1 h 4 min · 2,655 words · 18 November 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen explores the philosophical foundations of appearance and perception in Tibetan Buddhist epistemology, drawing particularly on Cittamātra (Mind-Only) school arguments. He begins with the common factor of appearance—how all observers perceive the same table—before turning to the central puzzle: uncommon factors of appearance, such as the emotional resonance an individual feels toward an expensive watch they treasure. Using this watch as a teaching example, he probes a logical knot: if the uncommon perception is merely mental, does it arise from a material cause (the watch itself) or a mental cause (karmic imprint)? Either way, phenomena seem to require two substantial causes, which is impossible. He then explores how Cittamātra resolves this by tracing all phenomena ultimately to subtle mind and wind, and examines the affiliated concept of afflicted mind—an innate sense of self present even in deep sleep. The session concludes with prepared debate topics for group discussion on these interlocking themes of perception, emptiness, and the architecture of consciousness.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-11-18.mp3
UUID: c73fc301-e014-43ce-9dde-e42eed66a94c
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Awareness and Knowledge
Date: 2014-11-18
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,649
So as usual, we will generate the motivation to listen to these teachings. So I would like to address the doubts you had last time regarding the uncommon factor of appearance. But initially, I will address the nature of the common factor of appearance. Let us take the standing little table in front of me. It appears to every single one of us.
Therefore, it is a shared or common factor of appearance for every one of us. So this doubt, which you expressed last time, is a good one. It’s one which arises in the class at the great seats, which studies ālāyavijñāna in debate. So what precisely is the origin or the source of this common factor of appearance of a phenomenon such as the table? You have heard of the view of the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka School according to which all phenomena are mere nominal imputations.
So the doubt arises in the context of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka if all phenomena are mere nominal imputations, if all phenomena are mere conceptual imputations, then we have strictly speaking no relation with things. Now in the system, when one says that phenomena are mere conceptual or nominal imputations, what precisely does the term mere allude to? The intent or the purpose of the term mere is to refute the specific object of refutation of Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, which is phenomena being established from their own side. So at present, this is not easy because we have little habit of study. But through experience over the years, eventually we will be able to grasp this as one whole.
This is different from what we are accustomed to study. Our topics of study in school or university are topics we study once and set aside before passing to the next topic. Here it is quite different. We study all these topics so that eventually we are able to see them with great ease, with facility, and to understand their innermost meaning. So when Prāsaṇgika refutes the establishment of phenomena from their own side, making the establishment of phenomena from their own side its object of negation, what is this establishment from its own side?
When we observe phenomena, we can see that probably all of us have this sense that a sort of entity is out there really. And it’s this sense that the entity is out there really, which is that phenomena’s establishment by its own characteristics. And therefore, when we, in this context, refer to the I or the person which is analyzing, from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, clearly, as long as this entity is not analyzed or investigated, it does exist. However, when one searches for it under analytical investigation, this object of imputation, the eye of the person, on the basis of imputation, the aggregates and so forth, is unfindable. So it is critical here to understand that the unfindability of the object of negation under analysis does not refer to the findability of nonexistence under investigation.
It does not refer to the fact that all phenomena are nonexistent, which is the fallacy in or the extreme of nihilism in which those of dull faculty will fall easily. Therefore, from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, this unfindability under analytical investigation, specifically ultimate analytical investigation, is not a findability of nonexistence. It is an unfindability of the object of negation. What is the object of negation here? It is phenomena or the persons being established from their own side.
This however in no way entails that phenomena or the person do not arise independent from causes and conditions. To the contrary, it is precisely because phenomena and persons are not established from their own side that they do arise in dependence on causes and conditions.
The Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view is quite strange, so we shall descend to the easier view of the Chitamatra view of the Chitamatra school at present. In Chitamatra, it is asserted that all phenomena are merely of the nature of mind. What precisely does the term merely in the statement all phenomena are merely of the nature of mind refer to? It contradicts or it refutes the view of the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika according to which forms specifically is established in dependence on partless particles. Let us take the example of this table.
From the standpoint of the Chitamatra school, this table is merely established as a nature of mind. Now what precisely does this mean? Clearly, all of us perceive this table. What is the origin of this table? It is undeniable even for the Chitamatra school that originally someone planted the seed.
