43 min · 2,608 words · 1 November 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains how conventional truth is presented through the five aggregates, twelve sources and eighteen constituents, taught in more or less detail according to students’ faculties, desires and obscurations. It outlines the 84,000 teachings, grouped into three scriptural collections, and the two truths as the path to liberation. The closing questions concern whether formally taking vows creates more merit than living by the precepts without vows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 44 min
UUID: e139d4d8-2a67-4202-81be-492b57925c99
Date: 1988-11-01
Words: 2,604
So, you know, if we give an example of the eye consciousness, from where does the eye consciousness develop? It develops in dependence upon the base, that is the eye sense power. And what is its object of observation? It could be any type of object, for example, the book. And so, what is the eye developing from?
The eye sense power. What is it observing? It’s observing, for example, color or shape or white, the various colors. And each of these three applies to each of these six possible constituents, so it would make a total of 18. So, you know, this explanation and the various conventional phenomena into the aggregates, the five aggregates or the 12 sources of the 18 constituents, these aren’t, you know, these categorizations are not mutually exclusive.
Know, do not exclude one another. These are simply methods of explaining, of explaining, of explanation or explaining. This is, you know, from the point of view of the master Vasubandhu and his skill in teaching his various students, he said that according to his students’ ability, for example, there are said to be three desires, there are three powers, and there are three obscurations on the parts of his different types of students. In accordance with their various desires, powers and wishes, he presented an explanation, abbreviated explanation, a middling explanation, and a detailed explanation. And this is how they developed these three ways of explaining the same phenomena, aggregates, sources, and constituents.
So, we were saying that this was a skillful method on the part of Vasubandhu in teaching his students these different ways of dividing phenomena. And if we take the example of the three types of powers, I guess you would say, faculties. The faculties of the different students. There are those who are dull, those who are mediocre, and those who are quite clever. So if we were to explain the conventional truth from the point of view of the five aggregates to a clever disciple, then this would be sufficient.
We wouldn’t have to go into the explanation of constituents and sources. But if you did this for the middling student, he wouldn’t be able to understand the conventional truth, in dependence upon only the five aggregates. You would have to go on and explain conventional phenomena in terms of sources. Likewise, if you were teaching a dull minded student, you would have to not only teach the five aggregates and teach also the sources, but you would have to go on and begin to point out every phenomena around you in order to get across what you mean by conventional truth. And this would entail a teaching upon 18 constituents.
So it’s according to the three powers of students or faculty. Likewise, the teaching has to be given in accordance with the student’s desires. You know, there are some students who might desire only the abbreviated teaching, the very condensed teaching. Therefore you would just teach that student the five aggregates. Another student might like a more mid length presentation.
Therefore you would include the sources. And another student would He wants a very detailed, expansive type of teaching. Therefore, you would go on to teach him the 18 or her, the 18 constituents. According to their desires, the three levels of desire. Yes.
So, again, according to the level of disciple, I mistranslated this third quality of a disciple. I said wishes, that’s wrong. It should be according to the obscuration Obscurations. So the teaching has to be given in accordance with the degree of obscuration that the student has. For a student who has only a slight obscuration in order to understand the conventional truth and a mere explanation of the five aggregates will be able to eliminate obscuration that he has to understanding conventional truths.
Then for those with middling obscurations, you would have to go on and teach the sources, the 12 sources. And those with great obscurations, would have to go on and give an extremely expanded detailed explanation involving the 18 constituents in order to remove the obscurations for him in understanding the conventional truth. So this is the difference in the presentation of which presentation of these three types of ways of presenting the conventional truth, would be made use of according to the disciples’ capacity, according to his type, you know, whether he was clever, whether he was dull faculty, his desire, his power, etcetera. So, you know, know, we could go to a lot further trouble. And there’s actually an explanation which divides up conventional truth into 62 categories.
But he doesn’t want to trouble you with all that. So Vasubandhu, he also had an extremely detailed teaching which divided conventional truth into 62 categories. So within the five aggregates, the aggregate of feeling, We’re there, we talk about the three types of feeling, that is the feelings of pleasure, pain, and neutrality. So we can understand these three quite easily. We experience the feelings of pleasure, sometimes when we’re doing work, various activities, we experience suffering, that is feelings of pain.
