called Sartrantikas. They believe in sutras. They’re the ones that only accept what’s stated in sutra, because when they looked at the Abhidharma material that was presented by the Sarvastavadans, by other schools, they thought all this discussion on permanent substance is useless, it’s wrong.

So they threw out all the Abhidharma literature and so they were called followers of Sutra. Still, they accepted the basic presentation of subtle and coarse selflessness that the Sarvastavadans put forward because that was based on the teachings of the Buddha as well. Okay. Now there’s a lot of information given in these paragraphs here, I’m just wondering. Okay, we might just skip to this next paragraph.

The Sartratigar assertion that only permanent entities with substance was accepted by later schools as a basic tenet. On this basis, Sartrantica had developed a penetrating analysis of cause and condition, and in particular, they emphasized the importance of seeds and latencies within mental causation. But Sartrantica has really closely examined the whole idea of how awareness arises from seeds, from a seed level, or latencies or imprints. They also expanded the phenomenology of mind by asserting a first type of non conceptual awareness called self cognition. They asserted this type of self cognition, which we’ve just mentioned before, a type of cognition that proves the existence of mind itself.

And this was regarded as an improvement because it was something that also was accepted by the Chitimatran School, a school higher to the Sattrantikas. In In brief, brief, their assertions regarding substance causation, self cognition, etcetera, formed the basis for the later development of the Chitamatra. Even their assertion that substance was an ultimate truth and truly existence was affirmed by the Chitamatrans. Though the Chitamatrans affirmed the central place of substance within their view, for them, all entities were a manifestation of the intrinsic essence of the mind itself, and this essence was far subtler than the external substance of matter, formed from an accumulation of particles which was asserted by the Sattrantika. So Chitamatrans then moved beyond what the Sattrantikas had to say and developed this idealist view of substance.

And what we should also mention here too is, even though mind and mental factors are types of substance and form is a type of substance, There’s a great difference in how coarse form is in comparison to mind. Mind is a much subtle level of substance and this was something that was understood by all the schools, but it really became evident in the Sautrantika presentation and then even more evident again in the Chitamatran presentation. So if we look briefly at the Chitamatra ontology or the Chitamatra version of substance, Tibetan scholars source the Chitamatra view in the third turning of the wheel of dharma at the Shaili. However, it was not until Asanga who lived nine hundred years after the Buddha that this view was explicitly delineated or taught. This was a period in which the views of the Savastavada Abhidhamma were overshadowed by the views of the Sattrantika and Madhyamika.

The genius of the Chittimatran School was initially to reinterpret the nature of substance, which had been clarified in the works of the Sartrantica School, as previously mentioned. The Chitta Matrons did not affirm the Sartrantica’s coarse presentation of substance, for the Chitta Matron, although form was not awareness and the continuum form and awareness retained their distinction, the substance of awareness was the ground supporting all substance and it did not support a coarse external form composed of particles. The Chitamatrans held that substance, the subtle substance of awareness and its dependent and its attributes formed the three characteristic. So the Chitamatrans really held that there was no external form. There was only internal form.

There was no extension, that the substance of form was just the substance of the mind itself. It wasn’t mind, but it was the substance of mind. There was no external reality. So in within that, they made a presentation of the three characteristics, dependent entities, imputed entities, and perfected entities. So dependent entities included form and awareness.

Imputed entities were such things as space and so on, selflessness, they were merely imputed. And, sorry, perfected entities were then selflessness, emptiness and so on. Imputed entities were relative or conventional truths that were generally permanent. Actually, it would be useful if we had more time to go into more of the detail of the Chitamatran view because especially because the Chitamatrans had a great and extensive presentation of causation and of this a presentation of how the seeds that exist within the mind stream manifest, how they are awakened and manifest, and how this process actually occurs in an ongoing way for us, establishing the whole field of our experience. Still, we just take note here that the Chitimatrans had a subtler idea of substance.

They denied external forms, so therefore they denied external coarse substance. They’re only interested really in subtle substance. Because if there is no external reality and everything is just exists within the mind itself, then we can see that substance itself has become very subtle. It appears as coarse, but it’s not coarse. So they’ve really refined the idea of what substance is.