From this seed a tree arose, planks were constituted or planks were cut from this tree, they were dried and eventually they gave rise to this table. This is the worldly public view of the table. So this viewpoint is the public worldly view. This view is a view which is accepted by the Chitamatra school because otherwise, the Chitamatra school would be at odds with reality. As Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen says in Legs bshad snying po, the essence of eloquence, whoever utters view which are at odds with logic is a propounder who is not a valid being or a valid person.
So clearly, Chitamatra’s position cannot be at odds with worldly reality. For Chitamatra, this table’s origin lies in wood and planks. Therefore, this little table from the standpoint of the Chitamatra tradition does indeed arise from wood and planks. For that matter, this table is an other phenomenon and all other-powered phenomena in Chitamatra are truly established as well as thoroughly established phenomena, which are truly established as well. If this is the case, what precisely is the meaning of the statement that this statement, this table is merely of the nature of mind?
What is meant is that unlike the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika school which assert that when one decomposes tables into parts, one eventually reaches partless particles. For Chitamatra, when one tries to decompose the table into its ultimate components, one eventually connects with the union of mind and subtle energy. This is the meaning of the statement that this table is merely established as mind. This should enable you to understand this. This should be accessible.
This is for the common factor of appearance using the example of the table. As to the uncommon factor of appearance, let us take for instance a watch which I value very highly, which is very expensive and which I see as different from other watches. It’s not the case of this watch. That perception of this watch is unique to myself. It actually arises from a karmic imprint within my own mind basis of all or ālaya vijnana.
It is my uncommon factor of appearance of this watch which others do not share. Let us assume, I’m not saying this is the case of the translator, that when the translator looks at his words, an uncommon feeling of cherishment arises within his mind. This is the factor of appearance of the watch to the translator’s mind and it is specific to him. Now a problem arises because if this watch is a watch, then a watch is produced by a factory, and a watch is made from iron. The factory uses iron and metal to produce a watch, and this is one substantial cause.
But there seems to be another substantial cause which gives rise to this uncommon factor of appearance of a watch to our mind. Now it is impossible to have two substantial causes for one given phenomenon. So this is problematical. So this is a very interesting line of reasoning. If this object is actually a watch, things get very awkward.
Therefore, it cannot be a watch. It is merely the appearance, the simile of a watch to my mind. Then the Chitamatras would say that there is no such thing as a watch out there. There is merely the appearance of the watch within my mind. Then if this is the case, there is no watch.
This is why the Chitamatra school becomes quite odd. There is one final topic which has to be addressed, that is that of afflicted mind within the Chitamatra school. Whether we walk, sit or sleep, we notice that the innate sense of a self is always present within us. Now when we examine to find where precisely this innate sense of a self is within the five aggregates or the six minds, we do not find it. Yet it is present.
Moreover, we notice that when we fall into a deep sleep, it must still be present because when we rise from deep sleep into the dream state, we can notice the presence of an innate sense of self. This leads the cittamatra to assert that there is a mind which bears this innate sense of self and it is called the afflicted mind. It is asserted to be the common locus of the innate sense of consciousness, of a self and consciousness. In other words, it is both the innate sense of a self and consciousness. Moreover, as you know, the Chitamatra school asserts both a subtle selflessness of persons and a subtle selflessness of phenomena.
Chitamatra however asserts that the subtle selflessness of phenomena is far more subtle than the subtle selflessness of persons. The question which arises is why is this the case? Is it because of the greater subtlety of the object of negation, or is it because of the greater subtlety of the basis of emptiness? Then we will have a long period of question and answers tonight, so you have the opportunity to ask your questions. I’m not saying you have to ask questions if you don’t have questions to fill time.
And I’d also like to ask one question per person, that every single person have the possibility to ask a question. Well, if everything is the nature of mind according to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamikas against the Chitamatras, then a simple reply to retort, the attack form of the Chitamatras is say that, well, you’re you’re asserting the existence
The minds which we are dealing with at present are extraordinarily coarse minds since they cease within the state of deep sleep. Therefore the answer cittamatra would provide to the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika counterattack would be that the cause of all of these minds is the subtle mind and wind, the fundamental mind and wind. Then, obviously, when the Chitamatras assert that all phenomena are of the nature of mind and ultimately can be traced back to subtle mind and wind, Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika are not going to remain speechless. They will counterattack. But whether their rejoinder is valid or not reflects reality or not is another question.
