48 min · 2,701 words · 8 November 1988
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the commentary on the third chapter of Opening the Eye of New Awareness, explaining why the Buddha’s teachings are classified into three scriptural collections: discipline, discourse and manifest knowledge. It gives the reasons for this classification from the points of view of antidote, subject matter and practice, including how discourses counter doubt, discipline counters extreme behaviour and knowledge counters holding wrong views.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 48 min
UUID: b94fd9d4-a127-44cc-bb7d-cc05d0ed085e
Date: 1988-11-08
Words: 2,697
Rinpoche requests that we adjust our motivation such that we’re going to listen to this teaching on the opening of the eye and New Awareness in order to attain enlightenment for the sake of bringing happiness and peace to all sentient beings. So, we’ve we’ve reached the third chapter of the text, Opening the Eye of New Awareness, goes into the description of the three collections. So initially the Buddha generated the awakening heart and in the intermediate he collected the two accumulations of merit and finally upon attaining enlightenment, he turned the wheel of Dharma giving 84,000 bundles of teachings. And this is a description of the classification of these 84,000 bundles of teachings of the Dharma. So all the 84,000 bundles of Dharma, the teachings which the Buddha gave, were directly taught in order to subdue the afflictive emotions.
And these 84,000 teachings can be subsumed under 12 branches of Scripture. And in turn, these 12 branches scripture can be subsumed or categorized into the three scriptural collections. Yes. So what do we mean when we say the three scriptural collections? Now, all the teachings that the Buddha gave, these were his pronouncements, so these were his actual words.
So, firstly, the three scriptural collections are the words of the Buddha. That is the actual sounds, speech by which he set forth his teachings. And then we give names to certain types of speech, certain types of pronouncements, and these constitute the three categories. The collection of the set of discipline, the set of discourses, and the set of manifest knowledge. So these three sets, discipline, discourse, and knowledge are the three scriptural collections.
The actual words of the Buddha, his pronouncements, are categorized into the three scriptural collections, the set of discipline, discourse, and manifest knowledge. Now, if we take his teachings from the point of view of the subject matter, which are set forth, then we can classify his teachings into the three trainings, the training of ethics, the training in meditative stabilization, and the training in wisdom. Scriptures are asserted there are nine reasons for asserting the the three categories of the scriptural collections. There are nine reasons for asserting the three scriptural category the three scriptural collections. There are nine reasons for asserting the three scriptural collections.
There are three reasons from the point of view antidote or abandonment. There are three reasons from the point of view of subject matter, and three reasons from the point of view of practice. Yes. So it is said that that the scriptural collections of the Buddha are definitely only three. There is not a fourth.
It’s also said that there are only four tenets that the Buddha set forth. There is no fifth. A fourth scriptural collection is not the intention of the Buddha, nor is a fifth tenet the intention of the Buddha. So, with respect to the the first reason for the categorization into three three scriptural collections, that is from the point of view of antidote. First, taking up the scriptural collection of the sets of discourses, which are the words of the Buddha.
Now, it’s said that the words of the Buddha, these sets of discourses, are the container, in which all three of the subject matters of what the Buddha taught are contained. That is, we said the subject matters of the Buddha were the three trainings: ethics, discipline, ethics, meditative stabilization, and wisdom. These three are like, as if we put, fit into the category of the sets of discourses, or sūtra. So, it’s like a cup. The sutras or the sets of discourses are like a cup, and in that we pour tea.
And the three trainings are like or the subject matter of the Buddhist discourses are like the tea in which fits into a container. The container are the sutras or the sets of discourses. So, we said that the in the first group of three reasons that is concerning antidotes, the reason for setting forth these sets of discourses was as a method for eliminating the faults of the practitioner. Now, the various types of faults. There are three types of faults.
There are three types of mental states which need to be overcome, that is to be eliminated. And, the first of these is doubt. So, that is to say, with the there is a doubt as to the existence of the nonexistence, there’s a hesitation or an inability to come to a single pointed position. So, the first affliction, which is to be overcome through the antidote of the scriptural collection is doubt. So what exactly do we have doubt with respect to which of these various doubts are to be eliminated?