For them, substance is only the substance of the mind, and the mind itself is subtle in comparison to form. I’m just looking at the clock, making sure we have enough time to get to the minute. We’ll just skip down and do the last paragraph here. The Chitamatrans denied external form and rejected the Sautrantika tendency to reify the external universe. By asserting the mind to be a stable, truly existing ground supporting all causation, they rejected what they held to be the nihilistic tendencies Nagarjuna and the Madhyamikan school, who denied the true existence of mind.

Their view of substance is therefore seen by many later scholars as a bridge from the Sattrantica to the Madhyamika. Still the Chitomerans were affected by similar idealist tendencies that had influenced the Savastavadans, who had asserted a quasi permanent non transforming essence which acted as a stable, truly existing ground for the causal manifestation of substance. The Chitamatrans instead asserted a stable, truly existent foundation consciousness, within which embedded seeds simultaneously generated all substance experienced within the duality of subject and object. However, by denying external substance and affirming only internal substance, the Chitamatran view of substance was far subtler than the Sattvastava or the Sattrantika, yet it was still not the ultimate, the final view. I think that the more we look at these views, the more we see that substance is really an essential issue right from the beginning and it’s something that can act as a focal point for our investigation of Buddhist view and it’s something that differentiates the different schools.

Now if we look again at the higher school, Madhyamika, Madhyamika view confirmed with the second turning of the wheel of dharma and in such sutras as the Ratnakuta, the 8,000 verse Prajnaparamita, and so on. These sutras were recorded as early as 100 BC and so forth. Among the Andraschools and their emergence marks the survival of the Mahayana doctrinal stream, the Madhyamika appeared to die out in the early period and was revived by Nagarjuna maybe in the first century AD. The Madhyamikans, like the Sattrantica, asserted all permanent entities were substance all impermanent entities, sorry, were substance and rejected permanent substance, a non transforming impermanent substance. There were two doctrinal streams, the Madhyumika of the Madhyumika.

The Svatantrika asserted that all substances lack true existence, therefore the pure substance was subtler again than that of the Chitamatrans, who asserted that the subtle substance of awareness was truly existent. So the Svatantrika Madhymekas were subtler than the Chitamatrans because they asserted that there was no truly existent substance, which meant that there was no substance that exists in the way that it appeared to exist. Yet the Svatantrika asserted that substance was inherently existent, existing from its own side and established by its characteristics, since substance was findable within its basis of designation. If we try and find substance anywhere, we can find it. This is something that was asserted by the Svatantrika school.

Still, the view of substance is extremely subtle, but there was this point where they asserted that substance itself was findable in its base of designation. And by holding this view, they maintained a basis for asserting that some entities, such as vases and so on, were substantially existent and some were imputed existents. So therefore, the Svatantrika Madhya Meegens also asserted that a table was a substantial existent, whereas a person was an imputed existent, because they still recognized a certain level of what, inherent existence within an object. This was something that was rejected by the Prasangikas. Then we move to the Prasangika.

Prasangika however rejected that substance or any permanent entity was inherently established or findable within its basis of designation. Thus, for them, the final mode of abidance of any substance was that it was merely imputed to exist by conception within its basis designation. Therefore, no substance was substantially existent. If it’s not inherently existent, it can’t be established as substantially existent. Now although this point follows, it’s hard to really grasp, but it’s extremely important because substantial existence is asserted by all the other schools.

You know, this would be a substantial existent. Why is it a substantial existent in the lower schools is because in order to recognize it, one doesn’t need to recognize anything else other than it. That’s the criteria that’s being used. But even for Prasangika, it’s not a substantial existent because not on that definition, it’s not a substantial existent because it’s not established by substance, because it’s not inherently existent. So it goes back to the same argument.

For the Prasangika, this lack of inherent existence of substance was the central object in relation to which transcendent wisdom was to be established. This also appears to be the present day upon the matter of ones of substance accepted by Atisha and the later followers of the Kadampa tradition, including the Gelugpa. Right. Okay, so we’ve just again looked at the ontology or the mode of abidance of substance there in the four different schools. So now we come to the substance as a continuum and a person.