And those times when we are feeling neither pleasure nor pain, we simply have a neutral or indifferent feeling. This is the feeling of neutrality. So the aggregate of discriminations are, for example, when we think, oh, this is white, this is black, this is a person, this is a book, etcetera. This type of thinking is are called aggregates of discriminations, aggregate of discriminations. Then the the fourth aggregate is the aggregate of compositional factors.
And in the in the study of mind, we can divide mind into minds and mental factors, minds and mental factors. And there are 52 mental factors. Sometimes they are called secondary mental factors. 52 mental factors, mental factors. If we set aside feeling and discrimination, that leaves 50 mental factors, these 50 mental factors are the aggregate of compositional factors.
The 50 remaining mental factors make up the aggregate of compositional factors. Then there’s the aggregate of consciousnesses, and this is we’ve been talking about the aggregates such as the eye consciousness, ear consciousness. There are six. So we are beings. That is to simplify, we are persons.
And the reasons that we have five aggregates, in dependence upon these five aggregates, we designate, we impute person or being. To an object which does not possess these five aggregates, we cannot impute or designate being or, we cannot designate being in general, but we cannot designate person, for example. For example, if there’s no feeling, aggregate feelings, then upon that object, we cannot designate being or person. So in order to attain liberation and omniscience, we have to realize the two truths. First, realize the conventional truth, and upon realizing that, we realize the ultimate truth, and and thereupon, we’re able to achieve the state of liberation and omniscience.
So just as wishing to walk down a path to reach a destination, have to rely on our two legs. Likewise, in in dependence upon the two truths, our realization of the two truths, we can achieve, liberation and omniscience. So so we Okay. So we have to realize the two truths. That is the conventional truth and ultimate truth.
Now, how is the how are we going to do this? What is the method for realizing the two truths? In order to bring this about, it is said that the Buddha spoke 84,000 bundles of Dharma, 84,000 bundles or heaps of teachings as a method to realize the two truths. This is encompassed within the three scriptural categories, The three scriptural categories. Three scriptural collections.
So why did why did the Buddha give pronounce 84,000 bundles of Dharma? It’s because we have 84,000 afflicted emotions, which need to be abandoned. Therefore, for every one of our 84,000 afflicted emotions which needs to be abandoned, he gave a teaching of a Dharma. Therefore, are 84,000 bundles of Dharma teachings. So there are you know, of these 84,000 afflictive emotions which we possess, there there are three main afflictive emotions.
That is delusion, attachment, and hatred. Delusion, attachment, and hatred. With respect to the abandonment abandoning delusion, the Buddha taught 21,000 bundles of Dharma. And likewise, 21,000 with respect to abandoning desire, 21,000 with respect to for the purpose of abandoning hatred. And he he gave gave he taught an additional 21,000 to help us to abandon all three together.
So the these 84,000 collections of doctrine or of the teachings are included in the 12 branches of scripture. 12 branches of scripture. And these these 12 branches of scripture are further are in turn included in the three scriptural collections. So the three scriptural collections are the sets of discourses, the sets of discourses or that is to say in Sanskrit the sutras. The second is discipline, or Vinaya.
And the third is manifest knowledge, or Abhidharma. And there’s a quotation from the from Maitreya’s Ornament for the Great Vehicle Sutras. And which says the scriptural collections are this the scriptural collections are either three or two. Nine reasons are asserted for including them in three. So when it says the scripture collections are either three or two, when we say three, we’re talking about the the collection of, discourses, discipline, and manifest knowledge.
When it says to, we’re talking about the collections from the point of view of the great vehicle and lesser vehicle. So, you know, this coming to this explanation of the three scriptural collections is like beginning a long journey. So we don’t have time to complete the journey. So maybe it’s better if we take the remaining time and and Rinpoche thinks it would be best if we answered any questions that you might have. So, any questions?