As we have explained before, with the consideration of the various objects of knowledge, such as the five aggregates, the 12 sources, the 18 constituents, the 12 links of dependent origination, and the four noble truths. We are seeking to eliminate doubts with respect to these various categories of objects of knowledge. So through the activities of listening and reflecting with respect to the mode of abidance, the reality of various objects, we can remove doubt with respect to them, to their actual nature. You know, just as in, as for example, if we were wondering, Is this a flower or not? And then by, by listening and reflecting and coming, we can understand that this is a flower, and therefore, in this way, we eliminate our doubt with respect to, Is this a flower or not?
Wondering whether this is a flower or not? Likewise, you know, with respect to the scarf, wondering, this a kata? Is this a scarf or not? And learning that it is a scarf, we eliminate our doubt with respect to whether or not it’s a scarf likewise. Is this a Buddha image or not?
Is this an image of a Buddha? And coming to listen and reflecting, come to understand, Ah yes, this is an image of a Buddha, and therefore we eliminate our doubt with respect to that particular object. And this we were doing with all the various phenomena with removing our doubt with respect to their nature, their mode of reality, mode of existence. Just as if Rinpoche had doubts as to each of your names, was wondering what your name was. And I said, you know, I explained that this person’s name is this, this person’s name is this, and this way Rinpoche could come to know what each of your various names is and thereby eliminate his doubt with respect to your name.
And, in the same way, the of the scriptural collection of the sets of discourses, the sutras, they set forth the mode of abidance, the nature, the reality of all the various phenomena whereby we can eliminate our doubt with respect to their nature, the reality of all the phenomena, of all the objects objects of knowledge. Then the the second affliction, which is to be eliminated, is the is the affliction of extreme behavior extreme behavior or behavior with respect to the two extremes. And so the the second afflictive emotion, which is to be With respect to the elimination of the behavior with the elimination of the afflictive behavior with respect to the two extremes, that is, the extreme behaviors. Entails setting forth the various types of practices which are to be adopted and those which are to be rejected. Essentially, we’re talking about the methods of practicing renunciation and ethics, whereby it is said that if we develop indulgent desire with respect to food, clothing, furnishings, and residence, then are, these are said to be prohibited.
Prohibited. If we develop this indulgent desire with respect to food, clothing, furnishings, residence, then we this will act as an obstacle to higher types of realizations. And therefore, it becomes necessary to to practice renunciation with respect to these various external objects. For example, you know, if we speak to developing desire with regards to clothing, if, you know, if if you find that by wearing very good clothing, new clothing that you develop attachment to it, then it’s it’s necessary as a method to eliminate this desire to begin to wear only used clothing. For example, some people, they they when they first buy something, they ask they give it to someone else to wear for a few months.
And then they they themselves after that, then they wear it, and they don’t develop this attachment to new clothing. So with respect to a method for eliminating attachment to food, it’s So, you know, if we in speaking of, eliminating desire for monks, this renounced, ordained people, then they were, they had to go on alms round and they had to accept and eat whatever was given to them and that they would go to three householders and what ever was given to them, that’s what they would eat that and if nothing was given to them, then they would return and not eat. So it’s just a matter of accepting and eating whatever is given. So if we and with respect to residence if you would begin to become attached to your house then you would have to go outside and live under a tree in order to eliminate that. It’s a method for eliminating your attachment to your home.
So we have to eliminate any types of great attachment that we have. These great attachment acts as an obstacle to higher realizations. Then on the other hand, the Buddha said that for those who have realizations, for those who do not generate attachments, for example, who have, you know, renunciation, awakening heart, the correct view, then they can make use of any types of good foods, good clothing, good residence. It doesn’t matter because with respect to these external objects they don’t generate attachment. You know, they see these objects, for example, without any essence.
They’re impermanent and empty, and therefore, with this understanding, they don’t generate attachment or indulgent desire. And therefore, the Buddha said that for such types of people, no external objects were prohibited that they could accept and make use of all kinds of good external foods and objects, foods, clothing, residence, whatever. So, the Buddha set forth his prohibitions and permissions, not with respect to the nature of the external object, but as to whether the external object had the potential to generate afflictive emotions in the person who uses that object. Generate attachment, indulgent desire for various external objects, then he’s quite he can make use of any type of excellent materials. Where, on the other hand, those who generate attachment, then they are prohibited from using good types of food, clothing, etc.