In the five categories, a continuum may be identified as the non associated formation of continuance, which refers to the unbroken continuum of causation that is defined by momentariness and continuity. In fact, of those nine categories that the Chitamatrans posited for non associated formations, one of those really is the identity of the continuum. In terms of a physical continuum, there are two broad divisions. On a subtle level, is the continuum of the eight fundamental particles, such as the fundamental particle of earth, which refers to the great element of earth. The existence of the eight fundamental particles was accepted by the Prasangikas.

If we look at subtle form, here we’re looking at establishing continuation of form. From a Buddhist point of view, subtle form is composed of atoms, which have levels of subatomic particles associated with them. So there are four the four elements, the great elements, such as the element of earth, water, fire, and wind, each exist as subtle particles. And then there’s also the particle of form, aroma, taste and tactility, four more particles, meaning eight subtle particles. Now this doesn’t anyway, there’s much to be said about this presentation, but even the Prasangikas were willing to accept the existence of these eight subtle particles.

This can present a bit of a problem in Buddhism because, of course, we have the scientific view of what an atom is composed of, which is the nucleus and the electrons spinning around the nucleus and they don’t accept this hypothesis of eight subtle particles or fundamental particles. Anyway, just an aside. Coarse level of the continuum of a vase is the stream of substance that continues from moment to moment. So we can see continuum existing on a subtle and a coarse level. In terms of awareness, the subtle level of awareness the continuum of awareness is this continuum of the shortest moments of awareness.

And on a coarse level of awareness, the awareness we have over the duration of our life. Okay. The first part, actually, the continuum is a stream of substance over an extended period of time, is also mentioned by Vasubandhi, for instance, in his auto commentary to the Abhidharmakosha. The first part of a continuum is arising, its severances, disintegration, it itself is abiding. Specific earlier and later moments of that continuum are just the transformation of abidance or the way that the abiding entity transforms.

So it’s just this continuation over a period of time, first moment, second moment, third moment, fourth moment and so on. This is obvious. The occurrence of that which was not previously existing is arising. Abiding is the continuum. Disintegration is severance.

Specific earlier and later moments of the continuum are asserted to be the transformation of abidance. So that transformation is what the continuum is about. And the continuum is identified as a homogenous cause. This is one of the five causes that comes up in early Buddhism. Anyway, therefore the basis of designation of person, the physical continuum of the body and the mental continuum that includes the range of emotions of a living being persist until death when, according to Buddhist philosophy, the coarse physical continuum is severed or stopped, the twelfth link is activated and the mental continuum continues to the next life supported by the body of an intermediate being.

Now, at this stage, would be very useful to investigate the four types of existence, death existence, intermediate existence, birth existence, prior existence. These four especially come up in Abhidharma. But here, these two streams, the physical stream and the mental stream that are the basis of designation of the I, are central in our investigation of rebirth. Okay, as it says, substance in the person. Although all impermanent entities are substance, only form and awareness, which include minds and mental factors, may be designated as fundamental substance according to our initial chart.

In the lower schools they are called substantial existence and so forth. We’ve covered that material there, so I’ll just read up the last paragraph here. From the categories of substantial and imputed existence, a person is an imputed existence including included in the category of non associated formations. A person is defined as that imputed independence on the four or five aggregates, and it is the two broad substantial streams of form and awareness that comprise the substance that is the basis of imputation to person. This area does require continued focus in order to get down to the level of where we can begin to prove rebirth.

We need to understand this continuum of mind that we have at present. The fact that our current mind, our feelings, our emotions just persist moment by moment by moment, that continuum. What energizes it? What is the driving force behind it? What controls it?

And so forth. All of these issues are of extreme of great importance to us as beings in the present. If that stream ends, then there is nothing beyond this life. Rebirth is the simple fact of the continuation of this current stream that we possess in this present moment. Okay, look, just thought I’d throw in some point five here, some conclusions that may be drawn regarding substance.

Based on what has been said at this point, some conclusions may be drawn about the nature of substance. One, fundamental substance includes minds, form, minds and mental factors, and each of these categories are composed of distinct or discrete, irreducible substance. That substance can’t be reduced to anything else. It’s just there. The physical stream, mental stream, they’re irreducible.