Then the line of reasoning is a very good one. Chitamatras consider that the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika have succumbed to the extreme of nihilism. So this is not the Chitamatra position. It’s a doubt regarding the Chitamatra position. The Chitamatras take the case of the uncommon factor of appearance of a watch.
Let us say I have a watch which is very expensive, very valuable, which I find very pleasing and attractive, and I see this watch in this light. This is a perspective on the watch which others do not share. It is a private perspective on the watch. It is therefore the uncommon factor of appearance of the watch to my mind. It is quite easy to see how we would say that this uncommon factor of appearance is merely of the nature of mind, is established as of the nature of mind.
But if this is the case, then the question which arises is, in that case, is that uncommon factor of appearance of watch a watch or not? Then, if it is a watch, it must come from a factory, from metal, it is manufactured, and suddenly we are dealing with two different substantial causes for one entity: one material substantial cause and one mental substantial cause. Then if this uncommon factor of appearance of a watch is not a watch, things also get very strange. Though phenomena can have numerous conditions, they can only have one single substantial cause. It is not possible for an impermanent phenomenon to have two substantial causes.
I’ve been away for a few weeks. Mod has already been covered but When I have translated as subtle energy in Tibetan, it’s literally subtle wind. The Tibetan term lung translates to Sanskrit prana. This subtle wind has nothing whatsoever to do with wind as we know it. It is a subtle form of energy and it is best understood through seeing that subtle mind and subtle energy are linked.
They are of one nature but of different isolates. Where there is subtle mind, there is subtle energy where there is subtle energy, there is subtle mind. Specifically, it is something which yogis gain experience of through their meditation. Then it is something which for us is very difficult to understand, but it is that component of mind which causes the mind to change objects and to be unable to stay on an object for more than a minute or so. Do you understand?
I understand the words you say, No problem. We have no usage, no means of using mind and wind. These are concepts which really enter into practice in Anuttara Yoga Tantra. Another? Please.
No, there’s no relationship between reflexive consciousness and afflicted consciousness. Since in the Chitamatra school, reflexive consciousness is a direct perceiver. As a direct perceiver, it is non conceptual. On the other hand, the afflicted consciousness is an innate sense of self. Therefore it is conceptual.
The difference between reflexive consciousness and afflicted consciousness is that of a non conceptual versus a conceptual state of mind. Our minds at present are afflicted. We don’t have access to the fundamental mind of clear light which is unafflicted, and we have no way of using it. In the case of the Cittamatras, they really do not make this distinction between afflicted and non afflicted minds. So the Chitamatras explain the difference between common and uncommon factors of appearance as was explained.
For the the Chitamatras, common factor of appearance refers to the shared public perception of the table, in a nutshell what is perceived by a conventional valid cognizer. For the Cittamatras, the uncommon factor of appearance of objects refers to our individual perception of objects as pleasant, unpleasant, beautiful, ugly and so forth. Yes, they accept this and it causes no problem whatsoever. It’s their tenet. It’s their position.
There are uncommon factors of appearance which arise out of anger, which arise out of craving. There are numerous such factors. I don’t understand your your doubt. Excuse me. Could you could you repeat it?
I If I understood the essence of your doubt correctly, you are saying that phenomena have both common and uncommon factors of appearance, which is true, but you seem to differentiate between the two and to consider the common factor of factors of appearance as established as exterior phenomena, as real somehow, and the uncommon factors of appearance as interior. That’s what I thought might be your inner doubt. That’s what I translated for Geshe la. Geshe la said both are unreal for Cittamātra. So the common factors of appearance are also unreal because if one analyzes objects into their ultimate entities, one eventually encounters subtle mind and wind.
So we shall stop here. We will have discussion as usual by groups of two different partners than last time, please. And the topics will be debate on the common and uncommon factors of appearance, number one. Number two, debate on the relationship between the subtle selflessness of phenomena and the subtle selflessness of persons in Chitamatra. Mhmm.
Debate on the subtle selflessness of persons and the subtle selflessness of phenomena in Chitamatra.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.