So this is the behavior with respect to the two extremes. So this also applies to lay people. If they’re lay people and the various articles that you make use of, if they generate attachment, indulgent desire, then the Buddha would prohibit you from using these that you would have to forego these. Whereas on the other hand if the layperson makes use of excellent types of articles, you know, external things without developing desire, without developing attachment, then the Buddha gave permission to make use of these things. Whether one is an ordained person or whether one is a lay person, it doesn’t make any difference.
Lay people also have to gain higher and higher realizations. The obstacle which prevents us from gaining realizations are the various afflictive emotions. Therefore, for those who generate afflictive emotions with respect to various external things, then these types of things are prohibited since they act as an obstacle for gaining higher realizations. But then on the other hand if we have few afflictive emotions and the various articles that we make use of don’t increase our afflictive emotions, they don’t generate attachment, no reason why we can’t and these articles are permissible. There’s no reason why we can’t make use of them.
So, for us to gain Buddhahood, to gain higher and higher realizations, it’s extremely important that we begin to decrease the force of our afflictive emotions. And then the third affliction which is to be eliminated through the scripture, the discourses, is the affliction of holding one’s own view to be supreme. Holding one’s own view to be supreme. This would entail for example. For example, that phenomenon where that things were So this is specifically means when we say holding one’s own views as supreme, holding one’s own holding the bad views or wrong views as supreme.
For example, with respect to the various types of wrong views, there’s the wrong view which holds things to be permanent. That is to say that they’re not momentarily arising and disintegrating. Where in fact things are impermanent, they’re momentarily arising and disintegrating. So the concept of things being permanent would be a wrong view. Another wrong view would be the holding that those things which were actually in the nature of suffering to be in the nature of happiness or pleasure.
That is, you know, all the various objects around us. The this house, wood, tables, floor, these are in the nature of suffering in the sense that they arise out of karma, that is actions and afflictive emotions. Therefore, they are said to be in the nature of suffering. But the concept which holds these as to be pleasurable in nature is a it would be a wrong view. Another wrong view would be holding the person to have a self.
A self holding or conceiving of a self of persons. Whereas in fact the person is self less. It lacks a self. So, this would be another wrong view or wrong awareness, which is to be eliminated through the antidote of the discourses. So I I think I’ve mixed things a little bit here.
Not too much. Let’s straighten it out. So we’re trying to to give nine reasons why there are three scriptural collections. And the first is from the point of view of the first three reasons are from the point of view of antidote. Now, the reason what the the first one was doubt is eliminated through the scriptural collection of discourses.
The second was that extreme behavior is eliminated through the category of discipline. The third affliction, that of holding wrong views to be supreme, is eliminated through this collection of manifest knowledge. Therefore, in order to eliminate these three afflictions, we have to have these three collections. Then the second set of three reasons why it’s necessary to have three scriptural categories is that from the point of view of subject matter. And the subject matter is the three trainings.
The the set of discourses sets forth the three the three trainings. The training the three trainings, the sets of discipline sets forth the three trainings, the training ethics, training in meditative stabilization, and the training in wisdom. The set of discipline sets forth the first two trainings, ethics and meditative stabilization, and the set of knowledge sets forth the training in wisdom. Then the three then the third set of three reasons why it’s necessary to have three scriptural categories is from the point of view of practice.
So the third set of three reasons why it’s necessary to have three scriptural categories is from the point of view of doctrines and meanings. Now the sutras, it’s necessary to have the sets of discourses since they set forth an elaborate explanation of the various doctrines and meanings. It’s necessary to have the set of disciplines because they set forth the means of practicing the doctrines and meanings. And then the third, the set of knowledge, having is necessary since having understood the doctrine and meanings one develops the skillful ability to explain them to others through the collection of manifest knowledge. The the skill in explaining.
So what do we mean when we say doctrine? The the doctrine? So by doctrine, mean the path of the 10 virtues by which we are able to achieve higher status, that is, rebirth as a god or human.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
- Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.