Especially the mental stream is beginningless and endless from a Buddhist point of view. That’s why purifying it is so important. Number two, associated substance such as the non associated formations, those 14 categories and so forth, do not possess their own separate substance, distinct from fundamental substance. All these other things like the person, the person, the substance associated with a person is awareness and form. The substance associated with time is only awareness and form.

The substance associated with the continuum is only awareness and form, or individually awareness and form and social. Fundamental substance and associated substance are fully determined by the process of causation. There is just a they’re not created by a creative being or anything like that. They’re just governed by the simple laws of causation. Four, the substantial streams of matter and awareness are beginningless.

They never merge. The continuation of form, the continuum of form and consciousness never actually join to become at least we can say that from the point of view of the Hinayana schools and the Mahayana schools. Perfection vehicle and the Abhidharma presentation, they never can merge, become of the same nature. However, in the tantric vehicle, there is some interesting point there. Anyway, leaving that aside, awareness is proactive and matter reactive.

In this whole issue, awareness itself is the active agent. It’s not the brain. Although the brain, you know, has is the basis of consciousness, is the basis of certain types of consciousness for us, like sensory consciousness, what the brain is, it’s the physical sense base of, you know, the the conscious like eye consciousness, ear consciousness, and so on. The actual basis of the mind and the being is the heart, the heart chakra. Right.

Anyway, just there were just some points there that tend to follow from the discussion that went previously. Now looking at rebirth. Now we’re looking at Gyaltsab Je’s commentary called Clarifying the Path of Liberation, Explaining the Verses of the Parmana Bhartika. And the proof focusing on the nature of the continuum and proofs of rebirth focusing on compassion. Okay.

So we got to this stage. Let’s look at the arguments proving the continuum. Take an ordinary being, such as a being who possesses inhalation and exhalation, who is just born, who possesses inhalation and exhalation like a baby just born. There are some issues also here, but okay, just born, they’re breathing. A baby is just breathing and they have a certain clarity of the sense faculties and a luminosity of mind and so on.

It is not that that being does not possess reliance on similar earlier states when taking rebirth because he or she possesses inhalation and exhalation and so on. Okay, now I’ve put that argument down in just the way it’s stated. What it means is that the inhalation and exhalation of a baby who’s just born relies on similar earlier states for that being to take rebirth. Why? Because that being possesses inhalation and exhalation.

What it means by that is the habit of being able to inhale and exhale is a mental instinct, an instinctual behavior, a mental behavior that comes from past lives. It’s not something that a baby knows how to do automatically. And that is established because the luminosity of mind and so on are incontrovertibly ascertained to arise through familiarity. So not only do such processes as breathing, which depends on a certain level of mental instinct, if we can call it that, but also the clarity of the sense faculties and mental sense faculty as well. The clarity of mind depends on prior familiarity with the process of clarifying the mind.

The luminosity of the mind, the brightness of the mind, when we say someone is bright, that brightness of the mind, the clarity of it, also comes about through past causation, the fact that we purified the mind in past lives. It doesn’t just come about automatically in the first moment of conception or at the stage when that embryo is born. And Gelsov Jay then continues, If that is not the case, there would be the extreme fallacy that in consequence there would be no causation at all because there would be no valid cognition ascertaining internal causation. What Gyatsev Jay is referring to here is that these are issues of internal causation, causation regarding the mind. If you don’t admit to that, then you don’t admit to that argument that I put above.

You don’t admit to internal causation. And if you don’t admit to internal causation, then all causation would be put at question because internal causation is a valid category of causation itself. So it’s this title. Again, Geltsav Jay says, again take that original subject, I. Inhalation and exhalation of that being who was just born.

They do not arise from physical elements alone because they arise from earlier minds and so on of similar type. So he’s setting up the argument to come to that conclusion. A being is not doesn’t arise through mere physical causes from one’s parents, the DNA material, because they arise from earlier minds and so on of similar type. There’s no other possibility. And Gelzab Jayden goes on to say, If that is not the case, there would be the extreme fallacy that in consequence all physical elements would become living beings because mental awareness would arise from physical elements alone.