Taken vows, accumulates less power than the person who took vows to refrain from those actions. It looks like that person who would naturally live by those three precepts without having taken vows might have actually taken those vows on a much more profound level than just standing up and saying, from now on, I refrain from killing, stealing. He might have taken the vows. I thought he didn’t take the vows. Much more profound level than standing up and saying, no, I’m not Yeah.
Got the before that. The person who? The person who quite naturally lives the life without killing stealing Yeah. And ally. I can’t see why they are accumulating this Yes, ma’am.
That a person who’s actually So now when we say there’s no difference between these two types, between these people. They both can be quite good people or they both might not be good people whether they take vows or not. But we’re only talking about, from all factors aside, just the fact of having this form within one’s mind causes one is a method for developing more positive energy. Just this development of this form, this factor of the subtle form of having the vow in your mind is a method for developing more positive potential. All other factors set aside.
Verbalizing that kind of doesn’t maybe negates something. The next I mean, does it actually have have to to be be formal or unform or just It doesn’t have to be formal, does it? The taking of a vow. We wanna explain further with that. You mean, like, what getting up and say getting up in front of Get up and say it to anybody anyone to be living by those Mhmm.
Precepts. As opposed to? Well, Rinpoche said that if you actually took vows that was carrying more merit than living by those precepts without taking vows. And I think that if you are living by those precepts without having taken vows, then perhaps you already took them on a very subtle level and that carries as much amount. So you’re saying if you didn’t take the vows, may have taken them on a subtle level.
But then you took them. Yeah? I mean, are you taking them where you don’t? I think you would have taken them if you were living by those. Those.
You would have taken them if you were living could be Yeah. Yes? I’m not sure what to say. So the the difference is, let’s say that someone there’s two people. One of them accepts to not kill today, he’s not going to kill anything today.
Just that acceptance deciding in your mind that you’re not going to kill today creates positive energy. Whereas this other person, and now we’re not talking about whether they kill or don’t kill, just one of them decides, accepts the fact that he’s not going to kill or she’s not going to kill. That decision, having taken that acceptance, that commitment, creates positive energy. Now the other person hasn’t created that positive energy. We’re not talking about whether they kill or don’t kill that day.
Just making that commitment to not kill creates positive energy. In the other case, the other positive energy isn’t created. So that’s right. It’s dependent upon the intention. You know, having, for example, you see that by killing you hurt others and out of, you develop compassion for sentient beings and you say, I’m not going to kill today.
And you make a commitment, for example, you know, take a vow in front of an image of a Buddha or a teacher, you say, Today, I’m going to commit myself to not killing. And dependence upon this, the actual, you’ve taken a commitment, well, you’re creating positive energy. Whereas the other person, you know, perhaps they may refrain from killing that day, maybe they just don’t have the opportunity, the chance to kill something. Just hasn’t arose in that day. They haven’t committed themselves.
They haven’t actually decided in their mind. They haven’t made the intention not to kill. It’s just perhaps the circumstances. And perhaps there’s benefit or no benefit to be derived that day by that person having made no commitment. But there’s definite benefit to be derived by the person who has committed themselves to that particular course of action.
So there’s a difference between committing oneself to a particular course of action and taking a vow with that, to that, with intention of that particular type of action. In the case of a vow, then initially it should be taken most properly in front of a spiritual teacher. If that, if you don’t have that available, him available, her available in front of a monk. If that’s not available, then in front of an image of a Buddha, for example. Initially, so vows are usually initially taken in front of these types of objects, whereas a commitment wouldn’t necessarily have to be.
For example, you know, the if you were to see an injured injured animal, you know, it might quite naturally develop compassion. That is the thought, you know, I wish this animal was separated from that suffering. You know, this would quite naturally develop. But if you went on to say, you know, went on to take the actual bodhisattva vows, vowing to actually motivated by this compassion to separate that being from suffering, then this would this would be extremely more powerful than the mere compassion that you would have developed, that you had developed to separate that that you’re wishing that being was separated from suffering, but actually committing yourself formally to actually separate that animal from suffering. So the the power would be greatly enhanced, having actually formally committed oneself by taking a vow.
So likewise in taking taking vows
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- eighteen constituents dhatu (Skt); kham (Tib)
- The six sense powers, the six consciousnesses and the six objects. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.