This is something Yal Sagye is recommending we contemplate, this type of argument. Of course, the mind doesn’t come from physical elements alone, from a Buddhist perspective. Although we tend to entertain the idea, we dabble with the idea. It sort of sounds attractive, because everyone in our culture tends to think these days that, you know, some gene lab somewhere is going to come up with a way of getting rid of unhappiness. It’s bound down to the old question.

The reason why the Buddha was reborn was to tackle the question of unhappiness, suffering, And he didn’t attribute a physical cause to unhappiness. He attributed a mental cause. But on on that presentation, it also comes along with it, this whole issue of rebirth, karma and so on. So underneath that, Gelzabje then continues, take the cognition of an ordinary being who has just taken birth. It is preceded by a former or earlier cognition because it is cognition.

The very fact that it is cognition, means that necessarily a former moment of cognition existed for it. There’s a stream there. There’s a pervasion in the syllogism, which is because it is that reason, it must be that predicate. If it is cognition, it must be preceded by a former or earlier cognition. There’s no cognition we’ve ever had that wasn’t preceded by an earlier moment of mind.

Impossible. So this is asserted to be a valid syllogism by Geltzer. Or we can take the other point of view here. Take the mental conception of a person about to die. It links with a subsequent cognition after the death process because it is cognition of one who possesses attachment.

So this only applies to beings such as ourselves with attachment who are destined to die. If we don’t have attachment, we get rid of the ignorance underlying attachment. We don’t have to die. So it’s extremely important here to understand this continuum. The moment the mind of the the mind of death links with what?

It links with the mind of the bardo being, the intermediate being, because always the mind must have a subsequent moment of mind, and that mind must have a basis. So at the moment of death, when we go through the clear light of death, it’s not as if everything stops because at that moment, one is reborn as an intermediate being and that intermediate, the body of that intermediate being, that subtle physical form, acts as the basis of that next moment of consciousness, and from there we progress to look for our future rebirth and so on. So these are important syllogisms to keep in mind for establishing rebirth, but they depend on understanding the continuum of the mind itself. And in fact, there’s two continuums there. There’s the continuum of mind and the continuum of form.

And death happens when the continuum of form ceases. That’s death. Mind the continuum of mind does not stop. It’s impossible for the continuum mind to stop, in other words. Now I’ll just skip forward.

There are further other arguments there. Just a couple of minutes just to present this second one, the proof focusing on compassion. Now in the Prahmanavarthika, in the second chapter, it states, you have become a valid being when talking about the Buddha. You are one who benefits reincarnating beings, a teacher, one who has preceded thus, a thus gone one, a tatagata and a protector. Now it’s stated this in praise of the Buddha.

So Buddha possesses these five qualities. He’s a valid being. He or she is a valid And that the Buddha is a valid being. The argument begins with the point that the Buddha is someone with excellent motivation, Sampa, excellent application, excellent result. They’ve attained enlightenment.

There’s no better result. Then in order to prove the first of those three statements, Geltsab Jay asserts that he possessed excellent motivation since he necessarily previously generated compassion, the desire to free all sentient beings from suffering. So that’s excellent motivation, to have that compassion to free all sentient beings. In other words, the great compassion existing in the mind stream of the Buddha arose from a cause, and that cause was compassion existing in the mind stream of the bodhisattva who possessed the same mind stream as that Buddha, the previous bodhisattva in the same substantial stream. So then Geltsap Jay gives the reason, Take that compassion in the mind of a Buddha.

It does not arise without a cause nor from an incompatible cause because it is established through familiarity with earlier compassion of similar type to it. So this is regarded as an extremely high form of proving rebirth, because compassion is so hard to generate. It can’t be done just in one light. Compassion, great compassion, it really only can be generated over a number of lifetimes. So the fact that a being develops perfect compassion is a proof itself of rebirth.

In order to really understand this proof, we have to understand how difficult it is to generate compassion. We don’t understand how difficult it is. We don’t understand, you know, let alone great compassion, we have trouble with infinite compassion. Let alone infinite compassion, have trouble with just ordinary compassion focused on all sentient beings, but then not only for all sentient beings, just one sentient being generating compassion is difficult. It’s extremely difficult.

So to get to the point where we have perfect compassion requires many lifetimes. And in response to that sort of an argument, the materialist Indian school says, take great compassion. It is not established due to familiarity over many lives because former later lives do not exist. So they reject that out of hand. Okay, look, I’ll just we’re just over it’s 11:30, isn’t it?

Finish. Yeah. I think we’ll just stop there and just open the paper up to discussion without finishing the final. Bits right at the end here. Are not important.

The main points were covered. Thank you. Just going on from that last point, the position of the materialists that great compassion isn’t due to past lives because past lives don’t exist, what do they posit as being the cause for great compassion in that case? Oh, they would, you know, like thinking about contemplating the benefits of love and compassion and so on. But as a materialist school, they really just they’re well known for simply asserting that things exist in a way that they exist without any reason.

We don’t contemplate why things are or what may be. They don’t have that causality? Do have a it’s interesting that they did develop their own system of inference and so on later, but they were really a school that just asserted that just the objects of the five senses exist. Anything else was speculation. Things like rebirth and so on were just, you know, ideas that arise from who knows where.

We don’t need to worry about that. We simply in the simple form of their view, you know, they were just in denial about philosophy, metaphysics, any possibility of answering the deeper questions of life. Actually, this tendency exists today as well. We see it. In our culture, philosophy has really taken a back seat to science over the last two hundred years, which is interesting because even science itself has assumptions that are philosophic in nature, such as materialism.

Materialism is a philosophic view that cannot be proved empirically. Yeah. On that, materialist view, the, scientists would assert that, instincts are biological or genetic. Yes. So that, yeah, how do you with that, I guess?

Again, it’s the knowledge of anything only comes through study and the application of becoming familiar with that subject matter. So even things like breathing, even instinctive behaviors, even for animals, for any living being, is coming about through training the mind, not, you know, through the genetic material that we possess. Although the genetic material itself may be influenced by the mind. This is an extremely interesting area of just this interface between awareness and the brain and so forth. And there is a certain amount of feedback going one way and the other.

But from a Buddhist point of view, the mind itself, fundamentally the mind is proactive and material phenomena are reactive. This tends to be a that tends to be the case, although there probably are exceptions to it. But we as beings and our makeup of our mind is really coming from our past mind. It’s an extremely interesting issue. And also the habits that we have, the way that we look at at, you know, particular things.

You know, we probably have deep seated habits that we’re not always aware of. For instance, we do tend to do things in certain ways and we do them, you know, like when we’re young, we do them in a particular way, and then we might forget that, and then later on we find ourselves doing things again in a similar way, the way we organize ourselves, the way these habits are really coming from our past mind, mind in our past lives. But there’s a lot of doubt on this issue about whether simply physical causes can govern the mind that we have at present. And because there’s great doubt about that, it’s something that we should examine very closely. Is it fair to say that there is no such thing as instinct?

It’s just a very deep familiarity of an action or a condition? I think instinct certainly does exist, but from a I think the mainstream Buddhist view would be that it is mentally based. It’s something that comes from the mind itself through familiarity. We have an instinct. So it’s the familiarity that is the crucial aspect of it.

Yeah. Familiarity has no meaning when applied to physical entities. But if we do things in certain ways, we develop a habit for doing doing it in that way, and that then is a habit, a mental habit that continues from one life to another. You know, at times instance, there was a monk at the time of the Buddha who had trouble meditating, and he went to the Buddha and the Buddha looked into his past lives and could see that in the past he’d been reborn as a cow many times over. And so he was used to resting on his side, so the Buddha advised him to meditate lying down in that way.

That would be easier for you. And so and he achieved results by meditating like that. Even these, you know, like physical posture, how one sits and so forth, are determined by past what? Habit of the mind. Not only our physical appearance, but our physical habits, or what we would regard as physical habits, tend to be coming from the mind itself and our past freedoms.

So in fact, it’s this issue of habitual behavior that is central in the proof of rebirth. I just want to know what’s what do you call the little voice in your head then? The little voice in our head that tells us to do do it this way or do it some other way. Well, often, yeah, we’re trying to work things out. We’re experimenting with different ideas and so forth.

We’re rehearsing arguments. Yeah, all sorts of. Yeah, we have this what can one say? We think through things on a verbal level mentally, sometimes just purely symbolically, but that exists. That’s fine.

It’s a way that we work things out, the way that we apply logic to our situation, hopefully. Thank you. My question is about, choice in karma and developing states not previously developed. So I understand that some Buddhist schools assert that one karmic imprint produces one effect or others assert that one karmic imprint can produce many effects. So if one karmic imprint can produce many or if many can produce one, then I see that change or developing states of mind not previously developed is relatively straightforward.

That’s just my personal opinion. However, when you take the people who say that one karmic imprint has one result, I find it difficult to see how new states of mind never previously developed could occur. I was wondering if you could comment on that. Oh, well, not everything is the result of karma either. There there are states that are just, you know, for us, that are neutral results, not necessarily what they what is called or a maturational result of past positive and negative actions.

That’s okay. But as you say, just getting back to the earlier part of your question, a single karmic seed can produce a single result or it could produce multiple results, and there are many instances of that. I think the Buddhist schools are generally, you know, in agreement there about that occurring. For instance, one, there are instances in Sutra where a monk may have or a nun may have made an offering and on basis of that offering, they’re reborn many times in the heaven of the 33 for instance, as the ruling deity of the heaven of the 33 with extremely good conditions and they may take rebirth there many times over to eons and then after that they’re born as a universal monarch on the earth and so on. You know they have one karmic seed.

If it’s extremely extensive and pure, can have a vast result over many lifetimes. But, in general, it’s said that the feelings that we experience at present are many of them are karmically sourced, positive and negative feeling. Neutral, not so, but positive and negative feeling, especially on a physical level. Physical positive and negative feeling is coming from past karma. Mental feeling is a little bit different.

Yeah, I probably didn’t explain myself. The states not previously generated, I was thinking of the states of mind in the in of an arya being or so on. So or or attaining buddhahood. So for instance, in my case, I’ve never before been an Arya being. So I’ve never been able to generate a cause that is in exact accordance with the result.

So if one karmic seed matures into only one result and every result has only one karmic cause, if I was to take that view, would it be possible to achieve liberation? It’s not, in a sense, a karmic result. It’s not it’s an uncontaminated. If you’re talking about the path of seeing, it’s coming from an uncontaminated cause. Whereas, when you’re talking about karmic causes, you’re talking about virtue and non virtue that are both contaminated.

Still, when you attain the path of seeing, path of seeing itself is uncontaminated, but the part of preparation that generates it is contaminated. Right? But this is outside the karmic process because you’re developing the path that gets beyond karma. What we’re trying to do because our problem, samsara, is the problem of karma, that we’re beyond our control. We’re potentially thrown into rebirths from the hells to ghosts to animals and so forth, beyond our control at any point, and we’ve got to get beyond that.

So generating a path is getting beyond that process. Thanks, Jumbo. What is the cause for the subtle body of the Bardo body, given that that’s the basis for the mind in the death state? So what is can you just break that down? That is a very, very good question and I’m not sure if there’s an easy answer to it.

It’s this question about at the point of death, when one emerges from the clear light of death, one does so on the basis of the body of an intermediate being. Now it’s really a subtle body. It’s not can’t be seen by our ordinary eye consciousness. Just what it’s composed of, it’s form, but it’s probably not material. It’s a body of the nature of consciousness itself.

In Tibetan, it’s called the Yigi Ranjin Gi Lu. Yigi Ranjing, yi is the mind, Ranjing is essence, a body of the essence of mind. So it’s formed, but it’s not matter. It’s not composed of material particles. Right?

And it’s similar to the dream body. When we dream at night, it’s said that we dream with a body of the nature of consciousness as well. Where is that coming from? To a degree, it’s related to the mind itself, but it’s not its form. There’s not a huge I haven’t come across many sources that deal with this.

However, there’s there’s four bodies. There’s also the arya body. When a being attains the path of seeing, they arise in a body of the nature of consciousness called an arya body. And I was talking with someone one Geshe, one Tibetan Geshe a couple of months ago in Dharamsala, and he was just brought up this issue, you know, and he was asking me if I’d come across anything, and I was saying, no, not at all. And he was saying that he’d read where it’s similar to the arising of the rainbow body.

Now the rainbow body is another body of the nature of consciousness that arises through the path of tantra, and it’s similar to the illusory body. The implication is that it’s not coming from the as a continuation of the previous body that one has left, that, you know, if one was a human and died and so on or attained, you know, the path of seeing and so on, it’s manifesting at that point through subtle form that is by itself. The very substance is the substance of consciousness. Which is why I think it was helpful for you to explain the various tenet systems, because, for example, the mind only system seems to be quite tricky to say that there’s no external phenomena. But that doesn’t mean that, you know, their proof is, nevertheless, think I’m right in saying it’s substantially existent because it arises in dependence of causes and conditions.

And so, you know, it’s easy to get confused by saying, well therefore that table is my mind’ rather than saying that, you know, if you keep going down to some sort of essential, you know, beyond the atoms, then you get to something like the nature of mind’. And that’s always because we’re working, or I am working from a premise, that what I see, experience from my senses actually is there. Namely that’s the materialistic So that’s why it seems tricky when we start talking about, you know, that separation between mind and matter as if they are two completely separate entities and how they actually relate to each other from a materialistic viewpoint seems to be incredibly problematic because For the mind only, Well, I think for all of us. Well, no, certainly. Coming out of all of this from a materialistic sort of ingrained set of assumptions.

I hear these things but I’m hearing them through my materialistic assumptions which perhaps I haven’t been able to make explicit. I haven’t examined them sufficiently so it’s easy to get caught up in knots. You know, like to say, there’s nothing external, immediately puts gets tied up in mental knots. Yeah. No.

In a way, the mind only presentation is counterintuitive. That if we think, although we’re quite, you know, relaxed about accepting a dream, and then when we later think about the dream, we realize that there’s no external objects there. Where are those, you know, where’s that person I met in a dream or where is that house, that luxurious villa I had on the South Of France? Where has it gone? Where does it exist?

I mean, it’s merely what, something impudent within the mind itself. That thing has we could probably say it has substance within the mind, a mental substance. This is what the mind only school is saying, that everything is a bit like a dream, just as we’d in a dream, we have a house, we live there, we meet people and so on, and then we later realize that they don’t, you know, really exist as they appear to exist. So to put the mind only school, these things, forms that appear are formed, they’re not mind, but they are the substance of mind. They are physical objects, but they’re not material objects.

They make this distinction as well. They’re not composed of atoms and molecules, but their substance is the substance of the mind itself. So it’s an idealist view. This is Buddhist idealism, the view of the mind only school. And for us in our society, we look at that and think, well yeah, that’s you know, that’s quite an extreme way to look at things because you know things appear to be external and you know we relate to things on that level.

However, the idea of the mind only school can be very useful for us in helping us understand what the illusory nature of existence, and in fact the external objects are a bit of an illusion. The more we try and find them, the less success we have. And even from the point of view of science, they are just a false appearance because there’s mainly space and only a very small percentage is of any material substance. But even when you go into the substance, I mean, you go into the atoms themselves, again, there’s just a nucleus and the electron and they’re mainly space. So 99.9999% space exists throughout the universe.

But we, you know, we apprehend it and interact with it as if it were really solid and, you know, something was actually there. It probably would be helpful to understand quantum physics. Sorry? It probably would be helpful, in that case, to understand quantum physics, which Yes. I And His Holiness continuously refers back to quantum physics and how close it is to the higher Buddhist schools such as the Madhyamikan school that, yeah, we can’t really there’s uncertainty about the nature of the objects around us and they don’t exist in the way they appear to exist and so on.

Definitely, that type of contemplation can be useful for us to develop a sense of the illusory nature of existence. Well, you’ve certainly got us going, Jameen, and thank you so much for an incredibly thorough and detailed presentation. I’m sure we’d all like to get hold of your notes, if that’s alright. So if you would like to join me to thank jumping in the usual manner. And we look forward to hearing from you again tomorrow and then a panel later in the day.

So now we have lunch until half past one when Ilya will be presenting. So if we can be here in good time, that will be appreciated. So thank you very much. Enjoy your lunch.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Tushita Ganden (Tib)
The Joyous Land. There are two Tushita realms. One is the pure land of the thousand buddhas of this eon, where the future buddha, Maitreya, and Lama Tsongkhapa reside. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top